SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 3
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
SA investors faced with Hobsons choice over possible takeover of Tongaat Hulett by Zims
Rudland family Tim Cohen 10 Jan 2022 The South African investment community is on the
horns of a dilemma regarding the underwritten rights offer for Tongaat Hulett either do a deal
with one of Zimbabwes most notorious families or face the breakup of southern Africas leading
sugar producer. Tongaat Hulett has been through the wringer over the past few years following
the discovery of accounting irregularities in 2019, which resulted in the company having to
restate its results and being fined by the JSE. The result was an implosion in the companys share
price which, in 2018, was trading at around R130 to the roughly R6 at which it is trading today.
Despite a clean-up campaign, an extensive investigation by PwC and a new management sweep,
the company is still struggling. The share price implosion has had the effect of rendering the
companys balance sheet on the verge of being unsustainable, and its huge debt load of roughly
R6.6-billion is now at risk, causing a minor panic among its bankers. Into this morass has
jumped a Mauritius-registered company, Magister, which is owned and controlled by members
of Zimbabwes Rudland family, who have reportedly been consistent supporters of Zanu-PF and
its leadership. The family also owns the Gold Leaf Tobacco company, which, by some estimates,
is the largest cigarette company in South Africa measured by the number of cigarettes sold. The
company burst into the public spotlight when co-owner Simon Rudland survived a gangland-
style assassination attempt in August 2019. There is no direct link between Magister and Gold
Leaf, which is represented by Simon Rudlands brother, Hamish, whose main business is in the
transport industry. However, several reports have warned about Zimbabwes recent descent into a
Russian-style oligarchical system. Its becoming a regional hub for laundering illicit wealth that is
fuelling violent conflict, one report concludes. It also included a detailed breakdown of the
alleged activities of the Rudland family, including gold smuggling, money laundering and
mining in conservation areas. Magister announced on 17 November 2021 that it would
underwrite the first R2-billion of a R4-billion rights offer. If successful, the rights offer will go a
long way towards solving Tongaats debt problem and will probably maintain the integrity of the
company. The drama of the rights offer is illustrated by the fact that Tongaat currently has an
equity value of R770-million. The rights offer therefore has the likely outcome that it will
completely transform the ownership structure of the company. In terms of the deal, Magisters
shareholding is capped at a maximum of 60% of the enlarged shareholding. Magister will receive
a board seat for every 20% of the company that it owns, post the rights issue. It will also receive
a fixed underwriting fee of 1.5%, or R30-million. Tongaat itself has few other options outside
selling its assets piecemeal, a process which it had already begun, principally by selling its very
profitable starch operations and a number of smaller businesses including the Namibian trading
and marketing business and operations in Swaziland. At an operating level, the company is still
struggling. In a trading statement in September, it announced that headline earnings for the six
months to 20 September would be sharply down. And so it turned out when the company
announced its interim results on 9 December, with operating profit down from R1.67-billion to
R1.2-billion. Profit after tax fell to R23-million from R385-million. For SA investors, the
proposal is a double-edged sword do a deal with a notorious family or face the break-up of the
company, putting at risk the future of the 29,000 employees at peak harvest season in operations
across South Africa, Zimbabwe, Mozambique and Botswana. For its part, Tongaat has thrown in
its lot with the former option. Asked in the context of the Zondo Commission report, which
slated SA business for turning a blind eye to corruption, whether a deal with Magister is
advisable, the company said it considers that Magister would be a suitable investor. Head of
communications for Tongaat Virginia Horsley said as part of the companys assessment of
Magister, PwC, at Tongaats request, conducted an independent compliance due diligence
exercise which included gaining an understanding of Magister, its assets and investments and its
associates, as well as a review of a combination of publicly available information, selected
private corporate information, references and responses from Magister to specific questions.
Magister is invested in several reputable and substantial businesses, and Tongaat believes that it
would be a suitable investor. Magister has provided Tongaat with a South African bank
guarantee to support its underwriting commitments. As part of this process, Standard Bank
undertook Anti-Money Laundering and Know Your Customer checks, which Tongaat has taken
comfort from. We believe that through a rights offer of up to R4-billion, Tongaat will unlock
long-term growth, protect intrinsic shareholder value and create a legacy for the many people
dependent on the Tongaat business across the SADC. For their part, the Rudland family is
adamant that the notorious tag is inappropriate. In reply to questions from Business Maverick,
the company said Rudland family members have many business interests in reputable and
substantial businesses, including listed companies. There is no basis to suggest that they are
unsuitable to invest in Tongaat. The family has high regard for good corporate governance
practices. Magister has confidence in the management of Tongaat and has no intention of being
involved in the day-to-day operations of Tongaat. Family members already own 9.98% of
Tongaat through a United Arab Emirates-registered company, Braemar. But neither Braemar nor
Magister will be voting on the resolutions for corporate governance reasons even though they are
not technically related parties as defined by the Companies Act or JSE rules. Other investors are
not so sure: they range from reluctantly supportive to outright astounded that Magister could
conceivably pass any reputable Know Your Customer check. Representatives of the major
cigarette producers affiliated with the Tobacco Institute of South Africa claim that the
newcomers, affiliated with the Fair Trade Independent Tobacco Association (Fita), have been
selling enormous quantities of cigarettes very cheaply by the simple mechanism of not paying
SAs huge cigarette excise tax. Fita members deny the claim. The pandemic, particularly the
banning of tobacco sales for a period in 2020, was a huge boon to Fita members who had been
operating mostly under the radar anyway, often selling cheapie cigarettes individually rather than
by the packet. Magister says Gold Leaf has not financed Magister and is not financing the
underwrite or any part of it. The two biggest shareholders in Tongaat are the Public Investment
Corporation (PIC), which did not respond to media enquiries, and financial group PSG, which
own 14% and 15% of the company, respectively. Both PSG and the PIC have supported the
process of putting the notion of the rights offer to shareholders but have not yet agreed to support
the bid, which will depend on the pricing of the offer. Chief Executive of PSG Asset
Management, Anet Ahern, said juggling all the stakeholders interests is exceptionally tricky in
this case, as Tongaat also has a big impact on the society in which it operates. Tough choices
need to be made, and these will always be controversial. In effect, the bankers of the deal,
Standard Bank, have sought to place the responsibility for the decision to proceed with the board
and shareholders of Tongaat. Standard Bank complies with local and international anti-money
laundering legislation and takes this responsibility seriously. Standard Bank follows its internal
client risk assessment processes diligently and consistently, and will not put its reputation at risk
by doing business in an unethical, illegal or unprofessional manner. Any decision to proceed
with the rights offer and any related transactions will be the sole and independent responsibility
of the Tongaat Hulett board and its shareholders, it said. BM/DM Source:
https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2022-01-10-sa-investors-faced-with-hobsons-
choiceover-possibletakeover-of-tongaat-hulett-by-zims-rudland-family/
Question 1 (10 Marks)
Identify the dilemma regarding the underwriting rights offer for Tongaat Hullett in the case study
and examine the ethical implications in the case study.

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie SA investors faced with Hobson�s choice over possible takeover of To.pdf

Mimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slide
Mimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slideMimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slide
Mimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slideZimpapers Group (1980)
 
NetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to Govt
NetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to GovtNetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to Govt
NetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to GovtZimpapers Group (1980)
 
Independent_Article_1995_original
Independent_Article_1995_originalIndependent_Article_1995_original
Independent_Article_1995_originalMark Garratt
 
Exiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the Diaspora
Exiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the DiasporaExiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the Diaspora
Exiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the DiasporaZimpapers Group (1980)
 
7 keys to open doors at Citigroup
7 keys to open doors at Citigroup7 keys to open doors at Citigroup
7 keys to open doors at Citigroupdatabahn
 
Business Day article on Junior financing
Business Day article on Junior financingBusiness Day article on Junior financing
Business Day article on Junior financingJames AH Campbell
 
News Release: Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...
News Release:  Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...News Release:  Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...
News Release: Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...Zimtu Capital Corp. (TSXv: ZC)
 
Germany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talks
Germany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talksGermany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talks
Germany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talksZimpapers Group (1980)
 
Ariston debt reduction plan edges closer
Ariston debt reduction plan edges closerAriston debt reduction plan edges closer
Ariston debt reduction plan edges closerZimpapers Group (1980)
 
Myanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company Status
Myanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company StatusMyanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company Status
Myanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company StatusMYO AUNG Myanmar
 
DealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe Interview
DealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe InterviewDealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe Interview
DealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe InterviewMamokete Ramathe
 
Zimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivals
Zimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivalsZimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivals
Zimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivalsZimpapers Group (1980)
 
Barclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time being
Barclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time beingBarclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time being
Barclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time beingZimpapers Group (1980)
 
Mwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive director
Mwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive directorMwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive director
Mwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive directorZimpapers Group (1980)
 
Tracking the trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...
Tracking the  trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...Tracking the  trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...
Tracking the trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...ZELA_infor
 
Stop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigations
Stop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigationsStop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigations
Stop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigationsContent Share
 

Ähnlich wie SA investors faced with Hobson�s choice over possible takeover of To.pdf (20)

Mimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slide
Mimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slideMimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slide
Mimosa HY production up 2pc, but revenues slide
 
NetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to Govt
NetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to GovtNetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to Govt
NetOne eyes improved bottomline, dividend to Govt
 
Independent_Article_1995_original
Independent_Article_1995_originalIndependent_Article_1995_original
Independent_Article_1995_original
 
CFI Holdings suspended from ZSE?
CFI Holdings suspended from ZSE?CFI Holdings suspended from ZSE?
CFI Holdings suspended from ZSE?
 
Exiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the Diaspora
Exiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the DiasporaExiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the Diaspora
Exiting Lafarge FD to be replaced by Zimbabwean in the Diaspora
 
7 keys to open doors at Citigroup
7 keys to open doors at Citigroup7 keys to open doors at Citigroup
7 keys to open doors at Citigroup
 
Business Day article on Junior financing
Business Day article on Junior financingBusiness Day article on Junior financing
Business Day article on Junior financing
 
News Release: Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...
News Release:  Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...News Release:  Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...
News Release: Zimtu Capital Corp Announces Transaction with 92 Resources Cor...
 
Kimari Group
Kimari GroupKimari Group
Kimari Group
 
Germany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talks
Germany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talksGermany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talks
Germany invites Zimbabwean delegation to Berlin for debt talks
 
Ariston debt reduction plan edges closer
Ariston debt reduction plan edges closerAriston debt reduction plan edges closer
Ariston debt reduction plan edges closer
 
Myanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company Status
Myanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company StatusMyanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company Status
Myanmar Mineral Exploration and Oversea Mining Company Status
 
DealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe Interview
DealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe InterviewDealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe Interview
DealSpeak03-December-2015 Mamokete Ramathe Interview
 
Zimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivals
Zimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivalsZimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivals
Zimbabwe targets 2,5 million tourist arrivals
 
Barclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time being
Barclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time beingBarclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time being
Barclays Plc sticks with Zim....for the time being
 
Mwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive director
Mwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive directorMwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive director
Mwana seeks to end dispute with shareholder and non-executive director
 
Tracking the trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...
Tracking the  trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...Tracking the  trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...
Tracking the trend an assessment of diamond mining sector tax contributions ...
 
ID 9th May 2012
ID 9th May 2012ID 9th May 2012
ID 9th May 2012
 
Stop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigations
Stop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigationsStop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigations
Stop Work Orders RSPO NGO investigations
 
dolomite market
dolomite marketdolomite market
dolomite market
 

Mehr von ishratmanzar1986

Soru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdf
Soru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdfSoru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdf
Soru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
someone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdf
someone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdfsomeone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdf
someone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Se induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdf
Se induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdfSe induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdf
Se induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Se descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdf
Se descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdfSe descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdf
Se descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
ScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdf
ScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdfScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdf
ScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Sandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdf
Sandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdfSandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdf
Sandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Satlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdf
Satlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdfSatlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdf
Satlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Salespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdf
Salespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdfSalespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdf
Salespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
S1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdf
S1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdfS1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdf
S1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
SoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdf
SoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdfSoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdf
SoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Social network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdf
Social network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdfSocial network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdf
Social network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
SNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdf
SNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdfSNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdf
SNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Snell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdf
Snell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdfSnell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdf
Snell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Skye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble. Capital balances .pdf
Skye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble.  Capital balances .pdfSkye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble.  Capital balances .pdf
Skye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble. Capital balances .pdfishratmanzar1986
 
SLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdf
SLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdfSLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdf
SLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Since the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdf
Since the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdfSince the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdf
Since the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Sinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdf
Sinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdfSinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdf
Sinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Simon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdf
Simon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdfSimon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdf
Simon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Si una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdf
Si una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdfSi una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdf
Si una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdfishratmanzar1986
 
Si la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdf
Si la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdfSi la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdf
Si la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdfishratmanzar1986
 

Mehr von ishratmanzar1986 (20)

Soru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdf
Soru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdfSoru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdf
Soru 1 Bir n�kleosit ve bir n�kleotit arasndaki fark udur A. n�.pdf
 
someone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdf
someone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdfsomeone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdf
someone help Python programming After the loop ends, return the expe.pdf
 
Se induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdf
Se induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdfSe induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdf
Se induce un modelo de rat�n para la esclerosis m�ltiple mediante la.pdf
 
Se descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdf
Se descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdfSe descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdf
Se descubre un agente infeccioso que provoca una determinada enferme.pdf
 
ScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdf
ScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdfScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdf
ScenarioSamuel Fox worked as a seaman on an Exxon Shipping Co. oil.pdf
 
Sandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdf
Sandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdfSandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdf
Sandrine, irketine son derece sadktr ve bu nedenle ayrlmay d��nmez. .pdf
 
Satlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdf
Satlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdfSatlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdf
Satlardaki belirli bir y�zde deiikliinden kaynaklanan hisse bana kaz.pdf
 
Salespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdf
Salespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdfSalespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdf
Salespeople are often stereotyped as pushy, shifty, and untrustworth.pdf
 
S1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdf
S1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdfS1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdf
S1 Aadakilerin t�m�, bir irketin ________ HAR� satn alarak yeni �.pdf
 
SoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdf
SoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdfSoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdf
SoftwareApplication architects works with multiple other architects.pdf
 
Social network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdf
Social network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdfSocial network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdf
Social network services are emerging as a promising IT-based busines.pdf
 
SNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdf
SNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdfSNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdf
SNPs are choose all that applyGroup of answer choicesa. Single-.pdf
 
Snell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdf
Snell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdfSnell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdf
Snell Co. realiza y completa servicios para un cliente en mayo y fac.pdf
 
Skye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble. Capital balances .pdf
Skye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble.  Capital balances .pdfSkye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble.  Capital balances .pdf
Skye and Chase Partnership agree to admit Rubble. Capital balances .pdf
 
SLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdf
SLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdfSLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdf
SLICE NAMERegression and CorrelationTOPIC NAMESLICE NAMERegr.pdf
 
Since the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdf
Since the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdfSince the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdf
Since the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA.pdf
 
Sinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdf
Sinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdfSinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdf
Sinaptik plastisite neden davransal ekolojide �nemli bir kavramdr.pdf
 
Simon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdf
Simon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdfSimon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdf
Simon, bal rasyonellik veya temelde bir bireyin rasyonel karar ver.pdf
 
Si una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdf
Si una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdfSi una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdf
Si una corporaci�n declara un dividendo en acciones del 10 sobre su.pdf
 
Si la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdf
Si la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdfSi la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdf
Si la capacidad de un paciente para crear la bicapa que rodea las c�.pdf
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptxmary850239
 
Jason Potel In Media Res Media Component
Jason Potel In Media Res Media ComponentJason Potel In Media Res Media Component
Jason Potel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Paul Dobryden In Media Res Media Component
Paul Dobryden In Media Res Media ComponentPaul Dobryden In Media Res Media Component
Paul Dobryden In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Transdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptx
Transdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptxTransdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptx
Transdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptxinfo924062
 
PART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFE
PART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFEPART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFE
PART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFEMISSRITIMABIOLOGYEXP
 
Objectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptx
Objectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptxObjectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptx
Objectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptxMadhavi Dharankar
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
DiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdf
DiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdfDiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdf
DiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdfChristalin Nelson
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17
Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17
Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17Celine George
 
CLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptx
CLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptxCLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptx
CLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptxAnupam32727
 
Sulphonamides, mechanisms and their uses
Sulphonamides, mechanisms and their usesSulphonamides, mechanisms and their uses
Sulphonamides, mechanisms and their usesVijayaLaxmi84
 
Indexing Structures in Database Management system.pdf
Indexing Structures in Database Management system.pdfIndexing Structures in Database Management system.pdf
Indexing Structures in Database Management system.pdfChristalin Nelson
 
Vinícius Portella In Media Res Media Component
Vinícius Portella In Media Res Media ComponentVinícius Portella In Media Res Media Component
Vinícius Portella In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptx
16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptx16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptx
16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptxUmeshTimilsina1
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
4.11.24 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
 
Jason Potel In Media Res Media Component
Jason Potel In Media Res Media ComponentJason Potel In Media Res Media Component
Jason Potel In Media Res Media Component
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design" - Introduction to Machine Learning"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design" - Introduction to Machine Learning"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design" - Introduction to Machine Learning"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design" - Introduction to Machine Learning"
 
Paul Dobryden In Media Res Media Component
Paul Dobryden In Media Res Media ComponentPaul Dobryden In Media Res Media Component
Paul Dobryden In Media Res Media Component
 
Introduction to Research ,Need for research, Need for design of Experiments, ...
Introduction to Research ,Need for research, Need for design of Experiments, ...Introduction to Research ,Need for research, Need for design of Experiments, ...
Introduction to Research ,Need for research, Need for design of Experiments, ...
 
Transdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptx
Transdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptxTransdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptx
Transdisciplinary Pathways for Urban Resilience [Work in Progress].pptx
 
PART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFE
PART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFEPART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFE
PART 1 - CHAPTER 1 - CELL THE FUNDAMENTAL UNIT OF LIFE
 
Objectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptx
Objectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptxObjectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptx
Objectives n learning outcoms - MD 20240404.pptx
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 - I-LEARN SMART WORLD - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (BẢN...
 
DiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdf
DiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdfDiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdf
DiskStorage_BasicFileStructuresandHashing.pdf
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 11 (CẢ NĂM) - FRIENDS GLOBAL - NĂM HỌC...
 
Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17
Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17
Tree View Decoration Attribute in the Odoo 17
 
CLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptx
CLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptxCLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptx
CLASSIFICATION OF ANTI - CANCER DRUGS.pptx
 
Sulphonamides, mechanisms and their uses
Sulphonamides, mechanisms and their usesSulphonamides, mechanisms and their uses
Sulphonamides, mechanisms and their uses
 
Plagiarism,forms,understand about plagiarism,avoid plagiarism,key significanc...
Plagiarism,forms,understand about plagiarism,avoid plagiarism,key significanc...Plagiarism,forms,understand about plagiarism,avoid plagiarism,key significanc...
Plagiarism,forms,understand about plagiarism,avoid plagiarism,key significanc...
 
Indexing Structures in Database Management system.pdf
Indexing Structures in Database Management system.pdfIndexing Structures in Database Management system.pdf
Indexing Structures in Database Management system.pdf
 
Vinícius Portella In Media Res Media Component
Vinícius Portella In Media Res Media ComponentVinícius Portella In Media Res Media Component
Vinícius Portella In Media Res Media Component
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KĨ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH LỚP 8 - CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC ...
 
16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptx
16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptx16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptx
16. Discovery, function and commercial uses of different PGRS.pptx
 

SA investors faced with Hobson�s choice over possible takeover of To.pdf

  • 1. SA investors faced with Hobsons choice over possible takeover of Tongaat Hulett by Zims Rudland family Tim Cohen 10 Jan 2022 The South African investment community is on the horns of a dilemma regarding the underwritten rights offer for Tongaat Hulett either do a deal with one of Zimbabwes most notorious families or face the breakup of southern Africas leading sugar producer. Tongaat Hulett has been through the wringer over the past few years following the discovery of accounting irregularities in 2019, which resulted in the company having to restate its results and being fined by the JSE. The result was an implosion in the companys share price which, in 2018, was trading at around R130 to the roughly R6 at which it is trading today. Despite a clean-up campaign, an extensive investigation by PwC and a new management sweep, the company is still struggling. The share price implosion has had the effect of rendering the companys balance sheet on the verge of being unsustainable, and its huge debt load of roughly R6.6-billion is now at risk, causing a minor panic among its bankers. Into this morass has jumped a Mauritius-registered company, Magister, which is owned and controlled by members of Zimbabwes Rudland family, who have reportedly been consistent supporters of Zanu-PF and its leadership. The family also owns the Gold Leaf Tobacco company, which, by some estimates, is the largest cigarette company in South Africa measured by the number of cigarettes sold. The company burst into the public spotlight when co-owner Simon Rudland survived a gangland- style assassination attempt in August 2019. There is no direct link between Magister and Gold Leaf, which is represented by Simon Rudlands brother, Hamish, whose main business is in the transport industry. However, several reports have warned about Zimbabwes recent descent into a Russian-style oligarchical system. Its becoming a regional hub for laundering illicit wealth that is fuelling violent conflict, one report concludes. It also included a detailed breakdown of the alleged activities of the Rudland family, including gold smuggling, money laundering and mining in conservation areas. Magister announced on 17 November 2021 that it would underwrite the first R2-billion of a R4-billion rights offer. If successful, the rights offer will go a long way towards solving Tongaats debt problem and will probably maintain the integrity of the company. The drama of the rights offer is illustrated by the fact that Tongaat currently has an equity value of R770-million. The rights offer therefore has the likely outcome that it will completely transform the ownership structure of the company. In terms of the deal, Magisters shareholding is capped at a maximum of 60% of the enlarged shareholding. Magister will receive a board seat for every 20% of the company that it owns, post the rights issue. It will also receive a fixed underwriting fee of 1.5%, or R30-million. Tongaat itself has few other options outside selling its assets piecemeal, a process which it had already begun, principally by selling its very profitable starch operations and a number of smaller businesses including the Namibian trading and marketing business and operations in Swaziland. At an operating level, the company is still
  • 2. struggling. In a trading statement in September, it announced that headline earnings for the six months to 20 September would be sharply down. And so it turned out when the company announced its interim results on 9 December, with operating profit down from R1.67-billion to R1.2-billion. Profit after tax fell to R23-million from R385-million. For SA investors, the proposal is a double-edged sword do a deal with a notorious family or face the break-up of the company, putting at risk the future of the 29,000 employees at peak harvest season in operations across South Africa, Zimbabwe, Mozambique and Botswana. For its part, Tongaat has thrown in its lot with the former option. Asked in the context of the Zondo Commission report, which slated SA business for turning a blind eye to corruption, whether a deal with Magister is advisable, the company said it considers that Magister would be a suitable investor. Head of communications for Tongaat Virginia Horsley said as part of the companys assessment of Magister, PwC, at Tongaats request, conducted an independent compliance due diligence exercise which included gaining an understanding of Magister, its assets and investments and its associates, as well as a review of a combination of publicly available information, selected private corporate information, references and responses from Magister to specific questions. Magister is invested in several reputable and substantial businesses, and Tongaat believes that it would be a suitable investor. Magister has provided Tongaat with a South African bank guarantee to support its underwriting commitments. As part of this process, Standard Bank undertook Anti-Money Laundering and Know Your Customer checks, which Tongaat has taken comfort from. We believe that through a rights offer of up to R4-billion, Tongaat will unlock long-term growth, protect intrinsic shareholder value and create a legacy for the many people dependent on the Tongaat business across the SADC. For their part, the Rudland family is adamant that the notorious tag is inappropriate. In reply to questions from Business Maverick, the company said Rudland family members have many business interests in reputable and substantial businesses, including listed companies. There is no basis to suggest that they are unsuitable to invest in Tongaat. The family has high regard for good corporate governance practices. Magister has confidence in the management of Tongaat and has no intention of being involved in the day-to-day operations of Tongaat. Family members already own 9.98% of Tongaat through a United Arab Emirates-registered company, Braemar. But neither Braemar nor Magister will be voting on the resolutions for corporate governance reasons even though they are not technically related parties as defined by the Companies Act or JSE rules. Other investors are not so sure: they range from reluctantly supportive to outright astounded that Magister could conceivably pass any reputable Know Your Customer check. Representatives of the major cigarette producers affiliated with the Tobacco Institute of South Africa claim that the newcomers, affiliated with the Fair Trade Independent Tobacco Association (Fita), have been selling enormous quantities of cigarettes very cheaply by the simple mechanism of not paying
  • 3. SAs huge cigarette excise tax. Fita members deny the claim. The pandemic, particularly the banning of tobacco sales for a period in 2020, was a huge boon to Fita members who had been operating mostly under the radar anyway, often selling cheapie cigarettes individually rather than by the packet. Magister says Gold Leaf has not financed Magister and is not financing the underwrite or any part of it. The two biggest shareholders in Tongaat are the Public Investment Corporation (PIC), which did not respond to media enquiries, and financial group PSG, which own 14% and 15% of the company, respectively. Both PSG and the PIC have supported the process of putting the notion of the rights offer to shareholders but have not yet agreed to support the bid, which will depend on the pricing of the offer. Chief Executive of PSG Asset Management, Anet Ahern, said juggling all the stakeholders interests is exceptionally tricky in this case, as Tongaat also has a big impact on the society in which it operates. Tough choices need to be made, and these will always be controversial. In effect, the bankers of the deal, Standard Bank, have sought to place the responsibility for the decision to proceed with the board and shareholders of Tongaat. Standard Bank complies with local and international anti-money laundering legislation and takes this responsibility seriously. Standard Bank follows its internal client risk assessment processes diligently and consistently, and will not put its reputation at risk by doing business in an unethical, illegal or unprofessional manner. Any decision to proceed with the rights offer and any related transactions will be the sole and independent responsibility of the Tongaat Hulett board and its shareholders, it said. BM/DM Source: https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2022-01-10-sa-investors-faced-with-hobsons- choiceover-possibletakeover-of-tongaat-hulett-by-zims-rudland-family/ Question 1 (10 Marks) Identify the dilemma regarding the underwriting rights offer for Tongaat Hullett in the case study and examine the ethical implications in the case study.