Africa RISING in East and Southern Africa: Monitoring and evaluation case study
1. Africa RISING in East and Southern Africa: Monitoring
and Evaluation Case Study
Ainsley Charles, IFPRI
Africa RISING–CSISA Joint Monitoring and Evaluation Meeting,
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 11-13 November 2013
2. Items
Motivation: accountability, effectiveness, scaling
up / down
Current status
Data landscape
Specific challenges
Looking forward
3. At start-up
Existing M&E plan not operationalized
No networks of information sharing for the
purposes of monitoring
No data sharing protocols
Best description: nascent
4. AR: Data landscape
Administrative data
Surveys: questionnaires, raw and enhanced datasets, metadata
Household-level surveys
Community-level surveys
Publications: working papers, journal articles
Training events
Demonstration days
Progress reports
Interim
End-year
Feed The Future indicator reporting
Event presentations
5. Challenges
Work-package structure
Lack of integration
Establishing trust
M&E a shared responsibility
Communication & responsiveness
Example: FtF reporting, Aug-Nov 2013
Outreach: multiple, diverse
Indicators: eight (hectares, households, partnerships, technologies); type
and gender disaggregations
Research proposal element
6. Looking forward: ARMEIS
Seamless collection / collation of data
Archiving & storing data, and making it available
IT / PMT
Sharing research ideas and results cross-program (intra- and inter-)
Analyzing the data
Descriptive analysis: baseline and follow-up characterizations
Causal analysis:
Is AR effective, on average or within specific sub-populations?
Which components? And what combinations?
Disseminating results
Main condition: Effective partnerships and researcher buy-in
7. Africa Research in Sustainable Intensification for the Next Generation
africa-rising.net
Hinweis der Redaktion
As with any infancy, it needs nurturing, guidance, teaching, what’s good behavior, what’s not
Seven-nine WPs across three districts in Tz. / ‘Newness’. Why am I being asked for data? Proprietary data. / Work package leaders (raw questionnaires, data capture forms, raw and enhanced datasets) along w/local-level implementers and extensionists; research program leaders (initial reporting); chief scientists (research outputs, publications). / Estimates?