SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 12
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
The Effect of American Military Intervention in the 2014 West Africa Ebola
Outbreak
Savannah Maxwell
May 8, 2015
POLS 413
Literature Review
Since the first case of the Ebola virus was discovered in the 1970’s, the virus has
continued to rear it’s ugly head time and time again, creating multiple outbreaks amongst
humans and Ape and Chimpanzee populations in Central and West Africa. When does a disease
become so dangerous that it warrants more than the healthcare intervention that a country can
provide? The nearly forty-year history of the Ebola virus is the perfect setting in which to
examine this particular concept.
What we know about the Ebola Virus is growing everyday, given that the virus has a
fairly short history in scientific context, only having been discovered nearly forty years ago in
the Democratic Republic of the Congo (formerly Zaire). (Peters, LeDuc Pg. 9) The Ebola virus
triggers hemorrhagic fever in its host, causing the patient to suffer bleeding (notably internal in
the gastrointestinal tract), high fever, soar throat, and inconsolable abdominal pain. So what
makes Ebola so deadly? These symptoms appear to be easy to control from an outsider
viewpoint, but often it is that the virus wears the host’s system down so far that their organ
systems can no longer fight and begin to shut down. The best means for fighting Ebola is simply
system support such as fluids and oxygen. What makes Ebola the deadly virus that it is known as
is how quickly the virus tends to spread. Ebola is spread through the contact with the bodily
fluids of a person infected with the virus. In environments where hygiene is not necessarily a
priority, or where access to proper medical care is available, the virus is able to flourish and
spread rapidly from person to person. The early epidemics of Ebola in Zaire provided evidence
early on of the just how deadly the Ebola virus had the potential to become if an outbreak was
allowed to get out of hand and not under control early on. The outbreak in Zaire had a case-
fatality rate of 88% (Heymann et. al. Pg. 372). Access to proper medical equipment, medical
care, and sanitation is essential during an Ebola outbreak. Unfortunately this is not always
accessible in rural (or even urban) areas of Africa where the Ebola virus tends to have a
prevalent presence. The Ebola Zaire (1976) outbreak would not have been as fatal were there
access to clean needles. It was found that the disease was spread in a hospital by the sharing of a
needle used on an infected person with other hospital patients. (Heymann et. al. Pg. 372)
One of the major issues present when there is an outbreak of Ebola is the access to
sanitation and sanitary medical supplies. Up until 2014, there had been little to no outside
intervention in any previous Ebola outbreak (save for what help the WHO offered). The most
attention given to Ebola up until 2014 was during an outbreak of Ebola-Reston in 1989 at a
primate facility in Reston, Virginia where monkeys that had been imported became ill with the
virus. The virus was then seen again at this same site in 1996 (Peters, Leduc, Pg.9). Until the
outbreaks in Virginia, the United States government had turned a relatively blind eye to the
Ebola virus and the havoc it had wrecked in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Sudan.
An outbreak, large in comparison to previous, in the DRC city of Kikwit in 1995 was the largest
outbreak at the time that had been observed. More than 300 people fell ill with the virus in this
particular incident. The WHO was contacted regarding the mysterious illness that had plagued so
many, and when the samples were sent to the CDC, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever was confirmed to
be the culprit. (Bwaka et. al. Pg. 1). Also in 1995, an outbreak in Mosango, DRC showed a
different side to the virus, the side that could be controlled with proper hygienic practices among
medical personnel and in hospitals. The outbreak remained small because of the conditions at the
hospital in Mosango. The sanitary conditions under which the patients were seen and treated, as
well as the way in which waste was disposed of provided the proper environment for the virus to
be stopped in its tracks. (Ndambi et. al. Pg 8). Another example of poor health measures
resulting in a lengthy outbreak is the outbreak of Ebola in Gabon in the years of 1994-1997. The
lack of health care supply, sanitation, and medical workers posed quite the challenge in fighting
back against the virus during the Gabon outbreaks. (Georges et. al. Pg 65).
The consensus amongst the examination of past Ebola outbreaks is the need for
consistent and quality medical care and sanitation in any incident of Ebola being diagnosed. The
way to stop the virus is through sanitary health care measures, unfortunately the regions in which
Ebola presents itself do not consistently have access to quality medical care and proper sanitary
medical practices, posing a need for outside intervention.
Research Design
The effect of the use of the American military for civilian purposes has been observed in
many instances, but never in such a way that shows the effect that the American military can
have during an epidemic of a deadly disease in another country, operating on foreign soil. The
Ebola virus has wrecked havoc in the West African countries of Liberia, Sierra Leone, and
Guinea. With casualties of over 9,000, the outbreak of Ebola in West Africa has no doubt been
the most deadly of the virus’ history. With the outbreak of Ebola threatening not just domestic
security in West Africa, but international security and the health of other countries, President
Obama announced the deployment of United States military servicemen and women to help aid
medical workers in areas most affected by the virus with the hopes of ending the further spread
of the virus.
In order to determine whether or not American military intervention in the West African
Ebola outbreak (2014) significantly contributed to the slowing of the spread of the Ebola virus in
Guinea, Sierra Leone, and Liberia, there are several sets of data that will need to be looked at and
studied to determine just the effect that the American intervention has made on the epidemic and
conditions in West Africa. United States military intervention in the Ebola outbreak has not only
had an effect on the ground in West Africa because of the American military servicemen and
women that were sent to aid in the crisis, but also because of the influence that the decision to
send American military to aid in ending the epidemic had on the decision made by other
countries to send aid to West Africa.
For this particular study, only the data concerning the timeline of the spread of the Ebola
virus in the outbreak in West Africa before United States military intervention, and the timeline
of the spread of the Ebola virus in West Africa when United States military intervention began to
current times will be used to provide answers to the research question. The independent variable
of the study is United States military intervention in the Ebola outbreak in the West African
countries of Guinea, Sierra Leone and Liberia, while the dependent variable of the study is the
spread of the Ebola virus and death counts in the Ebola outbreak in the West African countries of
Guinea, Sierra Leone, and Liberia. Data concerning the current West African Ebola outbreak in
Guinea, the only country of the three most affected that did not experience any intervention by
the United States military is used for comparison.
To measure the independent and the dependent variables of the study, a few different
sources were used to gather data on the current Ebola outbreak and past Ebola outbreaks, namely
the Center for Disease Control at www.cdc.gov and the European Center for Disease Control at
ecdc.europa.eu. Using the data provided concerning the amount of cases of Ebola in comparison
to the timeline of the outbreak, the effect of United States military intervention in terms of the
spread of the Ebola virus will be determined.
Data Analysis
In the case of the ongoing West African Ebola outbreak, the most important pieces of
data to analyze are the death count and case counts for each of the three main countries in West
Africa that were affected by the outbreak; Liberia, Sierra Leone, and Guinea. By placing the data
found through the European Center for Disease Control website into graphs where the data is
shown over time, the leveling off of death counts after American intervention in Liberia can be
seen in comparison to the death count in Guinea, where there was very little to no American
military intervention in the crisis. In the graphs below, the death counts for the three most
affected countries are displayed over time.
Figure 1: The death count for the ongoing Ebola Outbreak in Guinea is displayed for the
dates ranging from March 2014 to March 2015.
80	
   141	
   193	
   303	
   339	
   430	
  
710	
  
1018	
  
1327	
  
1739	
  
1937	
  
2127	
  
2279	
  
0	
  
500	
  
1000	
  
1500	
  
2000	
  
2500	
  
Number	
  of	
  Cases	
  
Guinea	
  Monthly	
  Death	
  Count	
  
Figure 2: The death count for the ongoing Ebola Outbreak in Liberia is displayed for the
dates ranging from March 2014 to March 2015.
Figure 3: The death count for the ongoing Ebola Outbreak in Sierra Leone is displayed
for the dates ranging from March 2014 to March 2015.
0	
   0	
   9	
   65	
   156	
  
694	
  
1998	
  
2697	
  
3155	
  
3423	
  
3739	
  
4057	
  
4301	
  
0	
  
500	
  
1000	
  
1500	
  
2000	
  
2500	
  
3000	
  
3500	
  
4000	
  
4500	
  
5000	
  Number	
  of	
  Cases	
  
Liberia	
  Monthly	
  Death	
  Count	
  
0	
   0	
   6	
   99	
   233	
  
422	
  
622	
  
1510	
   1583	
  
2827	
  
3274	
  
3530	
  
3764	
  
0	
  
500	
  
1000	
  
1500	
  
2000	
  
2500	
  
3000	
  
3500	
  
4000	
  
Number	
  of	
  Cases	
  
Sierra	
  Leone	
  Death	
  Count	
  
American military intervention in Sierra Leone and Liberia (main base for the relief efforts was
based out of Liberia) began in mid October of 2014. In the graphs displayed above, the death
count from the outbreak continues to rise even through November, but in Sierra Leone’s case
through much of December as well. After this time however, which I would like to refer to as an
“adjustment period”, the death count for Liberia and Sierra Leone largely begins to level off and
slow down, aligned with the timing of the arrival of American military aid to West Africa. Also
aligned with this is the death count in Guinea. Guinea, where the outbreak began, was not
affected as greatly as Sierra Leone and Liberia with the spread of the Virus; therefore the
American aid was concentrated in Liberia and Sierra Leone, which I believe the data accurately
shows.
Though the death count leveled off in correct correlation to the timing of American aid, it
can be argued that there were many other factors involved with the death rate of the Virus
slowing in the two most affected countries of Liberia and Sierra Leone. When President Barack
Obama announced that the United States would be sending American military to aid in the relief
efforts, many other international governments also became involved in the relief efforts
including countries such as China and Cuba. With this in mind however, the connection between
the death rate of the virus slowing in Liberia and Sierra Leone where the majority of the
American military aid was sent, and the death rate of the virus remaining relatively the same in
Guinea where little American military aid was sent cannot be denied.
The death rate of the virus was significantly lowered and appears to have leveled off, and
in addition to this, the rate of new confirmed cases also appears to have lowered and leveled off
in Sierra Leone and Liberia while remaining relatively high and stable in Guinea, consistent with
the death count data. I believe this to be a result of several different factors. Firstly, the main
effort of American military aid for the Ebola outbreak was to build hospitals and provide medical
services and supplies to hospitals to aid those that were infected. In addition to this, educational
services were offered by the American military officials that were sent to aid in the outbreak in
order to better educate medical personnel that were directly involved in treating Ebola patients to
create a more uniform set of information distributed to medical personnel on how to safely and
effectively treat patients infected with the virus. Therefore, with most aid that was sent for the
relief efforts going towards those persons that were already ill with the virus, not much was done
on the part of the American military to essentially stop the spread of the virus, but by lowering
the death rate of the virus, a lowering of the infection rate of the virus should in essence happen
as well, as shown below in the graphs of Case Count data.
In the graphs below, the case counts for the outbreak for the three most affected countries
are displayed in graph form over time.
Figure 4: The case counts for the ongoing Ebola outbreak in Guinea is displayed over
time from January 2014 to March 2015.
10	
   39	
   122	
   218	
   291	
   413	
   460	
  
648	
  
1157	
  
1667	
  
2164	
  
2730	
  
2959	
  
3205	
  
3459	
  
0	
  
500	
  
1000	
  
1500	
  
2000	
  
2500	
  
3000	
  
3500	
  
4000	
  
Number	
  of	
  Cases	
  
Guinea	
  Monthly	
  Case	
  Count	
  Increase	
  
Figure 5: The case counts for the ongoing Ebola outbreak in Liberia is displayed over
time from January 2014 to March 2015.
Figure 6: The case counts for the ongoing Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone is displayed
over time from January 2014 to March 2015.
0	
   0	
   12	
   0	
   12	
   107	
   329	
  
1378	
  
3696	
  
6525	
  
7650	
  8018	
  
8729	
  
9265	
  9602	
  
0	
  
2000	
  
4000	
  
6000	
  
8000	
  
10000	
  
12000	
  
Number	
  of	
  Cases	
  
Liberia	
  Monthly	
  Case	
  Count	
  Increase	
  
0	
   0	
   0	
   0	
   50	
   239	
   533	
   1026	
  
2304	
  
5338	
  
7312	
  
9633	
  
10707	
  
11443	
  11866	
  
0	
  
2000	
  
4000	
  
6000	
  
8000	
  
10000	
  
12000	
  
14000	
  
Number	
  of	
  Cases	
  
Sierra	
  Leone	
  Monthly	
  Case	
  Counts	
  
As earlier mentioned, figures 4-6 do in fact show a slow in the spread of the virus and newly
confirmed cases. Based on the graphs and the data, American military intervention does appear
to have affected the spread of the virus and the reduction in deaths from the virus.
Conclusion(s)
Each of the affected countries—Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone—experienced a rapid
increase in virus infection rates from October-December 2014. While the spike was experienced,
Liberia and Sierra Leone—the two countries that received aid from the American military during
the crisis, experience a significant drop in case increase and death increase each month following
this spike. The American military did not intervene in Guinea’s efforts to stop the spread of the
virus, and the data that was collected reflects this. Though Guinea also experienced the same
spike in cases and deaths from October-December 2014, the rate of the spread of the virus in
Guinea did not decrease after the speak, instead it continued to remain at a steady rate rather than
slowing down.
At the time that America intervened in the crisis and sent aid to West Africa, an
international movement started and after American aid had arrived, much other international aid
began to arrive. With this in mind, though there may have been other contributing factors, the
correlation between the decrease in death and infection rates in Liberia and Sierra Leone to the
arrival of American military aid cannot be denied. Though access is currently limited, it is
possible that with more comprehensive data regarding the American military intervention in the
West African Ebola crisis a more concrete conclusion can be reached as to whether or not the
American military sparked a decline in infection and death rates in Liberia and Sierra Leone.
Sources
1. C. J. Peters and J. W. LeDuc, An Introduction to Ebola: The Virus and the Disease, The
Journal of Infectious Diseases, Vol. 179, Supplement 1. Ebola: The Virus and the
Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 9-16.
2. D. L. Heymann, J. S. Weisfeld, P. A. Webb, K. M. Johnson, T. Cairns and H. Berquist, Ebola
Hemorrhagic Fever: Tandala, Zaire, 1977-1978, The Journal of Infectious Diseases,
Vol. 142, No. 3 (Sep., 1980), pp. 372-376.
3. Mpia A. Bwaka, Marie-José Bonnet, Philippe Calain, Robert Colebunders, Ann De Roo, Yves
Guimard, Kasongo R. Katwiki, Kapay Kibadi, Mungala A. Kipasa, Kivudi J. Kuvula,
Bwas B. Mapanda, Matondo Massamba, Kibadi D. Mupapa, Jean-Jacques Muyembe-
Tamfum, Edouard Ndaberey, Clarence J. Peters, Pierre E. Rollin and Erwin Van den
Enden, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever in Kikwit, Democratic Republic of the Congo: Clinical
Observations in 103 Patients, The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Vol. 179, Supplement
1. Ebola: The Virus and the Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 1-7.
4. Roger Ndambi, Philippe Akamituna, Marie-Jo Bonnet, Anicet Mazaya Tukadila, Jean-Jacques
Muyembe-Tamfum and Robert Colebunders
The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Epidemiologic and Clinical Aspects of the Ebola Virus
Epidemic in Mosango, Democratic Republic of the Congo, 1995, Vol. 179, Supplement 1.
Ebola: The Virus and the Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 8-10.
5. Alain-Jean Georges, Eric M. Leroy, André A. Renaut, Carol Tevi Benissan, René J. Nabias,
Minh Trinh Ngoc, Paul I. Obiang, J. P. M. Lepage, Eric J. Bertherat, David D. Bénoni, E.
Jean Wickings, Jacques P. Amblard, Joseph M. Lansoud-Soukate, J. M. Milleliri, Sylvain
Baize and Marie-Claude Georges-Courbot, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever Outbreaks in
Gabon, 1994-1997: Epidemiologic and Health Control Issues, The Journal of Infectious
Diseases, Vol. 179, Supplement 1. Ebola: The Virus and the Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 65-
75.
6. European Center for Disease Control, “Ebola Outbreak in West Africa” 2015.
http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/healthtopics/ebola_marburg_fevers/Pages/ebola-outbreak-west-
africa.aspx (March 23, 2015).
7. Center For Disease Control, “2014 Ebola Outbreak in West Africa” 2015.
http://www.cdc.gov/vhf/ebola/outbreaks/2014-west-africa/index.html (March 10, 2015).
	
  

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

ebola-prevention and challenges
ebola-prevention and challengesebola-prevention and challenges
ebola-prevention and challenges
Chitra Pai
 
Our health message romania.key
Our health message   romania.keyOur health message   romania.key
Our health message romania.key
szabilu
 
PDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - Cobras
PDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - CobrasPDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - Cobras
PDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - Cobras
Madison Lewis
 
Evan Gross Research Paper
Evan Gross Research PaperEvan Gross Research Paper
Evan Gross Research Paper
Evan Gross
 
IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...
IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...
IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...
EuFMD
 
New genotype of ASF in Ethiopia
New genotype of ASF in EthiopiaNew genotype of ASF in Ethiopia
New genotype of ASF in Ethiopia
Daniel Gizaw
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

ebola-prevention and challenges
ebola-prevention and challengesebola-prevention and challenges
ebola-prevention and challenges
 
Policy
PolicyPolicy
Policy
 
Our health message romania.key
Our health message   romania.keyOur health message   romania.key
Our health message romania.key
 
Helen Branswell: "The Current Status of the Ebola Epidemic"
Helen Branswell: "The Current Status of the Ebola Epidemic"Helen Branswell: "The Current Status of the Ebola Epidemic"
Helen Branswell: "The Current Status of the Ebola Epidemic"
 
Fighting Against Ebola: Public Health and Nepal
Fighting Against Ebola: Public Health and NepalFighting Against Ebola: Public Health and Nepal
Fighting Against Ebola: Public Health and Nepal
 
PDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - Cobras
PDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - CobrasPDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - Cobras
PDF Problem III - Langley-Tucker - D1 - Cobras
 
Ebola virus disease (EVD)
Ebola virus disease (EVD)Ebola virus disease (EVD)
Ebola virus disease (EVD)
 
State of Hawaii - Laboratory - Brazil Variant - Rendezous With Destiny
State of Hawaii - Laboratory - Brazil Variant - Rendezous With DestinyState of Hawaii - Laboratory - Brazil Variant - Rendezous With Destiny
State of Hawaii - Laboratory - Brazil Variant - Rendezous With Destiny
 
Evan Gross Research Paper
Evan Gross Research PaperEvan Gross Research Paper
Evan Gross Research Paper
 
WGHA Discovery Series: Supamit Chinsuttiwat
WGHA Discovery Series: Supamit ChinsuttiwatWGHA Discovery Series: Supamit Chinsuttiwat
WGHA Discovery Series: Supamit Chinsuttiwat
 
Knowledge perception and belief of Ebola virus disease (EVD) among the reside...
Knowledge perception and belief of Ebola virus disease (EVD) among the reside...Knowledge perception and belief of Ebola virus disease (EVD) among the reside...
Knowledge perception and belief of Ebola virus disease (EVD) among the reside...
 
IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...
IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...
IS AFRICAN SWINE FEVER RETURNING TO AFRICA ? A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE ANALYSIS ...
 
Topic presentation on emerging communicable diseases
Topic presentation on emerging communicable diseasesTopic presentation on emerging communicable diseases
Topic presentation on emerging communicable diseases
 
Cross‐Sectional Study on Burden of Hepatitis B/C and HIV Infection among Hira...
Cross‐Sectional Study on Burden of Hepatitis B/C and HIV Infection among Hira...Cross‐Sectional Study on Burden of Hepatitis B/C and HIV Infection among Hira...
Cross‐Sectional Study on Burden of Hepatitis B/C and HIV Infection among Hira...
 
The dynmics of covid 19 in africa compare to the rest of the world
The dynmics of covid 19 in africa compare to the rest of the worldThe dynmics of covid 19 in africa compare to the rest of the world
The dynmics of covid 19 in africa compare to the rest of the world
 
New genotype of ASF in Ethiopia
New genotype of ASF in EthiopiaNew genotype of ASF in Ethiopia
New genotype of ASF in Ethiopia
 
Importance of differentiating infected and vaccinated animals (DIVA) in outbr...
Importance of differentiating infected and vaccinated animals (DIVA) in outbr...Importance of differentiating infected and vaccinated animals (DIVA) in outbr...
Importance of differentiating infected and vaccinated animals (DIVA) in outbr...
 
Origin of hiv
Origin of hivOrigin of hiv
Origin of hiv
 
Twenty-first Century disease threats, epidemiology and One Health
Twenty-first Century disease threats, epidemiology and One HealthTwenty-first Century disease threats, epidemiology and One Health
Twenty-first Century disease threats, epidemiology and One Health
 
Pandemic
Pandemic Pandemic
Pandemic
 

Ähnlich wie Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413

Running head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docx
Running head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docxRunning head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docx
Running head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docx
susanschei
 
West Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docx
West Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docxWest Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docx
West Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docx
philipnelson29183
 
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Alexander Decker
 
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Alexander Decker
 
RUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE 1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE .docx
RUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE        1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE  .docxRUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE        1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE  .docx
RUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE 1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE .docx
charisellington63520
 
AssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docx
AssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docxAssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docx
AssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docx
normanibarber20063
 
Containing the Spread of Filoviruses
Containing the Spread of FilovirusesContaining the Spread of Filoviruses
Containing the Spread of Filoviruses
Savanna Williams
 
Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)
Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)
Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)
Christopher Dye
 
Topic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docx
Topic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docxTopic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docx
Topic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docx
edwardmarivel
 

Ähnlich wie Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413 (18)

Running head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docx
Running head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docxRunning head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docx
Running head Ebola outbreak in western AfricaEbola outbreak in .docx
 
West Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docx
West Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docxWest Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docx
West Africa Ebola Outbreak1West Africa Eb.docx
 
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. FriedenPublic Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
Public Health Response to Ebola Statement of Dr. Frieden
 
Ebola outbreak report
Ebola outbreak reportEbola outbreak report
Ebola outbreak report
 
Ebola Response Paper
Ebola Response PaperEbola Response Paper
Ebola Response Paper
 
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
 
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
Analyzing the economic consequences of an epidemic outbreak experience from t...
 
Ebola Truth
Ebola TruthEbola Truth
Ebola Truth
 
RUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE 1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE .docx
RUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE        1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE  .docxRUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE        1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE  .docx
RUNNING HEAD EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE 1EBOLA IS MANAGEABLE .docx
 
AssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docx
AssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docxAssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docx
AssignmentPurposePretend you are a homeowner and need to get.docx
 
Tracking The Ebola Virus
Tracking The Ebola VirusTracking The Ebola Virus
Tracking The Ebola Virus
 
Jpg140031
Jpg140031Jpg140031
Jpg140031
 
Yale - Tulane Special Report - West Africa - Ebola 26 AUG 2014
Yale - Tulane Special Report  - West Africa - Ebola  26  AUG 2014Yale - Tulane Special Report  - West Africa - Ebola  26  AUG 2014
Yale - Tulane Special Report - West Africa - Ebola 26 AUG 2014
 
Ebola Epidemic Analysis
Ebola Epidemic AnalysisEbola Epidemic Analysis
Ebola Epidemic Analysis
 
EVD in Westren Area
EVD in Westren AreaEVD in Westren Area
EVD in Westren Area
 
Containing the Spread of Filoviruses
Containing the Spread of FilovirusesContaining the Spread of Filoviruses
Containing the Spread of Filoviruses
 
Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)
Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)
Plos Medicine 2016 (Ebola)
 
Topic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docx
Topic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docxTopic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docx
Topic Ebola under EpidemiologyThis topic interests me to a grea.docx
 

Maxwell Final Paper_POLS 413

  • 1. The Effect of American Military Intervention in the 2014 West Africa Ebola Outbreak Savannah Maxwell May 8, 2015 POLS 413
  • 2. Literature Review Since the first case of the Ebola virus was discovered in the 1970’s, the virus has continued to rear it’s ugly head time and time again, creating multiple outbreaks amongst humans and Ape and Chimpanzee populations in Central and West Africa. When does a disease become so dangerous that it warrants more than the healthcare intervention that a country can provide? The nearly forty-year history of the Ebola virus is the perfect setting in which to examine this particular concept. What we know about the Ebola Virus is growing everyday, given that the virus has a fairly short history in scientific context, only having been discovered nearly forty years ago in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (formerly Zaire). (Peters, LeDuc Pg. 9) The Ebola virus triggers hemorrhagic fever in its host, causing the patient to suffer bleeding (notably internal in the gastrointestinal tract), high fever, soar throat, and inconsolable abdominal pain. So what makes Ebola so deadly? These symptoms appear to be easy to control from an outsider viewpoint, but often it is that the virus wears the host’s system down so far that their organ systems can no longer fight and begin to shut down. The best means for fighting Ebola is simply system support such as fluids and oxygen. What makes Ebola the deadly virus that it is known as is how quickly the virus tends to spread. Ebola is spread through the contact with the bodily fluids of a person infected with the virus. In environments where hygiene is not necessarily a priority, or where access to proper medical care is available, the virus is able to flourish and spread rapidly from person to person. The early epidemics of Ebola in Zaire provided evidence early on of the just how deadly the Ebola virus had the potential to become if an outbreak was allowed to get out of hand and not under control early on. The outbreak in Zaire had a case- fatality rate of 88% (Heymann et. al. Pg. 372). Access to proper medical equipment, medical
  • 3. care, and sanitation is essential during an Ebola outbreak. Unfortunately this is not always accessible in rural (or even urban) areas of Africa where the Ebola virus tends to have a prevalent presence. The Ebola Zaire (1976) outbreak would not have been as fatal were there access to clean needles. It was found that the disease was spread in a hospital by the sharing of a needle used on an infected person with other hospital patients. (Heymann et. al. Pg. 372) One of the major issues present when there is an outbreak of Ebola is the access to sanitation and sanitary medical supplies. Up until 2014, there had been little to no outside intervention in any previous Ebola outbreak (save for what help the WHO offered). The most attention given to Ebola up until 2014 was during an outbreak of Ebola-Reston in 1989 at a primate facility in Reston, Virginia where monkeys that had been imported became ill with the virus. The virus was then seen again at this same site in 1996 (Peters, Leduc, Pg.9). Until the outbreaks in Virginia, the United States government had turned a relatively blind eye to the Ebola virus and the havoc it had wrecked in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Sudan. An outbreak, large in comparison to previous, in the DRC city of Kikwit in 1995 was the largest outbreak at the time that had been observed. More than 300 people fell ill with the virus in this particular incident. The WHO was contacted regarding the mysterious illness that had plagued so many, and when the samples were sent to the CDC, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever was confirmed to be the culprit. (Bwaka et. al. Pg. 1). Also in 1995, an outbreak in Mosango, DRC showed a different side to the virus, the side that could be controlled with proper hygienic practices among medical personnel and in hospitals. The outbreak remained small because of the conditions at the hospital in Mosango. The sanitary conditions under which the patients were seen and treated, as well as the way in which waste was disposed of provided the proper environment for the virus to be stopped in its tracks. (Ndambi et. al. Pg 8). Another example of poor health measures
  • 4. resulting in a lengthy outbreak is the outbreak of Ebola in Gabon in the years of 1994-1997. The lack of health care supply, sanitation, and medical workers posed quite the challenge in fighting back against the virus during the Gabon outbreaks. (Georges et. al. Pg 65). The consensus amongst the examination of past Ebola outbreaks is the need for consistent and quality medical care and sanitation in any incident of Ebola being diagnosed. The way to stop the virus is through sanitary health care measures, unfortunately the regions in which Ebola presents itself do not consistently have access to quality medical care and proper sanitary medical practices, posing a need for outside intervention. Research Design The effect of the use of the American military for civilian purposes has been observed in many instances, but never in such a way that shows the effect that the American military can have during an epidemic of a deadly disease in another country, operating on foreign soil. The Ebola virus has wrecked havoc in the West African countries of Liberia, Sierra Leone, and Guinea. With casualties of over 9,000, the outbreak of Ebola in West Africa has no doubt been the most deadly of the virus’ history. With the outbreak of Ebola threatening not just domestic security in West Africa, but international security and the health of other countries, President Obama announced the deployment of United States military servicemen and women to help aid medical workers in areas most affected by the virus with the hopes of ending the further spread of the virus. In order to determine whether or not American military intervention in the West African Ebola outbreak (2014) significantly contributed to the slowing of the spread of the Ebola virus in Guinea, Sierra Leone, and Liberia, there are several sets of data that will need to be looked at and
  • 5. studied to determine just the effect that the American intervention has made on the epidemic and conditions in West Africa. United States military intervention in the Ebola outbreak has not only had an effect on the ground in West Africa because of the American military servicemen and women that were sent to aid in the crisis, but also because of the influence that the decision to send American military to aid in ending the epidemic had on the decision made by other countries to send aid to West Africa. For this particular study, only the data concerning the timeline of the spread of the Ebola virus in the outbreak in West Africa before United States military intervention, and the timeline of the spread of the Ebola virus in West Africa when United States military intervention began to current times will be used to provide answers to the research question. The independent variable of the study is United States military intervention in the Ebola outbreak in the West African countries of Guinea, Sierra Leone and Liberia, while the dependent variable of the study is the spread of the Ebola virus and death counts in the Ebola outbreak in the West African countries of Guinea, Sierra Leone, and Liberia. Data concerning the current West African Ebola outbreak in Guinea, the only country of the three most affected that did not experience any intervention by the United States military is used for comparison. To measure the independent and the dependent variables of the study, a few different sources were used to gather data on the current Ebola outbreak and past Ebola outbreaks, namely the Center for Disease Control at www.cdc.gov and the European Center for Disease Control at ecdc.europa.eu. Using the data provided concerning the amount of cases of Ebola in comparison to the timeline of the outbreak, the effect of United States military intervention in terms of the spread of the Ebola virus will be determined.
  • 6. Data Analysis In the case of the ongoing West African Ebola outbreak, the most important pieces of data to analyze are the death count and case counts for each of the three main countries in West Africa that were affected by the outbreak; Liberia, Sierra Leone, and Guinea. By placing the data found through the European Center for Disease Control website into graphs where the data is shown over time, the leveling off of death counts after American intervention in Liberia can be seen in comparison to the death count in Guinea, where there was very little to no American military intervention in the crisis. In the graphs below, the death counts for the three most affected countries are displayed over time. Figure 1: The death count for the ongoing Ebola Outbreak in Guinea is displayed for the dates ranging from March 2014 to March 2015. 80   141   193   303   339   430   710   1018   1327   1739   1937   2127   2279   0   500   1000   1500   2000   2500   Number  of  Cases   Guinea  Monthly  Death  Count  
  • 7. Figure 2: The death count for the ongoing Ebola Outbreak in Liberia is displayed for the dates ranging from March 2014 to March 2015. Figure 3: The death count for the ongoing Ebola Outbreak in Sierra Leone is displayed for the dates ranging from March 2014 to March 2015. 0   0   9   65   156   694   1998   2697   3155   3423   3739   4057   4301   0   500   1000   1500   2000   2500   3000   3500   4000   4500   5000  Number  of  Cases   Liberia  Monthly  Death  Count   0   0   6   99   233   422   622   1510   1583   2827   3274   3530   3764   0   500   1000   1500   2000   2500   3000   3500   4000   Number  of  Cases   Sierra  Leone  Death  Count  
  • 8. American military intervention in Sierra Leone and Liberia (main base for the relief efforts was based out of Liberia) began in mid October of 2014. In the graphs displayed above, the death count from the outbreak continues to rise even through November, but in Sierra Leone’s case through much of December as well. After this time however, which I would like to refer to as an “adjustment period”, the death count for Liberia and Sierra Leone largely begins to level off and slow down, aligned with the timing of the arrival of American military aid to West Africa. Also aligned with this is the death count in Guinea. Guinea, where the outbreak began, was not affected as greatly as Sierra Leone and Liberia with the spread of the Virus; therefore the American aid was concentrated in Liberia and Sierra Leone, which I believe the data accurately shows. Though the death count leveled off in correct correlation to the timing of American aid, it can be argued that there were many other factors involved with the death rate of the Virus slowing in the two most affected countries of Liberia and Sierra Leone. When President Barack Obama announced that the United States would be sending American military to aid in the relief efforts, many other international governments also became involved in the relief efforts including countries such as China and Cuba. With this in mind however, the connection between the death rate of the virus slowing in Liberia and Sierra Leone where the majority of the American military aid was sent, and the death rate of the virus remaining relatively the same in Guinea where little American military aid was sent cannot be denied. The death rate of the virus was significantly lowered and appears to have leveled off, and in addition to this, the rate of new confirmed cases also appears to have lowered and leveled off in Sierra Leone and Liberia while remaining relatively high and stable in Guinea, consistent with the death count data. I believe this to be a result of several different factors. Firstly, the main
  • 9. effort of American military aid for the Ebola outbreak was to build hospitals and provide medical services and supplies to hospitals to aid those that were infected. In addition to this, educational services were offered by the American military officials that were sent to aid in the outbreak in order to better educate medical personnel that were directly involved in treating Ebola patients to create a more uniform set of information distributed to medical personnel on how to safely and effectively treat patients infected with the virus. Therefore, with most aid that was sent for the relief efforts going towards those persons that were already ill with the virus, not much was done on the part of the American military to essentially stop the spread of the virus, but by lowering the death rate of the virus, a lowering of the infection rate of the virus should in essence happen as well, as shown below in the graphs of Case Count data. In the graphs below, the case counts for the outbreak for the three most affected countries are displayed in graph form over time. Figure 4: The case counts for the ongoing Ebola outbreak in Guinea is displayed over time from January 2014 to March 2015. 10   39   122   218   291   413   460   648   1157   1667   2164   2730   2959   3205   3459   0   500   1000   1500   2000   2500   3000   3500   4000   Number  of  Cases   Guinea  Monthly  Case  Count  Increase  
  • 10. Figure 5: The case counts for the ongoing Ebola outbreak in Liberia is displayed over time from January 2014 to March 2015. Figure 6: The case counts for the ongoing Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone is displayed over time from January 2014 to March 2015. 0   0   12   0   12   107   329   1378   3696   6525   7650  8018   8729   9265  9602   0   2000   4000   6000   8000   10000   12000   Number  of  Cases   Liberia  Monthly  Case  Count  Increase   0   0   0   0   50   239   533   1026   2304   5338   7312   9633   10707   11443  11866   0   2000   4000   6000   8000   10000   12000   14000   Number  of  Cases   Sierra  Leone  Monthly  Case  Counts  
  • 11. As earlier mentioned, figures 4-6 do in fact show a slow in the spread of the virus and newly confirmed cases. Based on the graphs and the data, American military intervention does appear to have affected the spread of the virus and the reduction in deaths from the virus. Conclusion(s) Each of the affected countries—Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone—experienced a rapid increase in virus infection rates from October-December 2014. While the spike was experienced, Liberia and Sierra Leone—the two countries that received aid from the American military during the crisis, experience a significant drop in case increase and death increase each month following this spike. The American military did not intervene in Guinea’s efforts to stop the spread of the virus, and the data that was collected reflects this. Though Guinea also experienced the same spike in cases and deaths from October-December 2014, the rate of the spread of the virus in Guinea did not decrease after the speak, instead it continued to remain at a steady rate rather than slowing down. At the time that America intervened in the crisis and sent aid to West Africa, an international movement started and after American aid had arrived, much other international aid began to arrive. With this in mind, though there may have been other contributing factors, the correlation between the decrease in death and infection rates in Liberia and Sierra Leone to the arrival of American military aid cannot be denied. Though access is currently limited, it is possible that with more comprehensive data regarding the American military intervention in the West African Ebola crisis a more concrete conclusion can be reached as to whether or not the American military sparked a decline in infection and death rates in Liberia and Sierra Leone.
  • 12. Sources 1. C. J. Peters and J. W. LeDuc, An Introduction to Ebola: The Virus and the Disease, The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Vol. 179, Supplement 1. Ebola: The Virus and the Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 9-16. 2. D. L. Heymann, J. S. Weisfeld, P. A. Webb, K. M. Johnson, T. Cairns and H. Berquist, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever: Tandala, Zaire, 1977-1978, The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Vol. 142, No. 3 (Sep., 1980), pp. 372-376. 3. Mpia A. Bwaka, Marie-José Bonnet, Philippe Calain, Robert Colebunders, Ann De Roo, Yves Guimard, Kasongo R. Katwiki, Kapay Kibadi, Mungala A. Kipasa, Kivudi J. Kuvula, Bwas B. Mapanda, Matondo Massamba, Kibadi D. Mupapa, Jean-Jacques Muyembe- Tamfum, Edouard Ndaberey, Clarence J. Peters, Pierre E. Rollin and Erwin Van den Enden, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever in Kikwit, Democratic Republic of the Congo: Clinical Observations in 103 Patients, The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Vol. 179, Supplement 1. Ebola: The Virus and the Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 1-7. 4. Roger Ndambi, Philippe Akamituna, Marie-Jo Bonnet, Anicet Mazaya Tukadila, Jean-Jacques Muyembe-Tamfum and Robert Colebunders The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Epidemiologic and Clinical Aspects of the Ebola Virus Epidemic in Mosango, Democratic Republic of the Congo, 1995, Vol. 179, Supplement 1. Ebola: The Virus and the Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 8-10. 5. Alain-Jean Georges, Eric M. Leroy, André A. Renaut, Carol Tevi Benissan, René J. Nabias, Minh Trinh Ngoc, Paul I. Obiang, J. P. M. Lepage, Eric J. Bertherat, David D. Bénoni, E. Jean Wickings, Jacques P. Amblard, Joseph M. Lansoud-Soukate, J. M. Milleliri, Sylvain Baize and Marie-Claude Georges-Courbot, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever Outbreaks in Gabon, 1994-1997: Epidemiologic and Health Control Issues, The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Vol. 179, Supplement 1. Ebola: The Virus and the Disease (Feb., 1999), pp. 65- 75. 6. European Center for Disease Control, “Ebola Outbreak in West Africa” 2015. http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/healthtopics/ebola_marburg_fevers/Pages/ebola-outbreak-west- africa.aspx (March 23, 2015). 7. Center For Disease Control, “2014 Ebola Outbreak in West Africa” 2015. http://www.cdc.gov/vhf/ebola/outbreaks/2014-west-africa/index.html (March 10, 2015).