3. Advantages of DIY - Corporate Rating? 1
Nakamura estimated the value of US gross
investments in intangibles in 2000 at $1 trillion and
Corrado and Hulten (2010) in 2007 at $4.1 trillion,
that was excluded from published national accounts
data in the United States.
Unavailability of granular data results in valuation of
a company unauthentic.
SEBI's Mandatory Grading for IPO is Intangible.
Advantages of DIY - Corporate Rating System are to
the company primarily. Intangible empowers
measuring one's own Value Capital. 3
4. Advantages of DIY - Corporate Rating? 2
For the Investor
– Assurance on:
Sustainability of Efficiency
Sustainability of Value System
Sustainability of profits
For the Corporate
– Wider access to Capital
– Sustainability of growth
For the Regulator
– Corporate Self-Regulatory Mechanism
4
5. Quantitative & Qualitative Elements
Mandatory Grading Characteristics
criteria for IPOs 1. EPS - Quantitative elements
1. EPS 2 & 3 - Management &
2. Management Accounting Quality -
Quality Qualitative elements purely
Intellectual
3. Accounting
Quality 4 & 5 Corporate Governance &
Financial Risks - Quantitative-
4. Corporate
cum-Qualitative elements -
Governance and
purely Emotional, linked to
5. Financial Risks. respective Quality.
5
7. Intangible Value Capital
Intangible Value Capital = (Intellectual Value
Capital + Emotional Value Capital) / 2 to derive 0 to
5 rating by each building-block.
At optimised level of 5 Rating assumes a power base
and an energy force within a corporate, assuring
sustainability of efficiency, value system and profits.
Assurance by Public Reporting goes beyond
financial terms which are tangible and objective but
speculative and divergent to project 'fundamentals'
capability which is intangible and subjective but
everlasting and convergent.
7
9. Corporate Rating
Mandatory Grading criteria incorporated in Corporate
Rating System
Intangible Value Capital is built bottom-up.
Consolidate by Corporate, by Industry, to arrive at
Country Rating
9
10. Corporate Rating
Banking
BASEL III targets incorporated.
IIF Report Principles & Recommendations regrouped under Intellectual
Value Capital & Emotional Value Capital enabling implementation.
CSR-Integrated Intangible Value Capital Rating arrived at.
Consolidate by Bank, by Banking Industry, to arrive at Country Rating.
10
11. Corporate Rating
Banking
Rating keeps track of targets - e.g., BASEL III will be optimised at 5 when targets
are reached, by real-time monitoring. Rating 0 - 5 is the status of preparedness.
Current Status of Rs.90k Crore deficit to reach status 5 when BASEL III target
is reached. 11
12. Three Principles for DIY - Corporate
Rating
1.Real-time Monitoring
– Rating is related to the stage of process
completion.
2. Study of Cost Consequence
– The resultant state of inactive elements.
3. People Participation
– CSR Integrated in each goal.
12
14. DIY - Corporate Rating
3-Ps - Policies, Practices & People
DIY - Corporate Rating signifies the measurement
of 3 Ps -Policies, Practices and People, of
Intellectual Value Capital, Emotional Value
Capital and Intangible Value Capital
respectively, that neither can be outsourced nor
dependant on outside agencies for rating
purposes.
14