SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 46
Hazards of price-per-use comparison in e-journal management Jason S. Price , Ph.D. Claremont Colleges’ Libraries Los Angeles, California Are they any use? Plenary Session 4 30 th  Annual UKSG Conference, 16-18 April 2007 University of Warwick, Coventry, UK
General hazards -- Broad Strokes ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
G1. A narrow definition of use ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
G2. Vagaries of search/use habits ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
G3. Dissemination style in teaching  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],http://www.springerlink.com/content/ygv3dbb9j8jj2vaq/
Specific Hazards ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
COUNTER briefing ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],COMPLIANT
S1. Determining Cost ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Overall cost per view by Subs Type $1.64
S2. Comparison with ILL ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
S3. Cross-package comparison ,[object Object],It might not be… CPV
Variation in use by format Davis and Price, 2006
html to pdf Ratios vary widely for these packages ,[object Object]
Live Link
S3. Package value revisited ,[object Object],CPP CPV vs.
Response: COUNTER filter ,[object Object],[object Object],Need to be applied to  Specific institutions/ interface configurations   Vendor % Reduction (Group 2)  Publisher A 25.14% Publisher B 25.50% Publisher C 21.40% Publisher D 35.65% Publisher E 47.36%
Reality Check ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],ASSUMPTIONS
S4. Ignoring by-title data
Cutting off the long tail…
Before…
After …
Before Collaboration   After Collaboration  
S5. Lack of Benchmarks Consortium
S5. Lack of Benchmarks Consortium
S5. Lack of Benchmarks Consortium
S5. Lack of Benchmarks Consortium
Consortial benchmarking
Recommendations ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Support from COUNTER ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
A ‘local’ analogy
 
 
S5. Lack of Benchmarks Consortium
New ways to answer classic questions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Q1. Which titles should be in our collection? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Which titles should be in our shared collection?   ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],(Road Hazard)
Example of Cumulative Use
Which titles should be in our shared collection?   ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Q1. Which titles should we share?   A: not the Unique Title List… For more detail see:  http://tinyurl.com/lte96
Q2. Which titles should we cancel?
Q2. Which titles should we cancel?
Q2. Which titles should we cancel?
(Q3. Which titles should we add?) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Thoughts on the COUNTER standard ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Average vs Overall vs Cost per View

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Bibliometrics Primer
Bibliometrics PrimerBibliometrics Primer
Bibliometrics PrimerElaine Lasda
 
Mendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th July
Mendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th JulyMendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th July
Mendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th JulyMichaela Kurschildgen
 
John Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data Policy
John Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data PolicyJohn Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data Policy
John Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data PolicyWiley
 
Counter workshop presentation 2015-03-10
Counter workshop presentation   2015-03-10Counter workshop presentation   2015-03-10
Counter workshop presentation 2015-03-10Sarah Tudesco
 

Was ist angesagt? (7)

Afternoon Talk on Impact Factor and Improved Access to Papers (July 2018)
Afternoon Talk on Impact Factor and Improved Access to Papers (July 2018)Afternoon Talk on Impact Factor and Improved Access to Papers (July 2018)
Afternoon Talk on Impact Factor and Improved Access to Papers (July 2018)
 
Bibliometrics Primer
Bibliometrics PrimerBibliometrics Primer
Bibliometrics Primer
 
COUNTER usage statistics: Measuring the benefits of the big deals
COUNTER usage statistics: Measuring the benefits of the big dealsCOUNTER usage statistics: Measuring the benefits of the big deals
COUNTER usage statistics: Measuring the benefits of the big deals
 
Citation analysis
Citation analysisCitation analysis
Citation analysis
 
Mendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th July
Mendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th JulyMendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th July
Mendeley introduction NUI Galway 15th July
 
John Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data Policy
John Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data PolicyJohn Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data Policy
John Rolfe - Editor Case Study: Implementing a Journal Data Policy
 
Counter workshop presentation 2015-03-10
Counter workshop presentation   2015-03-10Counter workshop presentation   2015-03-10
Counter workshop presentation 2015-03-10
 

Ähnlich wie Are they any use? Price per use comparisons...

COUNTER stats: applying JR1
COUNTER stats: applying JR1COUNTER stats: applying JR1
COUNTER stats: applying JR1Jason Price, PhD
 
Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia
Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia
Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia Jason Price, PhD
 
Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2
Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2
Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2ALATechSource
 
Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...
Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...
Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...Electronic Resources & Libraries
 
We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...
We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...
We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...Electronic Resources & Libraries
 
Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...
Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...
Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...Jason Price, PhD
 
Usage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study with
Usage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study withUsage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study with
Usage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study withJason Price, PhD
 
Consortia Level Collection Evaluation
Consortia Level Collection EvaluationConsortia Level Collection Evaluation
Consortia Level Collection EvaluationJohn McDonald
 
High Noon at the Pricing Model Corral
High Noon at the Pricing Model CorralHigh Noon at the Pricing Model Corral
High Noon at the Pricing Model CorralCharleston Conference
 
Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors
Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors
Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors Jason Price, PhD
 
Building a foundation for collection management decisions: two approaches
Building a foundation for collection management decisions: two approachesBuilding a foundation for collection management decisions: two approaches
Building a foundation for collection management decisions: two approachesNASIG
 
In search of better deep Recommender Systems
In search of better deep Recommender Systems In search of better deep Recommender Systems
In search of better deep Recommender Systems SK Reddy
 
Implementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCD
Implementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCDImplementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCD
Implementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCDRos Pan
 
Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)
Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)
Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)IRJET Journal
 
Recommenders, Topics, and Text
Recommenders, Topics, and TextRecommenders, Topics, and Text
Recommenders, Topics, and TextNBER
 
Virginia ACRL Presentation
Virginia ACRL PresentationVirginia ACRL Presentation
Virginia ACRL PresentationGreg Raschke
 
Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...
Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...
Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...Ringgold Inc
 
Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)
Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)
Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)ALATechSource
 

Ähnlich wie Are they any use? Price per use comparisons... (20)

COUNTER stats: applying JR1
COUNTER stats: applying JR1COUNTER stats: applying JR1
COUNTER stats: applying JR1
 
Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia
Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia
Applying usage data: Libraries & Consortia
 
Encountering COUNTER: Making the most of your usage statistics
Encountering COUNTER: Making the most of your usage statisticsEncountering COUNTER: Making the most of your usage statistics
Encountering COUNTER: Making the most of your usage statistics
 
Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2
Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2
Managing Electronic Resources for Public Libraries: Part 2
 
Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...
Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...
Comparison Complexities: The Challenges of Automating Cost-per-use Data Manag...
 
We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...
We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...
We've Got the Data - Now What Do We Do About It? Applying Quality Standard to...
 
Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...
Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...
Using the unbundling power of Unsub responsibly: unveiling its assumptions an...
 
Improved metrics for decision making in Libraries, poster på konferensen LOA ...
Improved metrics for decision making in Libraries, poster på konferensen LOA ...Improved metrics for decision making in Libraries, poster på konferensen LOA ...
Improved metrics for decision making in Libraries, poster på konferensen LOA ...
 
Usage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study with
Usage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study withUsage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study with
Usage Factor vs. Impact Factor: A case study with
 
Consortia Level Collection Evaluation
Consortia Level Collection EvaluationConsortia Level Collection Evaluation
Consortia Level Collection Evaluation
 
High Noon at the Pricing Model Corral
High Noon at the Pricing Model CorralHigh Noon at the Pricing Model Corral
High Noon at the Pricing Model Corral
 
Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors
Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors
Library management and User Trends for SAGE Editors
 
Building a foundation for collection management decisions: two approaches
Building a foundation for collection management decisions: two approachesBuilding a foundation for collection management decisions: two approaches
Building a foundation for collection management decisions: two approaches
 
In search of better deep Recommender Systems
In search of better deep Recommender Systems In search of better deep Recommender Systems
In search of better deep Recommender Systems
 
Implementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCD
Implementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCDImplementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCD
Implementing Serial Solutions ERMS, OpenURL and federatd search solutions t UCD
 
Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)
Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)
Book Recommendation System Using Deep Learning (GPT3)
 
Recommenders, Topics, and Text
Recommenders, Topics, and TextRecommenders, Topics, and Text
Recommenders, Topics, and Text
 
Virginia ACRL Presentation
Virginia ACRL PresentationVirginia ACRL Presentation
Virginia ACRL Presentation
 
Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...
Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...
Ringgold Webinar Series: 3. Lean and Mean - Publication Metadata to Enhance D...
 
Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)
Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)
Patron-Driven Acquisition: Turning Theory into Practice (Part 2)
 

Mehr von Jason Price, PhD

Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...
Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...
Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...Jason Price, PhD
 
A collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gap
A collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gapA collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gap
A collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gapJason Price, PhD
 
Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...
Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...
Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...Jason Price, PhD
 
Alternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or Potential
Alternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or PotentialAlternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or Potential
Alternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or PotentialJason Price, PhD
 
Techniques for successful negotiation
Techniques for successful negotiationTechniques for successful negotiation
Techniques for successful negotiationJason Price, PhD
 
Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05
Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05
Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05Jason Price, PhD
 
NISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best Practices
NISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best PracticesNISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best Practices
NISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best PracticesJason Price, PhD
 
Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...
Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...
Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...Jason Price, PhD
 
Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013
Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013
Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013Jason Price, PhD
 
Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013
Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013
Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013Jason Price, PhD
 
Publisher Journal Portfolio Growth
Publisher Journal Portfolio GrowthPublisher Journal Portfolio Growth
Publisher Journal Portfolio GrowthJason Price, PhD
 
CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325
CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325
CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325Jason Price, PhD
 
Saving time and money in the short(!) run...
Saving time and money in the short(!) run...Saving time and money in the short(!) run...
Saving time and money in the short(!) run...Jason Price, PhD
 
Citing the Biological Literature
Citing the Biological LiteratureCiting the Biological Literature
Citing the Biological LiteratureJason Price, PhD
 
Oxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New Orleans
Oxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New OrleansOxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New Orleans
Oxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New OrleansJason Price, PhD
 
KBART Update ALA June 2011
KBART Update ALA June 2011KBART Update ALA June 2011
KBART Update ALA June 2011Jason Price, PhD
 
Slicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELC
Slicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELCSlicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELC
Slicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELCJason Price, PhD
 

Mehr von Jason Price, PhD (20)

Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...
Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...
Indispensable or unnecessary? A data-driven appraisal of post cancellation ac...
 
A collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gap
A collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gapA collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gap
A collaborative imperative? The Read to Publish funding gap
 
Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...
Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...
Access to Freely Available Journal Articles: Gold, Green, and Rogue Open Ac...
 
Alternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or Potential
Alternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or PotentialAlternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or Potential
Alternative Avenues of Discovery: Competition or Potential
 
Discovery impact erl2014
Discovery impact erl2014Discovery impact erl2014
Discovery impact erl2014
 
Techniques for successful negotiation
Techniques for successful negotiationTechniques for successful negotiation
Techniques for successful negotiation
 
Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05
Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05
Discovery impact scelc colloquium 2014mar05
 
NISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best Practices
NISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best PracticesNISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best Practices
NISO Standards update: KBart and Demand Driven Acquisitions Best Practices
 
Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...
Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...
Discovery or Displacement? A Large Scale Longitudinal Study of the Effect of ...
 
Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013
Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013
Electronic resource negotiation and licensing SANLiC 2013
 
Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013
Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013
Ever Evolving Ebooks SANLiC 2013
 
Publisher Journal Portfolio Growth
Publisher Journal Portfolio GrowthPublisher Journal Portfolio Growth
Publisher Journal Portfolio Growth
 
CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325
CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325
CARLI Usage Stats Keynote 20130325
 
2011 CHS Springer keynote
2011 CHS Springer keynote2011 CHS Springer keynote
2011 CHS Springer keynote
 
Saving time and money in the short(!) run...
Saving time and money in the short(!) run...Saving time and money in the short(!) run...
Saving time and money in the short(!) run...
 
Citing the Biological Literature
Citing the Biological LiteratureCiting the Biological Literature
Citing the Biological Literature
 
Choosing a library leader
Choosing a library leaderChoosing a library leader
Choosing a library leader
 
Oxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New Orleans
Oxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New OrleansOxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New Orleans
Oxford Discoverability Panel ALA 2011 New Orleans
 
KBART Update ALA June 2011
KBART Update ALA June 2011KBART Update ALA June 2011
KBART Update ALA June 2011
 
Slicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELC
Slicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELCSlicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELC
Slicing and Dicing: consortial Paperstats at SCELC
 

Are they any use? Price per use comparisons...

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. If you get the reference of this poster to the car named the ‘General’ Lee, then the US has had a worse affect on UK culture than I thought possible… Another haz attending a talk by a guy Commercial vs Society Broad verus narrow China Academic Journals LOTS of content, but as in Chinese expect low demand
  2. IP-based—Delivered by
  3. Google Scholar
  4. On the theme of negative impacts of the US on the UK… I’d say this one is very specific, though Glad don’t have to put into words… Outline of rest of talk
  5. But first, a definition and the magic number… March 2002 Release 2 Without it we couldn’t even discuss this Collaborative effort of librarians publishers & intermediaries founded on well respected industry initiatives
  6. Big deal Lock-ins & Combined Subscriptions
  7. For the same publisher pkg in the same year…
  8. Not exactly red herrings…
  9. Significantly different? What metric for use?
  10. An option…
  11. Elsevier (22%) and Ebsco (28%) partnered with COUNTER ( Publisher/package? Journal? Journal year? Article? Ignoring or Overemphasizing PPU by journal Should depend on question
  12. Scholar – browsing may require use
  13. At least among academic libraries… Two reasons not to give up: Swapping Cooperative vendors
  14. 80-20 Rule
  15. Based on title by title use stats
  16. Kakorams
  17. Majority of collection comprised of added titles (at small fraction of list price) Simple answer: if not all of them, then the ones we use the most Pre-packed – Bad with the good, problem of breadth, OR you can have all these titles that other institutions subscribed to as of 5 years ago
  18. According to counter Post-analysis pending
  19. Gorey Details Switch gears to individual library Within a package & only subscribed titles (by definition) Those that have the highest price per use Use multiple years of Data
  20. Gorey Details Switch gears to individual library Within a package & only subscribed titles (by definition) Those that have the highest price per use Use multiple years of Data
  21. Gorey Details Switch gears to individual library Within a package & only subscribed titles (by definition) Those that have the highest price per use Use multiple years of Data