Nicola Spence, Chief Plant Health Officer Defra; Sarah Eberle, RHS Award Winning Garden Designer; Peter Clay, Crocus,: Nicola Gammon, Shoot: Wayne Grills CEO BALI; Angela Halksworth, Tendercare discuss innovation in the battle against invasive plant health risks
2. FACEBOOK LIVESTREAM
• Welcome to those watching online!
• Please do chat with each other on Facebook – but also be aware comments get deleted by
Facebook when the video is saved.
• We cannot moderate conversations or take online questions for the speakers today.
• Twitter hashtag #PlantHealth
#PlantHealth
3. AGENDA
Welcome
Angela Halksworth, Tendercare
• Safety notices, facilities, getting onto WiFi and networking at the end
Nicola Gammon, Shoot
• Facebook process, slides & event agenda
Nicola Spence, Chief Plant Health, Defra
• Plant Health Update
Sarah Eberle, Award-winning garden designer & Peter Clay, Crocus
• The Resilience Garden Chelsea 2019
#PlantHealth
4. Nicola Gammon, Shoot
• Other plant biosecurity initiatives - Wayne Grills, CEO BALI
• About Shoot and our customers
• Data Science & AI innovation
• Plant biosecurity data now & improvements in future
• Work with us – we are planning significant innovation and growth
Angela Halksworth, Tendercare
• Why and how working with Shoot
• Plant biosecurity measures
• Next steps – call to action
Q & A all speakers
Close and thank you
AGENDA
#PlantHealth
27. Italy (subspecies pauca)
• First findings in EU, from 2013 – olive most affected host
• Containment zone established in Lecce/parts of Brindisi
• New findings being confirmed beyond the buffer zone, with continued delays
in felling
27
29. 29
Key risks: Xylella fastidiosa and Philaenus spumarius
What is the threat? Xylella fastidiosa is a highly damaging bacterial pathogen native to the Americas and
introduced to Europe (Italy, Spain and France).
How would/does it get here? Xylella would most likely arrive on planting material.
How does it affect UK crops? Xylella has a vast host range including Polygala, vines, lavender, rosemary and trees like
almond, ash, cherry, plums and olives. Bacteria block the xylem (water carrying) vessels
leading to dieback, leaf scorch and in some cases mortality.
Other impacts Massive economic and social impacts due to the removal of ancient olive trees in Italy
and the impacts on trade.
How quickly does it spread? It is spread by xylem feeding insects like the meadow spittlebug, and can move in trade
of asymptomatic plants.
How controllable is it? The only control option is destruction of infected plants. Vector populations can be
controlled by spraying.
Current and proposed actions Under EU legislation, all hosts within 100 metres would be destroyed and movement of
host plants controlled for 5 km for an interception, 10km in the wider environment. All
hosts must move with a plant passport.
30. Enhancing preparedness for Xylella fastidiosa
30
• Defra has funded a number of projects focussed on Xylella fastidiosa
focussed on applied research that will enhance the way we respond
to a finding of the disease:
• Improving diagnostics
• Learning more about the distribution and behaviour of potential
vectors.
• Identifying optimum methods to control vectors
• Developing new in-field data capture platforms
• Collaborating with researchers in other European countries to
learn about the efficacy of management strategies
31. New Xylella R&D
• More than £18 million through a joint bid with BBSRC focussed on bacterial
plant pathogens, and Xylella fastidiosa in particular
• BRIGIT project launched in December 2018, with a budget of more that £5
million
• Consortium made up of 10 research institutions led by
• Research focuses on remaining evidence gaps, including:
• Behaviour of the disease in key native hosts, including movement within
the plant and triggers for symptom development
• Behaviour of potential vectors
• Epidemiological modelling
• Social science
31
32. Rose rosette virus and its vector
Phyllocoptes fructiphilus
• Both RRV and P. fructiphilus are only
recorded from North America but
recent finding in India
• Rosa multiflora is particularly
susceptible to the disease, with
infection always being lethal
• Has the potential to cause large
economic, environmental and social
impacts in the UK
33. Key risks: Rose rosette virus and its vector Phyllocoptes fructiphilus
What is the threat? Rose rosette virus (RRV) is a very damaging pest and can be lethal to many species of
the genus Rosa. Rose rosette virus is spread by the microscopic mite Phyllocoptes
fructiphilus, and has the potential to cause large economic, environmental and social
impacts in the UK.
How would/does it get here? Plants for planting and cut flowers of Rosa. Two native rose species are known to be a
host of RRV (Rosa canina and R. rubiginosa)
How does it affect UK crops? RRV is a highly destructive virus and infection kills the majority of rose hosts, with.
Potential economic impacts in the UK are large as infected plants will be
unmarketable, and there may be a reduction in demand for roses if the disease
spreads.
Other impacts Economic impacts associated with the removal and replacement of roses use in public
landscaping and impacts of tourism in public gardens.
How quickly does it spread? Spread is rapid. P. fructiphilus can be dispersed on air currents, and natural spread of
the mite occurs to plants downwind of those that are infested
How controllable is it? No control methods available. No proven resistant cultivars
Current and proposed actions Exclusion and regulation, with appropriate phytosanitary measures on the import of
Rosa plants from North America. EPPO Working Party in 2018 approved for
regulation.
34. Thousand canker disease of walnut
• Infestation of the walnut twig borer
Pityophthorus juglandis spreads the
fungus Geosmithia morbida, resulting
in disease
• A significant pest of walnut in the US,
outbreaks occurred in Europe for the
first time in Italy in 2013, where it is
spreading rapidly
• New research suggests Juglans regia
(a common UK host) is as susceptible
as Juglans nigra in the US
35. Key risks: Geosmithia morbida and Pityophthorus juglandis
What is the threat? Geosmithia morbida is introduced to the UK alongside its vector, the walnut twig borer.
How would/does it get here? Eggs, larvae and adults travel in non-squared wood, bark, wood packaging material or
plants for planting. As the pest is already established in Italy, natural spread to the UK
is a possibility.
How does it affect UK crops? Repeated infestations on the same host spread Geosmithia morbida throughout the
host, resulting in thousand cankers disease and significant host mortality of walnut
species
Other impacts Light infestations limit growth of the host
How quickly does it spread? The vector is capable of flying long distances. It has spread over 100km within two
years in Italy
How controllable is it? There are no effective treatments. The only current effective control to prevent spread
is tree destruction.
Current and proposed actions Statutory action would be taken on findings in the UK. The vector is subject to
extensive surveying in Italy.
36. Ambrosia beetle: Polyphagous Shot Hole Borer
(Euwallacea sp.) and Fusarium euwallaceae
• Spread through trade from its origin in
Vietnam to the USA, Israel and most
recently South Africa
• Larval burrows created by PSHB spread F.
euwallaceae throughout the host, leading to
mass build up of the fungi, clogging of
xylem vessels and characteristic ‘sugar
volcanoes’ form on the surrounding stem
galleries
• Very wide host range of broadleaved trees,
the most important UK host is oak.
• Avocado production is threatened
37. Key risks: Euwallacea sp. and Fusarium euwallaceae
What is the threat? Polyphagous Shot Hole Borer is introduced alongside Fusarium euwallaceae, causative
agent of Fusarium dieback
How would/does it get here? Import of plants for planting of the wide host range of this pest, movement with squared
and unsquared wood and wood packaging material.
How does it affect broadleaved trees? The ambrosia beetle introduces the pathogen throughout trunk and stems of the host,
this results in the clogging of the vascular tissues, necrosis and significant dieback.
Other impacts Avocado production in Israel is under threat from the beetle/pathogen, with incidence
rates reported of up to 100% in growing regions and significant crop losses. In South
Africa a large number of tree species have been attacked
How quickly does it spread? In Israel natural spread is reported to be between 10 and 20km a year. The wide
distribution in California is believed to be the result of multiple introduction events.
How controllable is it? The cryptic nature of the pest (it is very small) and very wide host range mean
identification, and eradication, are very difficult to achieve.
Current and proposed actions Watching brief needed on pest spread into areas with cooler climates. Added to the
EPPO A2 list in 2016 after a UK PRA.
39. Plant Health Management Standard (PHMS)
Plant Healthy – online self assessment
Plant Health Assurance Scheme (PHAS)
Plant Health Biosecurity Steering Group
Healthy Plants, Healthy Business
40. Plant Health Management Standard
(PHMS)
Helen Bentley-Fox
Tim Edwards
Jamie Dewhurst
Ed Birchall (APHA)
Ali Wilson (APHA)
Plant Health Biosecurity
Steering Committee
Many others including
Forestry Commission,
Forestry Research
Rebecca Grant
PHAS Steering Group
68. SHOOT
#PlantHealth
• Other industry resources
• About Shoot and our customers
• Data Science & AI innovation
• Defra Project: Plant biosecurity data now & improvements in future
• Demo videos
• Please work with us… how you can get involved.
70. #PlantHealth
What – 23 questions based on the Plant Health Management Standard
How – Create a free online account at planthealthy.org.uk
Why – help protect our businesses and industry from pests & diseases
It is designed to cover the supply chain and includes businesses such as – nurseries, retailers, landscapers,
arborists, public gardens.
72. OTHER PLANT BIOSECURITY INITIATIVES
#PlantHealth
What – 23 questions based on the Plant Health Management Standard
How – Create a free online account at planthealthy.org.uk
Why – help protect our businesses and industry from pests & diseases
It is designed to cover the supply chain and includes businesses such as – nurseries, retailers, landscapers,
arborists, public gardens.
1
www.landscapeinstitute.org @talklandscape
Landscape Institute
launches plant health &
biosecurity toolkit
https://bit.ly/2Gb3Faw
www.landscapeinstitute.org @talklandscape
Developed in
partnership with
• Society of Garden Designers (SGD)
• British Association of Landscape Industries (BALI)
• Association of Professional Landscapers (APL)
76. SHOOT OFFER NOW
2 Planting advice
Gardeners kill fewer plants with advice on right plant < > right place.
1 Design and plan
Gardeners can save
time creating plant lists
and garden plans using
our award-winning
planner.
Designers can create
professional mood
boards and planting
plans to scale using our
advanced garden
planner version for
professionals.
Designers can
collaborate all wrapped-
up in their own
branding.
3 Care calendar
Gardeners kill fewer plants
with personalised, expert
monthly to do lists direct to
your email inbox.
Designers can offer as a
valuable extra service to
their clients.
Retailers can provide
scalable, expert plant care
advice to their customers for
the plants they buy.
#PlantHealth
26,000 plants + growing
80. DATA AND AI INNOVATION
#PlantHealth#PlantHealth
81. DATA AND AI CHALLENGE
Defra data
• Species / variety level
• Genus level
• Family
• ‘broad-leaved trees’ / ‘woody plants’
Tendercare Nurseries
• Truncated names to fit onto
plant labels
Other retailer:
Extra text (e.g. 9cm pot)
Other retailer:
Genus or group level e.g.
‘Mixed clematis’ or ‘Mixed
bulbs’
#PlantHealth#PlantHealth
82. DEFRA < > SHOOT
RISK REGISTER DATA PROJECT
#PlantHealth#PlantHealth
83. DEFRA RISK REGISTER
1040 risks listed in total
Mitigated ratings: ‘likelihood’ and ‘impact’ ratings for each
Risks are rated 1-5 (1=low, 5=high)
Hosts: Species, Families and Genera and other e.g. ‘woody plants’ and ‘all
broadleaved trees’
#PlantHealth#PlantHealth
84. INITIAL MATCHING TO DEFRA
On initial match some Shoot plants had 53 invasive risks e.g. Prunus
#PlantHealth#PlantHealth
86. TOP 3 PER PLANT
Some plants still had 19 risks e.g. potato. So risks were then also ordered by impact highest
to lowest, and when the impact is the same, they are further ordered by likelihood.
#PlantHealth#PlantHealth
Plant
Scientific
Name Likelihood Impact To Display
acaena
microphylla
Margarodes
vitis 2 5 yes
acaena
microphylla
Hoplolaimus
spp. 2 4 yes
acaena
microphylla
Orgyia
thyellina 3 3 yes
acaena
microphylla
Choristoneura
rosaceana 2 3 no
97. #PlantHealth
UPDATING & IMPROVING DATA
#PlantHealth
Time stamp
Pest ID pages
with photos
and more
information
+ Process for newly added plants
Automated
updates
100. #PlantHealth
GARDEN DESIGNERS
#PlantHealth
ü If you are garden designer but not yet a member of Shoot – Book a
demonstration using this Calendly booking form: calendly.com/shoot/online-
demonstration-of-shoot
101. #PlantHealth
RETAILERS / PLANT NURSERIES
#PlantHealth
ü If you are a plant nursery or garden retailer and interested to learn more
about what Shoot can offer, please use this form: https://bit.ly/2YVj5Hn
102. #PlantHealth
INVESTORS
#PlantHealth
ü If you are interested being an investor in Shoot, we are soon going to
looking for more investment, so please contact Nicola using this form:
https://bit.ly/2WY9RbJ
105. SPEAKER Q & A
#PlantHealth#PlantHealth
Biosecurity Event 16th April 2019
106. The benefits of working
together
Tendercare's customer can benefit from Shoot’s plant care
calendar giving the customer a huge helping hand taking
care of their purchase.
Tendercare can continue to grow the relationship with the
customer by keeping the interaction going well after the
purchase.
107. Biosecurity Measures taken by the Nursery
Plant Passports
Tendercare only imports plants from
nurseries that are able to provide a
valid plant passport. Each
consignment delivered to
customers by Tendercare comes
with paperwork which has
Tendercare's plant passport number
attached.
Phytosanitary Certificates
Where we export to a country
outside the EU we will have the
plants inspected and transport the
plants with their phytosanitary
certificate. Where we import plants
from outside the EU, we will ensure
they have a phytosanitary
certificate and that the plants travel
with that phytosanitary certificate.
Notifiable P & D (applies to wide
range of trees and shrubs)
Where we find any notifiable pests
and diseases either at the goods in
stage or when the plants are being
grown we will immediately notify
the Plant Health and Seeds
Inspector and quarantine the
plants.
Other Statutory Schemes
Tendercare complies with the Eu
Tree Notification Scheme, where we
notify APHA through the eDomero
platform of any Castanea, Fraxinus,
Pinus, Platanus, Olea, Quercus and
Ulmus plants that are imported from
the EU so that they may be
inspected.
108. Why do we buy plants from Europe?
MANY OF OUR
MATURE TREES ARE
ORNAMENTAL, NON
NATIVE TREES SUCH
AS LIQUIDAMBER
AND GINKGOS,
PRODUCED BY
HIGHLY SKILLED
SPECIALIST
GROWERS IN SOILS
IDEAL FOR THESE
VARIETIES SUCH AS
THE GERMAN TREE
NURSERY LORBURG.
THE NURSERIES WE
DEAL WITH ARE ALL
COMMERCIAL
GROWERS AND ARE
SUBJECT TO THE
SAME EU
PHYTOSANITARY
INSPECTIONS AND
REGULATIONS THAT
WE ARE SUBJECT TO.
TENDERCARE ONLY
IMPORT FROM
NURSERIES IN EU
COUNTRIES THAT ARE
ABLE TO PROVIDE A
VALID PLANT
PASSPORT.
WE NOTIFY OUR
DELIVERIES TO DEFRA
THROUGH THE EU
TREE NOTIFICATION
SCHEME, WHO THEN
INSPECT IMPORTS AT
OUR NURSERY.
PLANTS WHICH MAY
HARBOUR
UNDIAGNOSABLE
INFECTIONS AT THE
TIME OF IMPORT ARE
HELD ON THE
NURSERY FOR A
RELEVANT PERIOD
TO THE LIFE-CYCLE
OF THE POTENTIAL
DISEASE OR PEST
UNTIL THEY ARE
KNOW TO BE RISK
FREE.
109. • The majority of our climbers, herbaceous and 20L shrub ranges are
grown in the UK at our Beaconsfield site
• All our plants are batch coded on the label for complete traceability.
• We were one of the first UK nurseries to start this system in the early 90’s.
• New for 2019 – we will indicate all plants which have been growing on
the nursery for over a year.
Do we grow any of our plants in the UK
YES!
110. • We check our Plant Health Management Policy Document against Industry
recommendations such as the Plant Healthy programme set up by the HTA.
• We scored highly doing this self test – 91% with 2 recommendations:
1. We took away advice on identifying out of the weeds we eradicate which
harbour vectors associated with notifiable diseases.
2. We aim to improve communicating the Biosecurity steps we are taking to our
customers.
112. Biocontrol Success story
Buxus sempervirens
We spray for the Box tree caterpillars Cydalima
perspectalis between March and October with
Dipel which contains Bacillus thuringiensis var.
kurstaki. The moths lay eggs on the underside of
the leaves, which become larvae which after
pupating become a caterpillar
Last year we had no evidence of the caterpillar
on our Buxus (hence them looking so fabulous)
and gardens we have treated in the same way,
in an area ravished by the caterpillar, stand out
with healthy Buxus, like an oasis.
It would make an excellent research study to
investigate Dipel’s use against processionary
moth.