This document provides an overview of grey literature and strategies for searching it. It defines grey literature as semi-published or unpublished work not produced by commercial publishers, such as reports, theses, and conference proceedings. Reasons to use grey literature include finding preliminary data and viewpoints not available in traditional publications. The document recommends search engines and repositories for finding grey literature, including BASE, OpenGrey, Google Scholar, and subject-specific databases. It provides tips for effective searching and examples of sources for different subject areas like social sciences, health, and government publications. Hands-on activities are suggested to allow people to practice searching grey literature resources.
2. What we will cover today
■What is grey literature?
■Why use grey literature?
■Search engines/ open access repositories.
■Finding theses and dissertations.
■Social sciences / government publications.
■Opportunity for hands on practice.
www.city.ac.uk/library
4. What is grey literature?
■ Grey literature is semi or unpublished information not produced by
commercial publishers. For example research reports, working papers,
conference proceedings, theses, preprints, white papers, government,
academic, business and industry reports (University of Leeds). Examples
at: GreyNet.org
■ There is some debate about how to define it and what it includes.
■ May be open access but some grey literature as not published by
mainstream publishers can be hard to track down.
■ It has not necessarily been peer-reviewed so you may wish to evaluate
the quality of it.
■ Search engines and interfaces may vary in quality and performance.
5. Why use grey literature?
■Some material such as research reports may only be
available as grey literature.
■ Source of preliminary data (e.g. statistics).
■ Quickly produced and disseminated.
■ Could include qualitative information such as viewpoints of
individuals such as patients.
■ More likely to be industry or sector focussed.
■ Balanced viewpoint? – may include negative results
■Can offer coverage of special interest topics and expand
your literature search.
■May be open access and international.
6. Some search engines for grey literature
■ BASE: Bielefeld Academic Search Engine- the Advanced Search
allows you to search for specific types of grey literature.
■ Google Scholar and Google are useful for locating some reports,
technical papers, conference proceedings and working papers.
■ Open Grey- Provides open access to 700,000 bibliographical references
of grey literature (papers) produced in Europe. It includes documents
from the fields of science, technology, biomedical science, economics,
social science and humanities. (Not up to date).
■ Grey Literature Report Public health topics (up to Jan 2017).
■ Online subscription databases such as Web of Science and Scopus
allow you to refine or limit your searches to look for specific types
of grey literature, such as conference proceedings.
7. Some search tips
■ AND combines search terms so that each result you retrieve will contain
all the keywords you have entered in no particular order.
■ OR retrieves documents where either keyword appears. For example,
teenagers or adolescents. OR is used to broaden results.
■ NOT excludes terms. Each search result will exclude any of the terms
which follow the word Not. For example, education NOT technology finds
results that contain the keyword Education but not technology.
■ “…..” searches for an exact phrase.
■ Wildcard (? #) Use the wildcard to replace a single character in the word
(eg. organi?ation, wom#n).
■ Truncation (* $) replaces multiple characters at the end of the word eg.
psycholog*
■ Word order?
10. Finding theses & dissertations
■ Library catalogues such as COPAC.
■ Harvesters such as OpenDOAR and CORE have access to
international subject-based and institutional repositories. There is a list of
international repositories SHERPA search (beta) for UK open access
repositories.
■ British Library EThOS Online e-theses service, some available to
download.
■ DART- Europe E-theses Portal www.dart-europe.eu/
Access to European research theses.
■ Humanities Commons dissertations and other materials.
■ Proquest Dissertations & Theses (subscription resource).
12. Examples of free social sciences resources
■Health Sciences has many sources.
■Social Sciences
■Popline contains the world’s most comprehensive collection of
population, family planning and related reproductive health and
development literature.
■Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Abstracts, working
papers and articles relating to social science research. Examples
of other free subject repositories include RePEc, arXiv or PubMed
Central.
■Social Care Online The UK’s largest database of information and
research on all aspects of social care and social work.
■PsycBITE is a database that catalogues studies of cognitive,
behavioural and other treatments for psychological
problems and issues.
13. SSRN – paper statistics & downloads
Related journals and papers.
14. Government publications
■The following resources provide information
produced by the UK government www.gov.uk
and its agencies. Information available includes
governmental publications, policy documents,
consultations and announcements.
■Publications example Social care
■Policies example Health and social care.
■Consultations (open and closed) example Network
Rail
■Announcements example Higher Education.
15. Other sources
■ Mailing lists – JISCMail Email discussion lists for the UK Education and
Research communities.
■ Blogs (search Google and add keyword blogs).
■ Zetoc Conference search.
■ Conference archives may contain papers or presentations eg. LILAC
Conference
■ Follow academics and hashtags on Twitter.
■ Figshare is a web-based interface designed for academic research data
management and research data dissemination.
16. Conclusion
■With the vast expansion of electronic information, it is much
easier to locate materials that are not commercially
published.
■It is certainly worth looking at these sources when
conducting research / literature reviews as they are often
free, open access and international.
■This might also mean that what is considered as ‘grey
literature’ is less defined and clear as the use of sources
such as electronic theses had become much more common.
17. Activity 1
■Take a look at some of the different resources on the grey
literature Library guide https://libguides.city.ac.uk/grey and
try some searches of your choice on them.
■How easy do you find them to use?
■What do you think of the interfaces, searching and content?
■Did you find any useful information?
■What are your top 3 resources?
18. Activity 2
■Go to the Grey literature library guide
http://libguides.city.ac.uk/grey
■Choose a topic. Think of some concepts, keywords and
synonym terms for the topic.
■ Identify some limits for your search.
■ Consider the types of documents you require eg. theses,
reports, articles, data, blogs.
■ Publication dates eg. in the last 5 years.
■ Geographical location ( eg. UK, international).
■ Choose which sources to use (See Grey literature page
above for some ideas).
■Try some searches.
19. Thank you, any questions?
■Diane Bell diane.bell.2@city.ac.uk
■@dianelouisebell
Hinweis der Redaktion
Different sources for finding different types of grey literature, in this context meaning semi or informally unpublished information, not published by commercial publishers, concentrating mainly on free sources.
Today we will look at:
What is grey literature? Semi or informally published materials, not produced by commercial publishers. May be useful and open access but you may have to work harder to locate it.
Grey Literature sources as a supplement to conducting research, you may wish to use these as they can be free of charge and may give you extra insight or a different approach.
For today I have created a Grey literature Library guide at: https://libguides.city.ac.uk/grey
This shows some different sources of grey literature. These vary and range from grey literature search engines, Google Scholar content to dissertations and theses to repositories to think tanks and government reports. Most of them are free sources.
It depends on the topic that you are studying or researching or the approach you wish to take.
It can be quite a “grey area” as to what it includes. Article: are electronic theses and dissertations still grey literature?
Tends to refer to semi or unpublished information not produced by commercial publishers.
Popular in Health Sciences as part of a literature review/ systematic review.
You may have to put in effort to track things down and check the quality. Preliminary work or findings or essays might not be quality checked/ peer reviewed.
May have to persevere to track it down, for example approach an organisation.
The search functionality, indexing and interfaces may be basic on some resources affecting discovery.
Some sources may be withdrawn or not maintained.
Self-archiving of slides and materials on websites.
If you are looking for free sources then grey literature might be a good option.
May supplement your research and be free/ open access
BASE – Next slide
Google Scholar “digital literacy” and “higher education” Since 2017.
Digital literacy in higher education – Learntechlib PDF, Cited by, related articles
Google Digital inclusion policy "digital inclusion policy“ More focussed
Open Grey example Academic libraries and grey literature
BASE – Advanced search screen – different search options, document types, boost open access documents, by different licence type.
Additional word forms
BASE provides more than 120 million documents from more than 6,000 sources. You can access the full texts of about 60% of the indexed documents for free (Open Access). BASE is operated by Bielefeld University Library.
We are indexing the metadata of all kinds of academically relevant resources - journals, institutional repositories, digital collections etc
The order of the search terms seems to make a difference Entire document search: Social care and dementia.
Additional word forms
Title search – different results
Different word order = Dementia and social care different order of results Using Dementia Care Mapping in Dementia Care Intervention Research.
Links to Google Scholar and to repositories. Has a Search history . Can refine by date of publication descending for recent works. And by year of publication, document type. Content provider.
You can create an account at the top right to save your search.
Library catalogues or repositories for theses. For example where the thesis was written. Main Search – Thesis.
OpenDOAR – find names of repositories, including international eg. The Freie Universitat, Berlin.
CORE – Search across different repository content. Dementia and Social Care .
BL EThoS Dementia and social care - Sort by Newest
Humanities Commons – CityLis group What is a digital library? Mariana Ou. Dissertation but also student assignments and lecture PowerPoints.
Very popular in Health Sciences as an extra dimension to literature / systematic reviews.
Subject archives have abstracts, articles, working papers etc. Can be open access.
SSRN – paper downloads, statistics
Digital libraries - E-Books in Libraries: A Briefing Document Developed in Preparation for a Workshop on E-Lending in Libraries
SSRN – Digital libraries – paper statistics and downloads.
JISC MAIL – Lis-link ; lis-research
Google Blogs – Digital inclusion – UK Digital Strategy.
Twitter – Phil Bradley ; Tim Lang ; Social Research Hub https://twitter.com/socphd
Figshare – Data, documents, slides : Melissa Terras; Ernesto Priego.