1. Planning for
the INTERcultural City
Practice + Visions
Tufts University Intercultural Planning Group
www.sites.tufts.edu/tuftsicp
October 22, 2010
2. Taya Dixon Mullane, Leader,
Lower Highlands Neighborhood Group
Planning for the INTERcultural City
3. LOWER
HIGHLANDS
Neighborhood GroupThe Lower Highlands Neighborhood Group represents a
group of residents, business owners and other community
members working together to improve the quality of life in
the Lower Highlands neighborhood of Lowell, MA.
Our work focuses on achieving three primary goals:
•Public Safety
•Neighborhood Beautification
•Community Building
5. • The LHNG was formed in 2007 following a second fatal
shooting at a neighborhood convenience store.
• Building trust within the existing community has been the
primary focus of the last three years of the current LHNG.
• The Lower Highlands had an active neighborhood group in
the 1990s that became defunct by the 2000s as many of
those residents left the neighborhood as new residents from
diverse cultural backgrounds moved into the community.
LHNG BACKGROUND
Candlelight Vigil for Victims of Violence in December 2008
6. THE LOWER HIGHLANDS
Our Vision for an Intercultural Neighborhood and City
Acceptance of Cultures Other Than Your Own
by Neighbors AND City Hall
• Lowell has a large minority population with twice the national average of foreign-born residents.
•Approximately 35% of Lower Highlands residents are foreign-born.
•Cambodians make up the largest percentage but there is also a concentration of the residents from the following:
Latin American countries, Vietnam, Thailand, African nations, Brazil, and Laos.
• Lowell has the highest concentration of Cambodian, Vietnamese and Laotians than any other community in the country –
most of whom are heavily concentrated in the Lower Highlands and adjacent Acre neighborhood.
• Approximate make-up of the neighborhood (2000 census):
•10% Latino
• 40% Asian
• 50% white
• The number of limited-English speakers is twice the
national average in Lowell.
Neighborhood Park Clean-up in May 2009
7. THE LOWER HIGHLANDS
Our Vision for an Intercultural Neighborhood and City
Creating Ownership of the Neighborhood
by the Community that is Actively Supported by City Hall
• The majority (about 60%) of housing in the Lower Highlands are rental units.
• Average residency in the Lower Highlands is between 3-7 years.
• Median Household Income is $40,000 (many are multi-family households).
• Majority of neighborhood businesses are minority-owned.
• Many businesses cater directly to the Cambodian community.
• restaurants
• markets
• jewelry and clothing stores
• hair salons
• meeting places
Meeting with DPW and City Councilors on major
street flooding in July 2008
8. THE LOWER HIGHLANDS
Partnering with Planners for an Intercultural City
• Members of neighborhood groups are volunteers with jobs and families and need all the help we can
get…don’t underestimate our desire to work with you.
• Engage the community directly.
• go to them…they are unlikely to come to you.
• do your research…immerse yourself in the community.
• accept that trust takes time…consider this in your timeline AND budget.
• Understand the History.
• is the community engaged; if not, why?
• who are the leaders within the community and how did they get there?
• what is the relationship with City Hall?
• Develop realistic planning goals.
• acknowledge disinvestment.
• include quality of life improvements.
• address the need for policy changes where warranted.
National Night Out,
“Movies at the Morey” in August 2010
9. THE LOWER HIGHLANDS
Partnerships and Planning Initiatives
• There had been no systematic community and urban planning initiatives in the
Lower Highlands until the LHNG was formed in 2007.
• April 2008 City Building Workshop on the Hamilton Canal District,
Goody Clancy
• December 2009 Lower Highlands Neighborhood Plan,
MIT Department of Urban Studies and Planning
• Summer 2010 City Manager’s Neighborhood Initiative, City of Lowell
10. THE LOWER HIGHLANDS
What Works and What Doesn’t?
• Hamilton Canal City Building Workshop
• the planners tried to engage the community in unusual ways.
• the community didn’t understand the benefit of the plan.
• recommended inter-neighborhood wayfinding.
• MIT Neighborhood Plan
• immersion in the neighborhood resulted in interesting ideas.
• confusion within the community of what the plan would/could do for us.
• recommended the City allow the neighborhood to continue to grow
organically.
• City Manager’s Neighborhood Initiative
• we talked, they listened.
• cultural barriers and lack of trust
slows progress.
• recommended emphasis on Clemente Park.
City Manager’s Neighborhood Initiative Kick-off Event
at Clemente Park in July 2010
Hinweis der Redaktion
Interculturalism implies that we plan with and not just for our diverse communities and that we actively engage with managing differences in our practice
We conducted research this spring to understand whether the concept of cultural competency, frequently applied in the field of public health, has found its place in planning curricula
I give an overview of what culturally competent planning is, share highlights from our study’s findings, and discuss its implications for the future