SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 15
Peter Pype MD, PhD 
Peter Pype – EGPRN - Antwerp 2012 pag. 1 
Ghent University - Belgium
Presenter Disclosure 
• Faculty: Peter Pype 
• This program has received financial support 
from : 
Kom op tegen Kanker, campaign of the Vlaamse 
Liga tegen Kanker VZW. 
There has been no influence of the funding body 
on the content of the study.
1. Background 
1. Most palliative patients prefer to stay at home 
2. General Practitioners (GP) are responsible for patient care 
3. Palliative Home Care Teams (PHCT) provide advice and support 
General Research Aim: 
How do GPs keep up their palliative care competences?
2. Research Questions 
RQ1: What is the current CME offer in palliative care for GPs? 
RQ2: What are GPs’ views and preferences toward lifelong learning in 
palliative care? 
RQ3: What are features of workplace learning in primary palliative care? 
RQ4: Can WPL be enhanced by training PHCT nurses as facilitator of 
physicians’ learning?
3. Results – RQ1: Current CME 
• Uncoordinated 
• Large content gaps 
• Mostly lectures 
• Low attendance rate
3. Results – RQ2: Preferences GPs 
• Lifelong learning acknowledged 
• Basic versus expert 
• Current CME inefficient 
• Mismatch with actual learning needs 
• Alternatives 
• Workplace learning with palliative home care teams
3. Results – RQ3: Features of WPL 
• Workplace learning is reciprocal 
• Content items (e.g. patient symptoms) more than proces items 
(e.g. teamwork) 
• Discussion and reflection – listening and observing more than 
learning from mistakes – receiving feedback 
• Individual characteristics seem not important
3. Results – RQ4: training nurses as facilitator 
Training content: 
1. Recognising and exploring learning opportunities 
2. Shifting specific questions to generic ones 
3. Giving positive and negative feedback 
4. Critical incident analysis 
5. Debriefing the collaboration
Full day training 
Small group sessions 
Interactive 
Role play 
Individual reflection 
Group reflection 
Practice based 
Three months 
practice 
Practice experience 
Home work 
Progress report 
Individual feedback 
Half day training 
Small group sessions 
Interactive 
Role play 
Individual reflection 
Group reflection 
Practice based 
Summative assessment 
Training format 
Interviews (video)
3. Results – RQ4: training nurses as facilitator 
• Implementation depends on: 
• Personal factors (e.g. professional identity) 
• Interpersonal factors (e.g. relationship with GP) 
• Team factors (e.g. preparing a conversation) 
• Context factors (e.g. workload – phone call versus 
meeting) 
• Style-preference according to context 
• Importance of ‘mentoring period’
3. Results – RQ4: training nurses as facilitator 
• Palliative care nurses learn as well as the GPs 
• Palliative care nurses change attitudes toward GPs 
• No more ‘good and bad doctors’ 
• Caring for GP as team member 
• Home care nurses get involved 
• GPs ‘change’ 
• Notice new style 
• Make more time
• Traditional CME seems insufficient to support GPs in their 
palliative care tasks 
• Workplace learning seems a suitable and feasible complement 
• Workplace learning can be influenced by training team members 
as facilitators 
4. Conclusion
5. Discussion 
• Linear cause-effect relationships are insufficient to explain results 
• System thinking: 
‧ Complexity Science 
‧ Complex Adaptive Systems
Health Care team as Complex Adaptive System 
Workplace learning 
 Adaptive behavior of a care team (‘Adaptability’) 
 To a ‘changing environment’ (internal of external change) 
 Resulting in team-functioning on a higher level

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Using Simulations for Instruction
Using Simulations for Instruction Using Simulations for Instruction
Using Simulations for Instruction
FCT at LSSU
 
Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14
Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14
Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14
NortheasternNursing
 
Competencies Required For Clinical Preceptor
Competencies Required For Clinical PreceptorCompetencies Required For Clinical Preceptor
Competencies Required For Clinical Preceptor
Tosca Torres
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Using Simulations for Instruction
Using Simulations for Instruction Using Simulations for Instruction
Using Simulations for Instruction
 
CanMeds RolesTeaching
CanMeds RolesTeaching CanMeds RolesTeaching
CanMeds RolesTeaching
 
Program instruction and modes of clinical teaching
Program instruction and modes of clinical teachingProgram instruction and modes of clinical teaching
Program instruction and modes of clinical teaching
 
Assessment in CBME Competency Based Medical Education Dr Girish .B CISP 2 MCI
Assessment in CBME Competency Based Medical Education Dr Girish .B CISP 2 MCIAssessment in CBME Competency Based Medical Education Dr Girish .B CISP 2 MCI
Assessment in CBME Competency Based Medical Education Dr Girish .B CISP 2 MCI
 
Chapter 27
Chapter 27Chapter 27
Chapter 27
 
MEU WORKSHOP The AT–com booklet
MEU WORKSHOP The AT–com bookletMEU WORKSHOP The AT–com booklet
MEU WORKSHOP The AT–com booklet
 
Ahec teaching skills
Ahec teaching skillsAhec teaching skills
Ahec teaching skills
 
Faculty Development - Simulation Education for Nurses
Faculty Development - Simulation Education for NursesFaculty Development - Simulation Education for Nurses
Faculty Development - Simulation Education for Nurses
 
Don't tell me show me ! - Lambert, Foley, Moore and Hinds
Don't tell me show me ! - Lambert, Foley, Moore and HindsDon't tell me show me ! - Lambert, Foley, Moore and Hinds
Don't tell me show me ! - Lambert, Foley, Moore and Hinds
 
Clinical Teaching Techniques
Clinical Teaching TechniquesClinical Teaching Techniques
Clinical Teaching Techniques
 
Teaching clinical skills 2015
Teaching clinical skills 2015Teaching clinical skills 2015
Teaching clinical skills 2015
 
Pearls of clinical teaching
Pearls of clinical teaching Pearls of clinical teaching
Pearls of clinical teaching
 
Clinical Teaching
Clinical TeachingClinical Teaching
Clinical Teaching
 
Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14
Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14
Neu what-to-expect-in-direct-entry-nursing-2-18-14
 
Direct observation and feedback
Direct observation and feedbackDirect observation and feedback
Direct observation and feedback
 
Competencies Required For Clinical Preceptor
Competencies Required For Clinical PreceptorCompetencies Required For Clinical Preceptor
Competencies Required For Clinical Preceptor
 
AETCOM
AETCOMAETCOM
AETCOM
 
Assessment and evaluation
Assessment and evaluationAssessment and evaluation
Assessment and evaluation
 
14 04 needs assessment
14 04 needs assessment14 04 needs assessment
14 04 needs assessment
 
Improving self directed learning through technology
Improving self directed learning through technologyImproving self directed learning through technology
Improving self directed learning through technology
 

Andere mochten auch

171 muster2014 mc kay
171 muster2014 mc kay171 muster2014 mc kay
171 muster2014 mc kay
Muster2014
 
168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership
168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership
168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership
Muster2014
 
Keynote muster2014 billett
Keynote muster2014 billettKeynote muster2014 billett
Keynote muster2014 billett
Muster2014
 
173 muster2014 dettwiller
173 muster2014 dettwiller173 muster2014 dettwiller
173 muster2014 dettwiller
Muster2014
 
114 muster2014 Billington
114 muster2014 Billington114 muster2014 Billington
114 muster2014 Billington
Muster2014
 
12 muster2014 Brooks
12 muster2014 Brooks12 muster2014 Brooks
12 muster2014 Brooks
Muster2014
 
79 muster2014 Reeve
79 muster2014 Reeve79 muster2014 Reeve
79 muster2014 Reeve
Muster2014
 
162 muster2014
162 muster2014162 muster2014
162 muster2014
Muster2014
 
122 muster2014 Dickey
122 muster2014 Dickey122 muster2014 Dickey
122 muster2014 Dickey
Muster2014
 
54 muster2014 Heddle
54 muster2014 Heddle54 muster2014 Heddle
54 muster2014 Heddle
Muster2014
 
106 weston el al muster2014
106 weston el al muster2014106 weston el al muster2014
106 weston el al muster2014
Muster2014
 
95 muster2014 Dean Doyle
95 muster2014 Dean Doyle95 muster2014 Dean Doyle
95 muster2014 Dean Doyle
Muster2014
 
155 muster2014 konkin
155 muster2014 konkin155 muster2014 konkin
155 muster2014 konkin
Muster2014
 
138 muster2014 Brotchie
138 muster2014 Brotchie138 muster2014 Brotchie
138 muster2014 Brotchie
Muster2014
 
74 muster2014 Britt
74 muster2014 Britt74 muster2014 Britt
74 muster2014 Britt
Muster2014
 
182 muster2014 ross
182 muster2014 ross182 muster2014 ross
182 muster2014 ross
Muster2014
 
117 muster2014 Bachiu
117 muster2014 Bachiu117 muster2014 Bachiu
117 muster2014 Bachiu
Muster2014
 
46 muster2014 Daly
46 muster2014 Daly46 muster2014 Daly
46 muster2014 Daly
Muster2014
 
128 doyle muster2014
128 doyle muster2014128 doyle muster2014
128 doyle muster2014
Muster2014
 

Andere mochten auch (19)

171 muster2014 mc kay
171 muster2014 mc kay171 muster2014 mc kay
171 muster2014 mc kay
 
168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership
168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership
168 muster2014 strasser grantham leadership
 
Keynote muster2014 billett
Keynote muster2014 billettKeynote muster2014 billett
Keynote muster2014 billett
 
173 muster2014 dettwiller
173 muster2014 dettwiller173 muster2014 dettwiller
173 muster2014 dettwiller
 
114 muster2014 Billington
114 muster2014 Billington114 muster2014 Billington
114 muster2014 Billington
 
12 muster2014 Brooks
12 muster2014 Brooks12 muster2014 Brooks
12 muster2014 Brooks
 
79 muster2014 Reeve
79 muster2014 Reeve79 muster2014 Reeve
79 muster2014 Reeve
 
162 muster2014
162 muster2014162 muster2014
162 muster2014
 
122 muster2014 Dickey
122 muster2014 Dickey122 muster2014 Dickey
122 muster2014 Dickey
 
54 muster2014 Heddle
54 muster2014 Heddle54 muster2014 Heddle
54 muster2014 Heddle
 
106 weston el al muster2014
106 weston el al muster2014106 weston el al muster2014
106 weston el al muster2014
 
95 muster2014 Dean Doyle
95 muster2014 Dean Doyle95 muster2014 Dean Doyle
95 muster2014 Dean Doyle
 
155 muster2014 konkin
155 muster2014 konkin155 muster2014 konkin
155 muster2014 konkin
 
138 muster2014 Brotchie
138 muster2014 Brotchie138 muster2014 Brotchie
138 muster2014 Brotchie
 
74 muster2014 Britt
74 muster2014 Britt74 muster2014 Britt
74 muster2014 Britt
 
182 muster2014 ross
182 muster2014 ross182 muster2014 ross
182 muster2014 ross
 
117 muster2014 Bachiu
117 muster2014 Bachiu117 muster2014 Bachiu
117 muster2014 Bachiu
 
46 muster2014 Daly
46 muster2014 Daly46 muster2014 Daly
46 muster2014 Daly
 
128 doyle muster2014
128 doyle muster2014128 doyle muster2014
128 doyle muster2014
 

Ähnlich wie 203 muster2014 pype

53 muster2014 Strasser
53 muster2014 Strasser53 muster2014 Strasser
53 muster2014 Strasser
Muster2014
 
Communication and utilization of research
Communication and utilization of researchCommunication and utilization of research
Communication and utilization of research
RenitaRichard
 
MentalHealthPreCon
MentalHealthPreConMentalHealthPreCon
MentalHealthPreCon
Jeff Carmack
 
Clinical Teaching
Clinical TeachingClinical Teaching
Clinical Teaching
Love Denia
 

Ähnlich wie 203 muster2014 pype (20)

Documenting your educational efforts: What we wish we had known
Documenting your educational efforts: What we wish we had knownDocumenting your educational efforts: What we wish we had known
Documenting your educational efforts: What we wish we had known
 
Ppt on clinical teaching methods
Ppt on clinical teaching methodsPpt on clinical teaching methods
Ppt on clinical teaching methods
 
Clinical teaching methods
Clinical teaching methodsClinical teaching methods
Clinical teaching methods
 
Wonca workshop 2011 pp
Wonca workshop 2011 ppWonca workshop 2011 pp
Wonca workshop 2011 pp
 
AETCOM
AETCOMAETCOM
AETCOM
 
AETCOM
AETCOMAETCOM
AETCOM
 
APE_PowerPoint_Presentation_Example2015.pptx
APE_PowerPoint_Presentation_Example2015.pptxAPE_PowerPoint_Presentation_Example2015.pptx
APE_PowerPoint_Presentation_Example2015.pptx
 
53 muster2014 Strasser
53 muster2014 Strasser53 muster2014 Strasser
53 muster2014 Strasser
 
Clinical teaching
Clinical teachingClinical teaching
Clinical teaching
 
Wonca ws ece maja
Wonca ws ece majaWonca ws ece maja
Wonca ws ece maja
 
Let's Talk Research 2015 - Joanna Harrison - CLAHRC NWC Internship scheme
Let's Talk Research 2015 - Joanna Harrison - CLAHRC NWC Internship scheme Let's Talk Research 2015 - Joanna Harrison - CLAHRC NWC Internship scheme
Let's Talk Research 2015 - Joanna Harrison - CLAHRC NWC Internship scheme
 
Dr. Kathleen Gallo, Senior Vice President and Chief Learning Officer, North S...
Dr. Kathleen Gallo, Senior Vice President and Chief Learning Officer, North S...Dr. Kathleen Gallo, Senior Vice President and Chief Learning Officer, North S...
Dr. Kathleen Gallo, Senior Vice President and Chief Learning Officer, North S...
 
Communication and utilization of research
Communication and utilization of researchCommunication and utilization of research
Communication and utilization of research
 
Online Clinical Assessment – New opportunities
Online Clinical Assessment – New opportunitiesOnline Clinical Assessment – New opportunities
Online Clinical Assessment – New opportunities
 
MentalHealthPreCon
MentalHealthPreConMentalHealthPreCon
MentalHealthPreCon
 
Clinical Teaching
Clinical TeachingClinical Teaching
Clinical Teaching
 
NCA Residency Session 3 Nov 9 2016
NCA Residency Session 3 Nov 9 2016NCA Residency Session 3 Nov 9 2016
NCA Residency Session 3 Nov 9 2016
 
Introduction to PCMH RN (abreviated)
Introduction to PCMH RN (abreviated)Introduction to PCMH RN (abreviated)
Introduction to PCMH RN (abreviated)
 
NURSING CARE DELIVERY SYSTEMS.pptx
NURSING CARE DELIVERY SYSTEMS.pptxNURSING CARE DELIVERY SYSTEMS.pptx
NURSING CARE DELIVERY SYSTEMS.pptx
 
Bridging gap edu nsg
Bridging gap edu nsgBridging gap edu nsg
Bridging gap edu nsg
 

Mehr von Muster2014

206 muster2014 pedro marvao
206 muster2014 pedro marvao206 muster2014 pedro marvao
206 muster2014 pedro marvao
Muster2014
 
204 muster2014 wood
204 muster2014 wood204 muster2014 wood
204 muster2014 wood
Muster2014
 
202 muster2014 pype
202 muster2014 pype202 muster2014 pype
202 muster2014 pype
Muster2014
 
200 muster2014 raymond
200 muster2014 raymond200 muster2014 raymond
200 muster2014 raymond
Muster2014
 
197 muster2014 douglas
197 muster2014 douglas197 muster2014 douglas
197 muster2014 douglas
Muster2014
 
196 muster2014 douglas
196 muster2014 douglas196 muster2014 douglas
196 muster2014 douglas
Muster2014
 
191 muster2014 barker
191 muster2014 barker191 muster2014 barker
191 muster2014 barker
Muster2014
 
188 muster2014 gwynne
188 muster2014 gwynne188 muster2014 gwynne
188 muster2014 gwynne
Muster2014
 
186 muster2014 briggs
186 muster2014 briggs186 muster2014 briggs
186 muster2014 briggs
Muster2014
 
185 muster2014 miller
185 muster2014 miller185 muster2014 miller
185 muster2014 miller
Muster2014
 
184 muster2014 woolley
184 muster2014 woolley184 muster2014 woolley
184 muster2014 woolley
Muster2014
 
180 muster2014 reade
180 muster2014 reade180 muster2014 reade
180 muster2014 reade
Muster2014
 
179 muster2014 reade
179 muster2014 reade179 muster2014 reade
179 muster2014 reade
Muster2014
 
176 muster2014 gail brescia
176 muster2014 gail brescia176 muster2014 gail brescia
176 muster2014 gail brescia
Muster2014
 
175 muster2014 dickey
175 muster2014 dickey175 muster2014 dickey
175 muster2014 dickey
Muster2014
 
170 muster2014 dettwiller
170 muster2014 dettwiller170 muster2014 dettwiller
170 muster2014 dettwiller
Muster2014
 
169 muster2014 campbell
169 muster2014 campbell169 muster2014 campbell
169 muster2014 campbell
Muster2014
 
166 muster2014 preston owens ross
166 muster2014 preston owens ross166 muster2014 preston owens ross
166 muster2014 preston owens ross
Muster2014
 
164 muster2014 boland
164 muster2014 boland164 muster2014 boland
164 muster2014 boland
Muster2014
 

Mehr von Muster2014 (20)

29 muster2014 wozniak
29 muster2014 wozniak29 muster2014 wozniak
29 muster2014 wozniak
 
206 muster2014 pedro marvao
206 muster2014 pedro marvao206 muster2014 pedro marvao
206 muster2014 pedro marvao
 
204 muster2014 wood
204 muster2014 wood204 muster2014 wood
204 muster2014 wood
 
202 muster2014 pype
202 muster2014 pype202 muster2014 pype
202 muster2014 pype
 
200 muster2014 raymond
200 muster2014 raymond200 muster2014 raymond
200 muster2014 raymond
 
197 muster2014 douglas
197 muster2014 douglas197 muster2014 douglas
197 muster2014 douglas
 
196 muster2014 douglas
196 muster2014 douglas196 muster2014 douglas
196 muster2014 douglas
 
191 muster2014 barker
191 muster2014 barker191 muster2014 barker
191 muster2014 barker
 
188 muster2014 gwynne
188 muster2014 gwynne188 muster2014 gwynne
188 muster2014 gwynne
 
186 muster2014 briggs
186 muster2014 briggs186 muster2014 briggs
186 muster2014 briggs
 
185 muster2014 miller
185 muster2014 miller185 muster2014 miller
185 muster2014 miller
 
184 muster2014 woolley
184 muster2014 woolley184 muster2014 woolley
184 muster2014 woolley
 
180 muster2014 reade
180 muster2014 reade180 muster2014 reade
180 muster2014 reade
 
179 muster2014 reade
179 muster2014 reade179 muster2014 reade
179 muster2014 reade
 
176 muster2014 gail brescia
176 muster2014 gail brescia176 muster2014 gail brescia
176 muster2014 gail brescia
 
175 muster2014 dickey
175 muster2014 dickey175 muster2014 dickey
175 muster2014 dickey
 
170 muster2014 dettwiller
170 muster2014 dettwiller170 muster2014 dettwiller
170 muster2014 dettwiller
 
169 muster2014 campbell
169 muster2014 campbell169 muster2014 campbell
169 muster2014 campbell
 
166 muster2014 preston owens ross
166 muster2014 preston owens ross166 muster2014 preston owens ross
166 muster2014 preston owens ross
 
164 muster2014 boland
164 muster2014 boland164 muster2014 boland
164 muster2014 boland
 

203 muster2014 pype

  • 1. Peter Pype MD, PhD Peter Pype – EGPRN - Antwerp 2012 pag. 1 Ghent University - Belgium
  • 2. Presenter Disclosure • Faculty: Peter Pype • This program has received financial support from : Kom op tegen Kanker, campaign of the Vlaamse Liga tegen Kanker VZW. There has been no influence of the funding body on the content of the study.
  • 3. 1. Background 1. Most palliative patients prefer to stay at home 2. General Practitioners (GP) are responsible for patient care 3. Palliative Home Care Teams (PHCT) provide advice and support General Research Aim: How do GPs keep up their palliative care competences?
  • 4. 2. Research Questions RQ1: What is the current CME offer in palliative care for GPs? RQ2: What are GPs’ views and preferences toward lifelong learning in palliative care? RQ3: What are features of workplace learning in primary palliative care? RQ4: Can WPL be enhanced by training PHCT nurses as facilitator of physicians’ learning?
  • 5. 3. Results – RQ1: Current CME • Uncoordinated • Large content gaps • Mostly lectures • Low attendance rate
  • 6. 3. Results – RQ2: Preferences GPs • Lifelong learning acknowledged • Basic versus expert • Current CME inefficient • Mismatch with actual learning needs • Alternatives • Workplace learning with palliative home care teams
  • 7. 3. Results – RQ3: Features of WPL • Workplace learning is reciprocal • Content items (e.g. patient symptoms) more than proces items (e.g. teamwork) • Discussion and reflection – listening and observing more than learning from mistakes – receiving feedback • Individual characteristics seem not important
  • 8. 3. Results – RQ4: training nurses as facilitator Training content: 1. Recognising and exploring learning opportunities 2. Shifting specific questions to generic ones 3. Giving positive and negative feedback 4. Critical incident analysis 5. Debriefing the collaboration
  • 9. Full day training Small group sessions Interactive Role play Individual reflection Group reflection Practice based Three months practice Practice experience Home work Progress report Individual feedback Half day training Small group sessions Interactive Role play Individual reflection Group reflection Practice based Summative assessment Training format Interviews (video)
  • 10. 3. Results – RQ4: training nurses as facilitator • Implementation depends on: • Personal factors (e.g. professional identity) • Interpersonal factors (e.g. relationship with GP) • Team factors (e.g. preparing a conversation) • Context factors (e.g. workload – phone call versus meeting) • Style-preference according to context • Importance of ‘mentoring period’
  • 11.
  • 12. 3. Results – RQ4: training nurses as facilitator • Palliative care nurses learn as well as the GPs • Palliative care nurses change attitudes toward GPs • No more ‘good and bad doctors’ • Caring for GP as team member • Home care nurses get involved • GPs ‘change’ • Notice new style • Make more time
  • 13. • Traditional CME seems insufficient to support GPs in their palliative care tasks • Workplace learning seems a suitable and feasible complement • Workplace learning can be influenced by training team members as facilitators 4. Conclusion
  • 14. 5. Discussion • Linear cause-effect relationships are insufficient to explain results • System thinking: ‧ Complexity Science ‧ Complex Adaptive Systems
  • 15. Health Care team as Complex Adaptive System Workplace learning  Adaptive behavior of a care team (‘Adaptability’)  To a ‘changing environment’ (internal of external change)  Resulting in team-functioning on a higher level