1. Establishing a molecular breeding program
based on the aluminum tolerance gene AltSB
and the P efficiency QTL Pup-1, for
increasing sorghum production in Sub-
Saharan Africa
GCP GRM 27-30 September, 2013
Fred Rattunde with
Willmar Leiser, Bob Schaffert, Jurandhir
Magalhaes, Sam Gudu, Soumana
Souley, Tom Hash, Eva Weltzien

2. Goal and Objectives
• Goal: Enhance sorghum resilience and
productivity in low-P and high Al
saturation environments in Africa
• Objectives:
– Create random-mating (ms3) source
populations with diversity for low-P
adaptation and Al tolerance combined with
required grain, glume, and plant traits
– Apply molecular marker selection tools for
Low-P and Al tolerance to effectively derive
superior lines from the random-mated
populations for the predominant low-input
production systems in Sub-Saharan Africa

3. Sorghum Growth under -P vs +P
(+ vs - Al saturation?)

4. Mali Low-P Population Donors
Donor Parent Type Origin
< Delay
Maturity in -P
> Grain Yield
in –P
1 CMDT45 LR Mali x
2 Seguetana LR Mali x
3 IS15401 LR Cameroon x
4 B2-3 LR Burkina x
5 B2-5 LR Burkina x x
6 DouaG LR Mali x
7 CSM660 LR Mali x
8 Lina3 Bred Population x
9 NafalenP6 Bred Population x
10 Dagnali Kossurou LR Mali x
• Ten donor parents: selected based on yield in Sko’06 and ’07
–P envs. (standardized) or < delay flowering in –P vs +P in
2009 Sko
• Source of Male-sterility: 19 Progenies originating from
farmers’ selections from Diversified Guinea populations

5. Mali Low-P/Al-Tol Population
Donor Parent
OS
09/10 2010
OS
10/11
2011
isolation
Yield
rank -P
Yield
rank +P
2012
isolation
Nafalen P6 xHSms3 F2 RM RM 1 21 RM
IS15401 xHSms3 F2 RM RM 3 41 RM
B2-5 xHSms3 F2 RM RM 6 23 RM
DouaG xHSms3 F2 RM RM 10 24 RM
Dagnali Kossourou xHSms3 F2 RM RM 12 11 RM
CSM660 xHSms3 F2 RM RM 14 7 RM
Lina3 xHSms3 F2 RM RM 18 9 RM
B2-3 xHSms3 F2 drop 40 28
Seguetana xHSms3 F2 drop 48 53
CMDT45 xHSms3 F2 drop 39 34
98-SB-F2-78 xHSms3 RM 2 8 RM
01-BE-F5P-15 xHSms3 RM 5 3 RM
Sakoyka ba xHSms3 RM 8 12 RM
00-CZ-F5P-135 xHSms3 RM 13 20 RM
SC566 RM RM
1/3 of donors with AltSB

6. Low-P/Al-tol Population advancement
Rainy season 2012: Final random-mating of 23 bulks,
representing different donor combinations (8 reps,
randomized)
Harvested 444 preferred and 251 acceptable panicles
from sterile plants, created Population bulk
Offseason 2012/2013: 1500 S0 plants produced 571
S1 lines (50% sterile, some plants did not reach
flowering)
Rainy season 2013: 571 S1-lines
grown for selfing, preliminary
assessment of critical traits
for adaptation, and sampling
for GBS

7. Low-P and Al-Tolerance in Kenya
Donor Parent
2010/
1
2010/
2
2011/
1
2011/
2
2012/
1
2013/
1
O2 xHSms3 F2 RM failed RM RM
L6 xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
N140d xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
C5 (O2xC1) xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
SC566 xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
SC283 xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
O2XC1 xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
A11XM45 xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
S58 xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
5 drought tol.
Lines xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM
11 Striga tol.
lines xHSms3 F2 RM RM RM

8. Low-P and Al-Tolerance in Niger
Donor Parent OS 2009/10 RS 2010 OS 2010/11
RS 2011 -
drought RS 2012 -flood
1. Lonkosaw X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
2. Macia X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
3. ST9007-5-3-4 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
4. Mota Maradi* X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
5. Bagoba X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
6. Jenjari V328 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
7. Serena X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
8. Male V332 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
9. Kaoura X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
10. ST9007-5-4-3 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
11. Balankoma X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
12. 90SN-2 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
13. Socomba 162 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
14. SSD35 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
15. L28 X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
16. MDK X ms3 pop F2 RM RM - failed RM - failed
17. SC 566 --- --- --- RM - failed RM - failed
* might have AltSB

9. Field testing of EMBRAPA BC lines
in Niger 2013
• Evaluation of BC –lines with IRAT 204 and local parent
with ALTSB allele introduced, received from EMBRAPA at
Sadore and Kollo
Sadore 2013
SC 566CSM-63E

10. SC566-14 ALTol Bres-21
Field testing of EMBRAPA BC lines in Mali 2013

11. Al-Tolerance Lab Testing
Phenotyping
• Al- seedling screening facility
installed at Samanko, Mali
• Set of selected diverse lines
from ICRISAT panel tested in
2012
• Good correspondence with
results obtained in Brazil
Genotyping for AltSB with
KASPar
• 188 sorghum genotypes from
WCA screened for AltSB
• 9% found to have AltSB alleles
• High frequency of Guinea-
race
Name Race
SAKOYKA-BA Guinea
CSM 485 Guinea
DIO-A Guinea
DOUA-G Guinea
IS 15401 Guinea
SL22 Guinea
MDK Durra
EL KURUMBASSAU Guinea-Caudatum
MOTA Caudatum-Guinea
EL RURUKA Caudatum-Guinea
EL DELE Guinea
(IS 15401*98-SB-F2-78)-3-1 Guinea-Caudatum
(IS 15401*98-SB-F2-78)-7-3 Guinea-Caudatum
(IS 15401*98-SB-F2-78)-7-5 Guinea-Caudatum
TOROBA Guinea
SL22-1 Guinea
IS 30804 Guinea

12. GWAS for low P adaptation
21% 40% 50%
188 genotypes
200k SNPs
Phenotyped in 14 –P environments

13. SNPs for GY in low P
similar to Sucrose-
phosphate synthaseAltSB
specific low P SNP
non-specific low P SNP
LD between these SNPs and AltSB markers: R²<0.1

14. AltSB effect on low-P grain yield
Grain yield in low P
Grain yield ratio –P/+P
Al-tolerant allele

15. Genomic Selection for Date of
Heading (DH), Plant Height (PH)
and Grain Yield (GY)

16. Proposed Population Progeny Testing
• 571 S1s derived from lowP and Al-Tol Mali
Population to be genotyped by GBS and
allele specific markers (AltSB and Pup-1)
to:
– Determine Allele freq Altsb and Pup-1
– Conduct genomic selection (best and worst
genotypes) using marker effects from
previous prediction set to validate utility in
independent population
– Conduct selection using AltSB, Pup-1 and the
SNPs identified with GWAS
– Compare effectiveness of different approaches
based on 2014 field phenotyping

17. Conclusions: Implementing molecular
breeding for LowP/Al_tol
(from Genetic Resource to Farmers’ Field)
• Sorghum RM Populations with diversity for
lowP and AltSB and key traits for varietal
adoption available in Mali and Kenya
• Field phenotyping for LowP established,
successful, but # of sites limited
• EMBRAPA Lab Al_tol screening method
established in Mali
• Molecular approaches for selecting LowP
adaptation showing potential
• Phenotyping and genotyping LowP
Population derived progenies: test molecular
methods (GS & MAS) for applied breeding
for Low-P production conditions

18. Publications and Acknowledgements
• Leiser W, Rattunde F, Piepho HP,
Parzies H. 2011 Getting the
most out of sorghum low-
input field trials in West-
Africa using spatial
adjustment.
• Leiser, W.L., H.F.W. Rattunde, H.-
P. Piepho, E. Weltzien, A. Diallo,
A.E. Melchinger, H.K. Parzies, and
B.I.G. Haussmann. 2012.
Selection Strategy for
Sorghum Targeting
Phosphorus-limited
Environments in West Africa:
Analysis of Multi-environment
Experiments. Crop Science
52(6): 2517.
• IER: Abdoulaye Diallo,
• IPR: Chiaka Diallo
• INRAN: Soumana Souley
• Moi University: Sam Gudu
• University Hohenheim:
Willmar Leiser, H.-P. Piepho,
• Embrapa: Jurandhir
Magalhaes, R. Schaffert, soil
science
• ICRISAT: F.Rattunde,
E.Weltzien
• Cornell University: Sharon
Mitchell
Funding:
 GCP – ALTFIELD, CG CI
 McKnight Foundation: WA CoP
 BMZ: Abiotic Stress Project