2. Perfecting Produce:
The success of HC secondary systems in the New Zealand
Produce Distribution Sector.
NZ Produce Sector
Case Studies
Understanding adoption
and success criteria.
How are we the
problem?
Matthew Darby
3. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017 3
Legislation to meet New Zealand's international treaty
commitments for Net 0 emissions by 2050…
1996
NZ implements Ozone Layer Protection Act
& Regulations
2oo8
Climate
Change
Response
(ETS) Act
2010
New HCFC
Imports
reduced on
yearly basis
by 63%
2015
NO new
HCFC’s
imported:
R22
2019
HFC PHASE
DOWN
BEGINS
NZ Regulatory change focused
on restricting F gas
refrigerants.
NOT A USE BAN
1987 Montreal Protocol
1992 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
Objective: Global warming 2º minimum by 2050.
EcoChill
4. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017 4
Despite the increasing cost of the ETS on refrigerants, many
end users holding on to R22 or investing in synthetics facing
phase out.
Refrigerant Carbon cost
alone*.
R-404a $403.78
R-410A $220.15
R-134a $182.44
• Significant additional bottom line.
• Estimated +$11,000,000 to
WHOLESALE costs in 2016.
• Estimated 33.33% increase
annually for next 3 years as
“2 for 1” subsidy removed.
Source: Dave Nicholls
IRHACE
EcoChill
* Carbon price as at February 2017
5. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017 5
Use of Secondary Refrigeration Systems
Diagram courtesy of water-food.com
• Reduce amount of primary
stage refrigerant.
• Reduce leakage rate of
primary stage refrigerant.
• Reduced primary system
size.
• Easier maintenance.
Why?
• Smaller primary circuit
compared to DX.
• Uses a secondary fluid as
main cooling medium.
What?
EcoChill
6. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017
• Reduced refrigerant charge
• Increased energy efficiency
• Increased system reliability
• Reduced operating costs
• Reduced stored product risk
• Guaranteed system safety and
compliance
6
Advancements in Secondary Systems
Standard
Secondary
EcoChill
Expansion Valves Likely Mechanical Electronic
Capacity Control Likely Unloaders VSD
Primary Circuit Size Likely Standard
Optimised for Critical
Charge
Primary Refrigerant
Quantity
Likely Standard
Minimised through
design
EcoChill
8. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017
79 49
4440
5641
1326 1372
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
Old system
power input
kW
New system
power input
kW
Old system
refrigerated
volume
New system
refrigerated
volume
Old system
average daily
kWh
New system
average daily
kWh
8
“27% increase in volume cooled, with 38% less power input”
SITE A: Comparison of R22 vs EcoChill Secondary System
“Cost to Cool:
EcoChill 20c vs
25c per pallet -
20% saving”.
EcoChill
9. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017 9
39% increase in volume cooled, with 43% less power input.
“Cost to Cool:
EcoChill 19c vs
48c per pallet -
60% saving”.
EcoChill
SITE B: Comparison of R407F vs EcoChill Secondary System
10. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017 10
Store
capacity
(Pallets)
Cost to Cool
(Per Pallet/
Day
%
Difference
R22 840 $0.34 Baseline
EcoChill 864 $0.25 26%
“26% saving on
energy costs while cooling
more pallets”
19%
-34%
5%
-5%
1 2 3 4
Series8
R22
Total Equivalent Warming Impact versus
R22
TEWI: “19% better off than with R22 system ”
EcoChill
SITE C: Comparison of R22 vs EcoChill Secondary System
11. ATMOsphere Australia/ Sydney / 2 May, 2017 11EcoChill
SITE D: Comparison of R404A vs EcoChill Secondary System
53 49
5230
5641
1344
1151
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
404A System
power input kW
EcoChill system
power input kW
404A System
refrigerated
volume
EcoChill system
refrigerated
volume
404A Average
Daily kW
EcoChill
Average Daily
kW
“Cost to Cool:
EcoChill17c vs 22c
per pallet -
23% saving”.
7% increase in volume cooled with 7.5% less power input.
Hinweis der Redaktion
So as with all industries reliant on refrigeration the industry is dealing with investment decisions around its refrigeration strategies and how it responds to the HFC Phase down.
And this is despite increasing economic pressures also being applied. Why are so many at the grower and cool store level holding on to R22 systems – which are reliant on availability of stockpiles and risking shutdown? Why are others investing in synthetic gases which are also being phased out?
Refrigeration landscape for produce: use of secondary systems and refrigerants. Synthetics dominated now move to naturals- Ammonia, Co2 & HC why choice of HC over Co2 in this space.
EcoChill only current provider these systems in this sector.
Those EcoChill are doing projects with range across the produce sector both blue chip /leadership space and smaller growers and producers. In the produce distribution space we are working with the biggest players in the PDS (produce dist sector) who are also some of NZs TOP 100 F&B companies.
$201 per day to run old store versus $172 for the new store plus $10, 581 per year plus service and maintenance.
So am I fitting 75 pallets more in on each turnover – over a year that additional volume may mean the difference between having to spend money on building a new Coolstore in the next 3 years or getting another 3 years out of existing sites.