The CLEANED R tool description https://cgspace.cgiar.org/handle/10568/78474 for the policy brief

1. Partner Logo
Partner
Logo
CLEANED R tool

2. CLEANED-R tool
• Landscape scale & spatially explicit
• Integration of open geographical
data to get quick context specific
data
• Based on 5 core module (production,
ghg, water, soil, biodiversity) and
simple exogenous land use change
module
• User interface in R-shiny
– Simple user with “vignettes”
– Advanced user
• Improvement and testing of the tool
within the ReSLeSS project

3. ResLess : CLEANED as an approach to social
learning

4. Resless components
• Economics
– Success factors as seen by the
community (more money is
not always better)
• Equity
– Understanding who is
marginalized and making sure
that marginalized group get a
voice in the learning space
• Environment
– CLEANED tool : understanding
the environmental impact of
interventions
=> INTEGRATION into the
learning space

5. Transformation Game :
enabling the learning space
Board game to
define scenarios
Number of
animals per
category
Feed baskets per
category
CLEANED
tool
Environmental score
card (generated
through CLEANED)
Stakeholder defined
socio-economic score
card
(generated through
discussions)
Renegotiation
of the scenario

6. Preliminary results from Burkina Faso
Scenario based on the pastoral vision
Baseline Initial Negotiated Diff. with initial
Vign. Number Vign. Number Vign. Number Vignettes Number
A (tr*) ABR 100 GT
238 PT
ABR 300 ST
200 LT
ABR 300 ST
200 LT
0 0
0
L (tr) LBR 200 LBR 300 L1 300 + 0
D (an*) DBR 1’400 D1 2’400 D2 1’400 + - 1000
F (an) FBR 55’000 FBR 110’000 F1 110’000 + 0
T (an) TBR 22’500 T1 23’000 T1 17’000 0 -5000
Total 123’460 201’400 194’400

7. Preliminary results from Burkina Faso
Environmental score cards
Productivity measure Initial Negotiated Change
Meat produced (tons) + 83 + 83 0
Milk produced (tons) + 57 + 31.6 -
Cropland used (ha) + 57 + 51 -
Grazing land used (ha) + 56 + 49 -
Rice area used (ha) + 100 + 100 0
Environmental indicators Initial Negotiated Change
water
Total + 60 + 52 -
Per animal - 1.4 - 1.7 -
Greenhous
e gases
Total + 61 + 57.5 -
Per animal + 0.2 + 1.5 +
Nitrogen + 31 + 27 -
All values are in
percentage change
compared to the base
run

8. Preliminary results from Burkina Faso
Socio-economic score card
Socio- economic indicators Score initial
scenario
Score negoc.
scenario
change
Improved breeds, infrastructures and services Low High ++
To be generous and helpful Medium Medium 0
Children go to school without hunger High High 0
Land rights are well defined High Medium to
high
-
Incomes are diversified Medium to
high
High +
Pastoralist household own two herds at any
time
High Medium -

9. Burkina Faso preliminary results
Identified trade-off and synergies
• Agreement in a long lasting conflict
between agro-pastoralists and mixed
crop livestock farmer could be found
– Agro-pastoralist will not intensify their
livestock production and relay in
natural grass.
– Crop farmers will get better breeds
and will feed them with planted
fodder.
– Tractors will replace some of the draft
animals
• More production and more
environmental impacts are necessary
to reach the socio-economic
objectives.

10. Reflection from the Burkina Faso learning
space
CLEANED tool as a boundary
object :
• Enables the learning space
• Entry point to discuss
environmental impacts
• “neutral participant” that all
conflicting parties could
agree on

11. This presentation is licensed for use under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Licence.
better lives through livestock
ilri.org
ILRI thanks all donors and organizations which globally support its work through their contributions to
the CGIAR system