SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 101
Christianity on Trial
    “A Proposition of fact is proved,
    When it’s truth is established by
         competent and satisfactory
                evidence.”
             -     Simon Greenleaf

            An Adversary Proceeding
Socratic Skepticism
   I never enter the research phase to
   "win the debate," but rather to find the truth.
    As I examine the material relevant to
  the theme of the debate,
  I have to ask myself several questions:
     1) Is this the truth or is it someone's
         personal opinion, bias, or prejudice?

     2) Is there sufficient credible evidence
        to support the truth claim?

     3) Is it relevant to the argument?
- Josh McDowell
     Honest or Dishonest
The Bible is:
Made up of 66 different
books.
Written over a span of
1,600 years (approximately
1500 BC to AD 100).
Written by more than 40
kings, prophets, leaders,
and followers of Jesus.
The Ancient Documents Rule
          & Evidence
“The law is the witness and external deposit
 of our moral life. Its history is the history
 of the moral development of the race.”
                 – Oliver Wendell Holms, Jr.
Ancient documents will be
received as competent
if they are “fair on their face”
(i.e., their preservation
  has been consistent with their content).
Applying The Ancient Documents Rule:

 Q. Is the content of the Bible
     consistent with it’s preservation?

     A. Applied to the Gospel records,
        and reinforced by responsible lower
 (textual) criticism, this rule would establish
 their competency in any court of law.

 - Dr. John Warwick Montgomery
What is Truth?
The Realm of Fact




Pilate Inscription
Caiaphas Ossuary
Names, Dates, and Places?

                                      “Ignorance of the law
                                         excuses no man;
                                           not that all men
                                          know the law,
                                             but because ‘tis
                                                 an excuse
                                         every man will plead.”
                                                              –
                                         John Selden




Tabgha. The Church of St. Peter’s Primacy (John 21:1–17)
Examine the Defendants Character

        Liar, Lunatic, Legend, or Lord?
Put simply,
the best reason for believing
that the Christian religion is true
is Jesus, and the best reason
for believing in Jesus
is Jesus himself.

                    - James Shire
What Did He Teach?
Jesus wants us to be Good:

 Saved (2 Pet. 3:9),
    Spirit-filled (Eph. 5:15–18),
 Sanctified (1 Thess. 4:3, 4),
    Submissive (1 Pet. 2:13–15),
 Willing to suffer (1 Pet. 4:12–19).
Unselfish Love
Be not angry that you cannot make others
as you wish them to be, since
you cannot make yourself as you wish to be.
Man proposes, but God disposes.
Love is swift, sincere, pious, pleasant, gentle,
strong, patient, faithful, prudent, longsuffering,
manly and never seeking her own;
for wheresoever a man seeketh his own,
there he falleth from love.
Nothing is sweeter than love, nothing stronger, nothing higher,
nothing wider, nothing more pleasant, nothing fuller or better
in heaven or in earth;
for love is born of God, and cannot rest
but in God, above all created things.
                            - Thomas a’ Kempis (1420)
Greek Papyrus
Part 2: Lawyers ask Questions
 The Defendant posits a well reasoned faith:

 What Is Faith?
 An arbitrary act of the will and feelings,
 detached from the mind?

 Faith is that which
 I have evident reason
 to believe is true.
The Defendant Accredits the OT




              Practically…Legally…Logically
But no one can answer every
            Question?
“Only deductive logic and pure mathematics
provide ‘apodictic certainty,”
and they do so because
they stem from self-evident formal axioms
(e.g., the tautology, if A then A)
 involving no matter of fact.

The moment we enter into the realm of fact,
we must depend on probability;
this may be unfortunate,
but it is unavoidable.”  -JWM
Truth and Knowledge
Truth                  The word knowledge
is a characteristic    denotes a person’s
of statements that     proper
properly describe      understanding
aspects                of the true nature
of the real world...   of reality

True affirmations      Truth doesn’t
are those that         depend on anyone
correspond             knowing the truth!
to reality.
The Art & Science of Answering Questions

Epistemology:
 The study of theories   How do we Know
 of knowledge.           anything at all?
 1. Rationalism          How can we know
 2. Empiricism           the world around us?
 3. Historical
 4. Intuition            How can we know
                         God?
The History of Philosophy
The One and the Many
The Subject Object Problem
 What Essence underlies Existence?



Rationalism   Empiricism     Skepticism   Despair



Existentialism: Existence Precedes Essence
Albert Camus: “Death is Philosophy’s only problem.”

                                Rome
Alexandria




    Athens    Pergamum Temple     Jerusalem
A Pagan Opinion
“I find that it has been the opinion
 of the wisest men that
 Law is not a product of human thought,
 nor is it any enactment of peoples,
 but something eternal which rules
 the whole universe by its wisdom
 in command and prohibition.
 Thus they [the wisest men]
 have been accustomed to say
 that Law is the primal and ultimate
 mind of God… - Cicero
Did Jesus rise from the Dead?

 The last vice from Pandora’s box was hope.
 In Thessalonica an inscription on a stone reads,

 “After death no reviving.
  After the grave no meeting again.”

 Theocritus, a Greek philosopher and poet, wrote,


 “Hopes are among the living.
 The dead are without hope.”
God is Immanent

            Mt. Sinai


Aaron

                                 Burning Bush




 Israel                 Manger
1500-400 BC                    Old Testament
    Events are written down in Hebrew (with
    portions in Aramaic) over many centuries.
    In Exodus, the LORD tells Moses to write in a
    book. Other writers, inspired by God, include
    leaders, kings and prophets. Together, these
    writings on leather scrolls and other materials
    are called the Hebrew Scriptures or
    Old Testament.


1500 BC
1500 BC   500 BC
          500 BC   AD 1
                   AD 1   AD 500
                           AD 500   ADAD 1000
                                       1000     ADAD 1500
                                                   1500     AD 1900
                                                             AD 1900    AD 2000
                                                                       AD 2000
450 BC                              Ezra
           According to Jewish
           tradition, Ezra, a
           priest and scribe,
           collects and arranges
           some of the books of
           the Hebrew Bible,
           around 450 BC.



 1500 BC
1500 BC     500 BC
           1000 BC   AD 1BC AD 500
                     500       AD1   AD 1000
                                       AD 500   AD 1500
                                                 AD 1000   AD 1900
                                                            AD 500   AD 2000
                                                                     AD 2000
Stone, Leather, and Clay
250-100 BC                The Septuagint
          The Septuagint is the first Greek
          translation of the Hebrew Bible
          (the Old Testament).
          It was translated in 250-100 BC
          by Jewish scholars in Alexandria,
          Egypt.


1500 BC    500 BC   AD 1   AD 500   AD 1000   AD 1500   AD 1900   AD 2000
Qumran
AD 45-100             Followers of Jesus
      Followers of Jesus write eye-witness reports
      (Gospels), history, letters to other believers,
      and the Revelation.

      •    Matthew         •   Paul
      •    Mark            •   James
      •    Luke            •   Peter
      •    John            •   Jude



 1500 BC
1500 BC    500 BC
           500 BC   AD 1
                    AD1    AD 500
                            AD 500   AD 1000
                                      AD 1000   ADAD 1500
                                                  1500      AD AD 1900 AD 2000
                                                               1900     AD 2000
“The Testimony of the Evangelists”
“All that Christianity asks of men
on this subject, is,
that they would
be consistent with themselves;
that they would treat its evidences
as they treat the evidence of other things;
and that they would
try and judge its actors and witnesses,
as they deal with their fellow men,
when testifying to human affairs
and actions, in human tribunals.”
- Simon Greenleaf
David Inscription
The Hearsay Rule
…a witness must testify
“of his own knowledge” not on the basis
of what has come to him indirectly from others.

Applied to the New Testament documents,
this demand for primary-source evidence
is fully vindicated by the constant asseverations
of their authors to be setting forth
“that which we have heard which we have seen
 with our eyes, which we have looked upon,
and our hands have handled, the word of life”

                                    - 1 John 1:1
Isaiah1:18
  "Come now, and let us reason together,"
A witness must testify “
          of his own knowledge”
Luke 1:1, Inasmuch as many have taken in hand to set in order
   a narrative of those things which have been fulfilled among us,
   just as those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers
   of the word delivered them to us…

   2 Peter 1:16, …For we did not follow
   cunningly devised fables when we made known to you
   the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ,
   but were eyewitnesses of His majesty.

   1 John 1:1, That which was from the beginning,
   which we have heard,
   which we have seen with our eyes,
   which we have looked upon,
   and our hands have handled…
AD 400
                                               Jerome
    Jerome starts translating the
    Scriptures into Latin in
    AD 410 and finishes 25
    years later. This translation,
    called the Latin Vulgate,
    remains the basic Bible for
    many centuries.
                                                               Jerome



1500 BC
 1500 BC
1500 BC    500 BC
            500 BC
           500 BC    AD1
                     AD 1
                      AD    AD 500
                              AD 500
                             AD 500    AD 1000
                                         AD 1000
                                        AD 1000    AD 1500
                                                     AD 1500
                                                    AD 1500     AD 1900
                                                                  AD 1900
                                                                 AD 1900    AD2000
                                                                            AD 2000
                                                                             AD 2000
AD 500              Roman Empire
                               Declines
  Germanic migrations
  (AD 378-600)                                                 Germanic
                                                               Peoples

  cause new
  languages, other
  than Latin, to
  emerge.


1500 BC
1500 BC   500 BC
          500 BC   AD1
                   AD 1   AD 500
                           AD 500   AD 1000
                                     AD 1000   AD 1500
                                                AD 1500   AD 1900
                                                           AD 1900   AD2000
                                                                     AD 2000
AD 397
                                        The
   The 27 books of the
                                        Canon
   New Testament are
   formally confirmed as
   canonical by the Synod
   of Carthage in AD 397,
   thus recognizing three
   centuries of use by
                                                 Carthage
   followers of Christ.


1500 BC
1500 BC   500 BC
          500 BC   AD1
                   AD 1   AD 500
                           AD 500   AD 1000
                                     AD 1000   AD 1500
                                                AD 1500   AD 1900
                                                           AD 1900   AD2000
                                                                     AD 2000
“A book is not the Word of God
  because it is accepted by the people of God.
  Rather, it was accepted by the people of God
  because it is the Word of God.
  That is, God gives the book its divine authority,
  not the people of God.
  They merely recognize the divine authority
  which God gives to it.”
                                - Norman Geisler
The Parole Evidence Rule
External, oral testimony or tradition
  will not be received in evidence
  to add to, subtract from, vary, or contradict
  an executed written instrument such as a will.
  Applied to the Biblical documents,
  which expressly claim to be “executed” and complete
           (Rev. 22:18-19),
  this rule insists that
  the Scriptures be allowed to “interpret itself”
  and not be twisted by external, extra-biblical data
  (comparative New Eastern religious texts
  and practices, Sitz im Leben interpretations,
  “historical-critical method “New Hermeneutic.” etc.).

                      -Dr. John Warwick Montgomery
God indicates that his written word
   would be a complete and final
            revelation!
Exodus 20:1;
Deuteronomy 4:2; 8:3;
Psalm 19:7; 119:89, 152, 160;
Proverbs 30:5-6;
Isaiah 40:8;
Matthew 5:18; 24;35;
Luke 16:31;
John 10:35; 16:13;
Romans 10:17;
1 Corinthians 14:37; 15:1;
Galatians 1:9;
Hebrews 1:1-2; 2:2-4;
Jude 3;
Revelation 1:1; 22; 18-19
The Verdict Please
Dr. John Warwick Montgomery

“…to be skeptical of the resultant text
  of the New Testament books
  is to allow all of classical antiquity
  to slip into obscurity,
  for no documents of the ancient period
  are as well attested bibliographically
  as the New Testament.”
Part 3: Escape From Reason
To obtain the          To avoid as much
largest amount of      error as possible;
true beliefs           doubt everything
possible;simply        (Skepticism).
believe everything
you hear (Gullible).
Christians: Thou Shall Not
                Judge?
Only God can judge the human heart (Jer.17: 9).

  (1) Truth from error
       (Rom.12:2, 9; 1Cor. 12:10; 14:29; 1Thess. 5:19),
  (2) Good from evil
      (Acts 17:11; 2Peter 2:1; 2Peter 3:2; 1John 4:1; Jude 17)
  (3) Sin, (Matt. 18:15; 1Cor. 5:9),
  (4) False, corrupted or counterfeit worldviews.
      (Rom.16: 17; Gal 1:6; 2 Tim. 3:16, 4:4; Titus3:10; 2Tim.2:17 )
  Hypocritical, unjust, and presumptuous judgments
       are always wrong.
      (Matt. 7:1-5, 23:1-3; Phil. 1:15; John 7:24; John 5:22;
       Acts 17;31 ; James 4:11, 5;9).
Judgment Seat
C.S. Lewis
“If nothing is self-evident,
nothing can be proved.
Similarly, if nothing is obligatory
for it’s own sake,
nothing is obligatory at all.”

(The Abolition of Man)
Unprovable Assumptions
“Without an objective criterion
  one is at a loss to make a meaningful
  choice among a-prioris.
 The resurrection provides a basis
 in historical probability
 for trying the Christian faith.
 Granted, the basis is only
 one of probability, not of certainty,
 but probability is the sole ground
 on which finite human beings
 can make any decisions.
Particular to Universal
“…the weight of historical probability
  lies the side of the validity of Jesus’ claim
  to be God incarnate, the Savior of man,
  and the coming Judge of the world.
  If probability does in fact
  support these claims
  (and can we really deny it, having studied the evidence?),
  then we must act in behalf of them.”
Universal to Particular
…“In geometry the “given” concepts
   are called axioms.
  Geometry begins with certain concepts
  which are unproved,
  but from which the rest of geometry
  is deduced.
  Theology also has it’s axioms
  or beginning principles.
  This is why we do not hesitate
  to begin with the doctrine of the Trinity
  as our a-priori axiom.”
                              -Robert Morey
How Then Do I Judge?
Without basic
first principles of reality,
nothing can be known.
Everything we know about reality
is known by them.
Twelve basic first principles
can be set forth.
First Principles
1. Being Is
   The Principle of Existence.

2. Being Is Being
   The Principle of Identity.

3. Being Is Not Non-being
   The Principle of Noncontradiction.

4. Either Being or Nonbeing
   The Principle of the Excluded Middle.
5.   Nonbeing Cannot Cause Being
     The Principle of Causality.

6.   Contingent Being Cannot Cause Contingent Being
     The Principle of Contingency (or Dependency).
7.   Only Necessary Being Can Cause a Contingent Being
     The Positive Principle of Modality.

8.   Necessary Being Cannot Cause a Necessary Being
     The Negative Principle of Modality.
9. Every Contingent Being
   Is Caused by a Necessary Being
   The Principle of Existential Causality.

10. Necessary Being exists
   Principle of Existential Necessity.

11. Contingent being exists
    Principle of Existential Contingency

12. Necessary Being is similar to
    similar contingent being(s) it causes
   Principle of Analogy
The Case for Christ
1. Truth is Knowable       7. The New Testament says that
                              Jesus claimed to be God
2. The opposite of
   true is false           8. Jesus’ claim to be God
3. Theism is True             was miraculously confirmed
                           9. Therefore Jesus is God
4. Miracles are Possible
5. Miracles Confirm        10. Whatever Jesus
6. The New Testament       (Who is God) Teaches is True
   is Historically         11. Jesus Taught that the Bible
   Reliable                    is the Word of God

                           12. Therefore it is
                               True that the Bible is the
                               Word of God
                               (and anything opposed to it
                                         is false).
Part 4: Arguments
Kalam Time Argument
Cosmological Argument
The Design Argument
Teleological Argument
Axiological Argument
Ontological Argument
Proving The Unseen
“If anything does now exist,
  then either something must be eternal,
  or something not eternal
  must have come from nothing.”
  The Argument then proceeds to that
  it is more reasonable to believe
  that something is eternal;
  and that among the many hypotheses
  of eternal existence,
  the God of the Bible is the most reasonable,
  the most probable eternal being.

                         -Oliver Busswell
Science is not Ultimate
          Reality!
The Great Questions
(origin, meaning, morality, and destiny);
that underscore all of life, are fundamentally
philosophical and theological.
Induction is limited to probabilities.
But then, with just a pinch of faith,
they point us in the right direction.
“Best explanations,” are real explanations that
we apply and live by every day.
Meaning, morality, and destiny won’t fit
  into any test tube.
                                       -Mal
There are Different Kinds of
              Proof
Martin Heidegger:
 Philosophy cannot be based on history-
 neither on the science of history
 nor on any other science.
      For every science rests on presuppositions
     which can never be established scientifically,
     though they can be demonstrated philosophically.
     All sciences are grounded in philosophy ,
         but not vice versa.
John Locke
“If, therefore, it be evident that
 something necessarily must exist from eternity,
 it is also as evident that something
 must be a cogitative being;
 for it is as impossible that incogitative matter
 should produce a cogitative being,
 as that nothing,
 or the negation of all being,
should produce a positive being or matter.”
Information
John Gerstner observed;
“Where ever we see matter, there is information in
matter, that is not native to matter.”

Ravi Zacharias adds,
“We live in an ontologically haunted universe.”

William Lane Craig asserts;
“There needs to be some kind of ontic seeding.”

Francis Schaeffer says it all; “Personality is central.”
Something Exists
“The DNA blueprint must encapsulate
  not only every physical attribute
  of our bodies,
  but also the concepts that underlie
  our inborn instincts.
  For example, nature has managed to capture the
  notion of “height” in mammalian DNA.
  Psychological tests show that human beings,
      and most other mammals, fear heights at birth.


                  -Arno Penzias

            Program, means Programmer
Four options for the origin of the cosmos.
  1. The cosmos is an illusion
  2. The cosmos is self-existent
  3. The cosmos is self-created
  4. The cosmos is created by something
     that is self-existent
  “This is a modern restatement of
  St. Thomas Aquinas’s argument of
  necessary being (ens necessarium).”
                      -R.C. Sproul
1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause,
2. The universe began to exist,
   The universe had a cause.

1. The fine-tuning of the initial conditions of
   the universe is due to;
   natural law, chance, or design.
2. It is not due to natural law or chance.
   The fine tuning was designed.

1. If God does not exist,
   objective moral values don’t exist.
2. Objective moral values do exist.
    God exists.
Actually or Potentially
            Infinite?
Oliver Buswell:
  “There is no religion or philosophy in all the
  history of human culture
  which teaches the omnipotence of God.
  This must be in the light of the fact
  that there is no other
  doctrine of creation from nothing,
  than that found in the Judeo-Christian
  tradition or derived from it.
  There are only three monotheistic religions in
  the world; Judaism, Christianity, and
  Mohammedanism.
Uncaused Cause
Christianity claims to be an outgrowth of the
  Jewish revelation, and it is quite obvious that
  Mohammed, in the seventh century A.D.
  derived his concept of one, and only one,
  supreme God from Judaism and Christianity
  Polytheism could not, of course exist along
  with the doctrine of God’s omnipotence,
  for if there are many gods, each with a
  sphere of power, no one god could have all
  the power that is or could be.”
Part 5: Supernatural?
Is the Universe a Closed system.
       Is the Universe an Open System?
What is mind? No matter.
“Mental events
are feelings of pain,     However,
episodes of thoughts,     physical events
or sensory experiences.   and their properties
                          do not have the same
Physical events are       features
happenings in the brain   as do mental events
and central nervous       and their properties...
system
that can be described
exhaustively
using terms from
chemistry and physics.
What is matter? Never mind.
….Picture a pink elephant in your mind.
Now close your eyes and look at the image.
In your mind, you will see a pink property
(a sense datum or a sensory way of experiencing).
There will be no pink elephant outside you,
but there will be a pink image of one in your mind.
However, there will be no pink entity in your brain;
no neurophysiologist could open your brain and see
a pink entity while you are having the sense image.
The sensory event has a property-pink-that no brain event has.
Therefore, they cannot be identical.
The sense image is a mental entity, not a physical one.”
    - J.P. Moreland and Gary Habermas, Beyond Death
One Breath Away: Death
 “Body is form. Even        “If no necessity exists
now what makes our         between events and
bodies our bodies is       interpretations, then
not atoms but              there is no way of
structure. The atoms       determining which
change every seven         meaning is correct....
years; yet it is the       This is both repugnant
same body because of       and absurd.
its continuity of form.”   There must be an
(Peter Kreeft)             empirical necessity
                           that unites an event
                           or fact with its correct
                           interpretation.”
                              - Paul D. Feinberg
Res ipsa loquitur
“…A resurrection considered
 only as a fact to be proved
 by evidence, is a plain Case;
 it requires no greater ability
 in the witnesses, than that they be able to
 distinguish between a man dead, and a
 man alive; A Point, in which I believe
 every Man living thinks himself a Judge.”
               -Thomas Sherlock
Primary Source Documents
“…no historian can legitimately rule out
  documentary evidence simply on the ground
  that it records remarkable events;
   if the documents are sufficiently reliable,
  the remarkable events must be accepted
  even if they cannot be successfully explained
  by analogy with other events
  or by an a-priori scheme of natural causation.”
  (Dr. John Warwick Montgomery)

           Naturalism: Is the Universe a Closed System?
A Non-Analogous Event
“People like us, who believe in physics,
  know that the distinction between
  past, present, and future is only a
  stubbornly persistent illusion.”
                  (Albert Einstein)

 An awesome and wide open
 universe is best explained by an
 Awesome God.
C. S . Lewis
Miracles :    “Now of course we must agree
 with Hume [Eighteenth Century Skeptic]
 that if there is absolutely ‘uniform experience’
 against miracles,
 if in other words they have never happened,
 why then they never have.
 Unfortunately, we know
 the experience against them to be uniform only
 if we know that all the reports of them are false.
 And we can know all the reports to be false
 only if we know already
 that miracles have never occurred.
 In fact, we are arguing in a circle.”
Who Moved the Stone?
Frank Morison:
  [1] If Jesus didn’t rise
      someone must have stolen the body;
  [2] the only people involved were
      the Roman authorities,
      the Jewish religious leaders, and Jesus’ disciples ;
  [3] The Romans and the Jewish religious leaders
      would certainly not have taken the body, since to
      do so would have been against their own interests
      (the Romans wanted to keep Palestine quiet, and
      the Jews wanted to preserve their religious
       influence): and
  [4] the disciples would hardly have stolen the body
      and then died for what they knew to be untrue.
Francis Schaeffer
But they failed [German Higher Critics]
In the same way that the rationalistic philosophers
had failed.
They too were caught in the round room
without an exit Their search for
the historical Jesus was doomed to failure.
The supernatural was so intertwined with
the rest that if they ripped out all the supernatural,
there was no Jesus left!
If they removed all the supernatural,
no historical Jesus remained;
if they kept the historical Jesus,
the supernatural remained as well.
Part 6

The Opposite of True is False
The Parole Evidence Rule insists
that the Scriptures be allowed to
    “interpret itself”
     and not be twisted by external,
        extra-biblical data
What About New Prophets?
External, oral testimony or tradition
 will not be received in evidence
 to add to, subtract from, vary,
 or contradict
 an executed written instrument
 such as a will.

              - The Parole Evidence Rule
The Verdict Please
      F. J. A. Hort
“…in the variety and fullness of the evidence
  on which it rests the text of the New Testament
  stands absolutely and unapproachably alone
  among ancient prose writings.”

      F. F. Bruce writes:
  “There is no body of ancient literature
  in the world which enjoys
  such a wealth of good textual
  attestation as the New Testament.”
Primary or Secondary Source?
 The Book of Mormon?
 The Koran?
 The New World Translation?
 These are secondary sources;
 positing contradictory truth claims
 and no contemporaneous eyewitnesses.
MORMONISM
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
                       KEY WRITINGS
                          The Book of Mormon

                          Doctrine and Covenants

                          Pearl of Great Price

                          The Bible (King James
                           Version only or Smith’s
                           “Inspired Version”)
                          Authoritative teachings of
                           Mormonism’s prophets
                           and other “general
                           authorities”
JEHOVAH’S WITNESSES
Watchtower Bible and Tract Society

                         KEY WRITINGS
                         Include…

                         – Bible (New World
                           Translation only)
                         – You Can Live Forever in
                           Paradise on Earth
                         – Reasoning from the
                           Scriptures
                         – Watchtower magazine
                         – Awake! magazine1
ISLAM
             KEY WRITINGS
         Qur’an (Koran), scripture in Arabic

                    In principle, no
                    translation is regarded as
                    conveying the exact
                    meaning of the original;
                    although a few
                    translations are
                    considered acceptable,
                    non-Arabic speaking
                    Muslims are encouraged
                    to learn Arabic.
Mormonism
“Joseph Smith is credited with the “translation” of the
 Inspired Version of the Bible.
 Actually, it is not a new translation,
 instead, Smith added to and subtracted from the King
 James Version (KJV)-not by examining Biblical manuscripts ,
 but by “divine inspiration.” Smith corrected, revised,
 altered, added to, and deleted from’ the KJV.
 Virtually thousands of changes were introduced.
 While it took 50 of the world’s greatest Bible scholars, with
 a knowledge of Hebrew and Greek,
 seven years to finish their work on the KJV,
 it took Smith a mere three years to complete his work-
 despite the fact that he had virtually
 no knowledge of the biblical languages.” (Ron Rhodes)
Jehovah Witnesses: New World
           Translation?
 Dr. Julius Mantey:
      “a shocking mistranslation.
Dr. Bruce Metzger:
  “a frightful mistranslation.”
Dr. William Barclay:
“It is abundantly clear
that a sect which can translate the
New Testament like that
    is intellectually dishonest.”
Islam: Politically Correct
            Idolatry
“The earliest accounts of     “The very least we can say
 Muhammad’s life were          is the more Fundamental
 written at least 150 years    a Christian becomes,
 after his death.              the more just and loving
                               he will become;
 All are Muslim sources,       but the more Fundamental
 and there is no external      a Muslim becomes,
 (i.e. non-Muslim)             the more violent and
 supporting evidence.”         intolerant he will become.
                               This is the reason why
 -Patrick Sookhdeo             Islamic Fundamentalism
                               is almost synonymous
                               with terrorism.
                               Not all Muslims
                               are terrorists,
                               but almost all terrorists
                               today are Muslim.”
                                          - Hal Lindsey
Let None Dare, Call It
          Idolatry
“…There are at least 109
identifiable war verses in the Koran.
One out of every 55 verses
in the Koran is a war verse.
War verses are scattered
throughout Mohammed’s chapters
like blood splatter at a crime scene.”
                        -Don Richardson
David Hume (1711-1776)
“ …[Mohammed] bestows praise upon
  such instances of treachery,
  inhumanity, cruelty, revenge and
  bigotry as are utterly incompatible
  with civilized society. No steady rule
  of right seems there to be attended
  to, and every action is blamed or
  praised so far only as it is beneficial
  or hurtful to the true believers.”
Part 7
Law and Grace at the Cross
Ravi Zacharias: “The Crucifixion
 displays the horror of sin in concrete
 form.”




                     Denotation and Description
The Cross Examination Principle:
“All trials proceed upon the idea
that some confidence is due to human
testimony, and that this confidence
grows and becomes more steadfast
in proportion as the witness
has been subjected to a close and
searching cross-examination”

(Justice Ruffin, in State v. Morriss 84 N.C. 764)
Applied to the apostolic proclamation,
 this rule underscores
the reliability of testimony to Christ’s resurrection
which was presented contemporaneously
in the synagogues-
among hostile cross-examiners
who would certainly have destroyed
the case for Christianity had the facts
been otherwise
            -Dr. John Warwick Montgomery
Cross Examining the Cross
1. Were the witnesses trustworth
2. Did anything external influence
   their motives?
3. Does their testimony harmonize?
4. Is the external physical
    or written evidence consistent?
   McCloskey and Schoenberg: “the finest work on the subject.” Alan Saltzman
Richard A Givens: Advocacy

                             Event


                        Recollection


       Portion selected to be communicated


                           Symbols


               Interpretation by listener


    John Warwick Montgomery: Evidence for Faith, Part 6
Evidence For Faith: Pg. 328-329
The Historical Jesus
      Gary Habermas: “Twelve Facts, even the Skeptics agree with”

Jesus was: executed by                    Amazing Transformations:
 Roman executioners                       From Fear to Boldness

Publicly buried                            The Early Church
                                           proclaimed the
His Disciples were                         Resurrection
disoriented
                                           Proclaimed in Jerusalem
His Guarded tomb was
found empty                                The Growth of the Church
                         Exodus 31:12
Many, witnessed                            Worship on Sunday
post resurrection
appearances                                Paul’s Conversion

                                           James’ Conversion
Just the Facts
1. Jesus was         3. The radical
publicly crucified   transformation
and buried           of the disciples

2. Witnesses,        4. Paul’s
proclaim many        conversion
literal
appearances of
the risen Jesus
Paul’s Radical Transformation
Paul …and that He was buried, and that He rose again the
third day according to the Scriptures (1 Cor. 15:4)
…“the earliest evidence we have for the resurrection
almost certainly goes back to the time
immediately after the resurrection event is
alleged to have taken place.
This is the evidence contained in the early sermons
in the Acts of the Apostles…
But there can be no doubt that
in the first few chapters of Acts its authors
have preserved materiel from very early sources.
Scholars have discovered that the language used
in speaking about Jesus in these early speeches in Acts
is quite different from that used at the time
when the book was compiled in its first form.”
                                       - John Drane
The Cowardly Lion
Peter…And we are witnesses of all things
which He did both in the land of the Jews
and in Jerusalem, whom they killed
by hanging on a tree.
Him God raised up on the third day,
and showed Him openly,
not to all the people, but to witnesses chosen
before by God, even to us who ate and drank with Him
after He arose from the dead.
He commanded us to preach to the people,
and to testify that it is He who was ordained by God
to be Judge of the living and the dead.
To Him all the prophets witness that,
through His name, whoever believes in Him
will receive remission of sins.
                  (Acts 10:40 NKJV)
Therefore:
Salvation
There are four kinds of people
  when it comes to assurance of salvation;

  1. Those who are saved
      and know they are saved;
  2. Those who are lost and know they’re lost;
  3. Those who are saved
      but think they are lost;
  4. Those who are lost
      but think they are saved.

  (Augustine) In essentials unity,
  in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity.
Walter Martin
“The secular and scientific age in which we live
  demands that things be tested and re-tested.
  They require evidence upon evidence, fact upon fact.
  Yet here in the truest sense is a controlled experiment.
  Christianity has been observed
  for almost two thousand years.
  Wherever it is faithfully proclaimed, accepted, and acted upon,
  it transforms men, cultures, and societies;
  and it can do this only because it is energized
  by a living Savior…
  To those who come to Him,
  Jesus Christ becomes the to all the problems of soul and body.
  The results of their experience with Him
  become the truly unanswerable argument
  of essential Christianity.”

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

4 divine revelation[1]
4 divine revelation[1]4 divine revelation[1]
4 divine revelation[1]
kion86
 
6 Intro To Bible
6    Intro To Bible6    Intro To Bible
6 Intro To Bible
fsweng
 
The Bible: A True Story
The Bible: A True StoryThe Bible: A True Story
The Bible: A True Story
guesteca47e
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Origins - Interpretations of Genesis
Origins - Interpretations of GenesisOrigins - Interpretations of Genesis
Origins - Interpretations of Genesis
 
The Essentials of Apologetics - A Defense of the New Testament
The Essentials of Apologetics - A Defense of the New TestamentThe Essentials of Apologetics - A Defense of the New Testament
The Essentials of Apologetics - A Defense of the New Testament
 
Why I Believe the Bible to be True -
Why I Believe the Bible to be True  -Why I Believe the Bible to be True  -
Why I Believe the Bible to be True -
 
The Bible
The BibleThe Bible
The Bible
 
4 divine revelation[1]
4 divine revelation[1]4 divine revelation[1]
4 divine revelation[1]
 
Bible introduction 1 (english)
Bible introduction 1 (english)Bible introduction 1 (english)
Bible introduction 1 (english)
 
The Word - The Science of Biblical Interpretation - Part 2
The Word - The Science of Biblical Interpretation - Part 2The Word - The Science of Biblical Interpretation - Part 2
The Word - The Science of Biblical Interpretation - Part 2
 
6 Intro To Bible
6    Intro To Bible6    Intro To Bible
6 Intro To Bible
 
Power Point: Islam
Power Point: IslamPower Point: Islam
Power Point: Islam
 
Power Point: How We Got the Bible
Power Point: How We Got the BiblePower Point: How We Got the Bible
Power Point: How We Got the Bible
 
The Word - The Science of Biblical Intepretation - Part 3
The Word - The Science of Biblical Intepretation - Part 3The Word - The Science of Biblical Intepretation - Part 3
The Word - The Science of Biblical Intepretation - Part 3
 
The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 3)?
The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 3)?The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 3)?
The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 3)?
 
How Archaeology Illuminates the Bible
How Archaeology Illuminates the BibleHow Archaeology Illuminates the Bible
How Archaeology Illuminates the Bible
 
The Creed - I Believe In Jesus Christ
The Creed - I Believe In Jesus ChristThe Creed - I Believe In Jesus Christ
The Creed - I Believe In Jesus Christ
 
The Bible: A True Story
The Bible: A True StoryThe Bible: A True Story
The Bible: A True Story
 
Freedom and the Law
Freedom and the LawFreedom and the Law
Freedom and the Law
 
Is the New Testament the Word of God?
Is the New Testament the Word of God?Is the New Testament the Word of God?
Is the New Testament the Word of God?
 
The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 2)?
The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 2)?The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 2)?
The Essentials of Apologetics - Why Jesus (Part 2)?
 
The Word - Why Study The Bible
The Word - Why Study The BibleThe Word - Why Study The Bible
The Word - Why Study The Bible
 
Failed
FailedFailed
Failed
 

Ähnlich wie Christianity on Trial

Hist Reliability
Hist ReliabilityHist Reliability
Hist Reliability
teologic
 
Purpose & Reliability Of The Bible
Purpose &  Reliability Of The  BiblePurpose &  Reliability Of The  Bible
Purpose & Reliability Of The Bible
StJohns Pondicherry
 
Did Jesus Really Resurrect?
Did Jesus Really Resurrect?Did Jesus Really Resurrect?
Did Jesus Really Resurrect?
Bob Fuhs
 

Ähnlich wie Christianity on Trial (20)

Apologetics Class: Biblical Reliability, Inspiration and Inerrancy
Apologetics Class: Biblical Reliability, Inspiration and InerrancyApologetics Class: Biblical Reliability, Inspiration and Inerrancy
Apologetics Class: Biblical Reliability, Inspiration and Inerrancy
 
Divine Revelation
Divine RevelationDivine Revelation
Divine Revelation
 
Reasons (Part 2) Is the Bible Authentic and Accurate?
Reasons (Part 2) Is the Bible Authentic and Accurate?Reasons (Part 2) Is the Bible Authentic and Accurate?
Reasons (Part 2) Is the Bible Authentic and Accurate?
 
divinerevelation-111122151011-phpapp02.pptx
divinerevelation-111122151011-phpapp02.pptxdivinerevelation-111122151011-phpapp02.pptx
divinerevelation-111122151011-phpapp02.pptx
 
Inspiration and Inerrancy: A Power Point
Inspiration and Inerrancy: A Power PointInspiration and Inerrancy: A Power Point
Inspiration and Inerrancy: A Power Point
 
Christianity 101 (apologetics)
Christianity 101 (apologetics)Christianity 101 (apologetics)
Christianity 101 (apologetics)
 
Hist reliability
Hist reliabilityHist reliability
Hist reliability
 
Hist Reliability
Hist ReliabilityHist Reliability
Hist Reliability
 
Purpose & Reliability Of The Bible
Purpose &  Reliability Of The  BiblePurpose &  Reliability Of The  Bible
Purpose & Reliability Of The Bible
 
Revisiting The Resurrection - addressing Jewish Skepticism
Revisiting The Resurrection - addressing Jewish SkepticismRevisiting The Resurrection - addressing Jewish Skepticism
Revisiting The Resurrection - addressing Jewish Skepticism
 
Is the bible_true
Is the bible_trueIs the bible_true
Is the bible_true
 
Basic Bible Survey Lesson 1
Basic Bible Survey Lesson 1Basic Bible Survey Lesson 1
Basic Bible Survey Lesson 1
 
The bible
The bibleThe bible
The bible
 
Did Jesus Really Resurrect?
Did Jesus Really Resurrect?Did Jesus Really Resurrect?
Did Jesus Really Resurrect?
 
What We Believe About The Bible
What We Believe About The BibleWhat We Believe About The Bible
What We Believe About The Bible
 
Apologetics Part 5
Apologetics Part 5Apologetics Part 5
Apologetics Part 5
 
Notes and Power Point: Apologetics and the Miracles of Jesus
Notes and Power Point: Apologetics and the Miracles of JesusNotes and Power Point: Apologetics and the Miracles of Jesus
Notes and Power Point: Apologetics and the Miracles of Jesus
 
Updated April 2019 Joseph Smith Papyrus Facsimiles
Updated April 2019 Joseph Smith Papyrus FacsimilesUpdated April 2019 Joseph Smith Papyrus Facsimiles
Updated April 2019 Joseph Smith Papyrus Facsimiles
 
Joseph Smith Papyrus Facs #1-3
Joseph Smith Papyrus Facs #1-3Joseph Smith Papyrus Facs #1-3
Joseph Smith Papyrus Facs #1-3
 
Apologetics Part 3
Apologetics Part 3Apologetics Part 3
Apologetics Part 3
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functionsSalient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
KarakKing
 
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Unit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdf
Unit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdfUnit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdf
Unit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdf
 
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
 
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdfUGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
 
HMCS Vancouver Pre-Deployment Brief - May 2024 (Web Version).pptx
HMCS Vancouver Pre-Deployment Brief - May 2024 (Web Version).pptxHMCS Vancouver Pre-Deployment Brief - May 2024 (Web Version).pptx
HMCS Vancouver Pre-Deployment Brief - May 2024 (Web Version).pptx
 
Philosophy of china and it's charactistics
Philosophy of china and it's charactisticsPhilosophy of china and it's charactistics
Philosophy of china and it's charactistics
 
Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)
Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)
Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)
 
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
 
21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx
21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx
21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx
 
How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17
How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17
How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17
 
Basic Intentional Injuries Health Education
Basic Intentional Injuries Health EducationBasic Intentional Injuries Health Education
Basic Intentional Injuries Health Education
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
 
How to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POS
How to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POSHow to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POS
How to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POS
 
Single or Multiple melodic lines structure
Single or Multiple melodic lines structureSingle or Multiple melodic lines structure
Single or Multiple melodic lines structure
 
REMIFENTANIL: An Ultra short acting opioid.pptx
REMIFENTANIL: An Ultra short acting opioid.pptxREMIFENTANIL: An Ultra short acting opioid.pptx
REMIFENTANIL: An Ultra short acting opioid.pptx
 
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functionsSalient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
 
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
 
Food safety_Challenges food safety laboratories_.pdf
Food safety_Challenges food safety laboratories_.pdfFood safety_Challenges food safety laboratories_.pdf
Food safety_Challenges food safety laboratories_.pdf
 
Fostering Friendships - Enhancing Social Bonds in the Classroom
Fostering Friendships - Enhancing Social Bonds  in the ClassroomFostering Friendships - Enhancing Social Bonds  in the Classroom
Fostering Friendships - Enhancing Social Bonds in the Classroom
 

Christianity on Trial

  • 1. Christianity on Trial “A Proposition of fact is proved, When it’s truth is established by competent and satisfactory evidence.” - Simon Greenleaf An Adversary Proceeding
  • 2. Socratic Skepticism I never enter the research phase to "win the debate," but rather to find the truth. As I examine the material relevant to the theme of the debate, I have to ask myself several questions: 1) Is this the truth or is it someone's personal opinion, bias, or prejudice? 2) Is there sufficient credible evidence to support the truth claim? 3) Is it relevant to the argument? - Josh McDowell Honest or Dishonest
  • 3. The Bible is: Made up of 66 different books. Written over a span of 1,600 years (approximately 1500 BC to AD 100). Written by more than 40 kings, prophets, leaders, and followers of Jesus.
  • 4. The Ancient Documents Rule & Evidence “The law is the witness and external deposit of our moral life. Its history is the history of the moral development of the race.” – Oliver Wendell Holms, Jr. Ancient documents will be received as competent if they are “fair on their face” (i.e., their preservation has been consistent with their content).
  • 5. Applying The Ancient Documents Rule: Q. Is the content of the Bible consistent with it’s preservation? A. Applied to the Gospel records, and reinforced by responsible lower (textual) criticism, this rule would establish their competency in any court of law. - Dr. John Warwick Montgomery
  • 7. The Realm of Fact Pilate Inscription
  • 9. Names, Dates, and Places? “Ignorance of the law excuses no man; not that all men know the law, but because ‘tis an excuse every man will plead.” – John Selden Tabgha. The Church of St. Peter’s Primacy (John 21:1–17)
  • 10. Examine the Defendants Character Liar, Lunatic, Legend, or Lord? Put simply, the best reason for believing that the Christian religion is true is Jesus, and the best reason for believing in Jesus is Jesus himself. - James Shire
  • 11. What Did He Teach? Jesus wants us to be Good: Saved (2 Pet. 3:9), Spirit-filled (Eph. 5:15–18), Sanctified (1 Thess. 4:3, 4), Submissive (1 Pet. 2:13–15), Willing to suffer (1 Pet. 4:12–19).
  • 12. Unselfish Love Be not angry that you cannot make others as you wish them to be, since you cannot make yourself as you wish to be. Man proposes, but God disposes. Love is swift, sincere, pious, pleasant, gentle, strong, patient, faithful, prudent, longsuffering, manly and never seeking her own; for wheresoever a man seeketh his own, there he falleth from love. Nothing is sweeter than love, nothing stronger, nothing higher, nothing wider, nothing more pleasant, nothing fuller or better in heaven or in earth; for love is born of God, and cannot rest but in God, above all created things. - Thomas a’ Kempis (1420)
  • 14. Part 2: Lawyers ask Questions The Defendant posits a well reasoned faith: What Is Faith? An arbitrary act of the will and feelings, detached from the mind? Faith is that which I have evident reason to believe is true.
  • 15. The Defendant Accredits the OT Practically…Legally…Logically
  • 16. But no one can answer every Question? “Only deductive logic and pure mathematics provide ‘apodictic certainty,” and they do so because they stem from self-evident formal axioms (e.g., the tautology, if A then A) involving no matter of fact. The moment we enter into the realm of fact, we must depend on probability; this may be unfortunate, but it is unavoidable.” -JWM
  • 17. Truth and Knowledge Truth The word knowledge is a characteristic denotes a person’s of statements that proper properly describe understanding aspects of the true nature of the real world... of reality True affirmations Truth doesn’t are those that depend on anyone correspond knowing the truth! to reality.
  • 18. The Art & Science of Answering Questions Epistemology: The study of theories How do we Know of knowledge. anything at all? 1. Rationalism How can we know 2. Empiricism the world around us? 3. Historical 4. Intuition How can we know God?
  • 19. The History of Philosophy The One and the Many The Subject Object Problem What Essence underlies Existence? Rationalism Empiricism Skepticism Despair Existentialism: Existence Precedes Essence
  • 20. Albert Camus: “Death is Philosophy’s only problem.” Rome Alexandria Athens Pergamum Temple Jerusalem
  • 21. A Pagan Opinion “I find that it has been the opinion of the wisest men that Law is not a product of human thought, nor is it any enactment of peoples, but something eternal which rules the whole universe by its wisdom in command and prohibition. Thus they [the wisest men] have been accustomed to say that Law is the primal and ultimate mind of God… - Cicero
  • 22. Did Jesus rise from the Dead? The last vice from Pandora’s box was hope. In Thessalonica an inscription on a stone reads, “After death no reviving. After the grave no meeting again.” Theocritus, a Greek philosopher and poet, wrote, “Hopes are among the living. The dead are without hope.”
  • 23. God is Immanent Mt. Sinai Aaron Burning Bush Israel Manger
  • 24. 1500-400 BC Old Testament Events are written down in Hebrew (with portions in Aramaic) over many centuries. In Exodus, the LORD tells Moses to write in a book. Other writers, inspired by God, include leaders, kings and prophets. Together, these writings on leather scrolls and other materials are called the Hebrew Scriptures or Old Testament. 1500 BC 1500 BC 500 BC 500 BC AD 1 AD 1 AD 500 AD 500 ADAD 1000 1000 ADAD 1500 1500 AD 1900 AD 1900 AD 2000 AD 2000
  • 25. 450 BC Ezra According to Jewish tradition, Ezra, a priest and scribe, collects and arranges some of the books of the Hebrew Bible, around 450 BC. 1500 BC 1500 BC 500 BC 1000 BC AD 1BC AD 500 500 AD1 AD 1000 AD 500 AD 1500 AD 1000 AD 1900 AD 500 AD 2000 AD 2000
  • 27. 250-100 BC The Septuagint The Septuagint is the first Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible (the Old Testament). It was translated in 250-100 BC by Jewish scholars in Alexandria, Egypt. 1500 BC 500 BC AD 1 AD 500 AD 1000 AD 1500 AD 1900 AD 2000
  • 29. AD 45-100 Followers of Jesus Followers of Jesus write eye-witness reports (Gospels), history, letters to other believers, and the Revelation. • Matthew • Paul • Mark • James • Luke • Peter • John • Jude 1500 BC 1500 BC 500 BC 500 BC AD 1 AD1 AD 500 AD 500 AD 1000 AD 1000 ADAD 1500 1500 AD AD 1900 AD 2000 1900 AD 2000
  • 30. “The Testimony of the Evangelists” “All that Christianity asks of men on this subject, is, that they would be consistent with themselves; that they would treat its evidences as they treat the evidence of other things; and that they would try and judge its actors and witnesses, as they deal with their fellow men, when testifying to human affairs and actions, in human tribunals.” - Simon Greenleaf
  • 32. The Hearsay Rule …a witness must testify “of his own knowledge” not on the basis of what has come to him indirectly from others. Applied to the New Testament documents, this demand for primary-source evidence is fully vindicated by the constant asseverations of their authors to be setting forth “that which we have heard which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon, and our hands have handled, the word of life” - 1 John 1:1
  • 33. Isaiah1:18 "Come now, and let us reason together,"
  • 34. A witness must testify “ of his own knowledge” Luke 1:1, Inasmuch as many have taken in hand to set in order a narrative of those things which have been fulfilled among us, just as those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word delivered them to us… 2 Peter 1:16, …For we did not follow cunningly devised fables when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but were eyewitnesses of His majesty. 1 John 1:1, That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon, and our hands have handled…
  • 35. AD 400 Jerome Jerome starts translating the Scriptures into Latin in AD 410 and finishes 25 years later. This translation, called the Latin Vulgate, remains the basic Bible for many centuries. Jerome 1500 BC 1500 BC 1500 BC 500 BC 500 BC 500 BC AD1 AD 1 AD AD 500 AD 500 AD 500 AD 1000 AD 1000 AD 1000 AD 1500 AD 1500 AD 1500 AD 1900 AD 1900 AD 1900 AD2000 AD 2000 AD 2000
  • 36. AD 500 Roman Empire Declines Germanic migrations (AD 378-600) Germanic Peoples cause new languages, other than Latin, to emerge. 1500 BC 1500 BC 500 BC 500 BC AD1 AD 1 AD 500 AD 500 AD 1000 AD 1000 AD 1500 AD 1500 AD 1900 AD 1900 AD2000 AD 2000
  • 37. AD 397 The The 27 books of the Canon New Testament are formally confirmed as canonical by the Synod of Carthage in AD 397, thus recognizing three centuries of use by Carthage followers of Christ. 1500 BC 1500 BC 500 BC 500 BC AD1 AD 1 AD 500 AD 500 AD 1000 AD 1000 AD 1500 AD 1500 AD 1900 AD 1900 AD2000 AD 2000
  • 38. “A book is not the Word of God because it is accepted by the people of God. Rather, it was accepted by the people of God because it is the Word of God. That is, God gives the book its divine authority, not the people of God. They merely recognize the divine authority which God gives to it.” - Norman Geisler
  • 39. The Parole Evidence Rule External, oral testimony or tradition will not be received in evidence to add to, subtract from, vary, or contradict an executed written instrument such as a will. Applied to the Biblical documents, which expressly claim to be “executed” and complete (Rev. 22:18-19), this rule insists that the Scriptures be allowed to “interpret itself” and not be twisted by external, extra-biblical data (comparative New Eastern religious texts and practices, Sitz im Leben interpretations, “historical-critical method “New Hermeneutic.” etc.). -Dr. John Warwick Montgomery
  • 40. God indicates that his written word would be a complete and final revelation! Exodus 20:1; Deuteronomy 4:2; 8:3; Psalm 19:7; 119:89, 152, 160; Proverbs 30:5-6; Isaiah 40:8; Matthew 5:18; 24;35; Luke 16:31; John 10:35; 16:13; Romans 10:17; 1 Corinthians 14:37; 15:1; Galatians 1:9; Hebrews 1:1-2; 2:2-4; Jude 3; Revelation 1:1; 22; 18-19
  • 41. The Verdict Please Dr. John Warwick Montgomery “…to be skeptical of the resultant text of the New Testament books is to allow all of classical antiquity to slip into obscurity, for no documents of the ancient period are as well attested bibliographically as the New Testament.”
  • 42. Part 3: Escape From Reason To obtain the To avoid as much largest amount of error as possible; true beliefs doubt everything possible;simply (Skepticism). believe everything you hear (Gullible).
  • 43. Christians: Thou Shall Not Judge? Only God can judge the human heart (Jer.17: 9). (1) Truth from error (Rom.12:2, 9; 1Cor. 12:10; 14:29; 1Thess. 5:19), (2) Good from evil (Acts 17:11; 2Peter 2:1; 2Peter 3:2; 1John 4:1; Jude 17) (3) Sin, (Matt. 18:15; 1Cor. 5:9), (4) False, corrupted or counterfeit worldviews. (Rom.16: 17; Gal 1:6; 2 Tim. 3:16, 4:4; Titus3:10; 2Tim.2:17 ) Hypocritical, unjust, and presumptuous judgments are always wrong. (Matt. 7:1-5, 23:1-3; Phil. 1:15; John 7:24; John 5:22; Acts 17;31 ; James 4:11, 5;9).
  • 45. C.S. Lewis “If nothing is self-evident, nothing can be proved. Similarly, if nothing is obligatory for it’s own sake, nothing is obligatory at all.” (The Abolition of Man)
  • 46. Unprovable Assumptions “Without an objective criterion one is at a loss to make a meaningful choice among a-prioris. The resurrection provides a basis in historical probability for trying the Christian faith. Granted, the basis is only one of probability, not of certainty, but probability is the sole ground on which finite human beings can make any decisions.
  • 47. Particular to Universal “…the weight of historical probability lies the side of the validity of Jesus’ claim to be God incarnate, the Savior of man, and the coming Judge of the world. If probability does in fact support these claims (and can we really deny it, having studied the evidence?), then we must act in behalf of them.”
  • 48. Universal to Particular …“In geometry the “given” concepts are called axioms. Geometry begins with certain concepts which are unproved, but from which the rest of geometry is deduced. Theology also has it’s axioms or beginning principles. This is why we do not hesitate to begin with the doctrine of the Trinity as our a-priori axiom.” -Robert Morey
  • 49. How Then Do I Judge? Without basic first principles of reality, nothing can be known. Everything we know about reality is known by them. Twelve basic first principles can be set forth.
  • 50. First Principles 1. Being Is The Principle of Existence. 2. Being Is Being The Principle of Identity. 3. Being Is Not Non-being The Principle of Noncontradiction. 4. Either Being or Nonbeing The Principle of the Excluded Middle.
  • 51. 5. Nonbeing Cannot Cause Being The Principle of Causality. 6. Contingent Being Cannot Cause Contingent Being The Principle of Contingency (or Dependency). 7. Only Necessary Being Can Cause a Contingent Being The Positive Principle of Modality. 8. Necessary Being Cannot Cause a Necessary Being The Negative Principle of Modality.
  • 52. 9. Every Contingent Being Is Caused by a Necessary Being The Principle of Existential Causality. 10. Necessary Being exists Principle of Existential Necessity. 11. Contingent being exists Principle of Existential Contingency 12. Necessary Being is similar to similar contingent being(s) it causes Principle of Analogy
  • 53. The Case for Christ 1. Truth is Knowable 7. The New Testament says that Jesus claimed to be God 2. The opposite of true is false 8. Jesus’ claim to be God 3. Theism is True was miraculously confirmed 9. Therefore Jesus is God 4. Miracles are Possible 5. Miracles Confirm 10. Whatever Jesus 6. The New Testament (Who is God) Teaches is True is Historically 11. Jesus Taught that the Bible Reliable is the Word of God 12. Therefore it is True that the Bible is the Word of God (and anything opposed to it is false).
  • 54. Part 4: Arguments Kalam Time Argument Cosmological Argument The Design Argument Teleological Argument Axiological Argument Ontological Argument
  • 55. Proving The Unseen “If anything does now exist, then either something must be eternal, or something not eternal must have come from nothing.” The Argument then proceeds to that it is more reasonable to believe that something is eternal; and that among the many hypotheses of eternal existence, the God of the Bible is the most reasonable, the most probable eternal being. -Oliver Busswell
  • 56. Science is not Ultimate Reality! The Great Questions (origin, meaning, morality, and destiny); that underscore all of life, are fundamentally philosophical and theological. Induction is limited to probabilities. But then, with just a pinch of faith, they point us in the right direction. “Best explanations,” are real explanations that we apply and live by every day. Meaning, morality, and destiny won’t fit into any test tube. -Mal
  • 57. There are Different Kinds of Proof Martin Heidegger: Philosophy cannot be based on history- neither on the science of history nor on any other science. For every science rests on presuppositions which can never be established scientifically, though they can be demonstrated philosophically. All sciences are grounded in philosophy , but not vice versa.
  • 58. John Locke “If, therefore, it be evident that something necessarily must exist from eternity, it is also as evident that something must be a cogitative being; for it is as impossible that incogitative matter should produce a cogitative being, as that nothing, or the negation of all being, should produce a positive being or matter.”
  • 59. Information John Gerstner observed; “Where ever we see matter, there is information in matter, that is not native to matter.” Ravi Zacharias adds, “We live in an ontologically haunted universe.” William Lane Craig asserts; “There needs to be some kind of ontic seeding.” Francis Schaeffer says it all; “Personality is central.”
  • 60. Something Exists “The DNA blueprint must encapsulate not only every physical attribute of our bodies, but also the concepts that underlie our inborn instincts. For example, nature has managed to capture the notion of “height” in mammalian DNA. Psychological tests show that human beings, and most other mammals, fear heights at birth. -Arno Penzias Program, means Programmer
  • 61. Four options for the origin of the cosmos. 1. The cosmos is an illusion 2. The cosmos is self-existent 3. The cosmos is self-created 4. The cosmos is created by something that is self-existent “This is a modern restatement of St. Thomas Aquinas’s argument of necessary being (ens necessarium).” -R.C. Sproul
  • 62. 1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause, 2. The universe began to exist, The universe had a cause. 1. The fine-tuning of the initial conditions of the universe is due to; natural law, chance, or design. 2. It is not due to natural law or chance. The fine tuning was designed. 1. If God does not exist, objective moral values don’t exist. 2. Objective moral values do exist. God exists.
  • 63. Actually or Potentially Infinite? Oliver Buswell: “There is no religion or philosophy in all the history of human culture which teaches the omnipotence of God. This must be in the light of the fact that there is no other doctrine of creation from nothing, than that found in the Judeo-Christian tradition or derived from it. There are only three monotheistic religions in the world; Judaism, Christianity, and Mohammedanism.
  • 64. Uncaused Cause Christianity claims to be an outgrowth of the Jewish revelation, and it is quite obvious that Mohammed, in the seventh century A.D. derived his concept of one, and only one, supreme God from Judaism and Christianity Polytheism could not, of course exist along with the doctrine of God’s omnipotence, for if there are many gods, each with a sphere of power, no one god could have all the power that is or could be.”
  • 65. Part 5: Supernatural? Is the Universe a Closed system. Is the Universe an Open System?
  • 66. What is mind? No matter. “Mental events are feelings of pain, However, episodes of thoughts, physical events or sensory experiences. and their properties do not have the same Physical events are features happenings in the brain as do mental events and central nervous and their properties... system that can be described exhaustively using terms from chemistry and physics.
  • 67. What is matter? Never mind. ….Picture a pink elephant in your mind. Now close your eyes and look at the image. In your mind, you will see a pink property (a sense datum or a sensory way of experiencing). There will be no pink elephant outside you, but there will be a pink image of one in your mind. However, there will be no pink entity in your brain; no neurophysiologist could open your brain and see a pink entity while you are having the sense image. The sensory event has a property-pink-that no brain event has. Therefore, they cannot be identical. The sense image is a mental entity, not a physical one.” - J.P. Moreland and Gary Habermas, Beyond Death
  • 68. One Breath Away: Death “Body is form. Even “If no necessity exists now what makes our between events and bodies our bodies is interpretations, then not atoms but there is no way of structure. The atoms determining which change every seven meaning is correct.... years; yet it is the This is both repugnant same body because of and absurd. its continuity of form.” There must be an (Peter Kreeft) empirical necessity that unites an event or fact with its correct interpretation.” - Paul D. Feinberg
  • 69. Res ipsa loquitur “…A resurrection considered only as a fact to be proved by evidence, is a plain Case; it requires no greater ability in the witnesses, than that they be able to distinguish between a man dead, and a man alive; A Point, in which I believe every Man living thinks himself a Judge.” -Thomas Sherlock
  • 70. Primary Source Documents “…no historian can legitimately rule out documentary evidence simply on the ground that it records remarkable events; if the documents are sufficiently reliable, the remarkable events must be accepted even if they cannot be successfully explained by analogy with other events or by an a-priori scheme of natural causation.” (Dr. John Warwick Montgomery) Naturalism: Is the Universe a Closed System?
  • 71. A Non-Analogous Event “People like us, who believe in physics, know that the distinction between past, present, and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion.” (Albert Einstein) An awesome and wide open universe is best explained by an Awesome God.
  • 72. C. S . Lewis Miracles : “Now of course we must agree with Hume [Eighteenth Century Skeptic] that if there is absolutely ‘uniform experience’ against miracles, if in other words they have never happened, why then they never have. Unfortunately, we know the experience against them to be uniform only if we know that all the reports of them are false. And we can know all the reports to be false only if we know already that miracles have never occurred. In fact, we are arguing in a circle.”
  • 73. Who Moved the Stone? Frank Morison: [1] If Jesus didn’t rise someone must have stolen the body; [2] the only people involved were the Roman authorities, the Jewish religious leaders, and Jesus’ disciples ; [3] The Romans and the Jewish religious leaders would certainly not have taken the body, since to do so would have been against their own interests (the Romans wanted to keep Palestine quiet, and the Jews wanted to preserve their religious influence): and [4] the disciples would hardly have stolen the body and then died for what they knew to be untrue.
  • 74. Francis Schaeffer But they failed [German Higher Critics] In the same way that the rationalistic philosophers had failed. They too were caught in the round room without an exit Their search for the historical Jesus was doomed to failure. The supernatural was so intertwined with the rest that if they ripped out all the supernatural, there was no Jesus left! If they removed all the supernatural, no historical Jesus remained; if they kept the historical Jesus, the supernatural remained as well.
  • 75. Part 6 The Opposite of True is False
  • 76. The Parole Evidence Rule insists that the Scriptures be allowed to “interpret itself” and not be twisted by external, extra-biblical data
  • 77. What About New Prophets? External, oral testimony or tradition will not be received in evidence to add to, subtract from, vary, or contradict an executed written instrument such as a will. - The Parole Evidence Rule
  • 78. The Verdict Please F. J. A. Hort “…in the variety and fullness of the evidence on which it rests the text of the New Testament stands absolutely and unapproachably alone among ancient prose writings.” F. F. Bruce writes: “There is no body of ancient literature in the world which enjoys such a wealth of good textual attestation as the New Testament.”
  • 79. Primary or Secondary Source? The Book of Mormon? The Koran? The New World Translation? These are secondary sources; positing contradictory truth claims and no contemporaneous eyewitnesses.
  • 80. MORMONISM Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints KEY WRITINGS  The Book of Mormon  Doctrine and Covenants  Pearl of Great Price  The Bible (King James Version only or Smith’s “Inspired Version”)  Authoritative teachings of Mormonism’s prophets and other “general authorities”
  • 81. JEHOVAH’S WITNESSES Watchtower Bible and Tract Society KEY WRITINGS Include… – Bible (New World Translation only) – You Can Live Forever in Paradise on Earth – Reasoning from the Scriptures – Watchtower magazine – Awake! magazine1
  • 82. ISLAM KEY WRITINGS  Qur’an (Koran), scripture in Arabic In principle, no translation is regarded as conveying the exact meaning of the original; although a few translations are considered acceptable, non-Arabic speaking Muslims are encouraged to learn Arabic.
  • 83. Mormonism “Joseph Smith is credited with the “translation” of the Inspired Version of the Bible. Actually, it is not a new translation, instead, Smith added to and subtracted from the King James Version (KJV)-not by examining Biblical manuscripts , but by “divine inspiration.” Smith corrected, revised, altered, added to, and deleted from’ the KJV. Virtually thousands of changes were introduced. While it took 50 of the world’s greatest Bible scholars, with a knowledge of Hebrew and Greek, seven years to finish their work on the KJV, it took Smith a mere three years to complete his work- despite the fact that he had virtually no knowledge of the biblical languages.” (Ron Rhodes)
  • 84. Jehovah Witnesses: New World Translation? Dr. Julius Mantey: “a shocking mistranslation. Dr. Bruce Metzger: “a frightful mistranslation.” Dr. William Barclay: “It is abundantly clear that a sect which can translate the New Testament like that is intellectually dishonest.”
  • 85. Islam: Politically Correct Idolatry “The earliest accounts of “The very least we can say Muhammad’s life were is the more Fundamental written at least 150 years a Christian becomes, after his death. the more just and loving he will become; All are Muslim sources, but the more Fundamental and there is no external a Muslim becomes, (i.e. non-Muslim) the more violent and supporting evidence.” intolerant he will become. This is the reason why -Patrick Sookhdeo Islamic Fundamentalism is almost synonymous with terrorism. Not all Muslims are terrorists, but almost all terrorists today are Muslim.” - Hal Lindsey
  • 86. Let None Dare, Call It Idolatry “…There are at least 109 identifiable war verses in the Koran. One out of every 55 verses in the Koran is a war verse. War verses are scattered throughout Mohammed’s chapters like blood splatter at a crime scene.” -Don Richardson
  • 87. David Hume (1711-1776) “ …[Mohammed] bestows praise upon such instances of treachery, inhumanity, cruelty, revenge and bigotry as are utterly incompatible with civilized society. No steady rule of right seems there to be attended to, and every action is blamed or praised so far only as it is beneficial or hurtful to the true believers.”
  • 89. Law and Grace at the Cross Ravi Zacharias: “The Crucifixion displays the horror of sin in concrete form.” Denotation and Description
  • 90. The Cross Examination Principle: “All trials proceed upon the idea that some confidence is due to human testimony, and that this confidence grows and becomes more steadfast in proportion as the witness has been subjected to a close and searching cross-examination” (Justice Ruffin, in State v. Morriss 84 N.C. 764)
  • 91. Applied to the apostolic proclamation, this rule underscores the reliability of testimony to Christ’s resurrection which was presented contemporaneously in the synagogues- among hostile cross-examiners who would certainly have destroyed the case for Christianity had the facts been otherwise -Dr. John Warwick Montgomery
  • 92. Cross Examining the Cross 1. Were the witnesses trustworth 2. Did anything external influence their motives? 3. Does their testimony harmonize? 4. Is the external physical or written evidence consistent? McCloskey and Schoenberg: “the finest work on the subject.” Alan Saltzman
  • 93. Richard A Givens: Advocacy Event Recollection Portion selected to be communicated Symbols Interpretation by listener John Warwick Montgomery: Evidence for Faith, Part 6
  • 94. Evidence For Faith: Pg. 328-329
  • 95. The Historical Jesus Gary Habermas: “Twelve Facts, even the Skeptics agree with” Jesus was: executed by Amazing Transformations: Roman executioners From Fear to Boldness Publicly buried The Early Church proclaimed the His Disciples were Resurrection disoriented Proclaimed in Jerusalem His Guarded tomb was found empty The Growth of the Church Exodus 31:12 Many, witnessed Worship on Sunday post resurrection appearances Paul’s Conversion James’ Conversion
  • 96. Just the Facts 1. Jesus was 3. The radical publicly crucified transformation and buried of the disciples 2. Witnesses, 4. Paul’s proclaim many conversion literal appearances of the risen Jesus
  • 97. Paul’s Radical Transformation Paul …and that He was buried, and that He rose again the third day according to the Scriptures (1 Cor. 15:4) …“the earliest evidence we have for the resurrection almost certainly goes back to the time immediately after the resurrection event is alleged to have taken place. This is the evidence contained in the early sermons in the Acts of the Apostles… But there can be no doubt that in the first few chapters of Acts its authors have preserved materiel from very early sources. Scholars have discovered that the language used in speaking about Jesus in these early speeches in Acts is quite different from that used at the time when the book was compiled in its first form.” - John Drane
  • 98. The Cowardly Lion Peter…And we are witnesses of all things which He did both in the land of the Jews and in Jerusalem, whom they killed by hanging on a tree. Him God raised up on the third day, and showed Him openly, not to all the people, but to witnesses chosen before by God, even to us who ate and drank with Him after He arose from the dead. He commanded us to preach to the people, and to testify that it is He who was ordained by God to be Judge of the living and the dead. To Him all the prophets witness that, through His name, whoever believes in Him will receive remission of sins. (Acts 10:40 NKJV)
  • 100. Salvation There are four kinds of people when it comes to assurance of salvation; 1. Those who are saved and know they are saved; 2. Those who are lost and know they’re lost; 3. Those who are saved but think they are lost; 4. Those who are lost but think they are saved. (Augustine) In essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity.
  • 101. Walter Martin “The secular and scientific age in which we live demands that things be tested and re-tested. They require evidence upon evidence, fact upon fact. Yet here in the truest sense is a controlled experiment. Christianity has been observed for almost two thousand years. Wherever it is faithfully proclaimed, accepted, and acted upon, it transforms men, cultures, and societies; and it can do this only because it is energized by a living Savior… To those who come to Him, Jesus Christ becomes the to all the problems of soul and body. The results of their experience with Him become the truly unanswerable argument of essential Christianity.”