1. 1
Intelligent Casing-Intelligent Formation
Telemetry (ICIFT) System
10121-4504-01
Dr. Harold Stalford
University of Oklahoma
RPSEA Ultra-Deepwater Drilling, Completions, and Interventions TAC Meeting
June 4, 2014
Greater Fort Bend Economic Development Council Board Room,
Sugar Land, TX
rpsea.org
2. 2
Acknowledgement
We would like to offer our sincere thanks to the
Department of Energy, RPSEA, Drill Right
Technology, and the Ultra-Deepwater committee
members for providing the University of Oklahoma
with this opportunity to develop the Intelligent
Casing-Intelligent Formation Telemetry (ICIFT)
System
3. 3
Project Participants
Principal Investigators:
• Dr. Harold Stalford, Professor of AME, OU
• Dr. Ramadan Ahmed, Assistant Professor of PE, OU
Industrial Professional:
• Darrell Husted, CEO/President, Drill Right Technology, Inc., Oklahoma City, OK
Research Assistants:
• Jason Edwards, AME, OU
• Victor Hugo Soriano Arambulo, PE, OU
• Mounraj Sharma, PE, OU
• Jeremy Friesenhahn, EE & CE, OU
• Ryan Bott, CS, OU
• Michael Nash, AME, OU
4. 4
Overall Objective ICIFT System
Intelligent Casing/Intelligent Formation Telemetry
• Enhance downhole data gathering from points external to the casing
• Allow much more reservoir data to be transmitted
• Allow real-time data transmission during cementing of prod. casing
• Prevent loss of well control incident by early identification
5. 5
Main Objective: ICIFT System
RFID & Wireless Sensor Telemetry Technologies
Pressure, Temperature, Flow Sensor Data
Integration of Technologies in Prototype Development
Laboratory Testing & Evaluation of RF Signals Transmission
through Cement, Rock Formations, Fluids
6. 6
Outline
o Literature Survey & Background Studies
o Assess. of Borehole Telemetry System Comp.
o Design and Development of RFID Sensor & Transceiver
Prototypes
o Laboratory Testing of Prototypes & Telemetry Network
o Communication of Sensor Data to Surface
o Conclusions & Technology Transfer
7. 7
Literature Survey and Background
Studies
Concept/Principles of Intelligent System
Fiber Optic Sensing (Real-Time, Distributive)
Instrumented Casing (History and Technology)
Borehole Telemetry (Data Transmission: Capabilities and
Reliability)
Sensor technologies (Measurements: Wired and Wireless)
8. 8
Principles of Intelligent System
P1: Permanent Downhole Components (life of well)
P2: Wells Remotely Monitored & Controlled from Surface; Zonal
Isolation & Multi-Zone Deployments
P3: Provide Real-Time Data
P4: Optimize Production, Increase Ultimate Reservoir Recovery,
Reduce Overall Costs, Accelerate Cash Flow, Maximize Net Present
Value (NPV)
P5: Reduce Physical Interventions, Provide Well Integrity
Monitoring, Improve HSE Issues
9. 9
Telemetry Systems
Wired Telemetry Systems
Wireline System
Wired Drill Pipe Telemetry System
Fiber Optic System
Non Wired Telemetry
Mud Pulse Telemetry
Electromagnetic Telemetry
Acoustic Telemetry
10. 10
Monitoring Systems: Components & Failures
(Permanent Downhole Sensors)
o Electronic gauges (20% failures)
o Gauge mandrels
o Connectors (50% failures)
o Cables (25% without being splice free)
o Acquisition system
o Interpretation software
o Power supply
11. 11
Factors to Consider
(Permanent Downhole Sensors)
o Minimize: downhole electronics
o Minimize: number of parts
o Minimize: number of moving parts
o Use appropriate coatings, packaging technology, & housing
o Consider non-electronic sensors (i.e., fiber optic)
o Consider “right” mix (electronic, fiber optic, electrode array)
o Consider materials for HT/HP UDW applications (e.g., quartz, fiber optic,
etc.)
o Consider fiber optic sensor issues:
- must be appropriately coated and protected (otherwise, ingression of
OH- molecules into fiber)
- drifting (changes of zero offset)
12. 12
Fiber‐Optic Distributive Sensing
Distributive sensing, permanent well monitoring
High-bandwidth, Low-loss transmission medium
High information transmission rates (1x1012 b/s)
No downhole electronics, immune EM radiation
Installation any length
Flexible configurations, greater sensitivity
Very thin (e.g., human hair), Cheap (relatively)
Slide 12
13. 13
Fiber-Optic DTS Deployed Outside
Casing
Over 70 wells with DTS permanent installations:
- Successfully tested, proved and applied DTS technology for
monitoring injection profile in major onshore waterflood
All challenges met with 100% success:
- Fiber deployed outside casing, cemented in place
without creating a micro-annulus
- Permitted perforations for completion without fiber damage
- Control line and fiber pulled through wellhead mandrel
- Fiber not damaged: rig move-out, well-head installation, etc.
- Integrated into lean manufacturing style of drilling
- Cheap enough for “low-cost” 20 BOPD environment
2013 SPE 163694 Rahman, et al., Aera Energy LLC
15. 15
Wireless RFID Passive SAW Sensors
o Temperature, Pressure, etc.
o Low Power
o Ultra Small Size ( 1 mm diameters)
o HT Ranges
o Piezoelectric Material
16. 16
RFID SAW Sensors
Passive (no battery needed)
Operates in Liquid and Metal Environment
Wide Temperature Range (exceeds 300C)
Micro-second delays avoids clutter returns
Robustness to Gamma Ray exposure
Sensors include Temperature, Pressure, etc.
Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW)
17. 17
Literature Survey & Background Studies
Review: instrumented casing and borehole telemetry
Review: passive wireless SAW sensors that can measure
pressure, temperature etc. lifetime of producing wells
Review: Instrumentation techniques that have potential to provide
distributed real-time/continuous pressure, temperature and flow
measurements
Integrated RFID sensor technology and application to borehole
telemetry
Power supply options for RFID based ICIFT system
RF signal transmission in rock formation
18. 18
Assessment of Borehole Telemetry
System Components
Wired Telemetry systems
Wireline System (100-500 Kb/s)
Allow simultaneous measurements of formation properties
Drilling assemblies must be pulled out of the borehole
Measurement from different formations, but not in real drilling time
Wired Drill Pipe Telemetry System (50-500 Kb/s)
A real time drill string telemetry network
Allow a two-way data communication at 57000 bits/s
Has reliability comparable with mud pulse system
Fiber Optic System (10-100 Mb/s)
A distributive telemetry method using optical fibers
The fiber serves as both sensor and telemetry channel
Is comparable with electronic sensors in terms of performance, cost and simplicity of
operation.
19. 19
Assessment of Borehole Telemetry
System Components
Non Wired Telemetry
Mud Pulse Telemetry (1.5-40 b/s)
Most reliable and widely used telemetry method.
Operates under harsh environments (20,000 psi and over 350°F).
Data transfer rate is limited 12 bit/s
Works with incompressible fluids
Electromagnetic Telemetry (10-100 b/s)
System uses the drill string as a dipole electrode.
Higher data transfer rate
Applicable in shallow wells
Works with both compressible and incompressible
Acoustic Telemetry (10-30 b/s)
Data is acoustically transmitted using the drill string
System offers some degree of reliability for data transmission
High level of noise due to drilling operations must be overcome
Methods require the use of repeaters, depending on the well depth
20. 20
Assessment of Borehole Telemetry
System Components
Telemetry System Components
Sensors,
Data processing
Transmission systems
Power supply
Relevant borehole conditions
Depths, Temperatures, Pressures
Borehole drilling and completion fluids
Borehole formations
Performance Assessment
Reliability,
Power requirements,
Data rates, Size requirements
Costs
21. 21
Assessment of Borehole Telemetry
System Components (cont.)
Evaluate different techniques
Effectively place sensors at different depths of the well
Reliably transfer real-time data to the surface
Provide power to the system
Identify preferences (benefits & drawbacks)
Deployment techniques
Data transmission methods to surface
Power transmission options
Issues with wellbore and tree integrity
Preliminary well design
Telemetry system components
Sensor embedding procedures
Reliable data transfer techniques
Power supply systems
22. 22
Design/Development of RFID (Wireless)
Sensor/Transceiver Prototypes
RFID Wireless Sensing Technology
• RFID SAW Passive Sensors
• Temperature & Pressure
• RF telemetry through cement & formation media
• RF telemetry through borehole fluids1
1RF through salt water (ocean):
5-10 MHz - 90 m - 500 Kbps
Design and develop RFID Sensor Telemetry prototypes
• Handle rock formations, and drilling and completion fluids
• Measure flow, pressure, and temperature sensors
• Permits high data rates at sufficient distances
23. 23
Rock FT-IR and Resistivity Analyses
o FT-IR (Fourier Transform Infra-Red Spectroscopy) analysis
23
22 Rock Samples
Claystone
Limestone
Sandstone
24. 24
Experimental Results
Wireless SAW Sensor
Passive (no battery)
434 MHz
US Dime
Air 120
Limestone >24
Sandstone >24
Claystone >24
Concrete >24
Water 16.5
Passive Wireless SAW Sensor (Pressure &Temperature)
R S
Reader (very low power)
4mW
Media
Range (inches)Media
Measurements at 4mW Power Reader
Sensor: Temperature & Pressure
Range
Telemetry of Pressure
& Temperature Data
25. 25
Design/Development of RFID (Wireless)
Sensor/Transceiver Prototypes
Prototype designs based on state-of-the-art technology :
• Sensors (RFID, SAW-based, Fiber optic-based)
Temperature &Pressure SAW sensors
• Power supply (low power considered)
4mW
• Rock formations & Fluids (drilling/completion)
Cement, limestone, sandstone, water
• Wireless EM transmission frequencies
434MHz, 2.4 GHz
Experimental Results Good Match with Simulation Modeling
26. 26
Laboratory Testing of Prototypes and Telemetry
Network
Laboratory Testing of Sensor and Transceiver Prototypes
Laboratory Testing of Telemetry Network
• Test sequence of multiple prototypes
• Test rock formation/borehole fluids combo; test bidirectional
capability
• Evaluate overall performance of the telemetry network
27. 27
Laboratory Testing of
Sensor/Transceiver Prototypes
Test and evaluate the performance of integrated components
Passive wireless SAW sensors (T & P)
• Vary the type of obstruction (rock and formation fluids)
Cement, limestone, sandstone, & water
• Attenuation of RF signal study
Attenuation data good match with model
Experimental Results Good Match with Simulation Modeling
28. 28
Laboratory Testing of Telemetry Network
Lab test RF 2-way telemetry of prototype network
RF 2-way wireless telemetry between 3 nodes of a preliminary
prototype network
• Rock formations
Cement, sandstone, limestone
• Borehole fluids
Water
Conducted preliminary tests in fiber optic based network system
components
Experimental Results Good Match with Simulation Modeling
29. 29
Prototype ICIFT System (iBITS)
(under development)
Two-way communication
between
surface command and UDW
wellbore elements
(continuous, real-time,
high data rate)
30. 30
ICIFT Systems Prototype Network
Central
Data Center
Station 3
3000 ft. FO cable 3000 ft. FO cable
SAW RFID Sensors
Station 2Station 1
• Temperature
• Pressure
Wireless Telemetry Wireless Telemetry Wireless Telemetry
SAW RFID Sensors SAW RFID Sensors
• Temperature
• Pressure
• Temperature
• Pressure
31. 31
Feedthroughs for Fiber-Optic Sensing?
On-Shore:
Tubing Annulus: Feed-throughs are standard
Casing Annulus: Feed-throughs are in use
Off-Shore:
Tubing Annulus: Feed-throughs are in practice
Casing Annulus: Feed-throughs are in debate
32. 32
Feedthrough Issues Subsea Wellhead
Fiber-Optic Sensing: Off-Shore
Issues-Feedthrough in Casing Annulus:
Sensors are needed in annulus to measure conditions (T, P, flow, etc.)
What if significant temperature & pressure differences start to occur
What if wellhead sensors in annulus stop working before lifetime of well
What if HP methane leak begins in feedthrough
What if no one knows what is in annulus behind the feedthrough
What if feedthrough in annulus creates well intervention
What if a leak develops in a feedthrough
What if…
What if…
33. 33
Options: ICIFT System
Sensor (Discrete/Distributive)
Communication
Wired/Wired
Wireless/Wireless
Wired/Wireless
Wireless/Wired
Copper
FO
EM
Acoustic
EM (RFID)
Acoustic
PDGs
Fiber Optics (FO)
34. 34
Communication From Casing Annulus
A Starting Position
1. Use only Carbon Steel Casing (magnetic)
2. Do not cut a hole in the casing
At wellhead…downhole…in reservoir
35. 35
Communication Methods: No Holes
& Through Steel Casing
1. Carbon Steel Casing (magnetic)
o Ultrasonic-Based Wireless
2. Steel Casing (non-magnetic)
o EM-Based Wireless
Sensor Data from Reservoir
Sensor Data to Annulus A
PT
41. 41
Communications Reservoir Cross-over
EM-Based Wireless Link
Casing to Tubing Link
Special Casing Sub
41
Sensor Data from Reservoir
Sensor Data to Surface
PT
42. 42
Production Casing: EM-Based Wireless Design
Special Casing Sub (Concept)
EM Wireless Communication
Requirements: Supersedes sub-sea standards of prod. casing
Annulus Clearance <2’’
EM Frequencies:10 MHz
External Data Transmitted:
Fiber-optic sensors,
RFID SAW, etc.
Production Casing Integrity not adversely affected
42
43. 43
ICIFT Systems
o Intelligent well technology outside casing/in cement/formation
o Wireless RFID SAW sensing
o Wired distributive sensing
o Configure best of wired and wireless combinations for UDW
- in casing, on casing surface; in cement, in formation
- wired sensors ; wireless sensors
- passive sensors (no batteries); active sensors (batteries)
- distributive sensors; discrete sensors
44. 44
ICIFT System (Cont.)
Config. 1: Wellhead Feed-Throughs
o Wellhead feed-throughs allow for fiber-optic, power and
communication cables
o Fiber-optics distributive sensors deployed outside casing (all
FO electronics/processing done external to well)
o Wireless sensors (RFID passive) deployed outside casing in
cement, in formation (downhole readers require power and
electronics)
o Wired sensors (e.g., quartz) deployed along casing external
surface require power and electronics
o Communications system- data telemetry to surface -required
for downhole discrete sensors
o Wellhead feed-throughs must be secured against leaks
45. 45
ICIFT System (Cont.)
Config. 2: Wellhead Acoustic-Based Passage
o Requires no holes in carbon steel casing at wellhead
o Ultrasonic piezoelectric-based systems provide high power
and high data rates through carbon steel casing walls
o Downhole fiber-optics distributive sensors deployed outside
casing (requires downhole electronics/processing)
o Wireless sensors (RFID passive) deployed outside casing in
cement, in formation (downhole readers require power and
electronics)
o Wired sensors (e.g., quartz) deployed along casing external
surface require power and electronics
o Communications system- data telemetry to surface -required
for all downhole sensors
46. 46
ICIFT System (Cont.)
Config. 3: Wellhead EM-Based Passage
o Requires non-magnetic casing at wellhead (but no holes)
o EM-based systems provide high power and high data rates
through non-magnetic casing walls
o Downhole fiber-optics distributive sensors deployed outside
casing (requires downhole electronics/processing)
o Wireless sensors (RFID passive) deployed outside casing in
cement, in formation (downhole readers require power and
electronics)
o Wired sensors (e.g., quartz) deployed along casing external
surface require power and electronics
o Communications system- data telemetry to surface -required
for all downhole sensors
47. 47
ICIFT System (Cont.)
Config. 4: Reservoir-Based Passage
o Passage occurs below packer in reservoir near perforations
region (holes in carbon steel casing are permitted there)
o Special casing sub with EM-based systems provides high
power and high data rates
o Downhole fiber-optics distributive sensors deployed outside
casing (requires downhole electronics/processing)
o Wireless sensors (RFID passive) deployed outside casing in
cement, in formation (downhole readers require power and
electronics)
o Wired sensors (e.g., quartz) deployed along casing external
surface require power and electronics
o Data telemetry to surface uses annulus between casing and
production tubing
48. 48
ICIFT System (Cont.)
Config. 5: Intelligent Formation EM-Based
o Wireless EM-based communications through formations to
surface (bypasses wellhead)
o Requires sequence of wireless communication “towers”
outside casing from downhole to surface
o Downhole fiber-optics distributive sensors deployed outside
casing (requires downhole electronics/processing)
o Wireless sensors (RFID passive) deployed outside casing in
cement, in formation (downhole readers require power and
electronics)
o Wired sensors (e.g., quartz) deployed along casing external
surface require power and electronics
49. 49
Conclusions: ICIFT System
o Wireless/wired, discrete/distributive sensors outside casing
o Communication systems (telemetry to surface)
- Fiber-optics feed-throughs in wellhead
- Ultrasonic
- passive sensors (no batteries); active sensors (batteries)
- distributive sensors; discrete sensors
o Wired distributive sensing
o Configure best of wired and wireless combinations for UDW
(configuration examples 1-5)
50. 50
Technology Transfer Activities
Reports:
Literature Survey & Background Studies
Assessment of Borehole Telemetry System Components
Design/Development: RFID Sensor & Transceiver Prototypes
Conference Presentations and Paper:
Intelligent Casing Design – ABC, Nov. 2013, Houston
Intelligent Casing-Intelligent Formation (ICIF) Design, OTC, May 2014
Intelligent Casing-Intelligent Formation (ICIF) Design, OTC25161-MS
Disclosure: The Intelligent Borehole Intranet Telemetry System (iBITS)
52. 52
Contacts
PI: Dr. Harold Stalford, Professor
School of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering
University of Oklahoma
Stalford@OU.edu
(405) 325-1742