This document provides an overview of organic weed management strategies for farmers. It discusses using multiple prevention and elimination approaches, including cultural, mechanical, biological, and chemical methods. Cultural strategies involve improving crop competitiveness through practices like crop rotation, cover cropping, mulching, and selecting competitive varieties. Mechanical methods include cultivation, mowing, and flaming. Biological controls utilize insects, diseases, and grazing animals. Organically-approved herbicides can also be used. The document emphasizes implementing many different strategies together for effective long-term weed management.
2. Weeds: Top Issue for Organic
Farmers
Successful Management Requires
Multiple approaches
Continual effort
Knowledge of the biology of weeds species
Reproduction, lifecycle, establishment annual,
perennial, wandering perennial, broadleaf,
grass
Cornell Organic Weed Database,
www.css.cornell.edu/WeedEco/WeedDatabase
/index2.html
3. Basic Weed Ecology
Weeds are nature’s way of
keeping bare ground covered and
increasing biodiversity
Dynamic system involving the
interaction of weeds, crops,
humans and environment
Factors affecting weed ecology are
identical to those affecting crop
ecology:
Light, temperature, water, pH,
nutrients, organic matter,
insects and diseases, etc
Weed
Humans
Natural
environment
Crop
4. Impact of High Weed Pressure
Compete with crops
for nutrients, water,
and light
Reduced yields
Lower crop quality
Harbor pest insects
and diseases
Increase irrigation
costs
But, complete
elimination of weeds is
unnecessary
Weed numbers or size
5. Multiple Prevention and
Elimination Strategies
Cultural
Mechanical
Biological
Chemical (organically
approved)
“Many hammers approach.”
Liebman and Gallandt, 1997
6. “Organic weed management practices” Crop
Rotations on Organic Farms, Mohler & Johnson, 2009
Practice Effect
Tillage Kills growing weeds; damages perennial roots &
rhizomes; buries seeds too deeply to emerge;
brings weed seeds to surface.
Post-planting cultivation Removes weeds from the crop.
Stale seedbed Flushes weeds from the soil before planting.
Organic fertility sources Favor crops over faster-growing weeds due to
slow release of nutrients.
Drip irrigation Directs water to the crops rather than to weeds.
Mulch Smothers weeds: delays emergence of weeds
Using transplants Competitive advantage to crop
Competitive cultivars Improves competitive ability of crop against
weeds.
Increase plant density Suppress weeds by shading
Rapid cleanup after
harvest
Prevents seed set by residual weeds.
Cover crops Suppress weeds, improves soil health
7. Cultural Strategies
Buy quality crop seed with low/no weed
seeds present
Do not allow weeds to form seed
Thoroughly compost (>130°F for ≥15 days)
all manure and plant residues to ensure
destruction of weed seed
Stale seedbed technique
Prepare soil for planting and bring weed seeds to
the surface; allow weeds to germinate, kill weeds
with light tillage/minimal soil disruption. May be
repeated. Plant main crop.
8. Cultural Practices
Improve crop competitiveness
Improve soil tilth, aeration, and fertility to
optimize crop growth
Increase crop density through narrow
row spacing and increased seeding rate
Use transplants, rather than seed, when possible
Plant at optimal soil temperatures to prevent slow
germination of crop
Choose competitive crop cultivars
Manage fertility according to crop needs; avoid
excess application
9. Cultural Practices
Reduce weed numbers
Mulch (wood chips, mow and blow, paper, living,
plastic, etc)
Use weed-suppressive cover crops
Quick germinating, high biomass
Field with high weed pressure may warrant full year of
cover cropping and fallow to reduce weeds
Crop rotations
altering narrowly spaced crops with closely spaced
crops, shallow rooted/deep rooted crops, cold/warm
season crops
Intercrop
Clover underseeded in sweetcorn
10. Mulch
• Prevent seeds from germinating by
blocking light, can smother out some
weeds
• Conserve water, minimal soil disruption
• Use local resources: straw, fabric, wood,
newspaper, plastic
• Be careful of weed seeds in straw or hay
• Avoid hay, unless you know its free of
weeds
• Especially good for perennial systems:
blueberries, blackberries, flowers, trees
• Living mulches – ie constant cover of clover
on orchard floor
12. Cover Crops
• Smother weeds by out-
competing for light, water,
nutrients
• Release allelopathic
chemicals that suppress weed
germination
• May reduce weed emergence
by 75-90%
• e.g. sudan grass, buckwheat,
annual rye grass, sesbania,
many more
Field pea-oat-
mustard cover crop
Red Clover
Managing Cover Crops Profitably, 3rd ed. SARE
www.sare.org/publications/covercrops/covercrops.pdf
crops profitably. 3rd ed. SARE
13. Crop Rotations
• Weeds tend to infest crops with
similar life cycles
• Change crop ecology:
shallow/deep roots, cold/warm
season, row/drilled crops, foliage
density, and heavy/light feeders
Change cultural practices:
cultivation, mowing, fertilization,
herbicide application, and
planting/harvest dates
14. 10 Year Rotation Scheme
Alex and Betsy Hitt, Chapel Hill NC;
http://www.ssawg.org/hitt.html
Y
R
Spring Summer Fall
1 Tomatos & leeks Oat-crimson cl
2 Flowers-cool seas. Sudangrass-soyb. Oat-crimson cl.
3 Spring lettuce Flowers, summer Rye-hairy vetch
4 Squash Fall planted flowers
5 Flowers-overwintered Sudangrass-soyb. Rye-hairy vetch
6 Peppers Wheat-crimson cl
7 Flowers -summer Oat-crimson clover
8 Mixed spring veg cowpeas Fall planted flowers
9 Flowers-overwintered Sudangrass-soyb. Oat-crimson clover
10 Flowers-summer Wheat-hairy vetch
15. Physical and Mechanical Practices
Mowing
Prevents seeding
Depletes storage reserves
Better control for broadleaves
Soil solarization
Effective control of winter
annuals
Limited control of perennials
Cost prohibitive on large
acreages
Avoid tillage deeper than 3”
after solarization
Hand weeding
Cultivation
Flaming
16. Cultivation
Should be shallow to
lessen disturbance to
weed seed bank
Better for perennial and
biennial control than
annual weed control
Exhaust root system by
depleting storage
reserves
Requires 6-8 timely
treatments in yr 1, then
3-5 the following year
Thoroughly clean equipment
before moving it between fields
to prevent weed transport
Wheel hoe
Various hoes
17. Potential Downsides of Cultivation
Exposes bare ground:
increased erosion,
decreased biodiversity,
speeds decomposition of OM,
increases water run-off
Major cause of soil compaction
Cost: expensive equipment, fuel
Should not be done in wet conditions
18. Use Cultivation Wisely
USDA-ARS research showed organic methods
can increase OM more than conventional no-till
Teasdale et al., 2007. Potential Long-Term
Benefits of No-Tillage and Organic Cropping
Systems for Grain Production and Soil
Improvement. Agron J. 99:1297-1305
Negative effects of tillage may be offset by the
use of cover crops and additions of organic
matter (compost, manures, mulch, etc)
Must still use caution to avoid negative effects
of cultivation
19. Type of Horticultural Cultivators
Spyders™
Torsion weeders
Spring hoe weeders
Finger weeder
Basket weeder
Multiple-component
weeder frame
Brush weeder
Rotary tilling cultivators
Rear- or front-tine tillers
Hand implements: push-
pull hoes, hand scrapers,
etc
Sustainable Vegetable Production from Start-Up to
Market, Grubinger, 1999
21. Flaming
Intense heat sears the leaf,
causing the cell sap to expand
and disrupt cell walls
seedlings are most susceptible
Broadleaf weeds are more
susceptible than grasses
May be used in wet soil
conditions
VIDEO:
www.extension.org/pages/Video
_Clip:_Backpack_Flame_Weed
er_from_Vegetable_Farmers_an
d_their_Weed_Control_Machine
s
Sustainable Vegetable Production from Start-Up to Market, Grubinger, 1999
22. Uses for Flaming
Stale seedbed technique:
Planting delayed after seed bed preparation (tillage, irrigation, etc)
Flaming knockdowns flush of weed seedlings prior to planting
Peak emergence technique:
Crop seeded promptly after seedbed preparation
Just before crop germinates, flaming used to kill weed seedlings
Good method for direct-seeded, slow-germinating crops
Glass or plastic can be used as a crop-germination indicator: crop
grown under cover germinates 2-3 days before uncovered crop;
flaming should occur when crop germinates under cover
Post-emergent flaming:
Emerged crops protected by: directing flame away from crops,
shielding the crop, or flaming at a time when crop stems are
resistant to heat
Older plants able to recover from heat damage, while young
seedlings are killed
23. Flaming Tips
Bigger weeds and wet weeds are harder to kill
Target weeds while seedlings up to 3 to 4 leaves
Avoid flaming with morning dew
Light drying winds and hot days increase effectiveness
Avoid flame deflection by soil clods or excessive
dust = protect weeds
Match equipment for your needs
Save on fuel, time
Make time for adjustments
Burner placement, fuel pressure, tractor speed
How much is enough?
When you squeeze plant leaf between finger and
thumb, want to see your thumb imprint = cells have
burst and weed will die/setback
24. Biological Control Practices
Insects: may consume large
numbers of weed seeds or
feeding injury to plant or
vector virus
Thistle & adult thistle-head
weevil, Rhinocyllus conicus
Multiflora rose & rose rosette
disease transmitted by fungi
or a (mite)
Selective grazing
Sheep: clean fields after
harvest
Weeder geese: useful against
grass weeds and in perennial
systems
Biofumigation
Use of Brassica species
(canola, Indian mustard)
as cover crop or in rotation
May be incorporated or left
as residue
Brassicas produce
glucosinolates, which may
by converted to cyanate
compounds during
decomposition
Cyantes toxic to many
bacteria, fungi,
nematodes, insects, and
germinating seeds
25. Chemical Control
Organic options
Corn gluten meal (pre-emergent herbicide)
Suppresses many common grasses and herbaceous
weeds
WeedBan™ and Corn Weed Blocker™
Look for non-gmo sources
Commonly based on vinegar or lemon juice or clove oil
ingredients (post-emergent burndown herbicide)
Perennials may require multiple applications
Corrodes metal sprayer parts
Burnout™, Bioganic™, AllDown ™, MATRAN™, and
Weed Bye Bye™
• Post-emergent chemicals are phytotoxic (burn plant tissue);
use caution when applying in crops
Cost can be decreased by knowing pattern of weed distribution (spot
treatment v. overall application
Organic herbicide in an
orchard
26. 12 Steps to Sustainable Weed
Management – Mark Schonbeck
Pre-season Planning
Step 1. Know the weeds on your farm.
Step 2. Plan cropping systems to minimize
open niches for weeds.
Step 3. Keep the weeds guessing.
Step 4. Design the cropping system and
select tools for effective weed control.
27. Preventive (Cultural) Practices
Step 5. Grow vigorous,
competitive crops.
Step 6. Put the weeds out of
work – grow cover crops.
Step 7. Manage the weed
seedbank: minimize deposits
and maximize withdrawls.
28. Control Tactics
Step 9. Utilize biological processes to
enhance weed control.
Step 10. Bring existing weeds under control
before planting weed-sensitive crops and
long-term perennial crops.
Step 8. Knock the weeds
out at critical times.
No-till organic farm; Weed-free
bed of weed-sensitive onion
crop.
29. Enhancing and Fine-tuning the
Weed Management Strategy
Step 11. Keep observing the weeds and adapt
practices accordingly.
Keep notes
What is suitable for one crop may not be for
another
Step 12. Experiment and stay educated. Keep up
on new developments and practices.
Night time cultivation
Soil solarization
Others…
Weed free bed of carrots
30. Conclusion
Using multiple approaches (“many hammers”) to manage
weeds will yield greater impact than relying on a few
practices.
Develop a weed management strategy that is designed
for the needs of your farm.
Big Hammers
-Competitive crops
-Rotation
-Cover Crops
-Mulches
-Weed predators
-Livestock/grazers
-Cultivation tools
-Rollers/roller-crimper
-Flamers
-Growers Observation
Little Hammers
-Solarization
-Organic herbicides
-Bioherbicides
-Soil
microorganisms
-Crop-weed
interactions
31. Resources
The Sustainable Weed Control Rag, Mark Schonbeck, e-
Organic, www.extension.org/article/18529,
www.extension.org/article/18539
www.extension.org/article/18538
Sustainable Vegetable Production from Start-up to Market,
Grubinger, 1999. NRAES-104
Crop rotation on Organic Farms: A Planning Manual, Mohler
and Johnson, 2009. NRAES-177
Managing Cover Crops Profitably, 3rd ed. SARE
www.sare.org/publications/covercrops/covercrops.pdf
Michigan Field Crop Pest Ecology Management. Cavigelli et al.
2000, MSU Extension Bulletin E-2704
Cornell Organic Weed Management Website,
www.css.cornell.edu/WeedEco/WeedDatabase/index2.htm l
32. Acknowledgements
This presentation address general organic production practices. It is to be
to use in planning and conducting organic horticulture trainings. The
presentation is part of project funded by a Southern SARE PDP titled
“Building Organic Agriculture Extension Training Capacity in the
Southeast”
Project Collaborators
• Elena Garcia, University of Arkansas CES
Heather Friedrich, University of Arkansas
Obadiah Njue, University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff
Jeanine Davis, North Carolina State University
Geoff Zehnder, Clemson University
Charles Mitchell, Auburn University
Rufina Ward, Alabama A&M University
Ken Ward, Alabama A&M University
Karen Wynne, Alabama Sustainable Agriculture Network
Hinweis der Redaktion
Weed management is a top issue for most organic growers. It requires continual effort using multiple approaches we’ll cover in this presentation. Biological knowledge of the weed species working with can be essential for success. Knowing what type of weed it is, how it reproduces and it most vulnerable period are critical information to managing the species. The Cornell University organic weed database is a useful resource that provides this type of information as well as management practices for specific weeds.
Weeds compete with crops for water, nutrients and sunlight. In high enough pressure weeds can reduce yields, reduce crop quality, increase irrigation needs and harbor insects (both beneficial and pestiferous) and diseases. Complete elimination of weeds is unnecessary, as they can protect the soil surface from heavy rain, add organic matter, help to recycle nutrients, provide habitat for beneficial insects and other impacts.
Employing various strategies or “many hammers” are most effective for maintaining adequate weed control. These include cultural, mechanical, biological and chemical practices.
Liebman and Gallandt. 2006. Many little hammers: ecological approaches for management of crop-weed interactios. In L.E. Jackson, 3d., Ecology in Agriculture, pp 291-343. Academic Press, San Diego CA
Table 3.6 from Crop Rotations on Organic Farms: A planning manual. NRAES-177
This table summarizes the effect of various cultural and mechanical practices for weed management
Note picture – these lettuce transplants have been in the ground for a few weeks; they are planted relatively close together, they are beginning to shade the ground, you can see the drip tape – watering the plants, not the weeds,
Weed article
A good resource for cover crops:
Managing Cover Crops Profitably, 3rd ed. SARE www.sare.org/publications/covercrops/covercrops.pdf
crops profitably. 3rd ed. SARE
Note the frequency of cover crops in their rotation
Keys to good solarization: work up soil to an even level surface removing big clods and rocks; lay thin plastic sheeting <3mm as close to the ground as possible, burying edges of plastic; use irrigation – wet soil conducts heat better than dry soil, field should remain at 70% field capacity; leave in place for 4-8 weeks; avoid anything more than shallow tilling to avoid bringing up weed seeds from lower depths that were not killed by the heat.
http://agron.scijournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/99/5/1297
Organic agriculture is often criticized for heavy use of cultivation for weed control. Long-term research has shown that by using cover crops and fertilizing with materials high in organic matter such as manure, organic methods can provide greater long term soil benefits compared to no-till production.
Sustainable Vegetable Production from Start-Up to Market, Grubinger 1999, NRAES 104
Sustainable Vegetable Production from Start-Up to Market, Grubinger 1999, NRAES 104
Hot days and drying winds further dry out weeds, for maximum impact
Avoid “burning” weeds; If weeds are black you are using too much fuel
Biocontrol is specific to the species and works well for infestations of a particular weed and typically in situations where immediate results are not necessary. Biocontrol mechanisms usually take time for maximum effectiveness.
Phyllocoptes fructiphilus has been shown to transmit rose rosette disease on young fast growing roses
Organic herbicides are expensive and will not work as effectively as conventional herbicides. May be useful in smaller, localized areas for spot treatment. The organic herbicides work by burning the plant tissue (due to very low pH), therefore good coverage is needed. Works better on smaller weeds.
The Sustainable Weed Control Rag. Mark Schonbeck. An excellent resource that provides a whole farm, systems approach. The document can be found on the Resources page of the website.
These steps provide a framework, not a step by step process. The steps combine direct and indirect management practices, and in conjunction with another have an additive effect on weed control, providing greater impact.
Step 1 – know the major, problematic weeds on your farm – make sure they are identified correctly. Research the lifecycle, growth, reproduction, etc and when it is most susceptible to control tactics.
Step 2 – Plan your crop rotation to minimize niches for weeds to emerge such as the transition time when a main crop is finished and a cover crop is planted and emerges. Consider overseeding into main crop before it’s completely finished with harvest; when main crop is done, a cover crop is established. A no-till planting of veggies into a killed cover crop, inter cropping, living mulches or organic mulches also reduces the niche for most weeds to emerge.
Step 3 – Keep the weeds guessing through a varied crop rotation with crops and cover crops of varied harvest dates, that required varied planting densities, methods of tillage, irrigation, fertilizers. All of these things will impact the type and population of weeds. See Mark’s handout for further details.
Step 4 – match cultivation tool for the crop and row spacing to get the best in-row and between row control; also consider the weed.
Step 5 – grow vigorous crops and varieties that outcompete weeds as much as possible. Crops that close their canopy (with appropriate planting density) shade the ground below, preventing sunlight from reaching the ground and preventing weeds from germinating. Other tips: use high quality seed, use transplants when appropriate, if direct seeding plant at soil temps suitable for rapid germination (different for each crop), choose crop cultivars that are locally adapted, feed and water the crop, not the weeds.
Step 6. Weeds have a natural purpose to cover and protect bare soil. By planting cover crops, you select which plants you want to grow and benefit the soil, doing the natural job of weeds. See SARE Managing Cover Crops Profitably 3rd ed. Available online at www.sare.org/publications/covercrops/covercrops.pdf
Step 7. Many weed seeds remain viable in the soil for many, many years. Many seeds are lost each year due to predation by insects, microbes and mice, however the seedbank can be replenished with inputs such as manure or compost fertilizers, mulches such as hay or straw, wildlife/birds, the movement of soil on equipment or even shoes. Effort should be made to minimize the numbers of weeds that go to seed (a primary source of seedbank renewal). Also, use clean inputs - compost manure to 140F for at least 3 days to kill seeds, know the source and quality of mulches used, clean equipment before moving it to another field. Remove seeds with the stale seedbed technique and encourage weed seed predation of beetles, cricket, mice – ie use cover crops and let critters glean before you work up or mow the harvested fields.
Step 8. Each crop has a ‘critical weed free period’ where it must be kept free of weed competition to prevent yield loss/economic loss from occurring. For a crop like snap beans this is from emergence to full bloom, but for a crop like onions, its all season long. This table shows other crops, http://www.ncsu.edu/sustainable/IPM/weeds/table7_1.html. The most critical times for weed control throughout the season generally are: 1) at planting, 2) as flushes of weed seedlings are emerging 3) during the crops minimum weed free period, 4) when perennial weed reserves reach a low, 5) before the weeds for seeds or propagate.
Step 9. biological control of weeds will likely never be as predominant as biological control in the insect world, even though advances have been made in “bioherbicides”. The examples of the multiflora rose and thistle in previous slides are two examples of biocontrol of invasive species. Even though biological products or agents play a minor role in weed management, biological processes play a significant role. These processes include herbivory, vectoring diseases, plant-soil-microorganism relationships that give competitive advantage to the crop and not the weed, allelopathy, and weed seed decomposition and decay. These elements are a natural part of a healthy, diversified organic ecosystem.
Step 10. Preventative measures to get weeds under control before you plant a perennial crop such as berries, tree fruits or asparagus and weed sensitive vegetables like onions or garlic, will go a long way in producing a successful crop. This may take several years of cover cropping, tilling, solarization, or mulching before the main crop is planted.
Step 11. Keep notes and records. What practices seem to work well; what rotations are suppressing weeds? What weeds are problematic? Change your practices – try different equipment, shallow cultivation vs inverting the soil, different cover crops, crop rotations, etc.
Step 12. Stay educated by reading, attending workshops, conferences, field days, and talking with other growers. Come up with your own experiments (on a small scale) and compare it with your regular practices. Some examples of experimental practices: night time cultivation – eliminates the light stimulus for weed seeds that are brought to the surface. Reduces weed germination by 20-70%. Soil Solarization – covering the soil with clear plastic for several weeks/months during the hottest part of the summer to “cook” the weed seeds and rhizomes. Can be very effective on a small scale.
There are many other good resources available – these are just a few.