This document discusses cultural tourism and art gallery tourists. It defines cultural tourism as visiting activities like museums, galleries, festivals or experiencing Aboriginal culture during a trip. Cultural tourists seek new knowledge and experiences. There are different segments of cultural tourists from those on a road trip to serious art enthusiasts. Art galleries attract tourists seeking social experiences or to learn about exhibits. Cultural tourism generates economic benefits through visitor spending and jobs. Regional art galleries are popular destinations but compete in a busy cultural tourism market. More research is needed to understand tourist decision making and how social media impacts cultural tourism.
4. International and domestic visitors
who participate in at least one of the
following activities during their trip:
• attend theatre or performing arts
• visit museums or galleries
• visit art, craft workshops/studios
• attend festivals or cultural events
• experience Aboriginal art , craft or
displays
• visit historical/heritage buildings.
(TRA: 2009)
Cultural
Tourism
Edinburgh
5. Cultural tourists to NSW (2014)
Source: DNSW (2014) Cultural and Heritage Tourism# to NSW
0 1000 2000 3000
Visit historic buildings, sites
Visit galleries/museums
Attend festivals, or cultural events
Attend theatre, concerts or…
Experience Aboriginal site/community
Attend Aboriginal performance
Visit art/craft workshops or studios
International Domestic
6. Cultural tourism
The SEARCH for
• new knowledge
• new experiences
• self-development
• cultural capital
Newcastle Regional Art Gallery Swell Sculpture Festival
Elvis Festival, Parkes. Cooly Rocks On
9. Spectrum of art interests
socialiser
Seeking:
• Social place
• Atmosphere
• Escape
• Awe
• Interaction
dabbler
Seeking:
•New interest
•Variety of art
•Guides
•Workshops
•New places
enthusiast
Seeking:
•High knowledge
•Special exhibit
• Authenticity
•Collections
•New places
•Merchandise
fanatic
Seeking:
•Social context
•Obsessive
• Expert
•Rare items
•Elite high
quality
experiences
•Web forums
10. Expenditure of cultural tourists
Exhibition name Attendance Million $
National Gallery of Australia - Masterpieces from Paris 470,000 $95.0
QAGOMA* - Andy Warhol 232,389 $14.2
QAGOMA - Valentino 202,849 $18.4
AGNSW - Pop to Popism 123,695 ^
AGNSW - Picasso 366,000 ^
Townsville Regional Gallery - Brick by Brick 102,320 ^
Bendigo Regional Gallery - Grace Kelly 152,500 $16.3
Source: Various State & local government reports
11. Economic evaluation process
1.
• Visitors from over 50kms?
2.
• Day visit or longer?
3.
• Expenditure per day?
4.
• Main purpose of visit?
12. Types of economic impact
1. Ticketed exhibitions = direct revenue to venues
2. Cultural tourist visitation = revenue to whole
destination
3. Donations and bequests of art and cultural material
4. Sponsorship and funding from partners outside the
region
5. Volunteer hours donated to cultural venues
13. Regional art galleries
What we know
Competitive cultural tourism environment
Galleries high on the list for cultural tourists
Segments and stages of gallery visitors
Social experience & VFR
Galleries generate economic activity
What we’d like to know
Tourist decisions?
Social media impacts?
14. Further information
Copies of cultural tourism reports
Recommended reading
On-site research
Coffee and a chat
Jo Mackellar
destination.research@yahoo.com
Hinweis der Redaktion
What is cultural tourism ?
Key features of cultural tourists
Segments and stages
Spectrum of art interests
Art gallery tourists
What is cultural tourism? – is it travelling to galleries, or events or just doing a bit of shopping?
CULTURE can be defined as “The arts and other manifestations of human intellectual achievement regarded collectively” Oxford as well as “The ideas, customs, and social behaviour of a particular people or society”.
So Which part of culture are tourists seeking?
Because really every tourist is a cultural tourist – walking the streets in any location from Edinburgh to Sydney or Broken Hill you are surrounded by and immersed in the culture of place and of people – by their customs and social behaviour. The streetscape and architecture represents their human intellectual achievement. – so is it both these things?
From the food you eat to the streets you walk are all representative of the people and place
Traditionally, cultural tourism has been associated with high culture, with high end arts and old museums, but it is becoming more widely recognised that the old distinctions between high and popular culture are disappearing. Tourists are just as willing to travel on a train to Parkes to see Elvis as they are to go to Sydney to the Museum, or to Newcastle to see a Mambo exhibition.
Way back last century in 1995 the sociologist John Urry identified the convergence of ‘high’ and ‘low’ culture, and with it - a convergence of ‘art’ and ‘life’.
To get even more philosophical for just a moment - Objects and people have become increasingly mobile, and boundaries between distinct cultures are increasingly being eliminated . In many cases in western society and certainly in Australia - travel is becoming part of our culture – we have more money and time to travel. We consider “having holidays” and “going overseas” as part of our lifestyle, as part of our social norms. At some point you could even ask are we the culture – or are we the tourist?
and so it is fair to ask what is cultural tourism? – and to keep asking the question over time.
While we could debate its meaning all day and forevermore – in practice - we must just get on and manage it. And in order to that someone needs to define it -
TRA is the pinnacle government organisation for collecting data on domestic and international tourists – the data they collect is then used to determine trends over time – and to inform the development of tourism strategies. So it is fair to say that these statistics are quite important to both tourism and creative industries.
They currently define cultural tourism as - International and domestic visitors who participate in at least one of the following activities during their trip:
attend theatre or performing arts
visit museums or galleries
visit art, craft workshops/studios
attend festivals or cultural events
experience Aboriginal art craft or displays
visit historical/heritage buildings.
Even this neat list provides more questions and ambiguity – I stayed in this quaint heritage building in Edinburgh – so does that make me a cultural tourist? It would be hard to visit Edinburgh at all without visiting historical buildings at some point – as it would in any city or regional town in Australia. Similarly – anyone who arrives in Bathurst by train and goes to the pub would have visited two historical buildings that day and qualify as a cultural tourist.
With these questions in mind – it is interesting to see the results of TRA research and the place of art galleries in the cultural tourism landscape.
As shown here visiting galleries and museums is the first choice of both international and domestic visitors in NSW with
59% of international visitors to NSW visiting museums and galleries
40% of domestic overnight visitors and 31% of day trippers
In terms of cultural tourism in regional areas – the figures are quite variable.
An average of 15% of visitors of the domestic visitors visit cultural attractions/events– with the Blue Mountains and The Outback doing very well with over 20% of tourists visiting cultural attractions/events.
For international visitors - the figures are also quite variable.
an average of 60% are cultural tourists
a remarkable 82% of visitors are cultural tourists to the Blue Mountains. And 74% to the outback NSW.
So this tells most of us that 6 out of 10 international visitors are likely to visit a gallery in your region and 1.5 out of 10 domestic visitors.
Research also tell us cultural tourists are increasingly engaged in a search for new knowledge and experiences, as part of a general process of self-development. These 'skilled consumers' are interested not just in cultural attractions, such as museums but also in the living culture, such as language, customs and gastronomy.
Some indications that cultural tourists like to use cultural consumption as a form of distinction. They have developed a cultural capital mainly through education, and like to indulge it at galleries, museums and events.
But this is also true with those who have interest in sub-cultures, niches or neo-tribes of people - who cluster together because of their mutual interest – just like at the Elvis Festival in Parkes where 20,000 people gather to celebrate all things Elvis. Or Cooly Rocks where 50,000 rock’n’roll dancers are absorbed in their own social world and celebrate all things from the 1950’s.
This is happening with all types of leisure that consumers are more fragmented into distinct smaller groups. Visiting such cultural attractions is primarily an opportunity to learn and experience new things, but there is evidence that other aspects of the experience MOTIVATE cultural tourists.
Through our own research we have found that there are 4 primary groups of people or segments which attend cultural tourists attractions – including galleries. Each segment is seeking different things from the Gallery – different levels of experience, from a deep and engaging experience to a social visit to a new attraction.
The touring holiday – or road trip
Touring holidays or as we call it in Australia the road trip make up 40% of travel to regional NSW
Discovery - seeing national parks and galleries and museums and beaches.
The Gallery is discovered on the way – not really a reason to visit this town.
We know that international tourists in particular are looking for galleries to reflect and represent the landscape and people of the region that the gallery is in – often in the local collection. Whereas locals are more interested in the touring exhibitions.
Visiting Frank and Rose (VFR)
VFR makes up 37% of travel to regional NSW
Aunty Rose makes very important recommendations and collaborates on the itinerary, which will also no doubt include visiting the other 5 attractions in town and the RSL club.
The Gallery is a part of the reasons to travel to this town. It may or may not be stimulating them to travel to that region.
Seeing the exhibition/artist
Primary reason to travel to this town.
It may be on a list of many – or a refined list which specialises in one area/type of artist
These visitors will travel a long way to achieve this goal.
Restoration/escape
Experiences at galleries provide a place to facilitate recovery from fatigue and stress
Just as natural environments promote peace it is shown that art galleries can provide this too.
Provide restorative energy
Segments are not static – people go through stages in life where they may be a part of any one of these segments or part of two or more. The more we know about these segments, the more we can tailor the delivery of experiences, information and marketing.
However there is one more important segment that provides enormous benefit for cultural tourism ...your local community
Back to Visiting Frank and Rose - If VFR travel is providing xx% of visitors to your region it is vitally important that regional galleries are high in the minds of local community.
Communication portal – Frank and Rose will distribute information for you to their visitors – as well as tell you what people really think is going on
local residents are often proud of the Gallery and what it has to offer Our research at Tweed and Lismore galleries showed that locals return an average of 4 times a year.
It is vital to embrace their interest with newsletters, emails and friends of the gallery programs – I believe the Tweed Gallery has over 1800 friends of the Gallery.
Local newspapers are still a vital point of communication to both locals and visitors, and that promotion extends into other regions through word of mouth.
Local media
Our research at Tweed Regional Gallery found that committed locals will come four times a year.
Another way to examine the segment sin cultural tourism is to think of visitors along a spectrum of art interests – where people gain more experience, skills and knowledge as they progress. From one end of the spectrum with little interest in cultural tourism and art, to those at the other end with a fanatical interest in art or a specific art form or even a specific artist.
Research suggests that people can progress along the spectrum, starting with a casual interest and over time becoming more fixated with seeking experiences and items.
The socialiser has come to the gallery seeking
A social experience
Atmosphere
Escape
That fills them with Awe
Provides Interaction with guides, other visitors, nice bit if cake from the café
Further along the spectrum is the dabbler
Who has a little interest in art – among other things – perhaps as a new hobby
Interested in learning more, from guides and workshops
New places – but not really as a specialist traveller
The enthusiast has high level of knowledge and skill and is Seeking
Special exhibits
Authenticity
New places
Merchandise
New information
The fanatic has a very high level of knowledge and skill and is a little
Obsessive about their interest – an artist, an art form an are of art.
They are the Expert -
Seek rare items for their own collection – sometimes resembles a religious altar
Elite high quality experiences
Share knowledge and experiences on Web forums and social media.
Understanding the segments of cultural tourists also helps us to examine their spending patterns and enables us to target more high yield visitors. We know for example that those segments that are coming to see major exhibitions will provide high attendance and high expenditure for a short period, such as the incredible $16 million brought in to the Bendigo economy from the Grace Kelly exhibition.
But equally we know that a steady one-third of our business comes from VFR travel, and that day trippers also provide a steady line of lower yield visitors throughout the year.
Visitor surveys are a crucial tool to help us work out the reason visitors are coming, and the amount they will spend while they are here. Research we have done over the past year at galleries here in the Tweed Valley and in Lismore has shown that the ratio of local and tourist audiences vary considerably, as they would at many regional towns in NSW and so it is increasingly important to gather local data from visitors as they come through the Gallery.
Understanding the ratios of day visitors and their average expenditure is the first crucial step to estimating the economic impact of visitors to the Gallery.
In a very simple format these are the crucial questions that need to be answered.
1. Are visitors from over 50kms away? This qualifies them as a tourist and not a local
2. IS this a day visit or longer ? – how many nights
3. What is the per person, per day expenditure
4. What is the main purpose of visit to the town?
The surveys often are more complex than this, but with these basic questions, and a basic count of visitors as they come through the door, it is possible to estimate the value of visitation to the local economy.
Clearly the main economic impact of art galleries to the local economy is their ability to attract visitors to the region.
However it is important to realise the economic value of a gallery to the local economy results from development of more than just visitors to the gallery.
There are at least 5 areas of general activity which can be developed and monitored by Gallery managers – (and possibly more through value added activities).
The five areas are
ticketed exhibitions which provide direct revenue to venues
visitation from tourists who are attracted by arts venues or activities also spend money in the local town and region
significant donations and bequests of valuable art and cultural material
sponsorship and funding from partners outside the region
volunteer hours donated to cultural venues contribute to the regions' economy
The combination of these factors makes up the total economic value of the Gallery, and these are the areas in which you can develop arguments in funding applications. Basically in any economic assessment you are looking to document the “new money” that comes in to the town as a result of Gallery activities. This will vary considerable from Gallery to Gallery and town to town.
However this total still underestimates the immeasurable social and cultural value that the Gallery can bring to the local region in celebrating and presenting art to the region.
What we know
We know that the huge diversity in leisure experiences provides a competitive playground for cultural tourists to pick and choose from. From cultural events, festivals, small galleries, museums and historic buildings. This is turn provides a competitive cultural tourism environment for organisations to attract visitors.
We know that there are Segments and stages of gallery visitors, and that at any one time there will be different types of cultural tourists in the gallery seeking different levels of experience.
We know we need to look after Frank and Rose, who are proud of their galleries and will bring visitors with them.
We know that galleries can generate substantial new economic activity in regional areas and that we can substantiate much of that activity.
What we’d like to know.
Is how do people makes decisions about visiting the gallery? – Is it Social media, the internet? visitor guides. TV Publicity? Films? And web forums?
How do tourists know about MONA? - opened in 2011 it attracted 330,000 visitors last year. Is it the art? Is it the location?
Regional galleries have opportunities to meet and INCREASE the demand for cultural tourism, but also to contribute to the ongoing cultural development of the region.
May have left you with more questions than answers – I hope so.
Please feel free to see me if you need more information or
Copies of government reports
Recommended reading
On-site research
Coffee and a chat