This document summarizes the key findings of an OECD Investment Policy Review of Georgia. It discusses Georgia's efforts to improve its domestic regulatory framework to attract foreign direct investment. While Georgia has made significant reforms, it needs to deepen reforms to facilitate broad-based economic growth. The document also examines trends in FDI in Georgia, noting that inflows have plateaued after initial growth. It provides recommendations to promote sustainable investment in priority sectors like agriculture. Responsible business conduct is also discussed as important to Georgia's business environment.
A PPT on digital India initiative by Government of India
OECD Investment Policy Review of Georgia: Key Findings
1. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 1
EASTERN EUROPE AND SOUTH CAUCASUS INITIATIVE
OECD Investment Policy Review
Georgia
KEY FINDINGS
15 December 2020
2. Scope of the Review
1. Assessment and recommendations
2. FDI trends and impact
3. Domestic regulatory framework, investor
protection
4. Promoting sustainable investment in
Georgia’s agri-food value chains
5. Investment promotion and facilitation
6. Responsible business conduct
OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 2
3. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 3
Doing business (overall)
Starting a business
Registering propertyTrading across borders
Resolving insolvency
Georgia
Armenia
Europe &
Central Asia
average
Georgia is one of the best performers in terms of Doing Business
Source: World Bank
4. 4
Georgia among the most open economies for foreign investors
OECD average
NON-OECD average
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
Libya
Algeria
PalestinianAuthority
Philippines
Indonesia
Thailand
Russia
Malaysia
China
NewZealand
Jordan
SaudiArabia
India
LaoPdr
Mexico
Tunisia
Iceland
Canada
Australia
Lebanon
BruneiDarussalam
KyrgyzRepublic
Korea
VietNam
Ukraine
Tajikistan
Israel
Kazakhstan
Myanmar
Austria
Egypt
UnitedStates
Belarus
Norway
Switzerland
Brazil
Azerbaijan
Peru
Mongolia
Poland
Uzbekistan
Morocco
Moldova
Turkey
Singapore
Sweden
Chile
Albania
SouthAfrica
Cambodia
Japan
Italy
Serbia
Uruguay
SlovakRepublic
France
Ireland
Belgium
UnitedKingdom
BosniaandHerzegovina
Croatia
Denmark
Greece
Argentina
CostaRica
Hungary
Macedonia,FYR
Colombia
Montenegro
Germany
Spain
Latvia
Lithuania
Armenia
Finland
Estonia
Georgia
Netherlands
CzechRepublic
Romania
Slovenia
Portugal
Luxembourg
Kosovo*
2019 OECD FDI Regulatory Restrictiveness Index (open=0; closed=1)
Source: OECD
5. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 5
Georgia’s reforms have been impressive but need to be deepened
• Georgia’s reform experience is commendable and is in many ways an example other
countries look to for inspiration
• But reforms have not sufficiently facilitated broad-based economic growth:
• Productivity growth weak
• Exports below potential and undiversified
• Poverty, particularly in rural areas, high
• Unemployment and under-employment high
• Skills and quality suppliers gap
• Infrastructure and connectivity challenges
Georgia has removed much of the de jure barriers to FDI; its task is now to improve the
overall enabling environment for investment
7. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 7
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
FDI inflows
FDI inflows, mil. USD (left axis) Inflows % of GDP (right axis)
-500
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019*
FDI inflows by component
Equity Reinvestment of earnings Debt instruments
• FDI inflows rose sharply after initial liberalisation reforms but have not substantially
grown over the past decade
• Equity investments, including greenfield projects and M&As, have been declining in
recent years, in absolute value and as a share of total FDI
• FDI is likely to further contract in the near-term as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic,
global supply & demand disruptions, and the pessimistic outlook of economic actors
FDI has plateaued after strong initial growth
Source: Geostat
8. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 8
FDI in tradable sectors below potential
• The majority of FDI in Georgia goes to services – primarily finance, real estate, wholesale
trade and tourism – followed by transport and energy
o Infrastructure projects and financial services have seen the greatest FDI growth in the
past decade
• These sectors have contributed to economic growth, but have not sufficiently advanced
job creation, particularly in rural areas, or productivity, and may be limited by Georgia’s
small domestic market
• FDI in export-oriented sectors remains minimal, despite some growth in FDI in tourism and
renewable energy
Services
28%
Energy
23%
Manufacturing
23%
Transport &
Warehousing
14%
Construction
9%
Agribusiness
3%
Greenfield FDI, % total 2007-2019
Services
40%
Transport*
21%
Energy &
extractives
17%
Manufacturing
11%
Construction
10%
Agriculture
1%
FDI inflows, % total 2007-2019
Source: Geostat (FDI inflows), fDi Markets by FT (Greenfield FDI)
9. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 9
FDI in Georgia contributes to positive development outcomes
-0.2
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
Georgia CA EaP MED SEE
A. Employment growth
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
Georgia CA EaP MED SEE
B. Training
-1.5
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Georgia CA EaP MED SEE
D. Energy efficiency
-2.0
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
Georgia CA EaP MED SEE
C. Average wage
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Georgia CA EaP MED SEE
F. Female employees
Note: Confidence intervals at 95%. If crosses zero line, the difference is statistically insignificant.
CA: Central Asia, EaP: Eastern Partner, MED: Southern Mediterranean, SEE: Southeast Europe
Source: OECD FDI Qualities Indicators.
Do foreign manufacturers have higher development outcomes? (yes > 0 > no)
-2.0
-1.5
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
Georgia CA EaP MED SEE
E. Labour productivity
11. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 11
Significant strides towards improving the domestic regulatory
framework for investors but challenges remain
• The Investment Law, together with several other laws, provides core protections
for investors, but Article 7 could be amended to provide further specification on
expropriation and the government’s right to regulate
• Reforms to IP laws and other IP-related improvements in line with DCFTA
commitments. The government should continue to prioritise initiatives to
improve the effectiveness of enforcement measures for IP rights
• Reforms to strengthen the independence of the judiciary and broader judicial
reform need to be sustained
• Efforts have been made to promote the use of arbitration and mediation services.
Aspects of the Arbitration Law should be amended to improve legal certainty;
and initiatives to improve public perceptions and awareness of arbitration and
mediation should be further supported
• Land laws provide a clear framework for property rights. The government should
complete and, if possible, expedite universal land registration reforms; detailed
recommendations on land policy in Chapter 3
• Well-developed laws and institutions on data protection and cybersecurity which
should be maintained as a national policy priority
12. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 12
Georgia’s approach to international investment agreements
Continue to reassess and update priorities for investment treaties
• Unqualified FET provisions, lightly regulated ISDS provisions
• Need to circumscribe MFN provisions to limit treaty shopping
• Ensure policy space
Continue to participate actively in and follow closely government
and other action on investment treaty reforms at the OECD,
UNCITRAL and ECT modernisation process
14. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 14
• The agri-food value chain plays an
essential role in Georgia’s economy,
accounting for 10% of GDP and 44%
of employment in 2019
• Georgia has favourable conditions for
attracting investment in the agri-food
value chain
• FDI inflows are below potential
• Agri-food exports are highly
concentrated in beverages
• The farm structure is highly
fragmented, with most food
produced by small-scale family farms
• Productivity and wages are low
Foreign and domestic investment can support the development
of Georgia’s agri-food value chain
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
USD million Agriculture Agriculture (% of total)
21%
20%
16%
14%
10%
8%
7%
2%
2%
1%
Wine
Vegetables, fruits and nuts
Water, soft drinks
Spirits, other beverages
Live animals, meat and dairy
Tobacco
Processed food products
Cereals, starches, oil seeds
Coffee, tea, spices
Animal or vegetable fats and oils
FDI Inflows in agriculture, 2007-19
Agri-food exports, 2015-19
15. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 15
• Introduce an objective on investment promotion and facilitation in the new
Agriculture and Rural Development Strategy 2021-2027
• Provide a clear and predictable framework for prospective investors to submit
investment plans and obtain government approvals to obtain agricultural land
• Ensure full completion of the land registration reform
• Strengthen the provision of credit guarantees for agri-food SMEs
• Continue investing in transport and utility infrastructure, and improve the quality of
logistics services
• Rehabilitate outdated irrigation infrastructure and drainage systems and improve
internet access in rural areas
• Consider allocating resources to encourage the formation of supply chain linkages,
including linking foreign investors with local SMEs
• Offer targeted incentives to prospective investors, conditional on their engagement
with small-scale producers and agricultural co-operatives
• Develop well-resourced and functioning agricultural training institutes, extension
services and vocational training systems
• Strengthen food safety and quality standards
Policy recommendations for the agri-food value chain
17. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 17
Strong investment promotion, ready for the next phase?
• History of successfully promoting investment, including through powerful IPA
• Part of the liberalisation and reform wave in 2000s
• Today, FDI inflows have plateaued and reforms are slowing
• Government’s ambition is to attract investment into more high value-added sectors (eg: BPO)
• Institutional changes have taken place:
Enterprise Georgia has absorbed the investment promotion agency from PM Office
Strong export promotion and enterprise development activities
Creation of GITA – strong momentum to foster innovation
Powerful stakeholders to support investment promotion (GCC, Investors’ Council…)
• … and are maturing:
New investment promotion strategy (Enterprise Georgia)
More Resources for investment promotion
New efforts in strategic communications
Overall professionalisation of the IPA (CRM, new strategic staff, guidelines for Embassies…)
18. Key recommendations for more effective investment promotion
Keep strengthening the investment
promotion function in Georgia
Strengthen the investment aftercare
system and improve one-stop shop
services
Link export, innovation and investment
promotion
Foster FDI-SME linkages
Strengthen investment promotion and
facilitation at the sub-national level
Main challenges:
Coordination of overall investment promotion activities across various actors
Strategically connecting investment promotion, export and innovation
development
Strategically channeling private sector insights into investment promotion
(oversight & guidance)
Effectively tackling business climate issues beyond the remit of Enterprise Georgia
Develop a comprehensive investment policy
statement
Enhance the Invest in Georgia brand
Enhance the investment promotion
oversight mechanism
Formalise strategic co-ordination for
investment promotion
Recommendations: strategic & operational
20. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 20
• Expectation that all businesses – regardless of status, size, ownership,
sector, location - avoid and address negative RBC impacts
Not philanthropy: part of core business and risk management
Important for all businesses, not just MNEs
• RBC minimises risks for businesses and helps prevent/address negative
impacts on people and environment – all subject to government
regulation and action
• RBC attracts quality investment
• RBC is increasingly expected and integrated in standards and policies at
global, regional, national levels:
OECD Guidelines for MNEs, ILO MNE Declaration, UN Guiding Principles
on Business and Human Rights
EU: towards mandatory human rights and env. due diligence
Responsible Business Conduct key to sustainable business
environment
21. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 21
Georgia has made strides towards increasing RBC awareness and
improving the legal framework that underpins RBC
State of play Challenges and opportunities
Awareness of RBC on the rise: activities by
government (HR Secretariat, sectoral
ministries, Ombudsman), business, CSOs
• Continued activities needed / expansion
• Moving from MNEs to SMEs
Policy coherence:
• Business and human rights integrated in
the Human Rights NAP 2018-2020
• Reforms in other sectors relevant to RBC
• Implementation and forthcoming NAP 2020-
2022
• State as economic actor
Achievements in legal and policy reforms on
human rights
Some areas for improvement: access to remedy
& independence of judiciary, civic space
Georgia top of its peers in corruption
perception; legal & policy frameworks in place
Less attention has been paid on preventing and
addressing corruption in the private sector
Major progress made in addressing legacy of
de-regularisation and weak labour and
environmental protection:
• Stengthening of labour inspection
(sept.2020 amendments)
• Occupational health & safety, environment
• focusing on implementation of
reforms/compliance Sectors identified as
high-risks (mining, hydropower)
22. OECD Eurasia Competitiveness Programme 22
Georgia can continue on this path by strengthening policy
coherence and leading by example in its commercial activities
• A National Action Plan is a useful tool to demonstrate a government’s
commitment to RBC, highlight relevant policies and ensure policy coherence:
23 countries (20 of which are Adherents to the OECD Guidelines) have
adopted a NAP on RBC/BHR; NAPs adopted in Czech Republic, Lithuania,
Slovenia, Poland; process in Ukraine
• Public procurement : core role of government as purchaser of goods, works
and services: public procurement averaged 9.9% of the country’s GDP and
31.7% of overall public spending between 2013-2016 (WB, 2018). Steps taken
to integrate environmental sustainability into procurement can be built upon.
• Investment Promotion Agency: Branding Georgia as a responsible business
destination can help attract FDI.
• State-owned Enterprises, albeit a small number (400), are large employers
and players in the economy. There is scope for improving management of
state ownership and defining RBC expectations for SOEs.
23. Recommendations on RBC (1/2): Coordinating,
consolidating and deepening efforts
Strengthen
awareness of
and
commitments
to RBC
Promote
policy
coherence
• Clearly communicate expectations that all
businesses operating in and from Georgia respect
RBC
• Increase awareness-raising and capacity-building
for employers and employees, esp. in SMEs and
sectors identified as high-risk
• Strengthen and expand RBC commitments in
forthcoming Human Rights NAP, including
resources for implementation
• Consider National Action Plan on RBC/BHR
• Set clear expectations on RBC for SOEs and public
procurement; improve State ownership
management
24. Recommendations on RBC (2/2)
• Continue to improve legislation and its
enforcement related to adequate working
conditions, esp. occupational health and safety;
continue strengthening the independence and
capacity of labour inspection; further guarantee
non-discrimination in practice
• Promote stronger compliance with environmental
protection regulations, esp. impact assessments
and environmental information and participation
• Promote enhanced due diligence and
implementation of RBC standards in mining and
hydropower sectors, including meaningful
consultations
• Continue reforms to combat corruption and assist
companies in doing so
Strengthen
RBC in key
areas