SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 11
Central to the Qu’ranic teaching is the
promotion of justice, which leads to peace
              and harmony.

Kamali says that the purpose of the Prophet’s mission
was not only mercy to mankind, but to all of God’s
creatures.

He says that in order to attain these objectives, which
constitute the component parts of mercy, we must
educate the individual, establish justice, and realize
benefit (maslahah) for the people.

We must follow the Rules on Counter-Values in Islamic
Finance to create justice.

Both counter-values must be certain and may either
occur both at the time of transaction or one now and
one later, however, not both in the future.

In the case of riba, the variance in certitude between the
two counter-values, the interest on the one hand and
the opportunity cost on the other hand, constitutes the
essence of the injustice of imposing interest on loans.

The increase over the principal, the common form of
which is bank interest, is certain and its amount is
known whereas the yield resulting from investing the
loan by the creditor is not sure to materialize and if it
does, its amount is not ascertainable in advance.

In a contract, which contains gharar, such as a contract
based on speculative activities, the contract may
include a counter-value, which is not only of uncertain
value, but may not be realized at all.

In both riba and gharar, one of the counter-values is
uncertain and may never materialize and both are
therefore invalid under Shari'ah.

Riba is an extreme form of gharar.

Islamic finance today primarily uses debt-finance,
which replicates the results of Interest-Financing rather
than using equity-finance, which promotes justice.

 Asyraf Wajdi Dusuki states that (2010): ‘In contrast to debt-
  financing, equity-financing utilizes a profit-loss sharing
  mechanism based on the contribution of capital in the project or
  investment.’

 Dusuki says that (2010): In equity- based financing, both the
  borrower and lender share profits and losses as compared to
  the case of debt- financing, where one party is made to take all
  the risk.’

 Dusuki explains that (2010): It also promotes expansion of the
  economy including the development of small- to -medium
  sized businesses in addition to large enterprises and promotes
  stability in the economy and society at large.’

Equity- financing fulfills the essence of Shari’ah requirements
in Islamic banking and finance as it fulfills the counter- value
(iwadh).

For a contract to be valid, there should be Iwadh or counter-
value present. Three elements of iwadh that should exist are
risk (ghorm), work and effort (ikhtiar) and liability (daman).

In the majority of debt- financing contracts, one or more of
these elements of Iwadh are missing. If there is no risk, effort
and liability, then such a contract cannot be considered to
contain any element of justice.'

Bank as a Finance House Rather than Loan House
The Islamic Banking and Finance Industry, which exists today is a sham.
There is nothing moral about it. It does not encompass any of the ideals of the
Islamic moral economy and has become just another branch of the
conventional banking system, imitating its products and services and dishing
out interest in disguised forms.
                                    
It is debt-based and produces similar outcomes as interest-based financing.

Shari’ah is not the base and the Tawhid (One-God) Framework is not being
utilized.

The modes of finance are not musharakah and mudharabah and thus a
participatory superstructure in society does not result.

The debt finance base of Islamic finance and banking creates the same debt-
trap superstructure encapsulating the neo-classical individual in his own
misery, which exists in the conventional economy.

The bank remains a loan house rather than finance house to the detriment of
the well-being of humanity.

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Counter-Values in Islamic Finance

Introduction to Islamic Finance
Introduction to Islamic Finance Introduction to Islamic Finance
Introduction to Islamic Finance
camillesillapaldi
 
The influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmes
The influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmesThe influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmes
The influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmes
malfofa
 
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistanCredit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Alexander Decker
 
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistanCredit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Alexander Decker
 
Islamic finance ov
Islamic finance ovIslamic finance ov
Islamic finance ov
SittiJhoe MG
 
Global crisis and islamic finance banking
Global crisis and islamic finance bankingGlobal crisis and islamic finance banking
Global crisis and islamic finance banking
Pir Irshad Ahmed
 

Ähnlich wie Counter-Values in Islamic Finance (20)

Introduction to Islamic Finance
Introduction to Islamic Finance Introduction to Islamic Finance
Introduction to Islamic Finance
 
The influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmes
The influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmesThe influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmes
The influence of faith on islamic microfinance programmes
 
ISLAMIC_BANKING_AND_DEVELOPMENT_March_2005_IN_HASSAN_AND_LEWIS_HANDBOOK.pdf
ISLAMIC_BANKING_AND_DEVELOPMENT_March_2005_IN_HASSAN_AND_LEWIS_HANDBOOK.pdfISLAMIC_BANKING_AND_DEVELOPMENT_March_2005_IN_HASSAN_AND_LEWIS_HANDBOOK.pdf
ISLAMIC_BANKING_AND_DEVELOPMENT_March_2005_IN_HASSAN_AND_LEWIS_HANDBOOK.pdf
 
FINANCING_INTER_TRADE.pdf
FINANCING_INTER_TRADE.pdfFINANCING_INTER_TRADE.pdf
FINANCING_INTER_TRADE.pdf
 
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistanCredit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
 
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistanCredit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
Credit risk assessment and management practices in islamic banks of pakistan
 
The Role of Financial Institution According to Islamic Framework
The Role of Financial Institution According to Islamic FrameworkThe Role of Financial Institution According to Islamic Framework
The Role of Financial Institution According to Islamic Framework
 
3[1]
3[1]3[1]
3[1]
 
Islamic finance ov
Islamic finance ovIslamic finance ov
Islamic finance ov
 
Global crisis and islamic finance banking
Global crisis and islamic finance bankingGlobal crisis and islamic finance banking
Global crisis and islamic finance banking
 
Global Fin Crisis Islamic Perspective.pdf
Global Fin Crisis Islamic Perspective.pdfGlobal Fin Crisis Islamic Perspective.pdf
Global Fin Crisis Islamic Perspective.pdf
 
A Comparative Literature Survey Of Islamic Finance And Banking
A Comparative Literature Survey Of Islamic Finance And BankingA Comparative Literature Survey Of Islamic Finance And Banking
A Comparative Literature Survey Of Islamic Finance And Banking
 
In search of islamic financial system p 2
In search of islamic financial system p 2In search of islamic financial system p 2
In search of islamic financial system p 2
 
Islamic Banking Lec 05.pdf
Islamic Banking Lec 05.pdfIslamic Banking Lec 05.pdf
Islamic Banking Lec 05.pdf
 
Maqasid shariah
Maqasid shariahMaqasid shariah
Maqasid shariah
 
Challenges facing the development of islamic banking
Challenges facing the development of islamic bankingChallenges facing the development of islamic banking
Challenges facing the development of islamic banking
 
Islamic banking
Islamic bankingIslamic banking
Islamic banking
 
File
FileFile
File
 
Islamic banking
Islamic bankingIslamic banking
Islamic banking
 
19. infrastructure project financing through sukuk as
19. infrastructure project financing through sukuk as19. infrastructure project financing through sukuk as
19. infrastructure project financing through sukuk as
 

Counter-Values in Islamic Finance

  • 1. Central to the Qu’ranic teaching is the promotion of justice, which leads to peace and harmony.
  • 2.  Kamali says that the purpose of the Prophet’s mission was not only mercy to mankind, but to all of God’s creatures.
  • 3.  He says that in order to attain these objectives, which constitute the component parts of mercy, we must educate the individual, establish justice, and realize benefit (maslahah) for the people.
  • 4.  We must follow the Rules on Counter-Values in Islamic Finance to create justice. Both counter-values must be certain and may either occur both at the time of transaction or one now and one later, however, not both in the future.
  • 5.  In the case of riba, the variance in certitude between the two counter-values, the interest on the one hand and the opportunity cost on the other hand, constitutes the essence of the injustice of imposing interest on loans. The increase over the principal, the common form of which is bank interest, is certain and its amount is known whereas the yield resulting from investing the loan by the creditor is not sure to materialize and if it does, its amount is not ascertainable in advance.
  • 6.  In a contract, which contains gharar, such as a contract based on speculative activities, the contract may include a counter-value, which is not only of uncertain value, but may not be realized at all. In both riba and gharar, one of the counter-values is uncertain and may never materialize and both are therefore invalid under Shari'ah. Riba is an extreme form of gharar.
  • 7.  Islamic finance today primarily uses debt-finance, which replicates the results of Interest-Financing rather than using equity-finance, which promotes justice.
  • 8.   Asyraf Wajdi Dusuki states that (2010): ‘In contrast to debt- financing, equity-financing utilizes a profit-loss sharing mechanism based on the contribution of capital in the project or investment.’  Dusuki says that (2010): In equity- based financing, both the borrower and lender share profits and losses as compared to the case of debt- financing, where one party is made to take all the risk.’  Dusuki explains that (2010): It also promotes expansion of the economy including the development of small- to -medium sized businesses in addition to large enterprises and promotes stability in the economy and society at large.’
  • 9.  Equity- financing fulfills the essence of Shari’ah requirements in Islamic banking and finance as it fulfills the counter- value (iwadh). For a contract to be valid, there should be Iwadh or counter- value present. Three elements of iwadh that should exist are risk (ghorm), work and effort (ikhtiar) and liability (daman). In the majority of debt- financing contracts, one or more of these elements of Iwadh are missing. If there is no risk, effort and liability, then such a contract cannot be considered to contain any element of justice.'
  • 10.  Bank as a Finance House Rather than Loan House
  • 11. The Islamic Banking and Finance Industry, which exists today is a sham. There is nothing moral about it. It does not encompass any of the ideals of the Islamic moral economy and has become just another branch of the conventional banking system, imitating its products and services and dishing out interest in disguised forms.  It is debt-based and produces similar outcomes as interest-based financing. Shari’ah is not the base and the Tawhid (One-God) Framework is not being utilized. The modes of finance are not musharakah and mudharabah and thus a participatory superstructure in society does not result. The debt finance base of Islamic finance and banking creates the same debt- trap superstructure encapsulating the neo-classical individual in his own misery, which exists in the conventional economy. The bank remains a loan house rather than finance house to the detriment of the well-being of humanity.