Day 2- Opening Scene-setting by Rachmat Mardiana, Bappenas
National Development Planning Policy on Electricity
Directorate of Electricity, Telecommunication and Informatics
Deputy Minister on Infrastructure
Ministry of National Development Planning
8 Maret 2023
2
ECONOMIC TRAJECTORY - VISION 2045
(Indonesia Towards Developed Country)
2
POST-PANDEMIC GDP PER CAPITA SCENARIO
Inclusive and Sustainable ECONOMIC TRANSFORMATION
as a “GAME CHANGER” for Indonesia’s becoming a developed country
GDP Growth
2022 – 2045
(average)
6,0%
Role of eastern
Indonesia in the
National Economy
25,0%
ECONOMIC TRANFORMATION
Strategi #1
Competitive Human
Resources:
• Health system
• Education (education
system and character
development)
• Research and Innovation
Strategi #2
Economic Sector
Productivity:
• Industrialization
• SME productivity
• Agriculture
modernization
Strategi #3
Green Economy:
• Low carbon
economy and
circular economy
• Blue Economy
• Energy transition
Strategi #5
Domestic Economic
Integration:
(economic powerhouse)
• Connectivity
infrastructure: Superhub,
Sea hub, Air Hub
• Domestic Value Chain
Strategi #4
Digital
Transformation:
• Digital Infrastructure
• Digital utilization
• Enabling factors
Strategi #6
New Capital City
Nusantara:
• New source of
development
• Regional economic
balance
Source: Deputy for Economics, Bappenas
3
Under exercising on up-dating
the national decarbonization
roadmap toward
Net Zero
Emission
by 2060
(more concrete, detailed,
integrated)
ENERGY SECTOR COMMITMENTS TOWARDS NET ZERO EMISSION 2050
National Commitments 2016-2030
• The Mandate of Law No.16/2016 on
Ratification of the Paris Agreement:
reducing GHG emissions by 29% (self-
effort) or 41% (with international
assistance) by 2030 according to NDC;
• The energy sector reduces GHG by
314-398 million tons of CO2 in 2030,
through the development of
renewable energy, implementation of
energy efficiency, energy
conservation, as well as the
application of clean energy
technology.
National Commitments 2021-2050
• Implement concrete actions on climate
change through a moratorium on forest and
peat land conversion to reduce forest fire
by 82%;
• Encouraging green development through
the development of a Green Industrial Park
covering an area of 12.500 hectares in
North Kalimantan;
• Unlock investment in the energy transition
through the development of biofuels,
lithium battery industry, and electric
vehicles.
Leaders Summit on Climate, 22 April 2021
UNFCCC – COP21, December 2015
4
DISCOURSE PROCESS OF PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT OF
THE NET-ZERO EMISSION 2060 SCENARIO
At the beginning of the discourse on developing the NZE model, the Ministry of National Development Planning/Bappenas
prepared several scenarios year options in which net-zero emissions must be achieved, namely 2045, 2050, 2060, and 2070.
• The projections results from various
scenarios for the target year for achieving
the NZE have been submitted by the
Minister of National Development
Planning/Head of Bappenas at the
Indonesia Net-Zero Summit 2021.
• Each of the NZE year options certainly has
different consequences, both in terms of
socio-economic and environmental
aspects, as well as cost and investment
requirements.
• After going through several discussion
processes and seeing the dynamics of the
latest developments, the process of
developing the system dynamics net-zero
emission model is focused on achieving
NZE in 2060.
NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLANNING SYSTEM
Planning is a process for determining
appropriate future actions, according to a
sequence of options, taking into account
available resources.
PLANNING APPROACH
1.
2.
3.
PLAN PREPARATION
PLAN ESTABLISHMENT
IMPLEMENTATION CONTROL PLAN
PERFOMANCE EVALUATION
• Draft National/Regional Development
Plan
• Draft K/L/SKPD Work Plan
• Development Planning Conference
• Final Draft Development Plan
• National RPJP (Law) and Regional RPJP
(Perda) for a period of 20 (twenty)
years [2005-2025]
• RPJMN by
Presidential/Regulation/Regional Head
for 5 (five) years [2020-2024]
• RKP/RKPD with
Presidential/RegionalHead Regulation
for annual period [2023
4.
PLANNING STAGES
1. Holistic, Integrative, Thematic,
Spatial (HITS)
2. Money follows program - through
(a) funding framework; (b)
regulatory framework; and (c)
public service and investment
framework
CONTAINED IN THE KRISNA SYSTEM (APBN)
AND PLANNING DOCUMENTS
During the last five years of the 2005-2024
National Long-Term Development Plan, the
Ministry of National Development
Planning/Bappenas began preparing the 2025-
2045 National Long-Term Development Plan and
the 2025-2030 National Medium-Term
Development Plan.
RPJPN
2005-2025
RPJMN
2020-2024
1945 Constitution
RPJPN
2025-2045
RPJMN
2025-2030
National Long-Term
Development Plan
FRAMEWORK OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
THE CONSTITUTION - RPJP - RPJM
6
Flow of RPJPN 2025 - 2045
VISI ABADI:
Independent, Unity, sovereign,
justice and properity
MISI ABADI BERNEGARA:
1. Protect the entire Indonesian
nation
2. Advancing the general
Welfare,
3. Enrich the life of the nation
4. Participate in carrying out
world order based on
freedom, eternal peace, and
social justice
UUD 1945
Vision and Mission INDONESIA
VISION INDONESIA EMAS 2025 - 2045
Target of vison Indonesia 2025 - 2045
Mission: Development Agenda
OBJECTIVE
INDICATOR
Visi antara
Misi
Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
Sumber: Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
7
DEVELOPMENT STAGES IN THE NATIONAL LONG TERM DEVELOPMENT PLAN (RPJPN) 2005-2025
RPJM I
(2005-2009)
Menata kembali NKRI,
menbangun Indonesia
yang aman dan damai,
yang adil dan demokratis,
dengan tingkat
kesejahteraan yang lebih
baik
RPJM II
(2009-2014)
Memantapkan
penataan kembali
NKRI, meningkatkan
kualitas SDM,
membangun
kemampuan IPTEK,
memperkuat daya
saing perekonomian
RPJM III
(2015-2019)
Memantapkan pembangunan
secara menyeluruh dengan
menekankan pembangunan
keunggulan kompetitif
perekonomian yang berbasis
pada SDA yang tersedia, SDM
yang berkualitas serta
kemampuan IPTEK
RPJM IV
(2020-2024)
Mewujudkan manusia
Indonesia yang mandiri,
maju, adil dan makmur
melalui percepatan
pembangunan di segala
bidang dengan struktur
perekonomian yang kokoh
berlandaskan keunggulan
kompetitif
VISI PEMBANGUNAN NASIONAL
2005–2025
INDONESIA THAT IS
INDEPENDENT,
ADVANCED, FAIR
AND PROSPEROUS
Some of them are:
• Per capita income in 2025
achieves prosperity equivalent to
middle-income countries.
• Achievement of rural
electrification and household
electrification.
Sumber: Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
8
NEXT LONG TERM DEVELOPMENT MILESTONE
Sumber: Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
9
FINAL ENERGY CONSUMPTION (2021)
ISU-ISU PEMBANGUNAN
1 EQUITY & AFFORDABILITY
2 SECURITY & RESILIENCE
3 ENV. SUSTAINABILITY
▪ Diversity of supply
▪ Import dependence
▪ Recovery capacity
▪ Energy prices
▪ Affordability (expenditure)
▪ Access to “modern” energy
▪ Productivity (efficiency & intensity)
▪ Decarbonization (renewable)
▪ Emission
848,9
juta BOE
* Sumber: Bappenas, HEESI (diolah)
Jenis Permintaan
Kelompok Permintaan
(Tidak termasuk biomasa)
76,3
BOE/Triliun Rp
INTENSITAS
ENERGI FINAL
3,11
BOE
KONSUMSI ENERGI
FINAL/CAPITA
10
PRIMARY ENERGY SUPPLY (2021)
1 Primary Supply Independence
▪ Domestic production is sufficient
but most of it is exported.
▪ Domestic supply is partly from
imports (23.3%).
▪ The largest imports are fuel
(finished products) and petroleum.
2 Trade Balance
▪ The oil and gas trade deficit
(starting 2012) was influenced by
the oil deficit and "helped" by the
net export of natural gas.
▪ The oil trade deficit was influenced
by the deficit in petrol since 1996
followed by the deficit in crude oil
starting in 2013.
* Sumber: Bappennas, HEESI (diolah)
IMPOR
346.6
kBOE
(Unit dalam ribu BOE, tidak termasuk biomasa)
PES: Primary Energy Supply
REPES: Renewable Energy PES
Exp: Export
Imp: Import
LARGEST CONSUMPTION (TRANSPORT)
IS MET PARTLY WITH IMPORTED
SUPPLIES (FUEL & CRUDE OIL)
11
ELECTRICITY SUPPLY AND DEMAND
(Supply)
▪ Generation capacity plans
▪ Renewable energy generation capacity
mix
▪ Investment needs
▪ Energy intensity
▪ Role/portion of electricity in total
energy demand
▪ Projected demand
▪ Electricity demand per capita
Objective Function
▪ Golden Indonesia 2045
▪ Regional development NZE of
electricity sector in 2060 No negative
emissions
▪ Energy source availability
▪ Least cost
(Demand)
Investment Framework (Technology Options)
Electric transport
technology:
❑ Battery Electric Vehicle
(BEV);
❑ Hybrid Electric Vehicle
(HEV); dan
❑ Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle
(FCEV).
Storage
technology:
❑ Baterai;
❑ Hidrogen.
Generation technology:
❑ Nuklir;
❑ Hidrogen dan amonia;
❑ PLTS;
❑ Co-firing;
❑ Coal phase out;
❑ Distributed Energy
Resources (DER).
Distributor technology
❑ Super-grid
❑ Smart grid
FINANCING AND FUNDING OF ELECTRICITY INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT
12
Infrastructure
Projects
Central
Government
Local Government
BUMN
Swasta
Central
Government
Local Government
(User Fee)
Tax
Community
Money flow to repay upfront
investment
Bank
Capital
Markets
Investor
MDBs
Funding Source:
*) Possible
combination of tax
and user fees
Financing:
Upfront Investment
Funding:
Origination of Money to Repay Financing
Source of
Financing:
Institusi yang membayar
investasi dimuka:
SLA; PMN; K/L
Internal; Direct
Lending; Bond, etc
IPP
Subsidy; Compensation;
Guarantee
Bill
Project Aspects:
Readiness
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND
CREDIBILITYCOHERENCE OF DEVELOPMENT
TARGETS LICENSING AND PROCUREMENT
PROCESSRATING TECHNICAL AND R&D
SUPPORT
ASSET SECURITIZATION
GREEN BOND
SEED CAPITAL
CONVERTIBLE GRANTS
PRICE POLICYTARIFF POLICY (SUBSIDIES)EXPENDITURE
REALLOCATION (SUBSIDY, REFOCUSING, INTERIM)FISCAL
CAPACITY (TAX AND NON-TAX)
GAP
* Ilustrasi
GAP
Policy
Direction
13
URGENSI TRANSFORMASI EKONOMI:
Hanya tersisa waktu selama 22 tahun, untuk menaikkan GNI per Capita 4x Lipat
Agar diatas threshold High Income Economy
Sumber: Deputi Bidang Ekonomi, Bappenas
*Proyeksi Threshold High Income dihitung dari trend inflasi SDR
2040
Proyeksi GNI per Capita2022
4.460
0
5.000
10.000
15.000
20.000
25.000
30.000
35.000
Proyeksi GNI per Capita Indonesia
(USD) 22 TAHUN
Proyeksi
Threshold High
Income*
7 %
6 %
5 %
Threshold Upper-Middle Income
ThresholdLow Income
Sejak tahun 1993:
Indonesia keluar dari Low
Income Country
1998-2002:
Indonesia kembali ke Low
Income Country akibat
krisis
2019:
Indonesia masuk ke dalam
Upper-Middle Income
Country
2020-2021:
Indonesia kembali ke Lower-
Middle Income Country akibat
pandemi
Peran Ekonomi Bagian Timur
Indonesia 25,0%
Rata-Rata Pertumbuhan PDB
2022 – 2045 6,0%
14
TATA KELOLA INDUSTRI KETENAGALISTRIKAN
STRUCTURE CONDUCT PERFORMANCE
GOVERNMENT POLICY
Membutuhkan
TRANSFORMASI STRUKTURAL
Efisiensi
Operasi
Keandalan
Kinerja
Financial
Perencanaan
& Pengadaan
single
buyer
Dominasi
vertical dan
geografis
Barrier to
entry
Kebijakan
harga dan
tarif
Konsistensi
regulasi
BUMN
sebagai last
resort dan
first priority
Akses
Pengawas
an
PENGUATAN KELEMBAGAAN
TRANSFORMASI STRUKTUR INDUSTRI
Bauran
16
Prakiraan Awal Permintaan Listrik Menurut Wilayah (Skenario NZE) (TWh)
-
200
400
600
800
1.000
1.200
1.400
201920202021202220232024202520262027202820292030203120322033203420352036203720382039204020412042204320442045
TWh
Sumatera Jamali Kalimantan Sulawesi Maluku Nusa Tenggara Papua
Region 2021 2030 2035 2040 2045
Sumatera 47 82 119 172 231
Jamali 187 293 402 545 695
Kalimantan 15 27 39 57 76
Sulawesi 16 30 45 67 95
Maluku 2 3 4 6 9
Nusa Tenggara 5 9 12 17 21
Papua 4 7 9 13 18
Total 276 450 631 876 1.145
18
Isu Strategis Transisi Energi: Ketenagalistrikan
TRANSISI KETENAGALISTRIKAN
Elektrifikasi (Transportasi,
Rumah Tangga dan Industri)
Dekarbonisasi Kerjasama (Internasional,
Swasta dan Pemerintah)
Percepatan Pemanfaatan
Energi Terbarukan
Keuangan Berkelanjutan
(Sustainable Finance)
penguatan Tata Kelola
19
Net-Zero Emission Scenario: Energy Sector Assumptions
No. Policy BAU Scenario 2060 NZE Scenario
1
Renewable Energy Power
Plant
The proportion of renewable energy
remains relatively constant until 2060
There is a significant increase in the proportion of renewable
energy in electricity generation to close to 100 percent by
2060, with the remainder being met by nuclear power.
2 Energy Efficiency
Final energy efficiency rate constant at
1 percent per year
Energy efficiency levels rise progressively from 1 percent
today to 6 percent by 2030 etc.
3 Electric Vehicle
No additional electric vehicles for
public and private transportation
Increase in the number of electric vehicles for public and
private transportation to 95 percent by 2055
4 Energy subsidies No removal of energy subsidies
Complete elimination of energy subsidies for fuel, gas and
electricity by 2030
5 Coal phase-out No coal phase-out
Decrease coal use to eventually zero by 2060 across all
sectors
6 Hydrogen fuel No utilization of hydrogen fuel
Utilization of hydrogen for fuel in the transportation sector (4
percent of total transportation fuel) and industry (100
percent replacing natural gas)
20
TERIMA KASIH
Direktorat Ketenagalistrikan, Telekomunikasi dan Informatika
Deputi Bidang Sarana dan Prasarana
Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
Jl. Taman Suropati No. 2 - Jakarta Pusat
www.bappenas.go.id
dit.eti@bappenas.go.id dit.kti direktoratenergidanTIK
22
Visi jangka Panjang 2045
Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
1. Negara Maritim yang Maju dan
Berkelanjutan;
2. Negara Maritim yang Berdaulat,
Maju, dan Berkelanjutan
23
ENERGI PRIMER TRANSFORMASI KONSUMSI
UU 16/2016
PENGESAHAN PARIS
AGREEMENT TTG CLIMATE
CHANGE
PERPRES 22/2017: RENCANA UMUM ENERGI NASIONAL ( SASARAN TAHUN 2025)
29% PENURUNAN EMISI
GRK DARI BUSINESS AS USUAL
TAHUN 2030
ENERGI
11%
PENGELOLAAN
LIMBAH
INDUSTRI
PERTANIAN KEHUTANAN
0,4%
0,3%
0,1%
17,2%
KEBUTUHAN LISTRIK
712 TWH1)
2.500 KWH/KAPITA
KEBUTUHAN NON LISTRIK
(BIOFUEL, BIOMASSA, BIOGAS, dll)
NON-PEMBANGKIT EBT
~ 23 MTOE (KILANG, DEPO, PIPA, DLL)
PEMBANGKIT EBT
~ 69,2 MTOE
PEMBANGKIT FOSIL
NON-PEMBANGKIT FOSIL
KAPASITAS PEMBANGKIT KONSUMSI
RPJMN 2020 - 2024
KEBUTUHAN LISTRIK
400 TWH4)
1.400 KWH/KAPITA
23%
77%
FOSIL
~ 307,7 MTOE
10 GW
(ANTARA LAIN MELALUI
PENINGKATAN PORSI EBT,
SHIFTING, EFISIENSI ENERGI)
20%
59 GW
18 GW
SHARE EBT:
FOSIL (EKSISTING)
SASARAN PEMBANGUNAN
PERTUMBUHAN
EKONOMI
5,7-6,0%
PENURUNAN EMISI
GAS RUMAH KACA
MENUJU TARGET 29% DI 2030
(PARIS AGREEMENT)
27,3%
KEMISKINAN
PENGANGGURAN
TERBUKA
FOSIL (BARU)
EBT (BARU)
EBT (EKSISTING)
TERMASUK TRANSMISI, DISTRIBUSI DAN
EKOSISTEM YANG MENDUKUNG
4)MEMPERTIMBANGKAN SASARAN
PERTUMBUHAN EKONOMI 2020 -
2024: 6,0%
45,2
GW
90,3
GW
EBT
~ 92,3 MTOE
2)PORSI EBT MENINGKAT >5% DARI KONDISI 2019
(14%) DAN AKAN TERUS DITINGKATKAN
TARGET PORSI BAURAN
PEMBANGKIT EBT
RUEN 2025 RPJMN 2024
45,2 GW
DARI 135,5 GW
19 GW2)
DARI 96 GW
~ 33% ~ 20%
TARGET PENURUNAN
EMISI GRK SEKTOR ENERGI
TAHUN 2030
NON-PEMBANGKIT
(TRANSPORTASI, MANUFAKTUR, DLL)
~5,7%
PEMBANGKIT LISTRIK ~5,3%5)
TOTAL 11%
5)KONTRIBUSI PEMBANGKIT ~ 48% TARGET
PENURUNAN EMISI GRK SEKTOR ENERGI
1)MEMPERTIMBANGKAN SASARAN
PERTUMBUHAN EKONOMI 2020
& 2025 : 8,0%
RASIO ELEKTRIFIKASI
~100%
DITERJEMAHKAN MELALUI
MAJOR PROJECT PENYEDIAAN
TENAGA LISTRIK
1 2
3
RASIO GINI
IPM
KERANGKA PEMBANGUNAN RENDAH KARBON 2020-2024: KETENAGALISTRIKAN
Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
Skenario Net-Zero Emission: Asumsi Sektor Energi
No. Kebijakan Skenario BAU Skenario 2060 NZE
1
Pembangkit Listrik Energi
Terbarukan
Proporsi energi terbarukan relatif
tetap hingga 2060
Terdapat peningkatan signifikan untuk proporsi energi
terbarukan pada pembangkit listrik hingga mendekati 100
persen pada 2060, dengan sisanya dipenuhi oleh tenaga
nuklir
2 Efisiensi Energi
Tingkat efisiensi energi final konstan di
angka 1 persen per tahun
Tingkat efisiensi energi naik secara progresif dari 1 persen
saat ini hingga 6 persen pada tahun 2030 dst
3 Kendaraan Listrik
Tidak ada penambahan kendaraan
listrik untuk transportasi umum dan
pribadi
Peningkatan jumlah kendaraan listrik untuk transportasi
umum dan pribadi hingga 95 persen di 2055
4 Subsidi energi Tidak ada penghapusan subsidi energi
Penghapusan subsidi energi, baik BBM, Gas, maupun listrik
hingga sepenuhnya di tahun 2030
5
Penghentian penggunaan
batubara
Tidak ada penghentian penggunaan
batubara
Penurunan penggunaan batubara hingga akhirnya nol pada
tahun 2060 di semua sektor
6 Bahan bakar hidrogen
Tidak ada pemanfaatan bahan bakar
hidrogen
Pemanfaatan hidrogen untuk bahan bakar di sektor
transportasi (4 persen dari total bahan bakar transportasi)
dan industri (100 persen menggantikan gas alam)
24
25
Langkah Kebijakan Transformasi Subsektor Ketenagalistrikan
No. Kebijakan Trasfromasi Sasaran
1
Peningkatan pembangkit
listrik EBT
Hidro, solar, panas bumi, angin,
anginn/bayu, arus laut, biomasa ,
nuklir??
2
Konversi Pembangkit
Listrik Fosil
Konversi PLTD, PLTU, PLTG/U
3
Penggunaan teknologi
energi bersih untuk
ketenagalistrikan
CCS/CCSU, Baterei, hidrogen
4
Perluasan jaringan
interkoneksi/transmisi,
smart grid
Interkoneksi antar pulau
(menghubungkan potensi EBT-
demand) dan pulau kecil/terluar,
smart
5
Konversi Ekosistem
Pengunaan/pemanfaaatn
Transportasi, industri dan bisnis dan
rumah tangga
6 Efisiensi pemanfaatan
Bangunan/Gedung, industri, peralatan
rumah tangga, alat transportasi.
Availability,
Accessibility,Affordability,
Sustainability &
Competitiveness
Energi
Rendah Carbon
Ketahanan Iklim &
Pengembangan
Berkelanjutan
Ketahanan
Kemandirian
Energi
• TKDN
• Penyaluran bantuan
internasional dan Karbon
trading
• Fasilitas bantuan
pendanaan
• Fasilitasi(penyiapan,
kompensasi)
pengembangan proyek
• Subsidi/bansos
• Insentif pajak
• Tarif (jual beli listrik, TDL)
• Kemudahan
investasi/Debottlenecking
Kebijakan Pendukung
Pengembangan ekonomi super produktif
Konektivitas SDM dan Teknologi berdaya saing
26
Peningkatan tata kelola energi dan ketenagalistrikan
Peningkatan efisiensi pemanfaatan energi dan tenaga listrik
ARAH KEBIJAKAN PEMBANGUNAN BERDASARKAN RPJMN 2020-2024
Diversifikasi energi dan ketenagalistrikan
Penguatan dan perluasan pelayanan pasokan
Pengembangan kebijakan pendanaan dan pembiayaan
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Pemanfaatan EBT untuk listrik; pengembangan microgrid off-grid; energi storage system (termasuk baterai);
solar rooftop; industri sel surya; serta pelaksanaan konservasi dan efisiensi energi
Perbaikan sistem transmisi dan distribusi; sistem informasi dan kontrol data; jaringan cerdas; teknologi yang
lebih efisien dan rendah emisi.
Kawasan prioritas; bantuan pasang baru; penyediaan energi primer; kemampuan enjinering nasional;
pendukung kendaraan listrik; clean cooking.
kelembagaan (perkuatan pengaturan dan operator sistem transmisi); mendorong kebijakan harga/tarif
energi.
Subsidi tepat sasaran; penyesuaian tarif listrik; pembiayaan murah, alternatif instrumen dan leverage asset;
pengembangan skema pendanaan yang cocok dan berkesinambungan.
Kementerian PPN/Bappenas
27
Peran Penting Transisi Energi dalam pencapaian Net Zero Emissions (NZE)
merupakan strategi jangka panjang
dalam sistem energi pembangunan
rendah karbon yang berbasis pada
energi terbarukan dan energi baru
hanya dapat dijalankan melalui
kebijakan terintegrasi yang
mendorong seluruh sektor dalam
suatu perekonomian
berakar pada gerakan
pembangunan berkelanjutan dan
dukungan publik untuk tindakan
mitigasi perubahan iklim
28
Proses
transisi
• Sebagai clearing house dan system integrator, Bappenas akan
memastikan berbagai kebijakan Pembangunan Rendah Karbon
dan Ketahanan Iklim dalam mencapai Net Zero Emissions dan
proses transisi yang adil (just transition) diintegrasikan ke dalam
RPJPN 2025-2045
Proses transisi menuju Upaya mencapai Net Zero Emissions
memerlukan proses transisi yang adil (just-transition) dan perlu
dilakukan secara hati-hati, terutama berkaitan dengan isu tenaga
kerja
Bappenas sebagai
clearing house
dan system
integrator