This presentation was held at the International Conference on Open and Distance learning for Sustainable Development in Agriculture - ODLSDA 2016 in Coimbatore, India. The conference was hosted by Tamil Nadu Agricultural University. The presentation focuses on global trends but with a specific perspective of India and its potential and challenges in the development of digital transformation of education.
AMERICAN LANGUAGE HUB_Level2_Student'sBook_Answerkey.pdf
Global Trends in Online Education
1. Global Trends in Online, Open and
Flexible Education
Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Adviser
International Council for Open and Distance Education
25 November 2016, ODLSDA Coimbatore
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 1
2. • ICDE is the leading global network for making quality learning
accessible throughout the world using online, open, distance
and flexible education.
• We connect institutions, organisations and professionals from
across the globe so that they can share ideas, resources and best
practices, partner on major projects and advocate together.
• We are the official partner of UNESCO, that shares that agency’s
key aim – the attainment of quality education for all
• ICDE believes that in pursuing education as a universal right, the
needs of the learner must be central.
25 Years Support
From Norway
Who are we?
Partner with
UNESCO
50 years
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 2
3. ”TOWARDS INCLUSIVE AND EQUITABLE
QUALITY EDUCATION AND LIFELONG
LEARNING FOR ALL”
Sustainable Development Goal 4 Education 2030
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 3
4. Deputy Vice-Chancellor
(Education) and Vice-
President, RMIT,
Australia
Open,
Transparent,
Accountable
and focus on
good
governance
President:
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 4
5. Key role of ICDE
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 5
Membership
organization
Network, services
and knowledge
ProjectsEvents
Policy work
10. India in the World
Some indicators and trends
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 10
11. • Global indicators – India
• Opportunities and growth
• Reaching the potential through technology
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 11
14. India has climbed from rank 71 to
55 in one year
A major shift in the world’s economic
balance of power, from Europe and United
States towards Asia – and India contributes
significantly
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 14
15. 5 opportunities for growth and transformation
in India
• Acceptable living standards for all Indians
• Sustainable urbanisation
• Manufacturing for India, in India
• Harnessing technology for India’s growth
• Unlocking the potential of women
Source: http://www.mckinsey.com/global-themes/employment-and-growth/indias-ascent-five-opportunities-for-
growth-and-transformation
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 15
17. But there are some challenges:
• Bridge the urban-rural divide
• Digital infrastructure
• Computer literacy
• Shift in competencies and skills
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 17
22. Perceptions of the use of technology
in teaching and learning
Has the world changed?
Has education changed?
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 22
26. Where the Digital
Economy Is Moving the
Fastest
Bhaskar Chakravorti
Christopher Tunnard Ravi
Shankar Chaturvedi
FEBRUARY 19, 2015
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 26
30. «We think cognitive technologies will fuel the
digital transformation as the damp machine
fuelled the industrial revolution».
– IBM Norway.
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 30
31. Eduational Trends – as observed
by ICDE - 1/2
1. Open and distance learning is now going mainstream
2. Digital transformation is challenging the relevance of
educational institutions all over the world
3. New developments as OER and MOOCs are fueling
innovation in education
4. New methodologies; learning analytics, Big Data, and new
online education systems, enable a shift to adapted,
personalized learning and assessment.
5. Education is on the brink of a revolution caused by
convergence of research. Education, Cognitive Psychology
and Neuroscience: powerful advances in optimizing online
learning experiences.
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 31
35. “Specialist ODL institutions have achieved so much over
the past few decades. As demand for higher education
surges worldwide, the ODL vision of accessible, low-cost,
high-quality provision has never been more relevant.
Renewed determination amongst specialist ODL
institutions to benchmark student performance and
institutional productivity, with fresh inspiration from new
competition and delivery models, will take this precious
legacy to new heights.”
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 35
36. New technologies and the potential for
education:
1: Learning Analytics
“Learning Analytics is the emerging field defined as “the measurement,
collection, analysis and reporting of data about learners and their contexts,
for purposes of understanding and optimizing learning and the environments
in which it occurs” (Long & Siemens, 2011)
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 36
37. Learning analytics
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUOrlp6AZ8E
“enormous potential to improve the student
experience at university” JISC, UK
• As a tool for quality assurance and quality improvement
• As a tool for boosting retention rates
• As a tool for assessing and acting upon differential outcomes
among the student population
• As an enabler for the development and introduction of
adaptive learning
https://vimeo.com/105802864
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 37
38. Student interest
in IPAS features
”Integrated Planning and
Advising Services (IPAS) ”
http://
www.educause.edu/ecar
40. New technologies and the potential for
education:
2: Open Educational Resources (OER)
“Open Educational Resources (OERs) are any type of educational materials
that are in the public domain or introduced with an open license. The
nature of these open materials means that anyone can legally and freely
copy, use, adapt and re-share them.”
UNESCO, http://www.unesco.org/new/en/communication-and-information/access-to-knowledge/open-educational-
resources/what-are-open-educational-resources-oers/
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 40
41. Key potentials of OER
• Digital technologies have become
ubiquitous in daily life and OER can harness
the new possibility afforded by digital
technology to address common educational
challenges.
• OER are a catalyst for social innovation,
which can facilitate changed forms of
interaction between teachers, learners and
knowledge.
• OER have an extended lifecycle beyond their
original design and purpose. The process of
distribution, adaptation and iteration can
improve access to high-quality, context-
appropriate educational materials for all.”
http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/content/book/9789264247543-en01 Dec 201511.05.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 41
42. New technologies and the potential for
education:
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 42
Has the world changed?
Will education change?
44. 6. Lack of resources or lack of understanding of
the concept of online, open and flexible
education
7. Skills and the relation education –
employment – lifelong learning is required
8. Quality, quality enhancement and
accreditation become top priority issues.
Trends
– as observed by ICDE - 2/2
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 44
45. Indian education in the world
• Higher Education in India – vision 2030
http://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/Higher-education-in-India-Vision-2030/%24FILE/EY-Higher-education-in-India-
Vision-2030.pdf
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 45
46. Demographics – India
“By 2030, India will be amongst the youngest nations in the
world. With nearly 140 million people in the college-going age
group, one in every four graduates in the world will be a product
of the Indian higher education system. By 2030, the already
existing challenges for Indian higher education – access, equity
and quality – will only be greatly exacerbated unless we
significantly transform our higher education model.”
(Higher Education In India: Vision 2030)
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 46
47. Suggested solutions (India Vision 2030)
• A student-centric, learning driven pedagogical
model
• A differentiated three-tiered university system
• The effective use of technology
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 47
48. Intensive use of technology is a
requirement
• The need for scalability of education is
unimaginable without intensive use of ICT
• But be careful: “the MOOC way” is not the
only way
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 48
49. What is a MOOC?
A Massive Open Online Course (MOOC /muːk/) is an online course aimed at
unlimited participation and open access via the web.[1] In addition to
traditional course materials such as filmed lectures, readings, and problem
sets, many MOOCs provide interactive user forums to support community
interactions among students, professors, and teaching assistants (Wikipedia)
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 49
50. What characterizes MOOCs?
• Mostly non formal education (no credits)
• Little student support
• Mostly used by already highly educated
people
• High drop out rates
• Providers struggle to find sustainable business
models, e.g through “freemium models”
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 50
51. Then what is the solution?
A fundamental change in pedagogical approach
in line with efficient use of digital methodologies
is recommended: blended learning, flipped
learning, personalized, adaptive….
(This is also in line with what India Vision 2030 recommends)
……and it is not a quick fix!
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 51
52. The global quality
agenda led by UNESCO
• The SDGs
• SDG 4
• Global and regional conventions
• Quality enhancement initiative
• 5 relevant for education
• Education 2030: Towards inclusive
and equitable quality education and
promote lifelong learning
opportunities for all
• Preparation of a Global Convention
on the Recognition of Higher
Education Qualifications – to be
decided 2019 (UNESCO)
• Quality assurance: Achieving
sustainable development through a
diverse provision of higher
education, regional meetings and
studies leading up to an
international conference issuing
guidance 2018 (UNESCO, INQAAHE,
ICDE and COL)
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 52
54. Education 2030 Framework
for Action (FFA)
• UNESCO is entrusted to lead
Sustainable Development
Goal 4 (SDG4) - Ensure
inclusive and equitable
quality education and
promote lifelong learning
opportunities for all -
through the Education 2030
Framework for Action (FFA).
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 54
55. Main principles
• Education is a fundamental human right and
an enabling right.
• Education is a public good, of which the state
is the duty bearer.
• Gender equality is inextricably linked to the
right to education for all.
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 55
56. ”Towards inclusive and equitable
quality education and lifelong
learning for all”
1. By 2030, ensure that all girls and boys complete free, equitable and quality primary and secondary education leading to relevant and Goal-4 effective learning outcomes
2. By 2030, ensure that all girls and boys have access to quality early childhood development, care and preprimary education so that they are ready for primary education
3. By 2030, ensure equal access for all women and men to affordable
and quality technical, vocational and tertiary education, including
university
4. By 2030, substantially increase the number of youth and adults who have relevant skills, including technical and vocational skills, for employment, decent jobs and entrepreneurship
5. By 2030, eliminate gender disparities in education and ensure equal access to all levels of education and vocational training for the vulnerable, including persons with disabilities,
indigenous peoples and children in vulnerable situations
6. By 2030, ensure that all youth and a substantial proportion of adults, both men and women, achieve literacy and numeracy
7. By 2030, ensure that all learners acquire the knowledge and skills needed to promote sustainable development, including, among others, through education for sustainable
development and sustainable lifestyles, human rights, gender equality, promotion of a culture of peace and non-violence, global citizenship and appreciation of cultural diversity and
of culture’s contribution to sustainable development
8. Build and upgrade education facilities that are child, disability and gender sensitive and provide safe, nonviolent, inclusive and effective learning environments for all
9. By 2020, substantially expand globally the number of scholarships
available to developing countries, in particular least developed
countries, small island developing States and African countries, for
enrolment in higher education, including vocational training and
information and communications technology, technical, engineering and
scientific programmes, in developed countries and other developing
countries
10. By 2030, substantially increase the supply of qualified teachers, including
through international cooperation for teacher training in developing
countries, especially least developed countries and small island
developing states
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 56
57. Target 3, point 43.:
A well-established, properly-regulated
tertiary education system supported by
technology, Open Educational Resources
(OERs) and distance education modalities
can increase access, equity, quality and
relevance, and narrow the gap between
what is taught at tertiary education
institutions and what economies and
societies demand. The provision of tertiary
education should be progressively free, in
line with existing international agreements.
Framework for Action
Education 2030:
November 2015
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 57
58. ICDE contributed - and,
influenced the future:
20 November 2014: Open Education
Key issues in policy for governments
and senior management in higher education
ICDE High Level Policy Forum 17 October 2015:
“Higher education for the sustainable future we want. The way ahead for
Online, Open and Flexible learning: Opportunities and Actions.”
In partership with UNESCO, CoL and OEC
Interventions, from UNESCO, ICDE and
key experts and senior management:
The Bali Message
Global High Level Forum in Paris
9 – 11 JUNE 2015:
Online, open and flexible higher
education for the future we want
UNESCO – in partnership with ICDE
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 58
59. QUALITY ASSURANCE:
ACHIEVING SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT THROUGH A
DIVERSE PROVISION OF HIGHER EDUCATION
International Conference 2018
6 – 10 regional meetings 2016 - 2018
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 59
60. Quality issues
• Opportunities
– Access and scalability
through online learning
– Student support and
mentoring systems
– Learning analytics and
other personalised
technology enhanced
learning systems
• Challenges
– Competencies
• Faculty
• Educational leaders
• Quality agencies
• Experts on quality
assurance
– Innovation
– Access, inclusion –
access to success
– Ethics
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 60
61. The ICDE Quality
initiatives
• Benchmarking and good
practice
• Address quality:
• Explore new
methodologies:
• Build future capacities
• Models for Online, open,
flexible and technology
enhanced higher education
• Global Quality Network
• Learning analytics initiative
• The Global Doctoral
Consortium
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 61
63. The change
• From focus on
– Quality of students
admitted
– Qualification of faculty
– Design and management
of programmes
– Rigour of marking
– Course outputs as
intended outcome?
• To focus on
– Student engagement and
satisfaction
– Data analytics to improve
learning
– Reflective assessments by
students
– Student-instructor-
interaction
– Assessments for learning
– Faculty satisfaction and
engagement
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 63
64. Where are we now?
One year after………..
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 64
66. World is not set to achieve key global education
commitments until 2084.
PROJECTIONS FOR EDUCATION 2030
2030 2042 2059 2084
Universal
primary
completion
Universal
Upper
secondary
completion
Universal
Lower
secondary
completion
YEAR
Education 2030
deadline
Education 2030
deadline
2042 2059 2084
YEAR Global average
Universal
primary
completion
Universal
Upper
secondary
completion
Universal
Lower
secondary
completion
2015
SDGs
adopted
20872051 2062
Southern Asia
After 21002080 2089
Sub-Saharan Africa
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 66
67. “Education needs to fundamentally
change if we are to reach our global
development goals”
Press relase 6 September 2016
UNESCO:
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 67
68. Main Message:
We need to fundamentally change
education through inclusive quality and
technology enhanced flexible education
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 68
69. Specific messages
• Quality first: quality digital, open and
flexible education
• Collaboration, on all levels, on content,
courses programmes, methodologies,
infrastructure, internationalisation….
• Take leadership for change for the
future we want – lead educational
transformation
25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 69
70. ”TOWARDS INCLUSIVE AND EQUITABLE
QUALITY EDUCATION AND LIFELONG
LEARNING FOR ALL”
Sustainable Development Goal 4: Education 2030
THANK YOUgjelsvik@icde.org
www.icde.org
Seize digital opportunities, lead educational transformation25.11.2016 Torunn Gjelsvik, Senior Advisor ICDE 70
Hinweis der Redaktion
As UNIDO we focus on a main SDG towards 2030. ICDE’s development goal is goal number 4, Education, with the ambition of providing quality education and lifelong learning for all.
ICDE have produced several reports with relevance to this topic, mostly the two reports «quality models» and «student success».
The International Monetary Fund has projected India’s GDP growth at 7.4 Percent for 2016-2017 (source McKinsey Global Institute: “India’s Ascent: Five opportunities for growth and transformation”, august 2016.
India has climbed from rank 71 the year before, to rank 55 in 2015-2016. According to the McKinsey report it took thousands of years for the world’s economic centre of gravity to shift from Asia to Europe, but the shift back is expected to continue over the next decade, with India as a major player. India compare favourably with most other emerging markets in terms of growth potential.
Bridge the urban-rural digital divide by addressing barriers such as limited telecom infrastructure, slow internet speed, low computer literacy,
On the other hand, the technological trends for educational technology is pointing in one direction for India: upwards.
EdTech Review “Investments in Asia “ report for the first two quarters of 2016 shows that a great deal of the EdTech investments in Asia are now happening in India. What expectations can we have on the development of education in India, and what trends do we see in other parts of the world_
Pepper is called one of the world’s first “emotional robots”, and communicates in a very human similar way.
What before was in the margins, open and distance learning, is now going mainstream in large parts of the world, materialised as online, blended, open, flexible, technology enhanced and e-Learning. Convergence is here, followed by increasing competition (and collaboration) and diversity in higher education. While this is the main trend, the situation in some regions will provide a different picture, e.g. in parts of the south.
Digital transformation is challenging the relevance of educational institutions and services all over the world, so also for ICDE members and those that have been in the distance and open field for a long time. While digitalisation is penetrating all fields and all regions, the pace and situation is different among regions, between developed and developing countries and within nations.
Skills and the relation education - employment, is becoming an increasingly hot topic around the world and in different contexts. The new SDG 4 puts utterly pressure on massification and the relevance of sustainability for education, to achieve the SDG goals.
Lack of resources or lack of understanding of the concept of online, open and flexible education is observed in some parts of the world as a major threat to scalable quality higher education both on a national and institutional level, and therefore also as a threat towards SDG 4.
Quality, quality assurance and accreditation have become more important than ever and are top priority issues – having the alternative in mind.
New developments as OER and MOOCs have been championed by ICDE member institutions, e.g. Athabasca University, Canada, coining the term MOOC in 2008, and Maryland University College introducing an OER based curricula up to Bachelor degree, August 2015.
Through new methodologies and concepts becoming mature, such as learning analytics, Big Data, MOOCs and new online education systems, a real shift to adapted, personalised learning and assessment – with great progress for student success – is becoming realistic, though – it is not a quick win or low hanging fruit. This development opens up for pedagogical changes and improvements in a number of other areas, e.g. curriculum content and design. Open University, UK, provides an annual overview “Innovating Pedagogy”, exploring new forms of teaching, learning and assessment, to guide educators and policy makers.
In the report “Online Education: A Catalyst for Higher Education Reforms” (2016), the MIT Online Education Policy Initiative suggests that education is on the brink of a revolution caused by convergence of outside-in and inside out research. Ref. the figure below. Collaborating on learning-related work across disciplines through an integrated research agenda could yield powerful advances in optimizing online learning experiences, the report suggests.
ref: http://news.mit.edu/2016/mit-releases-online-education-policy-initiative-report-0401
What about the traditional open and distance education providers? The Commonwealth of Learning (COL) launched this report earlier this year: an examination of ODL universities in the Commonwealth, such as The Open University UK, Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) and the University of South Africa (UNISA). The report seeks to better highlight both the achievements and the areas for improvement for the traditional ODL institutions. Higher education in general and distance and online education in particular, is under a lot of pressure for transparency in terms of success rates, retention, delivery modes etc. The report recommends types of performance indicators for ODL higher education institutions to adopt and benchmark.
The enrolment patterns are very mixed. About half of the institutions have grown steadily in recent years, while the other half has experienced enrolment decline and loss of market share.
Unfortunately, some ODL institutions suffer from a bad reputation for the lack of academic quality, but it is also a challenge that traditional metrix for academic quality is inappropriate for open and distance education. It is relevant to challenge the collected data and review them in the perspective of what improves student success, hence the report. There is no doubt that ODL institutions educate many students around the world with success, but if would be preferable if they could demonstrate more clearly relative performance and productivity at a general educational institutional level.
New technologies and the potential for education: Learning analytics
The potentials of OER are more thoroughly described in this OECD report, where it is described as a catalyst for innovation
This report says in its foreword: We are in the 21st century with a mid-20th century regulatory architecture. The suggested framework for solutions is to put the student at the center, an ICT infrastructure that increases access, equity and quality, and a transparent governance framework that will enable autonomy and self-regulation.
The learner centric paradigm: to engage students instead of instructing them in a predefined syllabus. The role of professors are more of facilitators than instructors. Students are engaged in many different ways as learning processes becomes more adaptive and personalized.
The three tiered structure: research universities on top level, comprehensive universities and specialized institutions in the middle and a wide range of highly accessible and high quality colleges at the bottom.
Hence the report HE in India: Vision 2030. To illustrate, if India were to create the additional needed capacity through increase in brick and mortar institutions alone, it would have had to build six universities and 270 colleges each and every month in the next 20 years .
We totally agree in this statement. But, be careful: the report suggests that India should go “the MOOC way”
The search for business models pushes MOOC providers to charge for academic credits or take student fees. It is still unclear whether MOOCs in itself will be a significant part of the scalability solution for formal higher education..
n 2013, the Chronicle of Higher Education surveyed 103 professors who had taught MOOCs. "Typically a professor spent over 100 hours on his MOOC before it even started, by recording online lecture videos and doing other preparation. Completion rates are typically lower than 10%, with a steep participation drop starting in the first week.
Because of massive enrollments, MOOCs require instructional design that facilitates large-scale feedback and interaction. The two basic approaches are:
Peer-review and group collaboration
Automated feedback through objective, online assessments, e.g. quizzes and exams. Machine grading of written assignments is also underway