SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 166
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
EUROPEANA 2019
28 Nov 2019 | LISBON
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
WIFI
Login: SSID: BNP-WIFI
Password: 1214EB0257
Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain
KU Leuven
https://pro.europeana.eu/n
etwork-association/special
-interest-groups/european
a-education
413565
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
Executive Director
Shaping the future of
education
with cultural heritage
“There is a wealth of digital heritage available online. World
renowned galleries, archives, museums and libraries provide
online access to their collections, and many local initiatives make
digital heritage more widely available. As access to the internet
improves, and more people own smartphones and other similar
devices, these collections can be accessed online by students and
educators with fewer and fewer technological barriers. So far,
however, this has failed to lead to the improvements in
education you might expect.”
Cats in human dress playing a variety of games, including arm wrestling and tug of war, Kunimasa IV, 1870s, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
Some sources
that teachers
want to use are
not there
● Leonardo Da
Vinci
● Del Castagno,
● Tintoretto
Some sources
that teachers
want to use are
not there
● Leonardo Da
Vinci
● Del Castagno,
● Tintoretto
“The real killer was finding super stuff on
Europeana and then seeing NO next to
copyright details.”
A member of the Historiana historical
content team expressing his frustration
about finding sources he could not use.
Unfounded
copyright claims
can prevent the
educational use
of sources that
are in the public
domain as some
teachers don’t
want to take
risks.
Some source
lack information.
They might be
interesting to
use, but finding
out more
information
would require a
lot of original
research.
Balletklas van dansschool Crielaars, Zuiden, Fotopersbureau Het,, Stadsarchief 's-Hertogenbosch, Netherlands, CC BY-SA
We select,
contextualise
and curate
source
collections on
historical topics
and themes that
are commonly
taught across
Europe.
Each source in
the collection
has a description
that helps
educators to use
the source, a
reference that
helps to find the
source, and
copyright
information.
We are making it
possible for
teacher to create
their own
eLearning
Activities in their
language of
choice.
Each block in the
activity builder is
focussed on
another aspect
of historical
thinking.
We provide
workshops for
teachers with the
Europeana
source
collections.
We offer online
workshops on
how to use the
tools
This guide
supports teacher
trainers to
provide
workshops as
well.
For each new
source
collection, there
is an exemplar
eLearning
Activity that
demonstrates
how the
collection can be
used.
Snell, A practical guide to the examination, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
We are are building three new tools for the Activity Builder.
Discover Highlight Compare
We want will
work further on
the
documentation
for
webdevelopers
historiana.dev
We want to work
more directly
with the cultural
heritage
organisation on
the development
of source
collections and
eLearning
Activities
- In what ways did Roman / Greek
inventions affect later developments in
European life?
- In what ways are nation-states
illustrated in artistic imagery?
- How and why did coffee become a global
commodity?
- What inventions were needed before
James Watt could invent his steam
machine?
- How did the industrial revolution
change working conditions?
We are
upgrading the
partner pages.
Making it
possible to
partners to
publish source
collections and
eLearning
Activities.
We will continue
to test Historiana
with educators
and research
how they search
for historical
sources.
The research
results will be
shared via
Europeana.
413565
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
Pedagogical Manager
Shaping the future of
education
with cultural heritage
Bulong Miao, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
413565
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
Europeana Ambassador PT
Shaping the future of
education
with cultural heritage
• Coordinate the UG
• Support the MOOCs
• Create LS
• Dissemination
• Moderate the Blog
• Jury – User Group competition
+ 200 Learning Scenarios
+ 80 Stories of Implementation
Learning Scenario
(LS)
• Europeana Content
• Educational Trends
• XXI Century Skills
• Curriculum
integration
• Activities
Westminster School of Industry, Old Pye Street,n.d, Welcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
Story of
Implementation
• Choose a LS
• Implement w/ students
• Collect information
• Stars - Wish
• Design SoI
• Publish a postWestminster School of Industry, Old Pye Street,n.d, Welcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
Brain Challenges (LS-PT-22)
Life on the trenches – A VR Experience (LS-PT-06)
From muscle machines to the smart machines (LS-PT).
?
Collaboration
Communication
Creativity
ComplexProblem
Solving
Curiosity
How we build skills of the 21st-century
like media literacy or critical thinking?
How to connect with children's and
young people trough Digital Cultural
Heritage?
By speaking the same language!
What language?
Digital!
Digital
Cultural Heritage
...we need to understand our past...to build a better future.
413565
➔ Find out more on Europeana Education Community
➔ Join our Europeana Education LinkedIn and Facebook
Groups
➔ Twitter: @EuropeanaEU, #EuropeanaEducation
➔ Contact us by email: education@europeana.eu
Enrich your educational resources and inspire learners with
Europeana content!
Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain
Europeana Foundation
1. Summary of Finnish Presidency event on Multilingualism and
digital cultural heritage (Andy Neale)
2. Use-cases for infrastructures enabling multilinguality in
digital cultural heritage (Pavel Kats and Alex Raginsky)
3. Improving access to historical documents in Transcribathon
Platform and Europeana Collections (Gordea Sergiu)
4. Europeana multilingual strategy and automatic translation
(Antoine Isaac)
Books on a table, Aalto, Ilmari, 1928, National Digital Library (NDL), Finland, CC0
EUROPEANA MEETING
UNDER FINLAND’S PRESIDENCY
OF THE COUNCIL OF THE EU
ESPOO, FINLAND
1. Stimulate reflection on multilingualism in digital cultural
heritage at large using Europeana as a case study
2. Develop a deeper understanding of the multilingualism
problem/opportunity space for digital cultural heritage
3. Consider what options can be pursued to provoke action at the local
level, furthering the multilingual capabilities
4. Provide input and feedback for the Europeana multilingual strategy
History of multilingual
development
Multilingual policy
Learnings from automatic
translation projects
User experience design
Linked vocabularies and automatic
subject indexing services
Measuring success
Multilingual metadata
Content translation
Update on eTranslation
Identify
language
Original
query
Translate to
English
Multilingual
index
User
Disambiguates
Search
Translated query (English)
Suggest Entity
(Knowledge Graph)
Entity-based query
Multilingual query:
entity based query
OR original query +
translated query
#1: French
#2: Spanish
#3: Polish
Determine the size of the
opportunity and place 1
to 5 stickers in the size
column, where 5 is the
biggest opportunity and
each lower number a
smaller opportunity. Use
each number only once.
Benefits
Group exercise
16:00 - 16:15
1. People can access the knowledge
of other cultures and knowledge
groups
2. More sources of material to search
across
3. Promotes socially inclusive
societies and mutual
understanding of different cultures
Top 3 benefits
Take a turn to present an issue to
your table. Combine with others
where appropriate. Write the
agreed issue upon on a card.
Place it on the canvas and
determine if we have the
capabilities and/or technology to
tackle this issue. Next person’s turn.
Issues
Group exercise
17:15 - 17:45
Circle the number of
the priority column
Issue text
Issue text
Common
themes
1. Lack of…
2. Quality of data
3. Standardisation
4. Knowledge sharing and
visibility
Solutions
Group exercise
11:30 - 11:40
Issue text
Issue text
Top
proposals
1. Strengthen capacity to identify, connect,
work with and facilitate technology transfer
2. Marketing and dissemination of tools
3. Improved communication mechanisms and
increased visibility of Europeana projects
4. Co-operation on national and local level
5. More language experts on local level
6. Awareness of benefits of good quality
content
7. Improve quality of metadata
8. Cheaper mass translation tools
9. Automated data cleaning tool
10. Terminology thesaurus
11. Requirements and dialogue with providers
of collection management systems
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
CEO
Culture Chatbot Tech Lead
‘Use-cases for infrastructures enabling
multilinguality in digital cultural heritage’
Who we are: Jewish Heritage Network
● Global digital initiative for Jewish cultural heritage content
● Content network of more than 30 Jewish museums, archives, libraries,
and research centers from Europe (mainly), US, and Israel
● Digital platform of services for content aggregation, publication and
promotion
● Accredited partner of Europeana, the European digital platform for
culture
Culture Chatbot
Who we are: Pangeanic
● Global translation company, offering translation technologies to
language industry professionals and translation services.
● World leader in AI-enhanced machine translation services.
● Frequent builder of infrastructure solutions for European Public
Administrations and CEF (Connecting Europe Facility).
● Leader of EU-funded PangeaMT and NTEU (upcoming) consortia and
projects
Culture Chatbot - flavour 1
Culture Chatbot
Culture Chatbot - flavour 2
Culture Chatbot
Culture Chatbot - flavour 3
Culture Chatbot
Source Integration Application Interaction / UI
Metadata
Digital Content
Vocabularies, thesauri etc
Aggregation
Semantic Enrichment
?
Chatbot
Collections
Exhibitions
Use
case
Service
Infra
Value
Chain
Process
/ Asset
Search
Browse
Display
Explore
Use case #1: User Messages Translation
Use case #1: User Messages Translation
Use case #2: Metadata Translation
Internal data representation derived from EDM
Use case #2: Metadata Translation
Use case #2: Metadata Translation (all
EU languages)
Culture Chatbot
● Pilot in Judaica Europeana 2.0
● Direct translation from source language to 24 EU
languages
● Enabled and supported by PangeaMT and NTEU
Use case #3: Human-assisted t-n
Use case #4: Multilingual Semantic
Search (not only for bots)
● Infrastructure: multilingual BERT model (104 languages)
● Extract entities from metadata and query (using NER built on BERT)
● Calculate word semantic vectors (“embeddings”) with BERT for
metadata, query and extracted entities
● Combine SOLR/ElasticSearch keyword search with nearest neighbor
vector search (“semantic search”)
Culture Chatbot
Use case #5: Language Choice UI
● Implicitly:
○ using site language
○ language detection of the first user message
● Explicitly:
○ a question at the beginning of the conversation (“Please
choose conversation language”)
○ a language change intent (“Do you speak English?”)
○ chatbot persistent menu
Source Integration Application Interaction / UI
Metadata
Digital Content
Vocabularies, thesauri etc
Aggregation
Semantic Enrichment
Chatbot
Collections
Exhibitions
Use
case
Service
Infra
Value
Chain
Process
/ Asset
Search
Browse
Display
Explore
Use case #1: User Messages
Translation
● Conversation history
● Real-time
Use case #2: Metadata Translation
● Aggregation-time translation
● Display in user’s preferred lang
Use case #3: Human-assisted
translationUse case #4: Semantic Multilingual
Search
Use case #5: Language Choice UI
Machine TranslationSemantic Search NER Human-assisted translation
Source Integration Application Interaction / UI
Metadata
Digital Content
Vocabularies, thesauri etc
Aggregation
Semantic Enrichment
Chatbot
Collections
Exhibitions
Use
case
Service
Infra
Value
Chain
Process
/ Asset
Search
Browse
Display
Explore
Use case #1: User Messages
Translation
● Conversation history
● Real-time
Use case #2: Metadata Translation
● Aggregation-time translation
● Display in user’s preferred lang
Use case #3: Human-assisted
translationUse case #4: Semantic Multilingual
Search
Use case #5: Language Choice UI
Machine TranslationSemantic Search NER Human-assisted translation
PangeaMT NTEUeTranslationBERT DSI
DSI
DSI
Ecosystem Considerations
● Infrastructurisation
Migrating technology “downwards” towards services and infras
● Supported Use Case Inventory
Rich and fine-grained inventory of supported use-cases through
conducting proactive research with the community
● Sustainability
Improving chances for sustainability by funding DSIs and keeping
them
● Community Building
Around DSIs and best practices in using them
Infrastructure vendor outlook
● Having a defined policy and commitment to mulilingualism as well as
the provision of multilingual content
● Continuity and sustainability
● Can be embedded in Europeana processes
● Leverage project money to offer free services to industry leaders to
create awareness
Role for Europeana and Invitation to NTEU
● Represent the Digital Heritage sector’s interests in need in European
machine translation DSIs
● Inform the development of new DSIs with requirements specific to
heritage data and usage scenarios
● Incorporate DSI-based services for heritage into Europeana DSI: for
its own sake and the sake of smaller practitioners and projects
Role for Europeana and Invitation to NTEU
We are very pleased to invite Europeana into NTEU User Group in
order to integrate language technologies and policies into the project.
NTEU is a newly started CEF project that will build 506 translation
engines in all EU languages but English, providing training data into
low-resourced and medium-resourced languages. Having Europeana
as an interest party in our User Group would allow both Europeana
and NTEU Consortium to evaluate the quality of engines as developed
for Public Administrations, and for Europeana to make use of other
DSI developments, as well as integrate their services into the
platform.
We look forward to working together with Europeana and make it
fully multilingual and improve accessibility and promoting cultural
assets across the EU's languages.
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
Senior Research Engineer
AIT Austrian Institute of Technology GmbH
Improving access to historical documents within
Transcribathon Platform and Europeana Collections
Further development of the Transcribathon Prototype and
integrate it with Europeana Collections, National Aggregator
and Libraries portals
ENRICH EUROPEANA
ENHANCE ACCESSIBILITY OF UGC
10628.11.2019
Crowdsourced and User Generated Content:
• Brings into light new insights related to historical Events (e.g.Europeana
1914-1918, Europeana 1989)
• Typically lacks of rich and standardized descriptive metadata
Goals:
• Facilitate access to information „hidden“ in scanned
manuscripts
• Enrich document descriptions with contextual information
Wikidata Places and Persons; keywords/topics
• Enhance user experience by integrating state of the
art technologies (e.g. IIIF, NERL)
THE BEAUTY OF HISTORICAL MANUSCRIPTS
10728.11.2019
• Letters and Journals present the life and the emotions
of regular people
• Often indicate facts, that were not written
in history books
• They catch attention and motivate user‘s to interact
with the content
…. AND THE CHALLENGES
10828.11.2019
• Historical documents are hardly understood with the passing of time:
• Grammar and words of all languages are changing in time
• Simple people use dialects
• Preserve the language and the writing from their time
Translation original text Translation improved version
On the first of March we passed the
tunnery exam, and with good behavior
we went into the (Geschitz Vormeister)
course, the first cannibal riders. For the
cannons as justifiers are sub-skills, and
this school I did. On March 28, Pola the
heir to the throne came. A. Sa Francis
Ferdinand (Erzherzog Franz Ferdinand)
had nice reception forces, Mr. arrived on
the boat (Jacht) reigning S.M.S.
Lacroma.
On the first of March I passed the
tunnery exam, and having a good
behaviour, I entered the course for
"Geschitz Vormeister", meaning first
cannon setter. As for the cannons, the
setters are lower officers, and this
school I did as well. On March 28th
came to Pola the heir to the throne, His
Highness Francis Ferdinand
("Erzherzog Franz Ferdinand"), he had
a very beautiful reception, He arrived on
the royal boat ("Jacht") S.M.S. Lacroma
SEMANTIC ENRICHMENTS
10928.11.2019
ENTITY RECOGNTION
11028.11.2019
Performance of person and location detection
• Based on English translation of 15 pages from Dumitru Nistor Journal
ENTITY LINKING
11128.11.2019
Performance of linking detected locations with items from Wikidata and Europeana Entity
Collection
IMPLEMENTATION OF FAIR PRINCIPLES
11228.11.2019
• Findable and Accesible:
• text becomes machine readable after trascription
• english translation is generated
• Interoperable:
• enrichments (including transcriptions) available as W3C Web Annotations
• integration with Europeana Collections
• Reusable
• Public Domain and CC0 content
• transcriptions and enrichments available
under CC0 Licence
…. THE GOOD NEWS
11328.11.2019
„My Diary“
2020
NEW TRANSCRIBATHON TOOL
11428.11.2019
https://beta.transcribathon.eu
NEW TRANSCRIBATHON TOOL
11528.11.2019 https://beta.transcribathon.eu
THANK YOU!
QUESTIONS?
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
R&D Manager
‘Europeana multilingual
strategy and automatic
translation’
● Juliane Stiller - You, We & Digital
● Tom Vanallemeersch - Crosslang
● Mónica Marrero, Andy Neale – Europeana Foundation
Content
Information Access
Interactions
User Interface
Metadata and digital
CH objects
Search, Browse & Explore
Show user‘s
preferred language
Bridge the gap between
language of user input
and content
Layers of digital CH systems
From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
User Interface
Challenges:
• Translation of static and dynamic
pages
• Switching languages via text or
icons such as flags
• Determine the user‘s preferred
language
User Interface
From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
Interactions: Search Interactions
From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
Mismatch between query and
content language
• Mona Lisa 203 results
• La Gioconda 376 results 
• La Joconde 78 results
Interactions
Roma, Galleria Corsini - La
Gioconda,From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
Interactions: Browse
● Search vs. browse
● Metadata vs. content
Interactions
From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
Content & Metadata
Image Credit: both from Europeana with Titlte „Kinderbuch” from
Spielzeugmuseum der Stadt Nürnberg (CC BY-NC-SA)
Content
From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
Metadata multilinguality
+ 40 other languages....
Content
From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
Towards a multilingual
strategy
France, Public Domain
1914, National Library of France
Agence de presse Meurisse
Concours de cycles nautiques sur le lac
d’Enghien : Berregent piloté par Austerling
Work in progress…
For example, for object metadata
Usage scenarios Proposal Outcome
• Display object metadata on item page
• Navigate to entities
• Input to search index
• Automated identification of metadata
language if needed
• Use translations from multilingual
knowledge graph (which results in an
index in the languages of the
knowledge graph)
• Augment the provider metadata with
static translation of the fields to English
(to fill metadata values not covered by
the knowledge graph)
• Store and index translated metadata
for search and display
• Item page metadata would display in
chosen language if knowledge graph
translations were present
• Where chosen language is not
supported, display will default to source
language and offer option to view in
English
• Multilingual search would be
supported for fields that are connected
to the knowledge graph translations,
and for other fields by using static
English translations that act as a lingua
franca for search
Other specific proposals for
● Text objects
● Editorial content
● Search
● Editorial content
● User interface
Identify
language
Original
query
Translate to
English
Multilingual
index
User
validation
Search
Translated query (English)
Align to
entity
Entity-based query
Multilingual query:
entity based query
+ original query +
translated query
#1: French
#2: Spanish
#3: Polish
Search results
The technical paper we have prepared for the Finnish presidency event is
open for comments!
● Use of translations for metadata and content
● Designs
● Choice of languages…
Comment via the doc or by sending emails to us before January 15
Translations for metadata using expert knowledge
● Multilingual vocabularies contributed by data providers
● Europeana’s knowledge graph (the Entity Collection)
Automatic translations
● For metadata not covered by the knowledge graph (to English)
● For text content (to English)
● For queries not aligned with the knowledge graph (to English)
● For on-demand translations of item pages
● 130+ out of 552 language pairs, often from or into English
● Sometimes pivot:
● Management: DG Translation (technical), DG CNECT (policy)
● Users: translators of DG Translation, public administrations in the EEA
● Free use
European Commission’s machine translation system for 24 official EU
languages + Icelandic and Norwegian
Finnish English Portuguese
From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
● Available via web interface & API
● Domain of training data: legal & administrative texts
● Specific versions for specific domains, e.g. “cultural”
From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
https://ec.europa.eu/cefdigital/wiki/display/CEFDIGITAL/What+is+eTranslation
1932, National Library of France, Public domain
Agence de presse Mondial Photo-Presse.
Tournoi royal de motos à Londres :
changement d'une roue de side-car en marche
Experiments
Pilot: apply eTranslation to assist
manual translation of exhibitions
●
●
●
Identify
language
Original
query
Translate to
English
Multilingual
index
User
validation
Search
Translated query (English)
Align to
entity
Entity-based query
Multilingual query:
entity based query
+ original query +
translated query
#1: French
#2: Spanish
#3: Polish
Search results
●
●
●
●
●
●
18,257 transcriptions of World War I objects in
17 languages from Transcribathons hosted by
the Enrich Europeana project
eTranslation didn't work only in 404 cases, either
language not supported (bs) or fixable issues
(long text)
Language tag Transcriptions Translated to English
de 9300 9151
fr 1669 1659
it 992 973
ro 578 577
nl 455 454
el 364 356
lv 226 226
bs 215 0
cs 90 90
da 90 90
sl 7 7
hu 3 2
es 2 2
pl 2 2
sk 2 2
hr 1 1
TOTAL (non-en) 13996 13592
en 4243 0
TOTAL 18239 13592
original query language translated query
results original
query
results translated
query
new docs retrieved
thanks to translation
domov cs home 2 1529 1527
Bernhard Stiens de Bernhard Stiens 16 21 8
cimitero de ciemitero 0 0 0
eastern front de Eastern front 345 1272 955
lagazuoi de lapiönoi 0 0 0
letters de letters 25 1935 1913
nova vas de Nova vas 4 31 29
Pinsk de Pinsk 1 1 0
podgora de podgora 1 7 6
Rokitno de Roitno 0 0 0
san elia de San elia 40 49 16
Talies de Talies 0 2 2
women de women 4 255 251
antonio sordi it Antonio Deaf 12 25 14
Asiago it Asiago 1) 4 2552 2548
avion it Avion 0 4 4
bini cima it Bini top 3 837 835
celle lager it lager cells 2 56 56
We used queries for
the Europeana
1914-1918 thematic
collection
Translations brings
more results in, but
some are dubious
NB: we didn't have time
to do a fine-grained
evaluation of the
accuracy of results
We evaluated translation of non-English
queries (69)
● In 22 cases the input was wrong - typos or wrong
language (einsenbahn in French?)
● In 4 cases we couldn't guess the user's intention
(avion on the Italian portal)
● eTranslation correctly handled 20 of 37 queries that
were to be left unchanged (54%)
● eTranslation correctly translated 5 of the 6
remaining cases (83%).
Frankreich, Avion.- Soldatenfriedhof, Bundesarchiv, CC-BY-SA
http://www.bild.bundesarchiv.de/archives/barchpic/search/_1268685391/
NB: in our case, we're hitting straight into the long tail of queries!
Snell, A practical guide to the examination, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
Reflections & future work
● Resource-rich language pairs, e.g. English-French
● Resource-poor language pairs, e.g. English-Icelandic
Difference in amount of training data for language pairs
From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
● Cultural heritage stretches across many dimensions
Languages, domains, genres, periods, …
● It is a particularly interesting and demanding area for machine translation
● Approaches involve new information sources, refinement of tools and methods
From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
Metadata consisting of short text fragments
Title: , bank = “financial institution” / “location near river” ?
= “comment” / “money” ?
From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
Metadata consisting of short text fragments
Title: , bank Subject: paper money
= “comment” / ?
From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
eTranslation welcomes datasets from the culture heritage sector
● Multilingual (and monolingual) datasets help tune the service for
cultural texts
● CH is under-represented in the training resources so far
Contributions can be made directly on the ELRC-SHARE portal (see
guidance)
● Better evaluate accuracy of search results
● Scale up & extend to metadata
● Evaluate the efficiency of cross-lingual search
● Better handle named entities, language identification
● Decide if query translation is really the way to go...
● Give feedback on the proposals
for improving Europeana’s
multilingual aspects, before
January 15
● Contribute (multilingual) training
data to enhance the EC’s
eTranslation service, whenever you
have someEuropeana Thanks You, CC BY-SA
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
#Europeana2019
#EuropeanaCommunities
EUROPEANA 2019
29 Nov 2019 | LISBON
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain
Central Institute for the Union Catalogue of Italian Libraries and Bibliographic
Information
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
Head of Research Services
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
Information Professional
Evaluation FAIRness
Improving reusability
➢ FAIR principles aim to facilitate the reuse of research data,
which is the final goal of FAIRness
➢ So, FAIRness is a means to an end, not a goal in itself
➢ The designers of the FAIR principles stress that “FAIR is a
journey”, helping researchers to understand what they can
do to increase reusability of their data .
The benefits for main stakeholders
➢ To give data providers (creators and publishers)
recommendations on how to improve and make their data
more reusable
➢ To give funding agencies an instrument to verify that
funded projects deliver reusable data
Enable comparison across evaluation approaches
➢ There are many evaluation approaches (questionnaires,
some automated tools), but they are not comparable
➢ RDA Working Group aims to harmonise approaches through
a core set of common criteria (indicators)
➢ The aim is to reach consensus among evaluators, supported
by guidelines on how to apply the indicators
RDA FAIR Data Maturity Model Working Group:
https://www.rd-alliance.org/groups/fair-data-maturity-model-wg
Most aspects already taken care of
➢ Persistent identifiers
○ Metadata: http://data.europeana.eu/item/DATASET_ID/LOCAL_ID
○ Digital objects: (not yet covered)
➢ Rich metadata: Europeana Data Model
➢ Controlled vocabularies: DBpedia, Geonames, Getty etc.
➢ Licensing: Europeana Licensing Framework
FAIR requirements
➢ European Commission will set minimum level of FAIRness
➢ At proposal stage: describe how FAIRness will be achieved
○ Data Management Plan
○ State how project will meet the core criteria
➢ At execution stage: review of FAIRness by evaluating the
data against the core criteria
To better meet the requirements
➢ Analyse the Europeana Publishing Framework against FAIR
principles, adapt where necessary (e.g. persistent identifiers
for data and digital objects)
➢ Think from the perspective of potential reusers, including
researchers beyond Europeana and cultural domain
➢ Facilitate the widest possible reuse of cultural material
Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain
University of Toronto
PARTHENOS
DARIAH
The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
#Europeana2019
#EuropeanaCommunities
Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain
Berlin State Library

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

The Impact of Open Collections...and What's Next
The Impact of Open Collections...and What's NextThe Impact of Open Collections...and What's Next
The Impact of Open Collections...and What's NextEffie Kapsalis
 
FryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the library
FryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the libraryFryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the library
FryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the libraryFers
 
The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...
The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...
The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...Śląska Biblioteka Cyfrowa
 
Dov Winer at Info2010 Conference
Dov Winer at Info2010 ConferenceDov Winer at Info2010 Conference
Dov Winer at Info2010 ConferenceDov Winer
 
Kangan Institute presentation
Kangan Institute presentationKangan Institute presentation
Kangan Institute presentationHamish Curry
 
G1 caron setthil_geshereuropa
G1 caron setthil_geshereuropaG1 caron setthil_geshereuropa
G1 caron setthil_geshereuropaevaminerva
 
Mate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertu
Mate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertuMate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertu
Mate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertuKISK FF MU
 
harvardjudaicawiner20150413
harvardjudaicawiner20150413harvardjudaicawiner20150413
harvardjudaicawiner20150413Dov Winer
 
Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015
Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015
Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015Iolanda Pensa
 
A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014
A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014
A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014evaminerva
 
Rethink the Public Library
Rethink the Public Library Rethink the Public Library
Rethink the Public Library Rolf Hapel
 
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text finalVitorino emmile milan 2012 text final
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text finalMaria Jose Vitorino
 
Why Open Access and What Is It?
Why Open Access and What Is It?Why Open Access and What Is It?
Why Open Access and What Is It?Mal Booth
 
Sharing and reuse museum objects in learning environment
Sharing and reuse museum objects in learning environmentSharing and reuse museum objects in learning environment
Sharing and reuse museum objects in learning environmentVincenza Ferrara
 
Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016
Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016
Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016Rolf Hapel
 
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdf
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdfVitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdf
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdfMaria Jose Vitorino
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

The Impact of Open Collections...and What's Next
The Impact of Open Collections...and What's NextThe Impact of Open Collections...and What's Next
The Impact of Open Collections...and What's Next
 
EuropeanaLocal, its contribution
EuropeanaLocal, its contributionEuropeanaLocal, its contribution
EuropeanaLocal, its contribution
 
FryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the library
FryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the libraryFryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the library
FryskLab - Education, innovation and maker culture in the library
 
The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...
The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...
The Social Digitization Workshop of the Silesian Digital Library at the Siles...
 
Dov Winer at Info2010 Conference
Dov Winer at Info2010 ConferenceDov Winer at Info2010 Conference
Dov Winer at Info2010 Conference
 
Inspiration Lab - Winner IFLA Biblibre 2016 marketing award
Inspiration Lab - Winner IFLA Biblibre 2016 marketing awardInspiration Lab - Winner IFLA Biblibre 2016 marketing award
Inspiration Lab - Winner IFLA Biblibre 2016 marketing award
 
Kangan Institute presentation
Kangan Institute presentationKangan Institute presentation
Kangan Institute presentation
 
G1 caron setthil_geshereuropa
G1 caron setthil_geshereuropaG1 caron setthil_geshereuropa
G1 caron setthil_geshereuropa
 
Mate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertu
Mate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertuMate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertu
Mate Toth: Digitisation and creative re-use of cultural content #blokexpertu
 
harvardjudaicawiner20150413
harvardjudaicawiner20150413harvardjudaicawiner20150413
harvardjudaicawiner20150413
 
Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015
Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015
Wikipedia and Africa at ECAS 2015
 
A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014
A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014
A1 hazan winer_conferenceoverview_2014
 
EMMILE 2012, Milano-Italia
EMMILE 2012, Milano-ItaliaEMMILE 2012, Milano-Italia
EMMILE 2012, Milano-Italia
 
Rethink the Public Library
Rethink the Public Library Rethink the Public Library
Rethink the Public Library
 
The role public libraries play in supporting digital literacy
The role public libraries play in supporting digital literacyThe role public libraries play in supporting digital literacy
The role public libraries play in supporting digital literacy
 
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text finalVitorino emmile milan 2012 text final
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final
 
Why Open Access and What Is It?
Why Open Access and What Is It?Why Open Access and What Is It?
Why Open Access and What Is It?
 
Sharing and reuse museum objects in learning environment
Sharing and reuse museum objects in learning environmentSharing and reuse museum objects in learning environment
Sharing and reuse museum objects in learning environment
 
Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016
Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016
Dokk1 eng udl juni 2016
 
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdf
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdfVitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdf
Vitorino emmile milan 2012 text final pdf
 

Ähnlich wie Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities

CARARE workshop: Europeana research
CARARE workshop: Europeana researchCARARE workshop: Europeana research
CARARE workshop: Europeana researchEuropeana
 
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework ProgrammeDigital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programmelocloud
 
Rob Davies : How we got here
Rob Davies : How we got hereRob Davies : How we got here
Rob Davies : How we got hereAccessITplus
 
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...Europeana
 
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - AuditoriumEuropeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - AuditoriumEuropeana
 
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1Europeana
 
The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts
The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts
The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts ariadnenetwork
 
Cross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projects
Cross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projectsCross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projects
Cross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projectsMia
 
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework ProgrammeDigital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programmelocloud
 
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.UBC Library
 
Europeana essentials June 2013
Europeana essentials June 2013Europeana essentials June 2013
Europeana essentials June 2013Europeana
 
2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural Education
2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural Education2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural Education
2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural EducationHieke van der Voort
 
Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...
Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...
Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...The European Library
 
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the FutureGlobal Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the FutureIngrid Parent
 
Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)
Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)
Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)Europeana
 
412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-Poulsen
412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-Poulsen412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-Poulsen
412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-PoulsenSURFfoundation
 
Europeana essentials August 2013
Europeana essentials August 2013Europeana essentials August 2013
Europeana essentials August 2013Europeana
 

Ähnlich wie Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities (20)

CARARE workshop: Europeana research
CARARE workshop: Europeana researchCARARE workshop: Europeana research
CARARE workshop: Europeana research
 
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework ProgrammeDigital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
 
Rob Davies : How we got here
Rob Davies : How we got hereRob Davies : How we got here
Rob Davies : How we got here
 
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 1...
 
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - AuditoriumEuropeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 29 November 2019 - Auditorium
 
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 1
 
The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts
The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts
The Effect of ARIADNE: A Success Story Why ARIADNE Counts
 
Museums and Europeana
Museums and EuropeanaMuseums and Europeana
Museums and Europeana
 
Cross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projects
Cross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projectsCross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projects
Cross-sector collaboration for digital museum and library projects
 
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework ProgrammeDigital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
Digital Cultural Heritage and the new EU Framework Programme
 
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future.
 
Europeana essentials June 2013
Europeana essentials June 2013Europeana essentials June 2013
Europeana essentials June 2013
 
2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural Education
2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural Education2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural Education
2A - Make It Visible Within Cultural Education
 
EurnewsLDN_Krzysztof_Nichczynski
EurnewsLDN_Krzysztof_NichczynskiEurnewsLDN_Krzysztof_Nichczynski
EurnewsLDN_Krzysztof_Nichczynski
 
Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...
Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...
Alastair Dunning, Europeana Cloud: The Project and the Challenges of Assessin...
 
Introducing DARIAH
Introducing DARIAHIntroducing DARIAH
Introducing DARIAH
 
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the FutureGlobal Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future
Global Networked Digital Environment: How Libraries Shape the Future
 
Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)
Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)
Europeana Essentials (updated June 2014)
 
412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-Poulsen
412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-Poulsen412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-Poulsen
412 The request for new learning resources, Leo Hojsholt-Poulsen
 
Europeana essentials August 2013
Europeana essentials August 2013Europeana essentials August 2013
Europeana essentials August 2013
 

Mehr von Europeana

Europeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdf
Europeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdfEuropeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdf
Europeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdfEuropeana
 
French Presidency - 1 march 2022
French Presidency - 1 march 2022French Presidency - 1 march 2022
French Presidency - 1 march 2022Europeana
 
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2Europeana
 
Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...
Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...
Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...Europeana
 
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - AuditoriumEuropeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - AuditoriumEuropeana
 
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities
Europeana 2019 - Connect CommunitiesEuropeana 2019 - Connect Communities
Europeana 2019 - Connect CommunitiesEuropeana
 
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...Europeana
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...Europeana
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...Europeana
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...Europeana
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...Europeana
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...Europeana
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...Europeana
 

Mehr von Europeana (20)

Europeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdf
Europeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdfEuropeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdf
Europeana Climate Action Community meetup 29_03_2022.pdf
 
French Presidency - 1 march 2022
French Presidency - 1 march 2022French Presidency - 1 march 2022
French Presidency - 1 march 2022
 
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2
Europeana Aggregators' Fair day 2
 
Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...
Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...
Europeana web conference portuguese presidency of the council of the eu - jun...
 
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - AuditoriumEuropeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - Auditorium
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities - 27-28 November 2019 - Auditorium
 
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities
Europeana 2019 - Connect CommunitiesEuropeana 2019 - Connect Communities
Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities
 
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...
Europeana meeting under Finland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU - Day 2...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, “Exposing Online the Eur...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
 
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
The Europeana meeting under the Romanian Presidency, Exposing Online the Euro...
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Marc...
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Juli...
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Gina...
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Alba...
 
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting 2019, The Hague by Harr...
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AIMicrosoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AITatiana Gurgel
 
Philippine History cavite Mutiny Report.ppt
Philippine History cavite Mutiny Report.pptPhilippine History cavite Mutiny Report.ppt
Philippine History cavite Mutiny Report.pptssuser319dad
 
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docxANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docxNikitaBankoti2
 
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...NETWAYS
 
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...NETWAYS
 
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...Sheetaleventcompany
 
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...Hasting Chen
 
Call Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night EnjoyPooja Nehwal
 
Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝soniya singh
 
Motivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdf
Motivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdfMotivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdf
Motivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdfakankshagupta7348026
 
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024eCommerce Institute
 
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )Pooja Nehwal
 
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...Kayode Fayemi
 
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...NETWAYS
 
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdfCTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdfhenrik385807
 
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...NETWAYS
 
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024eCommerce Institute
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@
call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@
call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@vikas rana
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStr
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStrSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStr
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStrsaastr
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AIMicrosoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
 
Philippine History cavite Mutiny Report.ppt
Philippine History cavite Mutiny Report.pptPhilippine History cavite Mutiny Report.ppt
Philippine History cavite Mutiny Report.ppt
 
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docxANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
 
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | Zero-Touch OS-Infrastruktur für Container und Kubern...
 
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Running WebAssembly on Kubernetes by Alex ...
 
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
 
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
 
Call Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Khar Mumbai📲 9892124323 💞 Full Night Enjoy
 
Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Sarojini Nagar Market Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
 
Motivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdf
Motivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdfMotivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdf
Motivation and Theory Maslow and Murray pdf
 
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
 
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
 
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
 
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...
Open Source Camp Kubernetes 2024 | Monitoring Kubernetes With Icinga by Eric ...
 
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdfCTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
 
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...
OSCamp Kubernetes 2024 | A Tester's Guide to CI_CD as an Automated Quality Co...
 
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
 
call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@
call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@
call girls in delhi malviya nagar @9811711561@
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStr
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStrSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStr
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w: Jason Lemkin, SaaStr
 

Europeana 2019 - Connect Communities

  • 1. EUROPEANA 2019 28 Nov 2019 | LISBON The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY WIFI Login: SSID: BNP-WIFI Password: 1214EB0257
  • 2. Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain KU Leuven
  • 5. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY Executive Director Shaping the future of education with cultural heritage
  • 6. “There is a wealth of digital heritage available online. World renowned galleries, archives, museums and libraries provide online access to their collections, and many local initiatives make digital heritage more widely available. As access to the internet improves, and more people own smartphones and other similar devices, these collections can be accessed online by students and educators with fewer and fewer technological barriers. So far, however, this has failed to lead to the improvements in education you might expect.”
  • 7. Cats in human dress playing a variety of games, including arm wrestling and tug of war, Kunimasa IV, 1870s, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
  • 8. Some sources that teachers want to use are not there ● Leonardo Da Vinci ● Del Castagno, ● Tintoretto
  • 9. Some sources that teachers want to use are not there ● Leonardo Da Vinci ● Del Castagno, ● Tintoretto
  • 10. “The real killer was finding super stuff on Europeana and then seeing NO next to copyright details.” A member of the Historiana historical content team expressing his frustration about finding sources he could not use.
  • 11.
  • 12. Unfounded copyright claims can prevent the educational use of sources that are in the public domain as some teachers don’t want to take risks.
  • 13. Some source lack information. They might be interesting to use, but finding out more information would require a lot of original research.
  • 14. Balletklas van dansschool Crielaars, Zuiden, Fotopersbureau Het,, Stadsarchief 's-Hertogenbosch, Netherlands, CC BY-SA
  • 15. We select, contextualise and curate source collections on historical topics and themes that are commonly taught across Europe.
  • 16. Each source in the collection has a description that helps educators to use the source, a reference that helps to find the source, and copyright information.
  • 17. We are making it possible for teacher to create their own eLearning Activities in their language of choice.
  • 18. Each block in the activity builder is focussed on another aspect of historical thinking.
  • 19. We provide workshops for teachers with the Europeana source collections.
  • 20. We offer online workshops on how to use the tools
  • 21. This guide supports teacher trainers to provide workshops as well.
  • 22. For each new source collection, there is an exemplar eLearning Activity that demonstrates how the collection can be used.
  • 23. Snell, A practical guide to the examination, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
  • 24. We are are building three new tools for the Activity Builder. Discover Highlight Compare
  • 25. We want will work further on the documentation for webdevelopers historiana.dev
  • 26. We want to work more directly with the cultural heritage organisation on the development of source collections and eLearning Activities - In what ways did Roman / Greek inventions affect later developments in European life? - In what ways are nation-states illustrated in artistic imagery? - How and why did coffee become a global commodity? - What inventions were needed before James Watt could invent his steam machine? - How did the industrial revolution change working conditions?
  • 27. We are upgrading the partner pages. Making it possible to partners to publish source collections and eLearning Activities.
  • 28. We will continue to test Historiana with educators and research how they search for historical sources. The research results will be shared via Europeana.
  • 30. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY Pedagogical Manager Shaping the future of education with cultural heritage
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34. Bulong Miao, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 45. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY Europeana Ambassador PT Shaping the future of education with cultural heritage
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48. • Coordinate the UG • Support the MOOCs • Create LS • Dissemination • Moderate the Blog • Jury – User Group competition
  • 49.
  • 50. + 200 Learning Scenarios + 80 Stories of Implementation
  • 51. Learning Scenario (LS) • Europeana Content • Educational Trends • XXI Century Skills • Curriculum integration • Activities Westminster School of Industry, Old Pye Street,n.d, Welcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
  • 52. Story of Implementation • Choose a LS • Implement w/ students • Collect information • Stars - Wish • Design SoI • Publish a postWestminster School of Industry, Old Pye Street,n.d, Welcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY
  • 54. Life on the trenches – A VR Experience (LS-PT-06)
  • 55. From muscle machines to the smart machines (LS-PT).
  • 58. How we build skills of the 21st-century like media literacy or critical thinking?
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61. How to connect with children's and young people trough Digital Cultural Heritage?
  • 62. By speaking the same language! What language?
  • 64. Digital Cultural Heritage ...we need to understand our past...to build a better future.
  • 66. ➔ Find out more on Europeana Education Community ➔ Join our Europeana Education LinkedIn and Facebook Groups ➔ Twitter: @EuropeanaEU, #EuropeanaEducation ➔ Contact us by email: education@europeana.eu Enrich your educational resources and inspire learners with Europeana content!
  • 67. Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain Europeana Foundation
  • 68. 1. Summary of Finnish Presidency event on Multilingualism and digital cultural heritage (Andy Neale) 2. Use-cases for infrastructures enabling multilinguality in digital cultural heritage (Pavel Kats and Alex Raginsky) 3. Improving access to historical documents in Transcribathon Platform and Europeana Collections (Gordea Sergiu) 4. Europeana multilingual strategy and automatic translation (Antoine Isaac)
  • 69. Books on a table, Aalto, Ilmari, 1928, National Digital Library (NDL), Finland, CC0 EUROPEANA MEETING UNDER FINLAND’S PRESIDENCY OF THE COUNCIL OF THE EU ESPOO, FINLAND
  • 70. 1. Stimulate reflection on multilingualism in digital cultural heritage at large using Europeana as a case study 2. Develop a deeper understanding of the multilingualism problem/opportunity space for digital cultural heritage 3. Consider what options can be pursued to provoke action at the local level, furthering the multilingual capabilities 4. Provide input and feedback for the Europeana multilingual strategy
  • 71. History of multilingual development Multilingual policy Learnings from automatic translation projects User experience design Linked vocabularies and automatic subject indexing services Measuring success Multilingual metadata Content translation Update on eTranslation
  • 72.
  • 73.
  • 74.
  • 75. Identify language Original query Translate to English Multilingual index User Disambiguates Search Translated query (English) Suggest Entity (Knowledge Graph) Entity-based query Multilingual query: entity based query OR original query + translated query #1: French #2: Spanish #3: Polish
  • 76. Determine the size of the opportunity and place 1 to 5 stickers in the size column, where 5 is the biggest opportunity and each lower number a smaller opportunity. Use each number only once. Benefits Group exercise 16:00 - 16:15
  • 77. 1. People can access the knowledge of other cultures and knowledge groups 2. More sources of material to search across 3. Promotes socially inclusive societies and mutual understanding of different cultures Top 3 benefits
  • 78. Take a turn to present an issue to your table. Combine with others where appropriate. Write the agreed issue upon on a card. Place it on the canvas and determine if we have the capabilities and/or technology to tackle this issue. Next person’s turn. Issues Group exercise 17:15 - 17:45 Circle the number of the priority column Issue text Issue text
  • 79. Common themes 1. Lack of… 2. Quality of data 3. Standardisation 4. Knowledge sharing and visibility
  • 80. Solutions Group exercise 11:30 - 11:40 Issue text Issue text
  • 81. Top proposals 1. Strengthen capacity to identify, connect, work with and facilitate technology transfer 2. Marketing and dissemination of tools 3. Improved communication mechanisms and increased visibility of Europeana projects 4. Co-operation on national and local level 5. More language experts on local level 6. Awareness of benefits of good quality content 7. Improve quality of metadata 8. Cheaper mass translation tools 9. Automated data cleaning tool 10. Terminology thesaurus 11. Requirements and dialogue with providers of collection management systems
  • 82. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY CEO Culture Chatbot Tech Lead ‘Use-cases for infrastructures enabling multilinguality in digital cultural heritage’
  • 83. Who we are: Jewish Heritage Network ● Global digital initiative for Jewish cultural heritage content ● Content network of more than 30 Jewish museums, archives, libraries, and research centers from Europe (mainly), US, and Israel ● Digital platform of services for content aggregation, publication and promotion ● Accredited partner of Europeana, the European digital platform for culture Culture Chatbot
  • 84. Who we are: Pangeanic ● Global translation company, offering translation technologies to language industry professionals and translation services. ● World leader in AI-enhanced machine translation services. ● Frequent builder of infrastructure solutions for European Public Administrations and CEF (Connecting Europe Facility). ● Leader of EU-funded PangeaMT and NTEU (upcoming) consortia and projects
  • 85. Culture Chatbot - flavour 1 Culture Chatbot
  • 86. Culture Chatbot - flavour 2 Culture Chatbot
  • 87. Culture Chatbot - flavour 3 Culture Chatbot
  • 88. Source Integration Application Interaction / UI Metadata Digital Content Vocabularies, thesauri etc Aggregation Semantic Enrichment ? Chatbot Collections Exhibitions Use case Service Infra Value Chain Process / Asset Search Browse Display Explore
  • 89. Use case #1: User Messages Translation
  • 90. Use case #1: User Messages Translation
  • 91. Use case #2: Metadata Translation Internal data representation derived from EDM
  • 92. Use case #2: Metadata Translation
  • 93. Use case #2: Metadata Translation (all EU languages) Culture Chatbot ● Pilot in Judaica Europeana 2.0 ● Direct translation from source language to 24 EU languages ● Enabled and supported by PangeaMT and NTEU
  • 94. Use case #3: Human-assisted t-n
  • 95. Use case #4: Multilingual Semantic Search (not only for bots) ● Infrastructure: multilingual BERT model (104 languages) ● Extract entities from metadata and query (using NER built on BERT) ● Calculate word semantic vectors (“embeddings”) with BERT for metadata, query and extracted entities ● Combine SOLR/ElasticSearch keyword search with nearest neighbor vector search (“semantic search”) Culture Chatbot
  • 96.
  • 97. Use case #5: Language Choice UI ● Implicitly: ○ using site language ○ language detection of the first user message ● Explicitly: ○ a question at the beginning of the conversation (“Please choose conversation language”) ○ a language change intent (“Do you speak English?”) ○ chatbot persistent menu
  • 98. Source Integration Application Interaction / UI Metadata Digital Content Vocabularies, thesauri etc Aggregation Semantic Enrichment Chatbot Collections Exhibitions Use case Service Infra Value Chain Process / Asset Search Browse Display Explore Use case #1: User Messages Translation ● Conversation history ● Real-time Use case #2: Metadata Translation ● Aggregation-time translation ● Display in user’s preferred lang Use case #3: Human-assisted translationUse case #4: Semantic Multilingual Search Use case #5: Language Choice UI Machine TranslationSemantic Search NER Human-assisted translation
  • 99. Source Integration Application Interaction / UI Metadata Digital Content Vocabularies, thesauri etc Aggregation Semantic Enrichment Chatbot Collections Exhibitions Use case Service Infra Value Chain Process / Asset Search Browse Display Explore Use case #1: User Messages Translation ● Conversation history ● Real-time Use case #2: Metadata Translation ● Aggregation-time translation ● Display in user’s preferred lang Use case #3: Human-assisted translationUse case #4: Semantic Multilingual Search Use case #5: Language Choice UI Machine TranslationSemantic Search NER Human-assisted translation PangeaMT NTEUeTranslationBERT DSI DSI DSI
  • 100. Ecosystem Considerations ● Infrastructurisation Migrating technology “downwards” towards services and infras ● Supported Use Case Inventory Rich and fine-grained inventory of supported use-cases through conducting proactive research with the community ● Sustainability Improving chances for sustainability by funding DSIs and keeping them ● Community Building Around DSIs and best practices in using them
  • 101. Infrastructure vendor outlook ● Having a defined policy and commitment to mulilingualism as well as the provision of multilingual content ● Continuity and sustainability ● Can be embedded in Europeana processes ● Leverage project money to offer free services to industry leaders to create awareness
  • 102. Role for Europeana and Invitation to NTEU ● Represent the Digital Heritage sector’s interests in need in European machine translation DSIs ● Inform the development of new DSIs with requirements specific to heritage data and usage scenarios ● Incorporate DSI-based services for heritage into Europeana DSI: for its own sake and the sake of smaller practitioners and projects
  • 103. Role for Europeana and Invitation to NTEU We are very pleased to invite Europeana into NTEU User Group in order to integrate language technologies and policies into the project. NTEU is a newly started CEF project that will build 506 translation engines in all EU languages but English, providing training data into low-resourced and medium-resourced languages. Having Europeana as an interest party in our User Group would allow both Europeana and NTEU Consortium to evaluate the quality of engines as developed for Public Administrations, and for Europeana to make use of other DSI developments, as well as integrate their services into the platform. We look forward to working together with Europeana and make it fully multilingual and improve accessibility and promoting cultural assets across the EU's languages.
  • 104. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY Senior Research Engineer AIT Austrian Institute of Technology GmbH Improving access to historical documents within Transcribathon Platform and Europeana Collections
  • 105. Further development of the Transcribathon Prototype and integrate it with Europeana Collections, National Aggregator and Libraries portals ENRICH EUROPEANA
  • 106. ENHANCE ACCESSIBILITY OF UGC 10628.11.2019 Crowdsourced and User Generated Content: • Brings into light new insights related to historical Events (e.g.Europeana 1914-1918, Europeana 1989) • Typically lacks of rich and standardized descriptive metadata Goals: • Facilitate access to information „hidden“ in scanned manuscripts • Enrich document descriptions with contextual information Wikidata Places and Persons; keywords/topics • Enhance user experience by integrating state of the art technologies (e.g. IIIF, NERL)
  • 107. THE BEAUTY OF HISTORICAL MANUSCRIPTS 10728.11.2019 • Letters and Journals present the life and the emotions of regular people • Often indicate facts, that were not written in history books • They catch attention and motivate user‘s to interact with the content
  • 108. …. AND THE CHALLENGES 10828.11.2019 • Historical documents are hardly understood with the passing of time: • Grammar and words of all languages are changing in time • Simple people use dialects • Preserve the language and the writing from their time Translation original text Translation improved version On the first of March we passed the tunnery exam, and with good behavior we went into the (Geschitz Vormeister) course, the first cannibal riders. For the cannons as justifiers are sub-skills, and this school I did. On March 28, Pola the heir to the throne came. A. Sa Francis Ferdinand (Erzherzog Franz Ferdinand) had nice reception forces, Mr. arrived on the boat (Jacht) reigning S.M.S. Lacroma. On the first of March I passed the tunnery exam, and having a good behaviour, I entered the course for "Geschitz Vormeister", meaning first cannon setter. As for the cannons, the setters are lower officers, and this school I did as well. On March 28th came to Pola the heir to the throne, His Highness Francis Ferdinand ("Erzherzog Franz Ferdinand"), he had a very beautiful reception, He arrived on the royal boat ("Jacht") S.M.S. Lacroma
  • 110. ENTITY RECOGNTION 11028.11.2019 Performance of person and location detection • Based on English translation of 15 pages from Dumitru Nistor Journal
  • 111. ENTITY LINKING 11128.11.2019 Performance of linking detected locations with items from Wikidata and Europeana Entity Collection
  • 112. IMPLEMENTATION OF FAIR PRINCIPLES 11228.11.2019 • Findable and Accesible: • text becomes machine readable after trascription • english translation is generated • Interoperable: • enrichments (including transcriptions) available as W3C Web Annotations • integration with Europeana Collections • Reusable • Public Domain and CC0 content • transcriptions and enrichments available under CC0 Licence
  • 113. …. THE GOOD NEWS 11328.11.2019 „My Diary“ 2020
  • 115. NEW TRANSCRIBATHON TOOL 11528.11.2019 https://beta.transcribathon.eu
  • 117. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY R&D Manager ‘Europeana multilingual strategy and automatic translation’
  • 118. ● Juliane Stiller - You, We & Digital ● Tom Vanallemeersch - Crosslang ● Mónica Marrero, Andy Neale – Europeana Foundation
  • 119. Content Information Access Interactions User Interface Metadata and digital CH objects Search, Browse & Explore Show user‘s preferred language Bridge the gap between language of user input and content Layers of digital CH systems From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
  • 120. User Interface Challenges: • Translation of static and dynamic pages • Switching languages via text or icons such as flags • Determine the user‘s preferred language User Interface From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
  • 121. Interactions: Search Interactions From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
  • 122. Mismatch between query and content language • Mona Lisa 203 results • La Gioconda 376 results  • La Joconde 78 results Interactions Roma, Galleria Corsini - La Gioconda,From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
  • 123. Interactions: Browse ● Search vs. browse ● Metadata vs. content Interactions From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
  • 124. Content & Metadata Image Credit: both from Europeana with Titlte „Kinderbuch” from Spielzeugmuseum der Stadt Nürnberg (CC BY-NC-SA) Content From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
  • 125. Metadata multilinguality + 40 other languages.... Content From Juliane Stiller, You, We & Digital
  • 126. Towards a multilingual strategy France, Public Domain 1914, National Library of France Agence de presse Meurisse Concours de cycles nautiques sur le lac d’Enghien : Berregent piloté par Austerling
  • 128. For example, for object metadata Usage scenarios Proposal Outcome • Display object metadata on item page • Navigate to entities • Input to search index • Automated identification of metadata language if needed • Use translations from multilingual knowledge graph (which results in an index in the languages of the knowledge graph) • Augment the provider metadata with static translation of the fields to English (to fill metadata values not covered by the knowledge graph) • Store and index translated metadata for search and display • Item page metadata would display in chosen language if knowledge graph translations were present • Where chosen language is not supported, display will default to source language and offer option to view in English • Multilingual search would be supported for fields that are connected to the knowledge graph translations, and for other fields by using static English translations that act as a lingua franca for search
  • 129. Other specific proposals for ● Text objects ● Editorial content ● Search ● Editorial content ● User interface
  • 130. Identify language Original query Translate to English Multilingual index User validation Search Translated query (English) Align to entity Entity-based query Multilingual query: entity based query + original query + translated query #1: French #2: Spanish #3: Polish Search results
  • 131. The technical paper we have prepared for the Finnish presidency event is open for comments! ● Use of translations for metadata and content ● Designs ● Choice of languages… Comment via the doc or by sending emails to us before January 15
  • 132. Translations for metadata using expert knowledge ● Multilingual vocabularies contributed by data providers ● Europeana’s knowledge graph (the Entity Collection) Automatic translations ● For metadata not covered by the knowledge graph (to English) ● For text content (to English) ● For queries not aligned with the knowledge graph (to English) ● For on-demand translations of item pages
  • 133. ● 130+ out of 552 language pairs, often from or into English ● Sometimes pivot: ● Management: DG Translation (technical), DG CNECT (policy) ● Users: translators of DG Translation, public administrations in the EEA ● Free use European Commission’s machine translation system for 24 official EU languages + Icelandic and Norwegian Finnish English Portuguese From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
  • 134. ● Available via web interface & API ● Domain of training data: legal & administrative texts ● Specific versions for specific domains, e.g. “cultural” From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang https://ec.europa.eu/cefdigital/wiki/display/CEFDIGITAL/What+is+eTranslation
  • 135. 1932, National Library of France, Public domain Agence de presse Mondial Photo-Presse. Tournoi royal de motos à Londres : changement d'une roue de side-car en marche Experiments
  • 136.
  • 137. Pilot: apply eTranslation to assist manual translation of exhibitions ● ● ●
  • 138.
  • 139. Identify language Original query Translate to English Multilingual index User validation Search Translated query (English) Align to entity Entity-based query Multilingual query: entity based query + original query + translated query #1: French #2: Spanish #3: Polish Search results
  • 141. 18,257 transcriptions of World War I objects in 17 languages from Transcribathons hosted by the Enrich Europeana project eTranslation didn't work only in 404 cases, either language not supported (bs) or fixable issues (long text) Language tag Transcriptions Translated to English de 9300 9151 fr 1669 1659 it 992 973 ro 578 577 nl 455 454 el 364 356 lv 226 226 bs 215 0 cs 90 90 da 90 90 sl 7 7 hu 3 2 es 2 2 pl 2 2 sk 2 2 hr 1 1 TOTAL (non-en) 13996 13592 en 4243 0 TOTAL 18239 13592
  • 142.
  • 143. original query language translated query results original query results translated query new docs retrieved thanks to translation domov cs home 2 1529 1527 Bernhard Stiens de Bernhard Stiens 16 21 8 cimitero de ciemitero 0 0 0 eastern front de Eastern front 345 1272 955 lagazuoi de lapiönoi 0 0 0 letters de letters 25 1935 1913 nova vas de Nova vas 4 31 29 Pinsk de Pinsk 1 1 0 podgora de podgora 1 7 6 Rokitno de Roitno 0 0 0 san elia de San elia 40 49 16 Talies de Talies 0 2 2 women de women 4 255 251 antonio sordi it Antonio Deaf 12 25 14 Asiago it Asiago 1) 4 2552 2548 avion it Avion 0 4 4 bini cima it Bini top 3 837 835 celle lager it lager cells 2 56 56 We used queries for the Europeana 1914-1918 thematic collection Translations brings more results in, but some are dubious NB: we didn't have time to do a fine-grained evaluation of the accuracy of results
  • 144. We evaluated translation of non-English queries (69) ● In 22 cases the input was wrong - typos or wrong language (einsenbahn in French?) ● In 4 cases we couldn't guess the user's intention (avion on the Italian portal) ● eTranslation correctly handled 20 of 37 queries that were to be left unchanged (54%) ● eTranslation correctly translated 5 of the 6 remaining cases (83%). Frankreich, Avion.- Soldatenfriedhof, Bundesarchiv, CC-BY-SA http://www.bild.bundesarchiv.de/archives/barchpic/search/_1268685391/ NB: in our case, we're hitting straight into the long tail of queries!
  • 145. Snell, A practical guide to the examination, Wellcome Collection, United Kingdom, CC BY Reflections & future work
  • 146. ● Resource-rich language pairs, e.g. English-French ● Resource-poor language pairs, e.g. English-Icelandic Difference in amount of training data for language pairs From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
  • 147. ● Cultural heritage stretches across many dimensions Languages, domains, genres, periods, … ● It is a particularly interesting and demanding area for machine translation ● Approaches involve new information sources, refinement of tools and methods From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
  • 148. Metadata consisting of short text fragments Title: , bank = “financial institution” / “location near river” ? = “comment” / “money” ? From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
  • 149. Metadata consisting of short text fragments Title: , bank Subject: paper money = “comment” / ? From Tom Vanallemeersch, Crosslang
  • 150. eTranslation welcomes datasets from the culture heritage sector ● Multilingual (and monolingual) datasets help tune the service for cultural texts ● CH is under-represented in the training resources so far Contributions can be made directly on the ELRC-SHARE portal (see guidance)
  • 151. ● Better evaluate accuracy of search results ● Scale up & extend to metadata ● Evaluate the efficiency of cross-lingual search ● Better handle named entities, language identification ● Decide if query translation is really the way to go...
  • 152. ● Give feedback on the proposals for improving Europeana’s multilingual aspects, before January 15 ● Contribute (multilingual) training data to enhance the EC’s eTranslation service, whenever you have someEuropeana Thanks You, CC BY-SA
  • 153. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY #Europeana2019 #EuropeanaCommunities
  • 154. EUROPEANA 2019 29 Nov 2019 | LISBON The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY
  • 155. Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain Central Institute for the Union Catalogue of Italian Libraries and Bibliographic Information
  • 156. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY Head of Research Services
  • 157. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY Information Professional Evaluation FAIRness
  • 158. Improving reusability ➢ FAIR principles aim to facilitate the reuse of research data, which is the final goal of FAIRness ➢ So, FAIRness is a means to an end, not a goal in itself ➢ The designers of the FAIR principles stress that “FAIR is a journey”, helping researchers to understand what they can do to increase reusability of their data .
  • 159. The benefits for main stakeholders ➢ To give data providers (creators and publishers) recommendations on how to improve and make their data more reusable ➢ To give funding agencies an instrument to verify that funded projects deliver reusable data
  • 160. Enable comparison across evaluation approaches ➢ There are many evaluation approaches (questionnaires, some automated tools), but they are not comparable ➢ RDA Working Group aims to harmonise approaches through a core set of common criteria (indicators) ➢ The aim is to reach consensus among evaluators, supported by guidelines on how to apply the indicators RDA FAIR Data Maturity Model Working Group: https://www.rd-alliance.org/groups/fair-data-maturity-model-wg
  • 161. Most aspects already taken care of ➢ Persistent identifiers ○ Metadata: http://data.europeana.eu/item/DATASET_ID/LOCAL_ID ○ Digital objects: (not yet covered) ➢ Rich metadata: Europeana Data Model ➢ Controlled vocabularies: DBpedia, Geonames, Getty etc. ➢ Licensing: Europeana Licensing Framework
  • 162. FAIR requirements ➢ European Commission will set minimum level of FAIRness ➢ At proposal stage: describe how FAIRness will be achieved ○ Data Management Plan ○ State how project will meet the core criteria ➢ At execution stage: review of FAIRness by evaluating the data against the core criteria
  • 163. To better meet the requirements ➢ Analyse the Europeana Publishing Framework against FAIR principles, adapt where necessary (e.g. persistent identifiers for data and digital objects) ➢ Think from the perspective of potential reusers, including researchers beyond Europeana and cultural domain ➢ Facilitate the widest possible reuse of cultural material
  • 164. Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain University of Toronto PARTHENOS DARIAH
  • 165. The Europeana Network Association AGM 2018 - Europeana Foundation, CC BY #Europeana2019 #EuropeanaCommunities
  • 166. Europa [Material cartográfico] : Nach den vorzüglichsten Hülfsnitteln, Götze, Johann August Ferdinand, 1773-1819 Biblioteca Digital de Madrid Spain, Public domain Berlin State Library