SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 11
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics
Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020,pp. 187~197
ISSN: 2302-9285,DOI: 10.11591/eei.v9i1.1649  187
Journal homepage: http://beei.org
Performance evaluation for outdoor wireless scenarios based on
IEEE 802.11b/g in the presence of co-channel interference
Roman A. Lara-Cueva, Michael S. Simba-Herrera
Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones, Grupe de Investigación en Sistemas Inteligentes
(WiCOM-Energy) and Ad Hoc Networks Research Center (CIRAD),
Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas ESPE, Ecuador
Article Info ABSTRACT
Article history:
Received May 31, 2019
Revised Aug 20, 2019
Accepted Oct 12, 2019
Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) has evolved over the years,
being a real-time service. VoIP has been coupled to different technologies,
one of them is WiFi, which is one of the most used for wireless local area
networks in domestic and commercial environments. In this paper,
we evaluate the performance of wireless scenarios by considering VoIP
traffic, based on WiFi technology in conformance with IEEE 802.11b/g
in interfered outdoor scenarios, by considering an intrusive injection traffic
technique, for codecs G711(1 sample), G711(2 samples), G723,
G729(2 samples), and G729(3 samples), related to the main metrics
associated to Quality of Service (QoS) parameters. Our results show the best
performance was obtained with the codecs G723 and G729(3 samples),
obtaining up to 30 simultaneous voice connections with optimal values
of delay, jitter and packet loss according to the recommendations given for
VoIP by ITU-T, while the worst performance was obtained with the codec
G711(2 samples), obtaining only 5 simultaneous voice connections,
reaching an efficiency loss of around 18% in a co-channel
interference scenario.
Keywords:
D-ITG
MATLAB
Medium accesscontrol
Quality of Service (QoS)
Voice over internet protocol
WiFi
This is an open access article under the CC BY-SAlicense.
Corresponding Author:
Michael S. Simba-Herrera,
Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones,
Universidad de las FuerzasArmadasESPE,
Av. General Rumiñahuis/n Ambato,Sangolquí-Ecuador.
Email: mssimba@espe.edu.ec
1. INTRODUCTION
Technology has evolved in such way that messages, telephone calls, and video-conferences have
become part of our daily lives [1]. In addition, the establishment of the Internet has allowed to Voice over
Internet Protocol (VoIP) calls to grow remarkably, indeed according to Zion Research group, VoIP service
has reached a total of 83 billion dollars in 2015, and it is estimated that by 2021 this service will reach
a profit of 140 billion dollars, with a growth rate of 9.1% [2]. VoIP is a viable alternative to the Public
Switched Telephone Network (PSTN) due to its high utilization resources and low cost, achieving savings
of up to 95% [3]. Initially, VoIP was used by wired connections, and now WiFi technology has allowed
the use of VoIP over wireless connections, this evolution is known as Voice over WiFi (VoWiFi),
which carries voice traffic in a basic area service, where the main disadvantage is related to some metrics
associated to Quality of Service (QoS) as Throughput (η), and Packet loss (PL), which could not guarantee
real time transmissions in presence of interference.
 ISSN:2302-9285
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197
188
Previous research projects have covered the behaviour of WiFi technology [4-5], in conformance
with the IEEE 802.11b/g standards by using analytical analysis [6], in which the parameters of the Medium
Access Control (MAC) protocol are modified in order to obtain the voice capacity in an infrastructure
network, and the maximum number of voice connections, reaching 19 voice connections with a satisfactory
quality perceived by the user, meanwhile in [7] a simulation was performed to improve the quality of VoIP
using signaling protocols, and codec schemes. Additionaly, in [8] was proposed an adaptive scheduling
method for emissions based on network statistics, PL rate and packet availability.
Otherwise, the performance evaluation of WiFi technology in an indoor environment was presented in [9 -11],
a handover analysis was performed in [12] with conventional Extended Service Set (ESS) infrastructure with
VoIP services and QoS assurance, and some methods to improve the quality of VoIP over a WLAN mesh
were presented in [13], the capacity of switching mechanisms using failover mechanisms in a WAN
and the quality of VoIP calls was studied in [14], also verifying the inherent limitations of the Distributed
Coordination Function (DCF) to calculate the maximum number of VoIP clients a single Access Point (AP)
can support, in which support 12 simultaneous VoIP calls considering G711 voice codec and 14 simultaneous
VoIP calls considering G729 voice codec over a wireless network [15]. In [16] was showed low VoIP
capacity in a WLAN and the unacceptable performance in the presence of coexisting traffic, another way to
evaluate the behavior of the standard was by generating real calls by the software PBX-VoIP Asterisk,
in [17] an outdoor environment was presented, and a total of simultaneous sessions were found that can be
performed by using G729 voice codec reaching 25 simultaneous sessions, while with G711 voice
codec 20 simultaneous sessions were obtained, also a traffic injection strategy was used in [18], by using
Distributed Internet Traffic Generator (D-ITG), in where a laboratory environment was analyzed, in such
environment was reached six clients connected wirelessly to an AP where the codec with the best stability
was the G723.
To the best of our knowledge, no principled studies have performed the network capacity in
a co-channel interfered outdoor scenarios, in such way the aim of this paper is to deployed an outdoor
wireless network to evaluate the performance of the scenarios in the presence of co-channel interference.
To accomplish this, we apply an intrusive injection traffic technique by considering the main metrics
associated to QoS as η, delay (δ), Jitter, and PL, by considering VoIP tra ffic within three proposed scenarios.
In the first scenario, three APs were implemented, each one separated by 120 degrees, creating three Basic
Service Set (BSS) in the same frequency channel. The second scenario consisted of two APs placed in
the same direction each one creating BSS in the same frequencies. The third scenario consisted of three APs
positioned in the same direction, each of which creates a BSS on independent frequency channels.
2. RESEARCH METHOD
In this section we show theequipment and the applied methodology that was considered for
the accomplishment of the experiment.Figure 1 shows the equipment deployed for the proposed scenarios,
we used two and three AP working in the frequency band of 2.4 GHz in conformance with IEEE 802.11b/g
standards, these were connected via an Unshielded Twisted Pair (UTP) cable to a modem, that was
responsible for distributing the traffic generated by the APs.The laptops used to perform VoIP traffic
injections have installed Linux operating system (Ubuntu 10.04), one of them with an Core i5 processor that
works at 2.60 GHz with 6GB RAM memory was connected to one of the APs described above via WiFi,
the other laptop with an Pentium CPU N3540 processor that works at 2.16 GHz with 4GB RAM memory
was connected to a different AP.
Figure 1. Equipment used for the different proposed scenarios
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva)
189
2.1. Performance with D-ITG
In order to obtain the performance evaluation, we used an intrusive injection traffic technique by
considering D-ITG software, which has 5 different predefined voice codecs: G711 of 1 and 2 samples,
G723 and G729 of 2 and 3 samples as shown in Figure 2, also provides information of the main metrics
associated to QoS, each flow represented a VoIP call, for this reason, the multi-flow sending option was used
in the D-ITG software, which allows several flows to be carried out at the same time; for more inform ation
about D-ITG please referred to [19-20]. In this way, several simultaneous multi-flow processes were carried
out, starting with 5 multi-flow processes, then 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, until 60 multi-flow processes for each
of the codecs. It should be noticed that in order to achieve a certain statistical validity in the results of traffic
injections, 15 repetitions were performed for each multi-flow process as recommended in [21-22], so that
the error in the direct measurementsdecreases at the time of the performance analysis.
Figure 2. Voice codecs and multi-flows in D-ITG
2.2. Scenarios
In order to carry out the study, three different scenarios were considered, the network was deployed
within Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas–ESPEcampus in a telecommunications towerlocated on the roof
of the Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones building, that consists of two floors;
the APs were placed 5.5 meters from the base of the tower to perform traffic injections and to analyze th eir
behavior by considering the main metrics associated to QoS parameters provided by
the aforementioned software.
2.2.1. Scenario 1
The first scenario is shown in Figure 3, where three AP were implemented, each one separated by
120 degrees creating three independent BSS's, each one using the same frequency channel, for this scenario
there existed only interference from other networks presented in the outdoor environment,
since the beamwidth of the APs has only 18 degrees aperture, so that their radiation patterns do not overlap
each other, in addition,the two laptopswere connected to a different BSS to perform the traffic injections by
using all the voice codecs of the software, first in one direction and then in the other, after all the traffic
injections had been carried out,the data from the two directions were collected for analysis.
2.2.2. Scenario 2
The second scenario is showed in Figure 4, in the same way, two laptops were connected to
a different AP, which are placed in the same direction, where each one created a different BSS that worked in
the same frequency channel, for this scenario a co-channel interference was presented in addition to
the interfering networks that may be presented when working in an outdoorenvironment.
 ISSN:2302-9285
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197
190
Figure 3. Scenario 1
Figure 4. Scenario 2
2.2.3. Scenario 3
The third scenario is showed in Figure 5, for this scenario three APs were deployed which created
three different BSS in independent frequency channels (ch. 1, ch. 6, and ch. 11), in addition, there were two
laptops in the same way that in the previous scenarios, each one of them were connected to a different BSS,
traffic injections were first performed by two BSS and then by the remaining BSS, the data from the three
BSS were collected for analysis. For this scenario did not exist interference created by the APs since they
were in independent channels, but there may be noise that interferes with traffic injections and also
interference created by devices that may be present in an outdoorscenario.
Figure 5. Scenario 3
The analysis of the traffic injections considering the main metrics associated to QoS was performed
taking into account the data provided by D-ITG: δ, η, Jitter and PL as shown in Figure 6, these data were
classified according to the scenario and voice codec used, the analysis was performed in Matlab®.
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva)
191
Figure 6. Data delivered by the software at the end of the multi-flows
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The analysis of the results was carried out according to the figures shown below, where the amount
of simultaneous multi-flows made is called the number of voice connections, which are also shown in terms
of percentage PL and η, while δ and Jitter are shown in milliseconds (ms). The three scenarios are described
above, which were taken into account and the analysis was also made for each voice codec in order to know
its behavior in each of the proposed scenario, bearing in mind the consideration of QoS parameters for VoIP
were PL<1%, δ<150 ms and Jitter<30 ms [23-25].
For the first scenario, Figure 7 shows that with 5 voice connections all codecs satisfied QoS
parameters, where the most efficient codec was G711(2 samples) with approximately η of 80%,
when reaching the 10 voice connections the codecs G711(1 sample) and G723 satisfied the QoS parameters
without any inconvenience,while the codecs G729(2 samples)and G729(3 samples) δ of 120 ms and 138 ms
respectively, which approach the limit described in [23-25]; at 20 voice connections, only the codecs G723
and G729(3 samples) complied with the QoS parameters continuing with values close to the limit of δ,
this behavior was maintained until the 30 voice connections, meanwhile, from 40 to 60 voice connections,
none of the codecs complied with the QoS parameters.
Figure 7. Results Scenario 1. (Blue line) Codec G711(1 sample), (Red line) Codec G711(2 samples),
(Yellow line) Codec G723, (Purple line) Codec G729(2 samples), (Green line) Codec G729(3 samples)
The results of the second scenario are shown in Figure 8, in the same way as in the first scenario,
with 5 voice connections, all codecs satisfied QoS parameters, where codec G711(2 sample) maintains
the best efficiency with around η of 80%, by increasing voice connections to 10, only codecs G723
 ISSN:2302-9285
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197
192
and G729(2 sample) satisfying QoS parameters, bearing in mind that codec G729(2 sample) had
approximately δ of 130 ms; reaching 20 voice connections, none of the codecs could satisfy all the
parametersof QoS, the codec G729(3 samples) satisfied the parameters PL and Jitter but did not comply with
the parameter δ as it had a value close to 200 ms, while the G723 codec satisfied the δ and Jitter parameters
but did not comply with the PL parameter which had an approximate value of 3%, after 30 to 60 voice
connections, all codecs had PL values above the ideal value, so none of the codecs comply
with QoS parameters.
Figure 8. Results Scenario 2. (Blue line) Codec G711(1 sample), (Red line) Codec G711(2 samples),
(Yellow line) Codec G723, (Purple line) Codec G729(2 samples), (Green line) Codec G729(3 samples)
Figure 9 shows the results of the third scenario, with 5 voice connections as in the previous
scenarios, all codecs comply with QoS parameters and in the same way,the G711 codec (2 samples) remains
the most efficient, with around η of 80%, when the 10 voice connections were reach, three codecs continue to
satisfied QoS parameters, these were the G711 codecs (1 sample), G723 and G729 (2 samples) where
the latter had a value of δ close to the allowed range with a value of 145 ms, while with 20 voice connections
only the G723 codec satisfied the QoS parameters,from 30 to 60 voice connections, none of the codecs were
able to satisfy all the QoS parameters, the G723 codec satisfied the parameters of δ and Jitter, but as in
previous scenarios, it did not satisfy the required percentage of PL with values greater than 1%.
Figure 9. Results Scenario 3. (Blue line) Codec G711(1 sample), (Red line) Codec G711(2 samples),
(Yellow line) Codec G723, (Purple line) Codec G729(2 samples), (Green line) Codec G729(3 samples)
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva)
193
The behavior in the different scenarios of the codec G711(1 sample) may be appreciated in
Figure 10, with values of δ of 25 ms for the 5 voice connections for the first and second scenarios,
while the third scenario had a δ of 100 ms, when reached the 10 voice connections the first scenario had
a δ of 50 ms while the third scenario had a δ of 110 ms approximately; the best performance was reach in
the first scenario, with lower values of δ compared to the third scenario, which were the scenarios that
achieve 10 voice connectionsthat complied with all QoS parameters.
Figure 10. Results Codec G711(1 sample). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2, (Yellow line)
Scenario 3
For the codec G711(2 samples) the behavior in the different scenarios is showed in Figure 11,
this codec only managed to reach up to 5 simultaneous voice connections within the QoS parameters,
in the three proposed scenarios it reached an efficiency of around η of 80%, where the best scenario was
the second scenario with around δ of 25 ms followed closely by the third scenario with δ of 35 ms,
while the first scenario had δ of 55 ms approximately, as voice connections increase, the values of δ and PL
increased rapidly, even surpassing 1000 ms and 50%.
Figure 11. Results Codec G711(2 samples). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2,
(Yellow line) Scenario 3
 ISSN:2302-9285
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197
194
The G723 codec was the only one in each of the scenarios proposed in terms of δ and Jitter was
within the QoS parameters for all voice connections, the only problem within this codec lies in
the percentages of PL, where the first scenario was the best performing reaching 30 voice connections with
a value of less than PL of 1%, in the third scenario reached 20 voice connections, while in the second
scenario barely reached 10 voice connections, this is shown in Figure 12.
Figure 12. Results Codec G723. (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2, (Yellow line) Scenario 3
Within the 3 proposed scenarios, codec G729(2 samples) had a similar behavior, reached only up to
10 voice connections, although with δ values quite close to the allowed limit, the lowest value of δ in 10
voice connections was in the first scenario with a value close to 110 ms, while the highest value was in
the third scenario with approximately δ of 145 ms, Figure 13 shows the results of the different scenarios
for this codec.
Figure 13. Results Codec G729(2 samples). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2,
(Yellow line) Scenario 3
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva)
195
Finally, for codec G729(3 samples) the scenario where the best results were obtained was the first
scenario where up to 30 simultaneousvoice connections are reached, similar to the previous codec the values
of δ from 10 voice connectionswere high and maintain this constant untilreaching 30 voice connections with
a range between 120 ms and 141 ms, this behaviormay be seen in Figure 14.
Figure 14. Results Codec G729(3 samples). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2,
(Yellow line) Scenario 3
4. CONCLUSION
It was determined that the codec with the best performance considering the main metrics associa ted
to QoS in the different test scenarios was the G723 codec, which achieved up to 30 simultaneous voice
connections in the first scenario, 10 simultaneous voice connections for the second scenario and 20
simultaneous voice connections for the third scenario, on the other hand the codec with the worst behavior
was the codec G711(2 samples), which achieved only 5 simultaneous voice connections in the three test
scenarios, as well as in [17] where reached 5 voice connections in Central sub-scenario, which had 10 meters
of distance between devices, working in the same frequency channel.
The scenario with the best performance considering the main metrics associated to QoS was the first
scenario, where most of codecs managed to make 10 simultaneous voice connections without exceeding
the parameters of QoS, it should be noted that in this scenario two codecs could reach up to 30 simultaneous
voice connections, these are codecs G723 and G729(3 samples), higher than those reached in [17],
where with the G729 codec reaching up to 25 voice connections in MED sub-scenario, which had 10 meters
of distance between devices working in the same frequency channel; while the worst performing scenario
was the second scenario with three codecs reaching only up to 5 simultaneous voice connections, these were
codecs G711(1 sample), G711(2 samples), and G729(3 samples), a voice connection above
for the G711 and G729 codecs in Enlace sub-scenario shown in [17], which had 128 meters of distance
between two locations.
Taking into account the QoS parameters for VoIP that exist according to [23-25], it was possible to
determine which are the limits for making simultaneous voice connections for each scenario,
where the parametersthat present abrupt changes between a certain numberof voice connections and another
were δ and PL. As these values increased, the Jitter also increased, although in a smaller proportion,
while efficiency was also affected, being progressively less.Likewise, all interferences that are presented in
an outdoor environment must be taken into account, since they cannot be avoided and affect the moment
traffic intrusions are made in any of the scenarios, making the QoS values taken vary depending on
the amount of interference that exists at that moment, where this can be appreciated most in the second
scenario, when co-channel interference was presented in addition to interference found in
an externalenvironment.
 ISSN:2302-9285
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197
196
Evaluating the different scenarios proposed, between the third and first scenario the efficiency was
reduced by approximately 3.67%,while comparingthem with the second scenario which presents co-channel
interference, between the first and second scenario, the efficiency was reduced by approximately 18%,
and between the third and second scenario, the efficiency was reduced by approximately 18.3%, noting that
when using independent channels the efficiency was higher.Finally, as future work is proposed to evaluate
the performance of VoIPoutdoorswith standards IEEE 802.11a,IEEE 802.11n and IEEE 802.11ac,working
on the frequency of 5 GHz, so that the existing interference outdoors is less because it has a greater number
of channels compared to the frequency of 2.4GHz with a high saturation in the channels, it would also be
interesting to evaluate the performance of VoIP using WIMAX (Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave
Access) technology
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors gratefully acknowledge the contribution of Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas ESPE
for the economical support in the development of this project by Research Grants 2011 -PIT-WiLD
and 2013-PIT-014.
REFERENCES
[1] W. Andocilla, M. Vallejo, “Integración de los servicios de voz sobre IP, aplicado a un caso de estudio,”
B.S. Thesis, Escuela Politécnica Nacional, Quito, Ecuador, March 2007.
[2] Market Research Store, “Global VoIP Services Market Set for Rapid Growth, to Reach Around USD 140 Billion
By 2021,” Market Research Store, May. 2, 2016. Accessed on: Feb. 26, 2019. [Online]. Available:
https://www.marketresearchstore.com/news/global-voip-services-market-is-expected-to-reach-above-231
[3] Hipertextual, El papel de las centralitas virtuales en la internacionalización de empresas, Accessed on: Feb. 26,
2019. [Online]. Available: https://hipertextual.com/presentado-por/vozelia/centralitas-virtuales
[4] D. Villacis, F. Acosta, R. Lara, “Performance analysis of VoIP services over WiFi-based systems” Communications
and Computing (COLCOM), Medellin, Colombia, pp. 1-6, May 2013.
[5] S. Suherman, "WiFi-friendly building to enable WiFi signal indoor,"Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and
Informatics, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 264-271, 2018.
[6] L. X. Cai, Xuemin Shen, J. W. Mark, L. Cai and Yang Xiao, "Voice capacity analysis of WLAN with unbalanced
traffic," in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 55, no. 3, pp. 752-761, May 2006.
[7] O. Khalifa, R. Roslin, S. Bhuiyan, "Improved voice quality with the combination of transport layer & audio codec
for wireless devices,"Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 264-271, 2018.
[8] P. Chandran, C. Lingam, "A statistical approach to adaptive playout scheduling in voice over internet protocol
communication,"International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol. 8, no. 5,
pp. 2926-2933, 2018.
[9] R. Lara-Cueva, C. Morales and C. Fernández, "Performance evaluation of WiFi technology in conformance with
IEEE 802.11b/n/ac and WDS for indoor environments," 2017 IEEE Colombian Conference on Communications
and Computing (COLCOM), Cartagena, pp. 1-6, 2017.
[10] R. Lara-Cueva, D. Benítez, C. Fernández, and C. Morales, “Performance analysis of wireless network modes in
conformance with ieee 802.11b and wds,” in Asia-Pacific Conference on Computer Aided System Engineering,
Quito, Ecuador, pp. 370–373, Jul 2015.
[11] M. A. Vallejo-Baldeón, D. N. Rodríguez and R. A. Lara-Cueva, "Performance evaluation of wireless network in
conformance with IEEE 802.11n in co-channel interference scenarios," 2017 IEEE Colombian Conference on
Communications and Computing (COLCOM), Cartagena, pp. 1-6, 2017.
[12] I. Prasetyo, M. Anif, A. Sriyanto, S. Pramono, S. Widodo, S. Hidayat, “Handover analysis of data and VoIP
services in 802.11b/g/n wireless LAN,”TELKOMNIKA (Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control),
vol. 12, no. 11, pp. 7832-7844, 2014.
[13] D. Niculescu, S. Ganguly, K. Kim and R. Izmailov, "Performance of VoIP in a 802.11 wireless mesh network,"
Proceedings IEEE INFOCOM 2006. 25TH IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications,
Barcelona, pp. 1-11, 2006.
[14] H. Septama, A. Ulvan, R. Bestak, J. Hlavacek, “High available VoIP server failover mechanism in wide area
network”, TELKOMNIKA (Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control), vol. 13, no. 2,
pp. 739-744, 2015
[15] S. Garg and M. Kappes, "Can I add a VoIP call?," IEEE International Conference on Communications, 2003.
ICC '03., Anchorage, AK, vo. 2, pp. 779-783, 2003.
[16] Wei Wang, Soung Chang Liew and V. O. K. Li, "Solutions to performance problems in VoIP over a 802.11
wireless LAN," in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 54, no. 1, pp. 366-384, Jan. 2005.
[17] M.Nuñez, C. Játiva, R. Lara, “Performance evaluation of VoIP technology in an extended service set,
in concordance with IEEE 802.11g,”Sistemas y Telemática, vol. 15, no. 42, pp. 85-100, Oct. 2017.
[18] G. Agredo, J. Gaviria, “Experimental evaluation of the capacity of IEEE 802.11b to support VoIP services,”
Sistemas y Telemática, vol. 4, no.8, pp. 125-151, Oct. 2006.
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva)
197
[19] A. Botta, A. Dainotti, A. Pescapè, "A tool for the generation of realistic network workload for emerging networking
scenarios", Computer Networks (Elsevier), vol. 56, no. 15, pp 3531-3547, 2012.
[20] D-ITG, “Distributed Internet Traffic Generator,” Accessed on: Feb. 18, 2019. [Online]. Available:
http://www.grid.unina.it/software/ITG/manual/
[21] A. Posadas, “Determinación de Errores y Tratamiento de Datos,” Accessed on: Feb. 27, 2019. [Online]. Available
https://w3.ual.es/~aposadas/TeoriaErrores.pdf
[22] A. Kowalski, “Técnicas Auxiliares de Laboratorio,” Accessed on: Feb. 27, 2019. [Online]. Available
https://www.ugr.es/~andyk/Docencia/TEB/Errores.pdf
[23] T. Szigeti and C. Hattingh, “QoS Design Overview” in “End-to-End QoS network design: quality of service in
LANs, WANs, and VPNs,”2nd ed. T. Szigeti, Ed. Indianapolis: Cisco Press, pp. 33-38, 2004.
[24] One-Way Transmission Time, document ITU-T Rec. G.114, International Telecommunication Union, Geneva,
Switzerland, May 2003.
[25] P. Mehta and S. Udani, "Voice over IP," in IEEE Potentials, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 36-40, Oct.-Nov. 2001.
BIOGRAPHIES OF AUTHORS
Román A. Lara-Cueva received the B.Eng. degree in electronic and telecommunications
engineering from Escuela Politécnica Nacional, Quito, Ecuador, in 2001, the M.Sc. degree in
wireless systems and related technologies from the Politecnico di Torino, Turin, Italy, in 2005,
and the M.Sc. and Ph.D. degrees in telecommunication networks for developing countries from
Rey Juan Carlos University, Fuenlabrada, Spain, in 2010 and 2015, respectively.In 2002, he
joined the Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones, Universidad de las
Fuerzas Armadas ESPE, Sangolquí, Ecuador, where he has been an Associate Professor since
2005 and a Full Professor since 2016. He has authored or coauthored 12 publicly funded
research projects and directed seven of them. He currently heads the Ad Hoc Network Research
Center and the Smart Systems Research Group (WiCOM-Energy). His research interests include
digital signal processing, smart cities, wireless systems, machine learning theory, and
volcano seismology.
Michael S. Simba-HerreraCandidate to Engineer in Electronics and Telecommunications at the
Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas - ESPE (Sangolquí, Ecuador). In 2018 he joined the Grupe
de InvestigaciónenSistemasInteligentes (WiCOM-Energy) and Ad Hoc Networks Research
Center (CIRAD) as research assistant. His main areas of interest in research are wireless systems
and Voice over IP (VoIP).

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Low cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosr
Low cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosrLow cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosr
Low cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosrteriazms
 
Meeting the data demand tital wave upgrade of in door das for lte
Meeting the data demand tital wave   upgrade of in door das for lteMeeting the data demand tital wave   upgrade of in door das for lte
Meeting the data demand tital wave upgrade of in door das for lteJim Alexander
 
Vo ip on 3gpp lte network a survey
Vo ip on 3gpp lte network a surveyVo ip on 3gpp lte network a survey
Vo ip on 3gpp lte network a surveyAlexander Decker
 
HIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATION
HIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONHIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATION
HIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONRezaul Islam
 
5G green communication
5G green communication5G green communication
5G green communicationAhmad El Tawil
 
Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3
Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3
Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3Justus @GreenPacket
 
5G live virtual classroom - trainig program
5G live virtual classroom - trainig program5G live virtual classroom - trainig program
5G live virtual classroom - trainig programNordinRamli
 
Bpl access network 101 v1
Bpl access network 101 v1Bpl access network 101 v1
Bpl access network 101 v1Broto Santoso
 
Microwave backhaul in 5 g networks
Microwave backhaul in 5 g networksMicrowave backhaul in 5 g networks
Microwave backhaul in 5 g networksslidedown123
 
Field test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailand
Field test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailandField test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailand
Field test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailandeSAT Journals
 
5 g architecture
 5 g architecture 5 g architecture
5 g architectureShibinPS3
 
Analysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX Environment
Analysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX EnvironmentAnalysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX Environment
Analysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX EnvironmentEditor IJMTER
 
NTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of High
NTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of HighNTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of High
NTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of HighLuke Markey
 
5G Technolgy webinar, Shahram G Niri
5G  Technolgy webinar, Shahram G Niri5G  Technolgy webinar, Shahram G Niri
5G Technolgy webinar, Shahram G NiriShahram G Niri
 
Network economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technology
Network economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technologyNetwork economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technology
Network economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technologyAnuj Malik
 

Was ist angesagt? (18)

Low cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosr
Low cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosrLow cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosr
Low cost front end diplexer for moca dvb-c_c2 systems_iosr
 
Meeting the data demand tital wave upgrade of in door das for lte
Meeting the data demand tital wave   upgrade of in door das for lteMeeting the data demand tital wave   upgrade of in door das for lte
Meeting the data demand tital wave upgrade of in door das for lte
 
Vo ip on 3gpp lte network a survey
Vo ip on 3gpp lte network a surveyVo ip on 3gpp lte network a survey
Vo ip on 3gpp lte network a survey
 
HIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATION
HIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONHIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATION
HIGH SPEED WIRELESS COMMUNICATION
 
5G green communication
5G green communication5G green communication
5G green communication
 
03
0303
03
 
Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3
Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3
Data Offload Survival Guide - Part 3
 
Edge1
Edge1Edge1
Edge1
 
5G live virtual classroom - trainig program
5G live virtual classroom - trainig program5G live virtual classroom - trainig program
5G live virtual classroom - trainig program
 
Bpl access network 101 v1
Bpl access network 101 v1Bpl access network 101 v1
Bpl access network 101 v1
 
Microwave backhaul in 5 g networks
Microwave backhaul in 5 g networksMicrowave backhaul in 5 g networks
Microwave backhaul in 5 g networks
 
Field test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailand
Field test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailandField test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailand
Field test of 4 g lte 1800 mhz deployment in dense urban environment in thailand
 
5 g architecture
 5 g architecture 5 g architecture
5 g architecture
 
Analysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX Environment
Analysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX EnvironmentAnalysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX Environment
Analysis of VoIP Traffic in WiMAX Environment
 
NTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of High
NTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of HighNTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of High
NTT DoCoMo and the Future Implications of High
 
5G Technolgy webinar, Shahram G Niri
5G  Technolgy webinar, Shahram G Niri5G  Technolgy webinar, Shahram G Niri
5G Technolgy webinar, Shahram G Niri
 
4g magic communication
4g magic communication4g magic communication
4g magic communication
 
Network economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technology
Network economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technologyNetwork economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technology
Network economics of optical transport networks with sd fec technology
 

Ähnlich wie Performance evaluation for outdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE 802.11b/g in the presence of co-channel interference

QoS of VOIP Over Broadband Network
QoS of VOIP Over Broadband NetworkQoS of VOIP Over Broadband Network
QoS of VOIP Over Broadband NetworkDr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Investigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus network
Investigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus networkInvestigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus network
Investigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus networkAlexander Decker
 
Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...
Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...
Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...ijwmn
 
Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...
Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...
Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...eSAT Journals
 
OPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEME
OPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEMEOPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEME
OPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEMEIJCNCJournal
 
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...Zac Darcy
 
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...Zac Darcy
 
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...Zac Darcy
 
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...Zac Darcy
 
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...Zac Darcy
 
IJSRED-V2I3P59
IJSRED-V2I3P59IJSRED-V2I3P59
IJSRED-V2I3P59IJSRED
 
Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...
Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...
Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...IJECEIAES
 
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deploymentAn analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deploymentConference Papers
 
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deploymentAn analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deploymentConference Papers
 
Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...
Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...
Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...Yi-Hsueh Tsai
 
Traffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFi
Traffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFiTraffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFi
Traffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFiShristi Pradhan
 
The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...
The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...
The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...IJECEIAES
 

Ähnlich wie Performance evaluation for outdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE 802.11b/g in the presence of co-channel interference (20)

QoS of VOIP Over Broadband Network
QoS of VOIP Over Broadband NetworkQoS of VOIP Over Broadband Network
QoS of VOIP Over Broadband Network
 
Investigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus network
Investigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus networkInvestigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus network
Investigating the performance of voip over wlan in campus network
 
Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...
Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...
Performance analysis of voip traffic over integrating wireless lan and wan us...
 
Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...
Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...
Performance analysis of voip over wired and wireless networks network impleme...
 
Performance Evaluation of Iptv over Wimax Networks Under Different Terrain En...
Performance Evaluation of Iptv over Wimax Networks Under Different Terrain En...Performance Evaluation of Iptv over Wimax Networks Under Different Terrain En...
Performance Evaluation of Iptv over Wimax Networks Under Different Terrain En...
 
OPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEME
OPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEMEOPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEME
OPTIMIZING VOIP USING A CROSS LAYER CALL ADMISSION CONTROL SCHEME
 
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
 
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
 
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
Comparative Study for Performance Analysis of VOIP Codecs Over WLAN in Nonmob...
 
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
 
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
COMPARATIVE STUDY FOR PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VOIP CODECS OVER WLAN IN NONMOB...
 
IJSRED-V2I3P59
IJSRED-V2I3P59IJSRED-V2I3P59
IJSRED-V2I3P59
 
Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...
Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...
Efficiency and effectiveness video on demand over worldwide interoperability ...
 
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deploymentAn analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
 
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deploymentAn analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
An analysis of a large scale wireless image distribution system deployment
 
Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...
Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...
Use Case and Requirements for Broadband Direct Air to Ground Communications (...
 
F502024852
F502024852F502024852
F502024852
 
M1803037881
M1803037881M1803037881
M1803037881
 
Traffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFi
Traffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFiTraffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFi
Traffic Offloading Solutions: Femto, WiFi and Integrated Femto-WiFi
 
The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...
The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...
The quality of service of the deployed LTE technology by mobile network opera...
 

Mehr von journalBEEI

Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipherSquare transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipherjournalBEEI
 
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...journalBEEI
 
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...journalBEEI
 
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networksA secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networksjournalBEEI
 
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural networkPlant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural networkjournalBEEI
 
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...journalBEEI
 
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...journalBEEI
 
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...journalBEEI
 
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithmWireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithmjournalBEEI
 
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antennaImplementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antennajournalBEEI
 
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human headThe calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human headjournalBEEI
 
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...journalBEEI
 
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting applicationDesign of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting applicationjournalBEEI
 
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...journalBEEI
 
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)journalBEEI
 
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...journalBEEI
 
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...journalBEEI
 
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...journalBEEI
 
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentationParking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentationjournalBEEI
 
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...journalBEEI
 

Mehr von journalBEEI (20)

Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipherSquare transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
 
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
 
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
 
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networksA secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
 
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural networkPlant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
 
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
 
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
 
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
 
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithmWireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
 
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antennaImplementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
 
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human headThe calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
 
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
 
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting applicationDesign of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
 
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
 
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
 
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
 
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
 
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
 
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentationParking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
 
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...srsj9000
 
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.eptoze12
 
computer application and construction management
computer application and construction managementcomputer application and construction management
computer application and construction managementMariconPadriquez1
 
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...Chandu841456
 
Sachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective Introduction
Sachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective IntroductionSachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective Introduction
Sachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective IntroductionDr.Costas Sachpazis
 
Decoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptx
Decoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptxDecoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptx
Decoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptxJoão Esperancinha
 
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfidmain PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfidNikhilNagaraju
 
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptxApplication of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx959SahilShah
 
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdfElectronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdfme23b1001
 
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .Satyam Kumar
 
Heart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptx
Heart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptxHeart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptx
Heart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptxPoojaBan
 
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...asadnawaz62
 
Arduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.ppt
Arduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.pptArduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.ppt
Arduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.pptSAURABHKUMAR892774
 
8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitter
8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitter8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitter
8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitterShivangiSharma879191
 
Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024
Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024
Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024hassan khalil
 
Past, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AIPast, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AIabhishek36461
 
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsCall Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girlsssuser7cb4ff
 
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdfAsst.prof M.Gokilavani
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
 
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
Oxy acetylene welding presentation note.
 
Call Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCR
Call Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCRCall Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCR
Call Us -/9953056974- Call Girls In Vikaspuri-/- Delhi NCR
 
computer application and construction management
computer application and construction managementcomputer application and construction management
computer application and construction management
 
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
 
Sachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective Introduction
Sachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective IntroductionSachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective Introduction
Sachpazis Costas: Geotechnical Engineering: A student's Perspective Introduction
 
Decoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptx
Decoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptxDecoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptx
Decoding Kotlin - Your guide to solving the mysterious in Kotlin.pptx
 
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfidmain PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
main PPT.pptx of girls hostel security using rfid
 
🔝9953056974🔝!!-YOUNG call girls in Rajendra Nagar Escort rvice Shot 2000 nigh...
🔝9953056974🔝!!-YOUNG call girls in Rajendra Nagar Escort rvice Shot 2000 nigh...🔝9953056974🔝!!-YOUNG call girls in Rajendra Nagar Escort rvice Shot 2000 nigh...
🔝9953056974🔝!!-YOUNG call girls in Rajendra Nagar Escort rvice Shot 2000 nigh...
 
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptxApplication of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
Application of Residue Theorem to evaluate real integrations.pptx
 
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdfElectronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
Electronically Controlled suspensions system .pdf
 
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .Churning of Butter, Factors affecting  .
Churning of Butter, Factors affecting .
 
Heart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptx
Heart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptxHeart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptx
Heart Disease Prediction using machine learning.pptx
 
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
complete construction, environmental and economics information of biomass com...
 
Arduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.ppt
Arduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.pptArduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.ppt
Arduino_CSE ece ppt for working and principal of arduino.ppt
 
8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitter
8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitter8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitter
8251 universal synchronous asynchronous receiver transmitter
 
Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024
Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024
Architect Hassan Khalil Portfolio for 2024
 
Past, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AIPast, Present and Future of Generative AI
Past, Present and Future of Generative AI
 
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsCall Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Call Girls Narol 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
 
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Network & Deep Learning UNIT III notes and Question bank .pdf
 

Performance evaluation for outdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE 802.11b/g in the presence of co-channel interference

  • 1. Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020,pp. 187~197 ISSN: 2302-9285,DOI: 10.11591/eei.v9i1.1649  187 Journal homepage: http://beei.org Performance evaluation for outdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE 802.11b/g in the presence of co-channel interference Roman A. Lara-Cueva, Michael S. Simba-Herrera Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones, Grupe de Investigación en Sistemas Inteligentes (WiCOM-Energy) and Ad Hoc Networks Research Center (CIRAD), Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas ESPE, Ecuador Article Info ABSTRACT Article history: Received May 31, 2019 Revised Aug 20, 2019 Accepted Oct 12, 2019 Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) has evolved over the years, being a real-time service. VoIP has been coupled to different technologies, one of them is WiFi, which is one of the most used for wireless local area networks in domestic and commercial environments. In this paper, we evaluate the performance of wireless scenarios by considering VoIP traffic, based on WiFi technology in conformance with IEEE 802.11b/g in interfered outdoor scenarios, by considering an intrusive injection traffic technique, for codecs G711(1 sample), G711(2 samples), G723, G729(2 samples), and G729(3 samples), related to the main metrics associated to Quality of Service (QoS) parameters. Our results show the best performance was obtained with the codecs G723 and G729(3 samples), obtaining up to 30 simultaneous voice connections with optimal values of delay, jitter and packet loss according to the recommendations given for VoIP by ITU-T, while the worst performance was obtained with the codec G711(2 samples), obtaining only 5 simultaneous voice connections, reaching an efficiency loss of around 18% in a co-channel interference scenario. Keywords: D-ITG MATLAB Medium accesscontrol Quality of Service (QoS) Voice over internet protocol WiFi This is an open access article under the CC BY-SAlicense. Corresponding Author: Michael S. Simba-Herrera, Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones, Universidad de las FuerzasArmadasESPE, Av. General Rumiñahuis/n Ambato,Sangolquí-Ecuador. Email: mssimba@espe.edu.ec 1. INTRODUCTION Technology has evolved in such way that messages, telephone calls, and video-conferences have become part of our daily lives [1]. In addition, the establishment of the Internet has allowed to Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) calls to grow remarkably, indeed according to Zion Research group, VoIP service has reached a total of 83 billion dollars in 2015, and it is estimated that by 2021 this service will reach a profit of 140 billion dollars, with a growth rate of 9.1% [2]. VoIP is a viable alternative to the Public Switched Telephone Network (PSTN) due to its high utilization resources and low cost, achieving savings of up to 95% [3]. Initially, VoIP was used by wired connections, and now WiFi technology has allowed the use of VoIP over wireless connections, this evolution is known as Voice over WiFi (VoWiFi), which carries voice traffic in a basic area service, where the main disadvantage is related to some metrics associated to Quality of Service (QoS) as Throughput (η), and Packet loss (PL), which could not guarantee real time transmissions in presence of interference.
  • 2.  ISSN:2302-9285 Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197 188 Previous research projects have covered the behaviour of WiFi technology [4-5], in conformance with the IEEE 802.11b/g standards by using analytical analysis [6], in which the parameters of the Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol are modified in order to obtain the voice capacity in an infrastructure network, and the maximum number of voice connections, reaching 19 voice connections with a satisfactory quality perceived by the user, meanwhile in [7] a simulation was performed to improve the quality of VoIP using signaling protocols, and codec schemes. Additionaly, in [8] was proposed an adaptive scheduling method for emissions based on network statistics, PL rate and packet availability. Otherwise, the performance evaluation of WiFi technology in an indoor environment was presented in [9 -11], a handover analysis was performed in [12] with conventional Extended Service Set (ESS) infrastructure with VoIP services and QoS assurance, and some methods to improve the quality of VoIP over a WLAN mesh were presented in [13], the capacity of switching mechanisms using failover mechanisms in a WAN and the quality of VoIP calls was studied in [14], also verifying the inherent limitations of the Distributed Coordination Function (DCF) to calculate the maximum number of VoIP clients a single Access Point (AP) can support, in which support 12 simultaneous VoIP calls considering G711 voice codec and 14 simultaneous VoIP calls considering G729 voice codec over a wireless network [15]. In [16] was showed low VoIP capacity in a WLAN and the unacceptable performance in the presence of coexisting traffic, another way to evaluate the behavior of the standard was by generating real calls by the software PBX-VoIP Asterisk, in [17] an outdoor environment was presented, and a total of simultaneous sessions were found that can be performed by using G729 voice codec reaching 25 simultaneous sessions, while with G711 voice codec 20 simultaneous sessions were obtained, also a traffic injection strategy was used in [18], by using Distributed Internet Traffic Generator (D-ITG), in where a laboratory environment was analyzed, in such environment was reached six clients connected wirelessly to an AP where the codec with the best stability was the G723. To the best of our knowledge, no principled studies have performed the network capacity in a co-channel interfered outdoor scenarios, in such way the aim of this paper is to deployed an outdoor wireless network to evaluate the performance of the scenarios in the presence of co-channel interference. To accomplish this, we apply an intrusive injection traffic technique by considering the main metrics associated to QoS as η, delay (δ), Jitter, and PL, by considering VoIP tra ffic within three proposed scenarios. In the first scenario, three APs were implemented, each one separated by 120 degrees, creating three Basic Service Set (BSS) in the same frequency channel. The second scenario consisted of two APs placed in the same direction each one creating BSS in the same frequencies. The third scenario consisted of three APs positioned in the same direction, each of which creates a BSS on independent frequency channels. 2. RESEARCH METHOD In this section we show theequipment and the applied methodology that was considered for the accomplishment of the experiment.Figure 1 shows the equipment deployed for the proposed scenarios, we used two and three AP working in the frequency band of 2.4 GHz in conformance with IEEE 802.11b/g standards, these were connected via an Unshielded Twisted Pair (UTP) cable to a modem, that was responsible for distributing the traffic generated by the APs.The laptops used to perform VoIP traffic injections have installed Linux operating system (Ubuntu 10.04), one of them with an Core i5 processor that works at 2.60 GHz with 6GB RAM memory was connected to one of the APs described above via WiFi, the other laptop with an Pentium CPU N3540 processor that works at 2.16 GHz with 4GB RAM memory was connected to a different AP. Figure 1. Equipment used for the different proposed scenarios
  • 3. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva) 189 2.1. Performance with D-ITG In order to obtain the performance evaluation, we used an intrusive injection traffic technique by considering D-ITG software, which has 5 different predefined voice codecs: G711 of 1 and 2 samples, G723 and G729 of 2 and 3 samples as shown in Figure 2, also provides information of the main metrics associated to QoS, each flow represented a VoIP call, for this reason, the multi-flow sending option was used in the D-ITG software, which allows several flows to be carried out at the same time; for more inform ation about D-ITG please referred to [19-20]. In this way, several simultaneous multi-flow processes were carried out, starting with 5 multi-flow processes, then 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, until 60 multi-flow processes for each of the codecs. It should be noticed that in order to achieve a certain statistical validity in the results of traffic injections, 15 repetitions were performed for each multi-flow process as recommended in [21-22], so that the error in the direct measurementsdecreases at the time of the performance analysis. Figure 2. Voice codecs and multi-flows in D-ITG 2.2. Scenarios In order to carry out the study, three different scenarios were considered, the network was deployed within Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas–ESPEcampus in a telecommunications towerlocated on the roof of the Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones building, that consists of two floors; the APs were placed 5.5 meters from the base of the tower to perform traffic injections and to analyze th eir behavior by considering the main metrics associated to QoS parameters provided by the aforementioned software. 2.2.1. Scenario 1 The first scenario is shown in Figure 3, where three AP were implemented, each one separated by 120 degrees creating three independent BSS's, each one using the same frequency channel, for this scenario there existed only interference from other networks presented in the outdoor environment, since the beamwidth of the APs has only 18 degrees aperture, so that their radiation patterns do not overlap each other, in addition,the two laptopswere connected to a different BSS to perform the traffic injections by using all the voice codecs of the software, first in one direction and then in the other, after all the traffic injections had been carried out,the data from the two directions were collected for analysis. 2.2.2. Scenario 2 The second scenario is showed in Figure 4, in the same way, two laptops were connected to a different AP, which are placed in the same direction, where each one created a different BSS that worked in the same frequency channel, for this scenario a co-channel interference was presented in addition to the interfering networks that may be presented when working in an outdoorenvironment.
  • 4.  ISSN:2302-9285 Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197 190 Figure 3. Scenario 1 Figure 4. Scenario 2 2.2.3. Scenario 3 The third scenario is showed in Figure 5, for this scenario three APs were deployed which created three different BSS in independent frequency channels (ch. 1, ch. 6, and ch. 11), in addition, there were two laptops in the same way that in the previous scenarios, each one of them were connected to a different BSS, traffic injections were first performed by two BSS and then by the remaining BSS, the data from the three BSS were collected for analysis. For this scenario did not exist interference created by the APs since they were in independent channels, but there may be noise that interferes with traffic injections and also interference created by devices that may be present in an outdoorscenario. Figure 5. Scenario 3 The analysis of the traffic injections considering the main metrics associated to QoS was performed taking into account the data provided by D-ITG: δ, η, Jitter and PL as shown in Figure 6, these data were classified according to the scenario and voice codec used, the analysis was performed in Matlab®.
  • 5. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva) 191 Figure 6. Data delivered by the software at the end of the multi-flows 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The analysis of the results was carried out according to the figures shown below, where the amount of simultaneous multi-flows made is called the number of voice connections, which are also shown in terms of percentage PL and η, while δ and Jitter are shown in milliseconds (ms). The three scenarios are described above, which were taken into account and the analysis was also made for each voice codec in order to know its behavior in each of the proposed scenario, bearing in mind the consideration of QoS parameters for VoIP were PL<1%, δ<150 ms and Jitter<30 ms [23-25]. For the first scenario, Figure 7 shows that with 5 voice connections all codecs satisfied QoS parameters, where the most efficient codec was G711(2 samples) with approximately η of 80%, when reaching the 10 voice connections the codecs G711(1 sample) and G723 satisfied the QoS parameters without any inconvenience,while the codecs G729(2 samples)and G729(3 samples) δ of 120 ms and 138 ms respectively, which approach the limit described in [23-25]; at 20 voice connections, only the codecs G723 and G729(3 samples) complied with the QoS parameters continuing with values close to the limit of δ, this behavior was maintained until the 30 voice connections, meanwhile, from 40 to 60 voice connections, none of the codecs complied with the QoS parameters. Figure 7. Results Scenario 1. (Blue line) Codec G711(1 sample), (Red line) Codec G711(2 samples), (Yellow line) Codec G723, (Purple line) Codec G729(2 samples), (Green line) Codec G729(3 samples) The results of the second scenario are shown in Figure 8, in the same way as in the first scenario, with 5 voice connections, all codecs satisfied QoS parameters, where codec G711(2 sample) maintains the best efficiency with around η of 80%, by increasing voice connections to 10, only codecs G723
  • 6.  ISSN:2302-9285 Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197 192 and G729(2 sample) satisfying QoS parameters, bearing in mind that codec G729(2 sample) had approximately δ of 130 ms; reaching 20 voice connections, none of the codecs could satisfy all the parametersof QoS, the codec G729(3 samples) satisfied the parameters PL and Jitter but did not comply with the parameter δ as it had a value close to 200 ms, while the G723 codec satisfied the δ and Jitter parameters but did not comply with the PL parameter which had an approximate value of 3%, after 30 to 60 voice connections, all codecs had PL values above the ideal value, so none of the codecs comply with QoS parameters. Figure 8. Results Scenario 2. (Blue line) Codec G711(1 sample), (Red line) Codec G711(2 samples), (Yellow line) Codec G723, (Purple line) Codec G729(2 samples), (Green line) Codec G729(3 samples) Figure 9 shows the results of the third scenario, with 5 voice connections as in the previous scenarios, all codecs comply with QoS parameters and in the same way,the G711 codec (2 samples) remains the most efficient, with around η of 80%, when the 10 voice connections were reach, three codecs continue to satisfied QoS parameters, these were the G711 codecs (1 sample), G723 and G729 (2 samples) where the latter had a value of δ close to the allowed range with a value of 145 ms, while with 20 voice connections only the G723 codec satisfied the QoS parameters,from 30 to 60 voice connections, none of the codecs were able to satisfy all the QoS parameters, the G723 codec satisfied the parameters of δ and Jitter, but as in previous scenarios, it did not satisfy the required percentage of PL with values greater than 1%. Figure 9. Results Scenario 3. (Blue line) Codec G711(1 sample), (Red line) Codec G711(2 samples), (Yellow line) Codec G723, (Purple line) Codec G729(2 samples), (Green line) Codec G729(3 samples)
  • 7. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva) 193 The behavior in the different scenarios of the codec G711(1 sample) may be appreciated in Figure 10, with values of δ of 25 ms for the 5 voice connections for the first and second scenarios, while the third scenario had a δ of 100 ms, when reached the 10 voice connections the first scenario had a δ of 50 ms while the third scenario had a δ of 110 ms approximately; the best performance was reach in the first scenario, with lower values of δ compared to the third scenario, which were the scenarios that achieve 10 voice connectionsthat complied with all QoS parameters. Figure 10. Results Codec G711(1 sample). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2, (Yellow line) Scenario 3 For the codec G711(2 samples) the behavior in the different scenarios is showed in Figure 11, this codec only managed to reach up to 5 simultaneous voice connections within the QoS parameters, in the three proposed scenarios it reached an efficiency of around η of 80%, where the best scenario was the second scenario with around δ of 25 ms followed closely by the third scenario with δ of 35 ms, while the first scenario had δ of 55 ms approximately, as voice connections increase, the values of δ and PL increased rapidly, even surpassing 1000 ms and 50%. Figure 11. Results Codec G711(2 samples). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2, (Yellow line) Scenario 3
  • 8.  ISSN:2302-9285 Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197 194 The G723 codec was the only one in each of the scenarios proposed in terms of δ and Jitter was within the QoS parameters for all voice connections, the only problem within this codec lies in the percentages of PL, where the first scenario was the best performing reaching 30 voice connections with a value of less than PL of 1%, in the third scenario reached 20 voice connections, while in the second scenario barely reached 10 voice connections, this is shown in Figure 12. Figure 12. Results Codec G723. (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2, (Yellow line) Scenario 3 Within the 3 proposed scenarios, codec G729(2 samples) had a similar behavior, reached only up to 10 voice connections, although with δ values quite close to the allowed limit, the lowest value of δ in 10 voice connections was in the first scenario with a value close to 110 ms, while the highest value was in the third scenario with approximately δ of 145 ms, Figure 13 shows the results of the different scenarios for this codec. Figure 13. Results Codec G729(2 samples). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2, (Yellow line) Scenario 3
  • 9. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva) 195 Finally, for codec G729(3 samples) the scenario where the best results were obtained was the first scenario where up to 30 simultaneousvoice connections are reached, similar to the previous codec the values of δ from 10 voice connectionswere high and maintain this constant untilreaching 30 voice connections with a range between 120 ms and 141 ms, this behaviormay be seen in Figure 14. Figure 14. Results Codec G729(3 samples). (Blue line) Scenario 1, (Red line) Scenario 2, (Yellow line) Scenario 3 4. CONCLUSION It was determined that the codec with the best performance considering the main metrics associa ted to QoS in the different test scenarios was the G723 codec, which achieved up to 30 simultaneous voice connections in the first scenario, 10 simultaneous voice connections for the second scenario and 20 simultaneous voice connections for the third scenario, on the other hand the codec with the worst behavior was the codec G711(2 samples), which achieved only 5 simultaneous voice connections in the three test scenarios, as well as in [17] where reached 5 voice connections in Central sub-scenario, which had 10 meters of distance between devices, working in the same frequency channel. The scenario with the best performance considering the main metrics associated to QoS was the first scenario, where most of codecs managed to make 10 simultaneous voice connections without exceeding the parameters of QoS, it should be noted that in this scenario two codecs could reach up to 30 simultaneous voice connections, these are codecs G723 and G729(3 samples), higher than those reached in [17], where with the G729 codec reaching up to 25 voice connections in MED sub-scenario, which had 10 meters of distance between devices working in the same frequency channel; while the worst performing scenario was the second scenario with three codecs reaching only up to 5 simultaneous voice connections, these were codecs G711(1 sample), G711(2 samples), and G729(3 samples), a voice connection above for the G711 and G729 codecs in Enlace sub-scenario shown in [17], which had 128 meters of distance between two locations. Taking into account the QoS parameters for VoIP that exist according to [23-25], it was possible to determine which are the limits for making simultaneous voice connections for each scenario, where the parametersthat present abrupt changes between a certain numberof voice connections and another were δ and PL. As these values increased, the Jitter also increased, although in a smaller proportion, while efficiency was also affected, being progressively less.Likewise, all interferences that are presented in an outdoor environment must be taken into account, since they cannot be avoided and affect the moment traffic intrusions are made in any of the scenarios, making the QoS values taken vary depending on the amount of interference that exists at that moment, where this can be appreciated most in the second scenario, when co-channel interference was presented in addition to interference found in an externalenvironment.
  • 10.  ISSN:2302-9285 Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 1, February2020 :187 – 197 196 Evaluating the different scenarios proposed, between the third and first scenario the efficiency was reduced by approximately 3.67%,while comparingthem with the second scenario which presents co-channel interference, between the first and second scenario, the efficiency was reduced by approximately 18%, and between the third and second scenario, the efficiency was reduced by approximately 18.3%, noting that when using independent channels the efficiency was higher.Finally, as future work is proposed to evaluate the performance of VoIPoutdoorswith standards IEEE 802.11a,IEEE 802.11n and IEEE 802.11ac,working on the frequency of 5 GHz, so that the existing interference outdoors is less because it has a greater number of channels compared to the frequency of 2.4GHz with a high saturation in the channels, it would also be interesting to evaluate the performance of VoIP using WIMAX (Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access) technology ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors gratefully acknowledge the contribution of Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas ESPE for the economical support in the development of this project by Research Grants 2011 -PIT-WiLD and 2013-PIT-014. REFERENCES [1] W. Andocilla, M. Vallejo, “Integración de los servicios de voz sobre IP, aplicado a un caso de estudio,” B.S. Thesis, Escuela Politécnica Nacional, Quito, Ecuador, March 2007. [2] Market Research Store, “Global VoIP Services Market Set for Rapid Growth, to Reach Around USD 140 Billion By 2021,” Market Research Store, May. 2, 2016. Accessed on: Feb. 26, 2019. [Online]. Available: https://www.marketresearchstore.com/news/global-voip-services-market-is-expected-to-reach-above-231 [3] Hipertextual, El papel de las centralitas virtuales en la internacionalización de empresas, Accessed on: Feb. 26, 2019. [Online]. Available: https://hipertextual.com/presentado-por/vozelia/centralitas-virtuales [4] D. Villacis, F. Acosta, R. Lara, “Performance analysis of VoIP services over WiFi-based systems” Communications and Computing (COLCOM), Medellin, Colombia, pp. 1-6, May 2013. [5] S. Suherman, "WiFi-friendly building to enable WiFi signal indoor,"Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 264-271, 2018. [6] L. X. Cai, Xuemin Shen, J. W. Mark, L. Cai and Yang Xiao, "Voice capacity analysis of WLAN with unbalanced traffic," in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 55, no. 3, pp. 752-761, May 2006. [7] O. Khalifa, R. Roslin, S. Bhuiyan, "Improved voice quality with the combination of transport layer & audio codec for wireless devices,"Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 264-271, 2018. [8] P. Chandran, C. Lingam, "A statistical approach to adaptive playout scheduling in voice over internet protocol communication,"International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol. 8, no. 5, pp. 2926-2933, 2018. [9] R. Lara-Cueva, C. Morales and C. Fernández, "Performance evaluation of WiFi technology in conformance with IEEE 802.11b/n/ac and WDS for indoor environments," 2017 IEEE Colombian Conference on Communications and Computing (COLCOM), Cartagena, pp. 1-6, 2017. [10] R. Lara-Cueva, D. Benítez, C. Fernández, and C. Morales, “Performance analysis of wireless network modes in conformance with ieee 802.11b and wds,” in Asia-Pacific Conference on Computer Aided System Engineering, Quito, Ecuador, pp. 370–373, Jul 2015. [11] M. A. Vallejo-Baldeón, D. N. Rodríguez and R. A. Lara-Cueva, "Performance evaluation of wireless network in conformance with IEEE 802.11n in co-channel interference scenarios," 2017 IEEE Colombian Conference on Communications and Computing (COLCOM), Cartagena, pp. 1-6, 2017. [12] I. Prasetyo, M. Anif, A. Sriyanto, S. Pramono, S. Widodo, S. Hidayat, “Handover analysis of data and VoIP services in 802.11b/g/n wireless LAN,”TELKOMNIKA (Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control), vol. 12, no. 11, pp. 7832-7844, 2014. [13] D. Niculescu, S. Ganguly, K. Kim and R. Izmailov, "Performance of VoIP in a 802.11 wireless mesh network," Proceedings IEEE INFOCOM 2006. 25TH IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications, Barcelona, pp. 1-11, 2006. [14] H. Septama, A. Ulvan, R. Bestak, J. Hlavacek, “High available VoIP server failover mechanism in wide area network”, TELKOMNIKA (Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control), vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 739-744, 2015 [15] S. Garg and M. Kappes, "Can I add a VoIP call?," IEEE International Conference on Communications, 2003. ICC '03., Anchorage, AK, vo. 2, pp. 779-783, 2003. [16] Wei Wang, Soung Chang Liew and V. O. K. Li, "Solutions to performance problems in VoIP over a 802.11 wireless LAN," in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 54, no. 1, pp. 366-384, Jan. 2005. [17] M.Nuñez, C. Játiva, R. Lara, “Performance evaluation of VoIP technology in an extended service set, in concordance with IEEE 802.11g,”Sistemas y Telemática, vol. 15, no. 42, pp. 85-100, Oct. 2017. [18] G. Agredo, J. Gaviria, “Experimental evaluation of the capacity of IEEE 802.11b to support VoIP services,” Sistemas y Telemática, vol. 4, no.8, pp. 125-151, Oct. 2006.
  • 11. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Performance evaluation foroutdoor wireless scenarios based on IEEE… (Román A. Lara-Cueva) 197 [19] A. Botta, A. Dainotti, A. Pescapè, "A tool for the generation of realistic network workload for emerging networking scenarios", Computer Networks (Elsevier), vol. 56, no. 15, pp 3531-3547, 2012. [20] D-ITG, “Distributed Internet Traffic Generator,” Accessed on: Feb. 18, 2019. [Online]. Available: http://www.grid.unina.it/software/ITG/manual/ [21] A. Posadas, “Determinación de Errores y Tratamiento de Datos,” Accessed on: Feb. 27, 2019. [Online]. Available https://w3.ual.es/~aposadas/TeoriaErrores.pdf [22] A. Kowalski, “Técnicas Auxiliares de Laboratorio,” Accessed on: Feb. 27, 2019. [Online]. Available https://www.ugr.es/~andyk/Docencia/TEB/Errores.pdf [23] T. Szigeti and C. Hattingh, “QoS Design Overview” in “End-to-End QoS network design: quality of service in LANs, WANs, and VPNs,”2nd ed. T. Szigeti, Ed. Indianapolis: Cisco Press, pp. 33-38, 2004. [24] One-Way Transmission Time, document ITU-T Rec. G.114, International Telecommunication Union, Geneva, Switzerland, May 2003. [25] P. Mehta and S. Udani, "Voice over IP," in IEEE Potentials, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 36-40, Oct.-Nov. 2001. BIOGRAPHIES OF AUTHORS Román A. Lara-Cueva received the B.Eng. degree in electronic and telecommunications engineering from Escuela Politécnica Nacional, Quito, Ecuador, in 2001, the M.Sc. degree in wireless systems and related technologies from the Politecnico di Torino, Turin, Italy, in 2005, and the M.Sc. and Ph.D. degrees in telecommunication networks for developing countries from Rey Juan Carlos University, Fuenlabrada, Spain, in 2010 and 2015, respectively.In 2002, he joined the Departamento de Eléctrica, Electrónica y Telecomunicaciones, Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas ESPE, Sangolquí, Ecuador, where he has been an Associate Professor since 2005 and a Full Professor since 2016. He has authored or coauthored 12 publicly funded research projects and directed seven of them. He currently heads the Ad Hoc Network Research Center and the Smart Systems Research Group (WiCOM-Energy). His research interests include digital signal processing, smart cities, wireless systems, machine learning theory, and volcano seismology. Michael S. Simba-HerreraCandidate to Engineer in Electronics and Telecommunications at the Universidad de las Fuerzas Armadas - ESPE (Sangolquí, Ecuador). In 2018 he joined the Grupe de InvestigaciónenSistemasInteligentes (WiCOM-Energy) and Ad Hoc Networks Research Center (CIRAD) as research assistant. His main areas of interest in research are wireless systems and Voice over IP (VoIP).