SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 2
BackgroundFact:
In this case, Mr A by a Powerof Attorney dated 6th
January 2009 donated powerto B
Limited to do the following:
a. To collect, hold, maintain,improve,invest,lease, or manage any or all property;
whetherreal or personal, tangible or intangible, located in Lagos and Abuja or
any interest therein;
b. To purchase,sell, mortgage,grant options, orotherwise dealin any way in any
real property or personalproperty,tangible,or intangible, or any interest
therein;
c. To engage in any administrative orlegal proceedings orlawsuits in connection
with the matterherein;
d. To execute any instrument and do all other,deeds and things which the
Attorney considers necessary orproperfor or in connection with any ofthe
above and he is given authority to act as fully and effectively in all respect as
could the Donor.
On the basis of the said power of attorney, B Limited instituted an action
against C Limited in its personal capacity and obtainedjudgment thereby.
Position of the Law
A donee of a Power of Attorney or an agent,in the initiation of a suit or action pursuant
to his powerunder the Power of Attorney,must sue in the name of the donoror his
principal and not otherwise.We refer to the cases of John Aghim Vs. GambaJeme
Yita [1972] 2 ELSLR 365; Ntia Vs. James [2007] All FWLR (Pt. 351) 1600;
Vulcan Gases Ltd. Vs. Gessellschaft F. I. G [2001] 9 NWLR (Pt. 719) 610.
The resultant effect is that the Writ of Summons by which the action was initiated is
invalid as the Plaintiff lacked locus standi to institute the action.
The situation in this case is similar to the situations that arose in all the legal
authorities cited above.It follows therefore that the legal principle of the said judicial
authorities are applicable to the case in hand.
It is clear from the powers donated to the Claimant,that the Claimant (B Limited)
has no proprietary interest in the Donor’s property,whateverlegal actions he will
institute with respect thereto has to be commencedin the Donor’s (Mr A) name. The
authorities cited above are clear that this is a fundamentalissue that borders on the
competenceofthe action.
By instituting the action in the Donee’s (B Limited) name thereof,the whole action
is flawed on the fundamentalissue.
Action Point
Move to file an appealmake the above a ground of appeal.

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Incompetence of Action in the name of a Donee of a Power of Attorney

Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...
Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...
Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...Acas Media
 
presentation study circle
presentation study circlepresentation study circle
presentation study circleMohamad Zebkhan
 
MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notes
MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notesMALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notes
MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notesFAROUQ
 
Contract law lecture 6 - object forbidden by law
Contract law   lecture 6 - object forbidden by lawContract law   lecture 6 - object forbidden by law
Contract law lecture 6 - object forbidden by lawDr. Arun Verma
 
Law-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdf
Law-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdfLaw-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdf
Law-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdfItsSaoirse
 
Landlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial Process
Landlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial ProcessLandlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial Process
Landlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial Processeglzfan
 
1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docx
  1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docx  1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docx
1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docxrobert345678
 
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suitPreliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suitIntan Muhammad
 
Company Law I - Pre-incorporation Contract
Company Law I - Pre-incorporation ContractCompany Law I - Pre-incorporation Contract
Company Law I - Pre-incorporation Contractsurrenderyourthrone
 
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docx
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docxBUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docx
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docxRAHUL126667
 
Law Of Association
Law Of AssociationLaw Of Association
Law Of AssociationFAROUQ
 
Administrative law questions and answers2
Administrative law questions and answers2Administrative law questions and answers2
Administrative law questions and answers2Baker Kosmac-Okwir
 

Ähnlich wie Incompetence of Action in the name of a Donee of a Power of Attorney (20)

Legal Research Memo
Legal Research MemoLegal Research Memo
Legal Research Memo
 
Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...
Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...
Action to Recover Solicitor's Fees - Locus Standi and Privity Hurdle: The cas...
 
Legal Research Memo
Legal Research MemoLegal Research Memo
Legal Research Memo
 
presentation study circle
presentation study circlepresentation study circle
presentation study circle
 
MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notes
MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notesMALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notes
MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM on civil & criminal exam notes
 
Estoppel
EstoppelEstoppel
Estoppel
 
Ne2
Ne2Ne2
Ne2
 
Contract law lecture 6 - object forbidden by law
Contract law   lecture 6 - object forbidden by lawContract law   lecture 6 - object forbidden by law
Contract law lecture 6 - object forbidden by law
 
Presentation final
Presentation finalPresentation final
Presentation final
 
Law-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdf
Law-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdfLaw-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdf
Law-of-Obligation-and-Contract-De-Leon.pdf
 
Equity - Exam Notes (1)
Equity - Exam Notes (1)Equity - Exam Notes (1)
Equity - Exam Notes (1)
 
Landlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial Process
Landlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial ProcessLandlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial Process
Landlord Tenant Law: Eviction and the Judicial Process
 
Case Digest 3.docx
Case Digest 3.docxCase Digest 3.docx
Case Digest 3.docx
 
1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docx
  1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docx  1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docx
1 2BUS 307 Case Study 2 – Professional Memo.docx
 
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suitPreliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
 
Company Law I - Pre-incorporation Contract
Company Law I - Pre-incorporation ContractCompany Law I - Pre-incorporation Contract
Company Law I - Pre-incorporation Contract
 
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docx
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docxBUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docx
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT Note Always remember to cite legal au.docx
 
Law Of Association
Law Of AssociationLaw Of Association
Law Of Association
 
TOPIC 2 - Agency (1).pptx
TOPIC 2 - Agency (1).pptxTOPIC 2 - Agency (1).pptx
TOPIC 2 - Agency (1).pptx
 
Administrative law questions and answers2
Administrative law questions and answers2Administrative law questions and answers2
Administrative law questions and answers2
 

Incompetence of Action in the name of a Donee of a Power of Attorney

  • 1. BackgroundFact: In this case, Mr A by a Powerof Attorney dated 6th January 2009 donated powerto B Limited to do the following: a. To collect, hold, maintain,improve,invest,lease, or manage any or all property; whetherreal or personal, tangible or intangible, located in Lagos and Abuja or any interest therein; b. To purchase,sell, mortgage,grant options, orotherwise dealin any way in any real property or personalproperty,tangible,or intangible, or any interest therein; c. To engage in any administrative orlegal proceedings orlawsuits in connection with the matterherein; d. To execute any instrument and do all other,deeds and things which the Attorney considers necessary orproperfor or in connection with any ofthe above and he is given authority to act as fully and effectively in all respect as could the Donor. On the basis of the said power of attorney, B Limited instituted an action against C Limited in its personal capacity and obtainedjudgment thereby. Position of the Law A donee of a Power of Attorney or an agent,in the initiation of a suit or action pursuant to his powerunder the Power of Attorney,must sue in the name of the donoror his principal and not otherwise.We refer to the cases of John Aghim Vs. GambaJeme Yita [1972] 2 ELSLR 365; Ntia Vs. James [2007] All FWLR (Pt. 351) 1600; Vulcan Gases Ltd. Vs. Gessellschaft F. I. G [2001] 9 NWLR (Pt. 719) 610. The resultant effect is that the Writ of Summons by which the action was initiated is invalid as the Plaintiff lacked locus standi to institute the action.
  • 2. The situation in this case is similar to the situations that arose in all the legal authorities cited above.It follows therefore that the legal principle of the said judicial authorities are applicable to the case in hand. It is clear from the powers donated to the Claimant,that the Claimant (B Limited) has no proprietary interest in the Donor’s property,whateverlegal actions he will institute with respect thereto has to be commencedin the Donor’s (Mr A) name. The authorities cited above are clear that this is a fundamentalissue that borders on the competenceofthe action. By instituting the action in the Donee’s (B Limited) name thereof,the whole action is flawed on the fundamentalissue. Action Point Move to file an appealmake the above a ground of appeal.