1. The WeldNet
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
THE WELDNET PTY LTD - ABN 74 009 408 226
UNIT 3/52 WELD STREET, NEDLANDS, WESTERN AUSTRALIA, 6009.
Website: www.weldnet.com.au Email: info@weldnet.com.au
Curriculum Vitae
NAME Christopher Paul Cobain
DATE OF BIRTH 1966
NATIONALITY Australian Citizen
QUALIFICATIONS
Masters Degree in Welding Engineering (University of Wollongong - UOW)
Post Graduate Diploma Materials Welding and Joining (UOW)
Advanced Diploma of Engineering Metallurgy (AMTC)
IMEA: Certified Materials Professional (CMatP)
WTIA: Certified Comprehensive Welding Inspector (CCWI)
WTIA: Welding Supervisor (AS 1796)
TWI: Senior Welding Inspector Level 3 (CSWIP)
TWI: Radiograph Interpreter Level 2 (CSWIP)
IIW: International Welding Inspector – Comprehensive
IIW: International Welding Specialist
DOL: Boilermaker / Welder 1st
Class
AFFILIATIONS / MEMBERSHIPS
Member Welding Technology Institute Australia
Member Institute of Materials Engineering Australia
Member of the Australian Welding Institute
POSITION
Senior Welding & Materials Engineer (2005 to Present). Providing materials, welding, project
engineering consulting services to the petrochemical, mining, construction and fabrication industry.
COMPETENCIES
Standards and Specifications
Project Documentation Development
Construction Management and Planning
All Fabrication, Welding and NDE Methods
QA / QC Procedure Review / Approval
Material Properties and Metallurgy
Third Party Verification
Client Representative
Safe Work Practice
Failure Analysis
Computer Skills
Leadership
2. The WeldNet
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
THE WELDNET PTY LTD - ABN 74 009 408 226
UNIT 3/52 WELD STREET, NEDLANDS, WESTERN AUSTRALIA, 6009.
Web: www.weldnet.com
MAJOR CLIENT LIST AND DETAILS OF EXPERIENCE FOR CHRISTOPHER COBAIN
WOODSIDE ENERGY LIMITED
1. North Rankin A Jacket Life Extension - 2010
Advise on jacket node weld blending to increase fatigue life.
Advise on pre / post weld NDE and crack rectification methods.
Review / approve WPS/PQR packages and NDE reports.
Materials: Heavy wall C-Mn steel structural tubing
Standards: AWS D1.1 / API RP documents / ECA assessment reports
2. North Rankin 2 Jacket Construction – 2010 / 2011
Review / approve fabrication and QC procedures.
Review / approve WPS/PQR packages.
Witness welding procedure operations, recording, NDE and mechanical
assessments including CTOD.
Review AUT procedures / advise on seeded defect weld requirements
Overseas site surveillance and monitoring during jacket manufacture / welding
Investigate DSS defect rate and advise / implement improvement program.
Support client QC management and work front team members
Materials: Heavy wall C-Mn steel structural tubing and manufactured sections,
Large and small bore C-Mn steel and DSS UNS S31803 piping systems
Standards: AWS D1.1 / ASME B31.3 / Client specifications
3. Woodside Office Welding Engineer Support – 2010 / 2011 / 2012
Attend Woodside offices, (ad hoc basis), and issue approved WPS packages
for offshore brownfield equipment and gas plant maintenance programs.
Assist Woodside QA / QC group on materials, welding and NDE.
Standards: AWS D1.1 / ASME B31.3 / Client specifications
3. Page 2 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
BHP BILLITON
1. Macedon Project - 2010
Specification development for welding, NDE to subsea structures and pipe
spools
Review / approval of welding procedures.
Materials: Structural Steel, C-Mn / SDSS UNS S32750 Linepipe and fittings
Standards: AWS D1.1, DNV OS F101
2. Worsley Alumina in service welding / Calciner expansion – 2011 / 2013
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X52 linepipe and Split Tee
Standards: AS 2885-2
TECHNIP OCEANIA
1. Vincent Stage 2 / Enfield Subsea Rigid Spools - 2010
Specification and QC / ITP document development for welding, NDE, coating,
pressure testing of subsea pipe spools
Preparation of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document compilation
Surveillance and inspection – welds / NDE / dimensions
Review / approval release certification / MDR data
Materials: DSS UNS S31803 Linepipe and fittings
Standards: DNV OS F101 and client specifications
2. Wheatstone Upstream- 2010
Review / approval WPS/PQR/WPQ documents
Surveillance and inspection – welds / NDE / dimensions
Materials: DSS UNS S31803 / C-Mn steel Linepipe and fittings
Standards: ASME B31.3 / DNV OS F101 and client specifications
4. Page 3 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
3. Vincent Stage 3 Subsea Rigid Spools - 2011
Specification and QC / ITP document development for welding, NDE, coating,
pressure testing of subsea pipe spools
Preparation of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification / mechanical testing
WPS/PQR/WPQ document compilation / approval
Surveillance and inspection – welds / NDE / dimensions
Review / approval release certification / MDR data
Materials: DSS UNS S31803 Linepipe and fittings
Standards: ASME B31.8 / DNV OS F101 and client specifications
4. Vincent Stage 3B Subsea Rigid Spools – 2011 / 2012
Stock material survey and report
Preparation of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification / mechanical testing
WPS/PQR/WPQ document compilation / approval
Surveillance and inspection – welds / NDE / dimensions
Review / approval release certification / MDR data
Materials: DSS UNS S31803 Linepipe and fittings
Standards: ASME B31.8 / DNV OS F101 and client specifications
5. Fletcher Funicane Project – 2012
WPS/PQR/WPQ document compilation / approval
Advise on NDE methods and application
Materials: ASTM A694 F65 forgings – Bend Restrictor
Standards: AWS D1.1 and client specifications
6. Macedon Gas Plant Project – 2012 / 2013
WPS/PQR/WPQ document compilation / approval
Witness welder qualifications / training / sign off
Guidance on pipe spool angular misalignment issues
Guidance on CVN requirement for base materials
Radiograph review
Offshore hook up activity, audit, inspection items report
Site inspection, surveillance and monitoring
Materials: C-Mn steel / DSS pipe and fittings
Standards: DNV OS-F101, ASME B31.3 and client specifications
5. Page 4 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
7. Gorgon Upstream – 2013
Specification review
NDE procedure review
Review / approval of WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Site production weld surveillance and inspection
Materials: Large bore C-Mn steel linepipe and fittings
Standards: ASME B31.3, AS 4041 and client specifications
8. Wheatstone Subsea Structure Fabrication – 2013 / 2014
Specification review
Contractor QC procedures development
Material certification review and approval
Review / approve WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Review NDE procedures / scope of work
Overseas site monitoring and recording of WPS/PQR/WPQ
Overseas site production weld surveillance and inspection
Materials: C-Mn structural steel
Standards: AWS D1.1 and client specifications
9. Wheatstone Subsea Post Metrology Spool Fabrication – 2014 / 2015
Specification review
Contractor QC procedures development
Material certification review and approval
Development of welding processes and automation
Supervise trial welding program
Site monitoring and recording of WPS/PQR/WPQ
Review NDE procedures / scope of work
Advise CTOD scope of work / Witness mechanical testing
Review / approve WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Site production weld surveillance and inspection
Materials: Large bore C-Mn steel linepipe and fittings
Materials: Large bore C-Mn steel Clad UNS N06625 linepipe and fittings
Standards: DNV OS-F101, ASME B31.8 and client specifications
6. Page 5 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
EPIC ENERGY / ORIGIN ENERGY / OSD PIPELINES
1. All - Onshore gas transmission pipelines – 2010 / 2011
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Surveillance and inspection – welds / NDE
Materials: C-Mn steel Linepipe / fittings API 5L F-X65 / F-X70
Standards: AS 2885-2 and client specifications
APACHE ENERGY / SUBSEA 7 / PTTEP
1. All - Offshore gas transmission trunklines – 2010 / 2011 / 2012
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Barge lay vessel surveillance and inspection – welds / NDE
Materials: C-Mn steel Linepipe API 5L X65 / X70 / DNV 450
Standards: AS 2885-4 / DNV OS-F101and client specifications
2. PTTEP – West Atlas Wreck Salvage - Removal / Montara Well head Platform
reinstatement – 2010 / 2011 / 2102
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Heat damaged material assessments and conduct replicas
Compile report for base material condition.
Advise on material damage and suitability for salvage equipment placement
Advise import / export riser / jacket cut lines for platform removal.
Review / approve Montara platform WPS/PQR packages
Review of MDR documentation package / sign off
Materials: C-Mn steel / Low alloy steels / DSS linepipe and structural steel
Standards: AWS D1.1 / ASME B31.3 / DNV OS-F101 and client specifications
7. Page 6 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
3. PTTEP – BHP Macedon Subsea Pipeline - 2011
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
MDR Review / Approval
Feedback to Lloyds / DNV review comments / close outs.
Provide report to close out Lloyds / DNV queries
Materials: C-Mn steel linepipe DNV 450
Standards: DNV OS-F101 and client specifications
4. Apache Energy – Devil Creek HDD Pipeline - 2011
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Material substitutions and material suitability
Materials: C-Mn steel linepipe and fittings API 5L X65 / ASTM A694 F65
Standards: AS 2885-2 / DNV OS-F101 and client specifications
5. Apache Energy – Julimar / Balnaves project - 2012
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Materials: C-Mn, Austenitic steels. Vessels and pipe spools
Standards: ASME IX, ASME B31.3 and client specifications
6. Apache Energy – Varanus island In service weld - 2012
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Compilation of in service welding package
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
7. Apache Energy – Ningaloo Vision FPSO Upgrade - 2013
Keppel Shipyard WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Review / approve QC procedures
Materials: C-Mn, Austenitic steels. Vessels and pipe spools
Standards: GL, ASME IX, ASME B31.3 and client specifications
8. Page 7 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
VERVE ENERGY
1. HP Rotor Turbine Shaft Refurbishment - 2010
Development and qualification of re-build WPS / PQR
Development of PWHT procedure
Surveillance and inspection – welds / NDE
Materials: AISI 4330 forged turbine shaft
Standards: Client specifications
SKM RIO TINTO
1. Port Hedland / Cape Lambert Port Facility – 2010 / 2011 / 2012 / 2013
Review / Approval of WPS / PQR / WPQ documentation
Advise on material substitutions (Chinese / Thai steels)
Review of site reports for portable hardness testing
Advise NDE methods / Review NDE procedures
Materials: C-Mn / Low alloy structural steels and forgings
Standards: AS/NZS:1554 Series and client specifications
2. Port Hedland / Cape Lambert Port B In service welds – 2012
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
MAERSK FPSO
1. Nguima-Yin FPSO turbine Fuel Lines - 2011
Review radiographs – Advise rectification and repair
Review / Approval of WPS / PQR / WPQ documentation
Offshore site surveillance and inspection welds / NDE
Sign off / approve turbine fuel line system
Materials: UNS S31803 DSS Linepipe and fittings
Standards: ASME B31.3 and client specifications
9. Page 8 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
ICON ENGINEERING
1. Offshore lifting Equipment / Heave Compensator – 2011 / 2012
Review / Approval of WPS / PQR / WPQ documentation
Site surveillance and inspection welds / NDE
Sign off / approve equipment
Materials: AISI 4130 / 4140 / Low Alloy Steels
Standards: ASME B31.3 / AWS D1.1 and client specifications
JOHN HOLLAND
1. IMPEX LNG Storage Tanks - 2011
Provide report for construction / weldability of LNG tanks
Materials: ASTM A553 Type 1 9% nickel
Standards: API 620 and client specifications
P & A WELDING
1. In service welding onshore gas transmission pipeline - 2011
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
2. Relocation onshore gas transmission pipeline - 2013
Develop and qualify onshore girth seam WPS/PQR/WPQ
Compilation of girth seam welding package
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
10. Page 9 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
NACAP PIPELINES
1. In service welding onshore gas transmission pipeline - 2011
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
AUSCLAD GROUP
1. Karara Iron Ore Processing Plant – 2011 / 2012
Review / Approval of WPS / PQR / WPQ documentation
Site inspector correspondences
Materials: C-Mn / Low alloy structural steels and piping
Standards: AS/NZS:1554 Series, ASME B31.3 and client specifications
2. Apache In service welding onshore gas transmission pipeline – 2012
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
3. Gorgon Subsea Post Metrology Spool Fabrication – 2012 / 2013
Specification review
Contractor QC procedures development
Material certification review and approval
Supervise trial welding program
Develop WPS proposals
Review NDE procedures / scope of work
Advise CTOD scope of work
Site monitoring and recording of WPS/PQR/WPQ
11. Page 10 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
Compilation of WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Site production weld surveillance and inspection
Training / mentoring Contractor QC team
Materials: Large bore C-Mn steel linepipe and fittings
Materials: Large bore C-Mn steel Clad UNS N06625 linepipe and fittings
Standards: DNV OS-F101, ASME B31.8 and client specifications
GORGON UPSTREAM JOINT VENTURE
1. Oil & Gas Processing Plant - 2011
Review / Approval of WPS / PQR / WPQ documentation
Review radiography and report
Materials: C-Mn piping and fittings ASTM A333 / ASTM A350
Standards: ASME B31.3 and client specifications
CLOUGH
1. Flange failure Investigation - 2012
Remove samples and expedite metallurgical assessment
Review NDE operations
Compile report and issue
Materials: ASTM A350
Standards: ASME B31.3 and client specifications
FUGRO TSM
1. Greater Western Flank Project – 2012 / 2013
Specification review
Contractor QC procedure review / approval
Material certification review and approval
Site monitoring and recording of WPS/PQR/WPQ
Review / approval of WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Site production weld surveillance and inspection
Training / mentoring Contractor QC team
Materials: Heavy wall UNS S31803 linepipe and fittings
Standards: DNV OS-F101 and client specifications
12. Page 11 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
KT PIPELINES
1. In service welding onshore gas transmission pipeline - 2013
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
APA PIPELINES
1. In service welding onshore gas transmission pipeline South Hedland - 2013
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
2. In service welding onshore gas transmission pipeline Boodarie - 2014
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
3. In service welding onshore gas transmission pipeline Murrin - 2015
Thermal analysis modelling and WPS proposal development.
Witness simulation weld qualification.
Compilation of in service welding package
Site surveillance and monitoring welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: API 5L X65 linepipe and Split Tee.
Standards: AS 2885-2
13. Page 12 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
CHEVRON
1. Heat Exchanger fabrication rework - 2014
Radiograph review
Compile rectification report and QC procedures
Overseas site monitoring and recording of WPS/PQR/WPQ
Compilation of WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Site surveillance and monitoring fabrication, welds / NDE
Site report and acceptance
Materials: 90/10 and 70/30 Copper Nickel
Standards: ASME B31.3
NEPTUNE
1. Wandoo A Platform Conductor repair - 2014
Compile rectification report and QC procedures
Site monitoring and recording of WPS/PQR/WPQ
Compilation of WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Materials: C-Mn steel structural sections
Standards: AWS D1.1 and client specifications
MONODELPHOUS
1. Ichthys shore crossing gas transmission trunklines – 2014
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Materials: C-Mn steel Linepipe DNV 450
Standards: AS 2885-4 / DNV OS-F101and client specifications
REGAL ENGINEERING
1. Offshore tension / spreader beam manufacture and re-certification – 2014 / 2015
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
PWHT procedure development and approval
Compile Re-certification scope of work
NDE procedure review
Site surveillance, monitoring and inspection
Materials: Low alloy steel and forgings
Standards: AWS D1.1, DNV OS C401 and client specifications
14. Page 13 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
CIVMEC
1. Buckle Trigger – 2014
Specification review
Contractor QC procedure development
Site monitoring and recording of WPS/PQR/WPQ
Review / approval of WPS/PQR/WPQ documentation
Site production weld surveillance and inspection
Training / mentoring Contractor QC team
Materials: C-Mn structural sections
Standards: AWS D1.1 client specifications
2. Prelude Modules Quote Assistance – 2014
Specification review
Contractor QC procedure development
Welding and NDE statement
Materials: Structural: C-Mn steel
Materials: Piping C-Mn clad UNS N06625 linepipe and fittings
Standards: AWS D1.1, ASME B31.8 and client specifications
BAE
1. ANZAC Frigate mast replacement – 2014
Contractor QC procedure development
WPS/PQR data base rationalisation
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
NDE procedure review
Site surveillance, monitoring and inspection
Materials: C-Mn structural sections, C-Mn bonded Aluminium, Aluminium
Standards: Germanischer Lloyds and client specifications
15. Page 14 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
FMC TECHNOLOGIES
1. XENA subsea manifolds – 2014 / 2015
Contractor QC procedure development
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
NDE procedure review
Site surveillance, monitoring and inspection
Materials: C-Mn structural sections, UNS S31803 linepipe and fittings
Standards: AWS D1.1, DNV OS-F101, ASME B31.3 and client specifications
DEACON ENGINEERS
1. Neerabup Replacement Digesters – 2014 / 2015
Contractor QC procedure review approval
Review / approval of WPS proposals
Witness WPS and welder qualification
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
NDE procedure review
Site surveillance, monitoring and inspection
Materials: C-Mn structural sections
Standards: AS/NZS:1554 series and client specifications
TUTT BRYANT
1. Crane boom repair – 2015
Review OEM rectification manual
Compile WPS qualification statement
WPS/PQR/WPQ document review and approval
Site surveillance, monitoring and inspection
Materials: LAS structural sections
Standards: AS/NZS:1554 series, AWS D1.1 and client specifications
16. Page 15 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
OTHER AREAS OF INVOLVEMENT
Over the previous 5 years, Chris has provided senior level consultative support within an
engineering and inspection role to several smaller fabricators not covered in the above list
of major clients. Details below however are also pertinent to larger project work scopes.
1. Transportation vessels
Design improvement with supports to reduce incidence of cracking
2. Mining equipment
Cost effective refurbishment of crushing, excavation, track pad equipment
3. Pipeline components
Well head spools, difficult to weld materials, 4140, NACE etc and development
of PWHT procedures for such components.
Compressor station pipework and equipment, pig launchers pig traps etc.
4. Lifting Equipment
Involving high yield materials within brittle fracture risk. Welding, NDE, PWHT
5. WeldNet database
Installation and training of WeldNet, and in house developed WPS/PQR/WPQ
database management system.
6. Welding / NDE Method Statements
Development of project Welding Method Statements encompassing all welding
and NDE related activities for each project.
7. Portable Hardness testing
The provision of portable hardness testing expertise on site using ultrasonic and
rebound test equipment.
8. Material Substitutions
Review of substitution material chemistry, processing and properties for
suitability as substitution materials specified in project documentation.,
9. Troubleshooting / Problem solving
Site based inspection and rectification of weld cracking problems, difficult to
qualify welding procedures, restricted NDE scenarios, fabrication sequences to
avoid weldability issues.
10. Failure Analysis
Involvement with NDE failures, establishing spurious indications with
radiography and UT equipment.
Material failure / brittle fracture and strain age embrittlement issues with high
fibre strain conditions.
17. Page 16 of 16
CONSULTANT ENGINEERS - METALLURGY AND WELDING
11. Specification development / Rationalisation
Development of project specifications and recommendations to rationalise /
update specifications.
Remove undue complexity and focus on simplicity.
12. Inspection and Test Plan development
Development of ITP’s covering all critical aspects of the project from contract
review to final sign off.
13. Technical Queries / Concession Requests
Compilation of technical queries and concession requests within client
specifications with focus on cost reduction without compromising project
integrity and serviceability.
14. Code queries
Correspondences with DNV and other code committees regarding code
interpretations and NDE acceptance criteria / NDE methodologies.
These correspondences have resulted in significant cost savings in preventing
unnecessary weld cut outs where interpretations have been incorrect by NDE
contractors.
15. QA / QC procedure development and review / approval
The development of QC procedures encompassing material receival, handling
and inspection, consumable control and storage, weld monitoring and
traceability, NDE methodologies, visual inspections, PWHT.
16. Training / Mentoring
Supervision of Contractor and Client QC teams, inspectors. Provide career
development options and CPD to inspectors, and QC personnel