The document discusses the woody biomass industry and projections for growth in the European pellet market. It notes that the pulp and paper industry in the southern US is holding steady due to demand for pulp. However, reduced planting and thinning of pine forests has led to dwindling pulpwood inventories that will impact both existing pulp mills and new bioenergy projects. The future may see increased prices for pulpwood and forest residue as a valuable feedstock.
Adapting Water Management Practice to the Double Exposure of Climate Change a...
Florida Energy Summit Dean Mc Craw
1. Woody Biomass
Fact vs. Fiction
Dean McCraw CF
McCraw Energy LLC
10/26/2011
mccrawenergy.com
2. McCraw Energy LLC
We provide a variety of services for the bioenergy field. These include:
Assessment of forest inventories, including forest residue.
Valuation of delivered bioenergy feedstocks.
Long range planning, including assessment of options to increase
future feedstock supplies.
Establishment of a bioenergy feedstock procurement
organization. This can include contract procurement or the training
of personnel for your facility.
Contract production and/or delivery of forest residue.
Design consultation on feedstock receiving facility.
Contract operation of feedstock receiving facility.
Consultation and/or contract establishment of energy tree
plantations and energy grasses.
Business contacts with all major forest landowners in the
Southeastern US
mccrawenergy.com
3. Background
• There is nothing new under the sun
• Renewable energy was all the rage from the mid-70’s
to the mid-80’s
• The difference from then to now is that in the 80’s the
Forest Products Industry was a leader and now it may
be a victim.
• The main driver in the 80’s was energy cost savings.
Today this can still be the case but politics now has a
larger role than energy cost savings.
• New players are entering the market and competing in
the pine pulpwood markets.
mccrawenergy.com
5. Background
• The main new competitor for pine pulpwood is
the energy market in Europe.
• These are not free markets. These are driven by
government policy as the EU is a signer of the
Kyoto Protocol.
• Large growth projected for this market moving
forward.
• This assumes that present EU economical
problems do not bring about a downfall of the
EU.
mccrawenergy.com
6. “Men, it has been well said,
think in herds; it will be seen
that they go mad in herds,
while they only recover their
senses slowly, one by one.”
Charles MacKay, Extraordinary Popular Delusions and
the Madness of Crowds
mccrawenergy.com
8. PROJECTIONS FOR FUTURE GROWTH OF
EUROPEAN PELLET MARKETS (IN MILLION MT)
European Demand
90
Poyry
80
70 RWE (Europe)
60
million tonnes
Mitsubishi
50
40
AEBIOM
30
20 Rotterdam Port
10
Enviva Expectation
0
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Source: U.S. Industrial Pellet Association
mccrawenergy.com
9. SHIPPING COST FROM THE SOUTHEAST ARE
COMPETITIVE COMPARED TO MOST REGIONS
DK/SW €20-€25
Bel/UK €30-€35
(Winter shipping challenge)
Source: Poyry
mccrawenergy.com
10. Southern Forest Research Station, Forest Inventory & Analysis, The Inventory, March 2009
mccrawenergy.com
13. Planting numbers
• Some have questioned these planting numbers.
• However the nursery numbers bear them out.
• ArborGen, the largest seedling producer in the
world, has seen a 49% decline in seedlings
shipped from 2001 to 2009.
• In 2000 I was responsible for the production and
planting of 45MM seedlings. That same company
will plant 18MM seedlings this next year, a
decline of 60%.
mccrawenergy.com
14. How did we get here?
• In the 80’s and on to the late 90’s, pine pulpwood
shortages, especially during periods of wet
weather, where not uncommon. During this
period overcutting of timber growing stock was
common.
• Our present situation is a result of this late 80’s
CRP, or as we now hear it referred to “unintended
consequences.”
• We added an additional 3 million acres of pine
timberland in the South.
• As this has moved thru the system it has caused
some real problems.
mccrawenergy.com
15. How did we get here?
• When these stands reached thinning age
starting in around 1999, we saw a glut of
pulpwood on the market.
• There were cases of landowners in Georgia
having to pay loggers to thin their CRP stands.
• This glut of pulpwood also coincided with
major changes in timberland ownership as
many integrated forest products companies
disposed of their timberlands.
mccrawenergy.com
16. Present state of things
• Presently we have an overabundance of small
and large sawtimber on the market. The 3
million acres of land planted during the late
80’s CRP program is now ready to harvest.
• This happens to coincide with one of the
greatest downturns in the housing market this
country has ever seen.
• It will be years before all this sawtimber will
find its way to the market.
mccrawenergy.com
17. Present state of things
• Industrial landowners (TIMOs & REITs)are not
helping the situation as most have lowered
planting densities . Some have lowered
densities to 218 stems/acre.
• Many are now planting CMP and SE seedlings.
These high priced, low density seedlings are
being grown for the sawtimber market.
• Tree improvement programs have focused on
selecting trees for the production of
sawtimber.
mccrawenergy.com
19. Present state of things
• Additional dangers to forest plantation
acreage may be in our current commodity
pricing. With corn and cotton at all time highs
we may see acreage revert from timberland
back to farm land.
• Keep in mind that there is no such thing as
marginal farmland. Marginal farmland in the
South is called timberland.
mccrawenergy.com
20. Present state of things
“The reports of my death are greatly
exaggerated.” Mark Twain
• This can also be said about the pulp/paper
industry in the South.
• Freesheet (fine papers) have declined.
Closure of the Franklin VA mill.
• Linerboard appears to be holding its own.
• Pulp is the golden boy at present. Franklin mill
to reopen in 2012 producing fluff pulp.
mccrawenergy.com
21. US South Daily Pulp/Paper Mill Wood Usage
80,000
70,000
60,000
50,000
Tons/Day
40,000 1991
2002
2009
30,000
20,000
10,000
0
AL AR FL GA KY LA MS NC OK SC TN TX VA
State
Southern Pulpwood Production 1991, 2002, 2009. US Forest Service, Southern Research Station
mccrawenergy.com
23. Recent Pulp Pricing
Dissolving pulp prices on world markets have
skyrocketed from protracted lows of $300 to
$500 per ton from the 1970s into the late 1990s
to as high as $1,800 to $1,900 currently, with
spot prices up to $2,500 per ton and higher
earlier this year. Market drivers have been in
and out of gear in recent months
but, overall, most observers see the dissolving
pulp boom continuing for at least several more
years.
The Dissolving Pulp Gold Rush, Paper 360, September/October 2011
mccrawenergy.com
24. Present state of things
• At this level of pricing, pulp mills are making
more than $300/ton.
• Typically a mill uses around four tons of
greenwood to produce a ton of pulp.
• Based on this ratio, a pulp mill could currently
pay an additional $75/ton for wood before
they run into the red.
• Energy users can not pay these prices for
wood.
mccrawenergy.com
25. Present state of things
• In recent months I have received feedback
from several sources on the FIA numbers.
• These numbers are being used to make major
investment decisions on energy projects.
• There are questions related to
inventory, removals and volumes.
• The issue of Florida timber harvest levels has
been examined by John Morris VP at Foley
Timberlands.
mccrawenergy.com
27. Southern Forest Research Station, Forest Inventory & Analysis, The Inventory, September 2011
mccrawenergy.com
28. What does the future hold?
Here are some possible scenarios;
• Southern pine plantations will be heavily stocked
with sawtimber.
• The specifications that differentiate pulpwood
from small sawtimber will probably change with
the smallest of this sawtimber moving into
pulpwood.
• This will result in landowners wanting increased
pricing for pulpwood and downward pricing
pressure on small sawtimber. There have been
recent incidences of spot markets paying more
for pulpwood than for small sawtimber.
mccrawenergy.com
30. What does the future hold?
• The volumes of forest residue will increase as we all
know that larger trees have larger limbs and tops.
Also, the current push to low planting densities will
increase the amount of residue hardwood that invades
these pine stands. These are both pluses for users of
forest residue.
• With the continued glut of sawtimber on the
market, there are many in the forest products industry
who feel that we may see increased sales of
timberlands by the TIMOs and REITs in an effort to
prop up returns within these organizations.
mccrawenergy.com
31. Summary
• The reduction in pine pulpwood inventories will impact
all users, the existing pulp/paper industry and the new
energy start-ups.
• Forest Landowners will have opportunities to “cash-in”
on these reduced inventories. This will include the use
of higher planting densities and intensive forest
management.
• Users of pine pulpwood can be proactive and begin to
plan for the feedstock markets changes or wait and pay
the price.
• This situation will be a plus for users of forest residue.
mccrawenergy.com
A younger skinnier me.I was called garbage man, junk man and at times Fred SanfordI just referred to myself as the Rodney Dangerfield of the Woodlands Division.As noted in the article, Union Camp installed a new boiler that could burn wood, coal, natural gas and #6 fuel oil.While UC had a big company logging operation, 25 crews, our operation was not in our company harvesting division but in our Land Department. We were considered a land clearing operation , there to reduce our site prep cost.We competed with the price of coal. We had to be at ¼ the price of delivered coal. This was before the internet, but I still kept up with the delivered price of coal.We were really successful and saved the company considerable money on site prep and energy cost. However, in the Fall of 86 we had a worldwide energy market crash and oil dropped to $10/barrel. We could not compete with UC was not the only forest products company that invested in renewable energy operations. There were a number of other forest products with forest residue operations.
This article appeared in the Savannah paper last year and shows the preposterous statements made about the energy market. I have heard Georgia referred to as the Saudi Arabia of pine trees. This type of hyping is coming from economic development folks and not foresters!
The US South has the second lowest freight rates to Europe.We are outdone by Russia which is opening the world largest pellet mill this month. It will replace the mill in Wax as the worlds largest as this new mill will be capable of producing 1MM tons/year. There are two major issues with this plant. The first is what both Napoleon and Hitler learned the hard way. Operations in the Russia during the winter can be nearly impossible and the harbor is frozen over for at least four months a year.The second relates to what happened in 1986. Chernobyl. When the reactor melted down and exploded most of the radiation cloud moved North. The world did not know of Chernobyl until a few days after the incident when detectors at a Sweden Nuclear plant starting going off. Apparently the issue is not the radioactivity in the wood. It is low enough to not be an issue in the pellets but when the wood is burned the radioactivity is concentrated in the ash and then it becomes an issue. Recently the Italian government forced a recall of pellets sold in Italy for home use.
Hardwood 7.49 x 1,000,000,000= 7,490,000,000/1000=7,490,000 x 20.0= 149,800,000 tonsPine 9.53 x 1,000,000,000=9,530,000,000/1000= 9,530,000 x 15.5= 147,715,000 tons
I have written two articles this year asking this question.This one for Forest Landowner magazine and a second for Biomass magazine.The one in Forest Landowner was written from the perspective of what a forest landowner can do. The one in Biomass was written from the perspective of what a pine pulpwood user could do.
Each of these spikes are the result of government intervention in the regeneration business.First one was the soil bank program.The second one is the CRP program in the late 80’s, which will be the main focus of my talk.The more recent one was in the late 90’s and early 2000’s. This one has not had as big an impact on the market since most of it was focused on longleaf and wildlife.The USFS handled all the data collection up until 1999. Since that time Steve Chapman with the GFC has handled the collection of this data.I provided data for the states on these numbers. GA and FL do a good job
39.4 tons/metric ton (2205 lbs) $ 7.85/bushel 10yr average is $3.68/bushel
Steve Troxler NC Commissioner of Agriculture -Show a farmer how to make a profit and in just a couple of years he will produce his way out of it.
If anyone would like more information on the pulp and paper industry I would encourage you to attend next year’s SESAF meeting in February on Jekyll Island. Dr. Richard Phillips, retired Senior VP of Research for IP and currently professor at NC State will be presenting an overview of the pulp/paper industry in the SE area. I heard Richard do this presentation at the Appalachian SAF meeting last year. It is one of the best presentations I have ever seen. He will cover specific mills and how they rank. He also compares mills in the South with worldwide competition and the effects of exchange rates on production.
August 1998 St Joe closed.
As I noted earlier about herds, this same article list 15 mills that are moving to increase production of dissolving pulp including one here in FL.
Based on his analysis, John estimates that Florida plantations were overharvested in 2007 by 3.8 million tons. He further forecast that this number would increase in the future as regeneration acreage continues to decline. Adding increased usage from bioenergy and biofuels operations “will further negate sustainability.” John is not the only one to question FIA data. I was at the GASAF meeting last month, where a speaker noted issues with Georgia’s FIA data. I have a copy of a recent presentation on Georgia data that I would be willing to share with anyone who contacts me. With all the recent