Case study at the 2014 Museum Computer Network Conference on Friday November 21, 2014 in Dallas, TX. In March and April 2014, members of the Albright-Knox Art Gallery staff conceived and executed a social media-based, crowdsourced tournament titled #ArtMadness, modeled after the NCAA March Madness basketball tournament. The tournament, conducted with sixteen works from the museum's collection in a bracket format, set two works against each other in daily head-to-head matchups with the outcome decided by votes on Facebook and Twitter. The online interaction this generated exceeded expectations, increasing user engagement and feedback across all platforms. The final matchup featured Jackson Pollock's "Convergence", 1952, against Vincent van Gogh's "La Maison de la Crau (The Old Mill)," 1888, with van Gogh emerging as the winner. With its simple design and ease of participation, the #ArtMadness tournament was an unanticipated runaway success. It drew local media coverage and engaged local and national museums, politicians, and artists. Implemented with limited resources and staff, and combining disparate elements of art and sport, the competition was the museum's largest driver of social media engagement to date.