SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 42
Pilot descriptive study of
midwifery centers in LMIC
JENNIFER STEVENS DRPHC, CNM, MS
5
The midwife you want to be….
6
Are you able to practice as the midwife
you want to be at work?
If you could design your our birth space to work in,
what would it look like?
Who would be the focus?
How would you make that happen?
How would you feel working there, with no barriers to
being a midwife?
7
A midwifery center
8
DEFINING A MIDWIFERY CENTER
9
A health care facility serving women through their life course
Rooted in the midwifery philosophy and model of care
In a home-like shared space
Ensuring basic emergency maternal and neonatal care for all births
Integrated within the health care system
Responsive to needs of its community
With the woman's experience at its heart and center
The physical place for the practice of midwifery
fits into global QoC framework
A MIDWIFERY CENTER IS:
Mutually
beneficial
relationship
Mutually
beneficial
relationship
this could be a problem in LMIC
MODEL PLACE PROVIDER & PATIENT
Over 100 in 56 countries have been networked where we focused…
DATABASE: MIDWIFERY CENTERS
EVERYWHERE
Are they safe?
MIDWIFERY CENTERS IN LMIC
16
Problems with facility based birth in low and middle income
countries (LMIC) (Bohren, M. et al, 2014) MDG and SDGs.
◦Distance to facility
◦Cost of delivery
◦Low QoC and fear of discrimination
◦Birth too medicalized and
dehumanized
Where are the MC globally?
FACILITY BASED BIRTH IN LMIC
17
How does a MBC function in LMIC?
What do they do?
Is the care provided safe?
Is the experiences of care high quality?
Is it a viable options in a low resource health care
system?
RESEARCH PROJECT QUESTIONS
Data was collected on:
• 25 MLBC in 10 low and middle income
countries surveyed, 21 used (3 no births yet)
• Total of 3,549 births including transfers
IRB H-35803 Boston University
PILOT DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS OF MIDWIFERY
CENTER MODEL
Haiti (5)
Uganda
Sierra Leone
Cambodia (2)
South Africa
Peru (2)
Trinidad
Ecuador
Mexico (6)
Midwifery centers in LMIC
what's the environment like there?
PARTICIPATING MIDWIFERY CENTERS IN LMIC
Bangladesh
20
PILOT DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS OF MIDWIFERY
CENTER MODEL
Birth centers surveyed Maternal
mortality ratio
per 100,000
Infant
Mortality per
1,000
#of births in 2016 at
MLBC (total
w/transfers)
1 in Sierra Leone 1,360 87 40
5 (+1) in Haiti 359 52 2,151
1 in Uganda 343 38 293
1 (+2) in Bangladesh 176 31 7 (just opening)
2 in Cambodia 161 25 573
1 in South Africa 138 34 99
2 in Peru 68 13 104
1 in Trinidad 63 13 59
1 Ecuador 64 18 23
6 in Mexico 38 11 200
total: 25 MLBC surveyed, 21
used (3 no births yet, 1 w/7)
3,549
Current MMR and IMR from:
https://data.unicef.org/topic/maternal-
health/maternal-mortality/
measuring quality and MW model in low resource areas
21
Safety: Sustainable: Satisfying:
1. BeMONC 1. Provider to volume ratio 1. Respectful care
2. Health outcome data 2. Management model 2. Quality of care
3. Transfers 3. Staff Education
INDICATORS
Safety
22
neonatal
mortality
3.5*
per 1,000
live births
maternal
mortality
105*
per 100,000
live births
Neonatal mortality
Surveys recorded 10 infant deaths in previous year.
80% had been transferred and died at the transfer facility.
Maternal mortality
There were 3 maternal deaths (2 in Haiti, 1 in Uganda) in the previous year.
All involved patients who were transferred and died at the transfer facility.
*n = 3,549 survey births
Safety measures:
1. BEmONC signal functions-
2. Outcome data
3. Transfer Relationship-
70% of BEmONC criteria met
25 min average- wide range
PROVISION OF CARE- SAFETY
BEmONC
23
transfers
"sometimes is goes fine,
sometimes it doesn't. Hospital
has no phone." "not a very
good site, very subpart care, but
patients can afford it"
"sometimes the hospital is full"
"They insist advanced payment,
poor treatment, disrespect and
abuse." "Not a lot of confidence
in QoC, although outcomes
have been ok so far."- Haiti
"Sometime difficult to speak
to OBs or new hospital
directors, leadership changes
and we have to start over.
We have been here for 21
years." - Peru
"In public hospital we can accompany the
women to the C/S room, not in private",
"When we transfer for FTP, the maternity
hospital is further, but relationship is
poor", "Depends on the docs present.
Some argue with MW, some request birth
info" "Continuity of care is interrupted,
personnel don’t listen to women or
clinical hx from MW. There is obstetrical
violence and disrespect for MW work.:"
- Mexico
"QoC at hospital no
the best- sometimes
they have no power,
sometimes the
surgeon is not
there."- Uganda
Much better (was
bad). They don’t
think the birth
center should do
primes. Not
supportive of
OOH" - Trinidad
Country (#of
MC)
# of
births
Admin
structure
IV
antibiotics
IV anti-
convulsants
IV
uterotonics
Removal of
retained
POC by
manual
vacuum
Assisted
Vaginal
delivery
(VAVD)
Manual
removal of
placenta
Resuscitation
of newborn
Haiti (5) n=2,151
NGO (4),
public (1) part yes yes part part yes yes
Mexico (6) n=200
NGO (3),
Priv (3) part part yes part part part yes
Cambodia (2) n=573 public (2) no no yes yes yes yes yes
Peru (2) n=104 priv (2) no part yes no no part yes
Ecuador n=23 priv yes yes yes yes no yes yes
Sierra L n=40 NGO yes yes yes yes no yes yes
South Africa n=99 priv no no yes no yes yes yes
Trinidad n=59 NGO no yes yes no no yes yes
Uganda n=293 NGO yes no yes no no yes yes
Key: No no
part part
yes yes
BeMONC criteria met in midwifery center by country
Summary Don’t forget about the country context
25
BEmONC criteria: Haitian hospital/MC Ugandan MC S Africa SL
1. Parenteral antibiotics 80%/ 67% yes NO YES
2. Parenteral anticonvulsants 69.2%/ 71% NO NO yes
3. Parenteral uterotonics 87%/ 100% yes yes yes
4. Removal of retained POC by MVA 55.8%/ 54% NO NO yes
5. Assisted vaginal delivery (ie VAVD) 13.3%/ 54% NO yes NO
6. Manual removal of the placenta 52.5%/ 87% yes yes yes
7. Resuscitation of the newborn 50.8%/ 100% yes yes yes
Sustainable?
BEMONC: HOW DO THE MIDWIFERY CENTERS
COMPARE TO COUNTRY DATA?
26
Sustainability measures:
1. Staff to volume ratio and transfer numbers
2. Management model
3. Staff education
Primary sources
of funding
37%- NGO
32% NGO/Patient fees
16% Patient Fees
10% Public
5%- Public/NGO
Education of staff n=71
26%= NMW
26%= nurse
19%= MW
17%= SBA
7%= MW aux
3%=EMT
2%=TBA
Average
50
births per
provider/year
PROVISION OF CARE- SUSTAINABLE
midwifery training
27
Traditional birth attendant- informal, experience, no degree, no license
Skilled birth attendant- trained formally, no license or degree
Nurse- college degree, OB experience
Auxiliary Midwife- min 3 yrs basic training
Midwife- min 3 yrs basic training and licensed
Nurse Midwife- degree and licensed
additionally found: OBs, EMT
EDUCATION OF STAFF
experience of care
28
100% of Newborn Care measures met by MC
84% of Quality of care measures met by MC
88% of Respectful maternity care measures met by MC
Experience of care/Quality measures:
1.Respectful maternity care (RMC) (based on Landscape)
2.Quality of care (QoC)
EXPERIENCE OF CARE- SATISFYING
RMC
1.PolicyforRMC
2.Supportpeopleencouragedtobe
present
3.Processforfeedback/complaints
availableandposted
4.Staffintroducethemselves
5.Infoaboutbirthprocessand
breastfeedingprovided
6.Modestyprotectedwithgowns/sheets
offeredfree
7.Informedconsentdocumented
8.Informedrefusaldocumented
9.Culturallytraditionalpracticesare
encouragedifsafe
10.Nonemergencyproceduresexplained
priortoadministered
11.Updatesonlaborstatusprovidedto
woman
12.Privacyofcareprotectedbyseparate
birthroomsorcurtains
13.Policytoprotectwoman'spersonal
medicalinfounlesspermissionprovided
14.Policyfornoabuse(physical,emotional,
hitting,restraintsetc.)
15.Handsoncomfortoffered
16.Midwifestaysphysicallypresent
17.Nonsupinedeliverypositions
encouraged
18.SkintoSkin
19.Mother/babyneverseparated
20.Newbornbreastfeedingwithinfirsthour
Haiti (5) part yes part yes yes part part part yes yes yes part yes yes part part part yes yes yes
Mexico (6) yes yes part yes yes part yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Cambodia (2) yes no yes yes yes part no yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Peru (2) yes yes part yes yes yes yes yes yes part part yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Ecuador yes yes yes yes yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Sierra Leone no yes no yes yes yes no no yes yes yes no yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes
South Africa no yes yes yes yes yes no yes yes yes yes no yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes
Trinidad no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Uganda yes yes yes yes yes no no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
KEY: No
partial
Yes
Respectful care measures met in midwifery centers
Respectful care measures based on midwifery model of care,
WRA and Bowser & Hill (2010) landscape analysis of disrespect and abuse.
Summary QoC in MC
Country
(# of MC)
Staff trained
at continual
risk
assessment
during
labor?
Staff have
regular
emergency
drills?
Partograph
used with
every
birth?
Process for
tracking
admission
time for
every
women?
Process
for
tracking
birth time
for each
woman?
Process for
tracking
discharge/
transfer time
for every
woman?
Transport
to
CEmONC
arranged
Haiti (5) yes part part part yes yes yes
Mexico (6) yes part part yes yes yes yes
Cambodia (2) yes part part yes yes yes yes
Peru (2) yes yes part yes yes yes yes
Ecuador yes yes no yes yes yes yes
Sierra L yes no no no yes no no
South Africa yes no yes yes yes yes yes
Trinidad yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Uganda yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Key: No no
part part
yes yes
Quality of care criteria met in midwifery center by country
Quality criteria specifically for midwifery
centers in low resources areas.
Summary Looking forward- How can they strengthen a system?
32
Health care workforce shortage:
◦ Utilizing appropriate provider for appropriate level of care needed.
Health care facility shortage, and cost effective:
◦ Utilizing appropriate level of facility for level of care needed
Bridging home and hospital:
◦ Providing optimal care experience
◦ Improving access and quality with an integrated health care system
Bridging professions:
◦ OB-Pediatrician-Midwife-Auxiliary-community workers- meeting women's and system's needs with
collaboration
MIDWIFERY LED BIRTH CENTERS STRENGTHEN:
future research
34
Contributing Midwifery Birth Centers
Sierre Leone: Taiama Birth Center (n=40)
South Africa: Midwives Exclusive (n=99)
Ghana: Sampa Birth Center (to open)
Uganda: Shanti Uganda (n=293)
Trinidad: Mama Toto (n=59)
Peru: Pakarii Case de Nacimiento (n=104)
Ecuador: Dulce Espera (n=23)
Mexico: Casa Colobri, Luna Maya DF, Luna Maya Chiapas (n=200)
Haiti: Northwest Haiti Christian Mission, Carmelle Voltaire Women's HC, Sante Place Cazeau ("Smile Clinic"),
Maison de Naissance, Olive Tree projects, Carrie Wortham BC, (n=2,151)
Bangladesh: (Hope): Pockhali BC, Khunia Palong BC, Islampur BC, Bharuakhali BC (just opening) (n=7)
Cambodia: Thmar Krae Community BC, Sandan Community BC (Samaritan purse) (n=573)
35
Merci!!!.......Thank you!
Contact:
Jennifer Stevens DrPHc CNM MS
Jen@goodbirth.net
Boston University
Slides available at: https://www.slideshare.net/secret/iZfAR43DNMm3Q5
DISCUSSION
RMC QoC
Country
(#of MC)
# of births at
MBC in 2016
(total
w/transfers)
BeMONC
criteria
met
RMC
criteria
met
QoC
criteria
met
Maternal
deaths
Newborn
deaths
Transfers
# IP, PP,
NB (%)
Haiti (5) 1,833 (2,151) 89% 86% 83% 2(tx site) 7 (tx site) 318 (15%)
Mexico (6) 157 (200) 69% 97% 86% 0 1 43 (22%)
Cambodia (2) 428 (573) 71% 84% 79% 0 2 (MC) 145 (25%)
Peru (2) 84 (104) 43% 93% 93% 0 0 20 (19%)
Ecuador 20 (23) 86% 95% 86% 0 0 3 (13%)
Sierra L 40 (40) 71% 67% 29% 0 0 0
South Africa 93 (99) 57% 86% 86% 0 0 6 (6%)
Trinidad 48 (59) 57% 95% 100% 0 0 11 (19%)
Uganda 275 (293) 57% 90% 100% 1 (tx site) 0 18 (6%)
2,978 (3,542) 70% 88%% 84% 3 10 564 (16%)
Summary of study data by country
BeMONC Haiti Mexico Cambodia Peru Ecuador Sierra L South Africa Trinidad Uganda
Country
(#of MC)
# of births at
MBC in 2016
(total
w/transfers)
Transfers #
IP, PP, NB
(%)
Transfer
time # FTE
#births/
provider
/year
Maternal
deaths
Newborn
deaths
Haiti (5) 1,833 (2,151) 318 (15%) 50 22 98 2(tx site) 7 (tx site)
Mexico (6) 157 (200) 43 (22%) 15 13 15 0 1
Cambodia (2) 428 (573) 145 (25%) 60 16 36 0 2 (MC)
Peru (2) 84 (104) 20 (19%) 15 3 35 0 0
Ecuador 20 (23) 3 (13%) 10 2 12 0 0
Sierra L 40 (40) 0 45 2 20 0 0
South Africa 93 (99) 6 (6%) 4 5 20 0 0
Trinidad 48 (59) 11 (19%) 5 2 30 0 0
Uganda 275 (293) 18 (6%) 10 5 56 1 (tx site) 0
2,978 (3,542) 564 (16%) 24 71 50 3 10
30
Median
Outcome data by country
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016
at MBC
(total w/ transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early Infant
deaths
5 Haiti 359/52 1,833 (2,151) 318 (15%) 89% 86% 83% 22 2 (tx site) 7(tx site)
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Haiti
SummaryCharges: $6, $20, $60, $60,$100 SBA, MWaux, nMW, 10-60min
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016
at MBC
(total w/ transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early Infant
deaths
6 Mexico 38/11 157 (200) 43 (22%) 69% 97% 86% 13 0 1(tx site)
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Mexico
SummaryCharges: $200, 350, 650, 650, 950 MW, aux MW, nMW, SBA, 15min
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016
at MBC
(total w/ transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early
Infant
deaths
2 Cambodia 161/25 428 (573) 145 (25%) 71% 84% 79% 16 0 2
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Cambodia
Summary$12 USD, SBA, nsg, MW, nurseMW, 1hr
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016
at MBC
(total w/ transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early Infant
deaths
2 Peru 68/13 84 (104) 20 (19%) 43% 93% 93% 3 0 0
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Peru
SummaryCharges: $900USD- $1,070 MW, Obs, 5min,
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in
2016 at MBC
(total w/
transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early
Infant
deaths
1 Ecuador 64/18 23 3 (13%) 86% 95% 86% 2 0 0
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Ecuador
Summary$1,400 USD MW, MW aux, 10-15 min to hosp
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016
at MBC
(total w/
transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early
Infant
deaths
1
Sierra
Leone 1360/87 40 0 71% 67% 29% 2 0 0
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Sierra Leone
Summary$10USD TBA, nsg, nMW, 45min,
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016 at
MBC
(total w/ transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early Infant
deaths
1 South Africa 138/34 99 6 (6%) 57% 86% 86% 5 0 0
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
South Africa
Summary$1080 USD 4min,
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016
at MBC
(total w/ transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early Infant
deaths
1 Trinidad 63/13 59 11 (19%) 57% 95% 100% 2 0 0
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Trinidad
Summary$2,300USD auxMW, MW, nMW, 5min
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in 2016
at MBC
(total w/ transfers)
Transfers- IP,
PP, NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early NB
deaths
1 Uganda 343/38 293 18 (6%) 57% 90% 100% 5 1 (tx site) 0
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Uganda
Summary$2USD, MW, auxMW, TBA, 10min
# of MBC
surveyed Country
2015
MMR*/
IMR*
# of births in
2016 at MBC
(total w/
transfers)
Transfers- IP, PP,
NB (%
transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE
Maternal
deaths
Early Infant
deaths
1 Bangladesh 176/31 7 0 100% 90% 100% 1 0 0
21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10
Bangladesh (not included in summary data)
Summary$12 USD MW, 1 hr
48
References
Bohren et al. Facilitators and barriers to facility-based birth in low-and middle- income countries: a qualitative evidence synthesis. Reproductive Health 2014, 11:71.
Bowser, D., Hill, K., (2010) Exploring evidence for disrespect and abuse in facility-based childbirth. Report of a landscape analysis. USAID-TRAction Project. Harvard
School of Public Health. University research Co., LLC. Available from: https://www.ghdonline.org/uploads/Respectful_Care_at_Birth_9-20-101_Final1.pdf
Feldstein, A., Glasgow, R. (2008) A practical, robust implementation and sustainability model (PRISM) for integrating research findings into practice. The joint commission
journal on quality and patient safety. April 2008; 34,4.
Garfield, R., Berrymen, E. (2012). Nursing and nursing education in Haiti.[Internet] Nursing Outlook 60(2012) 16-20. Available from:
http://www.nursingoutlook.org/article/S0029-6554(11)00093-5/pdf
Jerome, J., Ivers, LC.(2011) Community health workers in health systems strengthening: a qualitative evaluation from rural Haiti. [Internet] AIDS. 2010 Jan; 24 (suppl 1);
S67-S72. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3169202/pdf/nihms180962.pdf
Koski-Karell, V., et al. (2016). Haiti's progress in achieving its 10-year plan to eliminate cholera: hidden sickness cannot be cured. Risk management and healthcare
polity. 2016:9; 87-100. Available from: https://www.dovepress.com/haiti39s-progress-in-achieving-its-10-year-plan-to-eliminate-cholera-h-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-
RMHP
Le Nouvelliste. 50% des sages-femmes formees en Haiti exercent leur profession a l’etranger. [Internet]. Haiti. 2017-08-09. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Available from:
http://www.lenouvelliste.com/article/174626/50-des-sages-femmes-formees-en-haiti-exercent-leur-profession-a-letranger
Martineau.(2016) Quel avenir pour la profession d’infirmiere en Haiti? [Internet]. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Availble from: http://www.lescacosnoirs.com/quel-avenir-pour-la-
profession-dinfirmiere-en-haiti/
Moloney, A. (2013). Haiti’s new generation of doctors hope to revive ailing health sector, rebuild country. [Internet]. England, Wales. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Availble from:
https://www.pih.org/media-coverage/reuters-haitis-new-generation-of-doctors-hope-to-revive-ailing-health-secto
49
References (cont)
Monroe College. Health care in Haiti. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Available from: https://www.monroecollege.edu/uploadedFiles/_Site_Assets/PDF/Health_Care_in_Haiti.pdf
Mullan, F. (2005). The metrics of physician brain drain. New England Journal of Medicine 2005;353,1810-8.
Partners in Health (2013). Accompagnateur training guide. [Internet] Partners in health. ACME Books Inc. 2011. Available at: https://www.pih.org/sites/default/files/2017-
07/Accompagnatuer_FM_Haiti_English.pdf
Restavek Freedom. (2017). Haiti’s colleges and universities. [Internet] Restavek Freedom. Available from: https://restavekfreedom.org/2017/07/28/haitis-colleges-
universities/
TB/HaitiLibre. Häiti-Formation: Moins de 4% de étudiants es soins infirmiers, ont réussi examen d’État. [Internet] 13/03/2017. Haiti Libre.[cited Feb 7, 2018] Available from:
http://www.haitilibre.com/article-20348-haiti-formation-moins-de-4-des-etudiants-en-soins-infirmiers-ont-reussi-l-examen-d-etat.html
UNFPA. (2017). Midwives offer care, dignity and a lifeline for Haiti’s mothers. [Internet]. UNFPA. 2017 4 May. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Availble from:
https://www.unfpa.org/news/midwives-offer-care-dignity-and-lifeline-haitis-mothers?page=4
USAID, Global Health Workforce Alliance, WHO (2018). Human resources for health action framework. [Internet]. Geneva. [Cited: Feb 18, 2018] Available from:
https://www.capacityproject.org/framework/
WHO. (2006). Working together for health. The world health report 2006.[Internet] WHO. Geneva. Available from: http://www.who.int/whr/2006/whr06_en.pdf?ua=1
WHO. Global experience of community health workers for delivery of health related millennium development goals. [Internet] Available from:
http://www.who.int/workforcealliance/knowledge/publications/alliance/Global_CHW_web.pdf
50
Acknowledgements
AABC Foundation
Boston University
Cris Alonso
Rebecca Barlow
Gene Declercq
Cynthia Ingar
Anam Mohmood
Jack Resnik
Leslie Toledo
Stan Shaffer

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Ppt on expanded role of nurse
Ppt on expanded role of nursePpt on expanded role of nurse
Ppt on expanded role of nurse
Nursing Path
 
Why Midwifery? Childbirth Choices
Why Midwifery? Childbirth ChoicesWhy Midwifery? Childbirth Choices
Why Midwifery? Childbirth Choices
kristilynne84
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Maternal and Child Health Care Nursing
Maternal and Child Health Care NursingMaternal and Child Health Care Nursing
Maternal and Child Health Care Nursing
 
Midwifery Presentation by Triangle Midwives
Midwifery Presentation by Triangle MidwivesMidwifery Presentation by Triangle Midwives
Midwifery Presentation by Triangle Midwives
 
Vital statistics related to maternal health in india
Vital statistics related to maternal health in indiaVital statistics related to maternal health in india
Vital statistics related to maternal health in india
 
Professional governance, midwifery 2013
Professional governance, midwifery  2013Professional governance, midwifery  2013
Professional governance, midwifery 2013
 
Midwives 4 mothers
Midwives 4 mothersMidwives 4 mothers
Midwives 4 mothers
 
Role of midwife and independent nurse midwifery practitioner
Role of midwife and independent nurse midwifery practitionerRole of midwife and independent nurse midwifery practitioner
Role of midwife and independent nurse midwifery practitioner
 
Preventive obstetrics
Preventive obstetricsPreventive obstetrics
Preventive obstetrics
 
Nurse midwives
Nurse midwivesNurse midwives
Nurse midwives
 
Menopausal counseling
Menopausal counselingMenopausal counseling
Menopausal counseling
 
MCH SERVICES
MCH SERVICESMCH SERVICES
MCH SERVICES
 
Ppt on expanded role of nurse
Ppt on expanded role of nursePpt on expanded role of nurse
Ppt on expanded role of nurse
 
Why Midwifery? Childbirth Choices
Why Midwifery? Childbirth ChoicesWhy Midwifery? Childbirth Choices
Why Midwifery? Childbirth Choices
 
Role of nurse midwifery and obstetric care
Role of nurse midwifery and obstetric careRole of nurse midwifery and obstetric care
Role of nurse midwifery and obstetric care
 
Public private partnership in safemotherhood program in Nepal
Public private partnership in safemotherhood program in NepalPublic private partnership in safemotherhood program in Nepal
Public private partnership in safemotherhood program in Nepal
 
Maternal and child health program
Maternal and child health programMaternal and child health program
Maternal and child health program
 
Mother and Baby Friendly Care: Mother friendly care during pregnancy
Mother and Baby Friendly Care: Mother friendly care during pregnancyMother and Baby Friendly Care: Mother friendly care during pregnancy
Mother and Baby Friendly Care: Mother friendly care during pregnancy
 
Maternal and child health care services
Maternal and child health care servicesMaternal and child health care services
Maternal and child health care services
 
Birth compagin
Birth compaginBirth compagin
Birth compagin
 
The Safeguarding Role of the Midwife
The Safeguarding Role of the MidwifeThe Safeguarding Role of the Midwife
The Safeguarding Role of the Midwife
 
Area of Focus: Maternal and Child Health
Area of Focus: Maternal and Child HealthArea of Focus: Maternal and Child Health
Area of Focus: Maternal and Child Health
 

Ähnlich wie Midwifery Centers

Adherence to PMTCT: Plenary
Adherence to PMTCT: PlenaryAdherence to PMTCT: Plenary
Adherence to PMTCT: Plenary
icapclinical
 
Addressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser Presentation
Addressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser PresentationAddressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser Presentation
Addressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser Presentation
mothers2mothers
 
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptxMaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
ssuserc3e4e81
 
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptxMaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
ssuserc3e4e81
 
General practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forward
General practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forwardGeneral practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forward
General practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forward
arbin joshi
 
The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...
The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...
The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...
HopkinsCFAR
 

Ähnlich wie Midwifery Centers (20)

Midwifery Centers in LMIC: Evidence, quality and standards
Midwifery Centers in LMIC: Evidence, quality and standardsMidwifery Centers in LMIC: Evidence, quality and standards
Midwifery Centers in LMIC: Evidence, quality and standards
 
Adherence to PMTCT: Plenary
Adherence to PMTCT: PlenaryAdherence to PMTCT: Plenary
Adherence to PMTCT: Plenary
 
Addressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser Presentation
Addressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser PresentationAddressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser Presentation
Addressing the Gaps in PMTCT Care - A Dr Besser Presentation
 
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
 
Multifoetal reduction in Infertility
Multifoetal reduction in InfertilityMultifoetal reduction in Infertility
Multifoetal reduction in Infertility
 
Mwebesa abwao newborn_health
Mwebesa abwao newborn_healthMwebesa abwao newborn_health
Mwebesa abwao newborn_health
 
Roll out of More Efficacious PMTCT Regimens: Lesotho's National Approach
Roll out of More Efficacious PMTCT Regimens: Lesotho's National ApproachRoll out of More Efficacious PMTCT Regimens: Lesotho's National Approach
Roll out of More Efficacious PMTCT Regimens: Lesotho's National Approach
 
RMNCH+A 5 x 5 matrix
RMNCH+A 5 x 5 matrixRMNCH+A 5 x 5 matrix
RMNCH+A 5 x 5 matrix
 
Focused antenatal and emergecy obstetric care
Focused antenatal and emergecy obstetric careFocused antenatal and emergecy obstetric care
Focused antenatal and emergecy obstetric care
 
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptxMaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
 
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptxMaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
MaternityCareWorkforce-11-18-15.pptx
 
General practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forward
General practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forwardGeneral practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forward
General practitioner and obstetric service in rural Nepal A way forward
 
Women's Access to Healthcare - Adrienne Zertuche Presentation
Women's Access to Healthcare - Adrienne Zertuche PresentationWomen's Access to Healthcare - Adrienne Zertuche Presentation
Women's Access to Healthcare - Adrienne Zertuche Presentation
 
Nbs manual 28-6-2015
Nbs manual 28-6-2015 Nbs manual 28-6-2015
Nbs manual 28-6-2015
 
Nbs manual 28-6-2015
Nbs manual 28-6-2015 Nbs manual 28-6-2015
Nbs manual 28-6-2015
 
Normal and abnormal delivery Dr Falakha
Normal and abnormal delivery Dr FalakhaNormal and abnormal delivery Dr Falakha
Normal and abnormal delivery Dr Falakha
 
AHRQ POSTER
AHRQ POSTER AHRQ POSTER
AHRQ POSTER
 
The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...
The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...
The journey towards making elimination of mother to child transmission a real...
 
Reducing cesarean section rate. a national demand
Reducing cesarean section rate. a national demandReducing cesarean section rate. a national demand
Reducing cesarean section rate. a national demand
 
Implementation of psbi activities in kenya where are we now (30.4.2019)
Implementation of psbi activities in kenya   where are we now (30.4.2019)Implementation of psbi activities in kenya   where are we now (30.4.2019)
Implementation of psbi activities in kenya where are we now (30.4.2019)
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...
🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...
🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...
Call Girls In Delhi Whatsup 9873940964 Enjoy Unlimited Pleasure
 
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
Sheetaleventcompany
 
Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...
Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...
Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...
adilkhan87451
 
Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝 9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝  9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝  9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝 9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7
9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
adilkhan87451
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...
🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...
🌹Attapur⬅️ Vip Call Girls Hyderabad 📱9352852248 Book Well Trand Call Girls In...
 
Call Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
 
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
 
Coimbatore Call Girls in Coimbatore 7427069034 genuine Escort Service Girl 10...
Coimbatore Call Girls in Coimbatore 7427069034 genuine Escort Service Girl 10...Coimbatore Call Girls in Coimbatore 7427069034 genuine Escort Service Girl 10...
Coimbatore Call Girls in Coimbatore 7427069034 genuine Escort Service Girl 10...
 
Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...
Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...
Russian Call Girls Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service...
 
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
 
Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝 9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝  9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝  9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in Gagan Vihar (delhi) call me [🔝 9953056974 🔝] escort service 24X7
 
Kollam call girls Mallu aunty service 7877702510
Kollam call girls Mallu aunty service 7877702510Kollam call girls Mallu aunty service 7877702510
Kollam call girls Mallu aunty service 7877702510
 
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Coimbatore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Most Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on Whatsapp
Most Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on WhatsappMost Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on Whatsapp
Most Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on Whatsapp
 
Saket * Call Girls in Delhi - Phone 9711199012 Escorts Service at 6k to 50k a...
Saket * Call Girls in Delhi - Phone 9711199012 Escorts Service at 6k to 50k a...Saket * Call Girls in Delhi - Phone 9711199012 Escorts Service at 6k to 50k a...
Saket * Call Girls in Delhi - Phone 9711199012 Escorts Service at 6k to 50k a...
 
Call Girls Ahmedabad Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ahmedabad Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ahmedabad Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ahmedabad Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Madurai Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Madurai Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Madurai Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Madurai Just Call 9630942363 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
 
Call Girls Jaipur Just Call 9521753030 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Jaipur Just Call 9521753030 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Jaipur Just Call 9521753030 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Jaipur Just Call 9521753030 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Coimbatore Call Girls in Thudiyalur : 7427069034 High Profile Model Escorts |...
Coimbatore Call Girls in Thudiyalur : 7427069034 High Profile Model Escorts |...Coimbatore Call Girls in Thudiyalur : 7427069034 High Profile Model Escorts |...
Coimbatore Call Girls in Thudiyalur : 7427069034 High Profile Model Escorts |...
 
Call Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 

Midwifery Centers

  • 1. Pilot descriptive study of midwifery centers in LMIC JENNIFER STEVENS DRPHC, CNM, MS
  • 2. 5 The midwife you want to be….
  • 3. 6 Are you able to practice as the midwife you want to be at work? If you could design your our birth space to work in, what would it look like? Who would be the focus? How would you make that happen? How would you feel working there, with no barriers to being a midwife?
  • 6. 9 A health care facility serving women through their life course Rooted in the midwifery philosophy and model of care In a home-like shared space Ensuring basic emergency maternal and neonatal care for all births Integrated within the health care system Responsive to needs of its community With the woman's experience at its heart and center The physical place for the practice of midwifery fits into global QoC framework A MIDWIFERY CENTER IS:
  • 8. Over 100 in 56 countries have been networked where we focused… DATABASE: MIDWIFERY CENTERS EVERYWHERE
  • 9. Are they safe? MIDWIFERY CENTERS IN LMIC
  • 10. 16 Problems with facility based birth in low and middle income countries (LMIC) (Bohren, M. et al, 2014) MDG and SDGs. ◦Distance to facility ◦Cost of delivery ◦Low QoC and fear of discrimination ◦Birth too medicalized and dehumanized Where are the MC globally? FACILITY BASED BIRTH IN LMIC
  • 11. 17 How does a MBC function in LMIC? What do they do? Is the care provided safe? Is the experiences of care high quality? Is it a viable options in a low resource health care system? RESEARCH PROJECT QUESTIONS
  • 12. Data was collected on: • 25 MLBC in 10 low and middle income countries surveyed, 21 used (3 no births yet) • Total of 3,549 births including transfers IRB H-35803 Boston University PILOT DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS OF MIDWIFERY CENTER MODEL
  • 13. Haiti (5) Uganda Sierra Leone Cambodia (2) South Africa Peru (2) Trinidad Ecuador Mexico (6) Midwifery centers in LMIC what's the environment like there? PARTICIPATING MIDWIFERY CENTERS IN LMIC Bangladesh
  • 14. 20 PILOT DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS OF MIDWIFERY CENTER MODEL Birth centers surveyed Maternal mortality ratio per 100,000 Infant Mortality per 1,000 #of births in 2016 at MLBC (total w/transfers) 1 in Sierra Leone 1,360 87 40 5 (+1) in Haiti 359 52 2,151 1 in Uganda 343 38 293 1 (+2) in Bangladesh 176 31 7 (just opening) 2 in Cambodia 161 25 573 1 in South Africa 138 34 99 2 in Peru 68 13 104 1 in Trinidad 63 13 59 1 Ecuador 64 18 23 6 in Mexico 38 11 200 total: 25 MLBC surveyed, 21 used (3 no births yet, 1 w/7) 3,549 Current MMR and IMR from: https://data.unicef.org/topic/maternal- health/maternal-mortality/ measuring quality and MW model in low resource areas
  • 15. 21 Safety: Sustainable: Satisfying: 1. BeMONC 1. Provider to volume ratio 1. Respectful care 2. Health outcome data 2. Management model 2. Quality of care 3. Transfers 3. Staff Education INDICATORS Safety
  • 16. 22 neonatal mortality 3.5* per 1,000 live births maternal mortality 105* per 100,000 live births Neonatal mortality Surveys recorded 10 infant deaths in previous year. 80% had been transferred and died at the transfer facility. Maternal mortality There were 3 maternal deaths (2 in Haiti, 1 in Uganda) in the previous year. All involved patients who were transferred and died at the transfer facility. *n = 3,549 survey births Safety measures: 1. BEmONC signal functions- 2. Outcome data 3. Transfer Relationship- 70% of BEmONC criteria met 25 min average- wide range PROVISION OF CARE- SAFETY BEmONC
  • 17. 23 transfers "sometimes is goes fine, sometimes it doesn't. Hospital has no phone." "not a very good site, very subpart care, but patients can afford it" "sometimes the hospital is full" "They insist advanced payment, poor treatment, disrespect and abuse." "Not a lot of confidence in QoC, although outcomes have been ok so far."- Haiti "Sometime difficult to speak to OBs or new hospital directors, leadership changes and we have to start over. We have been here for 21 years." - Peru "In public hospital we can accompany the women to the C/S room, not in private", "When we transfer for FTP, the maternity hospital is further, but relationship is poor", "Depends on the docs present. Some argue with MW, some request birth info" "Continuity of care is interrupted, personnel don’t listen to women or clinical hx from MW. There is obstetrical violence and disrespect for MW work.:" - Mexico "QoC at hospital no the best- sometimes they have no power, sometimes the surgeon is not there."- Uganda Much better (was bad). They don’t think the birth center should do primes. Not supportive of OOH" - Trinidad
  • 18. Country (#of MC) # of births Admin structure IV antibiotics IV anti- convulsants IV uterotonics Removal of retained POC by manual vacuum Assisted Vaginal delivery (VAVD) Manual removal of placenta Resuscitation of newborn Haiti (5) n=2,151 NGO (4), public (1) part yes yes part part yes yes Mexico (6) n=200 NGO (3), Priv (3) part part yes part part part yes Cambodia (2) n=573 public (2) no no yes yes yes yes yes Peru (2) n=104 priv (2) no part yes no no part yes Ecuador n=23 priv yes yes yes yes no yes yes Sierra L n=40 NGO yes yes yes yes no yes yes South Africa n=99 priv no no yes no yes yes yes Trinidad n=59 NGO no yes yes no no yes yes Uganda n=293 NGO yes no yes no no yes yes Key: No no part part yes yes BeMONC criteria met in midwifery center by country Summary Don’t forget about the country context
  • 19. 25 BEmONC criteria: Haitian hospital/MC Ugandan MC S Africa SL 1. Parenteral antibiotics 80%/ 67% yes NO YES 2. Parenteral anticonvulsants 69.2%/ 71% NO NO yes 3. Parenteral uterotonics 87%/ 100% yes yes yes 4. Removal of retained POC by MVA 55.8%/ 54% NO NO yes 5. Assisted vaginal delivery (ie VAVD) 13.3%/ 54% NO yes NO 6. Manual removal of the placenta 52.5%/ 87% yes yes yes 7. Resuscitation of the newborn 50.8%/ 100% yes yes yes Sustainable? BEMONC: HOW DO THE MIDWIFERY CENTERS COMPARE TO COUNTRY DATA?
  • 20. 26 Sustainability measures: 1. Staff to volume ratio and transfer numbers 2. Management model 3. Staff education Primary sources of funding 37%- NGO 32% NGO/Patient fees 16% Patient Fees 10% Public 5%- Public/NGO Education of staff n=71 26%= NMW 26%= nurse 19%= MW 17%= SBA 7%= MW aux 3%=EMT 2%=TBA Average 50 births per provider/year PROVISION OF CARE- SUSTAINABLE midwifery training
  • 21. 27 Traditional birth attendant- informal, experience, no degree, no license Skilled birth attendant- trained formally, no license or degree Nurse- college degree, OB experience Auxiliary Midwife- min 3 yrs basic training Midwife- min 3 yrs basic training and licensed Nurse Midwife- degree and licensed additionally found: OBs, EMT EDUCATION OF STAFF experience of care
  • 22. 28 100% of Newborn Care measures met by MC 84% of Quality of care measures met by MC 88% of Respectful maternity care measures met by MC Experience of care/Quality measures: 1.Respectful maternity care (RMC) (based on Landscape) 2.Quality of care (QoC) EXPERIENCE OF CARE- SATISFYING RMC
  • 23. 1.PolicyforRMC 2.Supportpeopleencouragedtobe present 3.Processforfeedback/complaints availableandposted 4.Staffintroducethemselves 5.Infoaboutbirthprocessand breastfeedingprovided 6.Modestyprotectedwithgowns/sheets offeredfree 7.Informedconsentdocumented 8.Informedrefusaldocumented 9.Culturallytraditionalpracticesare encouragedifsafe 10.Nonemergencyproceduresexplained priortoadministered 11.Updatesonlaborstatusprovidedto woman 12.Privacyofcareprotectedbyseparate birthroomsorcurtains 13.Policytoprotectwoman'spersonal medicalinfounlesspermissionprovided 14.Policyfornoabuse(physical,emotional, hitting,restraintsetc.) 15.Handsoncomfortoffered 16.Midwifestaysphysicallypresent 17.Nonsupinedeliverypositions encouraged 18.SkintoSkin 19.Mother/babyneverseparated 20.Newbornbreastfeedingwithinfirsthour Haiti (5) part yes part yes yes part part part yes yes yes part yes yes part part part yes yes yes Mexico (6) yes yes part yes yes part yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Cambodia (2) yes no yes yes yes part no yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Peru (2) yes yes part yes yes yes yes yes yes part part yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Ecuador yes yes yes yes yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Sierra Leone no yes no yes yes yes no no yes yes yes no yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes South Africa no yes yes yes yes yes no yes yes yes yes no yes no yes yes yes yes yes yes Trinidad no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Uganda yes yes yes yes yes no no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes KEY: No partial Yes Respectful care measures met in midwifery centers Respectful care measures based on midwifery model of care, WRA and Bowser & Hill (2010) landscape analysis of disrespect and abuse. Summary QoC in MC
  • 24. Country (# of MC) Staff trained at continual risk assessment during labor? Staff have regular emergency drills? Partograph used with every birth? Process for tracking admission time for every women? Process for tracking birth time for each woman? Process for tracking discharge/ transfer time for every woman? Transport to CEmONC arranged Haiti (5) yes part part part yes yes yes Mexico (6) yes part part yes yes yes yes Cambodia (2) yes part part yes yes yes yes Peru (2) yes yes part yes yes yes yes Ecuador yes yes no yes yes yes yes Sierra L yes no no no yes no no South Africa yes no yes yes yes yes yes Trinidad yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Uganda yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Key: No no part part yes yes Quality of care criteria met in midwifery center by country Quality criteria specifically for midwifery centers in low resources areas. Summary Looking forward- How can they strengthen a system?
  • 25. 32 Health care workforce shortage: ◦ Utilizing appropriate provider for appropriate level of care needed. Health care facility shortage, and cost effective: ◦ Utilizing appropriate level of facility for level of care needed Bridging home and hospital: ◦ Providing optimal care experience ◦ Improving access and quality with an integrated health care system Bridging professions: ◦ OB-Pediatrician-Midwife-Auxiliary-community workers- meeting women's and system's needs with collaboration MIDWIFERY LED BIRTH CENTERS STRENGTHEN: future research
  • 26. 34 Contributing Midwifery Birth Centers Sierre Leone: Taiama Birth Center (n=40) South Africa: Midwives Exclusive (n=99) Ghana: Sampa Birth Center (to open) Uganda: Shanti Uganda (n=293) Trinidad: Mama Toto (n=59) Peru: Pakarii Case de Nacimiento (n=104) Ecuador: Dulce Espera (n=23) Mexico: Casa Colobri, Luna Maya DF, Luna Maya Chiapas (n=200) Haiti: Northwest Haiti Christian Mission, Carmelle Voltaire Women's HC, Sante Place Cazeau ("Smile Clinic"), Maison de Naissance, Olive Tree projects, Carrie Wortham BC, (n=2,151) Bangladesh: (Hope): Pockhali BC, Khunia Palong BC, Islampur BC, Bharuakhali BC (just opening) (n=7) Cambodia: Thmar Krae Community BC, Sandan Community BC (Samaritan purse) (n=573)
  • 27. 35 Merci!!!.......Thank you! Contact: Jennifer Stevens DrPHc CNM MS Jen@goodbirth.net Boston University Slides available at: https://www.slideshare.net/secret/iZfAR43DNMm3Q5 DISCUSSION
  • 28. RMC QoC Country (#of MC) # of births at MBC in 2016 (total w/transfers) BeMONC criteria met RMC criteria met QoC criteria met Maternal deaths Newborn deaths Transfers # IP, PP, NB (%) Haiti (5) 1,833 (2,151) 89% 86% 83% 2(tx site) 7 (tx site) 318 (15%) Mexico (6) 157 (200) 69% 97% 86% 0 1 43 (22%) Cambodia (2) 428 (573) 71% 84% 79% 0 2 (MC) 145 (25%) Peru (2) 84 (104) 43% 93% 93% 0 0 20 (19%) Ecuador 20 (23) 86% 95% 86% 0 0 3 (13%) Sierra L 40 (40) 71% 67% 29% 0 0 0 South Africa 93 (99) 57% 86% 86% 0 0 6 (6%) Trinidad 48 (59) 57% 95% 100% 0 0 11 (19%) Uganda 275 (293) 57% 90% 100% 1 (tx site) 0 18 (6%) 2,978 (3,542) 70% 88%% 84% 3 10 564 (16%) Summary of study data by country BeMONC Haiti Mexico Cambodia Peru Ecuador Sierra L South Africa Trinidad Uganda
  • 29. Country (#of MC) # of births at MBC in 2016 (total w/transfers) Transfers # IP, PP, NB (%) Transfer time # FTE #births/ provider /year Maternal deaths Newborn deaths Haiti (5) 1,833 (2,151) 318 (15%) 50 22 98 2(tx site) 7 (tx site) Mexico (6) 157 (200) 43 (22%) 15 13 15 0 1 Cambodia (2) 428 (573) 145 (25%) 60 16 36 0 2 (MC) Peru (2) 84 (104) 20 (19%) 15 3 35 0 0 Ecuador 20 (23) 3 (13%) 10 2 12 0 0 Sierra L 40 (40) 0 45 2 20 0 0 South Africa 93 (99) 6 (6%) 4 5 20 0 0 Trinidad 48 (59) 11 (19%) 5 2 30 0 0 Uganda 275 (293) 18 (6%) 10 5 56 1 (tx site) 0 2,978 (3,542) 564 (16%) 24 71 50 3 10 30 Median Outcome data by country
  • 30. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 5 Haiti 359/52 1,833 (2,151) 318 (15%) 89% 86% 83% 22 2 (tx site) 7(tx site) 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Haiti SummaryCharges: $6, $20, $60, $60,$100 SBA, MWaux, nMW, 10-60min
  • 31. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 6 Mexico 38/11 157 (200) 43 (22%) 69% 97% 86% 13 0 1(tx site) 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Mexico SummaryCharges: $200, 350, 650, 650, 950 MW, aux MW, nMW, SBA, 15min
  • 32. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 2 Cambodia 161/25 428 (573) 145 (25%) 71% 84% 79% 16 0 2 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Cambodia Summary$12 USD, SBA, nsg, MW, nurseMW, 1hr
  • 33. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 2 Peru 68/13 84 (104) 20 (19%) 43% 93% 93% 3 0 0 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Peru SummaryCharges: $900USD- $1,070 MW, Obs, 5min,
  • 34. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 1 Ecuador 64/18 23 3 (13%) 86% 95% 86% 2 0 0 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Ecuador Summary$1,400 USD MW, MW aux, 10-15 min to hosp
  • 35. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 1 Sierra Leone 1360/87 40 0 71% 67% 29% 2 0 0 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Sierra Leone Summary$10USD TBA, nsg, nMW, 45min,
  • 36. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 1 South Africa 138/34 99 6 (6%) 57% 86% 86% 5 0 0 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 South Africa Summary$1080 USD 4min,
  • 37. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 1 Trinidad 63/13 59 11 (19%) 57% 95% 100% 2 0 0 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Trinidad Summary$2,300USD auxMW, MW, nMW, 5min
  • 38. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early NB deaths 1 Uganda 343/38 293 18 (6%) 57% 90% 100% 5 1 (tx site) 0 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Uganda Summary$2USD, MW, auxMW, TBA, 10min
  • 39. # of MBC surveyed Country 2015 MMR*/ IMR* # of births in 2016 at MBC (total w/ transfers) Transfers- IP, PP, NB (% transferred) BeMONC RMC QoC #FTE Maternal deaths Early Infant deaths 1 Bangladesh 176/31 7 0 100% 90% 100% 1 0 0 21 TOTALs 2,985 (3,549) 564 (16%) 70% 88% 84% 71 3 10 Bangladesh (not included in summary data) Summary$12 USD MW, 1 hr
  • 40. 48 References Bohren et al. Facilitators and barriers to facility-based birth in low-and middle- income countries: a qualitative evidence synthesis. Reproductive Health 2014, 11:71. Bowser, D., Hill, K., (2010) Exploring evidence for disrespect and abuse in facility-based childbirth. Report of a landscape analysis. USAID-TRAction Project. Harvard School of Public Health. University research Co., LLC. Available from: https://www.ghdonline.org/uploads/Respectful_Care_at_Birth_9-20-101_Final1.pdf Feldstein, A., Glasgow, R. (2008) A practical, robust implementation and sustainability model (PRISM) for integrating research findings into practice. The joint commission journal on quality and patient safety. April 2008; 34,4. Garfield, R., Berrymen, E. (2012). Nursing and nursing education in Haiti.[Internet] Nursing Outlook 60(2012) 16-20. Available from: http://www.nursingoutlook.org/article/S0029-6554(11)00093-5/pdf Jerome, J., Ivers, LC.(2011) Community health workers in health systems strengthening: a qualitative evaluation from rural Haiti. [Internet] AIDS. 2010 Jan; 24 (suppl 1); S67-S72. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3169202/pdf/nihms180962.pdf Koski-Karell, V., et al. (2016). Haiti's progress in achieving its 10-year plan to eliminate cholera: hidden sickness cannot be cured. Risk management and healthcare polity. 2016:9; 87-100. Available from: https://www.dovepress.com/haiti39s-progress-in-achieving-its-10-year-plan-to-eliminate-cholera-h-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article- RMHP Le Nouvelliste. 50% des sages-femmes formees en Haiti exercent leur profession a l’etranger. [Internet]. Haiti. 2017-08-09. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Available from: http://www.lenouvelliste.com/article/174626/50-des-sages-femmes-formees-en-haiti-exercent-leur-profession-a-letranger Martineau.(2016) Quel avenir pour la profession d’infirmiere en Haiti? [Internet]. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Availble from: http://www.lescacosnoirs.com/quel-avenir-pour-la- profession-dinfirmiere-en-haiti/ Moloney, A. (2013). Haiti’s new generation of doctors hope to revive ailing health sector, rebuild country. [Internet]. England, Wales. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Availble from: https://www.pih.org/media-coverage/reuters-haitis-new-generation-of-doctors-hope-to-revive-ailing-health-secto
  • 41. 49 References (cont) Monroe College. Health care in Haiti. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Available from: https://www.monroecollege.edu/uploadedFiles/_Site_Assets/PDF/Health_Care_in_Haiti.pdf Mullan, F. (2005). The metrics of physician brain drain. New England Journal of Medicine 2005;353,1810-8. Partners in Health (2013). Accompagnateur training guide. [Internet] Partners in health. ACME Books Inc. 2011. Available at: https://www.pih.org/sites/default/files/2017- 07/Accompagnatuer_FM_Haiti_English.pdf Restavek Freedom. (2017). Haiti’s colleges and universities. [Internet] Restavek Freedom. Available from: https://restavekfreedom.org/2017/07/28/haitis-colleges- universities/ TB/HaitiLibre. Häiti-Formation: Moins de 4% de étudiants es soins infirmiers, ont réussi examen d’État. [Internet] 13/03/2017. Haiti Libre.[cited Feb 7, 2018] Available from: http://www.haitilibre.com/article-20348-haiti-formation-moins-de-4-des-etudiants-en-soins-infirmiers-ont-reussi-l-examen-d-etat.html UNFPA. (2017). Midwives offer care, dignity and a lifeline for Haiti’s mothers. [Internet]. UNFPA. 2017 4 May. [cited Feb 7, 2018]. Availble from: https://www.unfpa.org/news/midwives-offer-care-dignity-and-lifeline-haitis-mothers?page=4 USAID, Global Health Workforce Alliance, WHO (2018). Human resources for health action framework. [Internet]. Geneva. [Cited: Feb 18, 2018] Available from: https://www.capacityproject.org/framework/ WHO. (2006). Working together for health. The world health report 2006.[Internet] WHO. Geneva. Available from: http://www.who.int/whr/2006/whr06_en.pdf?ua=1 WHO. Global experience of community health workers for delivery of health related millennium development goals. [Internet] Available from: http://www.who.int/workforcealliance/knowledge/publications/alliance/Global_CHW_web.pdf
  • 42. 50 Acknowledgements AABC Foundation Boston University Cris Alonso Rebecca Barlow Gene Declercq Cynthia Ingar Anam Mohmood Jack Resnik Leslie Toledo Stan Shaffer

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. Thank you for your interest in MC and SRH in LMIC
  2. UK: percent of women who began prenatal care at a birth center developed a complication that precluded out ­of ­hospital birth. Almost 90 percent of those complications occurred during the third trimester; (postterm pregnancy most common) • 12 percent of the women admitted to birth centers in labor were transferred to hospitals before giving birth; 4 percent of the mothers and 4 percent of the newborns were transferred to hospitals because of postpartum or newborn complications. • Only 2.4 percent of all transfers were emergencies. The most common reasons for intrapartum transfers were failure to progress (43 percent), meconium stained amniotic fluid (11 percent), and non­reassuring fetal heart rate (8 percent).
  3. decades of research demonstrating the strength of the model in HIC
  4. focus meetings- Haiti, Mexico, researchers at ICM, globally with network
  5. how are MC in low resource areas (without healthy health care system to transfer to?)
  6. SDGs- QoC, Human rights approach, RMC
  7. Lancet
  8. MDG approaches to MM- SBA, facility based birth
  9. 4 not included: 1 Ghana (no births yet) 1 Haiti (no births yet) 2 Bangladesh (no birth yet)
  10. Picking what data to measure- how to we check to see if they are safe….AND offer midwifery model of care?? self reported, retrospective, unvalidated
  11. tx time from 5 min to 60
  12. read/discuss circles, 70%
  13. WIDE range of births/year (12-98 births/year/provider)
  14. ****outline rmc- think about how to present and mw model****
  15. measures chosen b/c MC are different than hosp….
  16. make fewer words 100%.... than pick a few big words
  17. MC offer a potential for improved quality with improved outcomes, safety and high level of satisfaction for women.
  18. What else do MC provide?
  19. consider bar graph Transfer rates in labor in Netherlands- 22% (KNOV) (http://www.europeanmidwives.com/upload/filemanager/content-galleries/members-map/knov.pdf) Netherlands- max transfer time- 27 min
  20. Births per provider per year: mean- 50 median- 30 UK Birthrate Plus national benchmark- 29.5 birth/midwife- currently doing 33 births/midwife midwifery services in England National Audit office (https://www.nao.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/10259-001-Maternity-Services-Book-1.pdf)
  21. $6, $20, $60, $60,$100 Most with bottled water, solar/generator, SBA, MWaux, nMW, 10-60min Burdened by poverty, communities isolated by geography, scarce health professionals, scare hospitals
  22. $200, $350,$650, $650, $950 USD, MW, aux MW, nMW, SBA, 15min Not integrated into system yet- but in the process, humanizing birth, high levels of obstetrical violence and C/S
  23. $12 USD, river, solar panel, SBA, nsg, MW, nurseMW, 1hr National strategy to train MW and adapt local health centers to birthing homes with 2-3 mw each "MW provide the backbone to the health workforce for mothers and children Samaritan Purse -Sandan Birth Center -Thmar Krae Birth Center , hosptial- 1 hour drive, charge
  24. $900USD- $1,070, MW, Obs, 5min, Pakarii and Ruruchay Case De Nacimiento-
  25. $1,400 USD, MW, MW aux, placenta encapsulation, 10-15 min to hosp, intercultural model of care, humanized birth Dulce Espera
  26. $10USD, TBA, nsg, nMW, 45min, no kitchen (fire pit outside), intermittent power, well, Registration process, work collaboratively with indigenous herbalist, incorporation of traditional women's society- 'solay'. Intense poverty, armed conflict, recent ebola epidemic, 90% FGM, #1 for high MM and NM Taiama birth center
  27. Midwives Exclusive BC- $1080 USD, public water and elec, generator, 4min,
  28. MamaToto- $2,300USD, public water and elec, 5 min, auxMW, MW, nMW
  29. Shanti Uganda- $2USD, rain water catchment and solar panels, MW, auxMW, TBA, 10min, (often no doc there), 1 MM at tx Began as an empowerment project- skills for women, expanded to women's health Have employment workshops, teen program, doula training, nutrition, yoga and wellness classes
  30. $12 USD, well, public power, MW, 1 hr to transfer Hope Foundation -Bharuakhali BC -Islampur BC -Khunia Palong BC -Pockhali BC