SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 45
Show Me the $! How Russian
         SMEs can Raise Foreign Capital
3rd Moscow Venture Forum:
Moscow Russia, 17/18 June 2009

                 Innovative Ventures Inc.
                     Haslett, MI. USA
                     Moscow, Russia
                                           Thomas Nastas
                                                Founder
                                          Tom@IVIpe.com
                                          www.IVIpe.com
   17/18 June 2009       www.IVIpe.com
                         Info@IVIpe.com
Today’s Message
Part I
What’s Happening in the Market, VC/PE?
   The Good & the Bad

Part II
Russian SMEs: Raise Foreign Capital!
   Clarify Motivation & Your Reasons Why
   Improve Your Chances of Success
   Specific Actions to Take
  17/18 June 2009      www.IVIpe.com
                       Info@IVIpe.com
IVI History-Direct Invest &
                        Advisory
  Canada (1992)
                                                  Europe (1992/94)
C$100MM-Canadian
  Bus. Dev. Bank                                  TP Fund, $10MM-
                                                  EU, $-Financière
                                                  St Dominique,
                                                  Paris


     USA (1986)
                                                   Russia (1997)
The Michigan Product
Dev. Fund ($5MM)                                HP LP, $30MM-EBRD &
                                                USAID
                         Africa (1993/96)
                       E. Africa $5MM, Sub-
                       Saharan, $200MM, South
                       Africa,$30MM, IFC/WB
   17/18 June 2009     www.IVIpe.com
                       Info@IVIpe.com
About Me
                               • Founder of IVI,1986. In
                                 Russia since 1997

                               • Moscow Bank, Member,
                                 Board of Directors, 2007
                  Ассоциация
                  независимых • Member, Board of Directors,
                  директоров    2008

                               • Moscow MBA Program, Prof
                                 of VC & Marketing, 2002/9

                               • Moscow, MBA Advising, 2001
17/18 June 2009             www.IVIpe.com
                            Info@IVIpe.com
Part I: What’s Happening in
                  the Market?

                  The Good & the Bad




17/18 June 2009         www.IVIpe.com
                        Info@IVIpe.com
Successes in the Market
                    Since 2001

                                              PBC Lasers
                                              & Wostec




        Multinationals w/R&D Labs in Russia


17/18 June 2009       www.IVIpe.com
                      Info@IVIpe.com
Limited Success in Raising
                     Int’l $



                             Insight Venture
                                 Partners




17/18 June 2009     www.IVIpe.com
                    Info@IVIpe.com
Crisis in Int’l PE/VC
                                           Distributions from Funds to LPs (Investors)

                                          100%
                                          90%                               15%
                                                     29%
                                          80%                                                     41%
                                          70%
              R e s p o n d e n ts (% )




                                                      6%
                                                                            42%                                        74%
                                          60%
                                          50%
                                          40%                                                     37%
                                          30%        65%

                                          20%                               43%
                                                                                                                       22%
                                          10%                                                     22%

                                           0%                                                                           4%
                                                 Winter 2004-05       Summer 2006             Winter 2007-8         Summer 2009
Source: Collier Capital
                                                                  Improve         No change           Deteriorate

        17/18 June 2009                                                      www.IVIpe.com
                                                                             Info@IVIpe.com
Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t
                                                              % LPs Receiving >16% Net Returns

                                 100%
                                  90%
                                  80%
     R e s p o n d e n ts (% )




                                  70%
                                  60%
                                  50%
                                  40%
                                  30%
                                  20%
                                  10%
                                   0%
                                            Funds-of-       North American   North American   European venture   European buyouts Asia-Pacific venture   Asia-Pacific
                                         funds/generalist       venture         buyouts                                                                   buyouts
Source: Collier                                                                     16% or more       Less than 16%
   Capital
                                 17/18 June 2009                                      www.IVIpe.com
                                                                                      Info@IVIpe.com
Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t
                             LP Plans for Investment (Over Next 3 years)
                             100%
                                        9%
                             90%
                                                                     31%
                             80%

                             70%        40%
           Respondents (%)




                             60%

                             50%                                     39%
                             40%

                             30%
                                        51%
                             20%
                                                                     30%
                             10%

                              0%
                                      Summer                       Summer
Source: Collier Capital                 2006                         2009
                                       Increase      No change      Decrease

   17/18 June 2009                                www.IVIpe.com
                                                  Info@IVIpe.com
Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t
                                   LPs Declining to Invest in Last 12 Months
                                   100%
                                     90%                                                         16%
                                                                           29%
                                     80%
                                                    55%
                 Respondents (%)




                                     70%
                                     60%
                                     50%
                                     40%                                                         84%
                                                                           71%
                                     30%
                                     20%            45%
                                     10%
                                      0%
Source: Collier Capital
                                                  Summer                  Summer              Summer
                                                    2005                    2007                2009
                                   Declined some re-investment requests       Accepted all re-investment requests

      17/18 June 2009                                        www.IVIpe.com
                                                             Info@IVIpe.com
Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t
                     Likely Valuations; 12/09 vs. 12/08

                                       Lower by Higher by
                                       41-60% up to 20%
                                         (4%)     (6%)
                                                             Remain
                                                            unchanged
                                                              (18%)
                            Lower by
                            21-40%
                             (33%)




  Source: Collier Capital
                                                Lower by
                                                up to 20%
                                                  (39%)

17/18 June 2009                        www.IVIpe.com
                                       Info@IVIpe.com
Crisis in Int’l PE/VC
     Proportion of VC/Buyout Funds Unable to Raise New $
                        within 7 Years


      Venture capital firms                     28%
      Buyout firms                              23%


Conclusions: less $ for VC, more competitive for LP $ & VC $:
                 VC invest in profitable SMEs
    Source: Collier Capital




  17/18 June 2009              www.IVIpe.com
                               Info@IVIpe.com
Part II: GoForward Plan to
            Raising Int’l VC $$
    Issues For Entrepreneurs/SMEs:
1. Why Int’l $-location of customers
   & access the market for expansion
   vs. start-up or ego
2. Stage of development, seed vs.
   growth
3. Proof: Are you best in class, top 3
   in your industry?
  17/18 June 2009   www.IVIpe.com
                    Info@IVIpe.com
Reasons Why
Components of SME Success                Probability
  Company has enough $$                       80%
  Mgt Capable & Focused                       80%
  PD Successful                               80%
  Mfging Successful                           80%
  Competitors Behave as Expected              80%
  Customers Want Product                      80%
  Pricing is Correct                          80%
  IP Issued                                   80%
Combined Probability of Success              17%
Success Rate <10% if Probability of One Event falls
from 80% to 50%
   17/18 June 2009     www.IVIpe.com
                       Info@IVIpe.com
Realities of VC Investment
   Ex: Global Spend in Clean Tech
                (2006)
• Corporate R&D Investment = $22 billion
• Government R&D Investment = $24 Billion
• VC Investment in R&D = $2 Billion

Same Pattern Repeated in Most Industries:
VCs Fund Commercialization Risk, not Tech
 17/18 June 2009    www.IVIpe.com
                    Info@IVIpe.com
Reasons for Rejecting
                   Russian Tech Deals




17/18 June 2009         www.IVIpe.com
                        Info@IVIpe.com
Reasons for Rejecting
                   Russian Tech Deals




17/18 June 2009         www.IVIpe.com
                        Info@IVIpe.com
Action Item #1 for
            Entrepreneurs/SMEs
1. Build Demand in the Supply Chain
   Link to Multinationals Interest: User Pull,
    Testing, Deploy & Commercialize

   Solve Tech & Supply Chain Needs/New
    Apps

   Don’t Worry about Small Volumes

    Build Locally, Upgrade Later for National &
          Int’l Expansion Info@IVIpe.com
  17/18 June 2009         www.IVIpe.com
Where’s the Customer Pain
               (Need) in the Industry?
1. MORE Perf, Execution & Cost Reduction
   Not GameChangers; blocking/tackling tech so
    customers meet business plan
2. MORE Local Content Applications
   Focus on Tech Challenges for Dev. & Growth




   17/18 June 2009    www.IVIpe.com
                      Info@IVIpe.com
Examples: Get Integrated
              into Global/Russian Projects
1. Apps for Smartphone & Social Platforms
2. In <15 months, iPhone, Blackberry, Google &
   Facebook (fbfund) funds invested over $55
   million into 80 companies
    New Companies & New Employment
    New Applications for Smartphones, Google
     Android & Facebook
    More Investment
    New Ideas
    17/18 June 2009    www.IVIpe.com
                       Info@IVIpe.com
Examples: Get Integrated
              into Global/Russian Projects
3. HP ‘Central Nervous System for Earth
    Nanosensors & IT to gather, transmit & monitor
     data on a global scale through intelligent nano-
     fabric networks
4. IBM’s Smart Planet Initiative
5. Cisco & NASA: ‘Planetary Skin’ Project
    Capture, collect, analyze & report environment
     data from satellite, airborne, sea & land sensors
     across Earth
    17/18 June 2009    www.IVIpe.com
                       Info@IVIpe.com
Examples: Get Integrated
              into Global/Russian Projects
6. Russia: Shtokman, Natural Resources for
   Solar & Alt. Energy Business Models
    Nitol Solar: Raised $500 million from Chinese &
     US customers, IFC & Rusnano.
    Chemical division processes chlorine, caustic
     soda and others to produce trichlorosilane (raw
     material for polysilicon production)
    Polysilicon Division processes raw material into
     photovoltaic wafers
    17/18 June 2009    www.IVIpe.com
                       Info@IVIpe.com
Domestic Opts to Build Bio-
                      Tech Supply Chain in Russia
    Agricultural        Drugs &    Medical Devices           Hospitals      Research, Testing, &
Feedstock/Chemicals Pharmaceuticals & Equipment                                Medical Labs

 Agricultural           Medicinal &    Laboratory        Specialty        Biological
 processing              botanicals      apparatus &        hospitals         research
 Basic organic                          furniture
                         Pharma-                           University       Commercial
 chemicals               ceutical        Surgical,         medical           medical
 Ethyl alcohol          preparations   medical, dental,    research          research
  mfg.                                  ophthalmic          hospitals
                         Diagnostic    & analytical                          Testing
Organic fiber           substances     instruments &       Clinical         laboratories
 mfg.                                   equipment           research
                         Biological                        institutions      Medical
 Fertilizers            products        Irradiation                          laboratories &
                                         apparatus &                           diagnostic
 Pesticides and                                                               imaging
 other agricultural                      electromedical
 chemicals                               equipment                             centers



     17/18 June 2009   Product-Oriented www.IVIpe.com                Service-Oriented
                                         Info@IVIpe.com
Action Item #2 for
                    Entrepreneurs/SMEs
2. Benchmark Your Tech to Competitors
  & Alternative

    Often & Early
    Define Strengths & Weaknesses
    Test Under Different Operating &
     Customer Conditions
    Invest to Overcome Deficiencies

  17/18 June 2009        www.IVIpe.com
                         Info@IVIpe.com
17/18 June 2009   www.IVIpe.com
                  Info@IVIpe.com
17/18 June 2009   www.IVIpe.com
                  Info@IVIpe.com
The Standard?




17/18 June 2009     www.IVIpe.com
                    Info@IVIpe.com
Competition is Every Where




17/18 June 2009   www.IVIpe.com
                  Info@IVIpe.com
Multiple Sources of
                     Competition




17/18 June 2009       www.IVIpe.com
                      Info@IVIpe.com
Build the Basics




17/18 June 2009      www.IVIpe.com
                     Info@IVIpe.com
Action Item #3 for
                    Entrepreneurs/SMEs
3. Create Relationships & Leverage
  Existing Ones
    Get Integrated into Supply Chains of SMEs
     that have raised Russian or Int’l $, e.g.,
     Acronis, Parallels, Ozon, Enforta, Volga
     Gas, Air-in-Space
    Prove your contribution to their business
    Participate in Int’l Biz Plan Competitions
     to Develop Awareness & Mkt. Reaction
  17/18 June 2009        www.IVIpe.com
                         Info@IVIpe.com
Action Item #4 for
                    Entrepreneurs/SMEs
4. Target Int’l Funding Orgs’ for $

    For R&D, Testing & PD Funding
    USIC, CRDF, ISTC, EU Eureka/EuropeAid
    In-Q-Tel (CIA VC fund) & Red Planet (US
     Army) if you have US presence & in their
     target for investment

     Attract $ from Russian groups like Rusnano to start.
              Build relationships with RVC (РВК)
  17/18 June 2009        www.IVIpe.com
                         Info@IVIpe.com
Concluding Remarks




17/18 June 2009       www.IVIpe.com
                      Info@IVIpe.com
Don’t Give Up




17/18 June 2009     www.IVIpe.com
                    Info@IVIpe.com
Believe in Yourself/Accept
                      Rejection

  Oldest VC Firm, investing since 1911
  Deals Rejected:

                                          Apollo Computer
                            (acquired by Hewlett Packard)
 BVP's Felda Hardymon was offered a small position in the
  company's last private round, and rejected it: too small
         a position, he thought, at too high a price. In less
                        than a year it was worth 17x more.
17/18 June 2009        www.IVIpe.com
                       Info@IVIpe.com
Believe in Yourself/Accept
                 Rejection

 Deal Rejected:



                                                    Check Point
             In 1994, Gil Schwed pitched his idea to BVP's David
                      Cowan, who said that Gil would never get
        distribution in the US. The next year, Check Point got
                  a huge Sun OEM deal and sold $25M of firewall
17/18 June 2009
                                                      software.
                        www.IVIpe.com
                        Info@IVIpe.com
Believe in Yourself/Accept
                      Rejection

  Deal Rejected:



                                                    eBay
  "Stamps? Coins? Comic books? You've GOT to be kidding,"
                       thought Cowan. "No-brainer pass."


17/18 June 2009       www.IVIpe.com
                      Info@IVIpe.com
Believe in Yourself/Accept
                  Rejection

  Deal Rejected:



                                         Federal Express
 Incredibly, BVP declined on Federal Express seven times.




17/18 June 2009       www.IVIpe.com
                      Info@IVIpe.com
Believe in Yourself/Accept
                 Rejection

 Deal Rejected:

                                                         Google
        Cowan’s college friend rented her garage to Sergey &
          Larry their 1st year. In 1999 and 2000 she introduced
           Cowan to “these two really smart Stanford students
                writing a search engine.” Students? A new search
                engine? In the most important moment ever for a
        Bessemer rejection, Cowan asked her, “How can I get
              out of this house without going near your garage?”
17/18 June 2009         www.IVIpe.com
                        Info@IVIpe.com
Believe in Yourself/Accept
                      Rejection

  Deal Rejected:

                                                      Paypal
       David Cowan declined on the Series A round. Young &
          unproven team, regulatory problems, and, 4 years
                   later, a $1.5 billion acquisition by eBay.




17/18 June 2009          www.IVIpe.com
                         Info@IVIpe.com
Believe in Yourself/Accept
                      Rejection

  Deal Rejected:

                                                  StrataCom
                                          (acquired by Cisco)
  Felda Hardymon: "[Sierra's] Pete Wendell asked if I'd like
     to invest in Stratacom, which was doing a 'fast packet
                          switch.' I gave him a blank stare."


17/18 June 2009         www.IVIpe.com
                        Info@IVIpe.com
Technology In Many Places!
                Just Look & Define


    Slaughter                        Raising          Genetic Engineering
                                                         & Breeding




                                                            Butcher
                            Distribution, Storage &       Retail Locations
Processing- Ham, Kielbasa
                                    Delivery
    17/18 June 2009             www.IVIpe.com
                                Info@IVIpe.com
Download at
                                   www.IVIpe.com
                                     News 2007




17/18 June 2009   www.IVIpe.com
                  Info@IVIpe.com
Thomas D. Nastas
                       Tom@IVIpe.com
                       www.IVIpe.com
                    Tel. 7.985.923.47.27
Innovative Ventures Inc. Moscow, Russia
                                            Haslett, MI USA
  17/18 June 2009          www.IVIpe.com
                           Info@IVIpe.com

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Investment Opportunities in Emerging Europe
Investment Opportunities in Emerging EuropeInvestment Opportunities in Emerging Europe
Investment Opportunities in Emerging EuropePete Chatziplis
 
Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011
Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011
Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011Everest Group
 
Are you feeling repressed september 2012 e
Are you feeling repressed  september 2012 eAre you feeling repressed  september 2012 e
Are you feeling repressed september 2012 eJared Buckley
 
The Swiss Watch Industries
The Swiss Watch IndustriesThe Swiss Watch Industries
The Swiss Watch IndustriesAbhishek Kapoor
 

Was ist angesagt? (6)

Investment Opportunities in Emerging Europe
Investment Opportunities in Emerging EuropeInvestment Opportunities in Emerging Europe
Investment Opportunities in Emerging Europe
 
Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011
Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011
Outsourcing Deal Activity - February 2011
 
Are you feeling repressed september 2012 e
Are you feeling repressed  september 2012 eAre you feeling repressed  september 2012 e
Are you feeling repressed september 2012 e
 
Jp littlebook
Jp littlebookJp littlebook
Jp littlebook
 
CBRE - m
CBRE - mCBRE - m
CBRE - m
 
The Swiss Watch Industries
The Swiss Watch IndustriesThe Swiss Watch Industries
The Swiss Watch Industries
 

Andere mochten auch

Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...
Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...
Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...Michel Dumontier
 
UserZoom: Search For People Online Study
UserZoom: Search For People Online StudyUserZoom: Search For People Online Study
UserZoom: Search For People Online StudyUserZoom
 
Intro to Social Media
Intro to Social MediaIntro to Social Media
Intro to Social MediaSascha Funk
 
OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7
OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7
OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7BYOUNG GON KIM
 
The Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big Data
The Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big DataThe Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big Data
The Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big DataEugen Glavan
 
What Is Windows Azure
What Is Windows AzureWhat Is Windows Azure
What Is Windows AzureDominic Green
 
AtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy Slide
AtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy SlideAtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy Slide
AtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy SlideJohnson Goh
 
Wealth Creation from New Zealand Science and Technology
Wealth Creation from New Zealand Science and TechnologyWealth Creation from New Zealand Science and Technology
Wealth Creation from New Zealand Science and TechnologyIain Sanders
 
Resources
ResourcesResources
Resourcesjactlc
 
Rdash demo
Rdash demoRdash demo
Rdash demoJobs2web
 
D4 I Framework Web
D4 I Framework WebD4 I Framework Web
D4 I Framework WebIain Sanders
 
Cinch Inch Loss Plan Testimonials
Cinch Inch Loss Plan TestimonialsCinch Inch Loss Plan Testimonials
Cinch Inch Loss Plan TestimonialsJohnine Bailey
 
Geekmeet Iasi Intro
Geekmeet Iasi IntroGeekmeet Iasi Intro
Geekmeet Iasi IntroGeekMeet
 
Certificación inversión o gasto
Certificación inversión o gastoCertificación inversión o gasto
Certificación inversión o gastoIvo Castillo
 
Formtech Composites Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1 Polymer ...
Formtech Composites   Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1   Polymer ...Formtech Composites   Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1   Polymer ...
Formtech Composites Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1 Polymer ...presspley
 
Harmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologies
Harmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologiesHarmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologies
Harmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologiesMichel Dumontier
 
Wight session 5 digital presentation
Wight session 5 digital presentationWight session 5 digital presentation
Wight session 5 digital presentationmrswight
 

Andere mochten auch (20)

Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...
Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...
Molecular symmetry and specialization of atomic connectivity by class-based r...
 
UserZoom: Search For People Online Study
UserZoom: Search For People Online StudyUserZoom: Search For People Online Study
UserZoom: Search For People Online Study
 
Intro to Social Media
Intro to Social MediaIntro to Social Media
Intro to Social Media
 
OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7
OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7
OpenSource Big Data Platform - Flamingo v7
 
The Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big Data
The Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big DataThe Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big Data
The Sociology of Nothingness: Challenges of Big Data
 
What Is Windows Azure
What Is Windows AzureWhat Is Windows Azure
What Is Windows Azure
 
SecurVoice 2010
SecurVoice 2010SecurVoice 2010
SecurVoice 2010
 
AtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy Slide
AtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy SlideAtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy Slide
AtticTV Pte. Ltd. Strategy Slide
 
Wealth Creation from New Zealand Science and Technology
Wealth Creation from New Zealand Science and TechnologyWealth Creation from New Zealand Science and Technology
Wealth Creation from New Zealand Science and Technology
 
Public Speaking for Salesman
Public Speaking for SalesmanPublic Speaking for Salesman
Public Speaking for Salesman
 
Resources
ResourcesResources
Resources
 
Rdash demo
Rdash demoRdash demo
Rdash demo
 
MOTIVATION
MOTIVATIONMOTIVATION
MOTIVATION
 
D4 I Framework Web
D4 I Framework WebD4 I Framework Web
D4 I Framework Web
 
Cinch Inch Loss Plan Testimonials
Cinch Inch Loss Plan TestimonialsCinch Inch Loss Plan Testimonials
Cinch Inch Loss Plan Testimonials
 
Geekmeet Iasi Intro
Geekmeet Iasi IntroGeekmeet Iasi Intro
Geekmeet Iasi Intro
 
Certificación inversión o gasto
Certificación inversión o gastoCertificación inversión o gasto
Certificación inversión o gasto
 
Formtech Composites Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1 Polymer ...
Formtech Composites   Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1   Polymer ...Formtech Composites   Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1   Polymer ...
Formtech Composites Composite Material Substitution In Formula 1 Polymer ...
 
Harmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologies
Harmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologiesHarmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologies
Harmony 2011: Formalization of SBML models as OWL ontologies
 
Wight session 5 digital presentation
Wight session 5 digital presentationWight session 5 digital presentation
Wight session 5 digital presentation
 

Ähnlich wie IVI (Tom Nastas) Presentation At 3rd Moscow Venture Fair

Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013
Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013
Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013Burton Lee
 
Business plan presentation v10.0
Business plan presentation v10.0Business plan presentation v10.0
Business plan presentation v10.0Darshan Shah
 
Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...
Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...
Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...Banco Popular
 
C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.
C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.
C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.Ricardo Ocampo
 
Media landscape updater i 2012
Media landscape updater i 2012Media landscape updater i 2012
Media landscape updater i 2012MediaDirectionOMD
 
Palestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van Agtmael
Palestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van AgtmaelPalestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van Agtmael
Palestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van AgtmaelBienal da Energia 2009
 
Distributing Video To The Masses
Distributing Video To The MassesDistributing Video To The Masses
Distributing Video To The MassesRichard Harrington
 
20090416 Update
20090416 Update20090416 Update
20090416 Updatebcondon42
 
2. Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...
2.	Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...2.	Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...
2. Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...comexcr
 
Middle Market M&A Platform Business Pitch
Middle Market M&A Platform Business PitchMiddle Market M&A Platform Business Pitch
Middle Market M&A Platform Business PitchPete Chatziplis
 

Ähnlich wie IVI (Tom Nastas) Presentation At 3rd Moscow Venture Fair (20)

Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
 
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
 
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
Pepperdine cost of capital national summit 10 18 2011
 
Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013
Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013
Anne Glover - Amadeus Capital - UK - Stanford - Jan 7 2013
 
Standard Chartered Bank BeyondBRIC
Standard Chartered Bank BeyondBRICStandard Chartered Bank BeyondBRIC
Standard Chartered Bank BeyondBRIC
 
Business plan presentation v10.0
Business plan presentation v10.0Business plan presentation v10.0
Business plan presentation v10.0
 
Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...
Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...
Ángel Ron: Competir en tiempo de crisis: un entorno desafiante para los banco...
 
Factors to Consider in Project Valuation
Factors to Consider in Project ValuationFactors to Consider in Project Valuation
Factors to Consider in Project Valuation
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Iberiabank Corp
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Iberiabank CorpQ1 2009 Earning Report of Iberiabank Corp
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Iberiabank Corp
 
Spread economy
Spread economySpread economy
Spread economy
 
UBS Ad:Tech 2009
UBS Ad:Tech 2009UBS Ad:Tech 2009
UBS Ad:Tech 2009
 
Galloway Capital
Galloway CapitalGalloway Capital
Galloway Capital
 
C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.
C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.
C. describe a time when you took a great risk. what was the outcome.
 
Media landscape updater i 2012
Media landscape updater i 2012Media landscape updater i 2012
Media landscape updater i 2012
 
Palestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van Agtmael
Palestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van AgtmaelPalestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van Agtmael
Palestra: O Futuro dos Países Emergentes. Palestrante: Antoine van Agtmael
 
Florent
FlorentFlorent
Florent
 
Distributing Video To The Masses
Distributing Video To The MassesDistributing Video To The Masses
Distributing Video To The Masses
 
20090416 Update
20090416 Update20090416 Update
20090416 Update
 
2. Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...
2.	Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...2.	Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...
2. Impulsando el desarrollo a través de la atracción de IED en los sectores d...
 
Middle Market M&A Platform Business Pitch
Middle Market M&A Platform Business PitchMiddle Market M&A Platform Business Pitch
Middle Market M&A Platform Business Pitch
 

Mehr von Thomas Nastas

Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment CorpNastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment CorpThomas Nastas
 
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment CorpNastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment CorpThomas Nastas
 
Bridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFC
Bridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFCBridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFC
Bridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFCThomas Nastas
 
Ivi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazan
Ivi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazanIvi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazan
Ivi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazanThomas Nastas
 
Tom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, english
Tom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, englishTom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, english
Tom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, englishThomas Nastas
 
From idea, feasibility to prototype
From idea, feasibility to prototypeFrom idea, feasibility to prototype
From idea, feasibility to prototypeThomas Nastas
 
Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...
Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...
Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...Thomas Nastas
 
Nastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network Creation
Nastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network CreationNastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network Creation
Nastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network CreationThomas Nastas
 
Path to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant Competition
Path to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant CompetitionPath to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant Competition
Path to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant CompetitionThomas Nastas
 
Grant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization Project
Grant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization ProjectGrant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization Project
Grant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization ProjectThomas Nastas
 
More Edisons Needed, not Einsteins: By Nastas
More Edisons Needed, not Einsteins:  By NastasMore Edisons Needed, not Einsteins:  By Nastas
More Edisons Needed, not Einsteins: By NastasThomas Nastas
 
Financing Innovation in Croatia: By Tom Nastas
Financing Innovation in Croatia:  By Tom NastasFinancing Innovation in Croatia:  By Tom Nastas
Financing Innovation in Croatia: By Tom NastasThomas Nastas
 
English, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
English, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-ContributionsEnglish, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
English, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-ContributionsThomas Nastas
 
IVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam description
IVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam descriptionIVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam description
IVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam descriptionThomas Nastas
 
Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...
Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...
Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...Thomas Nastas
 
Tom Nastas board of directors appointments
Tom Nastas board of directors appointmentsTom Nastas board of directors appointments
Tom Nastas board of directors appointmentsThomas Nastas
 
Russian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
Russian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-ContributionsRussian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
Russian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-ContributionsThomas Nastas
 
English Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus Review
English Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus ReviewEnglish Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus Review
English Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus ReviewThomas Nastas
 

Mehr von Thomas Nastas (20)

TCP_Infograph
TCP_InfographTCP_Infograph
TCP_Infograph
 
TCP_Infograph
TCP_InfographTCP_Infograph
TCP_Infograph
 
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment CorpNastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
 
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment CorpNastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
Nastas Appointment by Michigan Governor R. Snyder, Early Stage Investment Corp
 
Bridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFC
Bridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFCBridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFC
Bridging the Valley of Death, Nastas Presentation at World Bank & IFC
 
Ivi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazan
Ivi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazanIvi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazan
Ivi master class path to commercialization for csu exec ed mba in kazan
 
Tom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, english
Tom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, englishTom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, english
Tom Nastas 2011 2 page summary, english
 
From idea, feasibility to prototype
From idea, feasibility to prototypeFrom idea, feasibility to prototype
From idea, feasibility to prototype
 
Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...
Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...
Entrepreneurship & Capital, Engines that Power an Economy Forward, Nastas Pre...
 
Nastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network Creation
Nastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network CreationNastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network Creation
Nastas Presentation, Int'l Partners & Network Creation
 
Path to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant Competition
Path to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant CompetitionPath to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant Competition
Path to Commercialization, Nastas Presentation to Winner of Grant Competition
 
Grant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization Project
Grant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization ProjectGrant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization Project
Grant Awards, Kazakhstan, Tech Commercialization Project
 
More Edisons Needed, not Einsteins: By Nastas
More Edisons Needed, not Einsteins:  By NastasMore Edisons Needed, not Einsteins:  By Nastas
More Edisons Needed, not Einsteins: By Nastas
 
Financing Innovation in Croatia: By Tom Nastas
Financing Innovation in Croatia:  By Tom NastasFinancing Innovation in Croatia:  By Tom Nastas
Financing Innovation in Croatia: By Tom Nastas
 
English, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
English, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-ContributionsEnglish, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
English, Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
 
IVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam description
IVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam descriptionIVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam description
IVI Program, 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' progam description
 
Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...
Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...
Schedule, IVI Program (Content in documents) 'Scaling Up Entrepreneurship,' E...
 
Tom Nastas board of directors appointments
Tom Nastas board of directors appointmentsTom Nastas board of directors appointments
Tom Nastas board of directors appointments
 
Russian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
Russian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-ContributionsRussian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
Russian & English: Nastas Ltrs of Confirmation-Contributions
 
English Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus Review
English Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus ReviewEnglish Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus Review
English Translation Of Go Forward Plan, Harvard Bus Review
 

IVI (Tom Nastas) Presentation At 3rd Moscow Venture Fair

  • 1. Show Me the $! How Russian SMEs can Raise Foreign Capital 3rd Moscow Venture Forum: Moscow Russia, 17/18 June 2009 Innovative Ventures Inc. Haslett, MI. USA Moscow, Russia Thomas Nastas Founder Tom@IVIpe.com www.IVIpe.com 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 2. Today’s Message Part I What’s Happening in the Market, VC/PE? The Good & the Bad Part II Russian SMEs: Raise Foreign Capital! Clarify Motivation & Your Reasons Why Improve Your Chances of Success Specific Actions to Take 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 3. IVI History-Direct Invest & Advisory Canada (1992) Europe (1992/94) C$100MM-Canadian Bus. Dev. Bank TP Fund, $10MM- EU, $-Financière St Dominique, Paris USA (1986) Russia (1997) The Michigan Product Dev. Fund ($5MM) HP LP, $30MM-EBRD & USAID Africa (1993/96) E. Africa $5MM, Sub- Saharan, $200MM, South Africa,$30MM, IFC/WB 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 4. About Me • Founder of IVI,1986. In Russia since 1997 • Moscow Bank, Member, Board of Directors, 2007 Ассоциация независимых • Member, Board of Directors, директоров 2008 • Moscow MBA Program, Prof of VC & Marketing, 2002/9 • Moscow, MBA Advising, 2001 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 5. Part I: What’s Happening in the Market? The Good & the Bad 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 6. Successes in the Market Since 2001 PBC Lasers & Wostec Multinationals w/R&D Labs in Russia 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 7. Limited Success in Raising Int’l $ Insight Venture Partners 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 8. Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Distributions from Funds to LPs (Investors) 100% 90% 15% 29% 80% 41% 70% R e s p o n d e n ts (% ) 6% 42% 74% 60% 50% 40% 37% 30% 65% 20% 43% 22% 10% 22% 0% 4% Winter 2004-05 Summer 2006 Winter 2007-8 Summer 2009 Source: Collier Capital Improve No change Deteriorate 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 9. Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t % LPs Receiving >16% Net Returns 100% 90% 80% R e s p o n d e n ts (% ) 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Funds-of- North American North American European venture European buyouts Asia-Pacific venture Asia-Pacific funds/generalist venture buyouts buyouts Source: Collier 16% or more Less than 16% Capital 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 10. Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t LP Plans for Investment (Over Next 3 years) 100% 9% 90% 31% 80% 70% 40% Respondents (%) 60% 50% 39% 40% 30% 51% 20% 30% 10% 0% Summer Summer Source: Collier Capital 2006 2009 Increase No change Decrease 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 11. Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t LPs Declining to Invest in Last 12 Months 100% 90% 16% 29% 80% 55% Respondents (%) 70% 60% 50% 40% 84% 71% 30% 20% 45% 10% 0% Source: Collier Capital Summer Summer Summer 2005 2007 2009 Declined some re-investment requests Accepted all re-investment requests 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 12. Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Con’t Likely Valuations; 12/09 vs. 12/08 Lower by Higher by 41-60% up to 20% (4%) (6%) Remain unchanged (18%) Lower by 21-40% (33%) Source: Collier Capital Lower by up to 20% (39%) 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 13. Crisis in Int’l PE/VC Proportion of VC/Buyout Funds Unable to Raise New $ within 7 Years Venture capital firms 28% Buyout firms 23% Conclusions: less $ for VC, more competitive for LP $ & VC $: VC invest in profitable SMEs Source: Collier Capital 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 14. Part II: GoForward Plan to Raising Int’l VC $$ Issues For Entrepreneurs/SMEs: 1. Why Int’l $-location of customers & access the market for expansion vs. start-up or ego 2. Stage of development, seed vs. growth 3. Proof: Are you best in class, top 3 in your industry? 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 15. Reasons Why Components of SME Success Probability Company has enough $$ 80% Mgt Capable & Focused 80% PD Successful 80% Mfging Successful 80% Competitors Behave as Expected 80% Customers Want Product 80% Pricing is Correct 80% IP Issued 80% Combined Probability of Success 17% Success Rate <10% if Probability of One Event falls from 80% to 50% 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 16. Realities of VC Investment Ex: Global Spend in Clean Tech (2006) • Corporate R&D Investment = $22 billion • Government R&D Investment = $24 Billion • VC Investment in R&D = $2 Billion Same Pattern Repeated in Most Industries: VCs Fund Commercialization Risk, not Tech 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 17. Reasons for Rejecting Russian Tech Deals 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 18. Reasons for Rejecting Russian Tech Deals 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 19. Action Item #1 for Entrepreneurs/SMEs 1. Build Demand in the Supply Chain  Link to Multinationals Interest: User Pull, Testing, Deploy & Commercialize  Solve Tech & Supply Chain Needs/New Apps  Don’t Worry about Small Volumes  Build Locally, Upgrade Later for National & Int’l Expansion Info@IVIpe.com 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com
  • 20. Where’s the Customer Pain (Need) in the Industry? 1. MORE Perf, Execution & Cost Reduction  Not GameChangers; blocking/tackling tech so customers meet business plan 2. MORE Local Content Applications  Focus on Tech Challenges for Dev. & Growth 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 21. Examples: Get Integrated into Global/Russian Projects 1. Apps for Smartphone & Social Platforms 2. In <15 months, iPhone, Blackberry, Google & Facebook (fbfund) funds invested over $55 million into 80 companies  New Companies & New Employment  New Applications for Smartphones, Google Android & Facebook  More Investment  New Ideas 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 22. Examples: Get Integrated into Global/Russian Projects 3. HP ‘Central Nervous System for Earth  Nanosensors & IT to gather, transmit & monitor data on a global scale through intelligent nano- fabric networks 4. IBM’s Smart Planet Initiative 5. Cisco & NASA: ‘Planetary Skin’ Project  Capture, collect, analyze & report environment data from satellite, airborne, sea & land sensors across Earth 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 23. Examples: Get Integrated into Global/Russian Projects 6. Russia: Shtokman, Natural Resources for Solar & Alt. Energy Business Models  Nitol Solar: Raised $500 million from Chinese & US customers, IFC & Rusnano.  Chemical division processes chlorine, caustic soda and others to produce trichlorosilane (raw material for polysilicon production)  Polysilicon Division processes raw material into photovoltaic wafers 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 24. Domestic Opts to Build Bio- Tech Supply Chain in Russia Agricultural Drugs & Medical Devices Hospitals Research, Testing, & Feedstock/Chemicals Pharmaceuticals & Equipment Medical Labs  Agricultural  Medicinal &  Laboratory  Specialty  Biological processing botanicals apparatus & hospitals research  Basic organic furniture  Pharma-  University  Commercial chemicals ceutical  Surgical, medical medical  Ethyl alcohol preparations medical, dental, research research mfg. ophthalmic hospitals  Diagnostic & analytical  Testing Organic fiber substances instruments &  Clinical laboratories mfg. equipment research  Biological institutions  Medical  Fertilizers products  Irradiation laboratories & apparatus & diagnostic  Pesticides and imaging other agricultural electromedical chemicals equipment centers 17/18 June 2009 Product-Oriented www.IVIpe.com Service-Oriented Info@IVIpe.com
  • 25. Action Item #2 for Entrepreneurs/SMEs 2. Benchmark Your Tech to Competitors & Alternative  Often & Early  Define Strengths & Weaknesses  Test Under Different Operating & Customer Conditions  Invest to Overcome Deficiencies 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 26. 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 27. 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 28. The Standard? 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 29. Competition is Every Where 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 30. Multiple Sources of Competition 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 31. Build the Basics 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 32. Action Item #3 for Entrepreneurs/SMEs 3. Create Relationships & Leverage Existing Ones  Get Integrated into Supply Chains of SMEs that have raised Russian or Int’l $, e.g., Acronis, Parallels, Ozon, Enforta, Volga Gas, Air-in-Space  Prove your contribution to their business  Participate in Int’l Biz Plan Competitions to Develop Awareness & Mkt. Reaction 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 33. Action Item #4 for Entrepreneurs/SMEs 4. Target Int’l Funding Orgs’ for $  For R&D, Testing & PD Funding  USIC, CRDF, ISTC, EU Eureka/EuropeAid  In-Q-Tel (CIA VC fund) & Red Planet (US Army) if you have US presence & in their target for investment Attract $ from Russian groups like Rusnano to start. Build relationships with RVC (РВК) 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 34. Concluding Remarks 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 35. Don’t Give Up 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 36. Believe in Yourself/Accept Rejection  Oldest VC Firm, investing since 1911  Deals Rejected: Apollo Computer (acquired by Hewlett Packard) BVP's Felda Hardymon was offered a small position in the company's last private round, and rejected it: too small a position, he thought, at too high a price. In less than a year it was worth 17x more. 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 37. Believe in Yourself/Accept Rejection  Deal Rejected: Check Point In 1994, Gil Schwed pitched his idea to BVP's David Cowan, who said that Gil would never get distribution in the US. The next year, Check Point got a huge Sun OEM deal and sold $25M of firewall 17/18 June 2009 software. www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 38. Believe in Yourself/Accept Rejection  Deal Rejected: eBay "Stamps? Coins? Comic books? You've GOT to be kidding," thought Cowan. "No-brainer pass." 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 39. Believe in Yourself/Accept Rejection  Deal Rejected: Federal Express Incredibly, BVP declined on Federal Express seven times. 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 40. Believe in Yourself/Accept Rejection  Deal Rejected: Google Cowan’s college friend rented her garage to Sergey & Larry their 1st year. In 1999 and 2000 she introduced Cowan to “these two really smart Stanford students writing a search engine.” Students? A new search engine? In the most important moment ever for a Bessemer rejection, Cowan asked her, “How can I get out of this house without going near your garage?” 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 41. Believe in Yourself/Accept Rejection  Deal Rejected: Paypal David Cowan declined on the Series A round. Young & unproven team, regulatory problems, and, 4 years later, a $1.5 billion acquisition by eBay. 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 42. Believe in Yourself/Accept Rejection  Deal Rejected: StrataCom (acquired by Cisco) Felda Hardymon: "[Sierra's] Pete Wendell asked if I'd like to invest in Stratacom, which was doing a 'fast packet switch.' I gave him a blank stare." 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 43. Technology In Many Places! Just Look & Define Slaughter Raising Genetic Engineering & Breeding Butcher Distribution, Storage & Retail Locations Processing- Ham, Kielbasa Delivery 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 44. Download at www.IVIpe.com News 2007 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com
  • 45. Thomas D. Nastas Tom@IVIpe.com www.IVIpe.com Tel. 7.985.923.47.27 Innovative Ventures Inc. Moscow, Russia Haslett, MI USA 17/18 June 2009 www.IVIpe.com Info@IVIpe.com