Ähnlich wie From nano-ZnOenabled antimicrobial surfaces to propidium iodide staining underestimating biofilm viability. Presentation by Merilin Rosenberg
ASM Microbe 2017: Reaching the Parts Other Methods Can't: Long Reads for Micr...Nick Loman
Ähnlich wie From nano-ZnOenabled antimicrobial surfaces to propidium iodide staining underestimating biofilm viability. Presentation by Merilin Rosenberg (20)
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
From nano-ZnOenabled antimicrobial surfaces to propidium iodide staining underestimating biofilm viability. Presentation by Merilin Rosenberg
1. From nano-ZnO enabled antimicrobial surfaces to
propidium iodide staining underestimating biofilm
viability
Merilin Rosenberg
COST AMICI ECI and
STSM Workshop
Riga
07.03.2019
2. • Background:
– PhD project in National
Institute of Chemical
Physics and Biophysics
(NICPB)
• Laboratory of Environmental
Toxicology
• Dr Anne Kahru’s group
– PhD student in Tallinn
University of Technology
(TalTech)
• COST AMICI
Short Term Scientific Mission
(STSM) to
– University of Porto
• LEPABE - Laboratory for
Process Engineering,
Environment,
Biotechnology and Energy
• Dr. Nuno F. Azevedo
3. „Assessment of anti-biofilm
activity of antimicrobial
surfaces based on ZnO/Ag
heterostructures“
• STSM duration:
• 20/11/2017 to 19/12/2017,
1 month
• Data analysis planned after STSM
duration
• STSM objective
• Combining the expertise of
NICPB and UoP to evaluate the
anti-biofilm activity of surfaces
covered with ZnO or ZnO/Ag
heterostructure nanoparticles
• Well defined experimental plan
• Pre- ordered reagents
• LIVE/DEAD™ BacLight™ Bacterial
Viability Kit (Molecular Probes)
• 3 well-described photocatalytic antimicrobial
surface coatings and a control surface
– Described in Visnapuu et al. 2018
• 2 bacterial species
– Staphylococcus epidermidis DSM-20044
– Escherichia coli MG1655
• 4 time points
– 2, 8, 24, 48 h
– Dark incubation
• 1 oligotrophic test medium
– 1:500 diluted nutrient broth in deionized water
• Main methods:
– In situ viability staining of biofilm formation
• Propidium iodide and SYTO 9 (LIVE/DEAD™ BacLight™ )
– Planktonic plate counts to assess dissolution toxicity
– Planktonic samples for elemental analysis to assess
dissolution
– Possibly FISH or post-harvesting plate counts
1,8x1,8 cm
glass surface
5 ml inoculum
OD600=0,01
4. • S. epidermidis on
control surface
• S. epidermidis on
toxic surface
• E. coli on
control surface
• E. coli on
toxic surface
• Predictable total count results ↑
• Unexpected staining pattern!
→
• Harvested cells are
metabolically active (FDA
staining) and proved to be
cultivable (plate counts)!
• Osmotic stress?
– Medium switched to PBS
– Same phenomenon in PBS
Red = dead
Green = alive
5. DEAD – permanently
damaged membrane
PI - red
Syto 9 -
green
VIABLE - reversibly
permeable membrane
VIABLE &
CULTIVABLE – intact
membrane
VIABLE, but
NOT CULTIVABLE
(VBNC)
PI staining eDNA
Syto 9 staining
DNA
OR
• dormant cells,
• cultivable only in specific conditions,
• decreased metabolic activity,
• environmental stress,
• starvation
• reversible membrane damage
• eDNA in biofilm ECM,
• environmental stress,
• specific growth phases,
• gain of competence
Propidium
iodide (PI) Syto 9
chromosomal DNA,
cell membrane
6. Rosenberg et al., submitted,
preprint: https://doi.org/10.1101/475145
• 76% of Staphylococcus epidermidis and
96% of Escherichia coli cells in 24-hour
initial biofilms on untreated glass are PI-
positive ‘dead’ red cells.
• 68% the cells of either species in these
aggregates are metabolically active
based on fluorescein diacetate (FDA)
staining.
• PI and SYTO 9 co-staining pattern is
reversed by ultrasonication possibly by
(partially) removing the extracellular
matrix.
• Furthermore, 82% of E. coli and 89% S.
epidermidis are cultivable after harvesting
by ultrasonication.
• Most PI-stained ‘dead’ red cells are viable
and cultivable!
7. Rosenberg et al., submitted, preprint: https://doi.org/10.1101/475145
8. Staphylococcus epidermidis and gram-negative Escherichia coli 24-hour initial
biofilms on glass consist of 76 and 96% PI-positive red cells in situ, respectively,
even though 68% the cells of either species in these aggregates are
metabolically active. Furthermore, 82% of E. coli and 89% S. epidermidis are
cultivable after harvesting.
Rosenberg et al., submitted, preprint: https://doi.org/10.1101/475145
Confocal microscopy reveals mostly double-stained cells with red PI-stained eDNA
coronas around green intracellular SYTO 9 signals.
However, this explains only half of initial STSM conundrum of the undead microbes: the
(extracellular) PI signal absence on ZnO-coated surfaces.
9. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-4159.2009.06269.x
• Similar staining pattern totally masking intracellular
SYTO9 signal is achieved with SYTO9 and Congo
red co-staining
• Congo red is a well known amyloid stain staining
also bacterial surface-bound amyloid fibrils (SAFs)
e.g. E. coli curlis.
• SAFs are abundantly present in biofilms, important
in attachment to solid surfaces and able to bind
DNA.
• Zn(II) has been shown to inhibit amyloid fibril
formation in a dose-dependent manner
(Tõugu et al. 2009)
in similar concentration
range that is released
from our ZnO-coated
surfaces (≈15 µM).
• Zn(II) released from ZnO
may inhibit amyloid fibril
formation and thereby
restore green signals that
are masked on surfaces
that do not release Zn(II).
That would also explain
delayed biofilm formation
on ZnO-coated surfaces.
ThioflavinTfluorescence
10. Take-home message:
• Select STSM host carefully – support
at the lab is of utmost importance
• Practical everyday lab questions
• Background knowledge in the field
• Laboratory infrastructure
• Working language
• Plan ahead as much as possible
• Experimental plan, possible additional tests depending on results etc.
• Transport of samples, reagents – are there restrictions?
• Logistics, accommodation in case of late night lab sessions i.e. WIFI at the accommodation
for literature searches is essential.
• Pre-order or take with you everything needed
• to avoid waiting for shipping dates during STSM
• STSM budget is more limiting than longest possible time-frame without additional funding
• Be prepared to work independently
• while making use of all the help you can find
• Ask questions!
• Be prepared to manage major changes to experimental plan!
• Find a way to make use of failed experiments as well as successful ones – questions make
science!
• Take the most out of professional networking and local expertise as well as
sightseeing and cultural experiences!