SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 115
1
Extracellular Matrix Control of Tumor
            Cell Metabolism

                Joan Brugge

             Department of Cell
                  Biology

           Harvard Medical School
Anchorage Dependence of Normal Cells
  and Independence of TUmor Cells
                 Normal Epithelial Cells


                                           Detach from
                                             matrix
     Martin
   Schwartz                 Adapted from Geiger and Peeper, Cancer
                      Monolayer
  Steve Frisch
                                    Res 2005; 65: 7033-36.
                                                                     Suspension
Anchorage Dependence of Normal Cells
  and Independence of TUmor Cells
                 Normal Epithelial Cells                      Tumor Cells


                                           Detach from
                                             matrix
     Martin
   Schwartz                 Adapted from Geiger and Peeper, Cancer
                      Monolayer
  Steve Frisch
                                    Res 2005; 65: 7033-36.
                                                                     Suspension
Anchorage Dependence of Normal Cells
  and Independence of TUmor Cells
                   Normal Epithelial Cells                       Tumor Cells


                                             Detach from
                                               matrix
     Martin
   Schwartz                   Adapted from Geiger and Peeper, Cancer
                        Monolayer
  Steve Frisch
                                      Res 2005; 65: 7033-36.
                                                                       Suspension




                     Normal Cells                              Tumor Cells



  MacPherson and
  Montagnier
  1964
                     Soft agar                                 Soft agar
In Early Tumorigenesis, Excess Proliferation
 Displaces Cells from Their Normal Niches


                                  Laminin




                           DCIS




                                            Laminin




                                            4
Cells from non-glandular tumors also
   displaced from natural matrix
            attachment




                                 5
Tumors Cells Encounter Foreign Matrix
             Environments during Invasion and
                         Metastasis




                                Text


(Image from Merck Biosciences          www.youtube.com/watch?v=5L6lHfgL10Y
Tumors Cells Encounter Foreign Matrix
             Environments during Invasion and
                         Metastasis




                             Text
                           The pathways that allow tumor cells to survive
                         outside their niches provide attractive targets for
                                       therapeutic intervention
(Image from Merck Biosciences                                  www.youtube.com/watch?v=5L6lHfgL10Y
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

MCF-10A cells/HMECs
                                 Full medium + serum,
     Suspension                  EGF, insulin,
     culture                     hydrocortisone
                      Polyhema




     Mauricio
     Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                                 Caspase3
MCF-10A cells/HMECs
                                    Full medium + serum,
     Suspension                     EGF, insulin,
     culture                        hydrocortisone
                      Polyhema
                                            Apoptosis




     Mauricio
     Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                                   Caspase3
MCF-10A cells/HMECs
                                        Full medium + serum,
     Suspension                         EGF, insulin,
     culture                            hydrocortisone
                      Polyhema
                                               Apoptosis




                       Integrin

                                       EGFR
                                 Erk
     Mauricio                    Akt
     Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                                  Caspase3
MCF-10A cells/HMECs
                                        Full medium + serum,
     Suspension                         EGF, insulin,
     culture                            hydrocortisone
                      Polyhema
                                               Apoptosis




                         Integrin

                                        EGFR
                                 pErk
     Mauricio                    pAkt
     Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                                  Caspase3
MCF-10A cells/HMECs
                                        Full medium + serum,
     Suspension                         EGF, insulin,
     culture                            hydrocortisone
                      Polyhema
                                               Apoptosis




                         Integrin

                                        EGFR
                                 pErk
     Mauricio                    pAkt
     Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                                 Caspase3
MCF-10A cells/HMECs
                                    Full medium + serum,
     Suspension                     EGF, insulin,
     culture                        hydrocortisone
                      Polyhema
                                            Apoptosis




                         Integrin

                                    EGFR


     Mauricio
     Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                                 Caspase3
MCF-10A cells/HMECs
                                    Full medium + serum,
     Suspension                     EGF, insulin,
     culture                        hydrocortisone
                      Polyhema
                                            Apoptosis




                                                Proapototic    Bim


                         Integrin              Anti-apototic   Bcl-2

                                    EGFR


     Mauricio
     Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence




                   MCF-10A cells



3D basement
membrane
cultures




      Mauricio
      Reginato
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence




                   MCF-10A cells



3D basement
membrane
cultures




      Mauricio                                   Jay
      Reginato                                   Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence




                   MCF-10A cells



3D basement
membrane
cultures




                               Laminin
      Mauricio                                   Jay
      Reginato                                   Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence




                   MCF-10A cells



3D basement
membrane
cultures




                    phosphoAKT
                    (phospho mTor,   Laminin
      Mauricio                                   Jay
                    phosphoFKHD)
      Reginato                                   Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence




                       MCF-10A cells



3D basement
membrane
cultures




                        phosphoAKT
                 Erk    (phospho mTor,   Laminin
      Mauricio                                     Jay
                 Akt    phosphoFKHD)
      Reginato                                     Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence




                       MCF-10A cells



3D basement
membrane
cultures




                        phosphoAKT
                                         Laminin   Caspase3
                 Erk    (phospho mTor,
      Mauricio                                                Jay
                 Akt    phosphoFKHD)
      Reginato                                                Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                                      Caspase3


     Suspension
     culture            MCF-10A cells
                                                 Apoptosis

3D basement
membrane
cultures




                         phosphoAKT
                                          Laminin      Caspase3
                  Erk    (phospho mTor,
      Mauricio                                                    Jay
                  Akt    phosphoFKHD)
      Reginato                                                    Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                            Caspase3


     Suspension
     culture       MCF-10A cells
                                       Apoptosis

3D basement
membrane
                                         Bcl-2
cultures




      Mauricio                                     Jay
      Reginato                                     Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                            Caspase3


     Suspension
     culture       MCF-10A cells
                                       Apoptosis

3D basement
membrane
                                         Bcl-2
cultures




      Mauricio                                     Jay
      Reginato                                     Debnath
Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence

                            Caspase3


     Suspension
     culture       MCF-10A cells
                                       Apoptosis   Autophagy


3D basement
membrane
                                         Bcl-2
cultures




      Mauricio                                       Jay
      Reginato                                       Debnath
Is autophagy associated with a
                           reduction in ATP?

      Cells suspended in
      complete medium with
      EGF, serum, etc.




Alex
Grassian




           Zach
           Schafer
Is autophagy associated with a
                           reduction in ATP?

      Cells suspended in
      complete medium with
      EGF, serum, etc.




Alex
Grassian




           Zach
           Schafer
Is autophagy associated with a
                           reduction in ATP?

      Cells suspended in
      complete medium with
      EGF, serum, etc.




Alex
Grassian




           Zach
           Schafer
Detached Cells Show Severe Reduction in
            Glucose Uptake and Exogenous Pyruvate Can
                     Rescue the ATP Defiency
30000
               Glucose Uptake
25000
                 p=1.08 x 10-5
20000

15000

10000

 5000

    0
         Detached                Attached




Zach Schafer
Detached Cells Show Severe Reduction in
            Glucose Uptake and Exogenous Pyruvate Can
                     Rescue the ATP Defiency
30000
               Glucose Uptake
25000
                 p=1.08 x 10-5
20000

15000

10000

 5000

    0
         Detached                Attached




                                                  12

Zach Schafer
Detached Cells Show Severe Reduction in
            Glucose Uptake and Exogenous Pyruvate Can
                     Rescue the ATP Defiency
                                                                     glucose



                                                           X
30000
               Glucose Uptake
25000
                 p=1.08 x 10-5
20000

15000

10000
                                            glucose-6P

                                                           X
 5000

    0
         Detached                Attached
                                             Glycolysis
                                                           X                   methyl
                                                                                             methyl
                                                                                             pyruvate

                                                          pyruvate
                                                                               pyruvate




                                                           TCA
                                                                                             TCA
                                                           cycle
                                                                                          12 cycle

Zach Schafer
Fate of Glucose
                              glucose

                                           Glucose
                                           transporters

                              glucose-6P


           G6P Isomerase



          Glycolysis
             ATP
Lactate     Pyruvate + NADH




                   TCA
                   cycle
                                                          13
                   ATP
Fate of Glucose
                               glucose

                                               Glucose
                                               transporters

                               glucose-6P


                                         G6P Dehydrogenase
           G6P Isomerase


                                  Pentose Phosphate
          Glycolysis              Pathway
             ATP
Lactate     Pyruvate + NADH
                              NADPH- anti-oxidant


                   TCA
                   cycle
                                                              13
                   ATP
Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could
     Contribute to ROS Production


                             glucose



                         X
                             glucose-6P


        G6P Isomerase



       Glycolysis
                        X X            G6P Dehydrogenase



                                Pentose Phosphate
                                Pathway

        ATP                             ROS?
                                                           Zach Schafer
Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could
     Contribute to ROS Production


                             glucose



                         X
                             glucose-6P


        G6P Isomerase



       Glycolysis
                        X X            G6P Dehydrogenase



                                Pentose Phosphate
                                Pathway

        ATP                             ROS?
                                                           Zach Schafer
Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could
                          Contribute to ROS Production
               13000
                           ROS Levels - carboxy- H2 DCF-DA
               12000

                11000
ROS levels (a.u.)




               10000

                    9000

                    8000
                                                                         glucose



                                                                     X
                    7000

                    6000

                    5000
                             10A          Bcl-2     Attached
                                   Detached


                                                                         glucose-6P


                                                    G6P Isomerase



                                                  Glycolysis
                                                                    X X            G6P Dehydrogenase



                                                                            Pentose Phosphate
                                                                            Pathway

                                                     ATP                            ROS?
                                                                                                       Zach Schafer
Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could
                           Contribute to ROS Production
                13000
                            ROS Levels - carboxy- H2 DCF-DA
                12000

                 11000
 ROS levels (a.u.)




                10000

                     9000

                     8000
                                                                          glucose



                                                                      X
                     7000

                     6000

                     5000
                              10A          Bcl-2     Attached
                                    Detached


                                                                          glucose-6P
Also detected increase in



                                                                     X X
oxidized glutathione
                                                                                    G6P Dehydrogenase
                                                     G6P Isomerase


                                                                             Pentose Phosphate
                                                   Glycolysis                Pathway

                                                      ATP                            ROS?
                                                                                                        Zach Schafer
Multiple Death Processes Ass’d with
        Matrix Detachment




                         LC3-GFP




                    Metabolic Impairment
     Apoptosis             ATP
                           15
                           ROS?
Matrix-Deprived Cells in Center of 3D Structures


   MCF-10 cells                        laminin
Matrix-Deprived Cells in Center of 3D Structures


   MCF-10 cells                        laminin




   Apoptosis




  Caspase3*
Matrix-Deprived Cells in Center of 3D Structures


   MCF-10 cells                        laminin




   Apoptosis        Autophagy




  Caspase3*
Two Photon NAD(P)H Fluorescence
Loling
Song




                                                                           17
         Since NADH is the principal electron donor in glycolytic and oxidative
         energy metabolism, it represents a non-invasive fluorescent reporter of the
         metabolic state
Oxidative Stress in Acini




                                                                        DCF-DA
                                                                            d7



carboxy-H2DCFDA cell-permeant indicator for reactive oxygen species that is retained
in the cell after deacetylation and is nonfluorescent until oxidation occurs within the
cell
Oxidative Stress in Acini




                                                                        DCF-DA
                                                                              d7



carboxy-H2DCFDA cell-permeant indicator for reactive oxygen species that is retained
in the cell after deacetylation and is nonfluorescent until oxidation occurs within the
cell
                                                                         18
Similar Features of Matrix Detached
      Cells and Inner Cells of 3D Structures




        Autophagy       Elevated    Elevated


Metabolic Impairment    Low ATP    Lower NADH

          ROS          Elevated     Elevated

         Apoptosis         ++++       ++++
                                                19
         Entosis           +++++       +
Similar Features of Matrix Detached
      Cells and Inner Cells of 3D Structures




        Autophagy       Elevated    Elevated    What are the
                                                implications of
Metabolic Impairment    Low ATP    Lower NADH   these findings
                                                for
          ROS          Elevated     Elevated    tumorigenesis?

         Apoptosis         ++++       ++++
                                                   19
         Entosis           +++++       +
Survival of HyperproliferativeTumor Cells

Apoptosis                 Anti-apoptotic
                             activity




                        Text     Rescue
 Metabolic
                                Metabolic
Impairment
                               Impairment


             Low ATP
             High ROS




                                            20
Survival of HyperproliferativeTumor Cells

Apoptosis                 Anti-apoptotic
                             activity




                        Text     Rescue
 Metabolic
                                Metabolic
Impairment
                               Impairment


             Low ATP
             High ROS
                                 How?

                                            20
ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in
        Suspended Cells




                                    ext




                              21
ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in
           Suspended Cells




                                       ext


Glucose uptake




                                 21
ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in
           Suspended Cells




                                       ext

                    ROS
Glucose uptake




                                 21
ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in
           Suspended Cells




                                 + ErbB2   ext

                    ROS
Glucose uptake
                               Ras     PI3K

                                Mek
                                       Akt
                               Erk
                                 21
ErbB2 Rescue of ATP in Suspension is
       Suppressed by 2-DG
                                               glucose
                                                2-deoxyglucose




                                               glucose
                                                2-deoxyglucose



                       Glycolysis
                                     X
                                    pyruvate




                                     TCA
                                     cycle


                                                    Zach Schafer
ErbB2 Rescue of ATP in Suspension is
       Suppressed by 2-DG
                                               glucose
                                                2-deoxyglucose




                                               glucose
                                                2-deoxyglucose



                       Glycolysis
                                     X
                                    pyruvate




                                     TCA
                                     cycle
                                                22
                                                     Zach Schafer
Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic
    Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells

                                    glucose uptake
                                    ATP

                                    ROS




                  ErbB2
       Rescues glucose uptake
         • Restores glycolysis

         • Restores PPP - anti-Ox             23
Effects of Loss of Glucose Uptake

                          glucose



                      X
                          glucose-6P


     G6P Isomerase



    Glycolysis
                     X X            G6P Dehydrogenase



                             Pentose Phosphate
                             Pathway

     ATP                             ROS?



                                                        Zach Schafer
Effects of Loss of Glucose Uptake

                          glucose



                      X
                          glucose-6P


     G6P Isomerase



    Glycolysis
                     X X            G6P Dehydrogenase



                             Pentose Phosphate
                             Pathway

     ATP                             ROS?

                      WHAT IF ADD ANTI-OXIDANT

                      TO SUSPENDED CONTROL
                      CELLS?                            Zach Schafer
Antioxidant Treatment Leads to
Enhanced ATP Levels in Detached Cells

                    anti-oxidant




          Low ATP                   Elevated ATP



               10A




        1 mM                   50 uM
                                                   Superoxide
                               Vitamin E
                               Vitamin E           dismutase
                               analog
                               analog              mimic
Antioxidant Treatment Leads to
Enhanced ATP Levels in Detached Cells

                    anti-oxidant




          Low ATP                   Elevated ATP



               10A




        1 mM                   50 uM
                                                   Superoxide
                               Vitamin E
                               Vitamin E           dismutase
                               analog
                               analog              mimic
Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic
    Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells

                                 glucose uptake
                                 ATP

                                 ROS




           ErbB2               Anti-Oxidant
Rescues glucose uptake       Does not rescue glucose uptake

  • Restores glycolysis

  • Restores PPP - anti-Ox
                                                26
Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic
    Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells

                                 glucose uptake
                                 ATP

                                 ROS




           ErbB2               Anti-Oxidant
Rescues glucose uptake       Does not rescue glucose uptake

  • Restores glycolysis
                                   How do anti-
  • Restores PPP - anti-Ox        oxidants rescue
                                    ATP levels?26
Alternate Energy Pathways
        Glucose




 Glycolysis

         ATP

     pyruvate




                 PDH
           Acetyl
           CoA

                                                Ciitrate

                    OAA
                          TCA
                          cycle
                
                Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                           27
                                                                A
Alternate Energy Pathways
        Glucose
                                                Oxidizable
                                                substrates



                                                    Macromolecular
 Glycolysis                                         degradation

         ATP                         Oxidizable
                                     substrates

     pyruvate




                                     Oxidizable
                 PDH                 substrates
           Acetyl
           CoA

                                                 Ciitrate

                    OAA
                          TCA
                          cycle
                
                Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                                     27
                                                                          A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
   OXIDATION
                                           OAA
                                                 TCA
                                                 cycle
                                       
                                       Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                                                            27
Craig Thompson                                                                                   A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
   OXIDATION
                                           OAA
                                                 TCA
                                                 cycle
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                                                            27
Craig Thompson                                                                                   A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
   OXIDATION
                                           OAA
                                                 TCA
                                                 cycle
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                                                            27
Craig Thompson                                                                                   A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
   OXIDATION
                                           OAA
                                                 TCA
                                                 cycle
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                                                                 27
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
                                                                                            • Upregulation of FAO mRN
   OXIDATION                                                                                  program
                                           OAA
                                                 TCA
                                                 cycle
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                                                                 27
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
                                                                                            • Upregulation of FAO mRN
   OXIDATION                                                                                  program
                                           OAA                                              • FAO not sustained in
                                                 TCA                                          suspended cells
                                                 cycle
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200
                                                                                                 27
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
                                                                                            • Upregulation of FAO mRN
   OXIDATION                                                                                  program
                                           OAA                                              • FAO not sustained in
                                                 TCA                                          suspended cells
                                                 cycle
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200                              ATP 27
                                                                                                 Levels Fall!
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates

                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
                                                                                            • Upregulation of FAO mRN
   OXIDATION                                                                                  program
                                           OAA                                              • FAO not sustained in
                                                 TCA                                          suspended cells
                                                 cycle                                      Anti-oxidants rescue
                                                                                              FAO
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200                              ATP 27
                                                                                            ATP Levels Fall!
                                                                                                 Restored!
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates




                                                             X           ROS
                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
                                                                                            • Upregulation of FAO mRN
   OXIDATION                                                                                  program
                                           OAA                                              • FAO not sustained in
                                                 TCA                                          suspended cells
                                                 cycle                                      Anti-oxidants rescue
                                                                                              FAO
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200                              ATP 27
                                                                                            ATP Levels Fall!
                                                                                                 Restored!
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates




                                                             X           ROS           Anti-Ox
                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
                                                                                            • Upregulation of FAO mRN
   OXIDATION                                                                                  program
                                           OAA                                              • FAO not sustained in
                                                 TCA                                          suspended cells
                                                 cycle                                      Anti-oxidants rescue
                                                                                              FAO
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200                              ATP 27
                                                                                            ATP Levels Fall!
                                                                                                 Restored!
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Alternate Energy Pathways
                               Glucose
                                                                       Oxidizable
                                                                       substrates




                        Glycolysis
                                       X                                   Macromolecular
                                                                           degradation

                                ATP                         Oxidizable
                                                            substrates


                                                                                       Anti-Ox
                            pyruvate
          Glucose
          deprivation

                                                            Oxidizable
                                        PDH                 substrates                      •Loss of glucose transport
                                  Acetyl
   Upregulate                     CoA
   FATTY ACID                                                           Ciitrate
                                                                                            • Upregulation of FAO mRN
   OXIDATION                                                                                  program
                                           OAA                                              • FAO not sustained in
                                                 TCA                                          suspended cells
                                                 cycle                                      Anti-oxidants rescue
                                                                                              FAO
                                       
   ATP maintained                      Adapted from DeRobertis et al
                                       Cell Metabolism 2008200                              ATP 27
                                                                                            ATP Levels Fall!
                                                                                                 Restored!
Craig Thompson                                                                                                       A
Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic
    Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells

                                 glucose uptake
                                 ATP

                                 ROS




           ErbB2               Anti-Oxidant
Rescues glucose uptake       Does not rescue glucose uptake

  • Restores glycolysis         • Restores fatty acid oxidation

  • Restores PPP - anti-Ox
                                                28
Can Anti-Oxidant Affect
Morphogenesis In 3D Cultures?




    Apoptosis               NAD(P)H
                                      ROS
                                      DFC-DA



                Autophagy             29
Trolox Reduces NAD(P)H Dichotomy
 Between the Inner and Outer Cells




                               30
Anti-Oxidants Increase Luminal Filling

          Clear                Mostly Clear          Mostly Filled               Filled




                  Blue: DAPI   Red: Laminin V   Green: Cleaved Caspase-3




Control   56.7%                    26.7%               13.3%                     3.3%




                                                                           ROS
NAc                                                                          38.1%
          4.8%                     4.8%                 52.4%
Trolox    7.4%                     14.8%               48.1%                 29.6%

                                                                                     Zach Schafer
Trolox Also Increases Anchorage-Independent
             Colony Formation in Soft Agar

          MCF10A
HPV-E7          Bcl-2

     Rb       Blocks
  p27, p21   apoptosis



Hyperproliferation




                                           32
Trolox Also Increases Anchorage-Independent
             Colony Formation in Soft Agar

          MCF10A
HPV-E7          Bcl-2

     Rb       Blocks
  p27, p21   apoptosis



Hyperproliferation




                                           32
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in
                        tumor
                   suppressors and
                      oncogenes
                   Lead to
              hyperproliferation
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants
   Protective
 against DNA,
protein and lipid
    damage




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in
                        tumor
                   suppressors and
                      oncogenes
                   Lead to
              hyperproliferation
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k
                               ec
protein and lipid            ch

    damage




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in
                        tumor
                   suppressors and
                      oncogenes
                   Lead to
              hyperproliferation
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k
                               ec
protein and lipid            ch

    damage




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in
                        tumor
                   suppressors and
                      oncogenes
                   Lead to
              hyperproliferation
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k
                               ec
protein and lipid            ch

    damage




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in
                        tumor
                   suppressors and
                      oncogenes
                   Lead to
              hyperproliferation
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k
                               ec
protein and lipid            ch

    damage                       If anti-apop

                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in
                        tumor
                   suppressors and
                      oncogenes
                   Lead to
              hyperproliferation
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k
                               ec
protein and lipid            ch

    damage                       If anti-apop

                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in               Loss of glucose
                        tumor                       uptake
                   suppressors and              Increase in ROS
                      oncogenes
                   Lead to
              hyperproliferation
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k
                               ec
protein and lipid            ch

    damage                       If anti-apop

                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in               Loss of glucose
                        tumor                       uptake
                   suppressors and              Increase in ROS
                      oncogenes              Ros inhibits use of
                                            other substrates like
                   Lead to                      fatty acids by
              hyperproliferation              suppression FAO
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k
                               ec
protein and lipid            ch

    damage                       If anti-apop

                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in               Loss of glucose
                        tumor                       uptake
                   suppressors and              Increase in ROS
                      oncogenes              Ros inhibits use of
                                            other substrates like
                   Lead to                      fatty acids by
              hyperproliferation              suppression FAO
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k                                                 es
                               ec                                                cu
                             ch                                              res
protein and lipid                                                       ha
                                                                           t
                                                                               ke
                                                                     e t upta
    damage                                                        gen e
                                 If anti-apop                O nco lucos
                                                                   g
                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress
                     Mutations in               Loss of glucose
                        tumor                       uptake
                   suppressors and              Increase in ROS
                      oncogenes              Ros inhibits use of
                                            other substrates like
                   Lead to                      fatty acids by
              hyperproliferation              suppression FAO
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k                                                 es
                               ec                                                cu
                             ch                                              res
protein and lipid                                                       ha
                                                                           t
                                                                               ke
                                                                     e t upta
    damage                                                        gen e
                                 If anti-apop                O nco lucos
                                                                   g
                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress                                                  Anti-oxidant
                     Mutations in                                   program
                                                Loss of glucose
                        tumor                       uptake
                   suppressors and              Increase in ROS
                      oncogenes              Ros inhibits use of
                                            other substrates like
                   Lead to                      fatty acids by
              hyperproliferation              suppression FAO
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k                                                 es
                               ec                                                cu
                             ch                                              res
protein and lipid                                                       ha
                                                                           t
                                                                               ke
                                                                     e t upta
    damage                                                        gen e
                                 If anti-apop                O nco lucos
                                                                   g
                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress                                                  Anti-oxidant
                     Mutations in                                   program
                                                Loss of glucose
                        tumor                       uptake
                                                                             Cell generate ATP
                   suppressors and              Increase in ROS                through FAO
                      oncogenes              Ros inhibits use of
                                            other substrates like
                   Lead to                      fatty acids by
              hyperproliferation              suppression FAO
Potential Implications: Dichotomous
         Activity of Anti-Oxidants
  Anti-oxidants                         ic  t
                                      ot tac
                                    pt in
   Protective                     po ts
                                a in
 against DNA,                If po
                                 k                                                 es
                               ec                                                cu
                             ch                                              res
protein and lipid                                                       ha
                                                                           t
                                                                               ke
                                                                     e t upta
    damage                                                        gen e
                                 If anti-apop                O nco lucos
                                                                   g
                               checkpoints lost




Oxidative stress                                                  Anti-oxidant
                     Mutations in                                   program
                                                Loss of glucose
                        tumor                       uptake
                                                                             Cell generate ATP
                   suppressors and              Increase in ROS                through FAO
                      oncogenes              Ros inhibits use of
                                            other substrates like
                   Lead to                      fatty acids by
              hyperproliferation              suppression FAO
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                       APOPTOSIS


      Displaced cells lose
     survival signals from
              ECM




                                   34
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                       APOPTOSIS


      Displaced cells lose
     survival signals from             If anti-apop
              ECM
                                      checkpoints lost




                                      Cells survive but
                                    metabolically impaired
                                   due to lack of nutrients




                                                              34
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                       APOPTOSIS                         ROS INCREASE


      Displaced cells lose
     survival signals from             If anti-apop
              ECM
                                      checkpoints lost




                                      Cells survive but
                                    metabolically impaired
                                   due to lack of nutrients




                                                                        34
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                       APOPTOSIS                         ROS INCREASE   ABNORMAL CELLS DIE


      Displaced cells lose
     survival signals from             If anti-apop
              ECM
                                      checkpoints lost




                                      Cells survive but
                                    metabolically impaired
                                   due to lack of nutrients




                                                                        34
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                       APOPTOSIS                         ROS INCREASE    ABNORMAL CELLS DIE


      Displaced cells lose
     survival signals from             If anti-apop
              ECM
                                      checkpoints lost




                                      Cells survive but
                                    metabolically impaired
                                   due to lack of nutrients




                                                                        ROS IS BACK UP
                                                                          CHECKPOINT
                                                                          TO PREVENT
                                                                         OUTGROWTH
                                                                         OF ABNORMAL
                                                                          34
                                                                             CELLS!
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                       APOPTOSIS                         ROS INCREASE    ABNORMAL CELLS DIE


      Displaced cells lose
     survival signals from             If anti-apop
              ECM
                                      checkpoints lost




                                      Cells survive but
                                    metabolically impaired
                                   due to lack of nutrients
                                                                   Anti-oxidants
                                                                   prevent ROS
                                                                       killing




                                                                         34
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                         APOPTOSIS                         ROS INCREASE    ABNORMAL CELLS DIE


        Displaced cells lose
       survival signals from             If anti-apop
                ECM
                                        checkpoints lost




                                        Cells survive but
                                      metabolically impaired
                                     due to lack of nutrients
                                                                     Anti-oxidants
                                                                     prevent ROS
                                                                         killing
 Anti-oxidants have been shown to prevent other types of
 death involving ROS -- e.g. radiation, chemotherapy, etc.

                                                                           34
ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate
   Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells
                         APOPTOSIS                         ROS INCREASE    ABNORMAL CELLS DIE


        Displaced cells lose
       survival signals from             If anti-apop
                ECM
                                        checkpoints lost




                                        Cells survive but
                                      metabolically impaired
                                     due to lack of nutrients
                                                                     Anti-oxidants
                                                                     prevent ROS
                                                                         killing
 Anti-oxidants have been shown to prevent other types of
 death involving ROS -- e.g. radiation, chemotherapy, etc.
 Rigorous controlled studies in mouse models and humans
                                                  34
 required to understand effects of anti-oxidants.
SOD2 and TXN Elevated in Grade3 Tumors




                               from Oncomine




                                35
SOD2 Differentially Expressed in High
            Grade Breast Tumors




                Thioredoxin looks almost identical

                                                     36
From Oncomine
Human Protein Atlas - SOD2 IHC




Normal




                            37
Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress


       Increased ROS




      Loss of matrix
      DNA damage
   Loss of nutrients/O2
         etc etc


                                38
Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress


       Increased ROS




                          Anti-oxidant
                            program

      Loss of matrix
      DNA damage
   Loss of nutrients/O2
         etc etc


                                         38
Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress


       Increased ROS
                  Inhibit anti-oxidants


                            X
                          Anti-oxidant
                            program

      Loss of matrix
      DNA damage
   Loss of nutrients/O2
         etc etc


                                          38
Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress


       Increased ROS
                  Inhibit anti-oxidants


                            X
                          Anti-oxidant
                            program

      Loss of matrix
      DNA damage
   Loss of nutrients/O2
         etc etc


                                          38
Acknowledgments
                     METABOLISM                 TWO-PHOTON




              Zach Schafer     Alex Grassian        Loling Song



               U. Notre Dame


          APOPTOSIS/AUTOPHAGY                                     LAB MANAGER




                   Mauricio                     Yoko Irie          Grace Gao
Jay Debnath                       Mike
                   Reginato
                                  Overholtzer



   UCSF               Drexel        MSKCI
Acknowledgments




      Fatty Acid Oxidation - Pere Puigserver
                            Zach Gerhart-Hines



Nikon Imaging Center Harvard Medical School




                                                 40
We studied the effect of -carotene supplementation
on colorectal adenoma recurrence among subjects
in a multicenter double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical
trial of antioxidants for the prevention of colorectal adenomas.

A total of 864 subjects who had had an adenoma removed
and were polyp-free were randomly assigned (in a
factorial design) to receive -carotene (25 mg or placebo)
and/or vitamins C and E in combination (1000 mg and 400
mg, respectively, or placebo), and were followed with colonoscopy
for adenoma recurrence 1 year and 4 years after the
qualifying endoscopy.


                                                             41
We studied the effect of -carotene supplementation
Among subjects who neither smoked cigarettes nor drank
alcohol, -carotene was associated with subjects decrease in
on colorectal adenoma recurrence among a marked
thearisk of one or more recurrent adenomas! clinical
in multicenter double-blind, placebo-controlled
trial of antioxidants for the prevention of colorectal adenomas.

A total of 864 subjects who had had an adenoma removed
and were polyp-free were randomly assigned (in a
factorial design) to receive -carotene (25 mg or placebo)
and/or vitamins C and E in combination (1000 mg and 400
mg, respectively, or placebo), and were followed with colonoscopy
for adenoma recurrence 1 year and 4 years after the
qualifying endoscopy.


                                                             41
We studied the effect of -carotene supplementation
Among subjects who neither smoked cigarettes nor drank
alcohol, -carotene was associated with subjects decrease in
on colorectal adenoma recurrence among a marked
thearisk of one or more recurrent adenomas! clinical
in multicenter double-blind, placebo-controlled
trial of antioxidants for the prevention of colorectal adenomas.

For participants who smoked cigarettes and also
 A total of 864 subjects who had had an adenoma removed
drank more than one alcoholic drink per day, -carotene
 and were polyp-free were randomly assigned (in a
doubled design) to of adenoma recurrence (RR = 2.07, 95%
 factorial the risk receive -carotene (25 mg or placebo)
CI= 1.39 to 3.08;and E in combination (1000 mg and 400
 and/or vitamins C
                     P for difference from nonsmoker/
 mg, respectively, or placebo), and were followed with colonoscopy
nondrinker RR < .001).year and 4 years after the
 for adenoma recurrence 1
qualifying endoscopy.


                                                             41
Extracellular Matrix Protein IHC in Human and Mouse
                           Tumors
          Human Breast Tumors                       Mouse Mammary Tumors




                                          Text




                                                                    42
Mike Overholtzer; Arnaud Mailleux; Stuart Schnitt

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

TriStar Technology Group Corporate Presentation
TriStar Technology Group Corporate PresentationTriStar Technology Group Corporate Presentation
TriStar Technology Group Corporate Presentationthnkstudios
 
TriStar Corporate Presentation
TriStar Corporate PresentationTriStar Corporate Presentation
TriStar Corporate Presentationthnkstudios
 
New definition and new theory (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...
New definition and new theory  (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...New definition and new theory  (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...
New definition and new theory (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...Rajkumar Dhaugoda
 
Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11
Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11
Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11Cheng Luo
 
20614 ftp
20614 ftp20614 ftp
20614 ftpsofiles
 
WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...
WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...
WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...Quality Assistance s.a.
 
Characterization of stem cells
Characterization of stem cellsCharacterization of stem cells
Characterization of stem cellsRumana Tamboli
 
Ppt30 sak 23.11.17
Ppt30 sak 23.11.17Ppt30 sak 23.11.17
Ppt30 sak 23.11.17sathish sak
 
Therapeutic Humanised Monoclonal Antibodies
Therapeutic Humanised Monoclonal AntibodiesTherapeutic Humanised Monoclonal Antibodies
Therapeutic Humanised Monoclonal AntibodiesSyed Muhammad Shoaib
 
Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)
Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)
Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)Asma Kilani
 
monoclonal antibodies
monoclonal antibodiesmonoclonal antibodies
monoclonal antibodiesNasa Ahmad
 
Monoclonal antibodies Clinical Significance
Monoclonal antibodies Clinical SignificanceMonoclonal antibodies Clinical Significance
Monoclonal antibodies Clinical Significancedrvicky666
 
Monoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology And
Monoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology AndMonoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology And
Monoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology Anddrmisbah83
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

TriStar Technology Group Corporate Presentation
TriStar Technology Group Corporate PresentationTriStar Technology Group Corporate Presentation
TriStar Technology Group Corporate Presentation
 
5160
51605160
5160
 
TriStar Corporate Presentation
TriStar Corporate PresentationTriStar Corporate Presentation
TriStar Corporate Presentation
 
Medicina
Medicina Medicina
Medicina
 
New definition and new theory (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...
New definition and new theory  (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...New definition and new theory  (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...
New definition and new theory (stem cell-microRNA Theory) of cancer-by dr.ra...
 
Ihc
IhcIhc
Ihc
 
IHC Markers and Antibodies
IHC Markers and AntibodiesIHC Markers and Antibodies
IHC Markers and Antibodies
 
Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11
Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11
Mage gene-talk-13-01-2012-tartu22-11
 
20614 ftp
20614 ftp20614 ftp
20614 ftp
 
WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...
WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...
WEBINAR Characterisation of human pluripotent stem cells (ESCs and IPSC) and ...
 
Characterization of stem cells
Characterization of stem cellsCharacterization of stem cells
Characterization of stem cells
 
Ppt30 sak 23.11.17
Ppt30 sak 23.11.17Ppt30 sak 23.11.17
Ppt30 sak 23.11.17
 
Therapeutic Humanised Monoclonal Antibodies
Therapeutic Humanised Monoclonal AntibodiesTherapeutic Humanised Monoclonal Antibodies
Therapeutic Humanised Monoclonal Antibodies
 
Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)
Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)
Monoclonal antibodies anticancer therapy[1] (1)
 
Monoclonal antibodies
Monoclonal antibodiesMonoclonal antibodies
Monoclonal antibodies
 
monoclonal antibodies
monoclonal antibodiesmonoclonal antibodies
monoclonal antibodies
 
Monoclonal antibodies Clinical Significance
Monoclonal antibodies Clinical SignificanceMonoclonal antibodies Clinical Significance
Monoclonal antibodies Clinical Significance
 
Monoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology And
Monoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology AndMonoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology And
Monoclonal Antibodies As Therapeutic Agents In Oncology And
 
aCGH in PGD/PGS
aCGH in PGD/PGSaCGH in PGD/PGS
aCGH in PGD/PGS
 
CDD 2015
CDD 2015CDD 2015
CDD 2015
 

Andere mochten auch

Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...
Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...
Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...QuestexConf
 
知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」
知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」
知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」博士のシェアハウス
 
Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)
Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)
Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)Salmah Md Ali
 
M14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflows
M14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflowsM14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflows
M14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflowsQuestexConf
 

Andere mochten auch (7)

DIYブームは研究をどう変えるか?
DIYブームは研究をどう変えるか?DIYブームは研究をどう変えるか?
DIYブームは研究をどう変えるか?
 
Smips・研究現場の知財分科会2013
Smips・研究現場の知財分科会2013Smips・研究現場の知財分科会2013
Smips・研究現場の知財分科会2013
 
Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...
Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...
Exceeding Expectations with Escorted & Independent Vacations by The Travel Co...
 
知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」
知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」
知的財産マネジメント研究会(Smips)「ソーシャルメディアから生まれるイノベーションの新しい形」
 
Hate
HateHate
Hate
 
Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)
Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)
Bumi ting -1_pergerakan-bumi (1)
 
M14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflows
M14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflowsM14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflows
M14 driving mps_success_through_visual_print_workflows
 

Ähnlich wie Brugge metabolismfinal

Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)
Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)
Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)Garry D. Lasaga
 
The opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancer
The opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancerThe opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancer
The opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancerResearchsio
 
ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases
ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases
ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases European School of Oncology
 
Xenotransplantation of pig kidney to human
Xenotransplantation of pig kidney to humanXenotransplantation of pig kidney to human
Xenotransplantation of pig kidney to humanAbhinandanKanjikar
 
Stem cell and regenerative medicine
Stem cell and regenerative medicineStem cell and regenerative medicine
Stem cell and regenerative medicineManash Paul
 
Abstract piis0022202 x1831114x
Abstract piis0022202 x1831114xAbstract piis0022202 x1831114x
Abstract piis0022202 x1831114xWaddah Moghram
 
Current Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung Cancer
Current Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung CancerCurrent Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung Cancer
Current Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung CancerDr Felipe Templo Jr
 
CANCER STEM CELLS
CANCER STEM CELLSCANCER STEM CELLS
CANCER STEM CELLSsathish sak
 
Monoclonal Antibodies
Monoclonal AntibodiesMonoclonal Antibodies
Monoclonal AntibodiesAmeer Ahmed
 
Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...
Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...
Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...milapthaker
 
Rough draft pp of sigma xi sallies
Rough draft pp of sigma xi salliesRough draft pp of sigma xi sallies
Rough draft pp of sigma xi salliesdulkae
 
Various cell line &amp; utilities in detection of
Various cell line &amp; utilities in detection ofVarious cell line &amp; utilities in detection of
Various cell line &amp; utilities in detection ofanandvishwakarma47
 
Stem cells Types .pptx
Stem cells Types .pptxStem cells Types .pptx
Stem cells Types .pptxZahraa63902
 
Cell line development ol
Cell line development olCell line development ol
Cell line development olAnkita Gurao
 

Ähnlich wie Brugge metabolismfinal (20)

International Journal of Stem Cells & Research
International Journal of Stem Cells & ResearchInternational Journal of Stem Cells & Research
International Journal of Stem Cells & Research
 
Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)
Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)
Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells (iPSCs)
 
The opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancer
The opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancerThe opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancer
The opportunity of stem cell to treat diabetes and cancer
 
ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases
ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases
ABC1 - L. van't Veer - Genomic signatures of specific sites of metastases
 
Animal biotechnology
Animal biotechnologyAnimal biotechnology
Animal biotechnology
 
Xenotransplantation of pig kidney to human
Xenotransplantation of pig kidney to humanXenotransplantation of pig kidney to human
Xenotransplantation of pig kidney to human
 
Stem cell and regenerative medicine
Stem cell and regenerative medicineStem cell and regenerative medicine
Stem cell and regenerative medicine
 
Abstract piis0022202 x1831114x
Abstract piis0022202 x1831114xAbstract piis0022202 x1831114x
Abstract piis0022202 x1831114x
 
Current Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung Cancer
Current Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung CancerCurrent Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung Cancer
Current Concepts in the Diagnosis of Lung Cancer
 
CANCER STEM CELLS
CANCER STEM CELLSCANCER STEM CELLS
CANCER STEM CELLS
 
Surp08 Signaling
Surp08 SignalingSurp08 Signaling
Surp08 Signaling
 
stem_cell_day1_part2_presented by Dr mbah , uploaded by Emmarise.pdf
stem_cell_day1_part2_presented by Dr mbah , uploaded by Emmarise.pdfstem_cell_day1_part2_presented by Dr mbah , uploaded by Emmarise.pdf
stem_cell_day1_part2_presented by Dr mbah , uploaded by Emmarise.pdf
 
Monoclonal Antibodies
Monoclonal AntibodiesMonoclonal Antibodies
Monoclonal Antibodies
 
Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...
Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...
Cellular Engineering - Milap Thaker, Matt Lawler, W. Cartwright et. al Eradic...
 
Rough draft pp of sigma xi sallies
Rough draft pp of sigma xi salliesRough draft pp of sigma xi sallies
Rough draft pp of sigma xi sallies
 
Various cell line &amp; utilities in detection of
Various cell line &amp; utilities in detection ofVarious cell line &amp; utilities in detection of
Various cell line &amp; utilities in detection of
 
Stem cells Types .pptx
Stem cells Types .pptxStem cells Types .pptx
Stem cells Types .pptx
 
MCF-7: Human Breast Cancer Cell Line
MCF-7: Human Breast Cancer Cell LineMCF-7: Human Breast Cancer Cell Line
MCF-7: Human Breast Cancer Cell Line
 
Cell line development ol
Cell line development olCell line development ol
Cell line development ol
 
PROSTATIC TUMORS
PROSTATIC TUMORSPROSTATIC TUMORS
PROSTATIC TUMORS
 

Brugge metabolismfinal

  • 1. 1
  • 2. Extracellular Matrix Control of Tumor Cell Metabolism Joan Brugge Department of Cell Biology Harvard Medical School
  • 3. Anchorage Dependence of Normal Cells and Independence of TUmor Cells Normal Epithelial Cells Detach from matrix Martin Schwartz Adapted from Geiger and Peeper, Cancer Monolayer Steve Frisch Res 2005; 65: 7033-36. Suspension
  • 4. Anchorage Dependence of Normal Cells and Independence of TUmor Cells Normal Epithelial Cells Tumor Cells Detach from matrix Martin Schwartz Adapted from Geiger and Peeper, Cancer Monolayer Steve Frisch Res 2005; 65: 7033-36. Suspension
  • 5. Anchorage Dependence of Normal Cells and Independence of TUmor Cells Normal Epithelial Cells Tumor Cells Detach from matrix Martin Schwartz Adapted from Geiger and Peeper, Cancer Monolayer Steve Frisch Res 2005; 65: 7033-36. Suspension Normal Cells Tumor Cells MacPherson and Montagnier 1964 Soft agar Soft agar
  • 6. In Early Tumorigenesis, Excess Proliferation Displaces Cells from Their Normal Niches Laminin DCIS Laminin 4
  • 7. Cells from non-glandular tumors also displaced from natural matrix attachment 5
  • 8. Tumors Cells Encounter Foreign Matrix Environments during Invasion and Metastasis Text (Image from Merck Biosciences www.youtube.com/watch?v=5L6lHfgL10Y
  • 9. Tumors Cells Encounter Foreign Matrix Environments during Invasion and Metastasis Text The pathways that allow tumor cells to survive outside their niches provide attractive targets for therapeutic intervention (Image from Merck Biosciences www.youtube.com/watch?v=5L6lHfgL10Y
  • 10. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence MCF-10A cells/HMECs Full medium + serum, Suspension EGF, insulin, culture hydrocortisone Polyhema Mauricio Reginato
  • 11. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 MCF-10A cells/HMECs Full medium + serum, Suspension EGF, insulin, culture hydrocortisone Polyhema Apoptosis Mauricio Reginato
  • 12. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 MCF-10A cells/HMECs Full medium + serum, Suspension EGF, insulin, culture hydrocortisone Polyhema Apoptosis Integrin EGFR Erk Mauricio Akt Reginato
  • 13. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 MCF-10A cells/HMECs Full medium + serum, Suspension EGF, insulin, culture hydrocortisone Polyhema Apoptosis Integrin EGFR pErk Mauricio pAkt Reginato
  • 14. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 MCF-10A cells/HMECs Full medium + serum, Suspension EGF, insulin, culture hydrocortisone Polyhema Apoptosis Integrin EGFR pErk Mauricio pAkt Reginato
  • 15. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 MCF-10A cells/HMECs Full medium + serum, Suspension EGF, insulin, culture hydrocortisone Polyhema Apoptosis Integrin EGFR Mauricio Reginato
  • 16. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 MCF-10A cells/HMECs Full medium + serum, Suspension EGF, insulin, culture hydrocortisone Polyhema Apoptosis Proapototic Bim Integrin Anti-apototic Bcl-2 EGFR Mauricio Reginato
  • 17. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence MCF-10A cells 3D basement membrane cultures Mauricio Reginato
  • 18. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence MCF-10A cells 3D basement membrane cultures Mauricio Jay Reginato Debnath
  • 19. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence MCF-10A cells 3D basement membrane cultures Laminin Mauricio Jay Reginato Debnath
  • 20. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence MCF-10A cells 3D basement membrane cultures phosphoAKT (phospho mTor, Laminin Mauricio Jay phosphoFKHD) Reginato Debnath
  • 21. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence MCF-10A cells 3D basement membrane cultures phosphoAKT Erk (phospho mTor, Laminin Mauricio Jay Akt phosphoFKHD) Reginato Debnath
  • 22. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence MCF-10A cells 3D basement membrane cultures phosphoAKT Laminin Caspase3 Erk (phospho mTor, Mauricio Jay Akt phosphoFKHD) Reginato Debnath
  • 23. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 Suspension culture MCF-10A cells Apoptosis 3D basement membrane cultures phosphoAKT Laminin Caspase3 Erk (phospho mTor, Mauricio Jay Akt phosphoFKHD) Reginato Debnath
  • 24. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 Suspension culture MCF-10A cells Apoptosis 3D basement membrane Bcl-2 cultures Mauricio Jay Reginato Debnath
  • 25. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 Suspension culture MCF-10A cells Apoptosis 3D basement membrane Bcl-2 cultures Mauricio Jay Reginato Debnath
  • 26. Models Employed to Study Anchorage Independence Caspase3 Suspension culture MCF-10A cells Apoptosis Autophagy 3D basement membrane Bcl-2 cultures Mauricio Jay Reginato Debnath
  • 27. Is autophagy associated with a reduction in ATP? Cells suspended in complete medium with EGF, serum, etc. Alex Grassian Zach Schafer
  • 28. Is autophagy associated with a reduction in ATP? Cells suspended in complete medium with EGF, serum, etc. Alex Grassian Zach Schafer
  • 29. Is autophagy associated with a reduction in ATP? Cells suspended in complete medium with EGF, serum, etc. Alex Grassian Zach Schafer
  • 30. Detached Cells Show Severe Reduction in Glucose Uptake and Exogenous Pyruvate Can Rescue the ATP Defiency 30000 Glucose Uptake 25000 p=1.08 x 10-5 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 Detached Attached Zach Schafer
  • 31. Detached Cells Show Severe Reduction in Glucose Uptake and Exogenous Pyruvate Can Rescue the ATP Defiency 30000 Glucose Uptake 25000 p=1.08 x 10-5 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 Detached Attached 12 Zach Schafer
  • 32. Detached Cells Show Severe Reduction in Glucose Uptake and Exogenous Pyruvate Can Rescue the ATP Defiency glucose X 30000 Glucose Uptake 25000 p=1.08 x 10-5 20000 15000 10000 glucose-6P X 5000 0 Detached Attached Glycolysis X methyl methyl pyruvate pyruvate pyruvate TCA TCA cycle 12 cycle Zach Schafer
  • 33. Fate of Glucose glucose Glucose transporters glucose-6P G6P Isomerase Glycolysis ATP Lactate Pyruvate + NADH TCA cycle 13 ATP
  • 34. Fate of Glucose glucose Glucose transporters glucose-6P G6P Dehydrogenase G6P Isomerase Pentose Phosphate Glycolysis Pathway ATP Lactate Pyruvate + NADH NADPH- anti-oxidant TCA cycle 13 ATP
  • 35. Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could Contribute to ROS Production glucose X glucose-6P G6P Isomerase Glycolysis X X G6P Dehydrogenase Pentose Phosphate Pathway ATP ROS? Zach Schafer
  • 36. Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could Contribute to ROS Production glucose X glucose-6P G6P Isomerase Glycolysis X X G6P Dehydrogenase Pentose Phosphate Pathway ATP ROS? Zach Schafer
  • 37. Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could Contribute to ROS Production 13000 ROS Levels - carboxy- H2 DCF-DA 12000 11000 ROS levels (a.u.) 10000 9000 8000 glucose X 7000 6000 5000 10A Bcl-2 Attached Detached glucose-6P G6P Isomerase Glycolysis X X G6P Dehydrogenase Pentose Phosphate Pathway ATP ROS? Zach Schafer
  • 38. Loss of PPP generation of NADPH Could Contribute to ROS Production 13000 ROS Levels - carboxy- H2 DCF-DA 12000 11000 ROS levels (a.u.) 10000 9000 8000 glucose X 7000 6000 5000 10A Bcl-2 Attached Detached glucose-6P Also detected increase in X X oxidized glutathione G6P Dehydrogenase G6P Isomerase Pentose Phosphate Glycolysis Pathway ATP ROS? Zach Schafer
  • 39. Multiple Death Processes Ass’d with Matrix Detachment LC3-GFP Metabolic Impairment Apoptosis ATP 15 ROS?
  • 40. Matrix-Deprived Cells in Center of 3D Structures MCF-10 cells laminin
  • 41. Matrix-Deprived Cells in Center of 3D Structures MCF-10 cells laminin Apoptosis Caspase3*
  • 42. Matrix-Deprived Cells in Center of 3D Structures MCF-10 cells laminin Apoptosis Autophagy Caspase3*
  • 43. Two Photon NAD(P)H Fluorescence Loling Song 17 Since NADH is the principal electron donor in glycolytic and oxidative energy metabolism, it represents a non-invasive fluorescent reporter of the metabolic state
  • 44. Oxidative Stress in Acini DCF-DA d7 carboxy-H2DCFDA cell-permeant indicator for reactive oxygen species that is retained in the cell after deacetylation and is nonfluorescent until oxidation occurs within the cell
  • 45. Oxidative Stress in Acini DCF-DA d7 carboxy-H2DCFDA cell-permeant indicator for reactive oxygen species that is retained in the cell after deacetylation and is nonfluorescent until oxidation occurs within the cell 18
  • 46. Similar Features of Matrix Detached Cells and Inner Cells of 3D Structures Autophagy Elevated Elevated Metabolic Impairment Low ATP Lower NADH ROS Elevated Elevated Apoptosis ++++ ++++ 19 Entosis +++++ +
  • 47. Similar Features of Matrix Detached Cells and Inner Cells of 3D Structures Autophagy Elevated Elevated What are the implications of Metabolic Impairment Low ATP Lower NADH these findings for ROS Elevated Elevated tumorigenesis? Apoptosis ++++ ++++ 19 Entosis +++++ +
  • 48. Survival of HyperproliferativeTumor Cells Apoptosis Anti-apoptotic activity Text Rescue Metabolic Metabolic Impairment Impairment Low ATP High ROS 20
  • 49. Survival of HyperproliferativeTumor Cells Apoptosis Anti-apoptotic activity Text Rescue Metabolic Metabolic Impairment Impairment Low ATP High ROS How? 20
  • 50. ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in Suspended Cells ext 21
  • 51. ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in Suspended Cells ext Glucose uptake 21
  • 52. ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in Suspended Cells ext ROS Glucose uptake 21
  • 53. ErbB2 Rescue of ATP Deficiency in Suspended Cells + ErbB2 ext ROS Glucose uptake Ras PI3K Mek Akt Erk 21
  • 54. ErbB2 Rescue of ATP in Suspension is Suppressed by 2-DG glucose 2-deoxyglucose glucose 2-deoxyglucose Glycolysis X pyruvate TCA cycle Zach Schafer
  • 55. ErbB2 Rescue of ATP in Suspension is Suppressed by 2-DG glucose 2-deoxyglucose glucose 2-deoxyglucose Glycolysis X pyruvate TCA cycle 22 Zach Schafer
  • 56. Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells glucose uptake ATP ROS ErbB2 Rescues glucose uptake • Restores glycolysis • Restores PPP - anti-Ox 23
  • 57. Effects of Loss of Glucose Uptake glucose X glucose-6P G6P Isomerase Glycolysis X X G6P Dehydrogenase Pentose Phosphate Pathway ATP ROS? Zach Schafer
  • 58. Effects of Loss of Glucose Uptake glucose X glucose-6P G6P Isomerase Glycolysis X X G6P Dehydrogenase Pentose Phosphate Pathway ATP ROS? WHAT IF ADD ANTI-OXIDANT TO SUSPENDED CONTROL CELLS? Zach Schafer
  • 59. Antioxidant Treatment Leads to Enhanced ATP Levels in Detached Cells anti-oxidant Low ATP Elevated ATP 10A 1 mM 50 uM Superoxide Vitamin E Vitamin E dismutase analog analog mimic
  • 60. Antioxidant Treatment Leads to Enhanced ATP Levels in Detached Cells anti-oxidant Low ATP Elevated ATP 10A 1 mM 50 uM Superoxide Vitamin E Vitamin E dismutase analog analog mimic
  • 61. Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells glucose uptake ATP ROS ErbB2 Anti-Oxidant Rescues glucose uptake Does not rescue glucose uptake • Restores glycolysis • Restores PPP - anti-Ox 26
  • 62. Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells glucose uptake ATP ROS ErbB2 Anti-Oxidant Rescues glucose uptake Does not rescue glucose uptake • Restores glycolysis How do anti- • Restores PPP - anti-Ox oxidants rescue ATP levels?26
  • 63. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Glycolysis ATP pyruvate PDH Acetyl CoA Ciitrate OAA TCA cycle Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 A
  • 64. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Macromolecular Glycolysis degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Oxidizable PDH substrates Acetyl CoA Ciitrate OAA TCA cycle Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 A
  • 65. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate OXIDATION OAA TCA cycle Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 Craig Thompson A
  • 66. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate OXIDATION OAA TCA cycle ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 Craig Thompson A
  • 67. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate OXIDATION OAA TCA cycle ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 Craig Thompson A
  • 68. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate OXIDATION OAA TCA cycle ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 Craig Thompson A
  • 69. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate • Upregulation of FAO mRN OXIDATION program OAA TCA cycle ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 Craig Thompson A
  • 70. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate • Upregulation of FAO mRN OXIDATION program OAA • FAO not sustained in TCA suspended cells cycle ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 27 Craig Thompson A
  • 71. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate • Upregulation of FAO mRN OXIDATION program OAA • FAO not sustained in TCA suspended cells cycle ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 ATP 27 Levels Fall! Craig Thompson A
  • 72. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate • Upregulation of FAO mRN OXIDATION program OAA • FAO not sustained in TCA suspended cells cycle Anti-oxidants rescue FAO ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 ATP 27 ATP Levels Fall! Restored! Craig Thompson A
  • 73. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates X ROS pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate • Upregulation of FAO mRN OXIDATION program OAA • FAO not sustained in TCA suspended cells cycle Anti-oxidants rescue FAO ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 ATP 27 ATP Levels Fall! Restored! Craig Thompson A
  • 74. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates X ROS Anti-Ox pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate • Upregulation of FAO mRN OXIDATION program OAA • FAO not sustained in TCA suspended cells cycle Anti-oxidants rescue FAO ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 ATP 27 ATP Levels Fall! Restored! Craig Thompson A
  • 75. Alternate Energy Pathways Glucose Oxidizable substrates Glycolysis X Macromolecular degradation ATP Oxidizable substrates Anti-Ox pyruvate Glucose deprivation Oxidizable PDH substrates •Loss of glucose transport Acetyl Upregulate CoA FATTY ACID Ciitrate • Upregulation of FAO mRN OXIDATION program OAA • FAO not sustained in TCA suspended cells cycle Anti-oxidants rescue FAO ATP maintained Adapted from DeRobertis et al Cell Metabolism 2008200 ATP 27 ATP Levels Fall! Restored! Craig Thompson A
  • 76. Summary -- Alternate Rescue of Metabolic Defect of Matrix-Deprived Cells glucose uptake ATP ROS ErbB2 Anti-Oxidant Rescues glucose uptake Does not rescue glucose uptake • Restores glycolysis • Restores fatty acid oxidation • Restores PPP - anti-Ox 28
  • 77. Can Anti-Oxidant Affect Morphogenesis In 3D Cultures? Apoptosis NAD(P)H ROS DFC-DA Autophagy 29
  • 78. Trolox Reduces NAD(P)H Dichotomy Between the Inner and Outer Cells 30
  • 79. Anti-Oxidants Increase Luminal Filling Clear Mostly Clear Mostly Filled Filled Blue: DAPI Red: Laminin V Green: Cleaved Caspase-3 Control 56.7% 26.7% 13.3% 3.3% ROS NAc 38.1% 4.8% 4.8% 52.4% Trolox 7.4% 14.8% 48.1% 29.6% Zach Schafer
  • 80. Trolox Also Increases Anchorage-Independent Colony Formation in Soft Agar MCF10A HPV-E7 Bcl-2 Rb Blocks p27, p21 apoptosis Hyperproliferation 32
  • 81. Trolox Also Increases Anchorage-Independent Colony Formation in Soft Agar MCF10A HPV-E7 Bcl-2 Rb Blocks p27, p21 apoptosis Hyperproliferation 32
  • 82. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Oxidative stress Mutations in tumor suppressors and oncogenes Lead to hyperproliferation
  • 83. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants Protective against DNA, protein and lipid damage Oxidative stress Mutations in tumor suppressors and oncogenes Lead to hyperproliferation
  • 84. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k ec protein and lipid ch damage Oxidative stress Mutations in tumor suppressors and oncogenes Lead to hyperproliferation
  • 85. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k ec protein and lipid ch damage Oxidative stress Mutations in tumor suppressors and oncogenes Lead to hyperproliferation
  • 86. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k ec protein and lipid ch damage Oxidative stress Mutations in tumor suppressors and oncogenes Lead to hyperproliferation
  • 87. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k ec protein and lipid ch damage If anti-apop checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Mutations in tumor suppressors and oncogenes Lead to hyperproliferation
  • 88. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k ec protein and lipid ch damage If anti-apop checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Mutations in Loss of glucose tumor uptake suppressors and Increase in ROS oncogenes Lead to hyperproliferation
  • 89. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k ec protein and lipid ch damage If anti-apop checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Mutations in Loss of glucose tumor uptake suppressors and Increase in ROS oncogenes Ros inhibits use of other substrates like Lead to fatty acids by hyperproliferation suppression FAO
  • 90. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k ec protein and lipid ch damage If anti-apop checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Mutations in Loss of glucose tumor uptake suppressors and Increase in ROS oncogenes Ros inhibits use of other substrates like Lead to fatty acids by hyperproliferation suppression FAO
  • 91. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k es ec cu ch res protein and lipid ha t ke e t upta damage gen e If anti-apop O nco lucos g checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Mutations in Loss of glucose tumor uptake suppressors and Increase in ROS oncogenes Ros inhibits use of other substrates like Lead to fatty acids by hyperproliferation suppression FAO
  • 92. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k es ec cu ch res protein and lipid ha t ke e t upta damage gen e If anti-apop O nco lucos g checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Anti-oxidant Mutations in program Loss of glucose tumor uptake suppressors and Increase in ROS oncogenes Ros inhibits use of other substrates like Lead to fatty acids by hyperproliferation suppression FAO
  • 93. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k es ec cu ch res protein and lipid ha t ke e t upta damage gen e If anti-apop O nco lucos g checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Anti-oxidant Mutations in program Loss of glucose tumor uptake Cell generate ATP suppressors and Increase in ROS through FAO oncogenes Ros inhibits use of other substrates like Lead to fatty acids by hyperproliferation suppression FAO
  • 94. Potential Implications: Dichotomous Activity of Anti-Oxidants Anti-oxidants ic t ot tac pt in Protective po ts a in against DNA, If po k es ec cu ch res protein and lipid ha t ke e t upta damage gen e If anti-apop O nco lucos g checkpoints lost Oxidative stress Anti-oxidant Mutations in program Loss of glucose tumor uptake Cell generate ATP suppressors and Increase in ROS through FAO oncogenes Ros inhibits use of other substrates like Lead to fatty acids by hyperproliferation suppression FAO
  • 95. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS Displaced cells lose survival signals from ECM 34
  • 96. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS Displaced cells lose survival signals from If anti-apop ECM checkpoints lost Cells survive but metabolically impaired due to lack of nutrients 34
  • 97. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS ROS INCREASE Displaced cells lose survival signals from If anti-apop ECM checkpoints lost Cells survive but metabolically impaired due to lack of nutrients 34
  • 98. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS ROS INCREASE ABNORMAL CELLS DIE Displaced cells lose survival signals from If anti-apop ECM checkpoints lost Cells survive but metabolically impaired due to lack of nutrients 34
  • 99. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS ROS INCREASE ABNORMAL CELLS DIE Displaced cells lose survival signals from If anti-apop ECM checkpoints lost Cells survive but metabolically impaired due to lack of nutrients ROS IS BACK UP CHECKPOINT TO PREVENT OUTGROWTH OF ABNORMAL 34 CELLS!
  • 100. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS ROS INCREASE ABNORMAL CELLS DIE Displaced cells lose survival signals from If anti-apop ECM checkpoints lost Cells survive but metabolically impaired due to lack of nutrients Anti-oxidants prevent ROS killing 34
  • 101. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS ROS INCREASE ABNORMAL CELLS DIE Displaced cells lose survival signals from If anti-apop ECM checkpoints lost Cells survive but metabolically impaired due to lack of nutrients Anti-oxidants prevent ROS killing Anti-oxidants have been shown to prevent other types of death involving ROS -- e.g. radiation, chemotherapy, etc. 34
  • 102. ROS As Secondary Checkpoint to Eliminate Abnormal, Hyperproliferative Cells APOPTOSIS ROS INCREASE ABNORMAL CELLS DIE Displaced cells lose survival signals from If anti-apop ECM checkpoints lost Cells survive but metabolically impaired due to lack of nutrients Anti-oxidants prevent ROS killing Anti-oxidants have been shown to prevent other types of death involving ROS -- e.g. radiation, chemotherapy, etc. Rigorous controlled studies in mouse models and humans 34 required to understand effects of anti-oxidants.
  • 103. SOD2 and TXN Elevated in Grade3 Tumors from Oncomine 35
  • 104. SOD2 Differentially Expressed in High Grade Breast Tumors Thioredoxin looks almost identical 36 From Oncomine
  • 105. Human Protein Atlas - SOD2 IHC Normal 37
  • 106. Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress Increased ROS Loss of matrix DNA damage Loss of nutrients/O2 etc etc 38
  • 107. Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress Increased ROS Anti-oxidant program Loss of matrix DNA damage Loss of nutrients/O2 etc etc 38
  • 108. Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress Increased ROS Inhibit anti-oxidants X Anti-oxidant program Loss of matrix DNA damage Loss of nutrients/O2 etc etc 38
  • 109. Selection to Rescue Oxidative Stress Increased ROS Inhibit anti-oxidants X Anti-oxidant program Loss of matrix DNA damage Loss of nutrients/O2 etc etc 38
  • 110. Acknowledgments METABOLISM TWO-PHOTON Zach Schafer Alex Grassian Loling Song U. Notre Dame APOPTOSIS/AUTOPHAGY LAB MANAGER Mauricio Yoko Irie Grace Gao Jay Debnath Mike Reginato Overholtzer UCSF Drexel MSKCI
  • 111. Acknowledgments Fatty Acid Oxidation - Pere Puigserver Zach Gerhart-Hines Nikon Imaging Center Harvard Medical School 40
  • 112. We studied the effect of -carotene supplementation on colorectal adenoma recurrence among subjects in a multicenter double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial of antioxidants for the prevention of colorectal adenomas. A total of 864 subjects who had had an adenoma removed and were polyp-free were randomly assigned (in a factorial design) to receive -carotene (25 mg or placebo) and/or vitamins C and E in combination (1000 mg and 400 mg, respectively, or placebo), and were followed with colonoscopy for adenoma recurrence 1 year and 4 years after the qualifying endoscopy. 41
  • 113. We studied the effect of -carotene supplementation Among subjects who neither smoked cigarettes nor drank alcohol, -carotene was associated with subjects decrease in on colorectal adenoma recurrence among a marked thearisk of one or more recurrent adenomas! clinical in multicenter double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of antioxidants for the prevention of colorectal adenomas. A total of 864 subjects who had had an adenoma removed and were polyp-free were randomly assigned (in a factorial design) to receive -carotene (25 mg or placebo) and/or vitamins C and E in combination (1000 mg and 400 mg, respectively, or placebo), and were followed with colonoscopy for adenoma recurrence 1 year and 4 years after the qualifying endoscopy. 41
  • 114. We studied the effect of -carotene supplementation Among subjects who neither smoked cigarettes nor drank alcohol, -carotene was associated with subjects decrease in on colorectal adenoma recurrence among a marked thearisk of one or more recurrent adenomas! clinical in multicenter double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of antioxidants for the prevention of colorectal adenomas. For participants who smoked cigarettes and also A total of 864 subjects who had had an adenoma removed drank more than one alcoholic drink per day, -carotene and were polyp-free were randomly assigned (in a doubled design) to of adenoma recurrence (RR = 2.07, 95% factorial the risk receive -carotene (25 mg or placebo) CI= 1.39 to 3.08;and E in combination (1000 mg and 400 and/or vitamins C P for difference from nonsmoker/ mg, respectively, or placebo), and were followed with colonoscopy nondrinker RR < .001).year and 4 years after the for adenoma recurrence 1 qualifying endoscopy. 41
  • 115. Extracellular Matrix Protein IHC in Human and Mouse Tumors Human Breast Tumors Mouse Mammary Tumors Text 42 Mike Overholtzer; Arnaud Mailleux; Stuart Schnitt

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. One of the most fascinating aspects of cancer research is the uncharted path that we follow in tracking down the mechanisms underlying this complex disease --Five years ago, no two years ago, I certainly would never had predicted that I would be invited to give a talk in a TUmor metabolism session -- indeed it has been 40 year since my last lecture on intermediatry metabolism and needless to say, the depth of my understanding of metabolic processes was indeed shallow! I wouldn&amp;#x2019;t go so far as to say that we went into this field kicking and screaming, but I will say that it took me four years to convince a postdoc in the lab to take on the metabolic questions that begged to be addresses.
  2. Our foray into metabolism was trigged through studies of the mechanisms that regulate tumor cell survival. More specifically, we were investigating the mechanisms that trigger the death of normal cells when they lose attachment to matrix and how tumor cells escape these death mechanisms. that mechanism that drive tumor cell death when cultured with out attachment to extracelular matrix and the mechanism whereby tumor cells could escape this death. Martin Schwartz and Steve Frisch first described this requirement of normal cells matrix attachment for short term survival, but this work followed from what would now be considered ancient studies fo Macpherson and Montagnier showing that only tumor cells could make colonies in soft agar whereas their normal counterparts don&amp;#x2019;t? What is the relevance of these properties of anchorage dependence or independence in culture to tumor cells in humans. Truth is, we don&amp;#x2019; know for certain; however Colony formation in soft agar has been found to correlate most closely with in tumorigenesis in animal models and we would predict...
  3. Our foray into metabolism was trigged through studies of the mechanisms that regulate tumor cell survival. More specifically, we were investigating the mechanisms that trigger the death of normal cells when they lose attachment to matrix and how tumor cells escape these death mechanisms. that mechanism that drive tumor cell death when cultured with out attachment to extracelular matrix and the mechanism whereby tumor cells could escape this death. Martin Schwartz and Steve Frisch first described this requirement of normal cells matrix attachment for short term survival, but this work followed from what would now be considered ancient studies fo Macpherson and Montagnier showing that only tumor cells could make colonies in soft agar whereas their normal counterparts don&amp;#x2019;t? What is the relevance of these properties of anchorage dependence or independence in culture to tumor cells in humans. Truth is, we don&amp;#x2019; know for certain; however Colony formation in soft agar has been found to correlate most closely with in tumorigenesis in animal models and we would predict...
  4. Our foray into metabolism was trigged through studies of the mechanisms that regulate tumor cell survival. More specifically, we were investigating the mechanisms that trigger the death of normal cells when they lose attachment to matrix and how tumor cells escape these death mechanisms. that mechanism that drive tumor cell death when cultured with out attachment to extracelular matrix and the mechanism whereby tumor cells could escape this death. Martin Schwartz and Steve Frisch first described this requirement of normal cells matrix attachment for short term survival, but this work followed from what would now be considered ancient studies fo Macpherson and Montagnier showing that only tumor cells could make colonies in soft agar whereas their normal counterparts don&amp;#x2019;t? What is the relevance of these properties of anchorage dependence or independence in culture to tumor cells in humans. Truth is, we don&amp;#x2019; know for certain; however Colony formation in soft agar has been found to correlate most closely with in tumorigenesis in animal models and we would predict...
  5. During early stages of tumorigenesis, excess proliferation eventually displaces cells from their normal niches
  6. Conclude that oncogenes would need to rescue both --
  7. Conclude that oncogenes would need to rescue both --
  8. Not possible to measure ATP in situ, so to got a preliminary idea of metabolic activity of cells within the 3D structures by evaluate the levels of NADH and NADPH by two-photon microscopy -- NADH, as opposed to NAD, has a native fluorescece that canb e activated at
  9. dichlorodihydrofluorescein diacetate
  10. Add someting on senthils results
  11. The ability of ERbB2 to rescue ATP in suspension involves increase in glucose uptake i because blockage of glucose metabolism with 2DG prevented ErbB2 rescue.
  12. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  13. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  14. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  15. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  16. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  17. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  18. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  19. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  20. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  21. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  22. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.
  23. Quiescent cells such as those that are detached from matrix, have a basal rate of glycolysis, converting glucose (glc) to pyruvate (pyr), which is then oxidized in the TCA cycle. Cells can also oxidize other substrates like amino acids and fatty acids obtained from either the environment or the degradation of cellular macromolecules. As a result, the majority of ATP (yellow stars) is generated by oxidative phosphorylation. Craig Thompson had found that FA oxidation can provide energy under conditions of glucose starvation.