1. Perception survey
Catalonia / Spain
MAIN RESULTS
November 2009
Research by Universitat Oberta de Catalunya. Director: Miquel Strubell
(Identi.Cat research group)
Field work and data analysis: Instituto DYM
With the support of the Centre of Contemporary Studies of Catalonia (CETC)
NOTE: this document has been translated by volunteers. If in doubt refer to the
Catalan original file. Ref.: 09472183
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 1
2. TECHNICAL FILE
TECHNICAL FILE
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND SELF-DETERMINATION
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND SELF-DETERMINATION
REFERENDUM REACTIONS
INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 2
3. Technical File
Data collection Interviews with Computer Aided Technology Inc (C.A.T.I.).
Fieldwork dates From September 14 to October 2, 2009.
Questionnaire Designed by the working team, and thereafter revised and adpated by Instituto DYM to
C.A.T.I. methodology
Language preference Questions have been formulated in Catalan or Spanish according to preference of
interviewed person.
Universe Population between15 and 74 (both included).
Span Catalonia
Sample selection Random sampling stratified by vegueries (regions) and habitat size. The person to be
interviewed within the household was chosen randomly among household members,
according to established quotas.
Quotas Quotas crossed by region (vegueries), habitat, gender and age, proportional to actual
population.
Final Sample 2614 interviews
Sample error margin +2,0% calculated for a reliability level of 95,5%, under the assumption of maximum
statistical indetermination (p=q=50%) according to the sample error formula for infinite
universes.
Data weighting The weighting of interviews have been equated to the established distribution, so as to
correct little deviations. Extra weighting has been introduced according to place of birth,
equating it to actual proportion in present demographic data.
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 3
4. TECHNICAL FILE
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND SELF-DETERMINATION
REFERENDUM REACTIONS
INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 4
5. DEMOCRACY, LAW AND
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND
SELF-DETERMINATION
SELF-DETERMINATION
In case a democratic decision clashed against the current laws, which do you think should prevail?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
NC = No Choice NA= No Answer
Current laws;
22%
NA; 1%
NC; 10%
Democratic
Principles
67%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 5
6. SELF-DETERMINATION IN GENERAL
Do you think the peoples of the world
have the right of self-determination, ie to
choose freely and democratically their
own political future?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
NC = No Choice NA= No Answer
In general
terms no
NC
6,5%
1,1%
It depends
3,5%
In general
terms yes
88,9%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 6
7. SELF-DETERMINATION IN GENERAL
Do the peoples of the world have the right
And in the case of Catalonia, does it have
of self-determination, ie. deciding their
the right of deciding freely and
own political future freely and
democratically its own political future?
democratically?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
NC = No Choice NA= No Answer
NC = No Choice NA= No Answer
NC 2,6%
NA 0,4%
No 14,4%
In general
terms no
6,5% NC
1,1%
It depends
3,5% In general
term s yes
88,9%
Yes 82,6%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 7
8. TECHNICAL FILE
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND SELF-DETERMINATION
REFERENDUM REACTIONS
INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 8
9. REFERENDUM BEHAVIOUR
In a democratic Referendum to decide the independence of Catalonia, what would you do?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
NA
NC 1,4%
Vote for
5,8%
50,3%
Abstention
/refrain from
voting
24,6%
Vote against
17,8%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 9
10. REFERENDUM BEHAVIOUR
In a democratic Referendum to decide the independence of Catalonia, what would you do?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
19,4
18,8
64,2 9,1
64,5 8,8
25,3
56,3
11,3
26,6
46,3
19,8
20,9
47,2 25,9
Percentages
voting for
independence
19,3
63,4 11,9
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 10
11. REFERENDUM BEHAVIOUR
In a democratic Referendum to decide the independence of Catalonia, what would you do?
BY PLACE OF BIRTH
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
No answer
5,5 4,8 3,3
8,4
No choice 21,1 24,3 30,7
31,1
14,9
Abstention / 25,4 11,8
refrain from
voting 26,2
Vote against
57,1 53,3
44,8
Vote for 32,6
Born in Catalonia In the rest of Spain in the rest of Europe In the rest of the World
Over average Under average
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 12
12. MOTIVES BEHIND REFERENDUM BEHAVIOUR
Which of the following motives would you allege to vote for / vote against / abstain in a democratic referendum to
decide Catalan independence?
MOTIVES TO VOTE FOR
Base: Vote for (1.376)
Peaceful/democratic
65,7
reasons
Economic motives 62,3
Feelings or beliefs 58,6
Language and
56,4
cultural reasons
Weariness of Spain 29,6
None of the above 0,9
No choice 0,5
No answer 0,1
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 13
13. MOTIVES BEHIND REFERENDUM BEHAVIOUR
Which of the following motives would you allege to vote for / vote against / abstain in a democratic referendum to
decide Catalan independence?
MOTIVES TO VOTE FOR MOTIVES TO VOTE AGAINST
Base: Vote for (1.376) Base: Vote against (438)
Peaceful/democratic Feelings or
65,7 60,8
reasons beliefs
Economically
Economic motives 62,3 29,3
unfeasible
Laws do not
Feelings or beliefs 58,6 25,9
allow it
Language and Scared of
56,4 25,7
cultural reasons conflict
None of the
Weariness of Spain 29,6 5,8
above
None of the above 0,9 No choice 0,9
No choice 0,5
No answer 0,1
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 14
14. MOTIVES BEHIND REFERENDUM BEHAVIOUR
Which of the following motives would you allege to vote for / vote against / abstain in a democratic referendum to
decide Catalan independence?
MOTIVES TO VOTE FOR MOTIVES TO VOTE AGAINST MOTIVES TO ABSTAIN
Base: Vote for (1.376) Base: Vote against (438) Base: Abstention (607)
Peaceful/democratic Feelings or Not my
65,7 60,8 38,4
reasons beliefs business
Economically Feelings or
29,2
Economic motives 62,3 29,3 beliefs
unfeasible
Scared of
Laws do not 25,7
Feelings or beliefs 58,6 25,9 conflict
allow it
Laws do not
Scared of 20,6
Language and allow it
56,4 25,7
cultural reasons conflict
Economically
18,5
None of the unfeasible
Weariness of Spain 29,6 5,8
above
None of the
13,9
above
None of the above 0,9 No choice 0,9
No choice 3,2
No choice 0,5
No answer 0,4
No answer 0,1
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 15
15. TECHNICAL FILE
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND SELF-DETERMINATION
REFERENDUM REACTIONS
INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 16
16. INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
In the case Catalonia became independent...
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
Do you think the situation of 2,4%
64,6% 29,0% 3,8%
Catalan language and culture... 0,2%
7,8%
Do you think social w elfare of 54,7% 27,6% 9,7% 0,3%
Catalans...
Do you think im m igration 30,4% 40,6% 13,1% 15,2% 0,6%
policies...
Would improve Would stay the same
Would worsen NC
NA
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 17
17. INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
Do you agree with the expression: “An
independent Catalonia could keep good
relations with Spain?”
1,8 2,4 3,8
100
16,9
90
80 37,8
70 59,8
60
NS/NC
50
81,3 En desacord
40 D’acord
58,4
30
20 37,8
10
0
A f avor En contra Abstenció
Referendum behaviour
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 18
18. INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
EUROPEAN UNION
Would you be for or against Catalonia being No choice; 1,2%
No answer; 0,4%
part of the European Union as any other Indifferent; 17,1%
member state?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
Against; 17,6%
For; 63,6%
Pensa que una Catalunya independent que
formés part de la Unió Europea defensaria
millor els interessos dels catalans que en la NS
situació actual? 8,1%
Base: Total entrevistes (2.614)
Si
No 71,1%
20,8%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 19
19. INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
EUROPEAN UNION
Would you be for or against Catalonia being No choice; 1,2%
No answer; 0,4%
part of the European Union as any other Indifferent; 17,1%
member state?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
Against; 17,6%
For; 63,6%
Do you think that an independent Catalonia
which were part of the European Union
would sustain Catalan interests better? NC
8,1%
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
Yes
No 71,1%
20,8%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 20
20. TECHNICAL FILE
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND SELF-DETERMINATION
REFERENDUM REACTIONS
INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 21
21. PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
Would you say the majority of citizens of Catalonia are rather in favour or against its independence?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
NA
0,5% Rather in favour
NC 43,4%
8,3%
Rather against
34,4% Half and half
13,4%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 22
22. PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
Would you say the majority of citizens of Catalonia are rather in favour or against its independence?
DISTRIBUTION ACCORDING TO REFERENDUM BEHAVIOUR
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
NA
6,9 8,2 9,4 15,0
22,2
NC
38,7 33,9
13,4
63,5
Rather in
favour 13,0
20,5
57,2
Half and half 10,7 38,2
29,9
16,9
Rather against
Perception of those voting Perception of those voting Perception of those Perception of NC/NA
for against abstaining
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 23
23. TECHNICAL FILE
DEMOCRACY, LAW AND SELF-DETERMINATION
REFERENDUM REACTIONS
INDEPENDENT CATALONIA SCENARIO
PERCEPTION OF INDEPENDENCE
FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 24
24. FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Do you think Catalonia will become independent some day?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
Yes
NA 31,1%
0,1%
NC
10,7%
No
58,1%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 25
25. FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Do you think Catalonia will become independent some day?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
DISTRIBUTION BY VEGUERIES OR REGIONS
5.4 9.7
30.4
37.4
59.9 7.7
56.4 40.2
52.1
11.4
29.5
59,0
14.7
38.1
11.4
26.7
47.2
61.8
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 26
26. FULFILLMENT AND TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
Do you think Catalonia will become independent some day?
Base: Total interviews (2.614)
BIRTHPLACE DISTRIBUTION
0,1 0 0 0
8,7 14,6 7,7
19,9
42,1
63 55,6 51,4
50,2
28,1 29,8 28,7
Born in Catalonia In the rest of Spain In the rest of Europe In the rest of the World
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 27
27. TIMING FOR INDEPENDENCE
When do you think Catalonia could become independent?
Base: will be independent some day (768)
In the next 5
years
NC NA
12,1%
4,1% 0,1%
In the next 20
years
41,8%
In the longer run
41,9%
Diagnòstic percepcions Catalunya – Espanya 28