Comparison of GenAI benchmarking models for legal use cases
Bl law of agency
1. Law of AgencyLaw of Agency
Agent:Agent: is a person employed to do any act foris a person employed to do any act for
another or to represent another in dealings withanother or to represent another in dealings with
third personsthird persons
Principal:Principal: the person for whom such act is donethe person for whom such act is done
or who is so represented is called the Principalor who is so represented is called the Principal
Function of a agentFunction of a agent: is to bring his principal into: is to bring his principal into
contractual relations with third personscontractual relations with third persons
Essentials of relationship of agencyEssentials of relationship of agency
1. Agreement between the principal and the agent1. Agreement between the principal and the agent
2. Intention of agent to act on behalf of the principal2. Intention of agent to act on behalf of the principal
2. Kinds of AgentsKinds of Agents
Based on Extent of authorityBased on Extent of authority
•Special agentSpecial agent
•General agentGeneral agent
•Universal agentUniversal agent
Nature of Work performedNature of Work performed
Commercial or mercantile agentCommercial or mercantile agent
FactorFactor
AuctioneerAuctioneer
BrokerBroker
Commission agentCommission agent
Del credere agentDel credere agent
BankerBanker
Non-mercantile agentsNon-mercantile agents
3. Duties of a AgentDuties of a Agent
To carry out the work undertaken according to the directionsTo carry out the work undertaken according to the directions
given by the principalgiven by the principal
To carry out the work with reasonable care, skill andTo carry out the work with reasonable care, skill and
diligencediligence
To render proper accounts to his principalTo render proper accounts to his principal
To communicate with the principal in the case of difficultyTo communicate with the principal in the case of difficulty
Not to deal on his own accountNot to deal on his own account
To pay sums received for the principalTo pay sums received for the principal
4. Duties of a AgentDuties of a Agent (Contd..)(Contd..)
To protect and preserve the interests of principal in case ofTo protect and preserve the interests of principal in case of
death or insolvencydeath or insolvency
Not to use information obtained in the course of agencyNot to use information obtained in the course of agency
against principalagainst principal
Not to make secret profit from AgencyNot to make secret profit from Agency
Not to set up an adverse titleNot to set up an adverse title
Not to put himself in a position where interest and dutyNot to put himself in a position where interest and duty
conflictconflict
Not to delegate authorityNot to delegate authority
5. Rights of AgentsRights of Agents
Right of “Retainer”Right of “Retainer”
Right to receive RemunerationRight to receive Remuneration
Right of lienRight of lien
Right to receive compensationRight to receive compensation
6. Duties of PrincipalDuties of Principal
To Indemnify the agent against the consequences of all lawful actsTo Indemnify the agent against the consequences of all lawful acts
To indemnify the agent against the consequences of acts done in goodTo indemnify the agent against the consequences of acts done in good
faithfaith
To indemnify agent for injury caused by principal’s neglectTo indemnify agent for injury caused by principal’s neglect
To pay agent the commission or other remuneration agreedTo pay agent the commission or other remuneration agreed
Rights of PrincipalRights of Principal
ToTo recover damagesrecover damages
To obtain an account of secret profits and recover them and resist aTo obtain an account of secret profits and recover them and resist a
claim forclaim for remunerationremuneration
To resist agent’s claim for indemnity against liability incurredTo resist agent’s claim for indemnity against liability incurred
7. Creation of AgencyCreation of Agency
By Express agreementBy Express agreement
By Implied agreementBy Implied agreement
• Agent by estoppelAgent by estoppel
• Agency by holding outAgency by holding out
• Agent by necessityAgent by necessity
By operation of LawBy operation of Law
By RatificationBy Ratification
8. Requisites for valid ratificationRequisites for valid ratification
Agent must propose and is identifiableAgent must propose and is identifiable
Principal must be in existence at the time of contractPrincipal must be in existence at the time of contract
Principal should have contractual capacityPrincipal should have contractual capacity
Ratification must be with full knowledge of factsRatification must be with full knowledge of facts
Must be done within reasonable time of act proposedMust be done within reasonable time of act proposed
Act to be rectified must be lawfulAct to be rectified must be lawful
Whole transaction must be ratifiedWhole transaction must be ratified
Ratification must be communicatedRatification must be communicated
Ratification must be of acts which the principal had the powerRatification must be of acts which the principal had the power
to doto do
Should not put a third party to damageShould not put a third party to damage
9. Termination of AgencyTermination of Agency
Act of PartiesAct of Parties
By mutual agreementBy mutual agreement
By Revocation by the principalBy Revocation by the principal
By Renunciation by the agentBy Renunciation by the agent
Operation of LawOperation of Law
By PerformanceBy Performance
By Death of partyBy Death of party
By insolvency of either of the partyBy insolvency of either of the party
By expiry of timeBy expiry of time
By insanity of either partyBy insanity of either party
By destruction of subject matterBy destruction of subject matter
By Principal becoming an alien enemyBy Principal becoming an alien enemy
By dissolution of the companyBy dissolution of the company
By termination of sub agent’s authorityBy termination of sub agent’s authority
10. Bailment:Bailment:
" A bailment is the delivery of goods by one person to" A bailment is the delivery of goods by one person to
another person for some purpose, upon a contract thatanother person for some purpose, upon a contract that
they shall, when the purpose is accomplished, bethey shall, when the purpose is accomplished, be
returned or otherwise disposed of , according to thereturned or otherwise disposed of , according to the
directions of the person delivering them.”directions of the person delivering them.”
The person delivering the goods is called theThe person delivering the goods is called the BailorBailor
The person to whom they are delivered is called theThe person to whom they are delivered is called the
BaileeBailee
11. Essentials of BailmentEssentials of Bailment
Contract for delivery of goods and taking back the goodsContract for delivery of goods and taking back the goods
Delivery of goods by the Bailor to BaileeDelivery of goods by the Bailor to Bailee
Entrustment of goods should be for some purposeEntrustment of goods should be for some purpose
Bailment relates only toBailment relates only to ChattelsChattels (i.e., movable property)(i.e., movable property)
ConsiderationConsideration
In the form of moneyIn the form of money
In the form of benefit derived by each otherIn the form of benefit derived by each other
12. Classification of bailmentClassification of bailment
For the exclusive benefit of Bailor (for safe custody of goods)For the exclusive benefit of Bailor (for safe custody of goods)
For the exclusive benefit of Bailee (Lending without charge)For the exclusive benefit of Bailee (Lending without charge)
For mutual benefit of both the parties (repairing)For mutual benefit of both the parties (repairing)
Types of bailmentTypes of bailment
Gratuitous bailment Eg. lending book to a friend without chargeGratuitous bailment Eg. lending book to a friend without charge
Non- Gratuitous bailment Eg.lending something for chargesNon- Gratuitous bailment Eg.lending something for charges
13. Duties of BailorDuties of Bailor
Disclose known faults pertaining to the goodsDisclose known faults pertaining to the goods
To bear extra ordinary expenses of bailmentTo bear extra ordinary expenses of bailment
To indemnify the Bailee for any loss on account of prematureTo indemnify the Bailee for any loss on account of premature
termination of bailmenttermination of bailment
To receive back the goods bailedTo receive back the goods bailed
To indemnify the BaileeTo indemnify the Bailee
Rights of BailorRights of Bailor
To enforce terms of contract and rights conferred under statuteTo enforce terms of contract and rights conferred under statute
Right of avoidance of contractRight of avoidance of contract
To demand the Bailee to return the goods lent gratuitouslyTo demand the Bailee to return the goods lent gratuitously
Right to file a joint suit for compensation against a wrong-doerRight to file a joint suit for compensation against a wrong-doer
14. Duties of the BaileeDuties of the Bailee
Proper care for goodsProper care for goods
Not to make unauthorized use of goodsNot to make unauthorized use of goods
Not to mix bailed goods with his own goodsNot to mix bailed goods with his own goods
Paying compensation for the damages (in case of mixing of bailed goodsPaying compensation for the damages (in case of mixing of bailed goods
with own goods)with own goods)
Not to setup adverse titleNot to setup adverse title
Duty to return accretion of goods eg.delivery of cow with calfDuty to return accretion of goods eg.delivery of cow with calf
Bailee to return goodsBailee to return goods
Rights of the BaileeRights of the Bailee
Deliver goods to one of the joint bailorsDeliver goods to one of the joint bailors
To deliver goods to Bailor, even if the Bailor has no titleTo deliver goods to Bailor, even if the Bailor has no title
Right to apply to the courtRight to apply to the court
Right of action against trespassersRight of action against trespassers
Right of Bailee’s lien or particular lienRight of Bailee’s lien or particular lien
15. Termination of Bailment
On the expiry of the periodOn the expiry of the period
On the achievement of objectOn the achievement of object
Inconsistent use of goodsInconsistent use of goods
Destruction of subject matterDestruction of subject matter
Gratuitous bailmentGratuitous bailment
Death of bailor or baileeDeath of bailor or bailee
16. Pledge:
The bailment of goods as security for payment of a debt or
performance of promise
Bailor- pledger or pawnor
Bailee- pledgee or pawnee
Difference between Pledge & Bailment:
Purpose
Right to sell Goods
Right to use goods
17. Rights of PawneeRights of Pawnee
Right of retainerRight of retainer
Right of retainer for subsequent advancesRight of retainer for subsequent advances
Right of extraordinary expensesRight of extraordinary expenses
Right against true owner, when pawnor’s title is defectiveRight against true owner, when pawnor’s title is defective
Rights where pawnor makes defaultRights where pawnor makes default
*file suit against pawnor*file suit against pawnor
* sell goods* sell goods
*Recover from pawnor (deficiency arising after sale)*Recover from pawnor (deficiency arising after sale)
Right to sue for loan advancedRight to sue for loan advanced
18. Rights of pawnorRights of pawnor
Right to get back goodsRight to get back goods
Right to redeem debtRight to redeem debt
Preservation and maintenance of goodsPreservation and maintenance of goods