Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Engineers, 3D Objects, and Rhetoric
1. Engineers, 3D objects,
and Rhetoric
How do engineering students use 3D
objects and other visual artifacts to
develop their
designs and communi-
cate ideas to other
stakeholders?
Tom Burns
Eng 5389
2. Marketing Communication
is Changing
• Manufacturers and distributors
increasingly are using 3DCAD
models to entice potential customers
• Reid Supply
• McMaster-Carr
6. Selected Survey Results
• 50% of students responded to the
survey
• 100% of the students use Solidworks
Software
(1 years license supplied by SPSU)
• 75% self-identify as experienced –
25% self-identify as novice users
7. Selected Survey Results
• 75% of the students repurpose their CAD
models for use in illustrations.
• 38% of the students use the models to create
animations.
• 38% of the students use the models to create
marketing visuals.
• One student uses the models to fabricate parts
using rapid prototyping equipment.
8. Class Observations
• Five teams of students make four
types of design presentations.
1. Design Requirements
2. Conceptual/Parametric Design
3. Detailed Design
4. Final Rollout
9. Students use imagery derived from
a variety of sources to create a sort
of visual equation to communicate
their design concepts
=
+ +
12. Document Analysis
• Three sets of presentations from five
teams were analyzed
1. Team usage of image vs. text usage
compared
2. Total number of images used by all teams
compared with text usage
3. Coding and analysis of rhetorical images
13. Team Use of Image Per Slide
Compared To All Text Use Per
Slide
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
First Presentation Second Presentation Third Presentation
AG
AV
BP
PP
UGV
14. Overall Image Use Per Slide
Compared To Text Use Per
Slide
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
First Presentation Second Presentation Third Presentation
Image
Text
15. What are Engineering
Drawings?
• Orthogonal or two-dimensional plan,
profile, and section drawings are the
acknowledged carriers of engineering
product information.
• Isometric views are used in illustrations –
as pretty pictures – for maintenance and
operations manuals (Henderson 1999, pg
37).
16. What are Technical
Illustrations?
• Technical illustrations offer realistic or
semi-realistic views of an object or
process (Brasseur 2003, pg. 11).
• The goal, of course, in a technical
illustration is to convey information in a
realistic yet simplified view (Brasseur
2003, pg. 45).
21. Conclusion
• Data suggests that 3DCAD
provides a hybrid-genre that
crosses the professional
domains of Engineering and
Technical Communication
22. References
Brasseur, L., E. (2003). Visualizing technical information: A cultural critique. Baywood
Publishing Company, Inc., Amityville, NY
Henderson, K., R. (1999). On line and on paper: Visual representations, visual culture,
and computer graphics in design engineering. Graphics Press, Cheshire, CT
Hisarciklilar, O., Boujut, J. F., (2008). Symbolic vs. iconic: How to support argumentative
design discourse with 3D product representations. IDMME-Virtual Concept, Beijing
23. Students use 3DCAD to generate
photo-realistic objects to persuade
stakeholders of design plausability
Hinweis der Redaktion
The rapid adoption of 3DCAD to communicate a variety of information may be observed throughout all forms of engineering. References to its use may be seen in design magazines and product catalogs. Manufacturers, and distributors are promoting their product availability through the provision of 3D models engineers need to complete their design. Some manufacturers feature these CAD files prominently on their website splash page as an enticement for potential customers. As this form of marketing communication evolves it may displace the conventional documents typically associated with technical communication.
This diagram traces the 3D object as it’s used as a mediating artifact between the various stakeholders and institutions as students learn to organize their engineering data in a persuasive and effective manner. As this diagram shows, there are multiple stakeholders in the activity system associated with the student presentations. This system is bounded and structured by the rules of the engineering community and the student’s aspiration to take their place in the engineering ranks as a professional.
3D models have a great range of potential rhetorical expression.
キ3D models and various derivatives
キ3D physical materializations (manufactured products)
キ3D animations
キ2D drawings and illustrations
キSketches for designing 3D models
キActivity participants commenting on models
キStakeholder proposals
キSponsor solicitations for donations
In their exploration of 3D objects used for rhetorical purposes in collaborative engineering, Hisarcikilar and Boujut developed a continuum model measuring differences between icons and symbols based on Pierce’s typology of signs.
I’ve expanded the granularity of H&R continuum to include the default expressions of Solidworks.