SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 27
Inclusive Placemaking: Placing the
Christian Church in a Digital Age
Dr Bex Lewis
Senior Lecturer in Digital Marketing,
Manchester Metropolitan University
For http://www.placemanagement.org/
Tweet @drbexl 1
http://bit.ly/ChurchPlaceIPM
Paper Overview
• Church as geographical place
• The digital environment: reality and
place?
• Discipleship online: The Big Bible
Project
• Researching the church and digital
Tweet @drbexl 2
Church as Geographical
Place
Tweet @drbexl 3
Photo by Alexandre Perotto on Unsplash
Church of England
Tweet @drbexl 4https://www.churchofengland.org/
Grenfall Tower
Tweet @drbexl 5
http://bit.ly/churchtimesGrenfall
Image: Diocese of London
That trust exists because of the care and
compassion they have received for
decades… we actually live here… urge
those who speak about it to avoid the
ambiguous and woolly term “local
church”, but to speak proudly, precisely,
and powerfully of the “parish church”.
The parish church is a living icon of God’s
love, connecting with people in ways
that we hardly begin to understand and
so often underestimate.
Revd Dr Alan Everett, Vicar of St Clement with St Mark, Notting Dale, and St
James’s, Norlands
Methodist Church
Tweet @drbexl 6http://www.methodist.org.uk/
Foodbanks
"Faith in
Foodbanks?" recognises the
ministry of many churches
helping people who cannot
afford to eat, looks at why
there has been such a growth
in foodbanks, and suggests
ways churches can take action
to tackle the underlying
causes. It offers worship and
bible resources to help
Christians to reflect on food
and poverty in Britain today.
Tweet @drbexl 7
http://bit.ly/FoodbanksMC
http://re-dish.org/projects/food-action/
United Reformed Church
Tweet @drbexl 8http://www.urc.org.uk/discipleship.html
Baptist Church
Tweet @drbexl 9http://www.baptist.org.uk/Groups/287921/About_us.aspx
Catholic Church
Tweet @drbexl 10http://directory.cbcew.org.uk/
Theologians & Place
Tweet @drbexl 11
2003 2014 2017
The Digital Environment:
Reality and Place?
Tweet @drbexl 12
Photo by PixelsAway on Stockfresh
Communities of Practice
To be effective in the role of digital (technology) steward
(Cochrane 2010; Narayan and Baglow 2010; Wenger,
White, and Smith 2009), a person needs on the one hand
to be capable with the technology, experimenting with
innovations to explore their utility, whilst also aware of
the various ways in which those innovations may be
brought into the practice of the community. To achieve
this effectiveness, the steward needs to devote time to
increasing their own knowledge and abilities in the
technological and community aspects of the role.
Lewis, B, Rush, D. Experience of developing Twitter-based Communities of Practice in
Higher Education, 2013, 3
Tweet @drbexl 13
https://journal.alt.ac.uk/index.php/rlt/article/view/1310
Digital on its own terms
Even though in practice, face-to-
face communication can, of course,
be angry, negligent, resistant,
deceitful and inflexible, somehow it
remains the ideal against which
mediated communication is judged
as flawed
Livingstone, S. Children and the Internet: Great
Expectations and Challenging Realities, 2009, 26
Tweet @drbexl 14
For many churchgoing is no longer the
‘cultural norm’. People don’t actively ignore
the church: they don’t even think about it.
Matthew 5:13-16 calls us to be salt and light
in the world, and for thousands in the ‘digital
age’, that world includes social networks such
Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and Pinterest.
With literally billions in the digital spaces, the
online social spaces presented by churches
need to be appealing, welcoming, and not
look like they are just an afterthought: they
are now effectively the ‘front door’ to your
church for digital users, and you ignore those
spaces at your peril.
Lewis, B. Growing Churches in a Digital Age, 2013
Tweet @drbexl 15
http://bit.ly/ChurchDigAge
Image: Flickr
Online Church?
It may be possible to set up an online
mega-church of millions of people but
it is more likely that a long-term
online Christian community will be
small and quiet rather than large and
exciting, and may not be understood
by the wider Church…the commonest
question I am asked about online
church is ‘What do you do?’ and it is
hard to explain that we don’t ‘do’
church – we are church to each other,
despite the lack of sacraments or a
building, because we are committed
to each other’s journeys in the faith
and in Christ’s love.
Smith, P. Online Mission and Ministry, 2015,
Introduction
Tweet @drbexl 16
Online Church?
Tweet @drbexl 17Image: https://harperganesvoort.files.wordpress.com/2008/01/epiphany-
cathedral-3.jpg
Hutchings, T., Creating Church Online: Ritual,
Community and New Media, 2017, 2
Discipleship Online: The Big
Bible Project (2010-2015)
Tweet @drbexl 18
THANKS FOR FUNDING TO THE JERUSALEM TRUST AND
Photo by Nina Strehl on Unsplash
#Digidisciple
Tweet @drbexl 19
http://archive.bigbible.uk/digidisciple/
[If we are…] means by which God communicates
and reveals himself through his Spirit, then our
blog posts, status updates, tweets, artistic
images, and online comments should be
products of a life transformed by Christ and
indwelled by his Spirit. As restored image
bearers, our online presence and activity should
image the Triune God.
Byers, A. Theomedia: The Media of God and the
Digital Age, 2013, 196
Emerged Themes
• What is a theologically informed view of
digital engagement?
• What is good practice for being a Christian
online?
• What is the impact of digital on religious
practice (online/offline?)
• What does a welcoming church look like in a
digital age?
Tweet @drbexl 21
Media Interest
Tweet @drbexl 22http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b091sz8x
http://drbexl.co.uk/press
Researching the Church
and Digital
Tweet @drbexl 23
Photo by Oakozhan on Stockfresh
Digital Religion Reseach
Scholars are identified as having
moved from excitement at this
‘new thing’, to the digital
becoming a part of everyday life to
be analysed, to understanding
what the lived ‘reality’ of digital
religion is. The three academic
waves that Campbell identifies
here—the descriptive, the
categorical and the theoretical—
are echoed throughout the rest of
the book, as we understand how
‘digital religion’ has matured as a
field of study.
Lewis, B. Book review: Digital Religion: Understanding Religious Practice in
New Media Worlds, written by Heidi Campbell, 2015, 249
Tweet @drbexl 24http://bit.ly/CampbellReview
Intermediate Outputs
British Academy Funding Bid:
Planning:
Interviews: communications
leads, major British church
denominations
Design:
Content analysis: online
content produced (nationally?)
by churches
Reception:
Survey: Responses from users
of church digital content
• 2019: ‘Being a Christian
Online: How the church and
its members are adapting to
the digital age’, The
Information Society (to
submit summer 2018)
• 2020: ‘Raising Children in a
Digital Age: concerns and
policies for British
churches’, Business History
(to submit summer 2019)
Tweet @drbexl 25
Bigger Project: Being a Welcoming
Church in a Digital Age
Tweet @drbexl 26Photo: iqoncept, on Stockfresh
Q&A
Tweet @drbexl 27
HTTP://BIT.LY/ChurchPlaceIPM

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...
Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...
Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...
Bex Lewis
 
Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)
Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)
Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)
Bex Lewis
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Faith in a digital age: Dallas Theological Seminary
Faith in a digital age: Dallas Theological SeminaryFaith in a digital age: Dallas Theological Seminary
Faith in a digital age: Dallas Theological Seminary
 
Social Media, Peer Surveillance and Spiritual Formation
Social Media, Peer Surveillance and Spiritual FormationSocial Media, Peer Surveillance and Spiritual Formation
Social Media, Peer Surveillance and Spiritual Formation
 
The Church in the Digital Age. Keynote for URC. July 2014
The Church in the Digital Age. Keynote for URC. July 2014The Church in the Digital Age. Keynote for URC. July 2014
The Church in the Digital Age. Keynote for URC. July 2014
 
Social Media for Churches for Diocese of York (November 2014)
Social Media for Churches for Diocese of York (November 2014)Social Media for Churches for Diocese of York (November 2014)
Social Media for Churches for Diocese of York (November 2014)
 
Communicating the gospel in a digital age
Communicating the gospel in a digital ageCommunicating the gospel in a digital age
Communicating the gospel in a digital age
 
Social Media: The Importance of New Media in the Faith Story
Social Media: The Importance of New Media in the Faith StorySocial Media: The Importance of New Media in the Faith Story
Social Media: The Importance of New Media in the Faith Story
 
#DigiRev for #MediaLit15
#DigiRev for #MediaLit15#DigiRev for #MediaLit15
#DigiRev for #MediaLit15
 
Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...
Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...
Digidisciple: Issues and Opportunities for the Christian Sector in a Digital ...
 
Experiencing God in a Digital Age (Children/Young People)
Experiencing God in a Digital Age (Children/Young People)Experiencing God in a Digital Age (Children/Young People)
Experiencing God in a Digital Age (Children/Young People)
 
Raising Children in a Digital Age - Cavendish School
Raising Children in a Digital Age - Cavendish SchoolRaising Children in a Digital Age - Cavendish School
Raising Children in a Digital Age - Cavendish School
 
Social media for the Scared January 2013
Social media for the Scared January 2013Social media for the Scared January 2013
Social media for the Scared January 2013
 
Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)
Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)
Social Media for Churches (Hereford Diocese)
 
Continuing the ministry of Jesus through social media
Continuing the ministry of Jesus through social mediaContinuing the ministry of Jesus through social media
Continuing the ministry of Jesus through social media
 
Engaging in Discipleship in a Digital Age
Engaging in Discipleship in a Digital AgeEngaging in Discipleship in a Digital Age
Engaging in Discipleship in a Digital Age
 
#MediaLit14 - DigiRev - Media for Ministry
#MediaLit14 - DigiRev - Media for Ministry #MediaLit14 - DigiRev - Media for Ministry
#MediaLit14 - DigiRev - Media for Ministry
 
Preaching: Lessons from a Digital Age
Preaching: Lessons from a Digital AgePreaching: Lessons from a Digital Age
Preaching: Lessons from a Digital Age
 
Social Media for the Scared for @C_of_E
Social Media for the Scared for @C_of_ESocial Media for the Scared for @C_of_E
Social Media for the Scared for @C_of_E
 
Social Media for Ministry, Chester Diocese, July 2016
Social Media for Ministry, Chester Diocese, July 2016Social Media for Ministry, Chester Diocese, July 2016
Social Media for Ministry, Chester Diocese, July 2016
 
introduction to digital evangelism and discipleship
introduction to digital evangelism  and discipleshipintroduction to digital evangelism  and discipleship
introduction to digital evangelism and discipleship
 
Day with 'The Religious' at Catholic Vocations Communications Conference
Day with 'The Religious' at Catholic Vocations Communications Conference Day with 'The Religious' at Catholic Vocations Communications Conference
Day with 'The Religious' at Catholic Vocations Communications Conference
 

Ähnlich wie IPM placing the christian church in a digital age

Ähnlich wie IPM placing the christian church in a digital age (19)

Codec Research (A Brief Overview)
Codec Research (A Brief Overview)Codec Research (A Brief Overview)
Codec Research (A Brief Overview)
 
word_made_virtual
word_made_virtualword_made_virtual
word_made_virtual
 
Congregational renewal NGL synon oct 11
Congregational renewal NGL synon oct 11Congregational renewal NGL synon oct 11
Congregational renewal NGL synon oct 11
 
Digital Church An Introduction
Digital Church An IntroductionDigital Church An Introduction
Digital Church An Introduction
 
C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04
C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04
C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04
 
C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04
C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04
C3ppt parishcluster2013.03.04
 
Festival of Congregations Oct 11, 2014
Festival of Congregations  Oct 11, 2014Festival of Congregations  Oct 11, 2014
Festival of Congregations Oct 11, 2014
 
United Reformed Church: Digital Confidence with @drbexl
United Reformed Church: Digital Confidence with @drbexlUnited Reformed Church: Digital Confidence with @drbexl
United Reformed Church: Digital Confidence with @drbexl
 
Christianity and the Digital Age: Sustaining the Online Church
Christianity and the Digital Age: Sustaining the Online ChurchChristianity and the Digital Age: Sustaining the Online Church
Christianity and the Digital Age: Sustaining the Online Church
 
Evangelization Digital Age - Part I
Evangelization Digital Age - Part IEvangelization Digital Age - Part I
Evangelization Digital Age - Part I
 
Digital Theology An Overview
Digital Theology An OverviewDigital Theology An Overview
Digital Theology An Overview
 
Telling The Story Formatted
Telling The Story FormattedTelling The Story Formatted
Telling The Story Formatted
 
Why churches can't afford to ignore social media (for New Wine)
Why churches can't afford to ignore social media (for New Wine)Why churches can't afford to ignore social media (for New Wine)
Why churches can't afford to ignore social media (for New Wine)
 
Evangelism in a Digital Age for Christian Enquiry Agency
Evangelism in a Digital Age for Christian Enquiry AgencyEvangelism in a Digital Age for Christian Enquiry Agency
Evangelism in a Digital Age for Christian Enquiry Agency
 
Social Media in Ministry
Social Media in MinistrySocial Media in Ministry
Social Media in Ministry
 
Marketing-Church
Marketing-ChurchMarketing-Church
Marketing-Church
 
Social networking and the Church
Social networking and the ChurchSocial networking and the Church
Social networking and the Church
 
Social Networking and the Church
Social Networking and the ChurchSocial Networking and the Church
Social Networking and the Church
 
Evangelism in a Digital Age (CODEC Digital Theology Seminar)
Evangelism in a Digital Age (CODEC Digital Theology Seminar)Evangelism in a Digital Age (CODEC Digital Theology Seminar)
Evangelism in a Digital Age (CODEC Digital Theology Seminar)
 

Mehr von Bex Lewis

Mehr von Bex Lewis (16)

Hybridity and Mission for #PremDAC20
Hybridity and Mission for #PremDAC20Hybridity and Mission for #PremDAC20
Hybridity and Mission for #PremDAC20
 
Being One Church for #PremDAC20
Being One Church for #PremDAC20Being One Church for #PremDAC20
Being One Church for #PremDAC20
 
Raising Children in a Digital Age
Raising Children in a Digital AgeRaising Children in a Digital Age
Raising Children in a Digital Age
 
Women in Leadership, Laidlaw College
Women in Leadership, Laidlaw CollegeWomen in Leadership, Laidlaw College
Women in Leadership, Laidlaw College
 
Digital Theology: The Big C #PremDac19
Digital Theology: The Big C #PremDac19Digital Theology: The Big C #PremDac19
Digital Theology: The Big C #PremDac19
 
Ashton Sixth Form College: Building Your Personal Brand in a Digital Age
Ashton Sixth Form College: Building Your Personal Brand in a Digital AgeAshton Sixth Form College: Building Your Personal Brand in a Digital Age
Ashton Sixth Form College: Building Your Personal Brand in a Digital Age
 
#PremDac18: Introduction to Digital Marketing with Bex Lewis
#PremDac18: Introduction to Digital Marketing with Bex Lewis#PremDac18: Introduction to Digital Marketing with Bex Lewis
#PremDac18: Introduction to Digital Marketing with Bex Lewis
 
Mini Pecha Kucha: Public Engagement Activity
Mini Pecha Kucha: Public Engagement Activity Mini Pecha Kucha: Public Engagement Activity
Mini Pecha Kucha: Public Engagement Activity
 
'Left to their own devices' for #PremDac17
'Left to their own devices' for #PremDac17'Left to their own devices' for #PremDac17
'Left to their own devices' for #PremDac17
 
Working with opportunities and risks for CSE in a digital age
Working with opportunities and risks for CSE in a digital ageWorking with opportunities and risks for CSE in a digital age
Working with opportunities and risks for CSE in a digital age
 
How can digital and social media be used by youth leaders?
How can digital and social media be used by youth leaders?How can digital and social media be used by youth leaders?
How can digital and social media be used by youth leaders?
 
Keep Calm: Visualising the war in posters
Keep Calm: Visualising the war in postersKeep Calm: Visualising the war in posters
Keep Calm: Visualising the war in posters
 
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
 
Raising Children in a Digital Age for Emmanuel Community Church
Raising Children in a Digital Age for Emmanuel Community ChurchRaising Children in a Digital Age for Emmanuel Community Church
Raising Children in a Digital Age for Emmanuel Community Church
 
Raising Children in a Digital Age for West Auckland Vineyard Church
Raising Children in a Digital Age for West Auckland Vineyard ChurchRaising Children in a Digital Age for West Auckland Vineyard Church
Raising Children in a Digital Age for West Auckland Vineyard Church
 
Children - and a Digital Age, for Reimagine Faith Formation
Children - and a Digital Age, for Reimagine Faith FormationChildren - and a Digital Age, for Reimagine Faith Formation
Children - and a Digital Age, for Reimagine Faith Formation
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
QucHHunhnh
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
ciinovamais
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
QucHHunhnh
 
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please PractiseSpellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
AnaAcapella
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan FellowsOn National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
 
Magic bus Group work1and 2 (Team 3).pptx
Magic bus Group work1and 2 (Team 3).pptxMagic bus Group work1and 2 (Team 3).pptx
Magic bus Group work1and 2 (Team 3).pptx
 
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
 
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docxPython Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
 
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptxUnit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
 
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
PROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docxPROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docx
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
 
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
 
Spatium Project Simulation student brief
Spatium Project Simulation student briefSpatium Project Simulation student brief
Spatium Project Simulation student brief
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701
ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701
ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701
 
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxUnit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
 
Dyslexia AI Workshop for Slideshare.pptx
Dyslexia AI Workshop for Slideshare.pptxDyslexia AI Workshop for Slideshare.pptx
Dyslexia AI Workshop for Slideshare.pptx
 
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please PractiseSpellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
 
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning PresentationSOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
 
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
 

IPM placing the christian church in a digital age

  • 1. Inclusive Placemaking: Placing the Christian Church in a Digital Age Dr Bex Lewis Senior Lecturer in Digital Marketing, Manchester Metropolitan University For http://www.placemanagement.org/ Tweet @drbexl 1 http://bit.ly/ChurchPlaceIPM
  • 2. Paper Overview • Church as geographical place • The digital environment: reality and place? • Discipleship online: The Big Bible Project • Researching the church and digital Tweet @drbexl 2
  • 3. Church as Geographical Place Tweet @drbexl 3 Photo by Alexandre Perotto on Unsplash
  • 4. Church of England Tweet @drbexl 4https://www.churchofengland.org/
  • 5. Grenfall Tower Tweet @drbexl 5 http://bit.ly/churchtimesGrenfall Image: Diocese of London That trust exists because of the care and compassion they have received for decades… we actually live here… urge those who speak about it to avoid the ambiguous and woolly term “local church”, but to speak proudly, precisely, and powerfully of the “parish church”. The parish church is a living icon of God’s love, connecting with people in ways that we hardly begin to understand and so often underestimate. Revd Dr Alan Everett, Vicar of St Clement with St Mark, Notting Dale, and St James’s, Norlands
  • 6. Methodist Church Tweet @drbexl 6http://www.methodist.org.uk/
  • 7. Foodbanks "Faith in Foodbanks?" recognises the ministry of many churches helping people who cannot afford to eat, looks at why there has been such a growth in foodbanks, and suggests ways churches can take action to tackle the underlying causes. It offers worship and bible resources to help Christians to reflect on food and poverty in Britain today. Tweet @drbexl 7 http://bit.ly/FoodbanksMC http://re-dish.org/projects/food-action/
  • 8. United Reformed Church Tweet @drbexl 8http://www.urc.org.uk/discipleship.html
  • 9. Baptist Church Tweet @drbexl 9http://www.baptist.org.uk/Groups/287921/About_us.aspx
  • 10. Catholic Church Tweet @drbexl 10http://directory.cbcew.org.uk/
  • 11. Theologians & Place Tweet @drbexl 11 2003 2014 2017
  • 12. The Digital Environment: Reality and Place? Tweet @drbexl 12 Photo by PixelsAway on Stockfresh
  • 13. Communities of Practice To be effective in the role of digital (technology) steward (Cochrane 2010; Narayan and Baglow 2010; Wenger, White, and Smith 2009), a person needs on the one hand to be capable with the technology, experimenting with innovations to explore their utility, whilst also aware of the various ways in which those innovations may be brought into the practice of the community. To achieve this effectiveness, the steward needs to devote time to increasing their own knowledge and abilities in the technological and community aspects of the role. Lewis, B, Rush, D. Experience of developing Twitter-based Communities of Practice in Higher Education, 2013, 3 Tweet @drbexl 13 https://journal.alt.ac.uk/index.php/rlt/article/view/1310
  • 14. Digital on its own terms Even though in practice, face-to- face communication can, of course, be angry, negligent, resistant, deceitful and inflexible, somehow it remains the ideal against which mediated communication is judged as flawed Livingstone, S. Children and the Internet: Great Expectations and Challenging Realities, 2009, 26 Tweet @drbexl 14
  • 15. For many churchgoing is no longer the ‘cultural norm’. People don’t actively ignore the church: they don’t even think about it. Matthew 5:13-16 calls us to be salt and light in the world, and for thousands in the ‘digital age’, that world includes social networks such Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and Pinterest. With literally billions in the digital spaces, the online social spaces presented by churches need to be appealing, welcoming, and not look like they are just an afterthought: they are now effectively the ‘front door’ to your church for digital users, and you ignore those spaces at your peril. Lewis, B. Growing Churches in a Digital Age, 2013 Tweet @drbexl 15 http://bit.ly/ChurchDigAge Image: Flickr
  • 16. Online Church? It may be possible to set up an online mega-church of millions of people but it is more likely that a long-term online Christian community will be small and quiet rather than large and exciting, and may not be understood by the wider Church…the commonest question I am asked about online church is ‘What do you do?’ and it is hard to explain that we don’t ‘do’ church – we are church to each other, despite the lack of sacraments or a building, because we are committed to each other’s journeys in the faith and in Christ’s love. Smith, P. Online Mission and Ministry, 2015, Introduction Tweet @drbexl 16
  • 17. Online Church? Tweet @drbexl 17Image: https://harperganesvoort.files.wordpress.com/2008/01/epiphany- cathedral-3.jpg Hutchings, T., Creating Church Online: Ritual, Community and New Media, 2017, 2
  • 18. Discipleship Online: The Big Bible Project (2010-2015) Tweet @drbexl 18 THANKS FOR FUNDING TO THE JERUSALEM TRUST AND Photo by Nina Strehl on Unsplash
  • 20. [If we are…] means by which God communicates and reveals himself through his Spirit, then our blog posts, status updates, tweets, artistic images, and online comments should be products of a life transformed by Christ and indwelled by his Spirit. As restored image bearers, our online presence and activity should image the Triune God. Byers, A. Theomedia: The Media of God and the Digital Age, 2013, 196
  • 21. Emerged Themes • What is a theologically informed view of digital engagement? • What is good practice for being a Christian online? • What is the impact of digital on religious practice (online/offline?) • What does a welcoming church look like in a digital age? Tweet @drbexl 21
  • 22. Media Interest Tweet @drbexl 22http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b091sz8x http://drbexl.co.uk/press
  • 23. Researching the Church and Digital Tweet @drbexl 23 Photo by Oakozhan on Stockfresh
  • 24. Digital Religion Reseach Scholars are identified as having moved from excitement at this ‘new thing’, to the digital becoming a part of everyday life to be analysed, to understanding what the lived ‘reality’ of digital religion is. The three academic waves that Campbell identifies here—the descriptive, the categorical and the theoretical— are echoed throughout the rest of the book, as we understand how ‘digital religion’ has matured as a field of study. Lewis, B. Book review: Digital Religion: Understanding Religious Practice in New Media Worlds, written by Heidi Campbell, 2015, 249 Tweet @drbexl 24http://bit.ly/CampbellReview
  • 25. Intermediate Outputs British Academy Funding Bid: Planning: Interviews: communications leads, major British church denominations Design: Content analysis: online content produced (nationally?) by churches Reception: Survey: Responses from users of church digital content • 2019: ‘Being a Christian Online: How the church and its members are adapting to the digital age’, The Information Society (to submit summer 2018) • 2020: ‘Raising Children in a Digital Age: concerns and policies for British churches’, Business History (to submit summer 2019) Tweet @drbexl 25
  • 26. Bigger Project: Being a Welcoming Church in a Digital Age Tweet @drbexl 26Photo: iqoncept, on Stockfresh

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. *Unlike most theologians, who like to have a 3-point preaching plan, I’ve got 4 main areas I want to cover within this paper in a fairly whistlestop fashion, as I try and pull ideas I’ve worked on over the last 6+ years into a forward trajectory of research planning, with an interest in digital culture, and how it can be shaped to provide the most positive and valuable experience for those engaging in it.
  2. The church in the United Kingdom can be regarded as geographically placed and located, with an emphasis upon local church services, and services to the local community such as food banks, debt management, and children’s work. Abstract Part 1: The church in the United Kingdom can be regarded as geographically placed and located, with an emphasis upon local church services, and services to the local community such as food banks, debt management, and children’s work. Theologians such as Rumsey (2017), Hjalmarson (2014), and Inge, (2003) are concerned with a theology of place, whilst the Church of England, the Methodist Church and the URC churches, amongst others, are organised around geographical dioceses, circuits and parishes, whilst also contributing to national and international public policy debates.
  3. The most obvious of these within the UK is the Church of England, which proclaims that it offers “A Christian presence in every community”, structured around parishes (local churches) and dioceses (a more administrative area).. Familiar to most who have ever walked into an English village is the church physically centred at the heart of the (original) local community…. structured around the time when people remained much more bound to one place for their entire lives (until 19th/20th c) – Inge, 2003, p6 The site makes it easy for you to ‘find your local church’… *side-note – focus on a particular geographical area here.
  4. This can be seen in the recent Grenfall Tower tragedy, where St Clement’s churh and the associated centre next door became the focal point for aid, donations and retreat from the trauma of the fire – as the vicar says, this happened because these people were already part of the local community, and re-emphasises the place of the local church https://www.london.anglican.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Donations-at-St-Clements-for-Grenfell-Tower.jpg
  5. The Methodist church is arranged around ‘circuits’ (collections of local churches) and districts (collections of circuits) – again ‘find a church’ is made easy to find on the front page….
  6. One of the stories on a Methodist webpage page, refers to a 2014 project ‘Faith in Foodbanks’, highlighting that many churches also contribute locally through a mix of practical (local) action, theological reflection, and feeding into appropriate public policy debates. The Re:dish logo is from the foodbank in my local area.
  7. The URC is structured into regional synods, within which there are local churches – again the website makes it easy to discover that.
  8. The Baptist Church holds onto a view “the Church consists of and in people. It is neither a building nor an organization,” but again, we see the emphasis on being visible within local communities, and the place in which those people are embedded. http://www.patheos.com/library/baptist/ethics-morality-community/community-organization-and-structure
  9. The Catholic church also emphasizes local services, and the ability to connect locally. There’s other denominations, but you get the point… (and we’ve not even looked at the websites of local churches at this level…)
  10. In seeking to get a handle on this sense of ‘place’ and the importance of ‘the local’, I turned to three theological texts: Inge from 2003 is almost ‘required reading’ for ministers in training, and argues that the importance of ‘place’ has been under-researched within theology, because of the emphasis that the world is but a temporary ‘home’, before heaven (p48, Paul, as a ‘new creation in Christ’ had been set free from the Law and the Land). He highlights Relph - 1976 (p84) that ‘the distinctiveness of place lies not so much in its exact physical forms and arrangements, as in the meanings accorded to it by a community of concerned people.’ The notion of ‘community’, and when a place may be become ‘holy’ and ‘sacred’ is key, and ties in the later question of whether digital can ever be considered ‘a place’ by theologians. Goodreads (a book review site) suggested Hjalmarson’s book to me, so I’m currently reading that. The foreword mentions Alan Durning’s This Place on Earth: visited remote hill tribes, whose very being was built around sacred territories, and the look of pity in her eyes when he said that he had no roots where he lived, and couldn’t articulate what was valuable about it – for missional Christians ‘place’ can be irrelevant, as rootedness can ‘get in the way’ of going ‘where one is called’ by the needs of faith and mission (p18). This book focuses on what it means for Christians to live in an embodied way within a particular ‘place’: “To return home is to return to a place; through experience human hearts become rooted in place. The paradox of place is that it is both given, and socially constructed… but place has become transparent to us. Like air, we are immersed in it and can’t live without it, but don’t see it.” (p26) I’ve just been to Greenbelt (arts and faith) Festival, and via Facebook saw that Andrew Rumsey was speaking on his new book, so that’s arrived a couple of weeks ago, but from the preview available on Kindle notes the word ‘parish’ comes from the greek word for ‘stranger’, in which “The church was the fellowship of strangers, the community of non-belongers, who had found their place in Christ.” The parish system once established was the ‘pre-eminent model of communal ‘belonging’ for nearly 1000 years – as the system strains, he’s looking for a re-consideration of what this means. See if can get a 30 sec video from Andrew Rumsey at Greenbelt?
  11. So, I want to move on to talk briefly about the digital as an environment… the digital, whether as an overarching ‘space’, or within specific platforms, is a place (terminology varies to include world, sphere, environment and culture) in which communication, action and community participation can be undertaken online… Abstract Part 2: With the digital age, this model has been challenged, with the digital offering a new ‘public sphere’ at a personal, organisational and political level, and has effectively become ‘the front door’ for many offline churches (Lewis, 2013). The global and perceived virtual nature of the digital also raises questions of ‘sacredness’ and ‘spirituality’ online (Smith, 2015). The digital, whether as an overarching ‘space’, or within specific platforms, is a place (terminology varies to include world, sphere, environment and culture) in which communication, action and community participation can be undertaken online. Experience since 2010, particularly workshops and speaking engagements held as Digital Fingerprint consultancy (2008 – 2017), has shown that the strong sense of ‘place’ for the church continues, with many looking to the digital to support and enhance geographically placed initiatives, and demonstrate engagement with the local community. As Hutchings (2017) has demonstrated, for many who attend church online, whether through livestreamed services, or via interactive (including virtual) platforms, this is a supplement to the face-to-face experience, rather than a replacement for it. Where churches are ‘built’ in the virtual environment, they tend to replicate the offline churches that they are representative of, and national churches tend to retain a national feel, particularly noticeable stylistically between UK and USA churches.
  12. If you’ve not worked out by now, I’m very well embedded online, it’s a place that I consider that I live – as Hjalmarson about physical places “we are immersed in it and can’t live without it, but don’t see it”, but I want to refer briefly to a piece in the Association for Learning Technologies Journal, in which I and a colleague sought to analyse one of my social media accounts, how it contributed to my role, and whether it could be considered a ‘true community of practice’. What we discovered was that the majority of places where there was a concentration of followers all following each other, was built around the connections formed at e-learning conferences … As with many media appearances where I’m asked to highlight the ‘dangers’ of various digital aspects, I want to highlight that I rarely see digital and physical as either/or, but am looking at how the two work together, inform each other, at the affordances and constraints of each…. [http://www.ucl.ac.uk/ucl-press/browse-books/social-media-in-an-english-village - challenge to English sensibilities of overlapping personal/public… ]
  13. … within the Church in particular, where there’s an emphasis upon the idea that Jesus came to earth in human form, and therefore this is the ‘best’ form of interaction, but as this quote from Prof Sonia Livingstone “Even though...” illustrates, we need to look at digital on its own terms, rather than always in comparison. We need to avoid what’s known as ‘technological determinism’ – that technology is changing everything, and we have no choice but to give into it, and think more about the ‘social shaping’ of technology – in which technology offers us new opportunities, but we have choices in how we engage with those choices – e.g. Like a brick – chuck it through the window, or build a wall with it.
  14. With the digital age, the geographical model has been challenged, with the digital offering a new ‘public sphere’ at a personal, organisational and political level, and has effectively become ‘the front door’ for many offline churches, as you’ll see in this piece that I wrote for the Church of England research group in 2013. *Note, first church website I built, back in around 2001, we discussed the importance of the website being consistent with what would happen when someone walked through the door of the local church (the focus of the efforts). We emphasised that it needed to feature real people, the community (not so much the building unless of historical interest). If, as the Baptists say, the people are the church more than the building so many think of, social media is important as a relational tool (and the side-doors and windows into church life)… Experience since 2010, particularly workshops and speaking engagements held as Digital Fingerprint consultancy (2008 – 2017), has shown that the strong sense of ‘place’ for the church continues, with many looking to the digital to support and enhance geographically placed initiatives, and demonstrate engagement with the local community … the place that digital can contribute to pre-existing physcial communities is KEY (generally because that is how the systems they are working within are built… so takes some challenging to think about that.
  15. This is something that Rev Pam Smith, vicar of iChurch (a fully online church) has sought to write about in her book, answering the many questions about how the global and perceived virtual nature of the digital raises questions of ‘sacredness’ and ‘spirituality’ online… the question You’ll see her that it is about people undertaking a journey of discipleship together (we’ll come back to that shortly), and how the online space facilitates that, rather than, as was initially thought (and still persists to some extent), the things are cheaper, faster, easier, less intensive online, and that large numbers are all that count…
  16. The main academic researcher in this area is Tim Hutchings, with whom I worked at Durham university, so I’ve watched a lot of his work develop into this book (which I don’t have, because, £), where he undertook an ethnographic study of various online churches, including The Anglican Cathedral in Second Life, iChurch, St Pixel’s and Church Online (thesis completed 2010) – we see here the discussion as to whether an avatar created as a dragon was ‘ok’ to lead church – thereby demonstrating how concerns from the offline have led into the online (and in fact that the very shape of e.g. The Anglican Cathedral has a familiarity of ‘place’, as a recognisably UK Anglican Cathedral). One of the main concerns that many that I talk to have is that if online church is available, people will stop coming to offline churches, but Tim’s research demonstrated that for many who attend church online, whether through live-streamed services, or via interactive (including virtual) platforms, this is a supplement to the face-to-face experience, rather than a replacement for it.
  17. My work has not been as formal, or as academic, in this area. I was funded by various organisations, particularly The Jerusalem Trust (under their aim: the creative use of digital media and the internet to promote Christianity), for CODEC: The Centre for Digital Theology (80%), alongside running a consultancy (Digital Fingerprint) which largely worked with churches and charities to encourage engagement with digital opportunities, and overcome fears of engaging with these. Abstract Part 3: This paper, an informal netnography, draws together varying strands of work undertaken in the last decade, including Digital Fingerprint, and ‘The Big Bible Project’ undertaken at Durham University (http://bit.ly/BigBible1015, 2010-2015). Within the project over 3,000 blog posts were collected from ‘voices in the pew, the pulpit and the academy’ addressing questions as to what it means to be a Christian in a digital age: how does this impact upon organisational decisions, personal behaviour and discipleship, and the call to be missional within whichever community one finds oneself (arguably including the digital). The contributors were all volunteers, a mix of church members, vicars and academics, considering how various books of the Bible could speak into digital culture. Christian discipleship texts will encourage those of faith to be ‘the face of God’ to the rest of the world, a life visibly transformed by a relationship with Jesus Christ, a ‘witness’ to the world (Logan, 2014, Peterson, 2000). In the contemporary digital age, Christians are encouraged to think about how they are ‘the face of God’ in all spheres, including online (Byers, 2014).
  18. Originally intended to improve Biblical literacy, but with a very open brief, I took the concept of a disciple “A Disciple is one who, by following Jesus, grows in their faith in Christ and in so doing models and teaches Christians the precepts of the Bible, prayer, doctrine, relationship, Christian living, service, and worship, to name the main ones.”. As we sought themes, it became obvious we could work through the 66 books of the Bible, and the contributors (all volunteers, a mix of church members, vicars and academics) would consider every month how a particular book of the Bible (taken in Biblical order) could speak into digital culture, etiquette and behaviour online, evangelism and mission, both locally and with what one contributor referred to as ‘learning to live in your digital skin’. Over 3,000 blog posts were written in what we described as drawing on ‘voices from the pew, the pulpit and the academy’, as we grappled with what it means to be a Christian in a digital age. As I am seeking to turn this into appropriate academic publications, I noted to myself that the ‘digital world’ has often been described as an alien world, a virtual world, to be approached tentatively. The church, however, has sought to use the digital for mission (acquisition/conversion) and discipleship (retention/advocacy), with differing levels of success. Organisations and individuals use it to share their lives, tell their stories, open up discussions, and to engage with a sceptical world – a world that is hungry for relationships – and meaning. In a digital age, it is important for the church to consider how it is relevant (without losing its values), how it is connected with it’s community (local/global), and how it empowers its people to share their lives authentically (online) – in many ways as ‘influencer marketers’ within their group of friends.
  19. Christian discipleship texts have always encouraged those of faith to be ‘the face of God’ to the rest of the world, a life visibly transformed by a relationship with Jesus Christ, a ‘witness’ to the world (Logan, 2014, Peterson, 2000). In the contemporary digital age, Christians are encouraged to think about how they are ‘the face of God’ in all spheres, including online (Byers, 2014)…. and I’m currently finishing a journal article for Surveillance and Society on Social Media, Peer Surveillance and Spiritual Formation: What is it about social media (and digital) culture in general that shapes our expectations of what we can/want to do in those spaces? What does ‘surveillance’ look like within social media, especially when we understand ourselves to be observed in the space? What are the social norms, and (how) do we self-regulate with an awareness of being observed? How does social media impact our spiritual formation, and how do (a couple) of social media users perceive that? Gould (2013, 11) would agree that “Social media has opened up yet another portal for seeing and being seen, for knowing and being known, for being in and belonging to community,” offering opportunities for enhancing what already exists, rather than replacing it with something completely new. Byers, theological consultant for The BIGBible Project (2013: 196), notes that if we ourselves are the   means by which God communicates and reveals himself through his Spirit, then our blog posts, status updates, tweets, artistic images, and online comments should be products of a life transformed by Christ and indwelled by his Spirit. As restored image bearers, our online presence and activity should image the Triune God. At the core of this is the importance of a consistent message, embodying an unchanging God, as Byers (232) finishes “nothing would be more irrelevant to the world than a relevant church that is competent with digital media but inept with the media of God.” Vogt (2011: 15) agrees that each new technology offers new opportunities for mission (deeply tied to discipleship), but the basic message of Christianity remains the same.
  20. There were a lot of themes that emerged each month, but towards the end of my time there, I was working my way through seeking overarching themes to identify a reshaping of the site, and a way that it could tie more strongly with academic research. What is a theologically informed view of digital engagement? What does the Bible and years of theological discussions have to say about what, where, why, how, etc. we engage digitally – is it a place that the church needs to concern itself with with its concern for relationships, evangelism and living within community? What is good practice for being a Christian online? What is positive behaviour, what is a ‘good witness’ for living the life of a Christian? Social media I often describe as pull rather than push marketing, so how do our lives look interesting enough to intrigue others into asking questions about what it is that makes us live our lives differently? What is the impact of digital on religious practice (online/offline?) How has digital and social changed the way we undertake particular religious practices, e.g. communion, worship, prayer, etc. What does a welcoming church look like in a digital age? – will return to this one shortly…
  21. Various aspects of this work have fed through into media coverage – most recently on Radio 4, when we discussed whether the 20+ minute sermon still has a place in a digital age?s
  22. So, finally, I want to briefly touch upon projects that are in planning, to make use of a mix of the connections and the content that I’ve engaged with over the past 7+ years. Abstract Part 4: Drawing upon an empirical research proposal (with consequent journal article) in the early stages of planning, the paper will consider the way that social media and the digital impacts upon the public personas that the church as an organisation (at various levels), and also that of the individuals within it as representatives of ‘the church’ within their local communities (offline, and specific communities online). Churches have a long tradition of being in places of need, and can look at what they can offer the local and digital communities on a practical and spiritual level. The paper will finish with an exploration of an idea for a larger research project (with a more academic focus than the above projects), which considers what it means to be a welcoming church in a digital age. The project would consider questions such as what do churches think they are doing to be welcoming, including online, and does online/offline match; what do people ‘research’ when looking for a church to visit; does digital and social media seem to be a core part of this, and could the project provide guidance as to how the church could make use of these tools better, but also, could the experience of the church inform more general marketing practice for values-based organisations.
  23. The field of digital religion is a fast-evolving one, with Heidi Campbell one of the key theoretical scholars, pinpoints how ‘digital religion’ has emerged from disciplines such as theology, sociology, and media studies, and identifies how the subject has gained credibility, so it makes sense to study it from a business school perspective as much as any other discipline (also drawing in my historical training, and past projects in digital literacy and organisational development).
  24. Drawing upon the model of how I researched second world war propaganda posters in the Second World War (what did the government plan, how did the artists visualise that, and what responses can be identified), I am seeking funding for a similar model as to how the church as an organization is engaging with a digital age…. Queries: Planning – what do they THINK they are doing? Where do they see the place of the church fitting in contemporary society, and the digital within that? The question of which content to analyse is one I’m looking at at the moment, as for consistency it would be useful to look at national campaigns, but as anecdotally bottom-up campaigns quite often seem to have better reach (those relationships again)… What seems to be successful, can we identify best practice? What should be abandoned? How much more widely can we share that information and share secular marketing practice (as marketing itself is often regarded by the church as negative/slimy practice) The second paper would seek to draw upon a book of the same title that I wrote in 2014, and interview children’s leaders and the policies and practices they are putting in place to cope with the digital age.
  25. So, in that I’ve looked at in the paper so far, I’ve sought to look at where place has been of importance to churches, geographically and theologically, then considered whether the digital is a place – and how it’s less a question of either/or but of both/and and seeking ways to make them work together. I identified that one of the themes that emerged from the Big Bible project was ‘What does a welcoming church look like in a digital age?’. This also draws on my experiences of the past 2 years where I’m seeking a church to settle into – the website/social is the first place I go to, and one church I went to several times was appealing because it was engaging with Pokemon (draws on GPS) – and thinking back to an experience in Australia – where I was clearly ‘passing through’, but was welcomed, talked to, taken to the pub, and given dinner! That’s my golden benchmark – how can more churches reach that on limited resources? I am sketching out ideas for a project that would look at that How can churches look at what they contribute to their local community, and how they can welcome the local community? How does the digital impact what a church does, including it’s communications and practice to encourage welcome? How can digital be used to show people more of what church looks like once the doors are shut? How can the congregation be encouraged to be witnesses of the church where they are located – online and offline? How can we ensure that when people visit a church on the basis of digital content, that it’s not a horrible shock? What are people researching when they search online? What best practice guidelines could we gain from these insights? How can we help the church make better use of these tools? Could the experience of the church inform more general marketing practice for values-based organisations? 2- way street? Be interested in whether others think this has legs, etc., potential collaborators, etc. Potential Partners/Funders Possible funding/partners - Jerusalem Trust, CofE, URC, Methodist Church, LST, UCB, Premier Radio, CODEC?!, YesHeis, YouVersion, Tearfund, Christian Aid, Bible Society Theos, and all those other Christian organisations – e.g. Livability, etc.. Others who have done research: YesHeIs; David Giles; Chris Goswami Potential Outputs Articles, policy papers, training resources = impact http://www.churchgrowthrd.org.uk/blog/churchgrowth/growing_churches_in_the_digital_age http://drbexl.co.uk/2016/02/14/survey-putting-your-faith-in-social-media-with-faithsocialmedia/ http://www.faithinsocialmedia.org/ http://7minutes.net/christian-media-survey-2016/
  26. Thanks for listening, open for any questions and/or conversations afterwards.