Pests of mustard_Identification_Management_Dr.UPR.pdf
How to review a paper effectively
1. How to
review a paper
effectively
Graciela Gil-Romera
@gilromera www.gilromera.com
Dept. Geography and Environmental Sciences, Aberystwyth University (UK) Dept.
of Palaeoenvironments and Global Change, IPE-CSIC (Spain)
This presentation can be used and reproduced under CC By-SA license
photo by Eli Francis
via Unsplash (CC00)
48. Notes for the editor
Confidential comments to the editors should
not be significantly different to the comments
to the authors. The overall message of both
should be the same.
49. Notes for the editor
However, statements regarding whether or not
an article should be published in the journal
should only be made in the comments to the
editor.