SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 39
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
RFP        DOCUMENT




                                 State Level Evaluation
                       Study of “Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana”
                                     Chhattisgarh




                      State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh
                     Department of Health and Family Welfare
                            Government of Chhattisgarh
                                     Raipur




                       Issued / Released on 14th of September 2011


RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                           1
Tender document of State Nodal Agency Chhattisgarh for the Evaluation of
                                  RSBY

                             State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh
                            Department of Health and Family Welfare
                                   Government of Chhattisgarh
                                            Raipur

                                         RFP NOTICE ( 2nd Notice)

                              RASHTRIYA SWASTHYA BIMA YOJANA
(A scheme to provide health insurance coverage to unorganized sector workers belonging to BPL families)

        Sealed bids are invited from reputed organizations/agencies having experience of carrying out
evaluation studies for government schemes and programs for carrying out evaluation study of Rastriya
Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) Enrollment and Utilization by BPL families in divisions of Raipur viz.
Raipur, Mahasamund, Dhamtari, Kawardha, Durg & Rajnandgon, Bilaspur Viz.Bilaspur, Korba, Raigarh
& Janjgir, Sarguja viz. Sarguja, Koriya & Jashpur and Baster viz Baster, Narayanpur, Bijapur,
Dantewada & Kanker of Chhattisgarh State

        The bids are invited in two parts i.e., Technical Bid and Financial bid. Insurance companies and
Third Party Administrators (Health) & their allied companies and Agencies involved with DHFW
Chhattisgarh are not permitted to participate in the bidding process.

The tender document for this may be downloaded from the website http://cghealth.nic.in

The technical bids and financial bids should be sealed by the bidder in a cover duly super-scribed is to be
put in a bigger cover which should also be sealed and duly super-scribed.

The Technical bids will be evaluated by the Technical Bid Evaluation Committee. Financial
bids of only the technically acceptable offers shall be opened before the successful bidders
by the SNA for awarding of the contract. Following schedule will be observed in this regard.

Last date of submission of technical bid document: 6 PM of 17.10.2011
Opening of technical bids: 18.10.2011

The completed technical Bid documents should be submitted before at the following address:-

                             State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh
                            Department of Health and Family Welfare
      2nd Floor Directorate of Health and Family Welfare, Old Nursing Hostel, Raipur-492001
                            Email: rsbycg@gmail.com Tel: 0771-4255948

        All correspondence / communications on the scheme should be made at the above address.


      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                         2
RFP DOCUMENT


RASHTRIYA SWASTHY A BIMA YOJANA

A number of studies have revealed that risk owing to low level of health security is endemic for informal
sector workers. The vulnerability of the poor informal worker increases when they have to pay fully for
their medical care with no subsidy or support. On the one hand, such a worker does not have the financial
resources to bear the cost of medical treatment, on the other; the health infrastructure leaves a lot to be
desired. Large numbers of people, especially those below poverty line, borrow money or sell assets to pay
for the treatment in private hospitals. Thus, Health Insurance could be a way of overcoming financial
handicaps, improving access to quality medical care and providing financial protection against
high medical expenses. The “Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana” announced by the Central Government
attempts to address such issues. Government of Chhattisgarh has launched this scheme in all its 18
districts.

For the evaluation of the scheme, Proposals are invited from the Survey agencies. The agencies which are
in agreement with scheme and its Terms of Reference, only need to participate in the bidding and
any disagreement in this regard may invite disqualification / rejection of bid at technical
level. Hence all the agencies are requested to go through the scheme carefully and submit their agreement
in specific format given in the bid.

Agency/Organization after qualifying the Technical bid will have to make a presentation.
Finally, the study will be awarded to the agency/organization that is selected by the
Committee on the basis of both the Technical and Financial bid following due procedure.
The selected Institution/Organization has to start the study immediately after its award, and each of the
deliverables would be completed as per the time frame in the TOR. In case the selected
Institute/Organization declines to take up the study after a notice of award has been issued, it would be
barred from applying for any study, evaluation or assistance of any kind from Department
of Health and Family Welfare, Raipur, Chhattisgarh for a period of 3 years from the date of award.

The decision of the Bids Evaluation Committee shall be final, and no enquiries, or
application for review, shall be entertained.




      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                        3
PART-1 : TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR CONDUCTING EVALUATION
STUDIES OF RASTRIYA SWASTHYA BIMA YOJANA AT STATE
LEVEL

A: Introduction

State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh invite proposals for conducting household surveys related to
RSBY. This request for proposals is for carrying out a post-enrollment survey of health
insurance. This type of Household Survey Study will give idea about the enrollment process
for RSBY and the experience of the beneficiaries. It will also give States information about the type of
facilities provided to the beneficiaries when they receive the treatment under RSBY. All the benefits which
are supposed to be given by the providers to the beneficiaries whether they are getting those or not will
come out through this survey. It will also provide limited information about the quality of health care
provided. It will also provide results in terms of utilization pattern of public and private
providers by the beneficiaries in the State of Chhattisgarh. The districts to be covered for this
survey are all the 18 districts in four divisions of Chhattisgarh.


Proposals are invited from the Survey agencies (henceforth called consultants).

The following activities are to be carried out as part of the post-enrollment survey:

    •    Implementation of a post-enrollment and hospitalization household survey in the selected districts.
    •    Completion of an implementation report on the household survey including cases of households
         not covered due to extenuating circumstances (e.g. inability to locate or household unwilling).
    •    Completion of the database detailing responses to the household survey in appropriate format for
         subsequent analysis.

 Important information regarding the RFP has been given in Annexure - 1.


B. Clarification and Amendment of RFP Document


        1. Consultants may request a clarification of any of the RFP documents within 7 days
           of the advertisement data. Any request for clarification must be sent in writing, or
           by standard electronic means to the State Nodal Agency. The State Nodal Agency
           will respond in writing, or by standard electronic means and will send written
           copies of the response (including an explanation of the query but without
           identifying the source of inquiry) to all Consultants. Should the State Nodal Agency
           deem it necessary to amend the RFP as a result of a clarification, it shall do so following the
           procedure.

        2. At any time before the submission of Proposals, the State Nodal Agency may amend the RFP
           by issuing an addendum in writing or by standard electronic means. The addendum shall be
           communicated through a public advertisement and will be binding on them.
           Consultants shall acknowledge receipt of all amendments. To give Consultants reasonable
           time in which to take an amendment into account in their Proposals the State

        RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                        4
Nodal Agency may, if the amendment is substantial, extend the deadline for the submission of
            Proposals.


C: Qualifying Criteria’s:

        •   The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 25, 00,000 in at least one of the past three
            years (2007-08, 2008-09, and 2009-10). ( please attach audited statements)
        •   Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies projects with minimum project cost of
            Rs. 5,00,000/- for any Government (State/Central) / Government Autonomous Bodies
            / Government Corporation for building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3
            years (Please attach copy of work orders and completion certificates).
        •   Out of this, at least 2 (two) evaluations should have been successfully completed.
            (Please attach copy of completion certificate from the client).
        •   The agency/organization should have at least 5 years relevant experience carrying out
            evaluations studies (Please attach copy of evidence)
        •   The firm / company / organization should be registered as per law. (Please attach copy
            of evidence).
        •   No consortium is allowed to bid for the study
        •   Applicants should not be under a declaration of ineligibility for corrupt and fraudulent
            practices issued by Government of India / State Governments. A self-declaration
            certificate should be enclosed.


D. Methodology for Evaluation

Though consultant /agency are required to provide their methodology for conducing the survey,
main aspects of the methodology of the proposed survey is given as follows:

For this survey only RSBY beneficiaries needs to be surveyed. RSBY beneficiaries who are enrolled in
the scheme will be part of this survey. The sample of beneficiaries will include beneficiaries who have
utilized the scheme and who have not taken benefits in the scheme

        a. Sampling of District – State Nodal agency shall have this exercise in the first stage in all the
           districts where RSBY started in the first phase.
        b. Sampling – For every 1000 beneficiaries who are enrolled under RSBY in a district, at least 20
           should be selected in the sample. Care should be taken that the beneficiaries who have utilized
           the scheme shall also be present in the sample.
        c. Location of Surveys – The beneficiary in the sample should be sufficiently distributed among
           all the blocks of the district. Within the block also efforts should be there to have villages or
           clusters of villages distributed geographically.
        d. Duration of Surveys – Survey training and field work shall take approximately two month.
           Another month will be needed to analyze the data and prepare the report.
        e. Timelines – The process to start the selection of survey agency to get the final
           report shall take approx. 3-4 months. If a State Nodal agency starts the process in November
           then they shall have the final report by sometime in January.

      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                          5
f.   Draft Tool for the Survey – The draft tool for this type of survey is attached
             as Annexure- 5 of this document. This tool may be modified before start of the final survey.



E. Submission of Technical and Financial Proposal:

        a. Technical Proposal shall be provided in the format given in Annexure -2:
              i. The consultant shall provide in the technical proposal a description of the approach,
                 methodology and work plan for performing the assignment covering the
                 following subjects: technical approach and methodology, work plan, and
                 organization and staffing schedule. The list of the proposed Professional staff team by
                 area of expertise, the position that would be assigned to each staff team member,
                 and their tasks.
             ii. Estimates of the staff input (staff-months professionals) needed to carry out the
                 assignment. The staff-months input should be indicated separately for home office and
                 field activities.
            iii. CVs of the Professional staff.
            iv. A detailed description of the proposed methodology and staffing for training.
             v. Format for evaluation of technical proposal has been given in Annexure 4.
            vi. Technical bid evaluation will be done in following steps:
                          a. The bidders will be short listed after evaluation is done on the qualifying
                               criteria.
                          b. Short listed bidders will be asked to give a presentation in the prescribed
                               format in front of the technical evaluation committee.
                          c. After the presentation the bids will be evaluated on the other parameters as
                               mentioned in the Desirable Criteria of the Technical Proposal
                          d. All the successful bidders who qualify after the technical bid evaluation will
                               be eligible for the financial bid evaluation.
                          e. The Technical proposal shall not include any financial information. A
                               Technical Proposal containing financial information may be declared non
                               responsive.

        b. Financial Proposal:

        i. The Financial proposal shall take into account all costs associated with the assignment
        (Annexure-3). The quote should be for each division separately. Bidders can quote for more
        than one division.

        ii. No other information shall be provided along with the financial proposal.

F. Co-ordination with the State Nodal Agency

The agency will have to work closely with the State Nodal Agency in developing the methodology,
training of the surveyors, and conducting the surveys. State Government will provide the necessary contact
details and data for surveys.

G. Ownership of the Survey

The ownership of the survey tool and data shall lie with the State Government/ Nodal Agency.

      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                        6
PART –II SUBMISSION OF BIDS/ PROPOSALS

The State Nodal Agency seeks detailed proposal from agencies interested in evaluating the “Rastriya
Swasthya Bima Yojana”, in the Chhattisgarh State.

The bid/proposal document should include the following:

SECTION A – TECHNICAL PROPOSAL


QUALIFYING CRITERIA:

        •   A. The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 25, 00,000 in at least one of the past three
            years (2007-08, 2008-09, and 2009-10).
        •   Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies projects with minimum project cost of
            Rs. 5,00,000/- for any Government (State/Central) / Government Autonomous Bodies
            / Government Corporation for building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3
            years (Please attach copy of work orders).
        •   Out of this, at least 2 (two) evaluations should have been successfully completed.
            (Please attach copy of completion certificate from the client).
        •   The agency/organization should have at least 5 years relevant experience carrying out
            evaluations studies (Please attach copy of evidence)
        •   The firm / company / organization should be registered as per law. (Please attach copy
            of evidence).
        •   No consortium is allowed to bid for the study
        •   Applicants should not be under a declaration of ineligibility for corrupt and fraudulent
            practices issued by Government of India / State Governments. A self-declaration
            certificate should be enclosed.


Note: The qualifying requirements data shall be enclosed with the technical bid only. The bidder
who do not qualify this criterion, will be disqualified immediately and their bids will not be
considered.

The Technical proposal should be sealed in an envelope clearly marked in BOLD
“SECTION A – TECHNICAL PROPOSAL” and “TECHNICAL PROPOSAL FOR
Evaluation of “RASHTRIYA SWASTHYA BIMA YOJANA SCHEME” written on the top of the
envelope.

The Envelop should have the bidders Name and Address clearly written at the Left Bottom Corner of the
envelope. The technical supporting documents in physical form should be submitted at the following
address before the due date and time.

   State Nodal Agency Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana 2nd Floor, Directorate of Health Services,
                     Raipur, Chhattisgarh Phone: 0711-4255948, 4225196

      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                            7
SECTION B – FINANCIAL PROPOSAL

(KINDLY NOTE THAT ANNEXURE -3 SHOULD BE ATTACHED TO SECTION B- FINANCIAL PROPOSAL ONLY)



                                                                                            Annexure-3
 (A) The Financial bid submission should be done physically in a separate sealed and marked envelope.

No bid will be accepted after prescribed closing time for submission of the same.

The delay will not be condoned for any reason. However, if the last date of submission of tender is
declared as a holiday by government, the last date of submission of tender will be extended to the next
working day.

The bids may be cancelled and not evaluated if the bidder fails to:

    a.    Seal the envelope properly with sealing tape.
    b.    Submit envelopes i.e. Technical Proposal and Financial proposal in another large envelope.
    c.    Give complete bids in all respects.
    d.    Submit financial bids not as mentioned in the tender document.



Deadline for Submission Bids / Proposals:

Complete bid documents should be submitted by 18.00 hours on 16th of August 2011. Bid documents
received later than the prescribed date and time will not be considered for evaluation.



IN NO CASES, RATE S SHOULD BE QUOTED ANYWHERE EXCEPT IN FINANCIAL BID




         RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                    8
Annexure - 1



                               Instructions to the Consultants



Paragraph Reference

1 Name and Address of the State Nodal Agency:

  State Nodal Agency, RSBY Chhattisgarh
  Department of Health and Family Welfare,
  2nd Floor, Directorate of Health Services, Old
  Nursing Hostel, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Email: rsbycg@gmail.com
  Phone: 0711-4255948, 4225196
2 The physical submission of the technical bid document address is:

   State Nodal Agency, RSBY Chhattisgarh
   Department of Health and Family Welfare,
   2nd Floor, Directorate of Health Services, Old
   Nursing Hostel, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Email: rsbycg@gmail.com
   Phone: 0711-4255948, 4225196

  Proposals must be submitted not later than the following date and time 6 pm of 17th October
  2011
3 Proposals must remain valid 90 days after the submission date

4 Clarifications may be requested not later than 3 days before the submission date.

5 Proposals shall be submitted in the following language: - English

6 The format of the Technical Proposal to be submitted: As per the Annexure

7 Bidder must submit the original and 2 copies of the Technical Proposal, and the original of
  the Financial Proposal.




 RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                     9
Annexure-2


                              Details of the Technical Proposal


Technical approach, methodology and work plan are key components of the Technical Proposal. Please
submit your Technical Proposal divided into the following three chapters:

a) Technical Approach and Methodology,
b) Work Plan, and
c) Organization and Staffing,



   a) Technical Approach and Methodology. In this chapter understanding of the objectives of the
      assignment, approach to the services, methodology for carrying out the activities and obtaining the
      expected output, and the degree of detail of such output shall be explained. It should highlight the
      problems being addressed and their importance, and explain the technical approach that would be
      adopted to address them. It should also explain the methodologies which are proposed to be
      adopted and highlight the compatibility of those methodologies with the proposed approach.


   b) Work Plan. In this chapter the main activities of the assignment, their content and duration,
      phasing and interrelations, milestones, and delivery dates of the reports shall be proposed. The
      proposed work plan should be consistent with the technical approach and methodology, showing
      understanding of the TOR and ability to translate them into a feasible working plan. A list of the
      final documents, including reports, drawings, and tables to be delivered as final output, should be
      included here.


   c) Organization and Staffing. In this chapter the structure and composition of the team shall be
      proposed. It should list the main disciplines of the assignment, the key expert responsible, and
      proposed technical and support staff.




      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                      10
Evaluation of Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) Chhattisgarh State,
Division of _____________________________

A: ORGANISATIONAL PROFILE

Name of organization
Name and Designation of Contact Person
Postal Address of the Organization (with PIN CODE)
Physical Address, if different from postal address (With PIN CODE)
Telephone with STD Code
FAX No. with STD Code
Mobile No. of Contact Person
E-mail Address of Contact Person
Name and Designation of Head of the Organization responsible for the Study Contract
Establishment Details
a. Year Established
b. Type of Organization (Tick One) Educational & Research
Institution/ Consulting Organization/ Any Other (give details)
c. Regd. No. ; Name and Place of Registering Authority
(Attach attested photocopy of Registration Certificate)

B. EXPERIENCE
Experience   in    conducting   research    studies   in   the    field   of    rural &   social
development/welfare programme/schemes/projects by the organization/agency in the past years
(2006 to 2009 calendar years) that are relevant for demonstrating its expertise in the area of
proposed study (attach attested photo copy of the experience certificate):

 Sno.        Title of      Name &       Completion        Duration      Value         Name of
             the           Address      time/date         of            (Rs.          Sample
             research      of Client    (Month &          the           Lakh)         State (s) As
             project                    Year)             project                     per
                                                          completion                  TOR/
                                                          (in Months)                 Agreements
                                                                                      Actual

 House Hold survey
 1
 2
 3
 4
 Health Survey
 1
 2
      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                     11
Government survey
    1
    2

B.1: Completed research project (s) (Extra-sheet may be used if activities are more than 5 in number)
B.2: On-going research projects
 Sr.       Title of the       Name &            Project       Project                    Name of
No.         research           Address          starting    completion       Value        Sample
             project          of Client        date/time     time as          (Rs.       State (s)
                                               (Month &         per          Lakh)
                                                 Year)         ToR/
                                                            Agreement
                                                                (in
                                                             Months)
1
2
3
4
5

C: HUMAN RESOURCE
C. 1 Human Resources of the organization: (attach CVs)
Sr.          Official Station Professional/Technical Supporting Staff            All
No.          (Name of place) (Numbers)                 (Numbers)

                                   Fulltime     Part-time   Fulltime Part-time

1
2
3
4

C2: To be deployed for the proposed study/project
(a)- KEY PROFESSIONALS ** (attach CVs)
 Sr. No.                         Highest               Length of     No. of man         (Team
             Name Area          academic/              experience       months          Leader)
               of key          professional            (years) in    deployed for
              expertise        qualification               the         this study
                                 in the               area of key
                              area of key               expertise
                                expertise
1
2
3
4
5

       RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                 12
** Note: Care may be taken to demonstrate that each area of expertise required for the study is covered by different
key professionals in above table.

(b)- SUPPORT AND FIELD STAFF

    Sr. No.      Job profile (e.g. Field investigator, data                  No. of personnel
                      entry operator, analyst, etc.)                 Total number of man months to be
                                                                                deployed.
1
2
3
4
5

                                        Format for Team Composition
1. Professional Staff

Name of Staff          Firm       Area of                  Position Assigned               Task Assigned
                                  Expertise




2. Support Staff

Name of Staff          Firm       Area of                  Position Assigned               Task Assigned
                                  Expertise




D: Reasons for applying for this Region: Give in detail the capability of the organization/agency and
   the experience etc. to support the claim.

E: Methodology and Organization of Study: The sample procedure, sample size and study tools are
   given in the TOR. Please suggest:

(i) sample selections in detail;
(ii) Study tools refinements;
(iii) How you would complete the study in time? and
(iv) How to achieve quality?




        RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                              13
F: ANY OTHER DETAIL WHICH IS RELEVANT TO THE BID CERTIFICATE

 It is certified that:

1. The information given above is TRUE to the best of my knowledge. The organization
   shall stand liable for any information given above which is later found to be FALSE, including the
   forfeiture of any payment due to it.

2. The information given above is COMPLETE to the best of my knowledge and I have
   not willingly suppressed any material information that might lead to misjudgments while
   evaluating this Technical Bid.

3. The professionals, staff, equipment and all requisite infrastructural facilities mentioned in this bid shall
   be made available for this study in due time.

4. Our agency/organization/institution is interested to undertake the proposed evaluation.

5. I am competent to sign this Certificate.



                                                                                       Date: Authorized
Signatory

                                                                                       Place: Name:

                                                                                      Seal of the Organization:

                                                                                       Designation:




       RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                            14
Financial Bid
                                                                                   Annexure-3

            Evaluation of Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) Chhattisgarh State in
                      Division of :……………………………………………
                                (use separate sheet for each division)


Name of Bidder Agency/Organization with address: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

FINANCIAL BID
Sr. No.                             Head Total Cost (Rs.)

1         Salary of key professionals
2         Salary of field staff and support staff
3         Travel for key person
4         Travel for Field & Secretariat staff
5         Contingent expenses
6         Office expenses**
7         Total (1+2+3+4+5+6)
8         Institutional Overheads if any, and basis of charge
9         Service Tax, if any to be charged
          Grand Total (7+8+9) (In

          words______________________________________________________)




** Office expenses: Include expenses for required numbers of final report and 5
Compact Disks.


Date: Authorized Signatory ______________

Place: Name: ___________________________

Seal of the Organization: Designation: ______________________




      RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                          15
Annexure-4

                      Form A – Appraisal of the technical proposal

Bidder                          Bidder Name                              No. of Separate
 No.                                                                      Documents¹
                                                                           Including
                                                                            Annexes
1
2
3
4
5
6

1. Essential Criteria

 No.                              Criteria
1.            The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 25,
          00,000 in at least one of the past three years (2007-08,
          2008-09, and 2009-10).
2              Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies
          projects with minimum project cost of Rs. 3,00,000/- for
          any Government (State/Central) / Government
          Autonomous Bodies / Government Corporation for
          building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3
          years (Please attach copy of work orders).
3             Out of this, at least 2 (two) evaluations should have
          been successfully completed. (Please attach copy of
          completion certificate from the client).
4              The agency/organization should have at least 5 years
          relevant experience carrying out evaluations studies
          (Please attach copy of evidence)
5              The firm / company / organization should be
          registered as per law. (Please attach copy of evidence).
6              No consortium is allowed to bid for the study
7              Applicants should not be under a declaration of
          ineligibility for corrupt and fraudulent practices issued by
          Government of India / State Governments. A
          self-declaration certificate should be enclosed.

       RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                           16
8               The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 20,
            00,000 in at least one of the past three years    (2007-08,
            2008-09, and 2009-10).
9                Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies
            projects with minimum project cost of Rs. 3,00,000/- for
            any Government (State/Central) / Government
            Autonomous Bodies / Government Corporation for
            building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3
            years (Please attach copy of work orders).


Any other remarks
______________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________


If the answer to any one of the above criteria is “No”, then the bid is rejected at this stage itself.
There is no need to progress any further.


¹A document is considered separate if it is stapled/ bound as a single entity. Even a one page covering letter should be considered
as a separate document.
²specific years must be mentioned.




2. Desirable Criteria
No.                                 Criteria                                  1      2      3       4       5      6      7      8

1.          Specific experience of the Consultants in
            conducting:
                                a. Household Survey-20 marks
                                    b. health surveys-10 marks
         c. working with Government experience- 5 marks
2.          Adequacy of the proposed methodology and
            work plan in responding to the Terms of
            Reference and demonstrating an understanding of
            RSBY
         a. Technical approach and methodology-10 marks
         b. Work plan-5 marks
         c. Organization and staffing-10 marks
3.          Key professional staff qualifications and
            competence for the assignment
         a. Team Leader-10 marks
         b. Other Key Members-10 mark
4.          Suitability of training program -10 marks
         a. Relevance of training program -5 marks
         b. Training approach and methodology- 5 marks
                                Total: 100
        RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                                                              17
I hereby certify that after perusing through the documents supplied by the bidder
(………………………………………………………………………………………….............) it is my
opinion that this bidder should be …………………………..(accepted or rejected)³
________________________________________
³Please enter one of the decisions, in your own handwriting.

Bidder with more than 70% (70 marks out of 100) will be considered for Commercial
Evaluation.
COMMERCIAL OPENING

         Commercial opening will be done and on the basis of price quoted bidder will be termed
          as – L1, L2, L3 and so on… as per the rank of lowest price quoted.


BID EVALUATION

         If commercial bids for bidder 1, 2, 3, 4… are taken as L1, L2, L3, L4… where Lmin is the
          lowest bid then the weightage given to commercial bids would be:
          Lmin/L1, Lmin/L2, Lmin/L3, L4/Lmin and so on...
         Similarly weightage will be calculated for Technical Evaluation: T1/Tmax, T2/Tmax,
          T3/Tmax, T4/Tmax and so on… for bidder 1, 2, 3, 4… respectively
         Each proposal would be evaluated against the 70 – 30 Criteria. This means 70% weightage
          will be given to Technical Proposal 30% to Financial Proposal.
AWARD
Finally the technical and commercial scores obtained by all the vendors would be summed and
the bidder with highest score would be AWARDED THE BID.
The final scores of the vendors would be as given below –
Bidder 1:
(T1/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L1*0.3)
Bidder 2:
(T2/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L2*0.3)
Bidder 3:
(T3/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L3*0.3)
Bidder 4:
(T4/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L4) *0.3
The vendor with the highest marks computed above on cost and quality basis will be awarded the
bid.


         RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh                                            18
Annexure 5
                                              RSBY QUESTIONNAIRE
                          Post-enrolment Survey of the RSBY Programme
A 0 : CONSENT TO PARTICIPATE IN INTERVIEW
Household ID : __ __ __ __ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _


INTERVIEWER - Read out: Namaskar. My name is (please say your name here). I am asked by the Government of
Chhattisgarh, to conduct a survey with BPL people in Chhattisgarh to understand the penetration of Rashtriya Swasthya
Bima Yojana (RSBY). We will be asking you questions related to RSBY. We would appreciate your participation in this
survey. The information collected would be kept confidential. The survey should take a short time to complete.
                                Oral consent given (circle one):       YES – ContinueNO -- Stop the survey

    1.   Signature of Investigator_____________________
    2.   Date             Month       Year


A 1 : INTERVIEWER: COMPLETE (WHAT EVER APPLICABLE) BEFORE BEGINNING THE MODULE.
                                                                      Code

A1.1      State                    Gujarat…………..1
                                   Haryana…………..2
A1.2      District
A1.3      Village
A1.4      Hamlet name
A1.5      Block/Circle
A1.6      Rural/Urban
A1.7      Name of Gram
          Panchayat
A1.8      Address
A1.9      Family ID
A1.10     RSBY Status              RSBY Enrolled household ………….…1
                                   RSBY hospitalized household …………….2
                                   Non RSBY household …………………….3

  3.     Date of visit:      Day             Month         Year
  4.     Interview starting time: Hours              Minutes




                                                                                                                  19
A.2.1 BPL card No. :                                                                                              write 0 if not available


        A.2.2 Ration card No. :                                                                                           write 0 if not available


        A.2.3 RSBY card No : 2008:                                                                                                 , 0 if not available


         A.2.4                  2009 :                                                                                              0 if not available

                                                      SECTION B. HOUSEHOLD ROSTER

B.1            B.2.             B.3.      B.4.      B.5.       B.6.      B.7.       B.8.      B.9       B.10     Is name member of the following?
Me            Name             Relati    Age        sex      Marita     level       main    Presen      If no,   Y …………1, N ………..2
mbe     Enter the names       onship     If         M.1      l status     of       occup      tly        why      B.11    B.12     B.13     B.14             B.15
r ID    starting with the      with      less       F..2                educ        ation   living        not     BPL    Ration RSBY NREG                    No. of
        household head          the      than               (use        ation      of ID?   in the       (use             card     card                      days
                               head      one                code)       attain      (use    house       code)                                                worked
                              (use       year                             ed       codes)   Y….1                                                             in
                              codes)     write                           (use               N ….2                                                            NREG(l
                                         zero                           code)                                                                                ast year)




   Relationship Codes         Marital status               Education Codes                           Occupational Codes                   Presently not living
                                                                                                                                                reasons
 Head …………
                   1
 Spouse ………                                        Upto class 1 ………...       1
                   2
 Father ………..                                      Upto class2 …………          2        Farming          …………………………                1
                   3
 Mother ……….                                       Upto class 3 …………         3        Livestock Rearing………………………                 2
                   4
 Son …………                                          Upto class 4 …………         4        Salaried Job …………………………….                  3       Living separately
                   5        Married ……...      1
 Daughter ……                                       Upto class 5………….         5        Currently not working …………………              4       in the same
                   6        Divorced …….       2
 Brother                                           Upto class 6………….         6        Enrolled full time in School/Madrassa ..   5       village ……….            1
                   7        Separated ……       3
 Sister                                            Upto class 7 …………         7        Self Employed/ Trader …………………              6       Moved to some
                   8        Widowed …….        4
 Father in law                                     Upto class 8 …………         8        Employed Skilled Laborer ……………..           7       other                   2
                   9        Never Married.     5
 Mother in law                                     Upto class 9 ………...       9        Employed Unskilled Laborer …………..          8       village/town …...       3
                   10
 Grand son                                         Upto class 10 ……….        10       Too young to work ……………………..               9       Passed away …..         4
                   11
 Grand daughter                                    Upto class 11 ……….        11       Housewife/Housekeeping ………………              10      Got married …..
                   12
 Grand father                                      Upto class 12 ……….        12       Too Old to work ………………………..                11      Name was never
                   13
 Grand mother                                      Graduate and above ../    13       Enrolled full time in College …………..       12      the part of this        5
                   14
 Brother in law                                    Other diploma ……..        14       Other (Specify) …………………………                 13      family …….. ,…
                   15
 Sister in law                                     Never attended school     15       Does not work ………………………….                  14
                   16
 Other (Specify)                                   Nursery …………….            16       Don’t know ……………………………                     999
                   17
 Daughter-in-                                      Don’t know ………..          999
                   18
 law




                                                                                                                                                     20
SECTION C. HOUSEHOLD CHARACTERISTICS

C.1




C.2


C.3    Do you rent or own the house you live        Rent…………………….1
       in?                                          Own…………………….2
                                                    Rent Free house ............... 3
C.4



C.5    Do you have a separate toilet?               Yes……………………1
                                                    No…………………….2

C.6

C.7


C.8    What is the source of drainage               Open kutcha - 1, Open pucca - 2
                                                    Covered pucca - 3, Under ground – 4;
                                                    No drainage - 5
C.9    Does the family own any cultivable           Yes……………………1
       land?                                        No…………………….2                 C.12
       (in the native village)                      Does Not Know........-999     C.12



C.10   What is the total area of cultivable land?   ________Acres..........................1
                                                    ________Bighas........................2
                                                    ________Biswa .........................3
                                                    Does Not Know……………-999
C.11   What is main source of drinking water        Piped water
       for members of your household?               Piped into residence/yard/plot…..…1
                                                    Public tap……………………..…....2
                                                    Public hand pump………………....3
                                                    Hand pump in residence/yard/plot ..4
                                                    Well water
                                                    Covered well in residence/yard/plot..5
                                                    Open private well…………………..6
                                                    Covered public well………………7
                                                    Open public well………………….8
                                                    Surface water……………………..9
                                                    Spring water……………………….10
                                                    Pond/Lake…………………………11
                                                    Dam……………………………….12


                                                                                               21
Rainwater…………………………13
                                                            Tanker truck………………………14
                                                            Other (specify)…………………-777
                                                            _____________________________
      C.12     Is Water Treated Before Drinking?            Yes - 1,
                                                            No -2  C.19


      C.13     If 1 in item , type of water treatment       Ultra-violet/resin/reverse osmosis – 1,
               (code)                                       Boiling – 2, Filter – 3, Cloth – 4,
                                                            Any disinfectant – 5, Others – 777




                                         SECTION D: INCOME AND BORROWINGS

D.1   Who of the household        Nobody………………….1          D.2
      members worked and                    Last month(in   Last year(in Rs.)                 no. of days worked   No. of hours
      how much did each           ID
                                            Rs.)                                              in a month           worked a day
      member earn ?
      (INDICATE
      HOUSEHOLD BOARD
      NUMBER)




D.2   Is there any other source   Yes……………….1
      of income for the           No………………..2             D.4
      family? (eg. Pension,       Don’t know….-999        D.4
      rent, remittances etc. )    Will not answer…….-888  D.4
D.3   If yes, how much did                                                                      Income
                                  Source
      you get from that source
                                  …………………………
      last month?
                                  ………………………..
D.4   In last one year have you   Yes……………….1  give details
      borrowed from               No………………..2                 section E
      somewhere for some          Don’t know….-999            section E
      purpose?                    Will not answer…….-888  section E
D5    Details of borrowings       Amount          Source of borrowing (see codes below)         Reason of borrowing (see codes below)
       Sr No.                     borrowed
      1                                                 ,                                             ,
      2                                                 ,                                             ,
      3                                                 ,                                             ,
      4                                                 ,                                             ,




                                                                                                                         22
Source of borrowing                             Reason of borrowing

From friends and family without interest……..1   Start a new business…………….……...1
From friends and family with interest……..2      Acquire agricultural machinery or agricultural inputs …….…2
From moneylender...3                            Purchase stock for existing business………………………….…3
From bank………....4                               Repay old debt………………………..4
From MFI………….5                                  For health related expenses..………………………….….5
From chit funds…….6                             Marriage…………………..…………….6
From other financial institutions……….7          Funeral………………..………………7
From NGO……..…..8                                Festival/Other Ceremony.........................8
From SHG……..…..9                                Houseold consumption/Purchase household durable…..……….9
Others (specify)… - 777                         Home improvement/repair/construction….10
Don’t know……-999;                               Unemployment……………..………...11
Will not answer……..-888                         Purchase land………………..……….12
                                                Education…………………………..…13
                                                Purchase jewelry…….………………14
                                                Buy livestock…………………...…….15
                                                Other (specify)… ……………….…-777
                                                ___________________________
                                                Don’t know…………………..-999




                                                                                                 23
SECTION D.1: HOUSEHOLDS SOCIAL NETWORK

        Is anyone in the family presently a       SHG ………………………. 1
D.1.1   member of any of the following?           cooperative ………… ……...2                                 ,    ,
        (multiple answers possible)               trade union ………….…..3
                                                  NGO/MFI client ……….… 4                              ,        ,
                                                  village committees (e.g. VEC; ICDS) …...... 5   ,
                                                  political party ……………… 6
                                                  religious organization …..…..7
                                                  RWA (urban areas) …….…8
                                                  other membership-based organization ……. 9
                                                  No ……………………….. 22
                                                  Don’t know ……………...-999
        Do you or your family members             Yes...........................…..........1
D.1.2   personally know the sarpanch/ nigam       No ..........................…...........2
        parishad/ MLA or any ward member for      Don’t Know...........…......-999
        your gram panchayat ?                     .

D.1.3



        What is your main source of information   friends and family ….…..1
D.1.4   about government programs ?               media (print, visual or audio) ...2                     ,    ,
                                                  local panchayat workers/officials…….…….3
                                                  administration officials ……..4                      ,        ,
                                                  religious leaders ……………..5
                                                  MLA ………………………6
                                                  Local NGO ………………… 7
                                                  other______ (specify) ……-777
        How often does any member of your         Every week..1
D.1.5   family travel to -                        At least Once a month,,,,2                              1.
            1. block HQ                           At least once a quarter….3
            2. district HQ                        At least once in Year…..4
                                                  Never………………….5                                          2.




                                                                                                                   24
SECTION F:      F.1 HOUSEHOLD HEALTH (FOR ALL INDIVIDUALS FROM HOUSEHOLD
                                                 BOARD)
           (INTERVIEWER: SHOW THE LADDER TO THE RESPONDENT WHERE EVER REQUIRED)
F.1.1       F.1.3           F.1.4      F.1.5 Is
ID codes    . Is he/she     If yes,    he/she
            facing any      describe   taking
            recurrent       the        medicines
            medical         condition? regularly
            problem that               for this
            has lasted for             problem?
            more than one              Yes….1
            month?                     No…..2
            Yes….1                     Don’t
            No…..2                    know….-
            F.1.6                      999
            Don’t know….-
            99 F.1.6




                                                                                      25
F.2 HOUSEHOLD HEALTH EVENT AND HOSPITALISATION

      F.2.1      Does any of your family member has some health         Yes………………………………….1
                 related problem that may need hospitalization in       No…………………………………..2                                         F.2.3
                 the next 6 months?                                     Will Not Answer……..……….…-888                               F.2.3
                                                                        Does Not Know…………………-999                                   F.2.3
     F.2.2       Who you think would require hospitalization and        HH board no
                 for what?
                                                                                     ………………
                                                                                     ………………..
                                                                                 …………………………….
     F.2.3       Was anyone in your family very sick or severely        Yes………………………………….1
                 injured in the last two years?                         No…………………………………..2                                         F.3
                                                                        Does Not Know…………………-999                                   F.3

     F.2.4       How many cases like these happened in the last two year?


                                                    F.3 DESCRIPTION OF HEALTH EVENTS
                 Interviewer: ask the respondent if any one in the household suffered from major health event in last two
                 years. Fill the details of all the members of the household who had/ are having major health event in
                 following table:
F.3.1. ID      F.3.2.          F.3.4.How serious was this    F.3.5.              F.3.6.          F.3.7.                            F.3.8       F.3.9          F.3.10 How
codes of       What was the health event / condition?        For how long did Is he/she still Was [name]                           Which type Did [name] have many days
those who      major health    Caused death…1 F.3.7         this health event / taking a        hospitalized as a                 of hospital surgery as a   the [name]
had major      event that      Caused permanent inability to condition cause a treatment for result of this                        was [name] result of this  was admitted
health event   [name]          perform normal daily          temporary           this condition? major health                      admitted? major health     to the
               suffered?       activities….2 F.3.6          inability OR        Yes…..1         event?                            Governmen event?           hospital for
               Disease….1      Caused temporary              inconvenience to N…....2            Yes…...1                          t……1        Yes….......1   more than 24
               Accident..2     inability to perform          perform normal Don’t know....- No….….2 Don’t                          Private…2 No…….2           hrs?
               Complicated     normal daily                  daily activities? 999               know....-                         Don’t       Don’t know
               birth….3        activities……….…3              Days ….1                            999                               know…- …….-999
               Other-specify Caused no inability to perform Weeks…2                                                                999
               …-777           normal daily                  Months ..3
               Don’t know.999 activities, but was an         Don’t know....-999
               Can’t say..-555 inconvenience……4
                               No inability was
                               caused…....5 F.3.6
                               Don’t know....-999 F.3.6




 F.3a Has it ever happened that a very serious illness/death could      Yes..............................……....................1
 not be treated at hospital because of lack of money?                   No ...............................……..................2      F.4
                                                                        Don’t Know........……..……............-999
 F.3b Mention the member Id of that person from the above table




                                                                                                                                                        26
F.4. HEALTH-RELATED BEHAVIOR (head of the family)

 F.4.1    Do you or anyone in the family smoke? __         F.4.2 Indicate number of cigarettes smoked per
                                                           day:
    Yes.....................................1              (1-9) ……………………..…… 1
    No ....................................2  F.4.3       (10-19) …………………….…. 2
                                                           (20-29) ……………………….. 3
                                                           (30 OR MORE) ….……….… 4
 F.4.3 Do you drink alcoholic beverages?                   F.4.4 How would you rate your consumption?
 Yes................................1                             Daily ………………1
          No ................................2  F.4.5            3-5 days a week ………….. 2
                                                                 Less than 3 days a week ……. 3
                                                                 Occasionally ………………….. 4
 F.4.5 Are your kids vaccinated for pulse polio?           F.4.6 Have your kids got any other vaccination?
   Yes.....................................1                  Yes.....................................1
   No ....................…..............2                    No ....................…..............2


            SECTION G: RSBY


          INTERVIEWER: FOLLOWING SECTION SHOULD BE FILLED IN ONLY FOR HOUSEHOLDS WHO
          ARE AWARE OF RSBY CARD/SCHEME. FOR THOSE WHO ARE NOT AWARE, DIRECTLY JUMP TO
          SECTION H.
G.5 Awareness of RSBY
                                                   G.5.2 Where did you get to know about
G.5.1 Are you aware of RSBY scheme?                the scheme?
      Yes ……………………………..1                           Through friends / neighbours ……….…1
      No … …………………………..2                          Through Radio / TV / newspaper ..........2
    SECTION H                                      Through leaflets/brochure ………..….…3
                                                   Through Health Staff ………………...…4
                                                   Area Committee members/ Community
                                                   Educators.... 5
                                                   Panchayat………………….6
                                                   Ration shop keeper ……………………..7
                                                   NGO personnel ..................................... 8
                                                   Survey people ........................................9
                                                   Others (specify) ……………….…..-777
G.5.3 Do you know who is eligible for the scheme?  G.5.4     Is your family eligible for the
      Everyone…………………1                             scheme?
      Only BPL families ………….2                            Yes ………………………..1
      Only AAY families ……………3                            No … ……………………..2
      Only NREGA card holders ……4                         Don’t know …………..-..999
      Others(specify) ....................-777
      Don’t know …………...-999
G.5.5 How much does it cost to enroll in this      G.5.6 What is the maximum amount per
scheme? ( in Rs.)                                  year that can be spent? ( in Rs.)
       Zero ………………0                                        Don’t know………………….-999
       Rs 30..................................30
       Others (specify) ...............-777
       Don’t know……………….-999
G.5.7 Is free treatment provided in the hospitals  G.5.8 Are transportation allowances
under this scheme?                                         provided to the patient?
      Yes ……………………..1                                      Yes ………………………..1
      No … ……………………..2                                     No … ………………………..2



                                                                                                             27
Don’t know …………………-999                                                           Don’t know ………….…-999
G.5.9 Do you have to pay for the medical tests                                 G.5.10 Do you have to pay for medicines
during hospitalisation if you enroll in this                                   and drugs in case of hospitalisation if you
scheme?                                                                        enrol in this scheme?
        Yes …………………..1                                                                   Yes …………………..1
        No … ……………………..2                                                                 No ………………..2
       Don’t know ……….……-999                                                     Don’t know……………..-..999
G.5.11 How many household members can be                                       G.5.12 Which year did enrolment take
enrolled?                                                                      place? (multiple answers possible)
        At most 5 members …..1                                                 2008 ……………1
        All household members ………2                                             2009 ……………………2
        Others (specify) …………. -777                                            2010 …………………………………3
        Don’t know ……………….-999
                                                                               Don’t know……………-999
G.6 Which year did you apply to obtain the card?                               G.7 Why didn’t you apply? (multiple                            ,        ,
   2008…………....1  G.7.2                                                       answers possible)
    2009… ………..2  G.7.1                                                       Booth too far away……….…......….1                               ,        ,
   2010                                                                        It’s of no use. ………….......…….2
   Both (2008 & 2009)....3  G.7.3                                             Get similar facilities in government
   Didn’t apply at all ......... 4  G.7                                       hospitals.............3
                                                                               Didn’t find any hospital in the list which
                                                                               is closer to my place..….4
                                                                               Distrust in scheme……………...5
                                                                               Did not have proper documents to support
                                                                               family’s identity…......6
                                                                               Did not feel comfortable with the
                                                                               technology involved (eg. Use of smart
                                                                               cards)…….... ...7
                                                                               Didn’t understand the scheme……...8
                                                                               Not eligible for the scheme ............ 9
                                                                               Others (specify) .........................-777
                                                                                Section H
G.7.1 Why didn’t you apply in the first round?                             ,   G.7.2 why didn’t you reapply?                                  ,        ,
Booth too far away……….…...............................….1                      Booth too far away……….…......….1
Didn’t know about the scheme at that time............ 2                    ,   Didn’t get to know about enrolments......2                     ,        ,
Didn’t get to know about enrolments .. ............... 3                   ,   Had bad experience with hospital ..........3
Didn’t find any hospital in the list which is closer to                        Was not satisfied in first round .............5
my place..........................................................….4      ,   Didn’t get chance to use card in first
Did not have proper documents to support family’s                              round .....................................................6
identity…..............................................................5       Didn’t find any hospital in the list which
Didn’t understand the scheme…......................…...6                       is closer to my place this time.............7
                                                                               Name on on the list ............................. 8




        Interviewer: select whichever year family has enrolled in. choose the latest year if family has enrolled both
        the times.




                                                                                                                                                  28
G.8 For those who applied
G.8.1      Was any list of eligible families                             G.8.2   When did enrolment happen?
publicly displayed before enrolment began?
       Yes …………………………..1                                                         Don’t know …………..999
        No … …………………..2
       Don’t know ……………-999
G.8.4      How much time did it take to reach                            G.8.5 How far was the enrollment
enrolment station?                                                       station from your house? (in kms)
         5-10 mins …………………1                                                       within 2 km ……………1
        10-20 mins …………………..2                                                     2-5 kms …………...2
        20-30 mins ……….…….……3                                                     5-8kms ……………3
        >30 mins …………………4                                                         more than 8 kms ………….4
       Don’t know …………..…-999                                                    Don’t know.……………-999

G.8.6    How did you get to know when and
where enrolment was happening?
  From        Posters           displayed            in the
  village..................................... 1              From district/ block officials...... 8
  From Word of mouth.............. 2                          From Loudspeaker announcement......9
  From NGO personnel............. 3                           From Wall writings.......... 10
  From Sarpanch....................... 4                      From Nukkad natak ......... 11
  From ANMs...........................5                       From Aanganwadi Worker... 12
  From AWWs ........................6                         Others (pl. specify) .......... 999
  From ASHA.........................7
G.9 Did you obtain the RSBY card?                                        G.9.1      Why didn’t you obtain it? ?
Round 1. ...........................................                     (multiple answers possible)
Round 2 ……………………………..                                                    First round .                            ,   ,   ,
Yes ……………….1                       Section G.10                         Second round
No … …………...2                    G.9.1                                   Household head died …….……….1            ,   ,   ,
                                                                          Household not on the BPL list ……2
                                                                          Didn’t have required documents ….3
                                                                          Wait was too long …………………4
                                                                          Were asked to come again …………5
                                                                          Refused without any reason ………6
                                                                          There were problems at enrolment
                                                                          station…………...7
                                                                          Didn’t apply ................. 8
                                                                          Other ( specify ) …………………999

                                                                          Section H




                                                                                                                              29
G.10     For RSBY card holders
G.10.1 PLEASE SHOW YOUR RSBY                                           G.10.2      What problems did you face in
CARD.                                                                  obtaining the card?
Showed it………….….….….1                                                    ( Add extra sheets if required)
Did not want to show……..….2
Lost it………………..…………3
Someone has taken it (is with some one) .…4
Its with hospital ..………………5
Other (specify)…………….…-777
G.10.3 How many members of the family                                  G.10.4 How long did it take you to complete
are covered?                                                           the whole enrolment process?
                                                                       Less than one hour ………….1
                                                                       1-2 hours …………………2
                                                                       2-4 hours………….……….3
                                                                       4-6 hours ………………….4
                                                                       more than a day ……….…..5

G.10.5 Did you get smart card on the spot?                             G.10.8 Did you make any payments to get
      Yes …………………………..1                                                hold of it?
      No … ………………………..2
                                                                       Zero …………………0
                                                                       Rupees 30 ..................30
                                                                       Don’t know.……….-999

G.10.7     Which of the following pieces of                            G.10.6 Were you told about the date when
information did you get along with the card?                  ,   ,    you could start using the smart card?
  List of hospitals………………..1                                           Yes …. 1       No …. 2
  How to use the card………….….2                                 ,
  Who to contact in case of any query…..3
  Information about district kiosk .......... 4
  Didn’t get any ..................................... 5
Other (specify)……………………-777
G.10.8      Which is the nearest RSBY                                  G.10.9 Are you satisfied with the scheme?
empanelled hospital?                                                          Yes ……………………………..1
                                                           _________          No … …………………………..2
Don’t know ...................-999

G.10.10 Would you like to enrol next year
also?
Yes ………………………..1
No … ……………………..2
 Don’t know ……………………-999




                                                   G.11 INDIVIDUAL ENROLMENT
G.11.1            G.11.2Is ID          G.11.3 If no, why not?                At school at the time of enrolment…..2
ID                enrolled in          Five person limit …………….…..1;         Out of village at the time of enrolment...4

                                                                                                                     30
RSBY          At work at the time of enrolment……..3;          Not eligible by relationship ……….6
scheme?       Was not well on the day of enrolment....5;      Name is not on the ration card …….7;
  Yes ……..1   Name not on the BPL list ……..…..8               Refused by enrolment team …………..9
  No……...2    Did not know that name needed to show up ..10   Was not at home at the time of enrolment .11
 G.11.3      Not required ( person is healthy enough) ..12   Married …………………………………. 13
              Passed away …………………........ 14                  Others (specify) ………………………..-777




                                                                                                 31
SECTION H: MEDICAL TREATMENT (inpatient/outpatient)
Interviewer: Ask respondent who in their family needed outpatient services in the last 30days.
(explain properly what OPD is- that they were not hospitalized but had consulted the doctor, chemist, quack, local
vaidya, and had bought medicine/ paid consultation fee etc.)
H.1. Particulars of medical treatment received as Outpatient during the last 30 days
H.1.1      sr1. no. of the OPD case         1               2             3              4              5
H.1.2      Name & srl. no. of member (as
           in col. 1, block 4/5)
           hospitalised
H.1.3      Age (years) (as in col. 5, block
           4 / col. 4, block 5)
H.1.4      Date of First Visit

H.1.5     Number of visits
H.1.6     Total Expenditure during the
          OPD visit (in Rs.)
H.1.7     Medicine (in Rs.)
H.1.8     Diagnostic test (in Rs.)
H.1.9     Transportation (in Rs.)
H.1.10    Whether the person was
          Covered by RSBY?(Yes -1,
          No 2)


                     H.2a: Maternity experience                            Last          Next to Last    Second from
                                                                           Pregnancy     Pregnancy       Last
                                                                                                         pregnancy
H.2a.1    Who in your family got pregnant in the last 5 years? (starting
with the most recent ones) ( continue with the same lady if she has
successive birth histories otherwise switch to another)
Noone  H.3
H.2a.2 Member id from roster
H.2a.3   Date of Birth
         If dead ………………….. 88  H.2a.6
H.2a.5   What is the present age of child born?
         Living …..1, dead……. 2
H.2a.6 Where did birth take        place?
Home…………………………1                    Village clinic at ANM…….….7
Govt/Munic Hospital………….2          Other Public Health Facility..8
GovtDispensary………………..3            NGO/Trust
PHC/CHC………………..….…4                Hospital…………………9
Sub- Centre…………..…….….5            Pvt Hosp/Maternity
Anganwadi Centre………..….6           Home……..….10
                                   Other
                                   private……………………..…11
                                   Other………………….………..…..999
H.2a.7 If the delivery did not     place in a health facility then what
take                               was the reason?
Costs too much……………..…1            No Female Provider at Service….5
Facility not open………….....2        Husband/ Family did not allow……6
No nearby centre………….…...3         Not Necessary……… …..……..…..7
Don’t trust facility/ Poor         Not Customary……………………..8
Service…………...4                    Other………           …(Specify) 999




                                                                                                                 32
Ask respondent about all hospitalization cases in the family in the last two years ( including maternity
hospitalization)
H.2. Particulars of medical treatment received as Inpatient of a hospital during the last two years
H.2.1    sr1. no. of the hospitalisation case                          1        2          3       4       5
H.2.2    Name & srl. no. of member (as in col. 1, block 4/5)
         hospitalised
H.2.3    Type of hospital: Public hospital(PHC/sub centres/CHC).1,
         public dispensary(incl. CGHS/ESI) ……….2,
         private hospital………..3
         Add hospital name
H.2.4    When was patient admitted? (month/ year)
H.2.5    Duration of stay in hospital (days)
H.2.6    Whether patient was hospitalized using RSBY card? (Yes -
         1, No 2)
H.2.7    If no, why not?
         Name not on RSBY card……………………………………….1;
         Name is there but it was an emergency ……………………. 2;
         Bad experience with RSBY ……………………….…………..3 ;
         Neighbors had bad experience with RSBY……..…………. 4
         No nearby hospital …………………………………………... 5 ;
         Card didn’t work in hospital ………………………….…….6
         No balance in the card ………………………………………7 ;
         Hospital refused ………………………….…..………………. 8
         this disease was not covered………….…………………..…9;
         didn’t know disease was covered………………………..….10
         Others ……(specify..…….999




                                                                                                           33
H.3 Details of medical services
received
H.3.1 srl. no. of the
hospitalization case
H.3.2 Name and srl. no. of
member hospitalized
H.3.3 Why this particular hospital
was chosen for treatment?
Close to home…..…1,
Reputation is good..2,
Suggested by the relative/
friends…...3,
Referred by doctors….4,
Always go to this hospital……5,
there is no other RSBY
empanelled hospitals nearby…6,
Other( specify)....999
H.3.4 Did surgery take place?
  Yes … 1 No …….2
H.3.5 Did patient take medicine ?
Yes … 1 No …….2
H.3.6 Were X-
ray/ECG/EEG/Scan/ Diagnostic
tests conducted?
Yes … 1 No …….2
H.3.7 Whether treatment availed
before hospitalisation?
   Yes … 1 No …….2
H.3.8 If yes above, what is
source of treatment public
hospital (incl. PHC/ sub-
centres/CHC)…..… 1,
public dispensary (incl.
CGHS/ESI)………….2,
private hospital ……….. 3,
private doctor …..…… 4
H.3.9 Whether treatment
continued after discharge from
hospital ?               Yes … 1
No …….2
H.3.9a What was the source of
treatment?
Public hospital (incl. PHC/ sub-
centres/CHC)…..… 1,
public dispensary (incl.
CGHS/ESI)…..….2,
private hospital …… 3,
private doctor …..…… 4
H.3.9b Duration of treatment
H.3.10 Did you buy medicine
on your own?
 Yes … 1 No …….2
H.3.11 If yes, how much did
you spend on medicine?(in Rs.)
H.3.12 Did you spend anything
for getting diagnostic tests done?
  Yes … 1 No …….2
H.3.13 If yes, how much? (in
Rs.)
H.3.14 Any other amount that is
incurred on this health event
besides medicine and tests? (in
Rs.) (mention the cause also)
H.3.15 What is the total cost
incurred by the household for this
health event? (in Rs.)
H.3.16 What was the source of
this expenditure?
 Household savings/ income ..1
Contribution from
friends/relatives ………2
 Borrowings……….. 3
Sale of assets/ ornaments…. 4
H.3.17 Received any
reimbursement (Rs) from any
source such as government,
employer, insurance company, or
other agencies?
Yes …1 , No …….2
H.4: Transportation
H.4.1 How far is the hospital
from your house
(Approximately)?
H.4.2 How did the patient go to
the hospital?) Bus-1
Metro……….2 ;
Rickshaw………3; Two
wheeler…..4 Three
wheeler……..5; Car……....6;
Bus…………7 Others (please
specify)-……………………..999
H.4.3 What was the estimated
cost to reach the hospital?
H.4.4 Did the hospital
reimburse the cost of transport?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.4.5 How much was the
reimbursement? (in Rs.)

H.5: Inpatient experience
H.5.1 Was there a separate
RSBY help desk at the hospital or
it was at the reception only?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.5.2 How long did the patient
have to wait before he/she was
attended by the staff?
Less than 15 minute-1;         15 to
30 minutes…….2,; 30 to 60
minutes……3;           More than 60
minutes..4 Others, specify-
……..999
H.5.3 Was fingerprint
verification done through a
fingerprint scanner?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.5.4 Was the family told about
the cost involved for treating the
patient in advance?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.5.5 If yes, what was the cost?
(in Rs.)
H.5.6 Was the family told about
the money left in the smart card?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.5.7 Was the money in the card
sufficient to pay for this
treatment?         Yes ....1; No ......2
H.5.8 If the money in the card
was not sufficient was the patient
told that he would have to pay the
difference?           Yes ....1; No
......2
H.5.9 How much was the
shortfall in the card from the
package/ treatment rate? (in Rs.)
H.5.10 How was the admission
advised through?
Emergency……….1
;OPD……….2;
Referral…………3; Other (Please
Specify)……………….-999
H.5.11 Was the staff at the
RSBY help-desk polite and
helpful? Yes ....1; No ......2

H.5.13 Was the patient provided
with food during stay at the
hospital?      Yes ....1; No ......2

H.6: Discharge
H.6.1 On discharge was
discharge summary provided to
the family? Yes ....1; No ......2
H.6.2 Was the fingerprint
verification done at the time of
discharge? Yes ....1; No ......2
H.6.3       When did you get the
RSBY card back?
After swiping at the time of
admission ........1 H.6.6
On discharge ........2 H.6.6
 Next day......3;
two days later ......4
Others specify).......................-999
H.6.5 What was the reason for
holding back the card?
Staff wanted money for returning
the card……...1 Staff wanted to
keep the card till insurance claims
were settled……….2;                    Staff
said the card will stay deposited at
the hospital …3
Others, specify-………….999
H.6.6 Were you told about the
amount of money left in the card
at the time of discharge?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.6.7 Do you know about 5 day
post hospitalization expenses
coverage in RSBY?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.6.8 Was the patient prescribed
any medicines after the discharge?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.6.9 For how many days the
medicines needed to be taken after
discharge?
H.6.10 Were these medicines
provided by the hospital?              Yes
....1; No ......2
H.6.11 These medicines were for
how many days?
H.6.12 Was the patient
prescribed any tests after
discharge?               Yes ....1; No
......2
H.6.13 Within how many days
of discharge those tests were
supposed to be done?
H.6.14 Were facilities for those
tests organized by the hospital
free of cost?
Yes ....1; No ......2
H.6.15 How is health of patient
now comparing when he was
admitted to the hospital?
Has died …..1;         No
improvement ……2
Partially improved …3; Has
improved completely ….4
H.6.17 Diagnosis
                                        …………….        …………….    …………….             …………….
H.6.17a                                              ………………    ………………             ………………             ………………
Treatment given …………….                  ………………       ………………    ………………             ………………             ………………
Medical ……………………                        ………………       ………………    ………………             ………………             ………………
Surgical ……………………..                     ………………       ………………    ………………             ………………             ………………
Duration of stay ……………                  ………………       ………………    ………………             ………………             ………………
If surgical ,surgery type …….           ………………       ………………    ………………             ………………             ………………
If the investigator is unable to find   ………………       ………………    ………………             ………………             …………………
specific answers please get a           ………………       ………………    ………………             ………………              ……………
photocopy of the discharge
summary
H.6.18 Was there a suggestion
for follow-up
Yes ....1; No ......2

H.7 : Details of patients who died after receiving treatment
H.7.1 When did the patient die?                                H.7.2 Probable cause of death
During the Hospital Stay-1                                     from hospital documents if any?
Immediately after discharge-2                                  …………………….
Within a week after discharge-3                                No documents available-77
Within a fortnight-4
Within a month-5
Others, specify-999
H.7.3 Did the patient receive any
medical care before he/she died?
     Yes ……………………..1
      No … ………………..2
H.8: Patient Satisfaction
H.8.1 Were all your patient                                    H.8.2 How would you rate your
related queries answered during                                satisfaction about the treatment
your visit to hospital for treatment                           provided at the hospital?
under RSBY?                                                    Excellent-1        Very good-2
     Yes ……………………..1                                           Good-3
      No … ………………..2                                           Average-4           Poor-5
H.8.3 Where would you have                                     H.8.4 Were you forced to give
gone if scheme had not been                                    money to any staff member?
there?                                                              Yes …………………..1
To the same hospital……..1                                            No … ………………..2
To any other private hospital..2                               H.8.6
To government hospital……….3
Doctors private clinic………4
Nowhere………………….5
Other ( specify) …………….999
Don’t know ……….777
H.8.5 if yes, how much did you                                 H.8.6 Will you recommend your
pay? (in Rs.)                                                  relatives/friends to take treatment
from the same hospital?
                                                                        Yes ……..1 section I
                                                                         No … …………..2
H.8.7 If no Why?                                                    Will you go back to the same
Treated badly-1                                                     hospital if the need arise again?
Poor quality care-2                                                 Yes
Not receptive to RSBY patients-3                                    No
There is no money in the RSBY
card-4
If no Why?
Treated badly-1
Poor quality care-2
Not receptive to RSBY patients-3



I: RESPONDENT DETAILS
I.1     Who answered the survey?                  Name
        (INDICATE Household board number)                _________________

I.2      Was there another respondent present     Yes………………………………..1
         during the interview?                    No…………………………………2                     J
I.3      What is the name of this respondent?     Name
         (INDICATE Household board number)
                                                  ______________________

                                                  Name not on the board……..990


SECTION J

THANK THE RESPONDENT FOR TAKING HIS TIME OUT FOR THE INTERVIEW.

MAKE SURE TO GET THE SIGNATURE ON THIS SHEET.

INTERVIEW ENDING TIME: HOURS                    MINUTES

COMMENTS


_______________________________________________________________________________




______________________________________________________________________________

Signature of the respondent
___________________________

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Rsby evaluation chhattisgarh rfp document updated 14th september 2011

vacancies in BDL 2015
vacancies in BDL 2015vacancies in BDL 2015
vacancies in BDL 2015Sudha Sati
 
Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020
Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020
Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020Trinity Care Foundation
 
Notification uiic-assistant-posts
Notification uiic-assistant-postsNotification uiic-assistant-posts
Notification uiic-assistant-postshodmech. acts
 
Scientist vacancies in National Institute of pathology
Scientist vacancies in National Institute of pathologyScientist vacancies in National Institute of pathology
Scientist vacancies in National Institute of pathologySudha Sati
 
notification HAL technicians 2015
notification HAL technicians 2015notification HAL technicians 2015
notification HAL technicians 2015Raja Kashyap
 
Chc in ppp mode general presentation
Chc  in ppp mode  general presentationChc  in ppp mode  general presentation
Chc in ppp mode general presentationpranayrajmalhotra
 
Leveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in India
Leveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in IndiaLeveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in India
Leveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in IndiaAttaluri Srinivasacharyulu
 
Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...
Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...
Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...Harish Mahavar
 
Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015
Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015
Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015Raja Kashyap
 
Application form undergraduate programs 1
Application form undergraduate programs  1Application form undergraduate programs  1
Application form undergraduate programs 1Wasim Haider
 
Introduction to public procurement
Introduction to public procurement Introduction to public procurement
Introduction to public procurement Dr. Heera Lal IAS
 

Ähnlich wie Rsby evaluation chhattisgarh rfp document updated 14th september 2011 (20)

vacancies in BDL 2015
vacancies in BDL 2015vacancies in BDL 2015
vacancies in BDL 2015
 
PMJAY - DyCEO NHA.pptx
PMJAY - DyCEO NHA.pptxPMJAY - DyCEO NHA.pptx
PMJAY - DyCEO NHA.pptx
 
Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020
Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020
Karnataka government health recruitment notification 16 June 2020
 
Rfp
RfpRfp
Rfp
 
Notification uiic-assistant-posts
Notification uiic-assistant-postsNotification uiic-assistant-posts
Notification uiic-assistant-posts
 
Scientist vacancies in National Institute of pathology
Scientist vacancies in National Institute of pathologyScientist vacancies in National Institute of pathology
Scientist vacancies in National Institute of pathology
 
notification HAL technicians 2015
notification HAL technicians 2015notification HAL technicians 2015
notification HAL technicians 2015
 
Arogya bandhu scheme ppp model
Arogya bandhu scheme ppp modelArogya bandhu scheme ppp model
Arogya bandhu scheme ppp model
 
Chc in ppp mode general presentation
Chc  in ppp mode  general presentationChc  in ppp mode  general presentation
Chc in ppp mode general presentation
 
Appsc
AppscAppsc
Appsc
 
PMJAY - Dy CEO NHA.pptx
PMJAY - Dy CEO NHA.pptxPMJAY - Dy CEO NHA.pptx
PMJAY - Dy CEO NHA.pptx
 
HOTEL R
HOTEL R HOTEL R
HOTEL R
 
Leveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in India
Leveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in IndiaLeveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in India
Leveraging Community Radio for Extension Reforms in India
 
Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...
Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...
Rfp document for preparation of comprehensive detailed project report for rej...
 
Rites vacancy
Rites vacancyRites vacancy
Rites vacancy
 
Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015
Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015
Aiims bhopal-junior-resident-notification 2015
 
Application form undergraduate programs 1
Application form undergraduate programs  1Application form undergraduate programs  1
Application form undergraduate programs 1
 
Officers recruitment 2014-15
Officers recruitment 2014-15Officers recruitment 2014-15
Officers recruitment 2014-15
 
RAdv_28_2023.pdf
RAdv_28_2023.pdfRAdv_28_2023.pdf
RAdv_28_2023.pdf
 
Introduction to public procurement
Introduction to public procurement Introduction to public procurement
Introduction to public procurement
 

Mehr von K Madan Gopal

Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...
Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...
Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...K Madan Gopal
 
3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmg
3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmg3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmg
3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmgK Madan Gopal
 
Elm slides private sector contribution in kind
Elm slides   private sector contribution in kindElm slides   private sector contribution in kind
Elm slides private sector contribution in kindK Madan Gopal
 
Engaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CG
Engaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CGEngaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CG
Engaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CGK Madan Gopal
 
ELM For po 13th january 2016
ELM For po 13th january 2016ELM For po 13th january 2016
ELM For po 13th january 2016K Madan Gopal
 
Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1
Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1
Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1K Madan Gopal
 
Rsby 5 nw tvcbs7 quality
Rsby 5 nw tvcbs7  qualityRsby 5 nw tvcbs7  quality
Rsby 5 nw tvcbs7 qualityK Madan Gopal
 
Engaging with industries for slw mp1.
Engaging with industries for slw mp1.Engaging with industries for slw mp1.
Engaging with industries for slw mp1.K Madan Gopal
 
Engaging with industries elm model
Engaging with industries elm modelEngaging with industries elm model
Engaging with industries elm modelK Madan Gopal
 
RSBY -DKMA Training
RSBY -DKMA Training RSBY -DKMA Training
RSBY -DKMA Training K Madan Gopal
 
Training of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBY
Training of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBYTraining of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBY
Training of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBYK Madan Gopal
 
Rsby expterience in cg
Rsby expterience in cgRsby expterience in cg
Rsby expterience in cgK Madan Gopal
 
For bhopal meeting july 2011
For bhopal meeting july 2011For bhopal meeting july 2011
For bhopal meeting july 2011K Madan Gopal
 
RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011
RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011
RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011K Madan Gopal
 

Mehr von K Madan Gopal (15)

Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...
Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...
Introduction to elm presented at National Sensitization workshop for Industre...
 
3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmg
3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmg3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmg
3 icohe session v 24.9.2016 dr kmg
 
Elm slides private sector contribution in kind
Elm slides   private sector contribution in kindElm slides   private sector contribution in kind
Elm slides private sector contribution in kind
 
Engaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CG
Engaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CGEngaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CG
Engaging with industries elm model- presentation during State level workshop CG
 
ELM For po 13th january 2016
ELM For po 13th january 2016ELM For po 13th january 2016
ELM For po 13th january 2016
 
Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1
Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1
Quality assurance of rsby empanelled hospitals ppt for tvm1
 
Rsby 5 nw tvcbs7 quality
Rsby 5 nw tvcbs7  qualityRsby 5 nw tvcbs7  quality
Rsby 5 nw tvcbs7 quality
 
Engaging with industries for slw mp1.
Engaging with industries for slw mp1.Engaging with industries for slw mp1.
Engaging with industries for slw mp1.
 
Engaging with industries elm model
Engaging with industries elm modelEngaging with industries elm model
Engaging with industries elm model
 
DKMA Software
DKMA SoftwareDKMA Software
DKMA Software
 
RSBY -DKMA Training
RSBY -DKMA Training RSBY -DKMA Training
RSBY -DKMA Training
 
Training of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBY
Training of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBYTraining of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBY
Training of SNA 1-2 March 2012 -Greviance reddressal in RSBY
 
Rsby expterience in cg
Rsby expterience in cgRsby expterience in cg
Rsby expterience in cg
 
For bhopal meeting july 2011
For bhopal meeting july 2011For bhopal meeting july 2011
For bhopal meeting july 2011
 
RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011
RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011
RSBY regional review meeting eastern region Ranchi 28th June 2011
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...kajalverma014
 
fundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docx
fundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docxfundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docx
fundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docxssuserf63bd7
 
Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024
Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024
Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024Adnet Communications
 
+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...
+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...
+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...Health
 
Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...
Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...
Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...batoole333
 
Pension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdf
Pension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdfPension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdf
Pension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdfHenry Tapper
 
Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdf
Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdfQ1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdf
Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdfAdnet Communications
 
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate PresentationStrategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate PresentationAdnet Communications
 
Mahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Mahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsMahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Mahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsDeepika Singh
 
Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...
Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...
Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...Call Girls Mumbai
 
+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...
+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...
+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...Health
 
Dubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai Multiple
Dubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai MultipleDubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai Multiple
Dubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai Multiplekojalpk89
 
20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...
20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...
20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...Henry Tapper
 
falcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunities
falcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunitiesfalcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunities
falcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunitiesFalcon Invoice Discounting
 
Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...
Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...
Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...globusfinanza
 
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...batoole333
 
7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator Options
7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator Options7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator Options
7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator OptionsVince Stanzione
 
FE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case Studies
FE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case StudiesFE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case Studies
FE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case StudiesNghiaPham100
 
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.hyt3577
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

W.D. Gann Theory Complete Information.pdf
W.D. Gann Theory Complete Information.pdfW.D. Gann Theory Complete Information.pdf
W.D. Gann Theory Complete Information.pdf
 
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
 
fundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docx
fundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docxfundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docx
fundamentals of corporate finance 11th canadian edition test bank.docx
 
Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024
Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024
Lion One Corporate Presentation May 2024
 
+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...
+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...
+97470301568>>buy weed in qatar,buy thc oil in qatar doha>>buy cannabis oil i...
 
Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...
Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...
Black magic specialist in Canada (Kala ilam specialist in UK) Bangali Amil ba...
 
Pension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdf
Pension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdfPension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdf
Pension dashboards forum 1 May 2024 (1).pdf
 
Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdf
Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdfQ1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdf
Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation vF.pdf
 
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate PresentationStrategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
 
Mahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Mahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsMahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Mahendragarh Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...
Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...
Bhubaneswar🌹Ravi Tailkes ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswar ...
 
+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...
+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...
+971565801893>>SAFE ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI,RAK CITY,ABUDHA...
 
Dubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai Multiple
Dubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai MultipleDubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai Multiple
Dubai Call Girls Deira O525547819 Dubai Call Girls Bur Dubai Multiple
 
20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...
20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...
20240419-SMC-submission-Annual-Superannuation-Performance-Test-–-design-optio...
 
falcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunities
falcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunitiesfalcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunities
falcon-invoice-discounting-unlocking-prime-investment-opportunities
 
Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...
Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...
Avoidable Errors in Payroll Compliance for Payroll Services Providers - Globu...
 
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in Faisalabad and Kala ilam specialist i...
 
7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator Options
7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator Options7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator Options
7 tips trading Deriv Accumulator Options
 
FE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case Studies
FE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case StudiesFE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case Studies
FE Credit and SMBC Acquisition Case Studies
 
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
 

Rsby evaluation chhattisgarh rfp document updated 14th september 2011

  • 1. RFP DOCUMENT State Level Evaluation Study of “Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana” Chhattisgarh State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh Department of Health and Family Welfare Government of Chhattisgarh Raipur Issued / Released on 14th of September 2011 RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 1
  • 2. Tender document of State Nodal Agency Chhattisgarh for the Evaluation of RSBY State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh Department of Health and Family Welfare Government of Chhattisgarh Raipur RFP NOTICE ( 2nd Notice) RASHTRIYA SWASTHYA BIMA YOJANA (A scheme to provide health insurance coverage to unorganized sector workers belonging to BPL families) Sealed bids are invited from reputed organizations/agencies having experience of carrying out evaluation studies for government schemes and programs for carrying out evaluation study of Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) Enrollment and Utilization by BPL families in divisions of Raipur viz. Raipur, Mahasamund, Dhamtari, Kawardha, Durg & Rajnandgon, Bilaspur Viz.Bilaspur, Korba, Raigarh & Janjgir, Sarguja viz. Sarguja, Koriya & Jashpur and Baster viz Baster, Narayanpur, Bijapur, Dantewada & Kanker of Chhattisgarh State The bids are invited in two parts i.e., Technical Bid and Financial bid. Insurance companies and Third Party Administrators (Health) & their allied companies and Agencies involved with DHFW Chhattisgarh are not permitted to participate in the bidding process. The tender document for this may be downloaded from the website http://cghealth.nic.in The technical bids and financial bids should be sealed by the bidder in a cover duly super-scribed is to be put in a bigger cover which should also be sealed and duly super-scribed. The Technical bids will be evaluated by the Technical Bid Evaluation Committee. Financial bids of only the technically acceptable offers shall be opened before the successful bidders by the SNA for awarding of the contract. Following schedule will be observed in this regard. Last date of submission of technical bid document: 6 PM of 17.10.2011 Opening of technical bids: 18.10.2011 The completed technical Bid documents should be submitted before at the following address:- State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh Department of Health and Family Welfare 2nd Floor Directorate of Health and Family Welfare, Old Nursing Hostel, Raipur-492001 Email: rsbycg@gmail.com Tel: 0771-4255948 All correspondence / communications on the scheme should be made at the above address. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 2
  • 3. RFP DOCUMENT RASHTRIYA SWASTHY A BIMA YOJANA A number of studies have revealed that risk owing to low level of health security is endemic for informal sector workers. The vulnerability of the poor informal worker increases when they have to pay fully for their medical care with no subsidy or support. On the one hand, such a worker does not have the financial resources to bear the cost of medical treatment, on the other; the health infrastructure leaves a lot to be desired. Large numbers of people, especially those below poverty line, borrow money or sell assets to pay for the treatment in private hospitals. Thus, Health Insurance could be a way of overcoming financial handicaps, improving access to quality medical care and providing financial protection against high medical expenses. The “Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana” announced by the Central Government attempts to address such issues. Government of Chhattisgarh has launched this scheme in all its 18 districts. For the evaluation of the scheme, Proposals are invited from the Survey agencies. The agencies which are in agreement with scheme and its Terms of Reference, only need to participate in the bidding and any disagreement in this regard may invite disqualification / rejection of bid at technical level. Hence all the agencies are requested to go through the scheme carefully and submit their agreement in specific format given in the bid. Agency/Organization after qualifying the Technical bid will have to make a presentation. Finally, the study will be awarded to the agency/organization that is selected by the Committee on the basis of both the Technical and Financial bid following due procedure. The selected Institution/Organization has to start the study immediately after its award, and each of the deliverables would be completed as per the time frame in the TOR. In case the selected Institute/Organization declines to take up the study after a notice of award has been issued, it would be barred from applying for any study, evaluation or assistance of any kind from Department of Health and Family Welfare, Raipur, Chhattisgarh for a period of 3 years from the date of award. The decision of the Bids Evaluation Committee shall be final, and no enquiries, or application for review, shall be entertained. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 3
  • 4. PART-1 : TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR CONDUCTING EVALUATION STUDIES OF RASTRIYA SWASTHYA BIMA YOJANA AT STATE LEVEL A: Introduction State Nodal Agency RSBY Chhattisgarh invite proposals for conducting household surveys related to RSBY. This request for proposals is for carrying out a post-enrollment survey of health insurance. This type of Household Survey Study will give idea about the enrollment process for RSBY and the experience of the beneficiaries. It will also give States information about the type of facilities provided to the beneficiaries when they receive the treatment under RSBY. All the benefits which are supposed to be given by the providers to the beneficiaries whether they are getting those or not will come out through this survey. It will also provide limited information about the quality of health care provided. It will also provide results in terms of utilization pattern of public and private providers by the beneficiaries in the State of Chhattisgarh. The districts to be covered for this survey are all the 18 districts in four divisions of Chhattisgarh. Proposals are invited from the Survey agencies (henceforth called consultants). The following activities are to be carried out as part of the post-enrollment survey: • Implementation of a post-enrollment and hospitalization household survey in the selected districts. • Completion of an implementation report on the household survey including cases of households not covered due to extenuating circumstances (e.g. inability to locate or household unwilling). • Completion of the database detailing responses to the household survey in appropriate format for subsequent analysis. Important information regarding the RFP has been given in Annexure - 1. B. Clarification and Amendment of RFP Document 1. Consultants may request a clarification of any of the RFP documents within 7 days of the advertisement data. Any request for clarification must be sent in writing, or by standard electronic means to the State Nodal Agency. The State Nodal Agency will respond in writing, or by standard electronic means and will send written copies of the response (including an explanation of the query but without identifying the source of inquiry) to all Consultants. Should the State Nodal Agency deem it necessary to amend the RFP as a result of a clarification, it shall do so following the procedure. 2. At any time before the submission of Proposals, the State Nodal Agency may amend the RFP by issuing an addendum in writing or by standard electronic means. The addendum shall be communicated through a public advertisement and will be binding on them. Consultants shall acknowledge receipt of all amendments. To give Consultants reasonable time in which to take an amendment into account in their Proposals the State RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 4
  • 5. Nodal Agency may, if the amendment is substantial, extend the deadline for the submission of Proposals. C: Qualifying Criteria’s: • The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 25, 00,000 in at least one of the past three years (2007-08, 2008-09, and 2009-10). ( please attach audited statements) • Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies projects with minimum project cost of Rs. 5,00,000/- for any Government (State/Central) / Government Autonomous Bodies / Government Corporation for building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3 years (Please attach copy of work orders and completion certificates). • Out of this, at least 2 (two) evaluations should have been successfully completed. (Please attach copy of completion certificate from the client). • The agency/organization should have at least 5 years relevant experience carrying out evaluations studies (Please attach copy of evidence) • The firm / company / organization should be registered as per law. (Please attach copy of evidence). • No consortium is allowed to bid for the study • Applicants should not be under a declaration of ineligibility for corrupt and fraudulent practices issued by Government of India / State Governments. A self-declaration certificate should be enclosed. D. Methodology for Evaluation Though consultant /agency are required to provide their methodology for conducing the survey, main aspects of the methodology of the proposed survey is given as follows: For this survey only RSBY beneficiaries needs to be surveyed. RSBY beneficiaries who are enrolled in the scheme will be part of this survey. The sample of beneficiaries will include beneficiaries who have utilized the scheme and who have not taken benefits in the scheme a. Sampling of District – State Nodal agency shall have this exercise in the first stage in all the districts where RSBY started in the first phase. b. Sampling – For every 1000 beneficiaries who are enrolled under RSBY in a district, at least 20 should be selected in the sample. Care should be taken that the beneficiaries who have utilized the scheme shall also be present in the sample. c. Location of Surveys – The beneficiary in the sample should be sufficiently distributed among all the blocks of the district. Within the block also efforts should be there to have villages or clusters of villages distributed geographically. d. Duration of Surveys – Survey training and field work shall take approximately two month. Another month will be needed to analyze the data and prepare the report. e. Timelines – The process to start the selection of survey agency to get the final report shall take approx. 3-4 months. If a State Nodal agency starts the process in November then they shall have the final report by sometime in January. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 5
  • 6. f. Draft Tool for the Survey – The draft tool for this type of survey is attached as Annexure- 5 of this document. This tool may be modified before start of the final survey. E. Submission of Technical and Financial Proposal: a. Technical Proposal shall be provided in the format given in Annexure -2: i. The consultant shall provide in the technical proposal a description of the approach, methodology and work plan for performing the assignment covering the following subjects: technical approach and methodology, work plan, and organization and staffing schedule. The list of the proposed Professional staff team by area of expertise, the position that would be assigned to each staff team member, and their tasks. ii. Estimates of the staff input (staff-months professionals) needed to carry out the assignment. The staff-months input should be indicated separately for home office and field activities. iii. CVs of the Professional staff. iv. A detailed description of the proposed methodology and staffing for training. v. Format for evaluation of technical proposal has been given in Annexure 4. vi. Technical bid evaluation will be done in following steps: a. The bidders will be short listed after evaluation is done on the qualifying criteria. b. Short listed bidders will be asked to give a presentation in the prescribed format in front of the technical evaluation committee. c. After the presentation the bids will be evaluated on the other parameters as mentioned in the Desirable Criteria of the Technical Proposal d. All the successful bidders who qualify after the technical bid evaluation will be eligible for the financial bid evaluation. e. The Technical proposal shall not include any financial information. A Technical Proposal containing financial information may be declared non responsive. b. Financial Proposal: i. The Financial proposal shall take into account all costs associated with the assignment (Annexure-3). The quote should be for each division separately. Bidders can quote for more than one division. ii. No other information shall be provided along with the financial proposal. F. Co-ordination with the State Nodal Agency The agency will have to work closely with the State Nodal Agency in developing the methodology, training of the surveyors, and conducting the surveys. State Government will provide the necessary contact details and data for surveys. G. Ownership of the Survey The ownership of the survey tool and data shall lie with the State Government/ Nodal Agency. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 6
  • 7. PART –II SUBMISSION OF BIDS/ PROPOSALS The State Nodal Agency seeks detailed proposal from agencies interested in evaluating the “Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana”, in the Chhattisgarh State. The bid/proposal document should include the following: SECTION A – TECHNICAL PROPOSAL QUALIFYING CRITERIA: • A. The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 25, 00,000 in at least one of the past three years (2007-08, 2008-09, and 2009-10). • Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies projects with minimum project cost of Rs. 5,00,000/- for any Government (State/Central) / Government Autonomous Bodies / Government Corporation for building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3 years (Please attach copy of work orders). • Out of this, at least 2 (two) evaluations should have been successfully completed. (Please attach copy of completion certificate from the client). • The agency/organization should have at least 5 years relevant experience carrying out evaluations studies (Please attach copy of evidence) • The firm / company / organization should be registered as per law. (Please attach copy of evidence). • No consortium is allowed to bid for the study • Applicants should not be under a declaration of ineligibility for corrupt and fraudulent practices issued by Government of India / State Governments. A self-declaration certificate should be enclosed. Note: The qualifying requirements data shall be enclosed with the technical bid only. The bidder who do not qualify this criterion, will be disqualified immediately and their bids will not be considered. The Technical proposal should be sealed in an envelope clearly marked in BOLD “SECTION A – TECHNICAL PROPOSAL” and “TECHNICAL PROPOSAL FOR Evaluation of “RASHTRIYA SWASTHYA BIMA YOJANA SCHEME” written on the top of the envelope. The Envelop should have the bidders Name and Address clearly written at the Left Bottom Corner of the envelope. The technical supporting documents in physical form should be submitted at the following address before the due date and time. State Nodal Agency Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana 2nd Floor, Directorate of Health Services, Raipur, Chhattisgarh Phone: 0711-4255948, 4225196 RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 7
  • 8. SECTION B – FINANCIAL PROPOSAL (KINDLY NOTE THAT ANNEXURE -3 SHOULD BE ATTACHED TO SECTION B- FINANCIAL PROPOSAL ONLY) Annexure-3 (A) The Financial bid submission should be done physically in a separate sealed and marked envelope. No bid will be accepted after prescribed closing time for submission of the same. The delay will not be condoned for any reason. However, if the last date of submission of tender is declared as a holiday by government, the last date of submission of tender will be extended to the next working day. The bids may be cancelled and not evaluated if the bidder fails to: a. Seal the envelope properly with sealing tape. b. Submit envelopes i.e. Technical Proposal and Financial proposal in another large envelope. c. Give complete bids in all respects. d. Submit financial bids not as mentioned in the tender document. Deadline for Submission Bids / Proposals: Complete bid documents should be submitted by 18.00 hours on 16th of August 2011. Bid documents received later than the prescribed date and time will not be considered for evaluation. IN NO CASES, RATE S SHOULD BE QUOTED ANYWHERE EXCEPT IN FINANCIAL BID RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 8
  • 9. Annexure - 1 Instructions to the Consultants Paragraph Reference 1 Name and Address of the State Nodal Agency: State Nodal Agency, RSBY Chhattisgarh Department of Health and Family Welfare, 2nd Floor, Directorate of Health Services, Old Nursing Hostel, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Email: rsbycg@gmail.com Phone: 0711-4255948, 4225196 2 The physical submission of the technical bid document address is: State Nodal Agency, RSBY Chhattisgarh Department of Health and Family Welfare, 2nd Floor, Directorate of Health Services, Old Nursing Hostel, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Email: rsbycg@gmail.com Phone: 0711-4255948, 4225196 Proposals must be submitted not later than the following date and time 6 pm of 17th October 2011 3 Proposals must remain valid 90 days after the submission date 4 Clarifications may be requested not later than 3 days before the submission date. 5 Proposals shall be submitted in the following language: - English 6 The format of the Technical Proposal to be submitted: As per the Annexure 7 Bidder must submit the original and 2 copies of the Technical Proposal, and the original of the Financial Proposal. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 9
  • 10. Annexure-2 Details of the Technical Proposal Technical approach, methodology and work plan are key components of the Technical Proposal. Please submit your Technical Proposal divided into the following three chapters: a) Technical Approach and Methodology, b) Work Plan, and c) Organization and Staffing, a) Technical Approach and Methodology. In this chapter understanding of the objectives of the assignment, approach to the services, methodology for carrying out the activities and obtaining the expected output, and the degree of detail of such output shall be explained. It should highlight the problems being addressed and their importance, and explain the technical approach that would be adopted to address them. It should also explain the methodologies which are proposed to be adopted and highlight the compatibility of those methodologies with the proposed approach. b) Work Plan. In this chapter the main activities of the assignment, their content and duration, phasing and interrelations, milestones, and delivery dates of the reports shall be proposed. The proposed work plan should be consistent with the technical approach and methodology, showing understanding of the TOR and ability to translate them into a feasible working plan. A list of the final documents, including reports, drawings, and tables to be delivered as final output, should be included here. c) Organization and Staffing. In this chapter the structure and composition of the team shall be proposed. It should list the main disciplines of the assignment, the key expert responsible, and proposed technical and support staff. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 10
  • 11. Evaluation of Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) Chhattisgarh State, Division of _____________________________ A: ORGANISATIONAL PROFILE Name of organization Name and Designation of Contact Person Postal Address of the Organization (with PIN CODE) Physical Address, if different from postal address (With PIN CODE) Telephone with STD Code FAX No. with STD Code Mobile No. of Contact Person E-mail Address of Contact Person Name and Designation of Head of the Organization responsible for the Study Contract Establishment Details a. Year Established b. Type of Organization (Tick One) Educational & Research Institution/ Consulting Organization/ Any Other (give details) c. Regd. No. ; Name and Place of Registering Authority (Attach attested photocopy of Registration Certificate) B. EXPERIENCE Experience in conducting research studies in the field of rural & social development/welfare programme/schemes/projects by the organization/agency in the past years (2006 to 2009 calendar years) that are relevant for demonstrating its expertise in the area of proposed study (attach attested photo copy of the experience certificate): Sno. Title of Name & Completion Duration Value Name of the Address time/date of (Rs. Sample research of Client (Month & the Lakh) State (s) As project Year) project per completion TOR/ (in Months) Agreements Actual House Hold survey 1 2 3 4 Health Survey 1 2 RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 11
  • 12. Government survey 1 2 B.1: Completed research project (s) (Extra-sheet may be used if activities are more than 5 in number) B.2: On-going research projects Sr. Title of the Name & Project Project Name of No. research Address starting completion Value Sample project of Client date/time time as (Rs. State (s) (Month & per Lakh) Year) ToR/ Agreement (in Months) 1 2 3 4 5 C: HUMAN RESOURCE C. 1 Human Resources of the organization: (attach CVs) Sr. Official Station Professional/Technical Supporting Staff All No. (Name of place) (Numbers) (Numbers) Fulltime Part-time Fulltime Part-time 1 2 3 4 C2: To be deployed for the proposed study/project (a)- KEY PROFESSIONALS ** (attach CVs) Sr. No. Highest Length of No. of man (Team Name Area academic/ experience months Leader) of key professional (years) in deployed for expertise qualification the this study in the area of key area of key expertise expertise 1 2 3 4 5 RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 12
  • 13. ** Note: Care may be taken to demonstrate that each area of expertise required for the study is covered by different key professionals in above table. (b)- SUPPORT AND FIELD STAFF Sr. No. Job profile (e.g. Field investigator, data No. of personnel entry operator, analyst, etc.) Total number of man months to be deployed. 1 2 3 4 5 Format for Team Composition 1. Professional Staff Name of Staff Firm Area of Position Assigned Task Assigned Expertise 2. Support Staff Name of Staff Firm Area of Position Assigned Task Assigned Expertise D: Reasons for applying for this Region: Give in detail the capability of the organization/agency and the experience etc. to support the claim. E: Methodology and Organization of Study: The sample procedure, sample size and study tools are given in the TOR. Please suggest: (i) sample selections in detail; (ii) Study tools refinements; (iii) How you would complete the study in time? and (iv) How to achieve quality? RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 13
  • 14. F: ANY OTHER DETAIL WHICH IS RELEVANT TO THE BID CERTIFICATE It is certified that: 1. The information given above is TRUE to the best of my knowledge. The organization shall stand liable for any information given above which is later found to be FALSE, including the forfeiture of any payment due to it. 2. The information given above is COMPLETE to the best of my knowledge and I have not willingly suppressed any material information that might lead to misjudgments while evaluating this Technical Bid. 3. The professionals, staff, equipment and all requisite infrastructural facilities mentioned in this bid shall be made available for this study in due time. 4. Our agency/organization/institution is interested to undertake the proposed evaluation. 5. I am competent to sign this Certificate. Date: Authorized Signatory Place: Name: Seal of the Organization: Designation: RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 14
  • 15. Financial Bid Annexure-3 Evaluation of Rastriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) Chhattisgarh State in Division of :…………………………………………… (use separate sheet for each division) Name of Bidder Agency/Organization with address: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ FINANCIAL BID Sr. No. Head Total Cost (Rs.) 1 Salary of key professionals 2 Salary of field staff and support staff 3 Travel for key person 4 Travel for Field & Secretariat staff 5 Contingent expenses 6 Office expenses** 7 Total (1+2+3+4+5+6) 8 Institutional Overheads if any, and basis of charge 9 Service Tax, if any to be charged Grand Total (7+8+9) (In words______________________________________________________) ** Office expenses: Include expenses for required numbers of final report and 5 Compact Disks. Date: Authorized Signatory ______________ Place: Name: ___________________________ Seal of the Organization: Designation: ______________________ RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 15
  • 16. Annexure-4 Form A – Appraisal of the technical proposal Bidder Bidder Name No. of Separate No. Documents¹ Including Annexes 1 2 3 4 5 6 1. Essential Criteria No. Criteria 1.  The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 25, 00,000 in at least one of the past three years (2007-08, 2008-09, and 2009-10). 2  Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies projects with minimum project cost of Rs. 3,00,000/- for any Government (State/Central) / Government Autonomous Bodies / Government Corporation for building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3 years (Please attach copy of work orders). 3  Out of this, at least 2 (two) evaluations should have been successfully completed. (Please attach copy of completion certificate from the client). 4  The agency/organization should have at least 5 years relevant experience carrying out evaluations studies (Please attach copy of evidence) 5  The firm / company / organization should be registered as per law. (Please attach copy of evidence). 6  No consortium is allowed to bid for the study 7  Applicants should not be under a declaration of ineligibility for corrupt and fraudulent practices issued by Government of India / State Governments. A self-declaration certificate should be enclosed. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 16
  • 17. 8  The bidder has a financial turnover of at least Rs. 20, 00,000 in at least one of the past three years (2007-08, 2008-09, and 2009-10). 9  Should have done at least 3 evaluation studies projects with minimum project cost of Rs. 3,00,000/- for any Government (State/Central) / Government Autonomous Bodies / Government Corporation for building their Process Automation Systems in the last 3 years (Please attach copy of work orders). Any other remarks ______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ If the answer to any one of the above criteria is “No”, then the bid is rejected at this stage itself. There is no need to progress any further. ¹A document is considered separate if it is stapled/ bound as a single entity. Even a one page covering letter should be considered as a separate document. ²specific years must be mentioned. 2. Desirable Criteria No. Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 1. Specific experience of the Consultants in conducting: a. Household Survey-20 marks b. health surveys-10 marks c. working with Government experience- 5 marks 2. Adequacy of the proposed methodology and work plan in responding to the Terms of Reference and demonstrating an understanding of RSBY a. Technical approach and methodology-10 marks b. Work plan-5 marks c. Organization and staffing-10 marks 3. Key professional staff qualifications and competence for the assignment a. Team Leader-10 marks b. Other Key Members-10 mark 4. Suitability of training program -10 marks a. Relevance of training program -5 marks b. Training approach and methodology- 5 marks Total: 100 RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 17
  • 18. I hereby certify that after perusing through the documents supplied by the bidder (………………………………………………………………………………………….............) it is my opinion that this bidder should be …………………………..(accepted or rejected)³ ________________________________________ ³Please enter one of the decisions, in your own handwriting. Bidder with more than 70% (70 marks out of 100) will be considered for Commercial Evaluation. COMMERCIAL OPENING  Commercial opening will be done and on the basis of price quoted bidder will be termed as – L1, L2, L3 and so on… as per the rank of lowest price quoted. BID EVALUATION  If commercial bids for bidder 1, 2, 3, 4… are taken as L1, L2, L3, L4… where Lmin is the lowest bid then the weightage given to commercial bids would be: Lmin/L1, Lmin/L2, Lmin/L3, L4/Lmin and so on...  Similarly weightage will be calculated for Technical Evaluation: T1/Tmax, T2/Tmax, T3/Tmax, T4/Tmax and so on… for bidder 1, 2, 3, 4… respectively  Each proposal would be evaluated against the 70 – 30 Criteria. This means 70% weightage will be given to Technical Proposal 30% to Financial Proposal. AWARD Finally the technical and commercial scores obtained by all the vendors would be summed and the bidder with highest score would be AWARDED THE BID. The final scores of the vendors would be as given below – Bidder 1: (T1/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L1*0.3) Bidder 2: (T2/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L2*0.3) Bidder 3: (T3/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L3*0.3) Bidder 4: (T4/Tmax)*0.7 + (Lmin/L4) *0.3 The vendor with the highest marks computed above on cost and quality basis will be awarded the bid. RFP for evaluation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh 18
  • 19. Annexure 5 RSBY QUESTIONNAIRE Post-enrolment Survey of the RSBY Programme A 0 : CONSENT TO PARTICIPATE IN INTERVIEW Household ID : __ __ __ __ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ INTERVIEWER - Read out: Namaskar. My name is (please say your name here). I am asked by the Government of Chhattisgarh, to conduct a survey with BPL people in Chhattisgarh to understand the penetration of Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY). We will be asking you questions related to RSBY. We would appreciate your participation in this survey. The information collected would be kept confidential. The survey should take a short time to complete. Oral consent given (circle one): YES – ContinueNO -- Stop the survey 1. Signature of Investigator_____________________ 2. Date Month Year A 1 : INTERVIEWER: COMPLETE (WHAT EVER APPLICABLE) BEFORE BEGINNING THE MODULE. Code A1.1 State Gujarat…………..1 Haryana…………..2 A1.2 District A1.3 Village A1.4 Hamlet name A1.5 Block/Circle A1.6 Rural/Urban A1.7 Name of Gram Panchayat A1.8 Address A1.9 Family ID A1.10 RSBY Status RSBY Enrolled household ………….…1 RSBY hospitalized household …………….2 Non RSBY household …………………….3 3. Date of visit: Day Month Year 4. Interview starting time: Hours Minutes 19
  • 20. A.2.1 BPL card No. : write 0 if not available A.2.2 Ration card No. : write 0 if not available A.2.3 RSBY card No : 2008: , 0 if not available A.2.4 2009 : 0 if not available SECTION B. HOUSEHOLD ROSTER B.1 B.2. B.3. B.4. B.5. B.6. B.7. B.8. B.9 B.10 Is name member of the following? Me Name Relati Age sex Marita level main Presen If no, Y …………1, N ………..2 mbe Enter the names onship If M.1 l status of occup tly why B.11 B.12 B.13 B.14 B.15 r ID starting with the with less F..2 educ ation living not BPL Ration RSBY NREG No. of household head the than (use ation of ID? in the (use card card days head one code) attain (use house code) worked (use year ed codes) Y….1 in codes) write (use N ….2 NREG(l zero code) ast year) Relationship Codes Marital status Education Codes Occupational Codes Presently not living reasons Head ………… 1 Spouse ……… Upto class 1 ………... 1 2 Father ……….. Upto class2 ………… 2 Farming ………………………… 1 3 Mother ………. Upto class 3 ………… 3 Livestock Rearing……………………… 2 4 Son ………… Upto class 4 ………… 4 Salaried Job ……………………………. 3 Living separately 5 Married ……... 1 Daughter …… Upto class 5…………. 5 Currently not working ………………… 4 in the same 6 Divorced ……. 2 Brother Upto class 6…………. 6 Enrolled full time in School/Madrassa .. 5 village ………. 1 7 Separated …… 3 Sister Upto class 7 ………… 7 Self Employed/ Trader ………………… 6 Moved to some 8 Widowed ……. 4 Father in law Upto class 8 ………… 8 Employed Skilled Laborer …………….. 7 other 2 9 Never Married. 5 Mother in law Upto class 9 ………... 9 Employed Unskilled Laborer ………….. 8 village/town …... 3 10 Grand son Upto class 10 ………. 10 Too young to work …………………….. 9 Passed away ….. 4 11 Grand daughter Upto class 11 ………. 11 Housewife/Housekeeping ……………… 10 Got married ….. 12 Grand father Upto class 12 ………. 12 Too Old to work ……………………….. 11 Name was never 13 Grand mother Graduate and above ../ 13 Enrolled full time in College ………….. 12 the part of this 5 14 Brother in law Other diploma …….. 14 Other (Specify) ………………………… 13 family …….. ,… 15 Sister in law Never attended school 15 Does not work …………………………. 14 16 Other (Specify) Nursery ……………. 16 Don’t know …………………………… 999 17 Daughter-in- Don’t know ……….. 999 18 law 20
  • 21. SECTION C. HOUSEHOLD CHARACTERISTICS C.1 C.2 C.3 Do you rent or own the house you live Rent…………………….1 in? Own…………………….2 Rent Free house ............... 3 C.4 C.5 Do you have a separate toilet? Yes……………………1 No…………………….2 C.6 C.7 C.8 What is the source of drainage Open kutcha - 1, Open pucca - 2 Covered pucca - 3, Under ground – 4; No drainage - 5 C.9 Does the family own any cultivable Yes……………………1 land? No…………………….2  C.12 (in the native village) Does Not Know........-999  C.12 C.10 What is the total area of cultivable land? ________Acres..........................1 ________Bighas........................2 ________Biswa .........................3 Does Not Know……………-999 C.11 What is main source of drinking water Piped water for members of your household? Piped into residence/yard/plot…..…1 Public tap……………………..…....2 Public hand pump………………....3 Hand pump in residence/yard/plot ..4 Well water Covered well in residence/yard/plot..5 Open private well…………………..6 Covered public well………………7 Open public well………………….8 Surface water……………………..9 Spring water……………………….10 Pond/Lake…………………………11 Dam……………………………….12 21
  • 22. Rainwater…………………………13 Tanker truck………………………14 Other (specify)…………………-777 _____________________________ C.12 Is Water Treated Before Drinking? Yes - 1, No -2  C.19 C.13 If 1 in item , type of water treatment Ultra-violet/resin/reverse osmosis – 1, (code) Boiling – 2, Filter – 3, Cloth – 4, Any disinfectant – 5, Others – 777 SECTION D: INCOME AND BORROWINGS D.1 Who of the household Nobody………………….1  D.2 members worked and Last month(in Last year(in Rs.) no. of days worked No. of hours how much did each ID Rs.) in a month worked a day member earn ? (INDICATE HOUSEHOLD BOARD NUMBER) D.2 Is there any other source Yes……………….1 of income for the No………………..2  D.4 family? (eg. Pension, Don’t know….-999  D.4 rent, remittances etc. ) Will not answer…….-888  D.4 D.3 If yes, how much did Income Source you get from that source ………………………… last month? ……………………….. D.4 In last one year have you Yes……………….1  give details borrowed from No………………..2  section E somewhere for some Don’t know….-999  section E purpose? Will not answer…….-888  section E D5 Details of borrowings Amount Source of borrowing (see codes below) Reason of borrowing (see codes below) Sr No. borrowed 1 , , 2 , , 3 , , 4 , , 22
  • 23. Source of borrowing Reason of borrowing From friends and family without interest……..1 Start a new business…………….……...1 From friends and family with interest……..2 Acquire agricultural machinery or agricultural inputs …….…2 From moneylender...3 Purchase stock for existing business………………………….…3 From bank………....4 Repay old debt………………………..4 From MFI………….5 For health related expenses..………………………….….5 From chit funds…….6 Marriage…………………..…………….6 From other financial institutions……….7 Funeral………………..………………7 From NGO……..…..8 Festival/Other Ceremony.........................8 From SHG……..…..9 Houseold consumption/Purchase household durable…..……….9 Others (specify)… - 777 Home improvement/repair/construction….10 Don’t know……-999; Unemployment……………..………...11 Will not answer……..-888 Purchase land………………..……….12 Education…………………………..…13 Purchase jewelry…….………………14 Buy livestock…………………...…….15 Other (specify)… ……………….…-777 ___________________________ Don’t know…………………..-999 23
  • 24. SECTION D.1: HOUSEHOLDS SOCIAL NETWORK Is anyone in the family presently a SHG ………………………. 1 D.1.1 member of any of the following? cooperative ………… ……...2 , , (multiple answers possible) trade union ………….…..3 NGO/MFI client ……….… 4 , , village committees (e.g. VEC; ICDS) …...... 5 , political party ……………… 6 religious organization …..…..7 RWA (urban areas) …….…8 other membership-based organization ……. 9 No ……………………….. 22 Don’t know ……………...-999 Do you or your family members Yes...........................…..........1 D.1.2 personally know the sarpanch/ nigam No ..........................…...........2 parishad/ MLA or any ward member for Don’t Know...........…......-999 your gram panchayat ? . D.1.3 What is your main source of information friends and family ….…..1 D.1.4 about government programs ? media (print, visual or audio) ...2 , , local panchayat workers/officials…….…….3 administration officials ……..4 , , religious leaders ……………..5 MLA ………………………6 Local NGO ………………… 7 other______ (specify) ……-777 How often does any member of your Every week..1 D.1.5 family travel to - At least Once a month,,,,2 1. 1. block HQ At least once a quarter….3 2. district HQ At least once in Year…..4 Never………………….5 2. 24
  • 25. SECTION F: F.1 HOUSEHOLD HEALTH (FOR ALL INDIVIDUALS FROM HOUSEHOLD BOARD) (INTERVIEWER: SHOW THE LADDER TO THE RESPONDENT WHERE EVER REQUIRED) F.1.1 F.1.3 F.1.4 F.1.5 Is ID codes . Is he/she If yes, he/she facing any describe taking recurrent the medicines medical condition? regularly problem that for this has lasted for problem? more than one Yes….1 month? No…..2 Yes….1 Don’t No…..2  know….- F.1.6 999 Don’t know….- 99 F.1.6 25
  • 26. F.2 HOUSEHOLD HEALTH EVENT AND HOSPITALISATION F.2.1 Does any of your family member has some health Yes………………………………….1 related problem that may need hospitalization in No…………………………………..2 F.2.3 the next 6 months? Will Not Answer……..……….…-888 F.2.3 Does Not Know…………………-999 F.2.3 F.2.2 Who you think would require hospitalization and HH board no for what? ……………… ……………….. ……………………………. F.2.3 Was anyone in your family very sick or severely Yes………………………………….1 injured in the last two years? No…………………………………..2 F.3 Does Not Know…………………-999 F.3 F.2.4 How many cases like these happened in the last two year? F.3 DESCRIPTION OF HEALTH EVENTS Interviewer: ask the respondent if any one in the household suffered from major health event in last two years. Fill the details of all the members of the household who had/ are having major health event in following table: F.3.1. ID F.3.2. F.3.4.How serious was this F.3.5. F.3.6. F.3.7. F.3.8 F.3.9 F.3.10 How codes of What was the health event / condition? For how long did Is he/she still Was [name] Which type Did [name] have many days those who major health Caused death…1 F.3.7 this health event / taking a hospitalized as a of hospital surgery as a the [name] had major event that Caused permanent inability to condition cause a treatment for result of this was [name] result of this was admitted health event [name] perform normal daily temporary this condition? major health admitted? major health to the suffered? activities….2 F.3.6 inability OR Yes…..1 event? Governmen event? hospital for Disease….1 Caused temporary inconvenience to N…....2 Yes…...1 t……1 Yes….......1 more than 24 Accident..2 inability to perform perform normal Don’t know....- No….….2 Don’t Private…2 No…….2 hrs? Complicated normal daily daily activities? 999 know....- Don’t Don’t know birth….3 activities……….…3 Days ….1 999 know…- …….-999 Other-specify Caused no inability to perform Weeks…2 999 …-777 normal daily Months ..3 Don’t know.999 activities, but was an Don’t know....-999 Can’t say..-555 inconvenience……4 No inability was caused…....5 F.3.6 Don’t know....-999 F.3.6 F.3a Has it ever happened that a very serious illness/death could Yes..............................……....................1 not be treated at hospital because of lack of money? No ...............................……..................2 F.4 Don’t Know........……..……............-999 F.3b Mention the member Id of that person from the above table 26
  • 27. F.4. HEALTH-RELATED BEHAVIOR (head of the family) F.4.1 Do you or anyone in the family smoke? __ F.4.2 Indicate number of cigarettes smoked per day: Yes.....................................1 (1-9) ……………………..…… 1 No ....................................2  F.4.3 (10-19) …………………….…. 2 (20-29) ……………………….. 3 (30 OR MORE) ….……….… 4 F.4.3 Do you drink alcoholic beverages? F.4.4 How would you rate your consumption? Yes................................1 Daily ………………1 No ................................2  F.4.5 3-5 days a week ………….. 2 Less than 3 days a week ……. 3 Occasionally ………………….. 4 F.4.5 Are your kids vaccinated for pulse polio? F.4.6 Have your kids got any other vaccination? Yes.....................................1 Yes.....................................1 No ....................…..............2 No ....................…..............2 SECTION G: RSBY INTERVIEWER: FOLLOWING SECTION SHOULD BE FILLED IN ONLY FOR HOUSEHOLDS WHO ARE AWARE OF RSBY CARD/SCHEME. FOR THOSE WHO ARE NOT AWARE, DIRECTLY JUMP TO SECTION H. G.5 Awareness of RSBY G.5.2 Where did you get to know about G.5.1 Are you aware of RSBY scheme? the scheme? Yes ……………………………..1 Through friends / neighbours ……….…1 No … …………………………..2  Through Radio / TV / newspaper ..........2 SECTION H Through leaflets/brochure ………..….…3 Through Health Staff ………………...…4 Area Committee members/ Community Educators.... 5 Panchayat………………….6 Ration shop keeper ……………………..7 NGO personnel ..................................... 8 Survey people ........................................9 Others (specify) ……………….…..-777 G.5.3 Do you know who is eligible for the scheme? G.5.4 Is your family eligible for the Everyone…………………1 scheme? Only BPL families ………….2 Yes ………………………..1 Only AAY families ……………3 No … ……………………..2 Only NREGA card holders ……4 Don’t know …………..-..999 Others(specify) ....................-777 Don’t know …………...-999 G.5.5 How much does it cost to enroll in this G.5.6 What is the maximum amount per scheme? ( in Rs.) year that can be spent? ( in Rs.) Zero ………………0 Don’t know………………….-999 Rs 30..................................30 Others (specify) ...............-777 Don’t know……………….-999 G.5.7 Is free treatment provided in the hospitals G.5.8 Are transportation allowances under this scheme? provided to the patient? Yes ……………………..1 Yes ………………………..1 No … ……………………..2 No … ………………………..2 27
  • 28. Don’t know …………………-999 Don’t know ………….…-999 G.5.9 Do you have to pay for the medical tests G.5.10 Do you have to pay for medicines during hospitalisation if you enroll in this and drugs in case of hospitalisation if you scheme? enrol in this scheme? Yes …………………..1 Yes …………………..1 No … ……………………..2 No ………………..2 Don’t know ……….……-999 Don’t know……………..-..999 G.5.11 How many household members can be G.5.12 Which year did enrolment take enrolled? place? (multiple answers possible) At most 5 members …..1 2008 ……………1 All household members ………2 2009 ……………………2 Others (specify) …………. -777 2010 …………………………………3 Don’t know ……………….-999 Don’t know……………-999 G.6 Which year did you apply to obtain the card? G.7 Why didn’t you apply? (multiple , , 2008…………....1  G.7.2 answers possible) 2009… ………..2  G.7.1 Booth too far away……….…......….1 , , 2010 It’s of no use. ………….......…….2 Both (2008 & 2009)....3  G.7.3 Get similar facilities in government Didn’t apply at all ......... 4  G.7 hospitals.............3 Didn’t find any hospital in the list which is closer to my place..….4 Distrust in scheme……………...5 Did not have proper documents to support family’s identity…......6 Did not feel comfortable with the technology involved (eg. Use of smart cards)…….... ...7 Didn’t understand the scheme……...8 Not eligible for the scheme ............ 9 Others (specify) .........................-777  Section H G.7.1 Why didn’t you apply in the first round? , G.7.2 why didn’t you reapply? , , Booth too far away……….…...............................….1 Booth too far away……….…......….1 Didn’t know about the scheme at that time............ 2 , Didn’t get to know about enrolments......2 , , Didn’t get to know about enrolments .. ............... 3 , Had bad experience with hospital ..........3 Didn’t find any hospital in the list which is closer to Was not satisfied in first round .............5 my place..........................................................….4 , Didn’t get chance to use card in first Did not have proper documents to support family’s round .....................................................6 identity…..............................................................5 Didn’t find any hospital in the list which Didn’t understand the scheme…......................…...6 is closer to my place this time.............7 Name on on the list ............................. 8 Interviewer: select whichever year family has enrolled in. choose the latest year if family has enrolled both the times. 28
  • 29. G.8 For those who applied G.8.1 Was any list of eligible families G.8.2 When did enrolment happen? publicly displayed before enrolment began? Yes …………………………..1 Don’t know …………..999 No … …………………..2 Don’t know ……………-999 G.8.4 How much time did it take to reach G.8.5 How far was the enrollment enrolment station? station from your house? (in kms) 5-10 mins …………………1 within 2 km ……………1 10-20 mins …………………..2 2-5 kms …………...2 20-30 mins ……….…….……3 5-8kms ……………3 >30 mins …………………4 more than 8 kms ………….4 Don’t know …………..…-999 Don’t know.……………-999 G.8.6 How did you get to know when and where enrolment was happening? From Posters displayed in the village..................................... 1 From district/ block officials...... 8 From Word of mouth.............. 2 From Loudspeaker announcement......9 From NGO personnel............. 3 From Wall writings.......... 10 From Sarpanch....................... 4 From Nukkad natak ......... 11 From ANMs...........................5 From Aanganwadi Worker... 12 From AWWs ........................6 Others (pl. specify) .......... 999 From ASHA.........................7 G.9 Did you obtain the RSBY card? G.9.1 Why didn’t you obtain it? ? Round 1. ........................................... (multiple answers possible) Round 2 …………………………….. First round . , , , Yes ……………….1  Section G.10 Second round No … …………...2  G.9.1 Household head died …….……….1 , , , Household not on the BPL list ……2 Didn’t have required documents ….3 Wait was too long …………………4 Were asked to come again …………5 Refused without any reason ………6 There were problems at enrolment station…………...7 Didn’t apply ................. 8 Other ( specify ) …………………999  Section H 29
  • 30. G.10 For RSBY card holders G.10.1 PLEASE SHOW YOUR RSBY G.10.2 What problems did you face in CARD. obtaining the card? Showed it………….….….….1 ( Add extra sheets if required) Did not want to show……..….2 Lost it………………..…………3 Someone has taken it (is with some one) .…4 Its with hospital ..………………5 Other (specify)…………….…-777 G.10.3 How many members of the family G.10.4 How long did it take you to complete are covered? the whole enrolment process? Less than one hour ………….1 1-2 hours …………………2 2-4 hours………….……….3 4-6 hours ………………….4 more than a day ……….…..5 G.10.5 Did you get smart card on the spot? G.10.8 Did you make any payments to get Yes …………………………..1 hold of it? No … ………………………..2 Zero …………………0 Rupees 30 ..................30 Don’t know.……….-999 G.10.7 Which of the following pieces of G.10.6 Were you told about the date when information did you get along with the card? , , you could start using the smart card? List of hospitals………………..1 Yes …. 1 No …. 2 How to use the card………….….2 , Who to contact in case of any query…..3 Information about district kiosk .......... 4 Didn’t get any ..................................... 5 Other (specify)……………………-777 G.10.8 Which is the nearest RSBY G.10.9 Are you satisfied with the scheme? empanelled hospital? Yes ……………………………..1 _________ No … …………………………..2 Don’t know ...................-999 G.10.10 Would you like to enrol next year also? Yes ………………………..1 No … ……………………..2 Don’t know ……………………-999 G.11 INDIVIDUAL ENROLMENT G.11.1 G.11.2Is ID G.11.3 If no, why not? At school at the time of enrolment…..2 ID enrolled in Five person limit …………….…..1; Out of village at the time of enrolment...4 30
  • 31. RSBY At work at the time of enrolment……..3; Not eligible by relationship ……….6 scheme? Was not well on the day of enrolment....5; Name is not on the ration card …….7; Yes ……..1 Name not on the BPL list ……..…..8 Refused by enrolment team …………..9 No……...2 Did not know that name needed to show up ..10 Was not at home at the time of enrolment .11  G.11.3 Not required ( person is healthy enough) ..12 Married …………………………………. 13 Passed away …………………........ 14 Others (specify) ………………………..-777 31
  • 32. SECTION H: MEDICAL TREATMENT (inpatient/outpatient) Interviewer: Ask respondent who in their family needed outpatient services in the last 30days. (explain properly what OPD is- that they were not hospitalized but had consulted the doctor, chemist, quack, local vaidya, and had bought medicine/ paid consultation fee etc.) H.1. Particulars of medical treatment received as Outpatient during the last 30 days H.1.1 sr1. no. of the OPD case 1 2 3 4 5 H.1.2 Name & srl. no. of member (as in col. 1, block 4/5) hospitalised H.1.3 Age (years) (as in col. 5, block 4 / col. 4, block 5) H.1.4 Date of First Visit H.1.5 Number of visits H.1.6 Total Expenditure during the OPD visit (in Rs.) H.1.7 Medicine (in Rs.) H.1.8 Diagnostic test (in Rs.) H.1.9 Transportation (in Rs.) H.1.10 Whether the person was Covered by RSBY?(Yes -1, No 2) H.2a: Maternity experience Last Next to Last Second from Pregnancy Pregnancy Last pregnancy H.2a.1 Who in your family got pregnant in the last 5 years? (starting with the most recent ones) ( continue with the same lady if she has successive birth histories otherwise switch to another) Noone  H.3 H.2a.2 Member id from roster H.2a.3 Date of Birth If dead ………………….. 88  H.2a.6 H.2a.5 What is the present age of child born? Living …..1, dead……. 2 H.2a.6 Where did birth take place? Home…………………………1 Village clinic at ANM…….….7 Govt/Munic Hospital………….2 Other Public Health Facility..8 GovtDispensary………………..3 NGO/Trust PHC/CHC………………..….…4 Hospital…………………9 Sub- Centre…………..…….….5 Pvt Hosp/Maternity Anganwadi Centre………..….6 Home……..….10 Other private……………………..…11 Other………………….………..…..999 H.2a.7 If the delivery did not place in a health facility then what take was the reason? Costs too much……………..…1 No Female Provider at Service….5 Facility not open………….....2 Husband/ Family did not allow……6 No nearby centre………….…...3 Not Necessary……… …..……..…..7 Don’t trust facility/ Poor Not Customary……………………..8 Service…………...4 Other……… …(Specify) 999 32
  • 33. Ask respondent about all hospitalization cases in the family in the last two years ( including maternity hospitalization) H.2. Particulars of medical treatment received as Inpatient of a hospital during the last two years H.2.1 sr1. no. of the hospitalisation case 1 2 3 4 5 H.2.2 Name & srl. no. of member (as in col. 1, block 4/5) hospitalised H.2.3 Type of hospital: Public hospital(PHC/sub centres/CHC).1, public dispensary(incl. CGHS/ESI) ……….2, private hospital………..3 Add hospital name H.2.4 When was patient admitted? (month/ year) H.2.5 Duration of stay in hospital (days) H.2.6 Whether patient was hospitalized using RSBY card? (Yes - 1, No 2) H.2.7 If no, why not? Name not on RSBY card……………………………………….1; Name is there but it was an emergency ……………………. 2; Bad experience with RSBY ……………………….…………..3 ; Neighbors had bad experience with RSBY……..…………. 4 No nearby hospital …………………………………………... 5 ; Card didn’t work in hospital ………………………….…….6 No balance in the card ………………………………………7 ; Hospital refused ………………………….…..………………. 8 this disease was not covered………….…………………..…9; didn’t know disease was covered………………………..….10 Others ……(specify..…….999 33
  • 34. H.3 Details of medical services received H.3.1 srl. no. of the hospitalization case H.3.2 Name and srl. no. of member hospitalized H.3.3 Why this particular hospital was chosen for treatment? Close to home…..…1, Reputation is good..2, Suggested by the relative/ friends…...3, Referred by doctors….4, Always go to this hospital……5, there is no other RSBY empanelled hospitals nearby…6, Other( specify)....999 H.3.4 Did surgery take place? Yes … 1 No …….2 H.3.5 Did patient take medicine ? Yes … 1 No …….2 H.3.6 Were X- ray/ECG/EEG/Scan/ Diagnostic tests conducted? Yes … 1 No …….2 H.3.7 Whether treatment availed before hospitalisation? Yes … 1 No …….2 H.3.8 If yes above, what is source of treatment public hospital (incl. PHC/ sub- centres/CHC)…..… 1, public dispensary (incl. CGHS/ESI)………….2, private hospital ……….. 3, private doctor …..…… 4 H.3.9 Whether treatment continued after discharge from hospital ? Yes … 1 No …….2 H.3.9a What was the source of treatment? Public hospital (incl. PHC/ sub- centres/CHC)…..… 1, public dispensary (incl. CGHS/ESI)…..….2, private hospital …… 3, private doctor …..…… 4 H.3.9b Duration of treatment H.3.10 Did you buy medicine on your own? Yes … 1 No …….2 H.3.11 If yes, how much did you spend on medicine?(in Rs.)
  • 35. H.3.12 Did you spend anything for getting diagnostic tests done? Yes … 1 No …….2 H.3.13 If yes, how much? (in Rs.) H.3.14 Any other amount that is incurred on this health event besides medicine and tests? (in Rs.) (mention the cause also) H.3.15 What is the total cost incurred by the household for this health event? (in Rs.) H.3.16 What was the source of this expenditure? Household savings/ income ..1 Contribution from friends/relatives ………2 Borrowings……….. 3 Sale of assets/ ornaments…. 4 H.3.17 Received any reimbursement (Rs) from any source such as government, employer, insurance company, or other agencies? Yes …1 , No …….2
  • 36. H.4: Transportation H.4.1 How far is the hospital from your house (Approximately)? H.4.2 How did the patient go to the hospital?) Bus-1 Metro……….2 ; Rickshaw………3; Two wheeler…..4 Three wheeler……..5; Car……....6; Bus…………7 Others (please specify)-……………………..999 H.4.3 What was the estimated cost to reach the hospital? H.4.4 Did the hospital reimburse the cost of transport? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.4.5 How much was the reimbursement? (in Rs.) H.5: Inpatient experience H.5.1 Was there a separate RSBY help desk at the hospital or it was at the reception only? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.5.2 How long did the patient have to wait before he/she was attended by the staff? Less than 15 minute-1; 15 to 30 minutes…….2,; 30 to 60 minutes……3; More than 60 minutes..4 Others, specify- ……..999 H.5.3 Was fingerprint verification done through a fingerprint scanner? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.5.4 Was the family told about the cost involved for treating the patient in advance? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.5.5 If yes, what was the cost? (in Rs.) H.5.6 Was the family told about the money left in the smart card? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.5.7 Was the money in the card sufficient to pay for this treatment? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.5.8 If the money in the card was not sufficient was the patient told that he would have to pay the difference? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.5.9 How much was the shortfall in the card from the package/ treatment rate? (in Rs.) H.5.10 How was the admission advised through?
  • 37. Emergency……….1 ;OPD……….2; Referral…………3; Other (Please Specify)……………….-999 H.5.11 Was the staff at the RSBY help-desk polite and helpful? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.5.13 Was the patient provided with food during stay at the hospital? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6: Discharge H.6.1 On discharge was discharge summary provided to the family? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.2 Was the fingerprint verification done at the time of discharge? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.3 When did you get the RSBY card back? After swiping at the time of admission ........1 H.6.6 On discharge ........2 H.6.6 Next day......3; two days later ......4 Others specify).......................-999 H.6.5 What was the reason for holding back the card? Staff wanted money for returning the card……...1 Staff wanted to keep the card till insurance claims were settled……….2; Staff said the card will stay deposited at the hospital …3 Others, specify-………….999 H.6.6 Were you told about the amount of money left in the card at the time of discharge? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.7 Do you know about 5 day post hospitalization expenses coverage in RSBY? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.8 Was the patient prescribed any medicines after the discharge? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.9 For how many days the medicines needed to be taken after discharge? H.6.10 Were these medicines provided by the hospital? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.11 These medicines were for how many days? H.6.12 Was the patient prescribed any tests after discharge? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.13 Within how many days
  • 38. of discharge those tests were supposed to be done? H.6.14 Were facilities for those tests organized by the hospital free of cost? Yes ....1; No ......2 H.6.15 How is health of patient now comparing when he was admitted to the hospital? Has died …..1; No improvement ……2 Partially improved …3; Has improved completely ….4 H.6.17 Diagnosis ……………. ……………. ……………. ……………. H.6.17a ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… Treatment given ……………. ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… Medical …………………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… Surgical …………………….. ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… Duration of stay …………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… If surgical ,surgery type ……. ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… If the investigator is unable to find ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… ………………… specific answers please get a ……………… ……………… ……………… ……………… …………… photocopy of the discharge summary H.6.18 Was there a suggestion for follow-up Yes ....1; No ......2 H.7 : Details of patients who died after receiving treatment H.7.1 When did the patient die? H.7.2 Probable cause of death During the Hospital Stay-1 from hospital documents if any? Immediately after discharge-2 ……………………. Within a week after discharge-3 No documents available-77 Within a fortnight-4 Within a month-5 Others, specify-999 H.7.3 Did the patient receive any medical care before he/she died? Yes ……………………..1 No … ………………..2 H.8: Patient Satisfaction H.8.1 Were all your patient H.8.2 How would you rate your related queries answered during satisfaction about the treatment your visit to hospital for treatment provided at the hospital? under RSBY? Excellent-1 Very good-2 Yes ……………………..1 Good-3 No … ………………..2 Average-4 Poor-5 H.8.3 Where would you have H.8.4 Were you forced to give gone if scheme had not been money to any staff member? there? Yes …………………..1 To the same hospital……..1 No … ………………..2 To any other private hospital..2 H.8.6 To government hospital……….3 Doctors private clinic………4 Nowhere………………….5 Other ( specify) …………….999 Don’t know ……….777 H.8.5 if yes, how much did you H.8.6 Will you recommend your pay? (in Rs.) relatives/friends to take treatment
  • 39. from the same hospital? Yes ……..1 section I No … …………..2 H.8.7 If no Why? Will you go back to the same Treated badly-1 hospital if the need arise again? Poor quality care-2 Yes Not receptive to RSBY patients-3 No There is no money in the RSBY card-4 If no Why? Treated badly-1 Poor quality care-2 Not receptive to RSBY patients-3 I: RESPONDENT DETAILS I.1 Who answered the survey? Name (INDICATE Household board number) _________________ I.2 Was there another respondent present Yes………………………………..1 during the interview? No…………………………………2 J I.3 What is the name of this respondent? Name (INDICATE Household board number) ______________________ Name not on the board……..990 SECTION J THANK THE RESPONDENT FOR TAKING HIS TIME OUT FOR THE INTERVIEW. MAKE SURE TO GET THE SIGNATURE ON THIS SHEET. INTERVIEW ENDING TIME: HOURS MINUTES COMMENTS _______________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ Signature of the respondent ___________________________