SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 3
RELATIVE CLAUSES – AN EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

We use relative clauses to give additional information about something without starting another
sentence. By combining sentences with a relative clause, your text becomes more fluent and you can
avoid repeating certain words.

How to Form Relative Clauses
Imagine a girl is talking to Tom. You want to know who she is and ask a friend whether he knows her.
You could say:

 A girl is talking to Tom. Do you know the girl?

That sounds rather complicated, doesn't it? It would be easier with a relative clause: you put both
pieces of information into one sentence. Start with the most important thing – you want to know who
the girl is.

 Do you know the girl 


As your friend cannot know which girl you are talking about, you need to put in the additional
information – the girl is talking to Tom. Use „the girl“ only in the first part of the sentence, in the
second part replace it with the relative pronoun (for people, use the relative pronoun „who“). So the
final sentence is:

 Do you know the girl who is talking to Tom?

Relative Pronouns

relative
                                        use                                           example
pronoun


who            subject or object pronoun for people                      I told you about the
                                                                         woman wholives next door.


which          subject or object pronoun for animals and things          Do you see the cat which is lying
                                                                         on the roof?


which          referring to a whole sentence                             He couldn’t read which surprised
                                                                         me.


whose          possession for people animals and things                  Do you know the
                                                                         boy whosemother is a nurse?


whom           object pronoun for people, especially in non-defining     I was invited by the
               relative clauses (in defining relative clauses we         professorwhom I met at the
colloquially prefer who)                                  conference.


that         subject or object pronoun for people, animals and         I don’t like the table that stands in
             things in defining relative clauses (who orwhich are      the kitchen.
             also possible)



Subject Pronoun or Object Pronoun?
Subject and object pronouns cannot be distinguished by their forms - who, which, that are used for
subject and object pronouns. You can, however, distinguish them as follows:

If the relative pronoun is followed by a verb, the relative pronoun is a subject pronoun. Subject
pronouns must always be used.

 the apple which is lying on the table

If the relative pronoun is not followed by a verb (but by a noun or pronoun), the relative pronoun is
an object pronoun. Object pronouns can be dropped in defining relative clauses, which are then
called Contact Clauses.

 the apple (which) George lay on the table

Relative Adverbs
A relative adverb can be used instead of a relative pronoun plus preposition. This often makes the
sentence easier to understand.

 This is the shop in which I bought my bike.
 → This is the shop where I bought my bike.


  relative
                meaning                          use                              example
  adverb


when           in/on which   refers to a time expression                the day when we met him


where          in/at which   refers to a place                          the place where we met him


why            for which     refers to a reason                         the reason why we met him



Defining Relative Clauses
Defining relative clauses (also called identifying relative clauses or restrictive relative clauses) give
detailed information defining a general term or expression. Defining relative clauses are not put
incommas.
Imagine, Tom is in a room with five girls. One girl is talking to Tom and you ask somebody whether he
knows this girl. Here the relative clause defines which of the five girls you mean.

 Do you know the girl who is talking to Tom?

Defining relative clauses are often used in definitions.

 A seaman is someone who works on a ship.

Object pronouns in defining relative clauses can be dropped. (Sentences with a relative clause
without the relative pronoun are called Contact Clauses.)

 The boy (who/whom) we met yesterday is very nice.

Non-Defining Relative Clauses
Non-defining relative clauses (also called non-identifying relative clauses or non-restrictive relative
clauses) give additional information on something, but do not define it. Non-defining relative clauses
are put in commas.

Imagine, Tom is in a room with only one girl. The two are talking to each other and you ask somebody
whether he knows this girl. Here the relative clause is non-defining because in this situation it is
obvious which girl you mean.

 Do you know the girl, who is talking to Tom?

Note: In non-defining relative clauses, who/which may not be replaced with that.

Object pronouns in non-defining relative clauses must be used.

 Jim, who/whom we met yesterday, is very nice.

How to Shorten Relative Clauses?
Relative clauses with who, which, that as subject pronoun can be replaced with a participle. This
makes the sentence shorter and easier to understand.

 I told you about the woman who lives next door. – I told you about the
 woman living next door.

 Do you see the cat which is lying on the roof? – Do you see the cat lying on the
 roof?

Weitere Àhnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Intro To English Nouns
Intro To English NounsIntro To English Nouns
Intro To English Nouns
cornopean
 
Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
Pepa Mut
 
4.4 compound sentence by_subordination
4.4 compound sentence by_subordination4.4 compound sentence by_subordination
4.4 compound sentence by_subordination
paolyta28
 
Unit 9
Unit 9Unit 9
Unit 9
sellsoup
 
Chapter 3 using pronouns in sentences
Chapter 3   using pronouns in sentencesChapter 3   using pronouns in sentences
Chapter 3 using pronouns in sentences
Maximoff
 
Pronouns
PronounsPronouns
Pronouns
ewaszolek
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Relative clause
Relative clauseRelative clause
Relative clause
 
Relative clause
Relative clauseRelative clause
Relative clause
 
Importance of clause
Importance of clauseImportance of clause
Importance of clause
 
Relative clause
Relative clauseRelative clause
Relative clause
 
Relatives
RelativesRelatives
Relatives
 
Week 3 relative clause
Week 3 relative clauseWeek 3 relative clause
Week 3 relative clause
 
Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
 
Correct Usage of Nouns and Pronouns by Iqbal
Correct Usage of Nouns and Pronouns by IqbalCorrect Usage of Nouns and Pronouns by Iqbal
Correct Usage of Nouns and Pronouns by Iqbal
 
Intro To English Nouns
Intro To English NounsIntro To English Nouns
Intro To English Nouns
 
PRONOUNS
PRONOUNSPRONOUNS
PRONOUNS
 
Relatives
RelativesRelatives
Relatives
 
Pronoun ppt
Pronoun pptPronoun ppt
Pronoun ppt
 
Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
 
4.4 compound sentence by_subordination
4.4 compound sentence by_subordination4.4 compound sentence by_subordination
4.4 compound sentence by_subordination
 
Unit 9
Unit 9Unit 9
Unit 9
 
All About Pronouns
All About PronounsAll About Pronouns
All About Pronouns
 
Clauses and kinds
Clauses and kindsClauses and kinds
Clauses and kinds
 
Chapter 3 using pronouns in sentences
Chapter 3   using pronouns in sentencesChapter 3   using pronouns in sentences
Chapter 3 using pronouns in sentences
 
Parts of Speech (Pronoun) - English Grammar for beginners
Parts of Speech (Pronoun) - English Grammar for beginnersParts of Speech (Pronoun) - English Grammar for beginners
Parts of Speech (Pronoun) - English Grammar for beginners
 
Pronouns
PronounsPronouns
Pronouns
 

Ähnlich wie Relative clauses

UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...
UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...
UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...
FernandaCh
 
Relative pronouns
Relative pronounsRelative pronouns
Relative pronouns
Rick Zepeda
 
Relative Clauses
Relative ClausesRelative Clauses
Relative Clauses
Pilar
 
Relative clauses 2nd grade
Relative clauses   2nd gradeRelative clauses   2nd grade
Relative clauses 2nd grade
silviamilagres
 
Lesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUN
Lesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUNLesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUN
Lesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUN
jessieboymiguel8
 
Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
emullera614
 
Chapter 2 – Using Pronouns Correctly
Chapter 2 – Using Pronouns CorrectlyChapter 2 – Using Pronouns Correctly
Chapter 2 – Using Pronouns Correctly
Maximoff
 
Adjective clause and relative clause
Adjective clause and relative clauseAdjective clause and relative clause
Adjective clause and relative clause
ayu larissa
 
Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
mluisavm
 

Ähnlich wie Relative clauses (20)

Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
 
UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...
UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...
UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR FACULTAD DE FILOSOFÍA LETRAS Y CIENCÍAS DE LA...
 
Relative pronouns
Relative pronounsRelative pronouns
Relative pronouns
 
Relative clauses diapositivas
Relative clauses diapositivasRelative clauses diapositivas
Relative clauses diapositivas
 
Relative Clauses
Relative ClausesRelative Clauses
Relative Clauses
 
Relative clauses 2nd grade
Relative clauses   2nd gradeRelative clauses   2nd grade
Relative clauses 2nd grade
 
Lesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUN
Lesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUNLesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUN
Lesson 2 - PRONOUNS and TYPES OF PROUNOUN
 
Conjunction & Pronouns
Conjunction & PronounsConjunction & Pronouns
Conjunction & Pronouns
 
Parts of speech
Parts of speech Parts of speech
Parts of speech
 
Relative clause
Relative clauseRelative clause
Relative clause
 
Relative clause
Relative clauseRelative clause
Relative clause
 
What is a pronoun? Pronoun Presentations
What is a pronoun? Pronoun PresentationsWhat is a pronoun? Pronoun Presentations
What is a pronoun? Pronoun Presentations
 
Parts of the sentence i
Parts of the sentence iParts of the sentence i
Parts of the sentence i
 
Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
 
Pronoun
PronounPronoun
Pronoun
 
PRONOUNS.pdf
PRONOUNS.pdfPRONOUNS.pdf
PRONOUNS.pdf
 
Chapter 2 – Using Pronouns Correctly
Chapter 2 – Using Pronouns CorrectlyChapter 2 – Using Pronouns Correctly
Chapter 2 – Using Pronouns Correctly
 
Pronouns[1]
Pronouns[1]Pronouns[1]
Pronouns[1]
 
Adjective clause and relative clause
Adjective clause and relative clauseAdjective clause and relative clause
Adjective clause and relative clause
 
Relative clauses
Relative clausesRelative clauses
Relative clauses
 

Mehr von Universidad de Narino (20)

The most dangerous jobs
The most dangerous jobsThe most dangerous jobs
The most dangerous jobs
 
Dyslexia
DyslexiaDyslexia
Dyslexia
 
People who changed the world
People who changed the worldPeople who changed the world
People who changed the world
 
Near death experiences
Near death experiencesNear death experiences
Near death experiences
 
Phobias
PhobiasPhobias
Phobias
 
Lie detecting
Lie detectingLie detecting
Lie detecting
 
Interesting cultures
Interesting culturesInteresting cultures
Interesting cultures
 
Hypnosis
HypnosisHypnosis
Hypnosis
 
How to improve your conversational skills
How to improve your conversational skillsHow to improve your conversational skills
How to improve your conversational skills
 
Exotic pets
Exotic petsExotic pets
Exotic pets
 
Electric cars
Electric carsElectric cars
Electric cars
 
Crime
CrimeCrime
Crime
 
Crazy laws
Crazy lawsCrazy laws
Crazy laws
 
Children geniuses 1
Children geniuses 1Children geniuses 1
Children geniuses 1
 
Anxiety
AnxietyAnxiety
Anxiety
 
Religious mysteries and miracles
Religious mysteries and miraclesReligious mysteries and miracles
Religious mysteries and miracles
 
Myths & legends
Myths & legendsMyths & legends
Myths & legends
 
Demons
DemonsDemons
Demons
 
Metaphysical Phenomena
Metaphysical PhenomenaMetaphysical Phenomena
Metaphysical Phenomena
 
Ouija and divination
Ouija and divinationOuija and divination
Ouija and divination
 

KĂŒrzlich hochgeladen

Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
baharayali
 
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
Health
 
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdfJORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
Arturo Pacheco Alvarez
 
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
CMBustamante
 

KĂŒrzlich hochgeladen (20)

08448380779 Call Girls In Lajpat Nagar Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Lajpat Nagar Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Lajpat Nagar Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Lajpat Nagar Women Seeking Men
 
Technical Data | Sig Sauer Easy6 BDX 1-6x24 | Optics Trade
Technical Data | Sig Sauer Easy6 BDX 1-6x24 | Optics TradeTechnical Data | Sig Sauer Easy6 BDX 1-6x24 | Optics Trade
Technical Data | Sig Sauer Easy6 BDX 1-6x24 | Optics Trade
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men
 
UEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docx
UEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docxUEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docx
UEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docx
 
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
 
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum Call Girl available for hotel room package
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum  Call Girl available for hotel room packageWhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum  Call Girl available for hotel room package
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum Call Girl available for hotel room package
 
08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men
 
Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.
Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.
Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.
 
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Kasauli Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Kasauli Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Kasauli Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Kasauli Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
Ramban Escorts ☎8617697112 Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...
Ramban  Escorts ☎8617697112  Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...Ramban  Escorts ☎8617697112  Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...
Ramban Escorts ☎8617697112 Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...
 
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdfJORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
 
ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024
ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024
ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024
 
Trossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docx
Trossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docxTrossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docx
Trossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docx
 
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
 
08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men
 
Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...
Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...
Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...
 
Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...
Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...
Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...
 
Slovenia Vs Serbia UEFA Euro 2024 Fixture Guide Every Fixture Detailed.docx
Slovenia Vs Serbia UEFA Euro 2024 Fixture Guide Every Fixture Detailed.docxSlovenia Vs Serbia UEFA Euro 2024 Fixture Guide Every Fixture Detailed.docx
Slovenia Vs Serbia UEFA Euro 2024 Fixture Guide Every Fixture Detailed.docx
 
Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...
Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...
Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...
 

Relative clauses

  • 1. RELATIVE CLAUSES – AN EXECUTIVE SUMMARY We use relative clauses to give additional information about something without starting another sentence. By combining sentences with a relative clause, your text becomes more fluent and you can avoid repeating certain words. How to Form Relative Clauses Imagine a girl is talking to Tom. You want to know who she is and ask a friend whether he knows her. You could say: A girl is talking to Tom. Do you know the girl? That sounds rather complicated, doesn't it? It would be easier with a relative clause: you put both pieces of information into one sentence. Start with the most important thing – you want to know who the girl is. Do you know the girl 
 As your friend cannot know which girl you are talking about, you need to put in the additional information – the girl is talking to Tom. Use „the girl“ only in the first part of the sentence, in the second part replace it with the relative pronoun (for people, use the relative pronoun „who“). So the final sentence is: Do you know the girl who is talking to Tom? Relative Pronouns relative use example pronoun who subject or object pronoun for people I told you about the woman wholives next door. which subject or object pronoun for animals and things Do you see the cat which is lying on the roof? which referring to a whole sentence He couldn’t read which surprised me. whose possession for people animals and things Do you know the boy whosemother is a nurse? whom object pronoun for people, especially in non-defining I was invited by the relative clauses (in defining relative clauses we professorwhom I met at the
  • 2. colloquially prefer who) conference. that subject or object pronoun for people, animals and I don’t like the table that stands in things in defining relative clauses (who orwhich are the kitchen. also possible) Subject Pronoun or Object Pronoun? Subject and object pronouns cannot be distinguished by their forms - who, which, that are used for subject and object pronouns. You can, however, distinguish them as follows: If the relative pronoun is followed by a verb, the relative pronoun is a subject pronoun. Subject pronouns must always be used. the apple which is lying on the table If the relative pronoun is not followed by a verb (but by a noun or pronoun), the relative pronoun is an object pronoun. Object pronouns can be dropped in defining relative clauses, which are then called Contact Clauses. the apple (which) George lay on the table Relative Adverbs A relative adverb can be used instead of a relative pronoun plus preposition. This often makes the sentence easier to understand. This is the shop in which I bought my bike. → This is the shop where I bought my bike. relative meaning use example adverb when in/on which refers to a time expression the day when we met him where in/at which refers to a place the place where we met him why for which refers to a reason the reason why we met him Defining Relative Clauses Defining relative clauses (also called identifying relative clauses or restrictive relative clauses) give detailed information defining a general term or expression. Defining relative clauses are not put incommas.
  • 3. Imagine, Tom is in a room with five girls. One girl is talking to Tom and you ask somebody whether he knows this girl. Here the relative clause defines which of the five girls you mean. Do you know the girl who is talking to Tom? Defining relative clauses are often used in definitions. A seaman is someone who works on a ship. Object pronouns in defining relative clauses can be dropped. (Sentences with a relative clause without the relative pronoun are called Contact Clauses.) The boy (who/whom) we met yesterday is very nice. Non-Defining Relative Clauses Non-defining relative clauses (also called non-identifying relative clauses or non-restrictive relative clauses) give additional information on something, but do not define it. Non-defining relative clauses are put in commas. Imagine, Tom is in a room with only one girl. The two are talking to each other and you ask somebody whether he knows this girl. Here the relative clause is non-defining because in this situation it is obvious which girl you mean. Do you know the girl, who is talking to Tom? Note: In non-defining relative clauses, who/which may not be replaced with that. Object pronouns in non-defining relative clauses must be used. Jim, who/whom we met yesterday, is very nice. How to Shorten Relative Clauses? Relative clauses with who, which, that as subject pronoun can be replaced with a participle. This makes the sentence shorter and easier to understand. I told you about the woman who lives next door. – I told you about the woman living next door. Do you see the cat which is lying on the roof? – Do you see the cat lying on the roof?