SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 3
Lexical approach                                            Eclectic approach
Introduction   Focus in helping students to acquire vocabulary               Approach that does not hold rigidly to a single
               Away from grammar based-syllabus                              paradigm or set of assumptions, but instead draws
                                                                             upon multiple theories, styles or ideas to gain
                                                                             complementary insights into a subject (integrated)
                                                                             The usage of multiple teaching styles in a
                                                                             discriminating manner
Principles     Meaning of sentences are not carried by grammar but           The use of a variety of language learning activities
               through lexis                                                 which have different characteristics and may be
               Concentrate on developing learners’ proficiency with          motivated by underlying assumptions
               lexis or words                                                Limited number of techniques will not give any
               Believe in the centrality of the lexis to                     benefits to the students in learning
               -language structure
               -language use
               -multiword lexical units
Contents       What is lexis?                                          Application of the principle:
               -individual vocabulary words & word combinations               Addressing the issues of learners needs and styles
               (lexical chunk) that we store in our mental lexicon            Teacher can develop a needs analysis which can be
               -language production involves piecing together ready-          used to develop the course syllabus
               made units appropriate for a particular situation              Combination of a variety sources
               What is lexical chunk?                                         Approaches
               -any pair or group of words which commonly found               -communicative approach (opinion gap)
               together, or in close proximity                                -lexical approach (lexical chunk in reading text)
               -example: by the way, in my opinion                            -structural-situational approach (establishing a
               -types of lexical chunks:                                      context for the presentation of new structures)
               1)polywords (by the way)
               2)collocations (community service)
               3)institutionalised utterances (we’ll see)
               4) sentence frames (that is not as..as you think)
               5) sentence heads (the fact was that..)
               6) text frame (firstly.. secondly..)
Criticism    Lewis (1993)                                                     Advantages of an eclectic method
             ~PRINCIPLE 1: GRAMMATICALISED LEXIS                                    Safety; the usage of a variety of methods
                   Lexical approach is the development of communicative             and approaches increases the changes of
                   approach                                                         learning to take place
                   Language is learnt by an increasing ability to break             Interest; teacher can use different methods
                   down wholes into parts                                           to hold students’ attention
                   Grammar is acquired by a process of observation,                 Diversity; different learning/ teaching
                   hypothesis and experiment.                                       contexts require different methodologies
                   Use whole phrases without understanding their                    Flexibility; awareness of range of available
                   constituent parts                                                techniques will help teachers to exploit
                   Acquisition occurs when there is contact with a                  materials better and manage unexpected
                   sympathetic interlocutor of a higher level of competence         situations
                   in TL                                                      Inter language skills
                   Lexis is central in creating meaning, grammar plays a      -a scale of languages that fit the level of
                   subservient managerial role                                students’ language skills at any moment
             ~PRINCIPLE 2: COLLOCATION IN ACTION
                                                                              Comprehensible input
                   Strange combination of words in native-speakers’ ears
                                                                              -if we do not understand the input, we cannot
             ~PRINCIPLE 3: NOTICING
                                                                              learn
                   Teacher will guide the students
                   Sometimes it will occur on it’s own                        Negotiation of meaning
                   Noticing is explicit & implicit                            -interactional hypothesis that states that
             ~PRINCIPLE 4: LANGUAGE AWARENESS                                 learning comes about in the moment of exchange
                   Learning can occur affectively if teacher implements the   between a native speaker and a non-speaker
                   language awareness approach to learning with a lexical
                   approach to describe language.                             Product oriented approach
                   Teacher helps students to be aware of how language         -accumulation of bits and pieces of a language
                   functions
             Schmitt (2000)
                   Mind is able to store large amounts of information in
                   long term memory but its short term capacity is much
                   more limited
                   When producing language in speech, it is much more
                   efficient for the brain to recall a chunk of language as
                   if it were one piece of information
Activities         Intensive and extensive listening and reading in the       Set induction
                   target language                                                  Begins with inductive activity
                   Comparison between L1 & L2 (chunk-language awareness)            Identify different uses of synonyms of
                   Repetition and recycling of activities                           movement based on reading text
                   Guessing the meaning of vocabulary                         Practice
                   Activities which will evoke the students to identify the         Practise these using Total Physical Response
                   lexical chunk; collocations; in the materials                    (TPR)
                                                                              Next lesson
                   Use task-based approach
                                                                                    The input is recycled through a task-based
                   Don’t teach vocabulary out of context
                                                                                    lesson
                   Don’t teach isolated words; try to collocate them (bank
                                                                                    Students instructed to produce the
                   account)
                                                                                    instructions for an exercise manual
Comparison between lexical and eclectic approach

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Presentation on methods and practice
Presentation on methods and practicePresentation on methods and practice
Presentation on methods and practiceMd Arman
 
Post-Method Principles
Post-Method PrinciplesPost-Method Principles
Post-Method PrinciplesJeanne Smith
 
Presentation on post methodology
Presentation on post methodologyPresentation on post methodology
Presentation on post methodologyMd Arman
 
The Postmethod Era in SLA
The Postmethod Era in SLAThe Postmethod Era in SLA
The Postmethod Era in SLACesar Augusto
 
Teachig Grammar in the post-method era
Teachig Grammar in the post-method eraTeachig Grammar in the post-method era
Teachig Grammar in the post-method eraMohamed Benhima
 
Content based instruction
Content based instructionContent based instruction
Content based instructionEmine Özkurt
 
The post method era
The post method eraThe post method era
The post method eraErcan Aksoy
 
Eng 345 powerpoint
Eng 345 powerpointEng 345 powerpoint
Eng 345 powerpointsawhit2
 
Esl teaching methodology
Esl teaching methodologyEsl teaching methodology
Esl teaching methodologykarin27
 
Teaching methodologies
Teaching methodologiesTeaching methodologies
Teaching methodologiesAzra Ilyas
 
ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY (EFL)
ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY  (EFL)ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY  (EFL)
ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY (EFL)Haroon Baig
 
The postmethod condition
The postmethod conditionThe postmethod condition
The postmethod conditionMd Arman
 
Hina presentation
Hina presentationHina presentation
Hina presentationMad Jutt
 
Foreign Language Teaching Methodology
Foreign Language Teaching Methodology Foreign Language Teaching Methodology
Foreign Language Teaching Methodology Israolivoca
 
SLA: Approaches, methods and techniques
SLA: Approaches, methods and techniquesSLA: Approaches, methods and techniques
SLA: Approaches, methods and techniquesValeria Roldán
 
A Methodical History of Language Teaching, Brown
A Methodical History of Language Teaching, BrownA Methodical History of Language Teaching, Brown
A Methodical History of Language Teaching, BrownCristiane-Silva
 
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2lisyaseloni
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Presentation on methods and practice
Presentation on methods and practicePresentation on methods and practice
Presentation on methods and practice
 
Post-Method Principles
Post-Method PrinciplesPost-Method Principles
Post-Method Principles
 
Presentation on post methodology
Presentation on post methodologyPresentation on post methodology
Presentation on post methodology
 
The Postmethod Era in SLA
The Postmethod Era in SLAThe Postmethod Era in SLA
The Postmethod Era in SLA
 
Teachig Grammar in the post-method era
Teachig Grammar in the post-method eraTeachig Grammar in the post-method era
Teachig Grammar in the post-method era
 
Content based instruction
Content based instructionContent based instruction
Content based instruction
 
The post method era
The post method eraThe post method era
The post method era
 
Tefl - content based instruction
Tefl - content based instructionTefl - content based instruction
Tefl - content based instruction
 
Post method era
Post method eraPost method era
Post method era
 
Eng 345 powerpoint
Eng 345 powerpointEng 345 powerpoint
Eng 345 powerpoint
 
Esl teaching methodology
Esl teaching methodologyEsl teaching methodology
Esl teaching methodology
 
Teaching methodologies
Teaching methodologiesTeaching methodologies
Teaching methodologies
 
ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY (EFL)
ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY  (EFL)ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY  (EFL)
ENGLISH TEACHING METHODOLOGY (EFL)
 
The postmethod condition
The postmethod conditionThe postmethod condition
The postmethod condition
 
Hina presentation
Hina presentationHina presentation
Hina presentation
 
Foreign Language Teaching Methodology
Foreign Language Teaching Methodology Foreign Language Teaching Methodology
Foreign Language Teaching Methodology
 
SLA: Approaches, methods and techniques
SLA: Approaches, methods and techniquesSLA: Approaches, methods and techniques
SLA: Approaches, methods and techniques
 
Language pedagogy
Language pedagogyLanguage pedagogy
Language pedagogy
 
A Methodical History of Language Teaching, Brown
A Methodical History of Language Teaching, BrownA Methodical History of Language Teaching, Brown
A Methodical History of Language Teaching, Brown
 
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
 

Andere mochten auch

Back to school 7
Back to school 7Back to school 7
Back to school 7judygirl17
 
Four families-of-teaching
Four families-of-teachingFour families-of-teaching
Four families-of-teachingLeinoj Lopez
 
Teaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical Approach
Teaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical ApproachTeaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical Approach
Teaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical ApproachKarlaEssmann
 
Eclectic Apporach Therapy
Eclectic Apporach TherapyEclectic Apporach Therapy
Eclectic Apporach TherapyNeil Paul
 
Eclectic paradigm Dunning
Eclectic paradigm DunningEclectic paradigm Dunning
Eclectic paradigm DunningYoichi Miyata
 
Eclecticism, origin, principles and applications
Eclecticism, origin, principles and applicationsEclecticism, origin, principles and applications
Eclecticism, origin, principles and applicationsSandra Draskovic
 
Eclectic Approach
Eclectic ApproachEclectic Approach
Eclectic ApproachAli Soomro
 
Approach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teaching
Approach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teachingApproach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teaching
Approach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teachingElih Sutisna Yanto
 

Andere mochten auch (11)

Back to school 7
Back to school 7Back to school 7
Back to school 7
 
Four families-of-teaching
Four families-of-teachingFour families-of-teaching
Four families-of-teaching
 
Teaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical Approach
Teaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical ApproachTeaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical Approach
Teaching Vocabulary To Advanced Students: A Lexical Approach
 
Eclectic Apporach Therapy
Eclectic Apporach TherapyEclectic Apporach Therapy
Eclectic Apporach Therapy
 
Eclectic paradigm Dunning
Eclectic paradigm DunningEclectic paradigm Dunning
Eclectic paradigm Dunning
 
Models of Teaching
Models of TeachingModels of Teaching
Models of Teaching
 
Eclecticism, origin, principles and applications
Eclecticism, origin, principles and applicationsEclecticism, origin, principles and applications
Eclecticism, origin, principles and applications
 
Eclectic Approach
Eclectic ApproachEclectic Approach
Eclectic Approach
 
Curriculum models and types
Curriculum models and typesCurriculum models and types
Curriculum models and types
 
Approach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teaching
Approach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teachingApproach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teaching
Approach, method and Technique in Language Learning and teaching
 
Methods, approaches and techniques of teaching english
Methods, approaches and techniques of teaching englishMethods, approaches and techniques of teaching english
Methods, approaches and techniques of teaching english
 

Ähnlich wie Comparison between lexical and eclectic approach

E. s. l. methods
E. s. l. methodsE. s. l. methods
E. s. l. methodsaidiaza
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsdannaet
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsdannaet
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced  studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced  students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsmakarenasanchez
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsingridbelloa
 
Making content comprehensible for ell
Making content comprehensible for ellMaking content comprehensible for ell
Making content comprehensible for elltxiotxio
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students summary
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students summaryTeaching vocabulary to advanced students summary
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students summaryCamila__
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsingridbelloa
 
Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"
Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"
Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"elisapaslawski
 
Guided Discovery for Language Instruction
Guided Discovery for Language InstructionGuided Discovery for Language Instruction
Guided Discovery for Language InstructionVicky Saumell
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students Anna Molly
 
The Basics of SIOP
The Basics of SIOPThe Basics of SIOP
The Basics of SIOPtxiotxio
 
The lexical approach
The lexical approachThe lexical approach
The lexical approachJolexM
 
EXTINSIVE READING
EXTINSIVE READINGEXTINSIVE READING
EXTINSIVE READINGSa345mar
 
The Lexical Approach
The Lexical ApproachThe Lexical Approach
The Lexical Approachelkaiser1987
 

Ähnlich wie Comparison between lexical and eclectic approach (20)

E. s. l. methods
E. s. l. methodsE. s. l. methods
E. s. l. methods
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced  studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced  students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
 
Making content comprehensible for ell
Making content comprehensible for ellMaking content comprehensible for ell
Making content comprehensible for ell
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students summary
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students summaryTeaching vocabulary to advanced students summary
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students summary
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced studentsTeaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
 
Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"
Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"
Tips for teaching with CALL-Chapter 3:"Reading"
 
Guided Discovery for Language Instruction
Guided Discovery for Language InstructionGuided Discovery for Language Instruction
Guided Discovery for Language Instruction
 
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
Teaching vocabulary to advanced students
 
Lexical Approach
Lexical ApproachLexical Approach
Lexical Approach
 
The Basics of SIOP
The Basics of SIOPThe Basics of SIOP
The Basics of SIOP
 
Elt approaches and methods
Elt approaches and methodsElt approaches and methods
Elt approaches and methods
 
The lexical approach
The lexical approachThe lexical approach
The lexical approach
 
Summary of SIOP
Summary of SIOPSummary of SIOP
Summary of SIOP
 
EXTINSIVE READING
EXTINSIVE READINGEXTINSIVE READING
EXTINSIVE READING
 
The Lexical Approach
The Lexical ApproachThe Lexical Approach
The Lexical Approach
 
Analysis of study skills
Analysis of study skillsAnalysis of study skills
Analysis of study skills
 
Product oriented syllabus1
Product oriented syllabus1Product oriented syllabus1
Product oriented syllabus1
 

Mehr von justted

Concept of classroom management
Concept of classroom managementConcept of classroom management
Concept of classroom managementjustted
 
Learning environment and play
Learning environment and playLearning environment and play
Learning environment and playjustted
 
Week 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroom
Week 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroomWeek 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroom
Week 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroomjustted
 
Week 6 exploring and exploiting stories in the
Week 6 exploring and exploiting stories in theWeek 6 exploring and exploiting stories in the
Week 6 exploring and exploiting stories in thejustted
 
Week 5 multicultural literature
Week 5 multicultural literatureWeek 5 multicultural literature
Week 5 multicultural literaturejustted
 
Week 4 selection criteria of texts for young
Week 4 selection criteria of texts for youngWeek 4 selection criteria of texts for young
Week 4 selection criteria of texts for youngjustted
 
Week 3 elements of children’s literature
Week 3 elements of children’s literatureWeek 3 elements of children’s literature
Week 3 elements of children’s literaturejustted
 
Week 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learners
Week 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learnersWeek 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learners
Week 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learnersjustted
 
introduction to children’s literature
introduction to children’s literatureintroduction to children’s literature
introduction to children’s literaturejustted
 
Learning theories
Learning theoriesLearning theories
Learning theoriesjustted
 
Teaching methods methodology
Teaching methods methodologyTeaching methods methodology
Teaching methods methodologyjustted
 
Krashen's hypothesis
Krashen's hypothesisKrashen's hypothesis
Krashen's hypothesisjustted
 

Mehr von justted (13)

Concept of classroom management
Concept of classroom managementConcept of classroom management
Concept of classroom management
 
Learning environment and play
Learning environment and playLearning environment and play
Learning environment and play
 
Week 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroom
Week 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroomWeek 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroom
Week 8 exploring and exploiting poetry in primary esl classroom
 
Week 6 exploring and exploiting stories in the
Week 6 exploring and exploiting stories in theWeek 6 exploring and exploiting stories in the
Week 6 exploring and exploiting stories in the
 
Week 5 multicultural literature
Week 5 multicultural literatureWeek 5 multicultural literature
Week 5 multicultural literature
 
Week 4 selection criteria of texts for young
Week 4 selection criteria of texts for youngWeek 4 selection criteria of texts for young
Week 4 selection criteria of texts for young
 
Week 3 elements of children’s literature
Week 3 elements of children’s literatureWeek 3 elements of children’s literature
Week 3 elements of children’s literature
 
Week 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learners
Week 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learnersWeek 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learners
Week 2 pedagogical principles of teaching young learners
 
introduction to children’s literature
introduction to children’s literatureintroduction to children’s literature
introduction to children’s literature
 
Learning theories
Learning theoriesLearning theories
Learning theories
 
Teaching methods methodology
Teaching methods methodologyTeaching methods methodology
Teaching methods methodology
 
Krashen's hypothesis
Krashen's hypothesisKrashen's hypothesis
Krashen's hypothesis
 
Krashen
KrashenKrashen
Krashen
 

Comparison between lexical and eclectic approach

  • 1. Lexical approach Eclectic approach Introduction Focus in helping students to acquire vocabulary Approach that does not hold rigidly to a single Away from grammar based-syllabus paradigm or set of assumptions, but instead draws upon multiple theories, styles or ideas to gain complementary insights into a subject (integrated) The usage of multiple teaching styles in a discriminating manner Principles Meaning of sentences are not carried by grammar but The use of a variety of language learning activities through lexis which have different characteristics and may be Concentrate on developing learners’ proficiency with motivated by underlying assumptions lexis or words Limited number of techniques will not give any Believe in the centrality of the lexis to benefits to the students in learning -language structure -language use -multiword lexical units Contents What is lexis? Application of the principle: -individual vocabulary words & word combinations Addressing the issues of learners needs and styles (lexical chunk) that we store in our mental lexicon Teacher can develop a needs analysis which can be -language production involves piecing together ready- used to develop the course syllabus made units appropriate for a particular situation Combination of a variety sources What is lexical chunk? Approaches -any pair or group of words which commonly found -communicative approach (opinion gap) together, or in close proximity -lexical approach (lexical chunk in reading text) -example: by the way, in my opinion -structural-situational approach (establishing a -types of lexical chunks: context for the presentation of new structures) 1)polywords (by the way) 2)collocations (community service) 3)institutionalised utterances (we’ll see) 4) sentence frames (that is not as..as you think) 5) sentence heads (the fact was that..) 6) text frame (firstly.. secondly..)
  • 2. Criticism Lewis (1993) Advantages of an eclectic method ~PRINCIPLE 1: GRAMMATICALISED LEXIS Safety; the usage of a variety of methods Lexical approach is the development of communicative and approaches increases the changes of approach learning to take place Language is learnt by an increasing ability to break Interest; teacher can use different methods down wholes into parts to hold students’ attention Grammar is acquired by a process of observation, Diversity; different learning/ teaching hypothesis and experiment. contexts require different methodologies Use whole phrases without understanding their Flexibility; awareness of range of available constituent parts techniques will help teachers to exploit Acquisition occurs when there is contact with a materials better and manage unexpected sympathetic interlocutor of a higher level of competence situations in TL Inter language skills Lexis is central in creating meaning, grammar plays a -a scale of languages that fit the level of subservient managerial role students’ language skills at any moment ~PRINCIPLE 2: COLLOCATION IN ACTION Comprehensible input Strange combination of words in native-speakers’ ears -if we do not understand the input, we cannot ~PRINCIPLE 3: NOTICING learn Teacher will guide the students Sometimes it will occur on it’s own Negotiation of meaning Noticing is explicit & implicit -interactional hypothesis that states that ~PRINCIPLE 4: LANGUAGE AWARENESS learning comes about in the moment of exchange Learning can occur affectively if teacher implements the between a native speaker and a non-speaker language awareness approach to learning with a lexical approach to describe language. Product oriented approach Teacher helps students to be aware of how language -accumulation of bits and pieces of a language functions Schmitt (2000) Mind is able to store large amounts of information in long term memory but its short term capacity is much more limited When producing language in speech, it is much more efficient for the brain to recall a chunk of language as if it were one piece of information Activities Intensive and extensive listening and reading in the Set induction target language Begins with inductive activity Comparison between L1 & L2 (chunk-language awareness) Identify different uses of synonyms of Repetition and recycling of activities movement based on reading text Guessing the meaning of vocabulary Practice Activities which will evoke the students to identify the Practise these using Total Physical Response lexical chunk; collocations; in the materials (TPR) Next lesson Use task-based approach The input is recycled through a task-based Don’t teach vocabulary out of context lesson Don’t teach isolated words; try to collocate them (bank Students instructed to produce the account) instructions for an exercise manual