The document discusses building a cycle network in Dublin. It notes that only 10% of planned cycle routes have been completed after 7 years of work. At this pace, it would take 280 years to finish, but completing routes 25 times faster in 25 years is possible. Several challenges delay projects, including lengthy approval processes, stakeholder objections, and a lack of priority and funding. The document argues for enabling cycling through building safe, connected infrastructure to create a positive feedback loop of more riders and faster network delivery.
2. Agenda
● Why do we need to build a network of cycle routes?
● What is a cycle network?
● What progress have we made?
● What is the process for building new cycle infrastructure?
● What is delaying new cycle infrastructure?
● How can we can we speed up delivery?
4. “Our vision for Dublin is a vibrant,
liveable city where everyone can enjoy
everyday walking and cycling”
Dublin Cycling Campaign’s Vision
5. The three things people need to cycle
1. Access to a suitable cycle
2. The appropriate knowledge to cycle
3. A cycle route suitable for their needs
Why people travel the way they do is
a deeply personal choice based on a
huge number of criteria
6. Four types of ‘cyclists’
Source: Dr Jennifer Dill, Professor Urban Studies & Planning, Portland State University, Oregon USA
38. “Cycling is a niche activity for a small
subsection of the population. Investing in
cycling won’t make a meaningful contribution
to Ireland’s transport problems”
– Too Many Key Decision Makers in Ireland
49. Cycle of
Change
Enable
People
Cycling
Positive feedback loop if
more people START
cycling because of...
● Building safe cycle
routes
● Easier access to
cycles
● Seeing ‘more people
like me’ cycling
● Learnt necessary
knowledge and skills
Negative feedback loop if
more people QUIT cycling
because of...
● Experience road
danger / abuse
● Apathetic Garda
response
● Stolen cycle
● Changing life
circumstances
51. Development Stages
1. Concept Design
2. Preliminary Design
3. Statutory Approval Process
4. Detailed Design
5. Procurement
6. Construction
52. Planning Permission for Cycle Infrastructure
● Section 38 of the Road Traffic Act 1994
● Part 8 of the Planning and Development Regulations 2001
● Planning Act 2000 & Roads Act 1993
● Private developments via Planning and Development Act 2000
53. Section 38
● Can be used to provide “traffic calming measures” including cycle lanes
● Conditions:
○ Council can change existing roads
○ No road widening. Must stay within existing boundaries
● Only needs the council officials approval
● Approval period: 2-8 weeks
59. Part 8
● Council advertises project. The public can make submissions.
● Councillors vote to approve or reject the project
● Any compulsory purchase orders need to be approved by An Bord
Pleanála
● Requires a proper planning application (3-9 months preparation)
● Approval process (4 months)
63. Projects that need An Bord Pleanála approval
● Various sections of the Planning Act 2000 and Roads Act 1993
● Need an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
○ Large-scale construction projects
○ Projects with potentially significant environmental impacts
● Preparing an application takes 12-24 months
● An Bord Pleanála decision takes 9-18 months
66. Private Developments
● Private developer upgrades existing public road beside development
● Delivery local cycle network within developments
● Quality varies dramatically
● Can be small but significant contribution
69. Clontarf to City Centre
2.7km project from Alfie Byrne Road to Talbot Street via North Strand Road
● Original Part 8 2014
● Second Part 8 September 2017
● Tenders December 2020
● Construction Q3 2021
● Completed Q1 2023
9 YEARS!
70. Clontarf to City Centre Delays
● Novel design elements (junctions, bus stops, kerbs)
● Scope creep
● Major utility changes
● Irish Water not wanting to pay for water main upgrades
● Growing cost estimates and multiple business cases
● Backseat driving from National Transport Authority
● Huge number of community stakeholders
● Old coal cellars under the road
71. Clontarf to City Centre Timeline Slippage
When Timeline Announced Construction Date Completed Date
September 2019 Q1 2020 Q4 2021
November 2019 Q2 2020 +3 months Q2 2022 +6 months
February 2020 Q3 2020 +6 months Q3 2022 +9 months
June 2020 Q1 2021 +12 months
November 2020 Q3 2021 +18 months Q1 2023 +15 months
73. Royal Canal Greenway Phase 2
Approved in December 2015
Opened in July 2020
Delay Reasons:
● Liaising with Irish Rail and Waterways Ireland
● Potential conflicts with DART+ Programme
● Council staff re-assigned to other projects (Luas Cross City)
● No funding available to build the project (~€8M)
74. Sandymount to Blackrock
Published October 2016
Abandoned April 2018
Cancellation Reasons:
● Complaints over new road bridge
● Complaints over compulsory purchases
● Complaints over making Seapoint Avenue one-way
● Only handful of 680 submissions supportive
79. Dublin City Council Plans
“The Programme for Government envisages funding for cycling and walking
projects of €360 million a year for the next five years.”
“The project team has drawn from lessons learned on how cycle projects have
been delivered up to now; what has worked and what has not; and how delivery
can be speeded up“
Plan for 2021-2025 increases from 54 kilometres to 150-200 kilometres
Source: Report 278/2020; Dublin City Council
80. Dublin City Council Tiers
Tier 4: Major multi-sectoral projects
Tier 2: Minor complexity projects
Tier 3: Major complexity projects
Tier 1: Trials, bollards and wands
Section 38 of the
Road Traffic Act
Part 8 or ABP
Approval Required
}
}
98. How you can help...
● Join Dublin Cycling Campaign
● Engage and be supportive in public consultations
● Talk to your local politicians
● Encourage family, friends and co-workers to start cycling
● Talk to your neighbours
● Volunteer with Dublin Cycling Campaign
