SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 34

III. Axiomatic Design

3.1 Introduction (2)
Examples of axioms in Geometry:
Points and lines are names for the elements of two (distinct) sets. Incidence is a
relationship that may (or may not) hold between a particular point and a particular line.
The followings are examples of axioms:
1) For every two points, there exists a line incident with both points.
2) For every two points, there is no more than one line incident with both points.
3) There exist at least two points incident with each line.
4) There exist at least three points. Not all points are incident with the same line.
Examples of axioms in Physics:
1) Newton’s law: F = ma
2) Thermodynamic principles
3) ……

Axiomatic design is a design methodology that was created and popularized by Professor
Suh of MIT (used be the President of KAIST).
It is a design framework that is feasible on all design disciplines.
The Independence Axiom, The Information Axiom
An axiom is a statement accepted without proof as an underlying assumption of a formal
mathematical theory. It cannot be proved. If a counter example is found for an axiom, the
axiom becomes obsolete.
Geometry, Laws in Physics, Thermodynamic principles
3.1 Introduction

Design Axioms
Axiom 1: The Independence Axiom
Maintain the independence of FRs.
Alternate Statement 1: An optimal design always maintains the independence of FRs.
Alternate Statement 2: In an acceptable design, DPs and FRs are related in such a way
that a specific DP can be adjusted to satisfy its corresponding FR without affecting
other functional requirements.
Axiom 2: The Information Axiom
Minimize the information content of the design.
Alternate Statement: The best design is a functionally uncoupled design that has
minimum information content.
3.2. Design Axioms

Usage of the axioms:
Analysis of design
Find designs that satisfy the
Independence Axiom.
Determine the final design.
Is the no. of designs sufficient?
Find the best design with the
Information Axiom.
Multiple designs?
No
Yes
Yes
No
3.2. Design Axioms (2)
Figure 3.1. Flow chart of the application of axiomatic design

The Independence Axiom: The FR-DP relationship should be independent.






















3
2
1
3
2
1
,
DP
DP
DP
FR
FR
FR
DP
FR
equation
design
:
ADP
FR 































3
2
1
33
32
31
23
22
21
13
12
11
3
2
1
DP
DP
DP
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
FR
FR
FR
FR: FR vector, DP: DP vector, A: design matrix
3.3 Independence Axiom
































3
2
1
33
22
11
3
2
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
DP
DP
DP
A
A
A
FR
FR
FR 1
11
1 DP
A
FR 

2
22
2 DP
A
FR 

3
33
3 DP
A
FR 
































3
2
1
33
32
31
22
21
11
3
2
1
0
0
0
DP
DP
DP
A
A
A
A
A
A
FR
FR
FR 1
11
1 DP
A
FR 

2
22
1
21
2 DP
A
DP
A
FR 



3
33
2
32
1
31
3 DP
A
DP
A
DP
A
FR 





3.3 Independence Axiom (2)
1) Uncoupled design: Each DP satisfies the corresponding FR independently. - diagonal matrix
2) Decoupled design: The Independence Axiom is satisfied when the design sequence is right.
- triangular matrix

(3) Coupled design: No sequences of DPs can satisfy the FRs independently. –general matrix































3
2
1
33
32
31
23
22
21
13
12
11
3
2
1
DP
DP
DP
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
FR
FR
FR 3
13
2
12
1
11
1 DP
A
DP
A
DP
A
FR 





3
23
2
22
1
21
2 DP
A
DP
A
DP
A
FR 





3
33
2
32
1
31
3 DP
A
DP
A
DP
A
FR 





Constraints (Cs): Cs can be defined regardless of the independence of the FR-DP relationship.
3.3 Independence Axiom (3)

(a) Vertically hung door (b) Horizontally hung door
Example 3.1 [Design of a Refrigerator Door]
FRs for a refrigerator door are as follows:
FR1: Provide access to the items stored in the refrigerator.
FR2: Minimize energy loss.
Which door is better between the following doors?
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom
Figure 3.2. Refrigerator doors




















2
1
2
1 0
DP
DP
X
X
X
FR
FR



















2
1
2
1
0
0
DP
DP
X
X
FR
FR
X: nonzero value (relationship)
Example 3.1 [Design of a Refrigerator Door]
Vertically hung door in Figure 3.2(a)
DP1: Vertically hung door
DP2: Thermal insulation in the door
(2) Horizontally hung door in Figure 3.2(b)
DP1: Horizontally hung door
DP2: Thermal insulation in the door
Which one is better?
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (2)

Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet]
Some commercial water faucets are evaluated. FRs for the faucet are defined as follows:
FR1: Control the flow of water (Q).
FR2: Control the temperature of water (T).
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (3)

Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet]
For the one in Figure 3.3(a)
DP1: Angle
DP2: Angle
1

2




















)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
2
2
1
1
2
1


DP
DP
X
X
X
X
T
FR
Q
FR
1

2

3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (4)
Figure 3.3.(a) Coupled design

Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet]
For the one in Figure 3.3(b)
DP1: Angle
DP2: Angle
1

2




















)
(
)
(
0
0
)
(
)
(
2
2
1
1
2
1


DP
DP
X
X
T
FR
Q
FR
Cold water Hot water
2

1

3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (5)
Figure 3.3.(b) Coupled design




















)
(
)
(
0
0
)
(
)
(
2
1
2
1

DP
Y
DP
X
X
T
FR
Q
FR
Which one is the best? Is it different from what you expected?
Y

Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet]
For the one in Figure 3.3(c)
DP1: Displacement Y
DP2: Angle 
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (6)
Figure 3.3.(c) Coupled design
































3
2
1
3
2
1
0
0
0
0
DP
DP
DP
X
X
x
X
X
FR
FR
FR































3
2
1
3
2
1
0
0
0
0
DP
DP
DP
X
X
x
X
X
FR
FR
FR
for Figure 2.1(a)
Example 3.3 [Axiomatic Design of the Toaster in Example 2.1]
Make the design matrices for the products in Figure 2.1(a) and Figure 2.1(b)
Solution
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (7)
for Figure 2.1(b)

(a) Functional domain
FR
FR1 FR2
FR11 FR12
…
… FR21 FR22 …
DP
DP1 DP2
DP11 DP12
…
… DP21 DP22 …
①
②
③
④
(b) Physical domain
For complicated systems: we need a decomposition which yields a hierarchy.
The zigzagging process
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (8)
Figure 3.4. Zigzagging process between domains

FR: 서울에서 부산으로 가라.
 지그재그과정의 예 (서울에서 부산가는 법)
서울에서 부산으로 가라. 비행기
비행장으로 가라. 표를 사라. …
비행기를 타라.
서울에서 부산으로 가라. 기차
기차역으로 가라. 표를 사라. …
기차를 타라.
(1)
(2)
상위단계의 DP가 하위단계의 FR을 결정한다.

Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2]
The top level (first level) FRs and DPs are:
FR1: Freeze food or water for long-term preservation.
FR2: Maintain food at a cold temperature for short-term preservation.
DP1: The freezer section
DP2: The chiller section
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (9)

Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2]
The second (first level) FRs are:
FR11: Maintain the temperature of the freezer section in the range of .
FR12: Maintain a uniform temperature in the freezer section.
FR13: Control the relative humidity to 50% in the freezer section.
FR21: Maintain the temperature of the chiller section in the range of .
FR22: Maintain a uniform temperature in the chiller section within of the preset
temperature .
C
2
C
18 



C
3
C
2 


C
5
.
0 

3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (10)
































13
11
12
13
11
12
0
0
0
0
DP
DP
DP
X
X
X
X
X
FR
FR
FR
Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2]
The second level DPs are:
DP11: Sensor/compressor system that activates the compressor when the temperature of
the freezer section is different from the preset one.
DP12: Air circulation system that blows the air into the freezer and circulates it uniformly.
DP13: Condenser that condenses the moisture in the returned air when the dew point is
exceeded.
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (11)




















21
22
21
22 0
DP
DP
X
X
X
FR
FR
Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2]
The second level DPs are:
DP21: Sensor/compressor system that activates the compressor when the temperature of
the chiller section is different from the preset one.
DP22: Air circulation system that blows the air into the chiller section and circulates it
uniformly.
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (12)


















































21
22
13
11
12
21
22
13
11
12
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
DP
DP
DP
DP
DP
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
FR
FR
FR
FR
FR
Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2]
The entire design equation is
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (13)

Physical integration
There is a saying that a simple design is a good one.
A good design makes one DP satisfy multiple FRs?
A coupled design is better?
This is the case where multiple DPs make a physical entity. Multiple DPs satisfy FRs of the
same number.
Physical Integration: recommended
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (14)




















2
1
2
1
0
0
DP
DP
X
X
FR
FR
Example 3.5 [Bottle-can opener]
Given FRs are
FR1: Design a device that can open bottles.
FR2: Design a device that can open cans.
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (15)
DP2
DP1

12 FRs and 12 DPs: decoupled design
Example 3.6 [Beverage Can Design]
Another example for physical integration
3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (16)

In the designing process, the Independence Axiom should be satisfied first.
When multiple designs that satisfy the Independence Axiom are found, the Information
axiom is utilized to find the best design.
The best design is the one with minimum information.
Generally, the information is related to complexity.
How can we measure the complexity?
How can we quantify the information content?
3.5 The Information Axiom

p
I /
1
log2

The information can be defined in various ways.
Up to now, one measure is used for the information content.
where I is the information content and p is the probability of success to satisfy an FR with a DP.
The reciprocal of p is used to make the larger probability have less information.
The logarithm function is used to enhance additivity.
The base of the logarithm is 2 to express the information content with the bit unit.
3.5 The Information Axiom (2)
































3
2
1
33
22
11
3
2
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
DP
DP
DP
A
A
A
FR
FR
FR
Suppose p1, p2 and p3 are probabilities of satisfying FR1, FR2 and FR3 with DP1, DP2 and
DP3, respectively. The total information Itotal is
 












3
1
2
3
1
total
1
log
i i
i
i
p
I
I
For the following uncoupled design:
3.5 The Information Axiom (3)

If p1 is the probability that DP1 satisfies FR1, then the probability that DP2 satisfies FR2 under
the satisfaction of FR1 by DP1 is a conditional probability. Suppose it is p21. Then the
probability of success p that both FR1 and FR2 are satisfied is p=p1p21.
The total information content for p is



















2
1
2
1 0
DP
DP
X
X
X
FR
FR
2
1
21
2
1
2
21
1
2
2 log
log
)
(
log
log I
I
p
p
p
p
p
I 








For the following decoupled design:
3.5 The Information Axiom (4)

System range (Asr): response (output)
Design range: target, Common range: Acr
sr
cr / A
A
ps 
)
/
(
log sr
cr
2 A
A
I 

Design
range
Probability
density
Probability
density function
of the system
Common
range
FR
1 3 5 7 9
Information content can be calculated by using the probability density function in the
following figure:
3.5 The Information Axiom (5)

Example 3.7 [An Example of Calculating Information Content]
For the bottle-can opener problem
The probability of satisfying FR1 with DP1: 0.9
The probability of satisfying FR2 with DP2: 0.85
The total information content is
bits)
(
3865
.
0
2345
.
0
1520
.
0
85
.
0
1
log
9
.
0
1
log 2
2
2
1
total 

















 I
I
I
What if we do not have physical integration?
3.6 Application of the Information Axiom

city A city B
Price $45,000 - $60,000 $70,000 - $90,000
Commuting time 35-50 min 20-30 min
Example 3.9 [Calculation of the Information Content Using the Probability Density Function]
A person defines two functional requirements to buy a house as follows:
FR1: Let the price range be from $50,000 to $80,000.
FR2: Let the commuting time be within 40 minutes.
The following table shows the conditions of city A and city B.
3.6 Application of the Information Axiom (2)

For city A
59
.
1
5
15
log
,
59
.
0
1
5
.
1
log 2
2
2
1 














 A
A I
I
)
bits
(
18
.
2
2
1 

 A
A
A I
I
I
0
.
1
1
2
log2
1 







B
I 0
.
0
10
10
log2
2 







B
I
bits)
(
0
.
1
2
1 

 B
B
B I
I
I
Which one is better?
Design range
Bias
Probability
density
FR
Target
Probability density
function of the
system
Common
range
Variation from the
peak value
Example 3.9 [Calculation of the Information Content Using the Probability Density Function]
For city B
3.6 Application of the Information Axiom (3)

Time

Two axioms are independent of each other.
The flow in Figure 3.1 is recommended.
The numbers of FRs and DPs should be the same (ideal design).
The no. of DPs is smaller: New DPs should be added.
The no. of DPs is larger (redundant design): Some DPs are eliminated or specific DPs are
fixed.
Axiomatic design is useful in conceptual design. It can be used for creative design or
evaluating an existing design.
3.7 Discussion
Solution neutral environment

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

An overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigerator
An overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigeratorAn overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigerator
An overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigeratoreSAT Journals
 
Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)
Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)
Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)dkpawar
 
Product Design and Development
Product Design and DevelopmentProduct Design and Development
Product Design and DevelopmentSURYAPRAKASH S
 
Operations Management : Line Balancing
Operations Management : Line BalancingOperations Management : Line Balancing
Operations Management : Line BalancingRohan Bharaj
 
Training report on catia
Training report on catiaTraining report on catia
Training report on catiaTajender12singh
 
Special Cases in Simplex Method
Special Cases in Simplex MethodSpecial Cases in Simplex Method
Special Cases in Simplex MethodDivyansh Verma
 
Facility layout-material-handling
Facility layout-material-handlingFacility layout-material-handling
Facility layout-material-handlingAjit Kumar
 
Operation research - Chapter 01
Operation research - Chapter 01Operation research - Chapter 01
Operation research - Chapter 012013901097
 
Product design and development ch1
Product design and development ch1Product design and development ch1
Product design and development ch1Kavindra Singh
 
Craft software for dummies
Craft software for dummiesCraft software for dummies
Craft software for dummiesRama Renspandy
 
Ch5 process analysis
Ch5 process analysisCh5 process analysis
Ch5 process analysisvideoaakash15
 
Integer Linear Programming
Integer Linear ProgrammingInteger Linear Programming
Integer Linear ProgrammingSukhpalRamanand
 
Assembly Line Balancing -Example
Assembly Line Balancing -ExampleAssembly Line Balancing -Example
Assembly Line Balancing -ExampleJoseph Konnully
 
Product design and development
Product design and developmentProduct design and development
Product design and developmentKishor Tayade
 
transporation problem
transporation problemtransporation problem
transporation problemVivek Lohani
 
Operational research 2
Operational research 2Operational research 2
Operational research 2ZAKI ANWER
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Operations research
Operations researchOperations research
Operations research
 
An overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigerator
An overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigeratorAn overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigerator
An overview of stack design for a thermoacoustic refrigerator
 
Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)
Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)
Vogel’s Approximation Method (VAM)
 
Product Design and Development
Product Design and DevelopmentProduct Design and Development
Product Design and Development
 
Operations Management : Line Balancing
Operations Management : Line BalancingOperations Management : Line Balancing
Operations Management : Line Balancing
 
Training report on catia
Training report on catiaTraining report on catia
Training report on catia
 
Least cost
Least costLeast cost
Least cost
 
CAD/CAM Lecture #3
CAD/CAM Lecture #3CAD/CAM Lecture #3
CAD/CAM Lecture #3
 
Special Cases in Simplex Method
Special Cases in Simplex MethodSpecial Cases in Simplex Method
Special Cases in Simplex Method
 
Facility layout-material-handling
Facility layout-material-handlingFacility layout-material-handling
Facility layout-material-handling
 
Operation research - Chapter 01
Operation research - Chapter 01Operation research - Chapter 01
Operation research - Chapter 01
 
Product design and development ch1
Product design and development ch1Product design and development ch1
Product design and development ch1
 
Craft software for dummies
Craft software for dummiesCraft software for dummies
Craft software for dummies
 
Ch5 process analysis
Ch5 process analysisCh5 process analysis
Ch5 process analysis
 
Integer Linear Programming
Integer Linear ProgrammingInteger Linear Programming
Integer Linear Programming
 
Assembly Line Balancing -Example
Assembly Line Balancing -ExampleAssembly Line Balancing -Example
Assembly Line Balancing -Example
 
Product design and development
Product design and developmentProduct design and development
Product design and development
 
transporation problem
transporation problemtransporation problem
transporation problem
 
Operational research 2
Operational research 2Operational research 2
Operational research 2
 
Pinturas de Valparaiso
Pinturas de ValparaisoPinturas de Valparaiso
Pinturas de Valparaiso
 

Ähnlich wie Axiomatic Design Explained

A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCsA Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCsVLSICS Design
 
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCsA Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCsVLSICS Design
 
Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...
Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...
Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...orajjournal
 
JGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation Balance
JGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation BalanceJGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation Balance
JGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation BalanceMarialaura Bancheri
 
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...Alexander Decker
 
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...Alexander Decker
 
Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method
Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method
Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method Rishi Dua
 
REFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONING
REFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONINGREFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONING
REFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONINGradhakrishnan unni
 
Optimized mould design of an Air cooler tank
Optimized mould design of an Air cooler tankOptimized mould design of an Air cooler tank
Optimized mould design of an Air cooler tankIOSR Journals
 
CORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdf
CORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdfCORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdf
CORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdfmichelepalermo6
 
Ph.D. Capstone Seminar
Ph.D. Capstone SeminarPh.D. Capstone Seminar
Ph.D. Capstone Seminarshirabay
 
CFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamics
CFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamicsCFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamics
CFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamicsssuser92ea91
 
I144853
I144853I144853
I144853irjes
 
Huge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble Nuclei
Huge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble NucleiHuge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble Nuclei
Huge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble NucleiHiroshi Watanabe
 
Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...
Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...
Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...Stephane Meteodyn
 
El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711
El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711
El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711RCCSRENKEI
 

Ähnlich wie Axiomatic Design Explained (20)

Case studing
Case studingCase studing
Case studing
 
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCsA Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
 
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCsA Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
A Novel Methodology for Thermal Aware Silicon Area Estimation for 2D & 3D MPSoCs
 
Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...
Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...
Fuzzy Inventory Model of Deteriorating Items under Power Dependent Demand and...
 
JGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation Balance
JGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation BalanceJGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation Balance
JGrass-NewAge LongWave radiation Balance
 
Intro
IntroIntro
Intro
 
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
 
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
A numerical simulation of the effect of ambient temperature on capillary tube...
 
Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method
Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method
Simulation of Electron Beam Melting With the Lattice Boltzmann Method
 
REFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONING
REFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONINGREFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONING
REFRIGERATION AND AIR CONDITIONING
 
Optimized mould design of an Air cooler tank
Optimized mould design of an Air cooler tankOptimized mould design of an Air cooler tank
Optimized mould design of an Air cooler tank
 
CORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdf
CORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdfCORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdf
CORSO SMORZATORI_LEZ 2_31-05-2023.pdf
 
Ph.D. Capstone Seminar
Ph.D. Capstone SeminarPh.D. Capstone Seminar
Ph.D. Capstone Seminar
 
CFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamics
CFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamicsCFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamics
CFD discretisation methods in fluid dynamics
 
I144853
I144853I144853
I144853
 
Huge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble Nuclei
Huge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble NucleiHuge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble Nuclei
Huge-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Multi-bubble Nuclei
 
Chapter 3 pc
Chapter 3 pcChapter 3 pc
Chapter 3 pc
 
Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...
Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...
Validations and applications of a CFD tool dedicated to wind assessment in ur...
 
Lwrb linkers
Lwrb linkersLwrb linkers
Lwrb linkers
 
El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711
El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711
El text.tokuron a(2019).jung190711
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Karim apartment ideas 01 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 01 pppppppppppppppKarim apartment ideas 01 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 01 pppppppppppppppNadaMohammed714321
 
AI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - Morgenbooster
AI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - MorgenboosterAI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - Morgenbooster
AI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - Morgenbooster1508 A/S
 
world health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbb
world health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbbworld health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbb
world health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbbpreetirao780
 
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.pptMaking and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.pptJIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine                      Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine CharlottePulte
 
Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks                              Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks CharlottePulte
 
simpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdf
simpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdfsimpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdf
simpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdfLucyBonelli
 
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...Associazione Digital Days
 
CAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdf
CAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdfCAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdf
CAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdfAlasAlthaher
 
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptxNiintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptxKevinYaelJimnezSanti
 
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...Rishabh Aryan
 
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenologyThe spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenologyChristopher Totten
 
10 must-have Chrome extensions for designers
10 must-have Chrome extensions for designers10 must-have Chrome extensions for designers
10 must-have Chrome extensions for designersPixeldarts
 
General Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDin
General Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDinGeneral Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDin
General Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDinSamar Hossam ElDin Ahmed
 
FW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers Paris
FW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers ParisFW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers Paris
FW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers ParisPeclers Paris
 
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssssguest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssssNadaMohammed714321
 
guest bathroom white and bluesssssssssss
guest bathroom white and bluesssssssssssguest bathroom white and bluesssssssssss
guest bathroom white and bluesssssssssssNadaMohammed714321
 
NBA power point presentation final copy y
NBA power point presentation final copy yNBA power point presentation final copy y
NBA power point presentation final copy ysrajece
 
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 202410 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024digital learning point
 
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptxUnit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptxNitish292041
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Karim apartment ideas 01 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 01 pppppppppppppppKarim apartment ideas 01 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 01 ppppppppppppppp
 
AI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - Morgenbooster
AI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - MorgenboosterAI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - Morgenbooster
AI and Design Vol. 2: Navigating the New Frontier - Morgenbooster
 
world health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbb
world health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbbworld health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbb
world health day 2024.pptxgbbvggvbhjjjbbbb
 
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.pptMaking and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
 
Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine                      Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine
 
Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks                              Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks
 
simpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdf
simpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdfsimpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdf
simpson-lee_house_dt20ajshsjsjsjsjj15.pdf
 
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
 
CAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdf
CAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdfCAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdf
CAPITAL GATE CASE STUDY -regional case study.pdf
 
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptxNiintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
 
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
 
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenologyThe spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
 
10 must-have Chrome extensions for designers
10 must-have Chrome extensions for designers10 must-have Chrome extensions for designers
10 must-have Chrome extensions for designers
 
General Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDin
General Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDinGeneral Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDin
General Simple Guide About AI in Design By: A.L. Samar Hossam ElDin
 
FW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers Paris
FW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers ParisFW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers Paris
FW25-26 Knit Cut & Sew Trend Book Peclers Paris
 
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssssguest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
 
guest bathroom white and bluesssssssssss
guest bathroom white and bluesssssssssssguest bathroom white and bluesssssssssss
guest bathroom white and bluesssssssssss
 
NBA power point presentation final copy y
NBA power point presentation final copy yNBA power point presentation final copy y
NBA power point presentation final copy y
 
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 202410 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
 
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptxUnit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
 

Axiomatic Design Explained

  • 2.  3.1 Introduction (2) Examples of axioms in Geometry: Points and lines are names for the elements of two (distinct) sets. Incidence is a relationship that may (or may not) hold between a particular point and a particular line. The followings are examples of axioms: 1) For every two points, there exists a line incident with both points. 2) For every two points, there is no more than one line incident with both points. 3) There exist at least two points incident with each line. 4) There exist at least three points. Not all points are incident with the same line. Examples of axioms in Physics: 1) Newton’s law: F = ma 2) Thermodynamic principles 3) ……
  • 3.  Axiomatic design is a design methodology that was created and popularized by Professor Suh of MIT (used be the President of KAIST). It is a design framework that is feasible on all design disciplines. The Independence Axiom, The Information Axiom An axiom is a statement accepted without proof as an underlying assumption of a formal mathematical theory. It cannot be proved. If a counter example is found for an axiom, the axiom becomes obsolete. Geometry, Laws in Physics, Thermodynamic principles 3.1 Introduction
  • 4.  Design Axioms Axiom 1: The Independence Axiom Maintain the independence of FRs. Alternate Statement 1: An optimal design always maintains the independence of FRs. Alternate Statement 2: In an acceptable design, DPs and FRs are related in such a way that a specific DP can be adjusted to satisfy its corresponding FR without affecting other functional requirements. Axiom 2: The Information Axiom Minimize the information content of the design. Alternate Statement: The best design is a functionally uncoupled design that has minimum information content. 3.2. Design Axioms
  • 5.  Usage of the axioms: Analysis of design Find designs that satisfy the Independence Axiom. Determine the final design. Is the no. of designs sufficient? Find the best design with the Information Axiom. Multiple designs? No Yes Yes No 3.2. Design Axioms (2) Figure 3.1. Flow chart of the application of axiomatic design
  • 6.  The Independence Axiom: The FR-DP relationship should be independent.                       3 2 1 3 2 1 , DP DP DP FR FR FR DP FR equation design : ADP FR                                 3 2 1 33 32 31 23 22 21 13 12 11 3 2 1 DP DP DP A A A A A A A A A FR FR FR FR: FR vector, DP: DP vector, A: design matrix 3.3 Independence Axiom
  • 7.                                 3 2 1 33 22 11 3 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 DP DP DP A A A FR FR FR 1 11 1 DP A FR   2 22 2 DP A FR   3 33 3 DP A FR                                  3 2 1 33 32 31 22 21 11 3 2 1 0 0 0 DP DP DP A A A A A A FR FR FR 1 11 1 DP A FR   2 22 1 21 2 DP A DP A FR     3 33 2 32 1 31 3 DP A DP A DP A FR       3.3 Independence Axiom (2) 1) Uncoupled design: Each DP satisfies the corresponding FR independently. - diagonal matrix 2) Decoupled design: The Independence Axiom is satisfied when the design sequence is right. - triangular matrix
  • 8.  (3) Coupled design: No sequences of DPs can satisfy the FRs independently. –general matrix                                3 2 1 33 32 31 23 22 21 13 12 11 3 2 1 DP DP DP A A A A A A A A A FR FR FR 3 13 2 12 1 11 1 DP A DP A DP A FR       3 23 2 22 1 21 2 DP A DP A DP A FR       3 33 2 32 1 31 3 DP A DP A DP A FR       Constraints (Cs): Cs can be defined regardless of the independence of the FR-DP relationship. 3.3 Independence Axiom (3)
  • 9.  (a) Vertically hung door (b) Horizontally hung door Example 3.1 [Design of a Refrigerator Door] FRs for a refrigerator door are as follows: FR1: Provide access to the items stored in the refrigerator. FR2: Minimize energy loss. Which door is better between the following doors? 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom Figure 3.2. Refrigerator doors
  • 10.                     2 1 2 1 0 DP DP X X X FR FR                    2 1 2 1 0 0 DP DP X X FR FR X: nonzero value (relationship) Example 3.1 [Design of a Refrigerator Door] Vertically hung door in Figure 3.2(a) DP1: Vertically hung door DP2: Thermal insulation in the door (2) Horizontally hung door in Figure 3.2(b) DP1: Horizontally hung door DP2: Thermal insulation in the door Which one is better? 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (2)
  • 11.  Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet] Some commercial water faucets are evaluated. FRs for the faucet are defined as follows: FR1: Control the flow of water (Q). FR2: Control the temperature of water (T). 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (3)
  • 12.  Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet] For the one in Figure 3.3(a) DP1: Angle DP2: Angle 1  2                     ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( 2 2 1 1 2 1   DP DP X X X X T FR Q FR 1  2  3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (4) Figure 3.3.(a) Coupled design
  • 13.  Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet] For the one in Figure 3.3(b) DP1: Angle DP2: Angle 1  2                     ) ( ) ( 0 0 ) ( ) ( 2 2 1 1 2 1   DP DP X X T FR Q FR Cold water Hot water 2  1  3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (5) Figure 3.3.(b) Coupled design
  • 14.                     ) ( ) ( 0 0 ) ( ) ( 2 1 2 1  DP Y DP X X T FR Q FR Which one is the best? Is it different from what you expected? Y  Example 3.2 [Design of a Water Faucet] For the one in Figure 3.3(c) DP1: Displacement Y DP2: Angle  3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (6) Figure 3.3.(c) Coupled design
  • 16.  (a) Functional domain FR FR1 FR2 FR11 FR12 … … FR21 FR22 … DP DP1 DP2 DP11 DP12 … … DP21 DP22 … ① ② ③ ④ (b) Physical domain For complicated systems: we need a decomposition which yields a hierarchy. The zigzagging process 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (8) Figure 3.4. Zigzagging process between domains
  • 17.  FR: 서울에서 부산으로 가라.  지그재그과정의 예 (서울에서 부산가는 법) 서울에서 부산으로 가라. 비행기 비행장으로 가라. 표를 사라. … 비행기를 타라. 서울에서 부산으로 가라. 기차 기차역으로 가라. 표를 사라. … 기차를 타라. (1) (2) 상위단계의 DP가 하위단계의 FR을 결정한다.
  • 18.  Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2] The top level (first level) FRs and DPs are: FR1: Freeze food or water for long-term preservation. FR2: Maintain food at a cold temperature for short-term preservation. DP1: The freezer section DP2: The chiller section 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (9)
  • 19.  Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2] The second (first level) FRs are: FR11: Maintain the temperature of the freezer section in the range of . FR12: Maintain a uniform temperature in the freezer section. FR13: Control the relative humidity to 50% in the freezer section. FR21: Maintain the temperature of the chiller section in the range of . FR22: Maintain a uniform temperature in the chiller section within of the preset temperature . C 2 C 18     C 3 C 2    C 5 . 0   3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (10)
  • 20.                                 13 11 12 13 11 12 0 0 0 0 DP DP DP X X X X X FR FR FR Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2] The second level DPs are: DP11: Sensor/compressor system that activates the compressor when the temperature of the freezer section is different from the preset one. DP12: Air circulation system that blows the air into the freezer and circulates it uniformly. DP13: Condenser that condenses the moisture in the returned air when the dew point is exceeded. 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (11)
  • 21.                     21 22 21 22 0 DP DP X X X FR FR Example 3.4 [Decomposition of Example 2.2] The second level DPs are: DP21: Sensor/compressor system that activates the compressor when the temperature of the chiller section is different from the preset one. DP22: Air circulation system that blows the air into the chiller section and circulates it uniformly. 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (12)
  • 23.  Physical integration There is a saying that a simple design is a good one. A good design makes one DP satisfy multiple FRs? A coupled design is better? This is the case where multiple DPs make a physical entity. Multiple DPs satisfy FRs of the same number. Physical Integration: recommended 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (14)
  • 24.                     2 1 2 1 0 0 DP DP X X FR FR Example 3.5 [Bottle-can opener] Given FRs are FR1: Design a device that can open bottles. FR2: Design a device that can open cans. 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (15) DP2 DP1
  • 25.  12 FRs and 12 DPs: decoupled design Example 3.6 [Beverage Can Design] Another example for physical integration 3.4 Application of the Independence Axiom (16)
  • 26.  In the designing process, the Independence Axiom should be satisfied first. When multiple designs that satisfy the Independence Axiom are found, the Information axiom is utilized to find the best design. The best design is the one with minimum information. Generally, the information is related to complexity. How can we measure the complexity? How can we quantify the information content? 3.5 The Information Axiom
  • 27.  p I / 1 log2  The information can be defined in various ways. Up to now, one measure is used for the information content. where I is the information content and p is the probability of success to satisfy an FR with a DP. The reciprocal of p is used to make the larger probability have less information. The logarithm function is used to enhance additivity. The base of the logarithm is 2 to express the information content with the bit unit. 3.5 The Information Axiom (2)
  • 28.                                 3 2 1 33 22 11 3 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 DP DP DP A A A FR FR FR Suppose p1, p2 and p3 are probabilities of satisfying FR1, FR2 and FR3 with DP1, DP2 and DP3, respectively. The total information Itotal is               3 1 2 3 1 total 1 log i i i i p I I For the following uncoupled design: 3.5 The Information Axiom (3)
  • 29.  If p1 is the probability that DP1 satisfies FR1, then the probability that DP2 satisfies FR2 under the satisfaction of FR1 by DP1 is a conditional probability. Suppose it is p21. Then the probability of success p that both FR1 and FR2 are satisfied is p=p1p21. The total information content for p is                    2 1 2 1 0 DP DP X X X FR FR 2 1 21 2 1 2 21 1 2 2 log log ) ( log log I I p p p p p I          For the following decoupled design: 3.5 The Information Axiom (4)
  • 30.  System range (Asr): response (output) Design range: target, Common range: Acr sr cr / A A ps  ) / ( log sr cr 2 A A I   Design range Probability density Probability density function of the system Common range FR 1 3 5 7 9 Information content can be calculated by using the probability density function in the following figure: 3.5 The Information Axiom (5)
  • 31.  Example 3.7 [An Example of Calculating Information Content] For the bottle-can opener problem The probability of satisfying FR1 with DP1: 0.9 The probability of satisfying FR2 with DP2: 0.85 The total information content is bits) ( 3865 . 0 2345 . 0 1520 . 0 85 . 0 1 log 9 . 0 1 log 2 2 2 1 total                    I I I What if we do not have physical integration? 3.6 Application of the Information Axiom
  • 32.  city A city B Price $45,000 - $60,000 $70,000 - $90,000 Commuting time 35-50 min 20-30 min Example 3.9 [Calculation of the Information Content Using the Probability Density Function] A person defines two functional requirements to buy a house as follows: FR1: Let the price range be from $50,000 to $80,000. FR2: Let the commuting time be within 40 minutes. The following table shows the conditions of city A and city B. 3.6 Application of the Information Axiom (2)
  • 33.  For city A 59 . 1 5 15 log , 59 . 0 1 5 . 1 log 2 2 2 1                 A A I I ) bits ( 18 . 2 2 1    A A A I I I 0 . 1 1 2 log2 1         B I 0 . 0 10 10 log2 2         B I bits) ( 0 . 1 2 1    B B B I I I Which one is better? Design range Bias Probability density FR Target Probability density function of the system Common range Variation from the peak value Example 3.9 [Calculation of the Information Content Using the Probability Density Function] For city B 3.6 Application of the Information Axiom (3)
  • 34.  Time  Two axioms are independent of each other. The flow in Figure 3.1 is recommended. The numbers of FRs and DPs should be the same (ideal design). The no. of DPs is smaller: New DPs should be added. The no. of DPs is larger (redundant design): Some DPs are eliminated or specific DPs are fixed. Axiomatic design is useful in conceptual design. It can be used for creative design or evaluating an existing design. 3.7 Discussion Solution neutral environment