SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 12
ALERT Presentation:
 Learning Retention and the Timing of Refresher Education
 After The Deliberate Practice of Radiograph Interpretation



K. Boutis, M. Pecaric, J. Beckstead, P. Babyn, M. Pusic
                     Utoronto, USF, NYU
         IMSH 2013: Orlando, Florida / USA

           International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
Background

 • Content Area: PEM Radiology

 • Instructional Design:
  Online Deliberate Practice (Screen Simulation)

 • Question:
  What is the rate of skill decay?


    International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
PICO Question

 • P: PEM Fellows

 • I:       Online deliberate practice

 • C: Same + Refresher Training

 • O: Knowledge retention over 18 mo



        International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
Approach / Design




   International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
Study Protocol

Two Phases:
  1. Radiograph Calibration
           – Remove educationally poor cases

           – Broad sample of expertise

           – Use Rasch Modelling to ensure appropriate difficulty

  2. Actual Trial
           – Target Population


   International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
PICO Question

 Final Sample size: 100 + 100
                                            CALIBRATION:    TRIAL:
                                            (Read 100 Xrays (Read 220
                                            Once)           Xrays/18mo)
           Medical Students                            20
           EM Residents                                20                              40
           Peds Residents                              20
           PEM Fellows                                 20                              60
           PEM Attendings                              10
           Peds Radiology                              10


    International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
Approach / Design




   International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
Approach / Design




   International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
Approach / Design
                                                                                                                        Slope of Decay Curve
              Overlearning
PERFORMANCE




                                                       Area Under Curve

                                                                                                                       COMPETENCE




                                                                                                  Refresher Training


                             Training -- Learning (Units of          Skill Degradation   (Units of Elapsed Time)
                             Deliberate Practice)
                                                               Stops
                                                                                                                                        TIME
                                                              training
PICO Question

 Final Sample size: 100 + 100
                                            CALIBRATION:    TRIAL:
                                            (Read 100 Xrays (Read 220
                                            Once)           Xrays/18mo)
           Medical Students                            20
           EM Residents                                20                              40
           Peds Residents                              20
           PEM Fellows                                 20                              60
           PEM Attendings                              10
           Peds Radiology                              10


    International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
3 Questions to improve study

 1. How to balance number of centers with
    number of participants per center.

 2. How to ensure completion where
    participation requires activity over 18
    months.

 3. Role of site investigators
     International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
Contact Information

Name:                          Martin Pusic

Institution:                   NYU

E-mail:                        mpusic@gmail.com

Website: www.medals-silver.org/INSPIRE



    International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Mehr von INSPIRE_Network

New ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through Positioning
New ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through PositioningNew ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through Positioning
New ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through Positioning
INSPIRE_Network
 

Mehr von INSPIRE_Network (20)

Alert 2017 deshpande secure_tube study in simulated
Alert 2017 deshpande secure_tube study in simulatedAlert 2017 deshpande secure_tube study in simulated
Alert 2017 deshpande secure_tube study in simulated
 
Improving knowledge and confidence of emergency residents in pediatric resusc...
Improving knowledge and confidence of emergency residents in pediatric resusc...Improving knowledge and confidence of emergency residents in pediatric resusc...
Improving knowledge and confidence of emergency residents in pediatric resusc...
 
Interdisciplinary pediatric sedation provider course toolkit
Interdisciplinary pediatric sedation provider course toolkitInterdisciplinary pediatric sedation provider course toolkit
Interdisciplinary pediatric sedation provider course toolkit
 
Alert 2017 duff co_nsolidating tools for outcomes
Alert 2017 duff co_nsolidating tools for outcomesAlert 2017 duff co_nsolidating tools for outcomes
Alert 2017 duff co_nsolidating tools for outcomes
 
Alert 2017 kUse of a defined role/responsibility chart and a color coded floo...
Alert 2017 kUse of a defined role/responsibility chart and a color coded floo...Alert 2017 kUse of a defined role/responsibility chart and a color coded floo...
Alert 2017 kUse of a defined role/responsibility chart and a color coded floo...
 
Simulation as a strategy for learning in pediatrics graduate in high complexi...
Simulation as a strategy for learning in pediatrics graduate in high complexi...Simulation as a strategy for learning in pediatrics graduate in high complexi...
Simulation as a strategy for learning in pediatrics graduate in high complexi...
 
Alert 2017 lopreiato - a handover osce to measure skills in transitions of ...
Alert 2017   lopreiato - a handover osce to measure skills in transitions of ...Alert 2017   lopreiato - a handover osce to measure skills in transitions of ...
Alert 2017 lopreiato - a handover osce to measure skills in transitions of ...
 
Validating a serious games strategy to improve multi-patient care in emergenc...
Validating a serious games strategy to improve multi-patient care in emergenc...Validating a serious games strategy to improve multi-patient care in emergenc...
Validating a serious games strategy to improve multi-patient care in emergenc...
 
Using Cognitive task analysis to understand the decision making process for p...
Using Cognitive task analysis to understand the decision making process for p...Using Cognitive task analysis to understand the decision making process for p...
Using Cognitive task analysis to understand the decision making process for p...
 
Development of an Electronic Decision Support tool to optimize performance du...
Development of an Electronic Decision Support tool to optimize performance du...Development of an Electronic Decision Support tool to optimize performance du...
Development of an Electronic Decision Support tool to optimize performance du...
 
Alert 2017 sherman - virtual reality simulation training - updated #2
Alert 2017   sherman - virtual reality simulation training - updated #2Alert 2017   sherman - virtual reality simulation training - updated #2
Alert 2017 sherman - virtual reality simulation training - updated #2
 
INSPIRE Annual Report 2015 - 2016
INSPIRE Annual Report 2015 - 2016INSPIRE Annual Report 2015 - 2016
INSPIRE Annual Report 2015 - 2016
 
IPSSW Pre-Conference Workshop 7 (2016, Glasgow)
IPSSW Pre-Conference Workshop 7 (2016, Glasgow)IPSSW Pre-Conference Workshop 7 (2016, Glasgow)
IPSSW Pre-Conference Workshop 7 (2016, Glasgow)
 
INSPIRE @ IMSH 2016
INSPIRE @ IMSH 2016INSPIRE @ IMSH 2016
INSPIRE @ IMSH 2016
 
New ALERT - Improving Pediatric Acute Care in Community EDs through Collabora...
New ALERT - Improving Pediatric Acute Care in Community EDs through Collabora...New ALERT - Improving Pediatric Acute Care in Community EDs through Collabora...
New ALERT - Improving Pediatric Acute Care in Community EDs through Collabora...
 
New ALERT - Factors on quality pediatric care by paramedics using In-Situ Sim...
New ALERT - Factors on quality pediatric care by paramedics using In-Situ Sim...New ALERT - Factors on quality pediatric care by paramedics using In-Situ Sim...
New ALERT - Factors on quality pediatric care by paramedics using In-Situ Sim...
 
New ALERT - Teaching Infant CPR in the Pediatric Emergency Department
New ALERT - Teaching Infant CPR in the Pediatric Emergency DepartmentNew ALERT - Teaching Infant CPR in the Pediatric Emergency Department
New ALERT - Teaching Infant CPR in the Pediatric Emergency Department
 
New ALERT - Biometric parameters of Critical Care Practitioners using Hexoskin
New ALERT - Biometric parameters of Critical Care Practitioners using HexoskinNew ALERT - Biometric parameters of Critical Care Practitioners using Hexoskin
New ALERT - Biometric parameters of Critical Care Practitioners using Hexoskin
 
New ALERT - PALS-on-Demand in Skill Training
New ALERT - PALS-on-Demand in Skill TrainingNew ALERT - PALS-on-Demand in Skill Training
New ALERT - PALS-on-Demand in Skill Training
 
New ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through Positioning
New ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through PositioningNew ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through Positioning
New ALERT - Improving Neonatal LP success rates through Positioning
 

Learning Retention and the Timing of Refresher Education after the Deliberate Practice of Radiograph Interpretation

  • 1. ALERT Presentation: Learning Retention and the Timing of Refresher Education After The Deliberate Practice of Radiograph Interpretation K. Boutis, M. Pecaric, J. Beckstead, P. Babyn, M. Pusic Utoronto, USF, NYU IMSH 2013: Orlando, Florida / USA International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 2. Background • Content Area: PEM Radiology • Instructional Design: Online Deliberate Practice (Screen Simulation) • Question: What is the rate of skill decay? International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 3. PICO Question • P: PEM Fellows • I: Online deliberate practice • C: Same + Refresher Training • O: Knowledge retention over 18 mo International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 4. Approach / Design International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 5. Study Protocol Two Phases: 1. Radiograph Calibration – Remove educationally poor cases – Broad sample of expertise – Use Rasch Modelling to ensure appropriate difficulty 2. Actual Trial – Target Population International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 6. PICO Question Final Sample size: 100 + 100 CALIBRATION: TRIAL: (Read 100 Xrays (Read 220 Once) Xrays/18mo) Medical Students 20 EM Residents 20 40 Peds Residents 20 PEM Fellows 20 60 PEM Attendings 10 Peds Radiology 10 International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 7. Approach / Design International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 8. Approach / Design International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 9. Approach / Design Slope of Decay Curve Overlearning PERFORMANCE Area Under Curve COMPETENCE Refresher Training Training -- Learning (Units of Skill Degradation (Units of Elapsed Time) Deliberate Practice) Stops TIME training
  • 10. PICO Question Final Sample size: 100 + 100 CALIBRATION: TRIAL: (Read 100 Xrays (Read 220 Once) Xrays/18mo) Medical Students 20 EM Residents 20 40 Peds Residents 20 PEM Fellows 20 60 PEM Attendings 10 Peds Radiology 10 International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 11. 3 Questions to improve study 1. How to balance number of centers with number of participants per center. 2. How to ensure completion where participation requires activity over 18 months. 3. Role of site investigators International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education
  • 12. Contact Information Name: Martin Pusic Institution: NYU E-mail: mpusic@gmail.com Website: www.medals-silver.org/INSPIRE International Network for Simulation-based Pediatric Innovation, Research and Education