Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...
Cindy Brach - Becoming a Health Literate Organization
1. Becoming aBecoming a
Health Literate OrganizationHealth Literate Organization
Cindy BrachCindy Brach
Center for Delivery,Center for Delivery,
Organization, and MarketsOrganization, and Markets
3. Health Literate OrganizationsHealth Literate Organizations
A health literate organizationA health literate organization
makes it easy for people tomakes it easy for people to
navigate, understand, andnavigate, understand, and
use information and servicesuse information and services
to take care of their health.to take care of their health.
Brach et al. 2012Brach et al. 2012
4. Health Literacy EquationHealth Literacy Equation
Skills/Abilities xSkills/Abilities x Difficulty/ComplexityDifficulty/Complexity = Health Literacy= Health Literacy
XX ==
6. Communicate ClearlyCommunicate Clearly
Warm GreetingWarm Greeting
Eye ContactEye Contact
ListenListen
Use Plain, Non-medicalUse Plain, Non-medical
LanguageLanguage
Slow DownSlow Down
Limit ContentLimit Content
Show How It’s DoneShow How It’s Done
Use Teach-BackUse Teach-Back
Repeat Key PointsRepeat Key Points
Use GraphicsUse Graphics
Invite PatientInvite Patient
ParticipationParticipation
Encourage QuestionsEncourage Questions
Source: AHRQ Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit, Tool 4Source: AHRQ Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit, Tool 4
7. Implementing ClearImplementing Clear
CommunicationCommunication
Online training, e.g.,
http://www.teachbacktraining.org/http://www.teachbacktraining.org/
Practice, e.g., role play
Assessments
– Communication Self-Assessment
– Communication Observation Form
– Patient Feedback Form
Reminders: team huddles, poster
Source: AHRQ Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit, Tool 4 andSource: AHRQ Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit, Tool 4 and
Implementing the AHRQ Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit:Implementing the AHRQ Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit:
Practical Ideas for Primary Care PracticesPractical Ideas for Primary Care Practices
9. Implementing Action PlanningImplementing Action Planning
Watch ACP video and discussWatch ACP video and discuss
Practice, e.g., role playPractice, e.g., role play
Address team roles and workflowAddress team roles and workflow
– Who places copies of Action Plan forms inWho places copies of Action Plan forms in
the chart?the chart?
– Who helps patients choose goalsWho helps patients choose goals
– How can EHR support and track ActionHow can EHR support and track Action
Planning?Planning?
– Who follows up with patient?Who follows up with patient?
10. Improving WrittenImproving Written
MaterialsMaterials
Clear purposeClear purpose
Everyday languageEveryday language
No jargonNo jargon
Active voiceActive voice
Visuals reinforceVisuals reinforce
messagesmessages
White spaceWhite space
Short linesShort lines
Short sectionShort section
InformativeInformative
headingsheadings
Logical flowLogical flow
11. Implementing ImprovementsImplementing Improvements
in Written Materialsin Written Materials
Establish processEstablish process
Assess materialsAssess materials
– Formal assessments, e.g., PEMAT, CCIFormal assessments, e.g., PEMAT, CCI
– Review by consumers/patientsReview by consumers/patients
Replace poor materialsReplace poor materials
– Find better onesFind better ones
– Create better ones, use guides e.g., ToolkitCreate better ones, use guides e.g., Toolkit
for Making Written Material Clear & Effectivefor Making Written Material Clear & Effective
Consider alternatives to printConsider alternatives to print
12. Improving Informed ConsentImproving Informed Consent
Informed consent informed choiceInformed consent informed choice
Clear, unbiased information about allClear, unbiased information about all
optionsoptions
Help aligning options with patient’s goalsHelp aligning options with patient’s goals
& values& values
13. Implementing InformedImplementing Informed
Consent ImprovementsConsent Improvements
PolicyPolicy
– Why, who, what, when, howWhy, who, what, when, how
– DisseminationDissemination
– EnforcementEnforcement
Building systems to improve IC processBuilding systems to improve IC process
– Library of formsLibrary of forms
– Library of decision aidsLibrary of decision aids
– Remove communication barriersRemove communication barriers
– Establish efficient workflowsEstablish efficient workflows
18. Health LiteracyHealth Literacy
Universal PrecautionsUniversal Precautions
Structuring the delivery of care as ifStructuring the delivery of care as if
everyone may have limited healtheveryone may have limited health
literacyliteracy
– You can’t tell by lookingYou can’t tell by looking
– Higher literacy skillsHigher literacy skills ≠≠ understandingunderstanding
– Health literacy is dynamicHealth literacy is dynamic
– Everyone benefits from clearEveryone benefits from clear
communicationcommunication
19. Re-EngineeredRe-Engineered
Discharge Program (RED)Discharge Program (RED)
Evaluated their currentEvaluated their current
discharge process anddischarge process and
re-engineered usingre-engineered using
health literacy principleshealth literacy principles
RCT: 30% reduction inRCT: 30% reduction in
rehospitalizationsrehospitalizations
New RED Toolkit forNew RED Toolkit for
serving diverseserving diverse
populationspopulations
20. 1.1. Obtain language assistance for patients/familiesObtain language assistance for patients/families
2.2. Make appointments for follow-up medical appointments and postMake appointments for follow-up medical appointments and post
discharge tests/labs.discharge tests/labs.
3.3. Plan for the follow-up of results from lab tests or studies that arePlan for the follow-up of results from lab tests or studies that are
pending at discharge.pending at discharge.
4.4. Organize post-discharge outpatient services and medical equipment.Organize post-discharge outpatient services and medical equipment.
5.5. Identify the correct medicines and a plan for the patient to obtain andIdentify the correct medicines and a plan for the patient to obtain and
take them.take them.
6.6. Reconcile discharge plan with national guidelines.Reconcile discharge plan with national guidelines.
7.7. Teach a written Discharge Plan the patient can understand.Teach a written Discharge Plan the patient can understand.
8.8. Educate the patient about his/her diagnosis.Educate the patient about his/her diagnosis.
9.9. Assess the degree of the patient’s understanding of this plan.Assess the degree of the patient’s understanding of this plan.
10.10. Review with the patient what to do if a problem arises.Review with the patient what to do if a problem arises.
11.11. Expedite transmission of the discharge summary to cliniciansExpedite transmission of the discharge summary to clinicians
accepting care of the patient.accepting care of the patient.
12.12. Provide telephone reinforcement of the Discharge Plan.Provide telephone reinforcement of the Discharge Plan.
RED ComponentsRED Components
21. RED ImpactRED Impact
Reduction in readmissions (heart failure,Reduction in readmissions (heart failure,
COPD and facility-wide)COPD and facility-wide)
Increased HCAHPS Care TransitionIncreased HCAHPS Care Transition
scoresscores
Increase in patients reporting teach-Increase in patients reporting teach-
backback
More time spent with patients andMore time spent with patients and
families around transitionsfamilies around transitions
Changed organizational cultureChanged organizational culture
22. Being aBeing a
health literatehealth literate
health carehealth care
organizationorganization
23.
24. Attribute 1Attribute 1
A Health Literate OrganizationA Health Literate Organization
Leadership:Leadership:
Makes health literacy integral to its mission,Makes health literacy integral to its mission,
structure, & operationsstructure, & operations
Makes clear & effective communication aMakes clear & effective communication a
prioritypriority
Assigns responsibility for health literacyAssigns responsibility for health literacy
oversightoversight
Sets goals for health literacy improvementSets goals for health literacy improvement
Allocates fiscal and human resourcesAllocates fiscal and human resources
25. Attribute 2Attribute 2
A Health Literate OrganizationA Health Literate Organization
Integrates health literacy into planning,Integrates health literacy into planning,
evaluation measures, patient safety, andevaluation measures, patient safety, and
quality improvement.quality improvement.
– Incorporates health literacy into allIncorporates health literacy into all
planning activitiesplanning activities
– Conducts ongoing organizationalConducts ongoing organizational
assessmentsassessments
– Measures success & identifies areas forMeasures success & identifies areas for
quality improvementquality improvement
26. Attribute 3Attribute 3
A Health Literate OrganizationA Health Literate Organization
Prepares the workforce to be healthPrepares the workforce to be health
literate and monitors progressliterate and monitors progress
– Hires diverse staff with HL expertiseHires diverse staff with HL expertise
– Sets and meets goals for training all staff andSets and meets goals for training all staff and
members of governing bodiesmembers of governing bodies
– Provides HL training and incorporates HLProvides HL training and incorporates HL
into orientations and other trainingsinto orientations and other trainings
– Arranges for staff to take advantage of on-Arranges for staff to take advantage of on-
line HL training resourcesline HL training resources
27. Attribute 4Attribute 4
A Health Literate OrganizationA Health Literate Organization
Includes populations served in theIncludes populations served in the
design, implementation, and evaluationdesign, implementation, and evaluation
of health information and servicesof health information and services
– Includes members of the population onIncludes members of the population on
governing bodiesgoverning bodies
– Establish advisory groups that involveEstablish advisory groups that involve
individuals with limited health literacy, adultindividuals with limited health literacy, adult
educators, and experts in health literacyeducators, and experts in health literacy
– Collaborate with community members inCollaborate with community members in
design and implementation of interventionsdesign and implementation of interventions
and development and testing of materials.and development and testing of materials.
28. Get Patient FeedbackGet Patient Feedback
Include patients on HL TeamInclude patients on HL Team
Shadow patientsShadow patients
Conduct a walk throughConduct a walk through
Observe patients using your patientObserve patients using your patient
portalportal
Ask patients for feedback on forms orAsk patients for feedback on forms or
other materialsother materials
Have a suggestion boxHave a suggestion box
Survey your patientsSurvey your patients
Source: AHRQ HealthSource: AHRQ Health
Literacy UniversalLiteracy Universal
Precautions Toolkit, Tool 17Precautions Toolkit, Tool 17
29. Attribute 5Attribute 5
A Health Literate OrganizationA Health Literate Organization
Meets needs of populations with a rangeMeets needs of populations with a range
of health literacy skills while avoidingof health literacy skills while avoiding
stigmatizationstigmatization
– Adopts health literacy universalAdopts health literacy universal
precautions, such as offering everyoneprecautions, such as offering everyone
help with literacy taskshelp with literacy tasks
– Allocates resources proportionate to theAllocates resources proportionate to the
concentration of individuals with limitedconcentration of individuals with limited
health literacyhealth literacy
30. AHRQ Health LiteracyAHRQ Health Literacy
Universal Precautions ToolkitUniversal Precautions Toolkit
22ndnd
edition with 21 tools:edition with 21 tools:
– Make Referrals EasyMake Referrals Easy
– Follow up with PatientsFollow up with Patients
– Encourage QuestionsEncourage Questions
– Link Patients to Non-Link Patients to Non-
Medical SupportMedical Support
New companion guide forNew companion guide for
practice facilitatorspractice facilitators
http://ahrq.gov/qual/literacy
31. Vision of a HealthVision of a Health
Literate SocietyLiterate Society
Provides everyone access toProvides everyone access to
accurate, actionable healthaccurate, actionable health
informationinformation
Delivers person-centered healthDelivers person-centered health
information and servicesinformation and services
Supports life-long learning and skillsSupports life-long learning and skills
to promote good healthto promote good health
The vision informing the NationalThe vision informing the National
Action Plan is of a society that:Action Plan is of a society that:
32. AHRQ HealthAHRQ Health
Literacy InformationLiteracy Information
AHRQ Health Literacy Topic PageAHRQ Health Literacy Topic Page
HHS ResourcesHHS Resources
30,000+ subscribers to AHRQ Email30,000+ subscribers to AHRQ Email
UpdatesUpdates
You’ve learned a lot of specific skills about how to improve communication with consumers and patient
http://iom.edu/~/media/Files/Perspectives-Files/2012/Discussion-Papers/BPH_Ten_HLit_Attributes.pdf
Informed consent - more than a form
often treated as nuisance and formality
often thought as malpractice shield
Tell personal story about pap smear
Obtain language assistance
Make appointments for followup care
Followup with results from pending tests
Organize postdischarge outpatient services and medical equipment
Identify the correct medicines and a plan for the patient to obtain them
Reconcile discharge plan with national guidelines
Teach an understandable written discharge plan
Educate the patient about diagnosis and medicines
Review what to do if a problem arises
Assess understanding of discharge plan
Expedite discharge summary
Provide telephone reinforcement of the discharge plan.
Makes clear and effective patient communication a priority across all levels of the organization and across all communication channels.
Applies health literacy universal precautions, whereby communication is simplified to the greatest extent possible and comprehension must be demonstrated by all because no assumptions are made as to who understands or needs extra assistance.
Include an explicit commitment to be health literate in the organization’s mission statement, policies, and programs.
Assign responsibility for health literacy oversight (e.g., a health literacy officer or high-level health literacy task force)
Set goals for health literacy improvement, provide incentives to achieve those goals, and establish accountability for sub-optimal outcomes at every level of the organization.
Allocate fiscal and human resources necessary to effectively and efficiently meet health literacy improvement goals (e.g., funds for editing and testing materials with target audiences, extra time to support individuals who need additional reinforcement or assistance, funds and time for health literacy training).
Cultivate health literacy champions throughout the organization.
Redesign systems to maximize individuals’ capacities to learn how to maintain good health, manage illness or disease, communicate effectively, and make informed decisions.
Contribute to local, state, and national efforts to improve organizational responses to health literacy.
Integrates is a key word here. Addressing health literacy is not a one-off activity. If you’re a health literate organization, health literacy isn’t a special project, it suffices every aspect of the organization.
Develop and routinely collect metrics to measure the success of their system in achieving the health literacy attributes and to identify areas for further improvement
Design and conduct rigorous program evaluations of health literacy interventions and activities.
Assesses the impact of policies and programs on individuals with limited health literacy
Partner with researchers to build an evidence base for health literacy interventions.
Use assessments, measurement, and evaluations to inform continuous quality improvement.
Ensure that patient surveys are designed to be understandable and easy to complete, and offer and provide assistance in completing surveys.
Conduct root cause analysis of patient safety events to uncover and address communication failures.
Support staff in attending specialized health literacy training outside the organization.
Bring in outside experts to augment in-house training resources.
Develop ‘expert educators’ with cross-cutting educational skills who can serve as role models, mentors, and teach health literacy skills to others.
Identify and implement appropriate new curricula.
Collaborate with patients who can be effective speakers and trainers