Technology use among teachers.

1. Technological,
Pedagogical and Content
Knowledge Unfolded: A
Case Study
Mei Lick, CHEOK & DR. Wong Su Luan

2. Introduction
• Teachers are expected to integrate technology into their
teaching and learning processes.
• Learning Management System (LMS) are provided in all the
schools.
• Teacher Training Institutes shoulder part of this responsibility.
• Preparing student teachers to be ready to integrate
technology in their future practices.
• This study examined a teacher trainer’s effort in integrating
technology in her classrooms.

3. Hybrid theoretical lens
TPACK
(Thompson &
Mishra, 2008)
Complexity
Construct
(Syverson,
2008)

4. Purpose of Study
• Using the hybrid theoretical lens adapted from Toh, Wong,
Chai, Lee and Ng (2013), understanding towards the following
research questions hope to obtained:
• How was the knowledge of TPACK distributed in the process of
knowledge creation?
• How was the integration of TPACK enacted in the training room?
• What emerged as a result of the complex interaction of TPACK?

5. What is TPACK?
• Technological, pedagogical, content knowledge (TPACK) used
as framework to understand how teachers synthesise the
different knowledge bases when integrating technology in
their classrooms.

6. What is TPACK?
• TPACK espoused in the understanding that meaningful and
engaged learning takes place when there is an interplay
between the three constructs.

7. What is Complexity Theory?
• Complexity theory is used to explain how complex systems
emerge and maintained.
• Complex systems are composed of agents that interact with
and adapt to one another and the environment, co-evolving
and self-organising without any central control (Frenken,
2006).
• With this theory, one studies cognitive processes, activities
and situated learning , and also how people interact with their
environment and others, adapt to their interactions, and
organise complex system of behaviours.

8. What is Complexity Theory?
• This study adopts three of Syverson’s (2008) complexity
construct
Distribution
• Processes, activities, associations, relationships
• Between teacher, students and the environment
Enaction
• Practices, activities, experiences in specific environment
• Ongoing interpretations and knowledge building
Emergence
• New structures, activities, texts, thoughts arise

9. Methodology
• Context
• Teacher trainers have the liberty to choose whether or not to
integrate ICT in their lessons.
• In 2011, Teacher Training Institutes started their distance learning
courses for in-service teachers to pursue their degrees.
• With this LMS became more important. However, trainers’ use of
the LMS have been less than satisfactory.
• This study hopes to provide vivid process data that illuminates a
trainer’s TPACK through the complex construct framework.

10. Methodology
• Profile of the Trainer
• 30 years of teaching experience.
• Geography as her major for both her first degree and Masters.
• Actively involved at national level; writing modules, and training.
• Strong advocate of technology as a tool to improve students’
learning and develop one’s professional productivity.
• Pseudonym of Sam will be used to refer to the trainer

11. Methodology
• Research Design
Case study is an in-depth description and analysis of a bounded
system. The case can be a single person who is a case example of
some phenomenon, a programme, a group, an instituition, a
community or a specific policy ( Merriam, 2009).
For it to be a case study, it has to be on the basis of its
uniqueness, success, etc.
If there is no limit to the number of people to be studied, then
the phenomenon is not bounded enough to qualify as a case.
Data in this study is analysed from a critical theory’s perspective.

12. Methodology: Case Study
• Direct observation in natural settings, access to their
subjective factors; thoughts, feelings, desires
• Spread the net for evidence widely
• It reveals about a phenomenon, knowledge to which we
otherwise have no access to
• This study undertakes instrumental case study which is when
the researcher wants to capture an insight into an issue or to
redraw a generalisation.

13. Methodology
• Qualitative case study can be characterised as the following.
Particularistic
• The focus is on a particular situation,
event, programme or phenomenon
Descriptive
• End product is a rich, thick description of
the phenomenon under study
Heuristic
• It illuminates readers’ understanding of
the phenomenon under study

14. Methodology
• The issue of generalizability looms larger in a case study
• But readers can learn vicariously here through the
researcher’s narrative description.
• Here it is the reader who determines what can be applied to
his or her situations.
• The researcher is the primary instrument of data collection
and analysis.
• Will rely on his or her own instincts and abilities throughout most
of this research effort
• But will include paradoxes and acknowledges that there are no
simple answers
• Does not eliminate what cannot be discounted

15. Methodology
• Data Sources and Analysis
• Sources of information were collected from:
• Semi-structured interviews
• Lesson observations’, lesson plans, field notes
• Themes were then coded using the complexity constructs

16. Findings
• Distribution
• This section shows us how Sam’s knowledge and practices of
TPACK were shared and obtained in the process of knowledge co-
construction between herself, her trainees and technology
Sam’s attitude towards technology
Relationship between Sam and her trainees

17. Sam’s attitude towards technology
• Attitude is the most important criterion for TPACK to develop
well.
• Keep on the lookout for new tools and ways to improve her
teaching.
• Relied mostly on the tutorials offered in the programmes that
she wants to learn. And immediately sharing it with her
colleaques and trainees for her to improve her knowledge and
skills of that new programme or tools.
• It is also important for the ICT tools to be from an open source
to avoid copyright or licensing issues.
• Despite her Geography background, Sam’s feels that with the
right attitude, technology skills can be learned.

18. Relationship between Sam and her
trainees
• Sam focuses on the three modalities when teaching her
trainees; visual, auditory and kinesthetic (VAK)

19. Relationship between Sam
and her trainees
• Consideration of pedagogical aspects is equally necessary
when integrating technology in the classrooms.
• Cooperative learning strategies which are requirements of the
21st century skills ; teamwork, communication skills, problem
solving, higher-order thinking skills were also integrated.

20. Findings
• Enaction
• This section shows us how Sam’s TPACK was adapted to suit her
working environment and meet the requirements of her syllabus
and trainees.
Technological constraints
Technology integration

21. Technological constraints
• Among the top barrier known to prevent teachers from using
ICT in their classroom is the lack of technical assistance.
• Not wanting to appear helpless, inept, or stupid, teachers
without sufficient technical support, will not venture into the
unknown territory.

22. Technology integration
• With more ICT use, one’s TPACK will also increase (Yurdakul &
Coklart, 2014).
• Learning ICT tools must also be for just-in-time and not just-in-
case. Having one semester working with a subject-matter
expert, Sam was able to get her trainees to apply the tools
learned within a specific context of usage.
• Peer teaching also create awareness among her trainees that
teachers perform better when they are being supported by
their peers. Complimenting each other’s strength and
weaknesses through peer co-teach should be made more
common in schools.

23. Findings
• Emergence
• This section explains how new structures, activities, texts and
thoughts develop out of a sufficient degree of complexity in a
new environment
Pedagogical practices
Classroom culture

24. Pedagogical practices
• Her exploration and experimentation with technological tools
has resulted in an expanded repertoire of technological and
pedagogical strategies.
• She uses the LMS in all her classes. Her learning websites has
her tasks lined up, reading assignments, tutorials, forum, etc.
• Her students know what to do and what to expect in her
classes. As such, early preparations were possible for them.
• Able to read trainees level of readiness and follow-up lessons
were made accordingly.

25. Classroom culture
• New classroom behaviors' emerged among her trainees after
a few weeks.
• According to Sam, her students are used to checking for
updates on her website.
• Her classes offer her trainees a glimpse of what technology
can offer in the teaching and learning processes.
• She believes it made learning more meaningful through
collaboration work, and collecting, and adapting resources,
and the pride of publishing their work.
• Emergence of their understanding of ICT’s integration within
their subject matter will emerge through enough daily usage
and interaction with the LMS.

26. Discussion & implications
• Access to technology is no longer an issue at the Teacher
Training Institutes.
• If trainers are still not using them, then other barriers must be
looked into.
• Common barriers include lack of time, confidence, resistance
to change.
• According to Yelland (2001), traditional educational
environments is no longer suitable for the 21st century
workplaces.

27. Discussion & implications
• A meta-analysis carried out by Tamim, Rana, Bernard,
Borokhovski, Abrami and Schmid (2011) found that computer
use in the classroom has an overall positive effect on students’
achievement.
• This case study is meant to provide a clear description of how
a dedicated and experienced trainer integrate ICT in her
lessons without losing sight of her content and pedagogical
demands.
• It is hoped to encourage and motivate other educators to start
integrating or to do it more effectively.

28. Discussion & implications
• Having personal traits like willing to learn, and game for new
teaching tools and programmes has helped her leverage her
ICT skills.
• How trainees’ perspectives were then affected due to their
frequent interaction, coordination and adaptation with the
technology can be an interesting future study.

29. Several proposals emerged
• Teaching through the virtual learning environment makes
learning more engaging and interesting.
• No longer at the receiving end, students can be an expert in
just about any field through the advance of technology.
• Technology use in the teaching and learning must be
cultivated early in the profession. Trainers owe that to their
trainees in making sure they are relevant in their students’
eyes when they start teaching.
• As for trainers, by keeping track of one’s TPACK development,
one is in touch with one’s teaching strength and weaknesses.
Intervention can be designed accordingly.

30. Conclusion
• Exemplary example of teachers using technology in the
classrooms should be shared with other educators. This is to
either teach, give ideas or motivate those whom are still not
using the technology.
• Technology is a tool which when used effectively help support
students’ engagement with the content. Using technology to
capture the curriculum then is the right thing to do.
• Teachers must increase their usage of the technology in order
to improve their TPACK. There is just no other way.