SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 21
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
0
Perspective on alternative proteins
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Note: (1) R consists of various combinations of C, H, N, O and, for some types, S; (2) The other 11 amino acids that protein can consist of, can be made inside the human body by biosynthesizing molecules
Source: World Health Organization
Humans need protein for growing and maintaining cells
Perspective on alternative proteins
1
Human Body
Uses proteins for growing
and maintaining cells
Protein
Nine essential types of
amino acids must be directly
acquired via nutrition2
Series of amino acids linked by
peptide bonds
Peptide bond
Twenty types of amino acids exist
in the human body, as determined
by their variable group (R)1
Amino acid 1 Amino acid 2
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Note: (1) And a wide range of other organic molecules; (2) In Western Europe and North America
Source: Deloitte ‘Future of protein’; WEF (2019) ‘White paper alternative proteins’; RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; FAO
Alternative proteins could substitute traditional proteins ...
Perspective on alternative proteins
2
Traditional vs Alternative Proteins
Steak, milk, ...
Minced meat, cheese, ...
Insect
salad
Insect
burger
Boiled beans, salad, ...
Algae
salad
Algae
burger
Tofu, vegetable burgers, oat
milk, ...
Processing
degree
Individ.
protein1
Animal
Bird
• Poultry
• ...
Insect
• Crickets
• Larvae
• ...
Fish
• Salmon
• Shrimp
• ...
Mammal
• Cattle
• Pig
• Sheep
• ...
Other
• Reptiles
• Amphi-
bians
• ...
Plant
Nuts &
seeds
• Cashew
• Hemp
seeds
• ...
Vege-
tables
• Kale
• Broccoli
• ...
Legumes
• Soy
• Chickpeas
• Beans
• ...
Other
• Cereals
• Fruits
• Fungi
• ...
Algae
• Seaweed
• Micro-
algae
• ...
Synthetic
Precision
fermen-
tation
• Gene-
edited
microbes
Cell-
based
• Animal
cells
Meat,
milk, ...
Mycopro-
tein, ...
Mush-
rooms
Traditional proteins
>99% of current protein supply2
Alternative proteins
<1% of current protein supply2
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Protein Quality and Current Cost
Note: (1) Protein Digestibility Corrected Amino Acid Score (1=highest); (2) Fixed and variable cost for production in the UK; (3) kg CO2 equivalent emissions (e.g. 1 kg methane is equivalent to 25 kg CO2 emissions)
Source: USDA; WEF (2019) ‘White paper alternative proteins’; Various research papers; RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’
... if production cost can be substantially reduced
Perspective on alternative proteins
3
Quality Current Cost
Protein content
(g protein / 100g)
Amino acids
(PDCAAS)1
Production
($ / 100 g protein)2
Environmental
(CO2 / 100 g protein)3
Synthetic
Cell-based • Cultured beef 25.2 0.92 32.1 91.0
Prec. fermentation • Milk powder 26.0 1.00 10.0
Animal
Mammal
• Beef 25.2 0.92 5.3 114.9
• Pork 25.8 4.0 23.1
• Milk 3.3 1.00 2.7
Bird
• Chicken 25.8 0.95 10.7 23.8
• Eggs 12.6 1.00 3.9
Fish • Salmon 20.0 13.7
Insect • Silkworm 63.9 1.00 17.1 2.2
Plant
Legumes
• Tofu 10.0 0.91 10.4 12.5
• Chickpeas 5.4 0.78 6.0 18.7
Nuts & seeds • Hemp seed 19.5 0.66 12.4 6.2
Vegetables • Broccoli 0.9 0.73 9.1
Algae • Spirulina 57.4 0.85 9.1 11.1
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Cell-based - Production Process
Source: Good Food Institute (2020) ‘Meat by the molecule: Cultivated meat 101’; Growing Meat Sustainably ‘The clean meat revolution’
Cell-based protein production replicates the processes that occur inside a living animal
to produce meat
Perspective on alternative proteins
4
Animal Biopsy Bioreactor or Cultivator Final Product
• Sample of cells is
obtained from an animal
• Cells are inserted into a
closed sterile tank with
nutrients (‘medium’) to
naturally multiply
• Multiplication happens in
a ‘scaffold’ to create
right texture
• Muscle fibers form
strands of muscle tissue
• Strands of muscle
tissue are layered to
obtain meat
• Same biological
process that happens
inside an animal is
facilitated by providing
warmth, water, proteins,
carbohydrates, fats,
vitamins, and minerals
Cell-based
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Cell-based - Cost ($ / beef)
Note: Other costs include sales, marketing and operational overheads. Fixed costs of production (facilities, upfront investment etc.) are not included in this view; (1) Applies to the ingredients in the ‘basal medium’ as
well as the supplementary ingredients; (2) Costs of scaffolding is likely to vary for different product types (e.g. steak, legs, ribs)
Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Good Food Institute (2020) ‘An analysis of culture medium costs and production volumes for cultivated meat’; Monitor Deloitte analysis
Costs for cell-based production have potential to decrease through cost reduction in
cell culture medium, which currently makes up 80-90% of the production cost
Perspective on alternative proteins
Future (>5 yrs)
~99%
~80%
~20%
Now
~1%
-50-80%
CONCEPTUAL
5
Cost Drivers
Cell culture
medium
Medium costs could fall by 4,000 times, from about
$400/L today to less than $0.10/L by 2030 – driven by:1
• Commercialization in sourcing of bulk materials
(sodium bicarbonate, glucose)
• Substitution of specialty ingredients from pharma
grade to food grade (e.g. amino acids, vitamins)
• Utilization of precision fermentation to produce
complex growth factor proteins (e.g. FGF-2, TGF-β)
Additional cost savings from:
• Innovation (precision fermentation can be used to create
scaffolds for further performance improvement)2
• Good manufacturing practices and economies of scale
Other (SG&A) • Other cost are expected to remain stable
Cell-based
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
10
Cell-based - Cost
Source: Israel21C; Reuters; Mosa Meat; RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Good Food Institute (2020) ‘Analysis of culture medium costs and production volumes for cultivated meat’
Cell-based beef could reach cost parity with conventional beef in the near term, with
varying views on the exact pace
Perspective on alternative proteins
Cell-based beef
Cow beef
10,000,000
100,000
1,000
6
Forecast
’14
’13 ’16
’15 ’17 ’18 ’19 ’20
8
’21 ’22 ’23 ’24 ’25 ’26 ’27
6
’28 ’29
0
’30
2
4 -67%
Cost
($
/
kg
beef)
Mosa Meat world’s
first cell-based
meat hamburger
Memphis
Meat
~$5,300
Future Meat
Technologies
~$40,000
~$800
~$1.2m
$10 / kg beef
in ’23
Cost parity
in ’25-’26
Cow beef cost
increase due to
loss of scale
Fundamental cost advantages of cell-
based over cow beef:
• Higher feed conversion rate (25% vs
4%)
• Faster production cycle (~2 weeks vs.
~3 years)
• Shorter supply chain
Cell-based
The direction to cost competitiveness of cell-based meat is clear, the view on the exact pace varies
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Cell-based - Performance
Note: (1) To start resembling a realistic steak with full flavor, texture and nutrient content, lab-grown muscle needs to incorporate e.g. fat and connective tissue, each requiring own specialized growth environment
Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Harvard University (2018) ‘How bioengineering could change meat production’; Good Food Institute (2019) ‘Cultivated meat state o/t industry’
Cell-based meat production has potential to provide food that is of high quality, with
high consumer appeal, and more sustainable than conventional animal agriculture
Perspective on alternative proteins
7
Product
quality
• Next to minced beef, current experiments include chicken nuggets and fish croquettes
• Genetically identical to conventional animal products, but differences in texture
• Potential for a direct one-for-one substitution – however technology for structured meat (e.g.
steak) less mature, owing to structural complexity and need for different types of cell tissues1
Consumer
appeal
• Innovator and early adopter segments could purchase cell-based meat once commercial
− ~33% likely to regularly purchase cell-based meat
− ~20% willing to pay a higher price for cell-based meat than for its conventional counterpart
(e.g. Dutch consumers indicate that they are willing to pay nearly 40% more)
• Analysis of consumer attitudes also predicts an increase in adoption over time as affordability,
taste appeal, and cultural normalization are demonstrated in the marketplace
Environmental
impact
• Potential for lower greenhouse gas emissions than industrial animal agriculture
− No animal waste that currently contributes to extensive soil and water pollution
− Estimated to reduce land use by more than 95%, climate change emissions by 75%–85%,
and nutrient pollution by 95% (compared to conventional beef)
• Absolute emission levels will depend on electricity mix
Cell-based
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Precision Fermentation - Production Process
Note: (1) E.g. methanethiol, only for two types of amino acids; (2) Using CRISPR-Cas9
Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Good Food Institute (2018) ‘Cellular agriculture’; US National Library of Medicine (2019) ‘What are genome editing and CRISPR-Cas9?’
In precision fermentation, gene-edited microbes can make a wide range of organic
molecules, such as protein
Perspective on alternative proteins
8
Fermentation tank Desired (animal) protein Final product
• Inputs are inserted in
fermentation tank which
simulates conditions of
cow rumen
• Desired protein is
produced by microbes,
following ‘instruction
manual’ from edited DNA
• Protein is mixed with
other ingredients (water,
soy) to make final
product (milk, burger)
Precision fermentation
Input
• Carbohydrate (e.g.
glucose), nitrogen (e.g.
ammonium salt) and
sulfur1 source are feed
• Gene for protein is
inserted in microbe DNA2
Animal gene Microbe
(e.g. fungi, yeast,
bacteria)
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Precision Fermentation - Cost ($ / protein)
Note: Fixed costs of production (facilities, upfront investment etc.) are not included in this view;
Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Utrecht University (2009) ‘Understanding the reductions in US corn ethanol production costs’; Stanbury et al. (2016) ‘Principles of fermentation
technology’; Stanford medicine (2018) ‘CRISPR is a revolutionary gene editing tool’; Monitor Deloitte analyses
Precision fermentation cost could decrease significantly as a result of increased
operating efficiency and scale ...
Perspective on alternative proteins
~99%
Now
~90%
Future (>5 yrs)
-60-90%
CONCEPTUAL
9
Cost Drivers
Fermentation
cost
• Purification cost decrease exponentially when producing
at non-pharma quality
• Gene editing cost decrease with more efficient use of
CRISPR-Cas9 and other innovations, as well as increased
production volume per edited gene
• Fermentation tank cost decrease as tanks increase in
size (5,000L to >100,000L) and control systems are
used at scale
• Other operating cost decrease along experience curve
(e.g. corn ethanol fermentation shows -15% per doubling
of cumulative volume)
Feed and
microbe input
• Glucose cost as carbohydrate source decrease as
conversion increases from 3:1 to 2:1
• Other input cost for nitrogen and sulfur sources as well
as microbes do not change
Precision fermentation
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
10,000,000
1,000,000
100
10,000,000,000
1
10
10,000
1,000
100,000
100,000,000
1,000,000,000
’05 ’10
Cost
($
/
kg
of
PF
protein)
’85 ’90 ’95 ’20
’00 ’15 ’25 ’30 ’35
Precision Fermentation - Cost
Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’
... after already having decreased by several orders of magnitude in the past
Perspective on alternative proteins
10
$ 100 / kg protein in ’18,
enabled by breakthroughs in:
• computing power
• data storage
• genome sequencing
$ 1 / kg
protein in ’35
-7x orders of magnitude
(’88-’18)
-2x orders of magnitude
(’18-’35)
$ 10 / kg
protein in ’26
Forecast
Insulin, the first
PF substitute of
an animal product,
received FDA
approval in ’82
First production of
PF rennet for cheese
making in ’90
PF is used
predominantly for
medicine, vitamin and
flavorant production
Fundamental cost advantages
of PF over animal products:
• Higher feed conversion rate
(40-80% vs 4%)
• Faster ‘time to slaughter’
(weeks vs ~3 years)
• Shorter supply chain
Precision fermentation
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Precision Fermentation - Cost
Note: (1) Share PF protein ingredients is initially low but increases over time
Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’
Beef and milk substitutes using precision fermentation proteins could become more
cost competitive than their animal counterparts in the near term
Perspective on alternative proteins
11
’30
’18
2
5
’24
6
’20 ’28
’22 ’26
8
0
1
3
4
7
9
10
Cost
($
/
kg
beef)
-84%
Cost parity
in ’21
20
’24
’18
0
’28 ’30
’20 ’26
’22
5
30
10
15
25
Cost
($
/
kg
of
milk
protein)
-86%
Precision fermentation milk protein Whey Casein
Precision fermentation beef Cow beef
Cell-based beef
Cost parity
in ’24-’25
Precision fermentation beef
(plant-based product with PF protein ingredients1)
Precision fermentation milk protein
(PF milk protein powder)
Precision fermentation
The direction to cost competitiveness of precision fermentation is clear, the view on the exact pace varies
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Precision Fermentation - Performance
Precision fermentation allows substitute products to taste nearly identical to animal
products, at better nutritional values and lower environmental impact
Perspective on alternative proteins
12
Product
quality
• Precision fermentation ingredients can make substitute products that taste nearly identical to
animal products (e.g. milk protein and water, adding heme or animal fats to soy burgers)
• Nutritional value can be better than animal products (e.g. less cholesterol, less carcinogenic)
• Precision fermentation has no potential to replicate full animal products, only ingredients
Consumer
appeal
• Main drivers of consumer appeal for precision fermentation-based products are:
− Better for health
− Better for environment
− Better for animal welfare
Environmental
impact
• Precision fermentation has lower emissions per kg protein than beef
− More efficient production (no carcass, faster production cycle)
− No methane emissions in contrast to cattle (methane counts for 25 CO2 equivalents)
• Absolute emissions level of precision fermentation will depend on electricity mix and resources
used
Precision fermentation
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Dynamics of disruption of proteins
Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’
Increasing demand for modern foods could increase economies of scale, leading to
greater improvement in cost and capabilities, driving further increases in demand
Perspective on alternative proteins
13
Animal agriculture is a low-margin business where small shifts in demand can have large impacts
More variety
Economies of scale
Better capacity
More public acceptance
Lower cost
Higher revenues
Higher margins
More investment
More government support
Reverse economies of scale
Less public acceptance
Higher cost
Lower revenues
Lower margins
Less investment
Less government support
Loss of ‘social license’
Synthetic protein ‘virtuous cycle’ Animal protein ‘vicious cycle’
More
supply
More
demand
Less
supply
Less
demand
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Start-up
Country Product Growth thesis Partners
ANH end market
substitution /
increased comp.
(funding)
($324m) (CA)
• Chicken nuggets
• Has existing plant-based egg
substitute
• Apply for regulatory approval in
several countries and launch
product where obtained first
• Use brand name and retail access of
existing products
US:
EU:
($180m) (CA)
• Hamburgers from beef,
chicken and duck nuggets
• Produce multiple products in agnostic
technology to achieve further scale
• Build pilot production facility to prove
scalability, cost reduction and safety
($24m) (CA)
• Yellowtail, tuna and
salmon fillets
• Target premium restaurant market
first with quality product of whole
fillets of various species
• Build small production facility for first
volumes
($14m)
• Cell-based fats as food
ingredient
• Focus effort on single ingredient, for
cell-based & traditional premium
foods
• Beat animal fats on health (omega-3,
low saturated)
Cell-based - Startup Examples (1/2)
Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography; (1) Mosa Meat explores using Cubiq’s fat in its own products
Source: Pitchbook; Good Food Institute (2019) ‘Cultivated meat: State of the industry’; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis
Products of start-ups in cell-based protein production could decrease the need for the
animals that form a substantial part of ’s primary customer base
Perspective on alternative proteins
14
Cell-based
1
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Start-up
Country Product Growth thesis Partners
ANH end market
substitution /
increased comp.
(funding)
($14m)
• Minute (i.e. thin) beefsteak
• Develop steaks which has higher
value than mince
• Sell at slight premium to restaurant
(down from cost price of $50 per steak
today)
($9m)
• b2b package with
standardised technology for
cell production (for food and
materials)
• Tech allows low cost pro-duction so
that customers can focus on product
dev.
• Prove concept by producing e.g. foie
gras and cosmetics
($8m)
• Hamburgers from beef
mince
• Further reduce medium cost by
reducing quality from pharma grade
(current supplier is Merck) to food
grade
($3m) (CA)
• Pork sausage
• Investment to accelerate R&D and
production
• Opportunity for non-food applications
e.g. therapeutics and organ transplant
n/a
($3m) (PA)
• Pet food, probiotic
supplement using nutritional
yeast and cell-based mice
• First develop premium product of cat
treat
• Working on scaling to nutritionally-
complete foods for cats and dogs
n/a
Cell-based - Startup Examples (2/2)
Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography
Source: Pitchbook; Good Food Institute (2019) ‘Cultivated meat: State of the industry’; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis
... and could be a threat for by increasing competition on its product segments
Perspective on alternative proteins
15
Cell-based
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Start-up
Country Product Growth thesis Partners
ANH end market
substitution /
increased comp.
(funding)
($1.3b) (CA)
• Soy beef burger and pork
sausage enhanced with PF
heme (leghemo-globin)
• Enhance plant-based burger to be
indistinguishable from animal, to win
global market for meat substitutes
• First in restaurants, now also in
supermarkets
($197m) (CA)
• Ice cream, butter and milk
using PF milk protein and
PF milk fat
• First win share in animal-free
premium ice cream
• Then scale milk production to have
identical product at lower cost but
better for health and environment
($118m) (MA)
• PF protein and fats
ingredients to substitute
animal ones or to enhance
plant-based products
• Win in b2b market for ingredients
through broad portfolio with
performance customisable to client
needs
($54m) (NY)
• Leather from PF collagen
• Differentiate on product quality (shape
and size) and animal-free for high
fashion
• Produce at Evonik Slovakia plant,
expand to pharma
Precision Fermentation - Startup Examples (1/2)
Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography; (1) Also investor in the start-up; (2) Motif is a spin-off of Ginkgo
Source: Pitchbook; Cell-based tech weekly; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis
Also in precision fermentation, growth in start-ups could mean less need for animals ...
Perspective on alternative proteins
16
2
Commercial Precision fermentation
3
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
2
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Precision Fermentation - Startup Examples (2/2)
Start-up
Country Product Growth thesis Partners
ANH end market
substitution /
increased comp.
(funding)
($45m) (CA)
• Egg protein ingredients for
e.g. protein drinks or baking
products
• Win in b2b ingredient mkt, first with
better perfor-mance (e.g. taste,
foaming)
• Scale production to achieve lower
cost than chicken egg
($23m) (CA)
• Cosmetics with PF human
collagen and elastin proteins
• Differentiate on product quality and
animal-free to sell at premium
• Develop collagen for food and pharma
with Gelita
($16m) (CA)
• Pet food (dogs) with PF
protein1
• Develop cheapest complete PF protein
(not imitating existing animal protein)
• Sell at premium to vegan pet owners
($1m) (CO)
• PF protein-based cheese
• Differentiate on better taste and
nutrition than other non-animal (100%
plant-based) cheeses
Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography; (1) Also developing cell-based mice meat for cat food; (2) Also investor in the start-up; (3) stabilised hemoglobin and hydrolysed globin
Source: Pitchbook; Cell-based tech weekly; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis
... and increased competition in ’s product segments
Perspective on alternative proteins
17
Commercial
Precision fermentation
2
2
2 Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
Ruminants
Poultry
Aqua
Swine
Pet
2
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Volume and Value Composition by Species
Source: University of Tennesee; Oklahoma Department of Agriculture; Monitor Deloitte analysis
Swine and ruminants are more susceptible to disruption than poultry, as their easy-to-
substitute mince products make up a higher share of value
Perspective on alternative proteins
18
15%
25%
25%
35%
15%
25%
10%
10%
35%
5%
Mince
Volume Value
By-product
Chops
Ham &
bacon
Roast
20%
55%
25%
25%
10%
12%
25%
5%
20%
Legs
Volume Value
Wings
Breast
By-product
(other)
By-product
(carcass)
15%
50%
35%
40%
50%
10%
Volume Value
Steak
Mince
By-product
1. Profit lost to
substitution must
be recuperated
on other products
2. Other products
increase in price,
further decreasing
demand
Just chicken nugget
Example
substitute:
Impossible Pork Burger
Poultry Ruminants
Swine
INDICATIVE
High Limited
Synthetic protein activity: Moderate
Memphis Meat burger Aleph Farms steak
3%
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands
Synthetic Protein Threat and Opportunity
… while substitution of animal-based proteins also opens up new growth platforms, as
growing world population still need proteins, albeit from different sources
Perspective on alternative proteins
19
Opportunity for to
leverage existing
capabilities into adjacent
growth market
While synthetic proteins have the potential to mark a
decline of an industry which contains majority of ’s
conventional end markets …
… growth in synthetic protein market also offers new
growth opportunities, e.g.:
• Leverage fermentation expertise
• Provide specialty yeasts for precision fermentation
• Provide specialty food ingredients to synthetic protein
food producers
• …
Declining
animal-
based protein
industry and
associated
end markets
Growing
synthetic protein
market requires
new ingredients
Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee (“DTTL”), its network of member firms, and their related entities. DTTL and each of its member firms
are legally separate and independent entities. DTTL (also referred to as “Deloitte Global”) does not provide services to clients. Please see www.deloitte.nl/about to learn more about our global network of member
firms.
Deloitte provides audit, consulting, financial advisory, risk advisory, tax and related services to public and private clients spanning multiple industries. Deloitte serves four out of five Fortune Global 500ÂŽ companies
through a globally connected network of member firms in more than 150 countries and territories bringing world-class capabilities, insights, and high-quality service to address clients’ most complex business
challenges. To learn more about how Deloitte’s approximately 245,000 professionals make an impact that matters, please connect with us on Facebook, LinkedIn, or Twitter.
This communication contains general information only, and none of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, its member firms, or their related entities (collectively, the “Deloitte Network”) is, by means of this
communication, rendering professional advice or services. Before making any decision or taking any action that may affect your finances or your business, you should consult a qualified professional adviser. No entity
in the Deloitte Network shall be responsible for any loss whatsoever sustained by any person who relies on this communication.
Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

The future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteins
The future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteinsThe future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteins
The future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteinsDavid Welch
 
Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins
Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins
Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins Akshay Ramani
 
Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019
Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019 Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019
Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019 Mattan Lurie
 
Plant-based Meat Alternatives in Demand
Plant-based Meat Alternatives in DemandPlant-based Meat Alternatives in Demand
Plant-based Meat Alternatives in DemandNutrition & Biosciences
 
Soyfoods: Adding Value to Soybeans
Soyfoods: Adding Value to SoybeansSoyfoods: Adding Value to Soybeans
Soyfoods: Adding Value to SoybeansElisaMendelsohn
 
MEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODS
MEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODSMEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODS
MEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODSSreemoyee Moitra
 
Thermosonication
ThermosonicationThermosonication
ThermosonicationSAI PRASANNA N
 
Meat processing and Value added product outline
Meat processing and Value added product outlineMeat processing and Value added product outline
Meat processing and Value added product outlineHaripriya Radhakrishnan
 
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz Specht
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz SpechtImpact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz Specht
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz SpechtImpact.Tech
 
The Rise of Meatless Meat
The Rise of Meatless MeatThe Rise of Meatless Meat
The Rise of Meatless MeatBenjaminHung6
 
Power Plant Proteins
Power Plant ProteinsPower Plant Proteins
Power Plant ProteinsMUSWellness
 
Milk and milk products
Milk and milk productsMilk and milk products
Milk and milk productsManoj Solanki
 
Meat composition
Meat compositionMeat composition
Meat compositionMuzaffarHasan1
 
Food product development
Food product developmentFood product development
Food product developmentUxman ALi
 
Role of processed food in human nutrition
Role of processed food in human nutritionRole of processed food in human nutrition
Role of processed food in human nutritionKhwairakpamBembem1
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

The future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteins
The future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteinsThe future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteins
The future of food: business opportunities in alternative proteins
 
Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins
Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins
Physical, Chemical and Enzymatic Modified Milk Proteins
 
Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019
Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019 Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019
Alternative Protein - Jefferies Investor Day, Hong Kong, Nov. 2019
 
Plant-based Meat Alternatives in Demand
Plant-based Meat Alternatives in DemandPlant-based Meat Alternatives in Demand
Plant-based Meat Alternatives in Demand
 
Plant-based protein market in Asia
Plant-based protein market in AsiaPlant-based protein market in Asia
Plant-based protein market in Asia
 
Fabricated foods
Fabricated foodsFabricated foods
Fabricated foods
 
Soyfoods: Adding Value to Soybeans
Soyfoods: Adding Value to SoybeansSoyfoods: Adding Value to Soybeans
Soyfoods: Adding Value to Soybeans
 
MEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODS
MEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODSMEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODS
MEAT & MEAT PRODUCTS AS FUNCTIONAL FOODS
 
Thermosonication
ThermosonicationThermosonication
Thermosonication
 
Meat processing and Value added product outline
Meat processing and Value added product outlineMeat processing and Value added product outline
Meat processing and Value added product outline
 
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz Specht
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz SpechtImpact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz Specht
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz Specht
 
The Rise of Meatless Meat
The Rise of Meatless MeatThe Rise of Meatless Meat
The Rise of Meatless Meat
 
Power Plant Proteins
Power Plant ProteinsPower Plant Proteins
Power Plant Proteins
 
Milk and milk products
Milk and milk productsMilk and milk products
Milk and milk products
 
Meat composition
Meat compositionMeat composition
Meat composition
 
Food product development
Food product developmentFood product development
Food product development
 
Role of processed food in human nutrition
Role of processed food in human nutritionRole of processed food in human nutrition
Role of processed food in human nutrition
 
Food Testing Lab
Food Testing LabFood Testing Lab
Food Testing Lab
 
Fat Replacer
Fat ReplacerFat Replacer
Fat Replacer
 
Bioactive peptides
Bioactive peptidesBioactive peptides
Bioactive peptides
 

Ähnlich wie Alternative proteins perspectives

Integriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture Initiative
Integriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture InitiativeIntegriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture Initiative
Integriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture InitiativeYuki Hanyu
 
Environmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdf
Environmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdfEnvironmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdf
Environmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdfThe Good Food Institute
 
Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...
Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...
Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...ILRI
 
dissertation pdf linkedIn
dissertation pdf linkedIndissertation pdf linkedIn
dissertation pdf linkedInJessica Moult
 
Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...
Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...
Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...guycollender
 
The future of farming and food
The future of farming and foodThe future of farming and food
The future of farming and foodILRI
 
Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...
Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...
Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...AI Publications
 
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...ILRI
 
Meat in human diet new
Meat in human diet new Meat in human diet new
Meat in human diet new Prajwal nutan
 
Shojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiative
Shojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiativeShojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiative
Shojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiative2co
 
Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)
Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)
Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)2co
 
The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...
The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...
The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...Novus International
 
The role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food security
The role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food securityThe role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food security
The role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food securityILRI
 
Dr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: Enough
Dr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: EnoughDr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: Enough
Dr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: EnoughJohn Blue
 
Production of single cell protein from different food waste
Production of single cell protein from different food wasteProduction of single cell protein from different food waste
Production of single cell protein from different food wasteIRJET Journal
 

Ähnlich wie Alternative proteins perspectives (20)

Cultivated meat cost curve.pdf
Cultivated meat cost curve.pdfCultivated meat cost curve.pdf
Cultivated meat cost curve.pdf
 
Developments in the Nutrient Requirement of Chicken
Developments in the Nutrient Requirement of ChickenDevelopments in the Nutrient Requirement of Chicken
Developments in the Nutrient Requirement of Chicken
 
Integriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture Initiative
Integriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture InitiativeIntegriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture Initiative
Integriculture Inc., Cellular Agriculture Initiative
 
Environmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdf
Environmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdfEnvironmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdf
Environmental impacts (LCA) of cultivated meat_Sinke et al 2023.pdf
 
Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...
Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...
Science-fiction or science-fact? Research for sustainable livestock agri-food...
 
dissertation pdf linkedIn
dissertation pdf linkedIndissertation pdf linkedIn
dissertation pdf linkedIn
 
Rethinking national protein self-sufficiency
Rethinking national protein self-sufficiencyRethinking national protein self-sufficiency
Rethinking national protein self-sufficiency
 
Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...
Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...
Livestock and Climate Change - Tara Garnett, Food Climate Research Network, U...
 
Sustainability of insect rearing and insect-based food: the Nordic perspectiv...
Sustainability of insect rearing and insect-based food: the Nordic perspectiv...Sustainability of insect rearing and insect-based food: the Nordic perspectiv...
Sustainability of insect rearing and insect-based food: the Nordic perspectiv...
 
The future of farming and food
The future of farming and foodThe future of farming and food
The future of farming and food
 
Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...
Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...
Valorization of Cheese whey To “Bio”-value added food Products with Industria...
 
CRP Portfolio 2017 2022 Value for Money Analysis - Frank Rijsberman
CRP Portfolio 2017 2022 Value for Money Analysis - Frank RijsbermanCRP Portfolio 2017 2022 Value for Money Analysis - Frank Rijsberman
CRP Portfolio 2017 2022 Value for Money Analysis - Frank Rijsberman
 
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
Animal nutrition approaches for profitable livestock operations and sustainab...
 
Meat in human diet new
Meat in human diet new Meat in human diet new
Meat in human diet new
 
Shojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiative
Shojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiativeShojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiative
Shojinmeat Project - Open source cellular agriculture initiative
 
Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)
Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)
Shojinmeat Project Cellular Agriculture Initiative (Nov.2018)
 
The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...
The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...
The Egg's Global Footprint: Searching for True Sustainability in Global Egg P...
 
The role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food security
The role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food securityThe role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food security
The role of mixed crop-livestock farming systems in ensuring food security
 
Dr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: Enough
Dr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: EnoughDr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: Enough
Dr. Roger Cady - Sustainability Research Review: Enough
 
Production of single cell protein from different food waste
Production of single cell protein from different food wasteProduction of single cell protein from different food waste
Production of single cell protein from different food waste
 

KĂźrzlich hochgeladen

VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...SUHANI PANDEY
 
Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...
Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...
Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...MOHANI PANDEY
 
Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...
Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...
Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...tanu pandey
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...SUHANI PANDEY
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...SUHANI PANDEY
 
Call On 6297143586 Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...
Call On 6297143586  Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...Call On 6297143586  Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...
Call On 6297143586 Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...tanu pandey
 
Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...
Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...
Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...SUHANI PANDEY
 
kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...
kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...
kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...Amil Baba Dawood bangali
 
JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...
JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...
JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...tanu pandey
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Call Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Bookingroncy bisnoi
 
VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...
VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...
VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...SUHANI PANDEY
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...SUHANI PANDEY
 
Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...
Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...
Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...tanu pandey
 
(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...
(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...
(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile Call Girls
 
VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...
VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...
VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...SUHANI PANDEY
 
Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...
Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...
Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...tanu pandey
 
Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...SUHANI PANDEY
 
Pushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Pushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment BookingPushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Pushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment BookingNitya salvi
 

KĂźrzlich hochgeladen (20)

VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staf...
 
Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...
Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...
Get Premium Austin Town Call Girls (8005736733) 24x7 Rate 15999 with A/c Room...
 
Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...
Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...
Dighi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For Se...
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Chakan WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff And R...
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Alandi Road WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
 
Call On 6297143586 Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...
Call On 6297143586  Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...Call On 6297143586  Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...
Call On 6297143586 Pune Airport Call Girls In All Pune 24/7 Provide Call Wit...
 
Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...
Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...
Viman Nagar $ Call Girl in Pune | Starting ₹,5K To @25k with A/C 8005736733 E...
 
kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...
kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...
kala ilam specialist expert In UK, london, England, Dubai, Kuwait, Germnay, I...
 
JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...
JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...
JM road ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For ...
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls JM road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Ser...
 
Call Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Katraj Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...
VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...
VIP Model Call Girls Handewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Narayangaon WhatSapp Number 8005736733 With Elite Staff ...
 
Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...
Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...
Hinjewadi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready Fo...
 
(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...
(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...
(ISHITA) Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escor...
 
All Types👩Of Sex Call Girls In Mohali 9053900678 Romance Service Mohali Call ...
All Types👩Of Sex Call Girls In Mohali 9053900678 Romance Service Mohali Call ...All Types👩Of Sex Call Girls In Mohali 9053900678 Romance Service Mohali Call ...
All Types👩Of Sex Call Girls In Mohali 9053900678 Romance Service Mohali Call ...
 
VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...
VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...
VIP Model Call Girls Shivane ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to ...
 
Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...
Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...
Hadapsar ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For...
 
Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
Baner Pashan Link Road [ Escorts in Pune ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payme...
 
Pushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Pushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment BookingPushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Pushkar call girls 📞 8617370543At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
 

Alternative proteins perspectives

  • 2. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Note: (1) R consists of various combinations of C, H, N, O and, for some types, S; (2) The other 11 amino acids that protein can consist of, can be made inside the human body by biosynthesizing molecules Source: World Health Organization Humans need protein for growing and maintaining cells Perspective on alternative proteins 1 Human Body Uses proteins for growing and maintaining cells Protein Nine essential types of amino acids must be directly acquired via nutrition2 Series of amino acids linked by peptide bonds Peptide bond Twenty types of amino acids exist in the human body, as determined by their variable group (R)1 Amino acid 1 Amino acid 2
  • 3. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Note: (1) And a wide range of other organic molecules; (2) In Western Europe and North America Source: Deloitte ‘Future of protein’; WEF (2019) ‘White paper alternative proteins’; RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; FAO Alternative proteins could substitute traditional proteins ... Perspective on alternative proteins 2 Traditional vs Alternative Proteins Steak, milk, ... Minced meat, cheese, ... Insect salad Insect burger Boiled beans, salad, ... Algae salad Algae burger Tofu, vegetable burgers, oat milk, ... Processing degree Individ. protein1 Animal Bird • Poultry • ... Insect • Crickets • Larvae • ... Fish • Salmon • Shrimp • ... Mammal • Cattle • Pig • Sheep • ... Other • Reptiles • Amphi- bians • ... Plant Nuts & seeds • Cashew • Hemp seeds • ... Vege- tables • Kale • Broccoli • ... Legumes • Soy • Chickpeas • Beans • ... Other • Cereals • Fruits • Fungi • ... Algae • Seaweed • Micro- algae • ... Synthetic Precision fermen- tation • Gene- edited microbes Cell- based • Animal cells Meat, milk, ... Mycopro- tein, ... Mush- rooms Traditional proteins >99% of current protein supply2 Alternative proteins <1% of current protein supply2
  • 4. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Protein Quality and Current Cost Note: (1) Protein Digestibility Corrected Amino Acid Score (1=highest); (2) Fixed and variable cost for production in the UK; (3) kg CO2 equivalent emissions (e.g. 1 kg methane is equivalent to 25 kg CO2 emissions) Source: USDA; WEF (2019) ‘White paper alternative proteins’; Various research papers; RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’ ... if production cost can be substantially reduced Perspective on alternative proteins 3 Quality Current Cost Protein content (g protein / 100g) Amino acids (PDCAAS)1 Production ($ / 100 g protein)2 Environmental (CO2 / 100 g protein)3 Synthetic Cell-based • Cultured beef 25.2 0.92 32.1 91.0 Prec. fermentation • Milk powder 26.0 1.00 10.0 Animal Mammal • Beef 25.2 0.92 5.3 114.9 • Pork 25.8 4.0 23.1 • Milk 3.3 1.00 2.7 Bird • Chicken 25.8 0.95 10.7 23.8 • Eggs 12.6 1.00 3.9 Fish • Salmon 20.0 13.7 Insect • Silkworm 63.9 1.00 17.1 2.2 Plant Legumes • Tofu 10.0 0.91 10.4 12.5 • Chickpeas 5.4 0.78 6.0 18.7 Nuts & seeds • Hemp seed 19.5 0.66 12.4 6.2 Vegetables • Broccoli 0.9 0.73 9.1 Algae • Spirulina 57.4 0.85 9.1 11.1
  • 5. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Cell-based - Production Process Source: Good Food Institute (2020) ‘Meat by the molecule: Cultivated meat 101’; Growing Meat Sustainably ‘The clean meat revolution’ Cell-based protein production replicates the processes that occur inside a living animal to produce meat Perspective on alternative proteins 4 Animal Biopsy Bioreactor or Cultivator Final Product • Sample of cells is obtained from an animal • Cells are inserted into a closed sterile tank with nutrients (‘medium’) to naturally multiply • Multiplication happens in a ‘scaffold’ to create right texture • Muscle fibers form strands of muscle tissue • Strands of muscle tissue are layered to obtain meat • Same biological process that happens inside an animal is facilitated by providing warmth, water, proteins, carbohydrates, fats, vitamins, and minerals Cell-based
  • 6. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Cell-based - Cost ($ / beef) Note: Other costs include sales, marketing and operational overheads. Fixed costs of production (facilities, upfront investment etc.) are not included in this view; (1) Applies to the ingredients in the ‘basal medium’ as well as the supplementary ingredients; (2) Costs of scaffolding is likely to vary for different product types (e.g. steak, legs, ribs) Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Good Food Institute (2020) ‘An analysis of culture medium costs and production volumes for cultivated meat’; Monitor Deloitte analysis Costs for cell-based production have potential to decrease through cost reduction in cell culture medium, which currently makes up 80-90% of the production cost Perspective on alternative proteins Future (>5 yrs) ~99% ~80% ~20% Now ~1% -50-80% CONCEPTUAL 5 Cost Drivers Cell culture medium Medium costs could fall by 4,000 times, from about $400/L today to less than $0.10/L by 2030 – driven by:1 • Commercialization in sourcing of bulk materials (sodium bicarbonate, glucose) • Substitution of specialty ingredients from pharma grade to food grade (e.g. amino acids, vitamins) • Utilization of precision fermentation to produce complex growth factor proteins (e.g. FGF-2, TGF-β) Additional cost savings from: • Innovation (precision fermentation can be used to create scaffolds for further performance improvement)2 • Good manufacturing practices and economies of scale Other (SG&A) • Other cost are expected to remain stable Cell-based
  • 7. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands 10 Cell-based - Cost Source: Israel21C; Reuters; Mosa Meat; RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Good Food Institute (2020) ‘Analysis of culture medium costs and production volumes for cultivated meat’ Cell-based beef could reach cost parity with conventional beef in the near term, with varying views on the exact pace Perspective on alternative proteins Cell-based beef Cow beef 10,000,000 100,000 1,000 6 Forecast ’14 ’13 ’16 ’15 ’17 ’18 ’19 ’20 8 ’21 ’22 ’23 ’24 ’25 ’26 ’27 6 ’28 ’29 0 ’30 2 4 -67% Cost ($ / kg beef) Mosa Meat world’s first cell-based meat hamburger Memphis Meat ~$5,300 Future Meat Technologies ~$40,000 ~$800 ~$1.2m $10 / kg beef in ’23 Cost parity in ’25-’26 Cow beef cost increase due to loss of scale Fundamental cost advantages of cell- based over cow beef: • Higher feed conversion rate (25% vs 4%) • Faster production cycle (~2 weeks vs. ~3 years) • Shorter supply chain Cell-based The direction to cost competitiveness of cell-based meat is clear, the view on the exact pace varies
  • 8. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Cell-based - Performance Note: (1) To start resembling a realistic steak with full flavor, texture and nutrient content, lab-grown muscle needs to incorporate e.g. fat and connective tissue, each requiring own specialized growth environment Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Harvard University (2018) ‘How bioengineering could change meat production’; Good Food Institute (2019) ‘Cultivated meat state o/t industry’ Cell-based meat production has potential to provide food that is of high quality, with high consumer appeal, and more sustainable than conventional animal agriculture Perspective on alternative proteins 7 Product quality • Next to minced beef, current experiments include chicken nuggets and fish croquettes • Genetically identical to conventional animal products, but differences in texture • Potential for a direct one-for-one substitution – however technology for structured meat (e.g. steak) less mature, owing to structural complexity and need for different types of cell tissues1 Consumer appeal • Innovator and early adopter segments could purchase cell-based meat once commercial − ~33% likely to regularly purchase cell-based meat − ~20% willing to pay a higher price for cell-based meat than for its conventional counterpart (e.g. Dutch consumers indicate that they are willing to pay nearly 40% more) • Analysis of consumer attitudes also predicts an increase in adoption over time as affordability, taste appeal, and cultural normalization are demonstrated in the marketplace Environmental impact • Potential for lower greenhouse gas emissions than industrial animal agriculture − No animal waste that currently contributes to extensive soil and water pollution − Estimated to reduce land use by more than 95%, climate change emissions by 75%–85%, and nutrient pollution by 95% (compared to conventional beef) • Absolute emission levels will depend on electricity mix Cell-based
  • 9. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Precision Fermentation - Production Process Note: (1) E.g. methanethiol, only for two types of amino acids; (2) Using CRISPR-Cas9 Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Good Food Institute (2018) ‘Cellular agriculture’; US National Library of Medicine (2019) ‘What are genome editing and CRISPR-Cas9?’ In precision fermentation, gene-edited microbes can make a wide range of organic molecules, such as protein Perspective on alternative proteins 8 Fermentation tank Desired (animal) protein Final product • Inputs are inserted in fermentation tank which simulates conditions of cow rumen • Desired protein is produced by microbes, following ‘instruction manual’ from edited DNA • Protein is mixed with other ingredients (water, soy) to make final product (milk, burger) Precision fermentation Input • Carbohydrate (e.g. glucose), nitrogen (e.g. ammonium salt) and sulfur1 source are feed • Gene for protein is inserted in microbe DNA2 Animal gene Microbe (e.g. fungi, yeast, bacteria)
  • 10. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Precision Fermentation - Cost ($ / protein) Note: Fixed costs of production (facilities, upfront investment etc.) are not included in this view; Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’; Utrecht University (2009) ‘Understanding the reductions in US corn ethanol production costs’; Stanbury et al. (2016) ‘Principles of fermentation technology’; Stanford medicine (2018) ‘CRISPR is a revolutionary gene editing tool’; Monitor Deloitte analyses Precision fermentation cost could decrease significantly as a result of increased operating efficiency and scale ... Perspective on alternative proteins ~99% Now ~90% Future (>5 yrs) -60-90% CONCEPTUAL 9 Cost Drivers Fermentation cost • Purification cost decrease exponentially when producing at non-pharma quality • Gene editing cost decrease with more efficient use of CRISPR-Cas9 and other innovations, as well as increased production volume per edited gene • Fermentation tank cost decrease as tanks increase in size (5,000L to >100,000L) and control systems are used at scale • Other operating cost decrease along experience curve (e.g. corn ethanol fermentation shows -15% per doubling of cumulative volume) Feed and microbe input • Glucose cost as carbohydrate source decrease as conversion increases from 3:1 to 2:1 • Other input cost for nitrogen and sulfur sources as well as microbes do not change Precision fermentation
  • 11. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands 10,000,000 1,000,000 100 10,000,000,000 1 10 10,000 1,000 100,000 100,000,000 1,000,000,000 ’05 ’10 Cost ($ / kg of PF protein) ’85 ’90 ’95 ’20 ’00 ’15 ’25 ’30 ’35 Precision Fermentation - Cost Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’ ... after already having decreased by several orders of magnitude in the past Perspective on alternative proteins 10 $ 100 / kg protein in ’18, enabled by breakthroughs in: • computing power • data storage • genome sequencing $ 1 / kg protein in ’35 -7x orders of magnitude (’88-’18) -2x orders of magnitude (’18-’35) $ 10 / kg protein in ’26 Forecast Insulin, the first PF substitute of an animal product, received FDA approval in ’82 First production of PF rennet for cheese making in ’90 PF is used predominantly for medicine, vitamin and flavorant production Fundamental cost advantages of PF over animal products: • Higher feed conversion rate (40-80% vs 4%) • Faster ‘time to slaughter’ (weeks vs ~3 years) • Shorter supply chain Precision fermentation
  • 12. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Precision Fermentation - Cost Note: (1) Share PF protein ingredients is initially low but increases over time Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’ Beef and milk substitutes using precision fermentation proteins could become more cost competitive than their animal counterparts in the near term Perspective on alternative proteins 11 ’30 ’18 2 5 ’24 6 ’20 ’28 ’22 ’26 8 0 1 3 4 7 9 10 Cost ($ / kg beef) -84% Cost parity in ’21 20 ’24 ’18 0 ’28 ’30 ’20 ’26 ’22 5 30 10 15 25 Cost ($ / kg of milk protein) -86% Precision fermentation milk protein Whey Casein Precision fermentation beef Cow beef Cell-based beef Cost parity in ’24-’25 Precision fermentation beef (plant-based product with PF protein ingredients1) Precision fermentation milk protein (PF milk protein powder) Precision fermentation The direction to cost competitiveness of precision fermentation is clear, the view on the exact pace varies
  • 13. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Precision Fermentation - Performance Precision fermentation allows substitute products to taste nearly identical to animal products, at better nutritional values and lower environmental impact Perspective on alternative proteins 12 Product quality • Precision fermentation ingredients can make substitute products that taste nearly identical to animal products (e.g. milk protein and water, adding heme or animal fats to soy burgers) • Nutritional value can be better than animal products (e.g. less cholesterol, less carcinogenic) • Precision fermentation has no potential to replicate full animal products, only ingredients Consumer appeal • Main drivers of consumer appeal for precision fermentation-based products are: − Better for health − Better for environment − Better for animal welfare Environmental impact • Precision fermentation has lower emissions per kg protein than beef − More efficient production (no carcass, faster production cycle) − No methane emissions in contrast to cattle (methane counts for 25 CO2 equivalents) • Absolute emissions level of precision fermentation will depend on electricity mix and resources used Precision fermentation
  • 14. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Dynamics of disruption of proteins Source: RethinkX (2019) ‘Rethinking food and agriculture 2020-2030’ Increasing demand for modern foods could increase economies of scale, leading to greater improvement in cost and capabilities, driving further increases in demand Perspective on alternative proteins 13 Animal agriculture is a low-margin business where small shifts in demand can have large impacts More variety Economies of scale Better capacity More public acceptance Lower cost Higher revenues Higher margins More investment More government support Reverse economies of scale Less public acceptance Higher cost Lower revenues Lower margins Less investment Less government support Loss of ‘social license’ Synthetic protein ‘virtuous cycle’ Animal protein ‘vicious cycle’ More supply More demand Less supply Less demand
  • 15. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Start-up Country Product Growth thesis Partners ANH end market substitution / increased comp. (funding) ($324m) (CA) • Chicken nuggets • Has existing plant-based egg substitute • Apply for regulatory approval in several countries and launch product where obtained first • Use brand name and retail access of existing products US: EU: ($180m) (CA) • Hamburgers from beef, chicken and duck nuggets • Produce multiple products in agnostic technology to achieve further scale • Build pilot production facility to prove scalability, cost reduction and safety ($24m) (CA) • Yellowtail, tuna and salmon fillets • Target premium restaurant market first with quality product of whole fillets of various species • Build small production facility for first volumes ($14m) • Cell-based fats as food ingredient • Focus effort on single ingredient, for cell-based & traditional premium foods • Beat animal fats on health (omega-3, low saturated) Cell-based - Startup Examples (1/2) Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography; (1) Mosa Meat explores using Cubiq’s fat in its own products Source: Pitchbook; Good Food Institute (2019) ‘Cultivated meat: State of the industry’; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis Products of start-ups in cell-based protein production could decrease the need for the animals that form a substantial part of ’s primary customer base Perspective on alternative proteins 14 Cell-based 1 Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet
  • 16. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Start-up Country Product Growth thesis Partners ANH end market substitution / increased comp. (funding) ($14m) • Minute (i.e. thin) beefsteak • Develop steaks which has higher value than mince • Sell at slight premium to restaurant (down from cost price of $50 per steak today) ($9m) • b2b package with standardised technology for cell production (for food and materials) • Tech allows low cost pro-duction so that customers can focus on product dev. • Prove concept by producing e.g. foie gras and cosmetics ($8m) • Hamburgers from beef mince • Further reduce medium cost by reducing quality from pharma grade (current supplier is Merck) to food grade ($3m) (CA) • Pork sausage • Investment to accelerate R&D and production • Opportunity for non-food applications e.g. therapeutics and organ transplant n/a ($3m) (PA) • Pet food, probiotic supplement using nutritional yeast and cell-based mice • First develop premium product of cat treat • Working on scaling to nutritionally- complete foods for cats and dogs n/a Cell-based - Startup Examples (2/2) Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography Source: Pitchbook; Good Food Institute (2019) ‘Cultivated meat: State of the industry’; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis ... and could be a threat for by increasing competition on its product segments Perspective on alternative proteins 15 Cell-based Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet
  • 17. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Start-up Country Product Growth thesis Partners ANH end market substitution / increased comp. (funding) ($1.3b) (CA) • Soy beef burger and pork sausage enhanced with PF heme (leghemo-globin) • Enhance plant-based burger to be indistinguishable from animal, to win global market for meat substitutes • First in restaurants, now also in supermarkets ($197m) (CA) • Ice cream, butter and milk using PF milk protein and PF milk fat • First win share in animal-free premium ice cream • Then scale milk production to have identical product at lower cost but better for health and environment ($118m) (MA) • PF protein and fats ingredients to substitute animal ones or to enhance plant-based products • Win in b2b market for ingredients through broad portfolio with performance customisable to client needs ($54m) (NY) • Leather from PF collagen • Differentiate on product quality (shape and size) and animal-free for high fashion • Produce at Evonik Slovakia plant, expand to pharma Precision Fermentation - Startup Examples (1/2) Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography; (1) Also investor in the start-up; (2) Motif is a spin-off of Ginkgo Source: Pitchbook; Cell-based tech weekly; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis Also in precision fermentation, growth in start-ups could mean less need for animals ... Perspective on alternative proteins 16 2 Commercial Precision fermentation 3 Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet 2
  • 18. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Precision Fermentation - Startup Examples (2/2) Start-up Country Product Growth thesis Partners ANH end market substitution / increased comp. (funding) ($45m) (CA) • Egg protein ingredients for e.g. protein drinks or baking products • Win in b2b ingredient mkt, first with better perfor-mance (e.g. taste, foaming) • Scale production to achieve lower cost than chicken egg ($23m) (CA) • Cosmetics with PF human collagen and elastin proteins • Differentiate on product quality and animal-free to sell at premium • Develop collagen for food and pharma with Gelita ($16m) (CA) • Pet food (dogs) with PF protein1 • Develop cheapest complete PF protein (not imitating existing animal protein) • Sell at premium to vegan pet owners ($1m) (CO) • PF protein-based cheese • Differentiate on better taste and nutrition than other non-animal (100% plant-based) cheeses Note: Start-ups selected to show spread in product and geography; (1) Also developing cell-based mice meat for cat food; (2) Also investor in the start-up; (3) stabilised hemoglobin and hydrolysed globin Source: Pitchbook; Cell-based tech weekly; Company websites; Monitor Deloitte analysis ... and increased competition in ’s product segments Perspective on alternative proteins 17 Commercial Precision fermentation 2 2 2 Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet Ruminants Poultry Aqua Swine Pet 2
  • 19. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Volume and Value Composition by Species Source: University of Tennesee; Oklahoma Department of Agriculture; Monitor Deloitte analysis Swine and ruminants are more susceptible to disruption than poultry, as their easy-to- substitute mince products make up a higher share of value Perspective on alternative proteins 18 15% 25% 25% 35% 15% 25% 10% 10% 35% 5% Mince Volume Value By-product Chops Ham & bacon Roast 20% 55% 25% 25% 10% 12% 25% 5% 20% Legs Volume Value Wings Breast By-product (other) By-product (carcass) 15% 50% 35% 40% 50% 10% Volume Value Steak Mince By-product 1. Profit lost to substitution must be recuperated on other products 2. Other products increase in price, further decreasing demand Just chicken nugget Example substitute: Impossible Pork Burger Poultry Ruminants Swine INDICATIVE High Limited Synthetic protein activity: Moderate Memphis Meat burger Aleph Farms steak 3%
  • 20. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands Synthetic Protein Threat and Opportunity … while substitution of animal-based proteins also opens up new growth platforms, as growing world population still need proteins, albeit from different sources Perspective on alternative proteins 19 Opportunity for to leverage existing capabilities into adjacent growth market While synthetic proteins have the potential to mark a decline of an industry which contains majority of ’s conventional end markets … … growth in synthetic protein market also offers new growth opportunities, e.g.: • Leverage fermentation expertise • Provide specialty yeasts for precision fermentation • Provide specialty food ingredients to synthetic protein food producers • … Declining animal- based protein industry and associated end markets Growing synthetic protein market requires new ingredients
  • 21. Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee (“DTTL”), its network of member firms, and their related entities. DTTL and each of its member firms are legally separate and independent entities. DTTL (also referred to as “Deloitte Global”) does not provide services to clients. Please see www.deloitte.nl/about to learn more about our global network of member firms. Deloitte provides audit, consulting, financial advisory, risk advisory, tax and related services to public and private clients spanning multiple industries. Deloitte serves four out of five Fortune Global 500ÂŽ companies through a globally connected network of member firms in more than 150 countries and territories bringing world-class capabilities, insights, and high-quality service to address clients’ most complex business challenges. To learn more about how Deloitte’s approximately 245,000 professionals make an impact that matters, please connect with us on Facebook, LinkedIn, or Twitter. This communication contains general information only, and none of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, its member firms, or their related entities (collectively, the “Deloitte Network”) is, by means of this communication, rendering professional advice or services. Before making any decision or taking any action that may affect your finances or your business, you should consult a qualified professional adviser. No entity in the Deloitte Network shall be responsible for any loss whatsoever sustained by any person who relies on this communication. Š 2020 Monitor Deloitte The Netherlands