More than ever before, brands rely on strong claims to convince consumers of their superiority. Marketing executives recognize this and send directives to their teams to create more hard-hitting claims. The most intuitive response is to do this by making comparative claims that directly claim superiority over competitive offerings. But is this really the most effective way to set yourself apart?
We did a deep dive into this topic and are here to share our findings. Analysis of thousands of claims reveals how consumers really perceive value and the way it affects their decision making. By linking these insights to the everyday complexities clients face, we will bring you a set of actionable guidelines on how to maximize the impact of your product claims.
5. Because they
have a need that
the benefits of
the product
will fulfill
Make Salads
Tastier
Get smooth
skin
Disinfect
Surfaces
6. All else equal,
they will choose
the one with the
highest perceived
value (benefit)
Perceived
Value
A Perceived
ValueB
Perceived
Value
C
Cleans
Best
Cleans
Well
Cleans
Better
Consumer
Choice
7. So comparing our
brand versus the
competition with the
support of some
numbers is the right
way to go, no?
8. By leveraging positive associations
consumers have with a more
established brand, a brand can:
Establish credibility for new entrants
Help overcome specific barriers to
purchase, such as quality concerns
Brand comparisons
can successfully contribute
towards reaching certain goals
9. Is often judged
negatively (bashing)
Can remove focus
from the key benefit
Can undermine a
brand’s credibility
There are, however, also
serious risks involved
with using brand
comparisons
10. Consumer Perception = Reality
How do we
communicate
superior value
without these
side effects?
11. Which bar soap moisturizes better?
¼
In the end, a product offers as much value as the consumer perceives it does. By comparing
against objective benchmarks a brand can portray a sense of superior performance that in the
mind of the consumer will unconsciously transfer to its perceived value vs. competitors.
12. Always
focus on the
key benefits
principles of
creating superior
value perception
3
Make your
promise
tangible
#2
#1
Creatively
define your
benchmark
#3
13. Always focus on
the key benefits
Position yourself
on the basis of what
matters to consumers
1
21. Always
focus on the
key benefits
#1
Make your
promise
tangible
#2
Creatively
Define your
benchmark
#3
Usecompelling
tastedescriptorsto
bringtheproduct
experience
tolife
#1
Emphasizethe
qualityororiginof
theingredients,
nottheprocess
#2
Supportyour
messagewith
appealing
visuals
#3
22. Contact us
Paul Janssen
Vice President
Based in New York
p.janssen@skimgroup.com
Scott Garrison
Manager
Based in London
s.garrison@skimgroup.com
Hinweis der Redaktion
Explain that hard hitting is often interpreted as brand comparisons + numbers
So to answer the previous question, let’s take a step back and answer the question…
Keep it simple, just stick with these three benefits
THEY DON’T BUY DRESSING TO MAKE SALAD TASTIER
WE DON’T BUY A SHAVER BECAUSE IT LOOKS GOOD IN OUR BATHROOM CABINET
Value is related to the benefit they would like to obtain, the product that best addresses their needs has the most perceived value.
If price is equal, and everything else, they will choose the one that DELIVERS THE MOST BENEFIT, the one that BEST ADDRESSES THE REASON FOR PURCHASING THE PRODUCT IN THE FIRST PLACE.
So then it makes sense to position yourself versus the competition and show the consumers how they get more value out of you than the competition, or in other words, it makes sense to use comparative claims, no?
We are already discussed how consumers choose the option with the HIGHESTE PERCEIVED VALUE, so how does this work?
10,000+ claims, meta-analysis
Remember why consumers buy a product in the first place? Don’t forget this when we’re trying to sell them one.
This is easily forgotten in our pursuit of differentiation and creativity, but key to CREATING A CONNECTION with a RECIPICIENT, this is the same for JOB INTERVIEW, or TRYING TO CONVINCE YOUR HUSBAND OR WIFE TO GO A CERTAIN VACATION SPOT
BUTTER RE-IMAGINED great as a creative marketing campaign idea, but will not tell the consumer WHAT THE PRODUCT WILL DO FOR THEM.
Need high res image
Being specific allows people to get a better understanding of what the product will do for them, and helps them relate to it.
You can be specific in NUMBERS, WORDS and VISUALS
Here we go back to how perception is reality. By comparing against objective benchmarks a brand can portray a sense of superior performance that in the mind of the consumer will unconsciously transfer to its perceived value vs. competitors
By being smart about the bench mark (REGULAR SOAP, BASIC CLEANSING, NON-CONDITIONING SHAMPOO ALONE) you can portray an image of superior performance without absorbing all the negative side effects of bashing or getting caught up in comparing on that one IRRELEVANT BENEFIT where you do outperform your key competitors
FUNCTIONAL CATEGORIES it’s easier to prove in lab, but experiential ones not so much
Consumers trust peers (fellow buyers, fellow restaurant goers) AMAZON, YELP, but don’t trust it if is coming from the brand:
Examples: 4 out of 5 people prefer the taste of X maybe I’m the fifth? Company has paid for people to say that..
Experiential benefits (smell, taste, touch, hearing, sight) differ by person, so consumers tend to have an attitude of first try to believe it.
3X TASTIER
4X BETTER SMELL
THESE DON’T FLY AT ALL
#1 Use compelling taste descriptors to bring the product experience to life
It will help consumers paint a mental picture of the delicious taste they are looking for. FRESH, CREAMY, FLAVORFUL, PURE, DELICIOUS, AUTHENTIC
#2 Consumers look for FRESH, NATURAL, REAL, SIMPLE ingredients as they relay the impression of quality and a tasty product
Consumers know that good quality ingredients result in a better, tastier product, so leverage this association (Consumers look for FRESH, NATURAL, REAL, SIMPLE ingredients as they relay the impression of quality and a tasty product HUGE TREND OF GOING BACK TO SIMPLER PRODUCT LABELS)
Origin instills trust and triggers associations of quality that ladder up to better taste perceptions (Origin can be good because they trust LOCAL grown food (MADE IN USA) over imported NATIONAL PRIDE, NO LONG SHIPPING. UNLESS a region is really famous for a certain product: CHOCOLATE FROM BELGIUM, WINE FROM FRANCE, CHEESE FROM HOLLAND)
#3 Appealing pictures are more powerful than words and help build mental models of what the text is all about
a lot of claims that do well are very descriptive, they do a good job of helping consumers visualize the end results or workings of a product. This might have to do with the fact that in the end the consumer things in images and makes decisions based on the images that are formed, so the sooner you can get there in a positive way, the better. I don't mean necessarily a speed contest to getting to the images, but more like getting there at all. Some claims cannot be visualized and my hypothesis is that they are less effective because of that.