The document discusses the arXiv initiative and its sustainability. It provides an overview of arXiv, including its history and usage statistics. It then summarizes arXiv's sustainability model between 2010-2012, which involved voluntary contributions from institutions. The document outlines arXiv's budget and expenses. It proposes a sustainability model for 2013 and beyond which involves financial support from Cornell University Library, foundation support, and member organizations, as well as governance through advisory boards. Key principles for sustainability discussed are integration into the academic community, clear governance, stable technology platforms, content policies, and business planning.

1. arXiv
Sustainability Initiative
March 2012
Oya Y. Rieger
rieger@cornell.edu
1

2. Sustainability is capacity to endure
• technical
• sociocultural
• policy
• business
2

3. Sustainability is capacity to endure
• technical
• sociocultural
• policy
• business
Stewardship is the responsibility to
maintain this vision
3

4. 4

5. • established in 1991 by
Paul Ginsparg
• has been hosted at Cornell
since 2001
• includes 731,000 e-prints
• 2011
– 76,578 new submissions
– ~50 million downloads
5

6. 6

7. 2011 Institutional Downloads by Domain Name
other 24% edu 26%
es 2%
gov 3%
ca 3%
de 12%
ch 4%
it 5%
uk 8%
fr 6% jp 7% 7

8. 2011 Institutional Downloads by Domain Name
other 24% edu 26%
CUL: 0.5%
use rank #28
es 2%
gov 3%
ca 3%
de 12%
ch 4%
it 5%
uk 8%
fr 6% jp 7% 8

9. CY 2011 Budget (Direct Expenses: $434,691 )
Other Expenses $15,381
IT infrastructure $39,440
Salary -
Management
0.50 FTE $56,000
Salary - User
Support
2.25 FTE + 0.36 0.36 student
2.25 FTE + student $158,000
Salary -
Programming
1.58 FTE $166,000
$0 $100,000 $200,000

10. Interim Sustainability Model
2010-2012
voluntary contributions from libraries and
research institutes
– Target the top 200 based on downloads from
institutional domain names
• Annual contribution tiers per institution:
$4,000 $3,200 $2,300
• CUL covers 15% of annual expenses plus indirect costs
– Indirect: 37% of direct cost
10

11. 2010-2012: Sustainability Planning Outcomes
Review and stabilize arXiv staffing and
organization
Evaluate arXiv’s IT infrastructure
Assess arXiv’s functionality and user support
Hold discussions with a group of publishers
and societies about collaboration ideas
11

12. Sustainability Model
2013 and beyond
Financial Support
– CUL
– Foundation Support
– Member Organizations
Governance
– CUL
– Member Advisory Board
– Scientific Advisory Board
12

13. 2009

15. Repository
Architecture
Discovery and
Archiving Access
Interoperability stewardship Submission, M
with Related oderation, Qua
Systems lity Control
Designated
Financial
Community &
Stability
Sociology of Science

16. infrastructures are invisible and seamless

17. Principles for Sustainability
1. Deep integration into academic community
and scholarly processes
2. Clearly defined mandate & governance
structure
3. Technology platform stability and innovation
4. Systematic development of content policies
5. Reliance on business planning strategies

18. 1. Deep Integration into Academic Community
& Scholarly Processes
• Factor in research, communication, and
collaboration practices & values
• Balance IT bandwidth with sociocultural
bandwidth
• Implement user-based strategies &
feedback cycles

19. 2. Clearly Defined Mandate & Governance
Structure
• Ensure that an organization has the
means to:
– envision its future
– implement the vision
– sustain the process over time
• Tenets:
– Participatory, accountable, transparent, res
ponsive, equitable, and inclusive

20. arXiv -- Key Principles
• General
– arXiv provides an open access repository of scientific
research to authors and researchers worldwide.
– arXiv is a scholarly communication forum informed and
guided by scientists and the scientific cultures being served.
• Editorial
– Criteria and standards for deposit in arXiv are maintained by
the Scientific Advisory Board.
• Economic
– arXiv is supported financially by Cornell University Library
and a global collective of institutional members with
potential foundation grants
• Governance
20

21. 3. Technology Platform Stability and
Innovation
• Repository ecology:
– interoperability & relation to other
repositories
– lowering the barriers in contributing content
in multiple repositories
– discovery & access: increasing relevance
– archiving for access by designated
communities
– features in support of supplementary
information objects

22. 4. Systematic Development of Content Policies
• Clearly defined collection policies and
submission guidelines
• Quality control & endorsement systems
• Scholarly communication chain
– version control & persistence
– author name disambiguation

23. 5. Reliance on Business Planning Strategies
• Key elements of a business planning
– Value proposition
– Stakeholders’ perspectives
– Financial planning – costs & revenues
– ROI
– Communication plan