Law of the Future 2011 23 & 24 June 2011, Peace Palace, The Hague, The Netherlands title: Informal International Lawmaking (“IN-LAW”) By: Prof. Joost Pauwelyn www.lawofthefuture.org

1. Informal International Lawmaking (“IN-LAW”) Prof. Joost Pauwelyn Graduate Institute, Geneva

12. THE IN-LAW ACCOUNTABILITY TABLE ICH towards non-members & other affected actors FDA towards Brazilian people (open notice & comment procedure in US) FDA towards Brazilian people ICH towards non-members & other affected actors (Brazil gets voice & input at ICH) Toward EXTERNAL Stakeholders ‘ law-takers’ affected by IN-LAW; participation model ICH towards ICH members & their constituencies FDA towards US people; FDA bound to US regulations also for international (ICH) activity FDA towards US people, other internal stakeholders ( de facto application of US law to ICH) ICH towards ICH members & their constituencies (voting, transparency etc. at ICH) Toward INTERNAL stakeholders ‘ law-makers’ part of IN-LAW; delegation model IN-LAW network as such Individual participants Individual participants IN-LAW network as such Accountability at the DOMESTIC Level Accountability at the INTERNATIONAL Level