SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 10
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
1st Quarter, 2009                                                                                                           19




A practical approach in pipeline
 corrosion modelling: Part 1 –
 Long-term integrity forecasting
by Dr Érika S M Nicoletti* and Ricardo Dias de Souza
Petrobras Transporte SA, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil




      N     OWADAYS, MANY MAJOR MARKETS worldwide depend upon an increasingly-ageing pipeline
                 infrastructure to supply most energy demands. As corrosion damage accumulation is usually
      expected under typical pipeline service conditions, forecast metal-loss growth over time is a key element
      in their integrity management; but there is little industrial guidance on this issue. The current work has been
      undertaken aiming to provide a corrosion rate model by means of straightforward stochastic treatment
      of metal-loss ILI data. This first part will present a model framework regarding long-term scenarios and
      remaining-life predictions, based on a cost-effective pecuniary threshold for the system’s future remedial
      actions. The concept of local activity breaks new ground by merging two traditional approaches: the
      individual defect and the pipeline segment corrosion growth rates. The model’s underlying assumptions are
      detailed, together with its mathematical framework; an empirical balance has been established between
      over- and under-conservative premises, and the accuracy of the results has been considered suitable for
      forecasting intervals of up to 30 years. The technique provides powerful information with no need to carry
      out any further expensive and/or laborious analyses: the whole algorithm could be easily put into practice
      using commercial mathematical packages. In order to illustrate the model’s applicability, four case studies
      will be presented.




Nomenclature                                                       H: defect odometer [m]
                                                                   l: maximum defect length [mm]
    Dt1: pipeline service life under original operating            lf: defect forecast length [mm]
         conditions [years]                                        LSEGi: local segment length [m]
    Dt2: pipeline service life under posterior operating           N: total number of active corrosion sites
         conditions [years]                                        n: vicinity parameter
    Dtc: coating degradation lag [years]                           Ri: individual defect dimension corrosion rate [mm/
    Dtf: forecasting lag [years]                                        year]
    Dts: pipeline service life [years]                             RDi: local defect dimension corrosion rate [mm/year]
    sdi: forecast dimension standard deviation [mm]                RDij: individual corrosion rate at a nearby defect [mm/
    sRi: local depth corrosion rate standard deviation [mm]             year]
                                                                   s: scoring factor for service condition changes
    d: maximum metal-loss depth [mm]                               w: maximum defect width [mm]
    Df: maximum metal-loss forecast dimension [mm]                 wf: defect forecast width [mm]
    Dj: pig-reported dimension (depth, width and length)
        [mm]
    dj: pig-reported defect depth [mm]
    Epig: tool measurement error [mm] (at 80% confidence
        level)
    Fh: service conditions linearization factor
                                                               F   OR OVER ONE hundred years pipelines have been
                                                                   used to transport hydrocarbons from their distant
                                                               location to refineries and onwards to consumers. Many
                                                               major world markets nowadays depend upon this
                                                               increasingly-ageing pipeline infrastructure to supply most
*Author’s contact details:
tel: +55 21 3211 7264                                          of their energy demands. It is unfortunate that ageing
email: erika_nicoletti@petrobras.com.br                        adversely affects a pipeline’s integrity, and it can suffer from
20                                                                                      The Journal of Pipeline Engineering



many types of damage under typical service conditions.           hand, long-term scenario predictions are typically associated
                                                                 with the system’s economic viability forecasting (and
Corrosion has historically been the greatest time-dependent      estimating its remaining life); such analyses are usually
threat to pipeline integrity. The process itself reduces the     better served with accurate modelling.
local metal cross-section, affecting the remaining strength
and, consequently, reducing the pipeline’s containment           Despite both algorithms being developed with the aim of
capacity in the area of the damage.                              incorporating them into a company’s proprietary defect-
                                                                 assessment software [6], they can also be easily implemented
Operators can quantify corrosion in their systems through        using any common commercial mathematical package.
periodic metal-loss in-line inspections (ILI). Subsequently,     Accordingly, both are presented in only their most simplistic
the system’s fitness-for-purpose can be assessed at each         interpretations. The underlying assumptions of the models,
point by carrying out damage tolerance analysis using, as        and the descriptive formulations, will be described and
input, ILI data and required service conditions [1, 2].          discussed. Real cases studies will then be presented to
                                                                 illustrate the methodology anticipated results and overall
However, given that pig inspections show only the state of       performance, before final conclusions are given.
static damage at the time of the inspection, integrity
forecasting must take into account corrosion growth
estimates. Furthermore, although the phenomenon of               Theoretical background
corrosion is widely known, a plethora of factors impact the
process kinetics along a pipeline’s length, and the inherent     The corrosion process is irreversible: once it takes place,
randomness generally associated with real field conditions,      metal-loss damage at a particular site can only either grow,
makes its mechanistic modelling a complex task. This             or remain the same over time, the latter being a sign of site
requires highly-skilled work, the difficulties of which are      inactivity (and possible repassivation).
often compounded by an inconvenient lack of historical
data concerning many of the process control parameters.          As time goes by, it is expected that new active sites will arise,
Thus, it has become common practice to adopt an empirical        while some of the existing ones will cease growing.
approach, mostly based on worst-case scenarios                   Additionally, time-dependent defect enlargements usually
(recommended practices and/or historical data) [3, 4].           slow down over time although, as a general rule,
However, such procedures usually give rise to highly-            deterministic approaches treat those processes as linear [7,
inaccurate forecasts, particularly when dealing with long-       8]. Valor et al. [9] suggest the following should be taken into
term scenarios.                                                  account:

Indeed, the US’ Office of Pipeline Safety estimated that the         • the slowing down effect: 0-10% of reduction in past
ability to accurately forecast corrosion rates could save              corrosion rates
American pipeline companies more than US$ 100 million                • the cessation of growth effect: 0-20% of the number
per year through reduced maintenance costs and accident                of sites nucleated per year
avoidance [5].                                                       • new defect nucleation: 0-65% of the number of sites
                                                                       nucleated per year
Fortunately, ILI metal-loss mapping reflects either unknown
service condition variances and/or local electrochemical         Conversely, probabilistic models often use the following
mechanism abnormalities, providing a good background,            distributions in order to represent:
insofar as processing past behaviour is concerned, for
corrosion-rate inferences.                                           • nucleation time – exponential and Weibull [9, 10]
                                                                     • number of sites nucleated over time: Poisson [9]
The current work aims to develop a simplified methodology            • growth rate: gamma, log-normal, or extreme-value
to allow reasonably-accurate pipeline-integrity forecasts,             distributions [6, 10, 11]
chiefly by using ILI data. Two basic algorithms have been
constructed: the first, which is presented in this paper, has    The Bayesian approach and the Markovian process have
been directed to long-term scenarios. The second part of         also been widely used in probabilistic framework modelling
the methodology has targets short-term predictions, and          [12-15].
will be published in the second art of the paper [in the June,
2009, issue of the Journal of Pipeline Engineering].             Given that metal-loss measurements reflect operational
                                                                 condition variations and the overall randomness of the
The main differences between the algorithms result from          corrosion process itself, the proper treatment of ILI data
their diverse application expectations. Short-term scenarios     can lead to reasonable estimates of past behaviour [16-18].
are usually applied in order to define reinspection intervals
and rehabilitation scopes. As operational pipeline safety        In order to determine the corrosion rate, damage must be
and reliability often depends on the result, conservative        quantified at two different points in time. However, in
approaches have always been preferable. On the other             order to avoid the usual laborious defect-matching
1st Quarter, 2009                                                                                                                             21



procedures [5, 19], the current model has been adapted to                      – eventually – measurement bias, with a confidence
use a single ILI data set. Also, the model has been constructed                level of 80%. The mathematical framework to be
under the premise of a linear relationship existing with the                   presented is independently applied to the anomaly
process’s past behaviour. Its breakthrough came with the                       populations located on the external and internal
assumption that only adjacent metal loss represents the                        surfaces. New defect generation, as well as the rate
corrosion activity at each point, which will be described                      of cessation of defect growth, are considered to be
further below.                                                                 negligible.

The local corrosion activity principle                                    • Nucleation time: defect populations are assumed to
                                                                            be instantaneously nucleated at the first exposure to
The authors consider it a rational assumption that all                      corrosive conditions.
metal-loss located in close vicinity and on the same side of
the pipe wall (external/internal) is under similar conditions             • Defect growth: determined based on the past
of corrosion attack. If, regarding the variations in corrosion              behaviour of local corrosion activity. The details of
activity along a pipeline’s length, it is expected that future              this premise regarding external and internal surface
service conditions remain similar, then future corrosion                    corrosion are described below.
growth can be predicted based on the metal-loss anomaly
population located in the defect neighbourhood.                           • Coating protection effectiveness: the coating
                                                                            condition is considered to be perfect at the time of
To define the range of each defect’s environment, a vicinity                pipeline commissioning. All pipeline coating
parameter must be empirically determined, using the                         holidays are considered to be instantaneously
relationship expressed in Equn 1. Each defect will also have                generated after a specific coating degradation lag.
its associated characteristic length, as defined by Equn 21.                The protection effectiveness is assumed to be 0% at
                                                                            all active sites of external corrosion, and 100% in
    2n+1 > = 7                                            (1)               holiday-free regions. Water and air permeation
                                                                            time dependency is not taken into consideration.
    L Si = Hi + n − Hi − n                                (2)
                                                                          • Coating degradation lag: must be empirically defined
Figure 1 illustrates the principle in a pipe section from case              based on coating data history and engineering best
study 4. All the anomalies displayed are internal metal-loss,               judgment.
and channelling can be clearly noted. Two anomalies have
been arbitrarily chosen to exemplify the neighbourhood’s                  • Cathodic protection: is assumed to remain in a
delimitation mechanism: for the purpose of illustration,                    steady-state condition throughout the entire service
the lower recommended value for the vicinity parameter                      life of the pipeline.
has been used in the figure (n = 3). Note that only axial
proximity is taken into account: n anomalies immediately                  • Probability density functions (PDFs): defect depth
up- or downstream are considered as belonging to each                       dimensions and corrosion rates are described by
defect’s local population.                                                  Gaussian PDFs. It is worth noting that, given that
                                                                            each defect’s corrosion rate is represented in terms
A number of additional simplistic assumptions have been                     of a local average, there is a normalizing effect on the
made, and a general outline of them will be given in the                    overall depth corrosion rate data set2.
following paragraphs.

    • Process characterization: irreversible, evolving at a           Mathematical framework
      constant rate, and at discrete time intervals.
                                                                      Corrosion rates PDFs
    • Defect population: ILI reported metal-loss anomalies
      trimmed, based on the empirical criterion defined               The probability density functions should be individually
      in Equn 3:                                                      defined, taking account of the damage accumulated in each
                                                                      defect neighbourhood, according to the previously-outlined
               2Et                                                    principle of local corrosion activity3. If a significant change
        Dj ≥                                              (3)         in the system’s operating conditions takes place after any
               1.28


        where Et represents tool the measurement error and            2. Pipeline geometry, material features, and the axial and circumferential
                                                                      corrosion rates, have only been considered deterministically, as will be
                                                                      the allowable damage as a consequence.

1. The parameter n should be adjusted in order to obtain an average   3. Clustering criteria should preferably be applied after a future
segment length not exceeding 1-2 km.                                  morphology forecast, not before.
22                                                                                                 The Journal of Pipeline Engineering



particular event, then a factor Fh is defined accordingly,              while Equn 2 should be used to define its neighbourhood
using Equn 4; otherwise, Fh is assumed as 14.                           characteristic length.

             Δt1 + sΔt2
     Fh =                                                   (4)         Future defect morphology
                Δt s
                                                                        The average dimensions of future defects can be calculated
Internal defects                                                        from Equn 6a, and Equn 6b is used to determine the
                                                                        associated dispersion.
Individual defect growths (radial, axial, and circumferential)
are determined by means of Equn 5a. The subsequent                          D f = D i .RLi .Δt f                                   (6a)
application of the local corrosion activity principle leads to
the determination of the corrosion rate average for the
defect population located in the adjoined region by using                                         ⎛ E ⎞
                                                                                                             2

                                                                            σ Df = Δt f (σ Li ) + ⎜ t ⎟
                                                                                               2
Equn 5b, while the dispersion is obtained from Equn 5c.                                                                            (6b)
                                                                                                  ⎝ 1.28 ⎠
Furthermore, the characteristic length associated with each
defect neighbourhood (Lseg) can also be defined, as previously
discussed.
                                                                        Damage tolerance
Hence, each flaw on a pipe’s inside surface will have one
single PDF representing its depth corrosion growth rate,                There are a number of metal-loss assessment criteria that
while axial and circumferential rates, as well as its                   can be used to determine damage tolerance. The most
neighbourhood characteristic length, are deterministically              simplistic and widely known is ASME B31.G, which only
defined.                                                                takes into account axially-oriented corrosion defects
                                                                        submitted to internal pressure loading. Depending on the
                                                                        particular system’s damage characteristics (which can include
             Di
     Ri =                                                   (5a)        circumferential- or even helically-oriented defects), or the
             Δt s                                                       existence of axial loads (such as those geotechnically or
                    j=i+ n
                                                                        thermally induced), an appropriate criterion should be
                                                                        chosen to deterministically find out the maximum allowable
                     ∑R      j
                                                                        defect depth as a function of its forecast width and length,
     RLi = Fh       j=i−n                                   (5b)
                    (2n + 1)                                            according to Equn 7.

                                                                            d a = f (l f , w f )                                   (7)
                j=i+ n

                    ∑ (R          − Rj )
                                       2
                             Li

     σ Li =     j=i−n                                       (5c)
                             2n                                         Probability of exceedance
                                                                        The future defect depth (df) shall not exceed its allowable
                                                                        depth (da) [22, 23], as represented by the limit-state function
External defects
                                                                        in Equn8:
It is proposed that pipeline coating holidays are considered
stationary. Thus, circumferential and axial growth rates are                d f − da < 0                                           (8)
assumed as zero at all active sites located on the pipeline’s
external surface. Equation 5d represents the depth growth               In the current approach, df is characterized by a normal
rate, considering the lag in coating degradation.                       distribution, while da is deterministic. This means that the
                                                                        probability of a pipeline exceeding the limit-state condition
                     dj                                                 at each defect can be determined as the area on the right-
     Rdi =                                                  (5d)        hand side of the allowable depth under the df PDF (see
              Δt s − Δt c                                               Fig.2)5.

Equations 5b and 5c must therefore also be applied in                   Economic remediation rate
order to characterize the defect’s depth corrosion rate PDF,
                                                                        The economic remediation rate which provides cost-effective
                                                                        operation must be ascertained by a pipeline’s own operator,
                                                                        considering each case individually. It is outside the scope of
4. The scoring factor for changes in service conditions (s) should be
determined based on historical data (coupons/probes, comparison of
multiple ILI data or computation simulations) and engineering best
judgment [20].                                                          5. Most commercial packages have standard functions to perform this.
1st Quarter, 2009                                                                                                                  23



                                                                 Pipeline 1          Pipeline 2      Pipeline 3       Pipeline 4


                                          Diameter (in)               16                    14          22                16

                                          Minimum
                                                                     8.7                    8.2         6.3               7.9
                                          thickness (mm)

                                          Pipe material              X60                    X65       X40/46             X35


                                          Length (km)                184                    228         98                98


                                          Service life (yr)           26                    36          32                41


                                          MAOP (kg/sqcm)             100                    97         21-56*           31-41*

Table 1. Construction
and operational data.                     *worst case scenario hydraulic simulated range.




this work to accomplish a full perspective into problem, but               • Pipeline 1: an onshore pipeline carrying dry gas
some of the factors that must be taken into account in such                  since its operation began. Accumulated corrosion
an analysis include:                                                         damage was slight on both the external and internal
                                                                             pipeline surfaces.
   • technical and economic viability of alternative
     pipeline systems, or other modes of transportation                    • Pipeline 2: an onshore gas pipeline that has been
   • the ratio between the cost of a new pipeline and the                    used to transport both wet and sour products.
     estimated maintenance costs of the existing one                         Accumulated internal corrosion is severe although,
   • the impact of a possible delivery shortage on the                       on the other hand, almost no external metal-loss
     local economy                                                           indications have been reported as a result of the
   • current, and possible future, economic scenarios                        dryness of the of region crossed by this pipeline, in
                                                                             the NE of Brazil.
Restriction on the model’s applicability
                                                                           • Pipeline 3: a trunk line responsible for transporting
As the whole model is based on averaging the behaviour of                    all of one refinery’s crude oil supply. During its
the local corrosion process, its application is not                          operational life, it endured production water
recommended to systems where hot-spot mechanisms (such                       pumped through recurrently, together with some
as stray current, under-coat corrosion, etc.) are significant                high-BSW content product. Long shut-down periods
features.                                                                    were also a regular occurrence. Internal corrosion
                                                                             damage is quite severe and channelling damage is
                                                                             general. In order to meet an increase in demand, an
Case studies                                                                 increase in flow capacity was required. The resultant
                                                                             new service conditions were simulated by the worst-
In order to illustrate the model’s application, four case                    case hydraulic scenarios, and the maximum
studies have been chosen, the input data for which is                        operational pressure profile was defined accordingly.
summarized in Table 1. A brief introduction is given for
each, before the model results and overall performance are                 • Pipeline 4: an onshore line which has been used to
discussed.                                                                   transport naphtha and crude oil, the latter usually




                                                                                                     Fig.1. Local corrosion activity.
24                                                                                             The Journal of Pipeline Engineering




                                                                                                    Fig.2. The probabilistic limit-state
                                                                                                                               function.


       with a high BSW content. Again, production water                 POE threshold range of 10-4-10-5, and the economic
       transportation was a frequent occurrence together                remediation rate specified for each case, it can be concluded
       with extensive shutdown periods. The whole pipeline              that pipeline 3 could be safely operated for almost 30 years,
       has bad channelling damage, as shown in Fig.1.                   while pipeline 4 would be cost-effectively operational for
                                                                        approximately 20 years at most.
Results and discussion
                                                                        Conversely, with the exception of pipeline 1, Figs 6 and 7
The model’s output data from the four case studies are                  show that internal corrosion developing over 30 years
summarized in Table 2, while Fig.3 shows the overall                    would be a direct threat. Pipeline 4 is not expected to
normalized local corrosion activity. Figures 4 and 5 present            maintain its present use for long, while the operational
the expected probability of exceedance for safe operations              reliability of pipelines 2 and 3 will not be cost-effective for
(at the required levels) without repair to the 200 most                 more than 20 and 10 years, respectively.
critical metal-loss areas in each case study, for the next 20
and 30 years, respectively. Pipeline 2 was not analysed for             As a result of applying these forecasts, the company’s board
external corrosion, due the lack of significant indications             of directors has undertaken the following:
on its external surface. In view of a desirable operational


                                       Pipeline 1    Pipeline 2    Pipeline 3    Pipeline 4


      Population - filtered               213             -           867           222


E     Vicinity parameter (n)               5              -            5             5
X
T     Local corrosion rates Gaussian
E     distribution parameters          0.08-0.006         -        0.053-0.004   0.80-0.006
R     [mm/year]
N
A     Pecuniary remediation rate
      Cost-effective coating repairs       50             -           100           100
L
      number

      Remaining life Expected under
                                          > 30            -            30            20
      historic conditions [years]

      Population - filtered               337          10,370        50,325        23240

I     Vicinity parameter (n)               5             10            20            15
N
T     Local corrosion rates Gaussian
E                                      0.065-0.008   0.080-0.006   0.045-0.003   0.081-0.007
      distribution parameters
R
N     Pecuniary remediation rate
A     Cost-effective coating repairs       40            80            80            50
L     number

      Remaining life Based under                                                                                  Table 2. Modelling
                                           30          15-20           10             5
      historic conditions [years]                                                                             parameters and output.
1st Quarter, 2009                                                                                                                                                                     25




                                       00052



                                       00002




                                       0 0 0 51



                                       0 0 0 01




                                        0005



                                             0
                                                  2 3 0, 0   6 3 0, 0   0 4 0, 0   4 4 0, 0   8 4 0, 0   2 5 0, 0   6 5 0, 0   0 6 0, 0   4 6 0, 0   8 6 0, 0   2 7 0, 0   6 7 0, 0

                                                                                                          mm/year
Fig.3. Internal corrosion rate                                      Local                                                                 Individual
histogram for pipeline 3.




Fig.4. 20-year POE forecast of the
worst external metal-loss anomalies.




Fig.5. 30-year POE forecast of
the worst external metal-loss
anomalies.
26                                                                                     The Journal of Pipeline Engineering




                                                                                           Fig.6. 10-year POE forecast of the
                                                                                          worst internal metal-loss anomalies.




                                                                                           Fig.7. 20-year POE forecast of the
                                                                                          worst internal metal-loss anomalies.


     • pipeline 4 was converted to specified diesel              between the conceptual design and commissioning stages,
       transportation;                                           mostly as consequence of the complexities concerning the
     • a major rehabilitation project is being carried out       legal agreements with landowners through whose land the
       on pipeline 3, together with several mitigating actions   pipeline will be routed, together with the tougher regulations
       (including a new strategy regarding production            regarding environmental and operational issues.
       water);
     • a brand new pipeline is under construction to             Pipeline operators therefore need to forecast their systems’
       replace pipeline 2 (mainly in order to supply the         remaining lives with reasonable long-term accuracy. Despite
       local market’s forecast rising demand) while an           corrosion being the major time-dependent threat to ageing
       alternative use for pipeline 2 is being studied.          pipeline systems, there is little available guidance concerning
                                                                 corrosion modelling for real pipeline service conditions,
                                                                 and the subject remains controversial.
Conclusions
                                                                 The current work has been developed to support the
Nowadays, new onshore pipeline systems must be planned           operator’s long-term strategic planning, by providing a
well in advance. Sometimes almost a decade can pass              straightforward stochastic model to forecast the remaining
1st Quarter, 2009                                                                                                                      27



life of corroded pipelines. As input data, the newly-developed      2. R.Bea et al., 2003. Reliability based fitness-for-service
model requires pipeline geometry and material properties,               assessment of corrosion defects using different burst pressure
the worst-case scenario for operational pressure, a good-               predictors and different inspection techniques. 22nd
quality set of metal-loss ILI data, and also the economic               International Conference on Onshore Mechanics and Arctic
                                                                        Engineering, June 8-13, Cancun.
threshold for the system’s future remediation. The
                                                                    3. NACE RP-0775. Preparation, installation, analysis and
pioneering concept of local corrosion activity was                      interpretation of corrosion coupons in oilfield operations.
introduced, and the underlying simplistic assumptions are           4. NACE SP0502, 2008. Pipeline external corrosion direct
detailed together with the entire mathematical framework.               assessment methodology.
The definitions and roles of the empirical parameters have          5. J.M.Race, S.J.Dawson, L.Stanley, and S.Kariyawasam, 2006.
also been described.                                                    Predicting corrosion rates for onshore oil and gas pipelines.
                                                                        International Pipeline Conference, Calgary.
A balance has been established between over- and under-             6. S.B.Cunha, A.P.F.Souza, E.S.M.Nicoletti, and L.D.Aguiar,
conservative assumptions, and the model had been                        2006. A risk-based inspection methodology to optimize in-
                                                                        line inspection programs. The Journal of Pipeline Integrity,
considered suitable for forecasting periods of up to 30
                                                                        pp133-144.
years. Its algorithm is set out in detail and it can easily be      7. M.Ahammed, 1998. Probabilistic estimation of remaining
implemented using standard commercial mathematical                      life of a pipeline in the presence of active corrosion defects.
packages.                                                               International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 75, pp321-
                                                                        329
The technique provides powerful information with no                 8. S.L.Fenyvesi, H.Lu, and T.R.Jack, 2004. Prediction of
need for further expensive or laborious analyses. The use of            corrosion defect growth on operating pipeline. Proc.
the model has already proved to be particularly relevant to             International Pipeline Conference, October 4 - 8, Calgary,
forecasting critical problems long before they present any              Canada.
                                                                    9. A.Valor, F.Caleyo, L.Alfonso, D.Rivas, and J.M.Hallen, 2007.
real threat. The model has also been used to give rise to
                                                                        Stochastic modeling of pitting corrosion: a new model for
active mitigation planning, such as a review of inhibitor               initiation and growth of multiple corrosion pits. Corrosion
strategy and definition of the scope of coating rehabilitation          Science, 49, pp559–579.
projects.                                                           10. A.Ainouche, 2006. Future integrity management strategy of
                                                                        a gas pipeline using Bayesian risk analysis. 23rd World Gas
Additionally, if more-sophisticated mathematical packages               Conference, Amsterdam.
are available, the model could be easily adapted to                 11. P.J.Laycock and P.A.Scarf. Exceedances, extremes,
incorporate further refinements, incuding:                              extrapolation and order statistics for pits, pitting and other
                                                                        localized corrosion phenomena. Corrosion Science, 35. no 1-4,
                                                                        pp135-145, 193.
     • non-Gaussian behaviour (for which an automatic
                                                                    12. J.L.Alamilla and E.Sosa, 2008. Stochastic modelling of
       best-fitting-distribution tool is required)                      corrosion damage propagation in active sites from field
                                                                        inspection data. Corrosion Science, 50, pp1811–1819.
     • full limit-state approach: pipeline geometry and             13. J.L.Alamilla, D.De Leon, and O.Flores, 2005. Reliability
       material properties could also be considered                     based integrity assessment of steel pipelines under corrosion.
       probabilistically (if convolution integrals can be               Corrosion Engineering, Science and Technology, 40, 1.
       easily solved) [2, 10, 24]                                   14. S.A.Timashev, 2003. Updating pipeline remaining life
                                                                        through in-line inspection. International Pipeline Pigging
     • any specifics of a system’s history could be taken               Conference, Houston.
                                                                    15. S.A.Timashev et al., 2008. Markov description of corrosion
       into consideration by making the necessary
                                                                        defect growth and its application to reliability based inspection
       adjustments to the model’s premises and                          and maintenance of pipelines. Proc. 7th International Pipeline
       assumptions.                                                     Conference, Calgary.
                                                                    16. G.Desjardins, 2002. Optimized pipeline repair and inspection
                                                                        planning using in-line inspection data. Pipeline Pigging,
Acknowledgments                                                         Integrity Assessment, and Repair Conference, Houston.
                                                                    17. B.Gu, R.Kania, S.Sharma, and M.Gao, 2002. Approach to
The authors thank Petrobras Transporte SA for permission                assessment of corrosion growth in pipelines. 4th International
to publish this paper, and their colleagues Dr Sérgio                   Pipeline Conference, Calgary.
                                                                    18. G.Desjardins, 2001. Predicting corrosion rates and future
Cunha, Carlos Alexandre Martins, and João Hipólito de
                                                                        corrosion severity from in-line inspection data. Materials
Lima Oliver for many enlightening discussions and                       Performance, August, 40,8.
contributions.                                                      19. J.M.Race et al., 2007. Development of a predictive model for
                                                                        pipeline external corrosion rates. Journal of Pipeline Engineering,
                                                                        6, pp15-29.
References                                                          20. R.B.Eckert and B.Cookingham, 2002. Advanced procedures
                                                                        for analysis of coupons used for evaluating and monitoring
1.    B.Gu, R.Kania, and M.Gao, 2004. Probabilistic based               internal corrosion. CC Technolgies, Doublin, OH, USA.
     corrosion assessment for pipeline integrity. Corrosion 2004,   21. ASME B 31G. Manual for determining the remaining strength
     NACE International, New Orleans.                                   of corroded pipelines.
28                                                                                                          The Journal of Pipeline Engineering


22. H.Plummer and J.M.Race, 2003. Determining pipeline                             24. G.Pognonec, 2008. Predictive assessment of external
    corrosion growth rates. Corrosion Management, April.                               corrosion on transmission pipelines. 7th International
23. F.Caleyo et al., 2002. A study on the reliability assessment                       Pipeline Conference, Calgary.
    methodology for pipelines with active corrosion defects.
    International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 79, pp77-86.




                           Technical Writing A–Z: A Commonsense                                Mister Mech Mentor, Volume I:
                           Guide to Engineering Reports and Theses,                            Hydraulics, Pipe Flow, Industrial HVAC &
                           British English Edition                                             Utility Systems
                           by Trevor M. Young                                                  by James A. Wingate
                           Topics include: format and content of reports and theses;           Gain practical knowledge from frank, colorful cases and
                           copyright and plagiarism; print and Internet reference cita-        learn to solve mechanical problems related to hydraulics,
                           tion; abbreviations; units and conversion factors; significant      pipe flow, and industrial HVAC and utility systems with
                           figures; mathematical notation and equations; writing styles        these organized solutions to the problems involving: water
      TITLES OF            and conventions; frequently confused words; grammatical
                           errors and punctuation; commonsense advice on issues
                                                                                               and steam hammer phenomena; gravity flow of liquids in
                                                                                               pipes; siphon seals and water legs; regulating steam pres-
                           such as getting started and holding the reader’s attention.         sure drop; industrial risk insurers’ fuel gas burner piping
       INTEREST            2005 256 pp. Softcover ISBN: 0-7918-0237-X                          valve train; controlling differential air pressure of a room
                                                                                               with respect to its surroundings; water chiller decoupled
                           Order No. 80237X $29 (list)/$23 (ASME member)
                           Order sets of 10 copies at a special price. Order No. 80236S $199
                                                                                               primary-secondary loops; pressure drop calculations of
                                                                                               incompressible fluid flow in piping and ducts; water chillers
              FROM         American Edition:                                                   in turndown; hydraulic loops; radiation heat transfer; and
                           2005 256 pp. Softcover ISBN: 0-7918-0236-1                          thermal insulation.
                           Order No. 802361 $29 (list)/$23 (ASME member)
 ASME PRESS                Order sets of 10 copies at a special price. Order No. 80236S $199
                                                                                               2005 160 pp. Softcover ISBN: 0-7918-0235-3
                                                                                               Order No. 802353 $45 (list)/$36 (ASME member)

                           Pipeline Operation and Maintenance:
                                                                                               Pipeline Design and Construction:
                           A Practical Approach
                                                                                               A Practical Approach, Second Edition
                           by M. Mohitpour, J. Szabo, and T. Van Hardeveld
                                                                                               by M. Mohitpour, H. Golshan and A. Murray
                           Covering pipeline metering, pumping, and compression, the
                           book covers day-to-day concerns of the operators and                This second edition includes updated codes and standards
                           maintainers of the vast network of pipelines and associated         information, solutions to technical problems, additional ref-
                           equipment and facilities that deliver hydrocarbons and              erences, and clarifications to the text. It offers straightfor-
                           other products. It is a useful reference for veterans and a         ward, practical techniques for pipeline design and con-
                           training tool for novices.                                          struction, making it an ideal professional reference, training
                                                                                               tool, or comprehensive text.
                           2004 600 pp. Hardcover ISBN: 0-7918-0232-9
                           Order No. 802329 $125 (list)/$99 (ASME member)                      2003 700 pp. Hardcover ISBN: 0-7918-0202-7
                                                                                               Order No. 802027 $110 (list)/$88 (ASME member)
     Order Now!              North America: www.asme.org • Europe: www.ihsatp.com

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Nicoletti Jpe Part1

Structural Health Monitoring: Review and practice
Structural Health Monitoring: Review and practiceStructural Health Monitoring: Review and practice
Structural Health Monitoring: Review and practiceIRJET Journal
 
Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology
Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology
Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology VLSICS Design
 
Corrosion in water industry and wind turbines
Corrosion in water industry and wind turbinesCorrosion in water industry and wind turbines
Corrosion in water industry and wind turbinesGuillaume R. Fery
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)IJERD Editor
 
Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)
Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)
Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)Jonathan Lloyd
 
Non destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminium
Non destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminiumNon destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminium
Non destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminiummarcionilo neri
 
Emergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best Practice
Emergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best PracticeEmergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best Practice
Emergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best PracticeJames Rowley
 
Modelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCS
Modelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCSModelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCS
Modelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCSABOLAJI ADESOJI
 
Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...
Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...
Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...Power System Operation
 
IRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil Infrastructure
IRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil InfrastructureIRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil Infrastructure
IRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil InfrastructureIRJET Journal
 
Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper
Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper
Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper Tudor Dragea
 
ONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALS
ONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALSONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALS
ONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALSRamamSingh
 
LONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURES
LONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURESLONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURES
LONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURESIRJET Journal
 
Corrosion detection
Corrosion detectionCorrosion detection
Corrosion detectionLikhith1
 
IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...
IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...
IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...IRJET Journal
 
Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304
Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304
Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304IRJET Journal
 

Ähnlich wie Nicoletti Jpe Part1 (20)

Structural Health Monitoring: Review and practice
Structural Health Monitoring: Review and practiceStructural Health Monitoring: Review and practice
Structural Health Monitoring: Review and practice
 
Jpe Part2
Jpe Part2Jpe Part2
Jpe Part2
 
Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology
Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology
Design and test challenges in Nano-scale analog and mixed CMOS technology
 
Corrosion in water industry and wind turbines
Corrosion in water industry and wind turbinesCorrosion in water industry and wind turbines
Corrosion in water industry and wind turbines
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
 
Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)
Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)
Ageing of Industrial Plant (BPPT_Jakarta_06-08-2003)
 
Non destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminium
Non destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminiumNon destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminium
Non destructuctive testing friction stir wleds of aluminium
 
software Paper published.pdf
software Paper published.pdfsoftware Paper published.pdf
software Paper published.pdf
 
Kf3418331844
Kf3418331844Kf3418331844
Kf3418331844
 
Emergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best Practice
Emergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best PracticeEmergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best Practice
Emergency Pipeline Repair Systems, A Global Overview of Best Practice
 
Modelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCS
Modelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCSModelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCS
Modelling Corrosion Rate Using MANN And MCS
 
REDUCTION IN TIG WELDING DEFECTS FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING SIX SIGMA
REDUCTION IN TIG WELDING DEFECTS FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING SIX SIGMAREDUCTION IN TIG WELDING DEFECTS FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING SIX SIGMA
REDUCTION IN TIG WELDING DEFECTS FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING SIX SIGMA
 
Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...
Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...
Transmission Line Conductor Asset Health Assessment with Non-Contact Monitori...
 
IRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil Infrastructure
IRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil InfrastructureIRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil Infrastructure
IRJET- Non-Destructive Test Application in Civil Infrastructure
 
Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper
Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper
Tudor Dragea ICONE 23 Final Paper
 
ONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALS
ONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALSONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALS
ONGOING PROGRESS IN ADVANCED WELDING PROCESSES AND MATERIALS
 
LONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURES
LONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURESLONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURES
LONGEVITY ASSESSMENT AND LIFE SPAN ENHANCEMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING STRUCTURES
 
Corrosion detection
Corrosion detectionCorrosion detection
Corrosion detection
 
IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...
IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...
IRJET- An Evaluation of the Performance Parameters of CMOS and CNTFET based D...
 
Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304
Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304
Evaluation of Design Provisions for One-Way Solid Slabs in SBC-304
 

Nicoletti Jpe Part1

  • 1. 1st Quarter, 2009 19 A practical approach in pipeline corrosion modelling: Part 1 – Long-term integrity forecasting by Dr Érika S M Nicoletti* and Ricardo Dias de Souza Petrobras Transporte SA, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil N OWADAYS, MANY MAJOR MARKETS worldwide depend upon an increasingly-ageing pipeline infrastructure to supply most energy demands. As corrosion damage accumulation is usually expected under typical pipeline service conditions, forecast metal-loss growth over time is a key element in their integrity management; but there is little industrial guidance on this issue. The current work has been undertaken aiming to provide a corrosion rate model by means of straightforward stochastic treatment of metal-loss ILI data. This first part will present a model framework regarding long-term scenarios and remaining-life predictions, based on a cost-effective pecuniary threshold for the system’s future remedial actions. The concept of local activity breaks new ground by merging two traditional approaches: the individual defect and the pipeline segment corrosion growth rates. The model’s underlying assumptions are detailed, together with its mathematical framework; an empirical balance has been established between over- and under-conservative premises, and the accuracy of the results has been considered suitable for forecasting intervals of up to 30 years. The technique provides powerful information with no need to carry out any further expensive and/or laborious analyses: the whole algorithm could be easily put into practice using commercial mathematical packages. In order to illustrate the model’s applicability, four case studies will be presented. Nomenclature H: defect odometer [m] l: maximum defect length [mm] Dt1: pipeline service life under original operating lf: defect forecast length [mm] conditions [years] LSEGi: local segment length [m] Dt2: pipeline service life under posterior operating N: total number of active corrosion sites conditions [years] n: vicinity parameter Dtc: coating degradation lag [years] Ri: individual defect dimension corrosion rate [mm/ Dtf: forecasting lag [years] year] Dts: pipeline service life [years] RDi: local defect dimension corrosion rate [mm/year] sdi: forecast dimension standard deviation [mm] RDij: individual corrosion rate at a nearby defect [mm/ sRi: local depth corrosion rate standard deviation [mm] year] s: scoring factor for service condition changes d: maximum metal-loss depth [mm] w: maximum defect width [mm] Df: maximum metal-loss forecast dimension [mm] wf: defect forecast width [mm] Dj: pig-reported dimension (depth, width and length) [mm] dj: pig-reported defect depth [mm] Epig: tool measurement error [mm] (at 80% confidence level) Fh: service conditions linearization factor F OR OVER ONE hundred years pipelines have been used to transport hydrocarbons from their distant location to refineries and onwards to consumers. Many major world markets nowadays depend upon this increasingly-ageing pipeline infrastructure to supply most *Author’s contact details: tel: +55 21 3211 7264 of their energy demands. It is unfortunate that ageing email: erika_nicoletti@petrobras.com.br adversely affects a pipeline’s integrity, and it can suffer from
  • 2. 20 The Journal of Pipeline Engineering many types of damage under typical service conditions. hand, long-term scenario predictions are typically associated with the system’s economic viability forecasting (and Corrosion has historically been the greatest time-dependent estimating its remaining life); such analyses are usually threat to pipeline integrity. The process itself reduces the better served with accurate modelling. local metal cross-section, affecting the remaining strength and, consequently, reducing the pipeline’s containment Despite both algorithms being developed with the aim of capacity in the area of the damage. incorporating them into a company’s proprietary defect- assessment software [6], they can also be easily implemented Operators can quantify corrosion in their systems through using any common commercial mathematical package. periodic metal-loss in-line inspections (ILI). Subsequently, Accordingly, both are presented in only their most simplistic the system’s fitness-for-purpose can be assessed at each interpretations. The underlying assumptions of the models, point by carrying out damage tolerance analysis using, as and the descriptive formulations, will be described and input, ILI data and required service conditions [1, 2]. discussed. Real cases studies will then be presented to illustrate the methodology anticipated results and overall However, given that pig inspections show only the state of performance, before final conclusions are given. static damage at the time of the inspection, integrity forecasting must take into account corrosion growth estimates. Furthermore, although the phenomenon of Theoretical background corrosion is widely known, a plethora of factors impact the process kinetics along a pipeline’s length, and the inherent The corrosion process is irreversible: once it takes place, randomness generally associated with real field conditions, metal-loss damage at a particular site can only either grow, makes its mechanistic modelling a complex task. This or remain the same over time, the latter being a sign of site requires highly-skilled work, the difficulties of which are inactivity (and possible repassivation). often compounded by an inconvenient lack of historical data concerning many of the process control parameters. As time goes by, it is expected that new active sites will arise, Thus, it has become common practice to adopt an empirical while some of the existing ones will cease growing. approach, mostly based on worst-case scenarios Additionally, time-dependent defect enlargements usually (recommended practices and/or historical data) [3, 4]. slow down over time although, as a general rule, However, such procedures usually give rise to highly- deterministic approaches treat those processes as linear [7, inaccurate forecasts, particularly when dealing with long- 8]. Valor et al. [9] suggest the following should be taken into term scenarios. account: Indeed, the US’ Office of Pipeline Safety estimated that the • the slowing down effect: 0-10% of reduction in past ability to accurately forecast corrosion rates could save corrosion rates American pipeline companies more than US$ 100 million • the cessation of growth effect: 0-20% of the number per year through reduced maintenance costs and accident of sites nucleated per year avoidance [5]. • new defect nucleation: 0-65% of the number of sites nucleated per year Fortunately, ILI metal-loss mapping reflects either unknown service condition variances and/or local electrochemical Conversely, probabilistic models often use the following mechanism abnormalities, providing a good background, distributions in order to represent: insofar as processing past behaviour is concerned, for corrosion-rate inferences. • nucleation time – exponential and Weibull [9, 10] • number of sites nucleated over time: Poisson [9] The current work aims to develop a simplified methodology • growth rate: gamma, log-normal, or extreme-value to allow reasonably-accurate pipeline-integrity forecasts, distributions [6, 10, 11] chiefly by using ILI data. Two basic algorithms have been constructed: the first, which is presented in this paper, has The Bayesian approach and the Markovian process have been directed to long-term scenarios. The second part of also been widely used in probabilistic framework modelling the methodology has targets short-term predictions, and [12-15]. will be published in the second art of the paper [in the June, 2009, issue of the Journal of Pipeline Engineering]. Given that metal-loss measurements reflect operational condition variations and the overall randomness of the The main differences between the algorithms result from corrosion process itself, the proper treatment of ILI data their diverse application expectations. Short-term scenarios can lead to reasonable estimates of past behaviour [16-18]. are usually applied in order to define reinspection intervals and rehabilitation scopes. As operational pipeline safety In order to determine the corrosion rate, damage must be and reliability often depends on the result, conservative quantified at two different points in time. However, in approaches have always been preferable. On the other order to avoid the usual laborious defect-matching
  • 3. 1st Quarter, 2009 21 procedures [5, 19], the current model has been adapted to – eventually – measurement bias, with a confidence use a single ILI data set. Also, the model has been constructed level of 80%. The mathematical framework to be under the premise of a linear relationship existing with the presented is independently applied to the anomaly process’s past behaviour. Its breakthrough came with the populations located on the external and internal assumption that only adjacent metal loss represents the surfaces. New defect generation, as well as the rate corrosion activity at each point, which will be described of cessation of defect growth, are considered to be further below. negligible. The local corrosion activity principle • Nucleation time: defect populations are assumed to be instantaneously nucleated at the first exposure to The authors consider it a rational assumption that all corrosive conditions. metal-loss located in close vicinity and on the same side of the pipe wall (external/internal) is under similar conditions • Defect growth: determined based on the past of corrosion attack. If, regarding the variations in corrosion behaviour of local corrosion activity. The details of activity along a pipeline’s length, it is expected that future this premise regarding external and internal surface service conditions remain similar, then future corrosion corrosion are described below. growth can be predicted based on the metal-loss anomaly population located in the defect neighbourhood. • Coating protection effectiveness: the coating condition is considered to be perfect at the time of To define the range of each defect’s environment, a vicinity pipeline commissioning. All pipeline coating parameter must be empirically determined, using the holidays are considered to be instantaneously relationship expressed in Equn 1. Each defect will also have generated after a specific coating degradation lag. its associated characteristic length, as defined by Equn 21. The protection effectiveness is assumed to be 0% at all active sites of external corrosion, and 100% in 2n+1 > = 7 (1) holiday-free regions. Water and air permeation time dependency is not taken into consideration. L Si = Hi + n − Hi − n (2) • Coating degradation lag: must be empirically defined Figure 1 illustrates the principle in a pipe section from case based on coating data history and engineering best study 4. All the anomalies displayed are internal metal-loss, judgment. and channelling can be clearly noted. Two anomalies have been arbitrarily chosen to exemplify the neighbourhood’s • Cathodic protection: is assumed to remain in a delimitation mechanism: for the purpose of illustration, steady-state condition throughout the entire service the lower recommended value for the vicinity parameter life of the pipeline. has been used in the figure (n = 3). Note that only axial proximity is taken into account: n anomalies immediately • Probability density functions (PDFs): defect depth up- or downstream are considered as belonging to each dimensions and corrosion rates are described by defect’s local population. Gaussian PDFs. It is worth noting that, given that each defect’s corrosion rate is represented in terms A number of additional simplistic assumptions have been of a local average, there is a normalizing effect on the made, and a general outline of them will be given in the overall depth corrosion rate data set2. following paragraphs. • Process characterization: irreversible, evolving at a Mathematical framework constant rate, and at discrete time intervals. Corrosion rates PDFs • Defect population: ILI reported metal-loss anomalies trimmed, based on the empirical criterion defined The probability density functions should be individually in Equn 3: defined, taking account of the damage accumulated in each defect neighbourhood, according to the previously-outlined 2Et principle of local corrosion activity3. If a significant change Dj ≥ (3) in the system’s operating conditions takes place after any 1.28 where Et represents tool the measurement error and 2. Pipeline geometry, material features, and the axial and circumferential corrosion rates, have only been considered deterministically, as will be the allowable damage as a consequence. 1. The parameter n should be adjusted in order to obtain an average 3. Clustering criteria should preferably be applied after a future segment length not exceeding 1-2 km. morphology forecast, not before.
  • 4. 22 The Journal of Pipeline Engineering particular event, then a factor Fh is defined accordingly, while Equn 2 should be used to define its neighbourhood using Equn 4; otherwise, Fh is assumed as 14. characteristic length. Δt1 + sΔt2 Fh = (4) Future defect morphology Δt s The average dimensions of future defects can be calculated Internal defects from Equn 6a, and Equn 6b is used to determine the associated dispersion. Individual defect growths (radial, axial, and circumferential) are determined by means of Equn 5a. The subsequent D f = D i .RLi .Δt f (6a) application of the local corrosion activity principle leads to the determination of the corrosion rate average for the defect population located in the adjoined region by using ⎛ E ⎞ 2 σ Df = Δt f (σ Li ) + ⎜ t ⎟ 2 Equn 5b, while the dispersion is obtained from Equn 5c. (6b) ⎝ 1.28 ⎠ Furthermore, the characteristic length associated with each defect neighbourhood (Lseg) can also be defined, as previously discussed. Damage tolerance Hence, each flaw on a pipe’s inside surface will have one single PDF representing its depth corrosion growth rate, There are a number of metal-loss assessment criteria that while axial and circumferential rates, as well as its can be used to determine damage tolerance. The most neighbourhood characteristic length, are deterministically simplistic and widely known is ASME B31.G, which only defined. takes into account axially-oriented corrosion defects submitted to internal pressure loading. Depending on the particular system’s damage characteristics (which can include Di Ri = (5a) circumferential- or even helically-oriented defects), or the Δt s existence of axial loads (such as those geotechnically or j=i+ n thermally induced), an appropriate criterion should be chosen to deterministically find out the maximum allowable ∑R j defect depth as a function of its forecast width and length, RLi = Fh j=i−n (5b) (2n + 1) according to Equn 7. d a = f (l f , w f ) (7) j=i+ n ∑ (R − Rj ) 2 Li σ Li = j=i−n (5c) 2n Probability of exceedance The future defect depth (df) shall not exceed its allowable depth (da) [22, 23], as represented by the limit-state function External defects in Equn8: It is proposed that pipeline coating holidays are considered stationary. Thus, circumferential and axial growth rates are d f − da < 0 (8) assumed as zero at all active sites located on the pipeline’s external surface. Equation 5d represents the depth growth In the current approach, df is characterized by a normal rate, considering the lag in coating degradation. distribution, while da is deterministic. This means that the probability of a pipeline exceeding the limit-state condition dj at each defect can be determined as the area on the right- Rdi = (5d) hand side of the allowable depth under the df PDF (see Δt s − Δt c Fig.2)5. Equations 5b and 5c must therefore also be applied in Economic remediation rate order to characterize the defect’s depth corrosion rate PDF, The economic remediation rate which provides cost-effective operation must be ascertained by a pipeline’s own operator, considering each case individually. It is outside the scope of 4. The scoring factor for changes in service conditions (s) should be determined based on historical data (coupons/probes, comparison of multiple ILI data or computation simulations) and engineering best judgment [20]. 5. Most commercial packages have standard functions to perform this.
  • 5. 1st Quarter, 2009 23 Pipeline 1 Pipeline 2 Pipeline 3 Pipeline 4 Diameter (in) 16 14 22 16 Minimum 8.7 8.2 6.3 7.9 thickness (mm) Pipe material X60 X65 X40/46 X35 Length (km) 184 228 98 98 Service life (yr) 26 36 32 41 MAOP (kg/sqcm) 100 97 21-56* 31-41* Table 1. Construction and operational data. *worst case scenario hydraulic simulated range. this work to accomplish a full perspective into problem, but • Pipeline 1: an onshore pipeline carrying dry gas some of the factors that must be taken into account in such since its operation began. Accumulated corrosion an analysis include: damage was slight on both the external and internal pipeline surfaces. • technical and economic viability of alternative pipeline systems, or other modes of transportation • Pipeline 2: an onshore gas pipeline that has been • the ratio between the cost of a new pipeline and the used to transport both wet and sour products. estimated maintenance costs of the existing one Accumulated internal corrosion is severe although, • the impact of a possible delivery shortage on the on the other hand, almost no external metal-loss local economy indications have been reported as a result of the • current, and possible future, economic scenarios dryness of the of region crossed by this pipeline, in the NE of Brazil. Restriction on the model’s applicability • Pipeline 3: a trunk line responsible for transporting As the whole model is based on averaging the behaviour of all of one refinery’s crude oil supply. During its the local corrosion process, its application is not operational life, it endured production water recommended to systems where hot-spot mechanisms (such pumped through recurrently, together with some as stray current, under-coat corrosion, etc.) are significant high-BSW content product. Long shut-down periods features. were also a regular occurrence. Internal corrosion damage is quite severe and channelling damage is general. In order to meet an increase in demand, an Case studies increase in flow capacity was required. The resultant new service conditions were simulated by the worst- In order to illustrate the model’s application, four case case hydraulic scenarios, and the maximum studies have been chosen, the input data for which is operational pressure profile was defined accordingly. summarized in Table 1. A brief introduction is given for each, before the model results and overall performance are • Pipeline 4: an onshore line which has been used to discussed. transport naphtha and crude oil, the latter usually Fig.1. Local corrosion activity.
  • 6. 24 The Journal of Pipeline Engineering Fig.2. The probabilistic limit-state function. with a high BSW content. Again, production water POE threshold range of 10-4-10-5, and the economic transportation was a frequent occurrence together remediation rate specified for each case, it can be concluded with extensive shutdown periods. The whole pipeline that pipeline 3 could be safely operated for almost 30 years, has bad channelling damage, as shown in Fig.1. while pipeline 4 would be cost-effectively operational for approximately 20 years at most. Results and discussion Conversely, with the exception of pipeline 1, Figs 6 and 7 The model’s output data from the four case studies are show that internal corrosion developing over 30 years summarized in Table 2, while Fig.3 shows the overall would be a direct threat. Pipeline 4 is not expected to normalized local corrosion activity. Figures 4 and 5 present maintain its present use for long, while the operational the expected probability of exceedance for safe operations reliability of pipelines 2 and 3 will not be cost-effective for (at the required levels) without repair to the 200 most more than 20 and 10 years, respectively. critical metal-loss areas in each case study, for the next 20 and 30 years, respectively. Pipeline 2 was not analysed for As a result of applying these forecasts, the company’s board external corrosion, due the lack of significant indications of directors has undertaken the following: on its external surface. In view of a desirable operational Pipeline 1 Pipeline 2 Pipeline 3 Pipeline 4 Population - filtered 213 - 867 222 E Vicinity parameter (n) 5 - 5 5 X T Local corrosion rates Gaussian E distribution parameters 0.08-0.006 - 0.053-0.004 0.80-0.006 R [mm/year] N A Pecuniary remediation rate Cost-effective coating repairs 50 - 100 100 L number Remaining life Expected under > 30 - 30 20 historic conditions [years] Population - filtered 337 10,370 50,325 23240 I Vicinity parameter (n) 5 10 20 15 N T Local corrosion rates Gaussian E 0.065-0.008 0.080-0.006 0.045-0.003 0.081-0.007 distribution parameters R N Pecuniary remediation rate A Cost-effective coating repairs 40 80 80 50 L number Remaining life Based under Table 2. Modelling 30 15-20 10 5 historic conditions [years] parameters and output.
  • 7. 1st Quarter, 2009 25 00052 00002 0 0 0 51 0 0 0 01 0005 0 2 3 0, 0 6 3 0, 0 0 4 0, 0 4 4 0, 0 8 4 0, 0 2 5 0, 0 6 5 0, 0 0 6 0, 0 4 6 0, 0 8 6 0, 0 2 7 0, 0 6 7 0, 0 mm/year Fig.3. Internal corrosion rate Local Individual histogram for pipeline 3. Fig.4. 20-year POE forecast of the worst external metal-loss anomalies. Fig.5. 30-year POE forecast of the worst external metal-loss anomalies.
  • 8. 26 The Journal of Pipeline Engineering Fig.6. 10-year POE forecast of the worst internal metal-loss anomalies. Fig.7. 20-year POE forecast of the worst internal metal-loss anomalies. • pipeline 4 was converted to specified diesel between the conceptual design and commissioning stages, transportation; mostly as consequence of the complexities concerning the • a major rehabilitation project is being carried out legal agreements with landowners through whose land the on pipeline 3, together with several mitigating actions pipeline will be routed, together with the tougher regulations (including a new strategy regarding production regarding environmental and operational issues. water); • a brand new pipeline is under construction to Pipeline operators therefore need to forecast their systems’ replace pipeline 2 (mainly in order to supply the remaining lives with reasonable long-term accuracy. Despite local market’s forecast rising demand) while an corrosion being the major time-dependent threat to ageing alternative use for pipeline 2 is being studied. pipeline systems, there is little available guidance concerning corrosion modelling for real pipeline service conditions, and the subject remains controversial. Conclusions The current work has been developed to support the Nowadays, new onshore pipeline systems must be planned operator’s long-term strategic planning, by providing a well in advance. Sometimes almost a decade can pass straightforward stochastic model to forecast the remaining
  • 9. 1st Quarter, 2009 27 life of corroded pipelines. As input data, the newly-developed 2. R.Bea et al., 2003. Reliability based fitness-for-service model requires pipeline geometry and material properties, assessment of corrosion defects using different burst pressure the worst-case scenario for operational pressure, a good- predictors and different inspection techniques. 22nd quality set of metal-loss ILI data, and also the economic International Conference on Onshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering, June 8-13, Cancun. threshold for the system’s future remediation. The 3. NACE RP-0775. Preparation, installation, analysis and pioneering concept of local corrosion activity was interpretation of corrosion coupons in oilfield operations. introduced, and the underlying simplistic assumptions are 4. NACE SP0502, 2008. Pipeline external corrosion direct detailed together with the entire mathematical framework. assessment methodology. The definitions and roles of the empirical parameters have 5. J.M.Race, S.J.Dawson, L.Stanley, and S.Kariyawasam, 2006. also been described. Predicting corrosion rates for onshore oil and gas pipelines. International Pipeline Conference, Calgary. A balance has been established between over- and under- 6. S.B.Cunha, A.P.F.Souza, E.S.M.Nicoletti, and L.D.Aguiar, conservative assumptions, and the model had been 2006. A risk-based inspection methodology to optimize in- line inspection programs. The Journal of Pipeline Integrity, considered suitable for forecasting periods of up to 30 pp133-144. years. Its algorithm is set out in detail and it can easily be 7. M.Ahammed, 1998. Probabilistic estimation of remaining implemented using standard commercial mathematical life of a pipeline in the presence of active corrosion defects. packages. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 75, pp321- 329 The technique provides powerful information with no 8. S.L.Fenyvesi, H.Lu, and T.R.Jack, 2004. Prediction of need for further expensive or laborious analyses. The use of corrosion defect growth on operating pipeline. Proc. the model has already proved to be particularly relevant to International Pipeline Conference, October 4 - 8, Calgary, forecasting critical problems long before they present any Canada. 9. A.Valor, F.Caleyo, L.Alfonso, D.Rivas, and J.M.Hallen, 2007. real threat. The model has also been used to give rise to Stochastic modeling of pitting corrosion: a new model for active mitigation planning, such as a review of inhibitor initiation and growth of multiple corrosion pits. Corrosion strategy and definition of the scope of coating rehabilitation Science, 49, pp559–579. projects. 10. A.Ainouche, 2006. Future integrity management strategy of a gas pipeline using Bayesian risk analysis. 23rd World Gas Additionally, if more-sophisticated mathematical packages Conference, Amsterdam. are available, the model could be easily adapted to 11. P.J.Laycock and P.A.Scarf. Exceedances, extremes, incorporate further refinements, incuding: extrapolation and order statistics for pits, pitting and other localized corrosion phenomena. Corrosion Science, 35. no 1-4, pp135-145, 193. • non-Gaussian behaviour (for which an automatic 12. J.L.Alamilla and E.Sosa, 2008. Stochastic modelling of best-fitting-distribution tool is required) corrosion damage propagation in active sites from field inspection data. Corrosion Science, 50, pp1811–1819. • full limit-state approach: pipeline geometry and 13. J.L.Alamilla, D.De Leon, and O.Flores, 2005. Reliability material properties could also be considered based integrity assessment of steel pipelines under corrosion. probabilistically (if convolution integrals can be Corrosion Engineering, Science and Technology, 40, 1. easily solved) [2, 10, 24] 14. S.A.Timashev, 2003. Updating pipeline remaining life through in-line inspection. International Pipeline Pigging • any specifics of a system’s history could be taken Conference, Houston. 15. S.A.Timashev et al., 2008. Markov description of corrosion into consideration by making the necessary defect growth and its application to reliability based inspection adjustments to the model’s premises and and maintenance of pipelines. Proc. 7th International Pipeline assumptions. Conference, Calgary. 16. G.Desjardins, 2002. Optimized pipeline repair and inspection planning using in-line inspection data. Pipeline Pigging, Acknowledgments Integrity Assessment, and Repair Conference, Houston. 17. B.Gu, R.Kania, S.Sharma, and M.Gao, 2002. Approach to The authors thank Petrobras Transporte SA for permission assessment of corrosion growth in pipelines. 4th International to publish this paper, and their colleagues Dr Sérgio Pipeline Conference, Calgary. 18. G.Desjardins, 2001. Predicting corrosion rates and future Cunha, Carlos Alexandre Martins, and João Hipólito de corrosion severity from in-line inspection data. Materials Lima Oliver for many enlightening discussions and Performance, August, 40,8. contributions. 19. J.M.Race et al., 2007. Development of a predictive model for pipeline external corrosion rates. Journal of Pipeline Engineering, 6, pp15-29. References 20. R.B.Eckert and B.Cookingham, 2002. Advanced procedures for analysis of coupons used for evaluating and monitoring 1. B.Gu, R.Kania, and M.Gao, 2004. Probabilistic based internal corrosion. CC Technolgies, Doublin, OH, USA. corrosion assessment for pipeline integrity. Corrosion 2004, 21. ASME B 31G. Manual for determining the remaining strength NACE International, New Orleans. of corroded pipelines.
  • 10. 28 The Journal of Pipeline Engineering 22. H.Plummer and J.M.Race, 2003. Determining pipeline 24. G.Pognonec, 2008. Predictive assessment of external corrosion growth rates. Corrosion Management, April. corrosion on transmission pipelines. 7th International 23. F.Caleyo et al., 2002. A study on the reliability assessment Pipeline Conference, Calgary. methodology for pipelines with active corrosion defects. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 79, pp77-86. Technical Writing A–Z: A Commonsense Mister Mech Mentor, Volume I: Guide to Engineering Reports and Theses, Hydraulics, Pipe Flow, Industrial HVAC & British English Edition Utility Systems by Trevor M. Young by James A. Wingate Topics include: format and content of reports and theses; Gain practical knowledge from frank, colorful cases and copyright and plagiarism; print and Internet reference cita- learn to solve mechanical problems related to hydraulics, tion; abbreviations; units and conversion factors; significant pipe flow, and industrial HVAC and utility systems with figures; mathematical notation and equations; writing styles these organized solutions to the problems involving: water TITLES OF and conventions; frequently confused words; grammatical errors and punctuation; commonsense advice on issues and steam hammer phenomena; gravity flow of liquids in pipes; siphon seals and water legs; regulating steam pres- such as getting started and holding the reader’s attention. sure drop; industrial risk insurers’ fuel gas burner piping INTEREST 2005 256 pp. Softcover ISBN: 0-7918-0237-X valve train; controlling differential air pressure of a room with respect to its surroundings; water chiller decoupled Order No. 80237X $29 (list)/$23 (ASME member) Order sets of 10 copies at a special price. Order No. 80236S $199 primary-secondary loops; pressure drop calculations of incompressible fluid flow in piping and ducts; water chillers FROM American Edition: in turndown; hydraulic loops; radiation heat transfer; and 2005 256 pp. Softcover ISBN: 0-7918-0236-1 thermal insulation. Order No. 802361 $29 (list)/$23 (ASME member) ASME PRESS Order sets of 10 copies at a special price. Order No. 80236S $199 2005 160 pp. Softcover ISBN: 0-7918-0235-3 Order No. 802353 $45 (list)/$36 (ASME member) Pipeline Operation and Maintenance: Pipeline Design and Construction: A Practical Approach A Practical Approach, Second Edition by M. Mohitpour, J. Szabo, and T. Van Hardeveld by M. Mohitpour, H. Golshan and A. Murray Covering pipeline metering, pumping, and compression, the book covers day-to-day concerns of the operators and This second edition includes updated codes and standards maintainers of the vast network of pipelines and associated information, solutions to technical problems, additional ref- equipment and facilities that deliver hydrocarbons and erences, and clarifications to the text. It offers straightfor- other products. It is a useful reference for veterans and a ward, practical techniques for pipeline design and con- training tool for novices. struction, making it an ideal professional reference, training tool, or comprehensive text. 2004 600 pp. Hardcover ISBN: 0-7918-0232-9 Order No. 802329 $125 (list)/$99 (ASME member) 2003 700 pp. Hardcover ISBN: 0-7918-0202-7 Order No. 802027 $110 (list)/$88 (ASME member) Order Now! North America: www.asme.org • Europe: www.ihsatp.com