3. Chronic debilitating gynae disorder, affects 10% of women in the reproductive age
group 1
3 main types
1.PERITONEAL: 1-2cm, red, blue, black or white
2.ENDOMETRIOMA: chocolate cyst
3.D. I. E: penetrate the bowel, bladder and vaginal wall including nerves
4. 30 to 50% are infertile 2
About half will require treatment
No indices to predict those that will require treatment for infertility
Reduced fecundity 3
5. HOW DOES ENDOMETRIOSIS CAUSE
INFERTILITY
Still unclear but the following are incriminated 4
I.Anatomic distortion
II.Tubal occlusion
III.Oocyte quality / ovarian function
IV.Endometrial receptivity
6. I & II mainly due to Adhesions associated with advanced disease
11. TREATMENT OF INFERTILITY RELATED TO
ENDOMETRIOSIS
Most appropriate treatment is still controversial but we have some tools in our
armamentarium
Surgery
ART
Medical therapy though useful in alleviating, if not eliminating symptoms of
endometriosis e.g. danazol, GnRHa and progestogens have not been shown to enhance
pregnancy rates
12.
13. The clinician may need to make a decision either for surgery or ART or both to increase
the chance of pregnancy.
A comprehensive fertility assessment is therefore necessary
a) Age
b) Male factor
c) Tubal patency + Hydrosalpinges
d) Ovarian reserve
e) Uterine cavity assessment
14. Surgery may be considered for early stage disease especially less than 35 years
Hydrosalpinges
Not diagnostic laparascopy: avoid repeated surgery.
Surgery may improve spontaneous pregnancy rates in early stage disease 5
If 6-12 months→ ART
15. IUI + COH if indicated may be beneficial in minimal/mild stages.
50% reduction in pregnancy rates
3-4 cycles (ESHRE GUIDELINES for the diagnosis and treatment of
endometriosis 2008)
16. IVF represents the most efficient and successful means of achieving conception.
Indications
a) Tubal function is compromised
b) Presence of male factor
c) Age factor ≥ 38 years
d) Other treatment failed
e) Advanced disease (stage iii & iv)
Frequently associated with Adhesions, endometriomas and tubal occlusion
17.
18.
19. IMPACT OF ENDOMETRIOSIS ON IVF
OUTCOME
The issue is not yet resolved
Earlier studies showed poorer outcome in patient with
endometriosis
20.
21.
22.
23.
24. a) Increased gonadotropins needed and duration of stimulation
b) Reduced oocytes number and quality
c) Cycle cancellation higher
d) ? ICSI may give better results
e) Reduced fertilization rates
f) Reduced implantation rates
g) Pregnancy outcome poorer in advanced disease particularly
with significant ovarian involvement (endometrioma) or prior
ovarian surgery
26. CAN ANYTHING BE DONE TO MINIMIZE THE
DETRIMENTAL EFFECT OF ENDOMETRIOSIS ON
OOCYTE QUALITY?
GnRH agonist was touted to help improve clinical pregnancy rate
? Ovarian/endometrial effect; unexplained
27.
28. Further research is probably needed as there are still no diagnostic markers to
predict the group of patient that will benefit from this protocol
29. Pre-IVF surgery was also tried
The logic was to minimize the effect of peritoneal implants or their secretory products migh
have on oocyte quality, embryo development or implantation.
No obvious improvement in outcome with pre-surgical resection 6
Excision Vs Ablation
Repeated surgical excision should be avoided as large body of evidence suggest a negative
impact on ovarian reserve and response to gonadotropins
34. Rapid growth
Suspicious features on Ultra sound
Painful symptoms attributable to mass
Potential rupture in pregnancy
Inability to access follicles in normal ovarian tissue
35.
36.
37. SUMMARY
When IVF is indicated
1. Counselling:
a) May need to do multiple cycles for egg/embryo pooling + FET as number of
oocytes retrieved might be reduced especially if advanced disease or multiple
previous surgeries
b) Risk of cycle cancellation
2) Increased dosage of gonadotropins
3) Agonist or antagonist can be used
4) Endometrioma do not need to be removed unless indicated
38. 2) Avoid endometriomas at OPU to reduce risk of pelvic infection/abscess
3) Consider prolonged down regulation before FET especially in advanced disease or
previous failed cycle due to implantation failure
Lessey et al: 64% restoration of β 3 integrin expression
7) Frozen embryo transfer
39. FERTILITY PRESERVATION
FP was developed for women undergoing gonadotoxic treatments.
Improvements in methods have made it possible to apply to other conditions that
threaten ovarian reserve
The presence of endometriomas in patients with endometriosis signifies severe disease
and there is a large body of evidence showing that both it’s presence alone and
surgical excision may impact negatively on ovarian reserve 7
40.
41.
42.
43. INDICATIONS FOR FP IN ENDOMETRIOSIS
1. Severe endometriosis with bilateral endometrioma : risk of ovarian tissue damage from
treatment which can lead to premature ovarian failure
2. Recurrent endometriosis
3. ? Age < 35
48. WORD OF CAUTION
Oocyte freezing and ovarian tissue cryopreservation rely on autologous folliculogenesis,
disregarding any effect of endometriosis on follicles/oocytes quality at the time of
freezing.
Current literature provides no insight into the survival rate of frozen/thawed oocyte from
women with endometriosis compared to controls
49. CONCLUSION
The purpose of this presentation is to open discussions about the still very poorly
understood disease and to point to the need for further research in the management of
infertility associated with endometriosis.
Hinweis der Redaktion
Schwatz et al 0.15-0.20 per month in normal couples Vs 0.02-0.10 in women with endometriosis
In a retrospective study in 1994. Simon et al showed recipient with severe endometriosis have same chance of implantation and pregnancy using oocytes from healthy donors. In contrast embryos from donors with endometriosis shows reduction in implantation rates.
Went on to show using sibling oocyte in recipient with severe endometriosis and those without. No difference in implantation / pregnancy
In a recent review of literature Sanchez et al 2017 confirmed that the quality of the oocyte is affected by ENDO.
↓P450 aromatase activity (Granulosa cell)
↑Follicular oxidative stress status
Higher levels of iron in follicular fluid of
follicles developing adjacent to endometriomas
Arici et al from Yale university, Garrido et al pointed out the contribution of endometrial receptivity together with oocyte quality
Our experience in Nigeria, over 60% present in advanced stage in a retrospective study and like ESHRE DATA , women with minimal/mild endometriosis had a better live birth than women with advanced stage disease - Ajayi et al
Barnhat et at (Pennsylvania) 2002: meta-analysis which included clinical trials btw 1983-98. Data from 22 non-randomized involving 2377 IVF cycles of women with endo and 4383 cycles of non affected women
Lower number of oocytes , fertilization rates, implantation and pregnancy rates.
The fertilization rate in women with severe was higher than minimal and tubal infertility
Harb et al (Birmingham Uk)2013: meta-analysis showed a reduction in fertilization rate fro 27 studies in minimal/mild but no significant reduction in fertilization rate in moderate/severs. However implantation and clinical pregnancy rates were reduced
Shebl et al: patient with endo have lower quality oocytes. Therefore fertilization rate is different in IVF and ICSI (ICSI preffered)
Once fertilized no impairment on further pre-implantation embryo development and pregnancy out come.
***Longer stimulation period
Komsky- Elbaz et al (Israel) 2013: using sibling oocytes and normospermic semen showed ICSI better than IVF
2002 SART data and more recent studies like the Latin American registry concluded that pregnancy outcome was not altered by ENDO but a closer look at many of these studies brought some things into the fore
Endo is oestrogen dependent but in spite of higher levels of estradiol from the use of higher dosage of gonadotropins. Symptoms did not worsen and even the size of Endometriosis did not change 3-6 months after IVF treatment
Surrey et al , 51 patients 25 Vs 26
Increased implantation, clinical pregnancy and 35% increased live birth rates
Sallam et al: 163 patient agreed
Belgium: RCT tested efficacy of the three month long GnRH agonist treatment prior to IVF. Looking at number of M2 oocytes retrieved as main outcome and failed to find any benefit
GARCIA Velasco and Somigiliana proposed a series of indicators
Somigiana emphasized the importance of caution as they reported a 53% reduction in gonadotropin responsiveness in ovaries that have been operated irrespective of size of cyst and 13% did not produce follicles at all. Following unilateral endometrioma removal
Khamsi et al showed that exposure of human oocyte to endometrioma fluid does not alter fertilization rates
Advocating for early diagnosis and intervention to protect ovarian function of women
Donnez pointed out that endometrioma only has a pseudo plane →ovarian tissue loss
Somigliana showed declining AMH levels after cystectomy
Kitajima et al showed that follicular density was significantly lower in the cortex from ovaries with endometriomas than in cortex of contralateral ovaries without endometrioma . They then postulated than the presence of endometrioma even less than 4cm induce local inflammation in ovarian cortex which causes activation of follicular recruitment and early atresia of follicles : follicle burnout