ICANN-ASWG Strategy Plan presented during ICANN-45
1. ICANN's AFRICA Strategy Document
V1.1
Presentation
by
Africa Strategy Working Group (ASWG)
www.afrinic.net/en/community/icann-aswg
October 2012
ASWG
2. Outline
• Introduction
• Background and ToRs
• Methodology and Process
• Public consultations and Outreach
• Facts - Africa by Numbers
• Strategic objectives and Projects
• Measurements, resources and timeline
• Key recommendations toward finalization of the
ICANN Africa Strategy document
• Conclusion
• Appendix
ASWG
4. ICANN's New Approach to Africa
In August 2012, ICANN announced a new
approach to Africa
(see http://www.icann.org/en/news/
announcements/announcement-10aug12-en.htm.)
ASWG
5. The New approach
• Develop a framework for ICANN's Africa
strategy and announce initial plan in October
• Support stronger presence for ICANN in
Africa
• To increase Africa's participation in ICANN
ASWG
7. Background and TORs
Africa is one of the five regions of ICANN Towards the conclusion of the tenure of
and Africans have been active members the outgoing CEO of ICANN there
of constituencies in ICANN since 1998. were new hires of Vice Presidents
Africa is an emerging Internet economy for some regions. A group of
andAfrica has the fastest growing concerned Africans in a public
networks but it's participation in ICANN communication to ICANN suggested
is not commensurate where the few
number of African Registries and new
that hiring of senior staff for Africa
gTLD applications is the popular would be better guided by a strategic
example.
plan for Africa
At the recently held ICANN meeting in
Prague, the incoming CEO requested
The ministerial meeting held alongside the the African group of participants to assist
ICANN Dakar meeting in October 2011 in developing a 3 year strategic plan
issued a communique that called on with clear goals for Africa. The group
ICANN to increase its presence in Africa decided to form a working group instead
and to be more relevant to needs of the to lead a community process to develop
region. the strategic plan
ASWG
8. Terms of Reference
Africa Strategy Working Group
• Develop a strategic plan for ICANN's activities in Africa addressing the needs
for presence in Africa, African participation and representation in ICANN
• Determine how best to reach out to governments, private sector, civil society,
academia and others from Africa for increased participation of Africans in
ICANN. Governments have a significant influence in Internet development in
Africa
• Identify education and technology needs of the region that ICANN may be
able to assist with
• Formulate an ICANN regionalization program to Africa and why, when and
how to accomplish it
• Develop a clear 3 year strategy and a concrete plan for the first 12 months –
with clearly stated objectives, timelines, roles/responsibilities, governance,
and metrics by which we can measure success
• Present plan in Toronto
ASWG
10. Deliverables
• The process of the strategy working group to engage
the community is an important result by itself
• A three year strategic plan
• Action plan for first 12 months
• Success factors to evaluate the implementation of
strategy
ASWG
12. Methodology of The ASWG
• Group Formation and constituency
representation
• Literature review on African Internet, ICANN
• Monthly Teleconferencing with ICANN
• The ASWG retreat in Mauritius
• Public Consultation and Outreach
ASWG
13. Phase I Process: Developing the Strategy
Budget
ToR
Community Questionnaire
ToR Schedule Strategy
Core
ICANN
ASWG
Start Constituencies
Retreat
ASWG Review Regions
6/12 7/12 7/12 8/12
ASWG
14. Phase II Process: Validating the Strategy
Facts
Questionnaire
Analysis
I
SWOTs C
Retreat Outreach Presentation
Recommendation A
Strategic
Objectives N
N
8/12 Strategic
Projects 10/12
9/12 9/12
Others
ASWG 8/12
16. Public Input
• At the start a questionnaire survey was administered
to the African community
• Community input sought to identify African needs,
ICANN benefits, African perspective on SWOT on
ICANN and views on implementing ICANN presence
• The input influenced the SWOT on ICANN and
contributed to the recommended strategic
objectives
ASWG
17. Outreach
• ASWG was expanded to include Regions,
Constituencies and Liaisons to SOs
• Output of the Retreat was made public and
the community invited to comment on the
results
• The comments have influenced the
recommendation being made to ICANN
ASWG
19. Africa in ICANN Ecosystem
• ASO • @LARGE
– AFRINIC – AFRALO
– 3 elected Members
in the ASO-AC • SSAC
• ccNSO – 1 member
– AFTLD • RSAC
– 24 Afcc Member
– 0 member
• gNSO
– 4 Registrars • Operations
• GAC – 2 Staff
– ~34 formal Members – 1(2) Board
member
Page 2
ASWG
20. What do we know about Africa
• One of the richest and promising Region
– 54 economies
– 10 of the fastest growing economies are in
Africa
– More than 1 Billion inhabitants
• Internet users growth more than 1000%
over the past 4 years.
• ICT contribution GDP in the region
growing rapidly
Page 3
ASWG
27. Reasons to be optimistic
The African connectivity landmark has
fundamentally changed over the past 10 years
~3000% users growth
~500% IPv4 Address distributed
[50, 100, 200 ]% { g,cc }TLD Registration Growth
ASWG
28. Reasons to be optimistic
The African connectivity landmark has
fundamentally changed over the past 10 years
~3000% users growth
~500% IPv4 Address distributed
[50, 100, 200 ]% { g,cc }TLD Registration Growth
Internet users IP Address
(&!$!!!$!!!" !#$$%$$$!!
(%!$!!!$!!!" !)($%$$$!!
!)'$%$$$!!
(#!$!!!$!!!"
!)&$%$$$!!
(!!$!!!$!!!" !)#$%$$$!!
'!$!!!$!!!" !)$$%$$$!!
&!$!!!$!!!" !($%$$$!!
!'$%$$$!!
%!$!!!$!!!"
!&$%$$$!!
#!$!!!$!!!" !#$%$$$!!
!" !"!!!!
())'" #!!!" #!!#" #!!%" #!!&" #!!'" #!(!" #!(#" #!(%" )**(! #$$$! #$$#! #$$&! #$$'! #$$(! #$)$! #$)#! #$)&!
Page 24
ASWG
29. Reasons To be Optimistic
• The African connectivity landmark has
fundamentally changed over the past 10 years
– ~3000% users growth
– ~500% IPv4 Address distributes
– [50, 100, 200]% {g,cc}TLD Registration Growth
!"#$%"$#&'($%(& !"#$%%&'((#
(&!$!!!$!!!" !#$$%$$$!!
(%!$!!!$!!!" !)($%$$$!!
!)'$%$$$!!
(#!$!!!$!!!"
!)&$%$$$!!
(!!$!!!$!!!" !)#$%$$$!!
'!$!!!$!!!" !)$$%$$$!!
&!$!!!$!!!" !($%$$$!!
!'$%$$$!!
%!$!!!$!!!"
!&$%$$$!!
#!$!!!$!!!" !#$%$$$!!
!" !"!!!!
())'" #!!!" #!!#" #!!%" #!!&" #!!'" #!(!" #!(#" #!(%" )**(! #$$$! #$$#! #$$&! #$$'! #$$(! #$)$! #$)#! #$)&!
Page 24
ASWG
30. ICANN & AFRICA
• How can ICANN adjust its Strategy in
order to match it up with the changing
environment in Africa?
– What is the particularity of Africa Region
– Key areas/challenges to focus on.
• How
• With whom?
• When?
Page 25
ASWG
32. Approach
• Alignment with the four focus areas ICANN
2012 - 2015 strategic plan for consistency
• Address the fifth focus area of stakeholder
development, business development,
incubation and partnering
33. Strategic Objectives -1
Competition,
Healthy
DNS stability and consumer trust Core operations
governance
security and consumer including IANA
ecosystem
choice
Promote the multi-stakeholder
model and platform in Africa at
Support and facilitate
the government, civil society
competition in Domain Name
and private sector levels to
Strengthen ccTLD business.
Development in Africa , Build
enrich participation in ICANN
constituencies.
Capacity in DNS technical
operations and provide
Strengthen ccTLDs in Africa
Regionalization of IANA
operations in Africa.
Support capacity building
assistance and support as
requested.
Build business environment
that favor customer trust and
and development of Internet
choice (Technology solution,
Regionalization of other CORE
ICANN operations in Africa.
governance in Africa
Enhance regional and
international cooperation DNS
Legal and regulation
Framework).
Support policy development
stakeholders and Promote best
Effective communication /
Outreach on ICANN operations
process to create conducive
environment for the internet
practices of DNS operations
Encourage resiliency of local
DNS infrastructure (IXP, Copy
including IANA
economy in Africa
Promote adoption of DNSSEC
of Root, Anycast DNS)
Promote Anycast Root-servers
deployment in Africa
Ensure internationalization of
ICANN using outreach
Enhance cooperation with Deploy more root servers in
program.
CERTs for better handling of
DNS related incidents.
Africa
Ensure physical presence in
Promote new gTLD registries,
Africa to conduct outreach to
registrars
help reflect ICANN’s global
image
ASWG
34. Strategic Objectives -2
Competition,
Healthy
DNS stability and consumer trust Core operations
governance
security and consumer including IANA
ecosystem
choice
Expand a Multi-Stakeholder
platform to increase
Introduce gTLDs in African participation and
languages and IDNs
engagement in collaboration
with I* organizations and ICANN
Build African constituencies
entrepreneurship programmes
in the DNS area
Encourage Industry
development by setting up an
Promote research and Internet foundation for DNS
development to foster industry in developing
innovation in Internet countries (Africa)
related technologies and
businesses
Ensure ongoing commitment of
ICANN and constituencies to
Promote strategic partnerships act in Africa’s public interest.
between global and local
entrepreneurs in the Promote globalization of ICANN
DNS industry and its operations through a
phased internationalization of
IANA functions.
ASWG
35. Strategic Projects - 1
Competition,
Healthy
DNS stability and consumer trust Core operations
governance
security and consumer including IANA
ecosystem
choice
Develop WHOIS program for
DNS in Africa
Support Anycast workshops
Increase domain name
penetration in Africa
A program for enhancing
Conduct registry, registrar
business development model
cooperation with I*
organizations and IGFs
African ccTLD Operations and workshops
Support Training.
Establish ICANN operations in
Africa, including IANA
to promote regional events for
multi-stakeholder engagement
a support programme for
accreditation of registrars
operations.
Business Best Practices and
-IANA Operations
Participate in African meetings
Marketing Support for AfTLD,Create a foundation to -Registrar liaison functions
ccTLDs and Registrars
Establish a program for
support development of African
-Registry liaison functions
inclusion of African academic
registrars
Consumer/Community Capacity
-Compliance function
community in Internet
Governance ecosystem
Building
ccTLD business Model
workshops
-Legal Advice and Support
-Regional meetings
Continued support for African
participation at ICANN
Develop and Improve African Commit and conduct a study -Institutionalize IDN support
meetings through the
Security Expertise
on business feasibility of
fellowship program
growing DNS industry in Africa
Produce Targeted Documents
Promote and Support in appropriate languages Expand AFRALO
Cooperation between African
An observatory to develop new regarding ICANN operations
indices for DNS industry
CERTs and DNS Operators
Support African government
growth in Africa
participation in ICANN high
level meetings
Promote DNSSEC Set up an Internet foundation
for innovative funding
mechanisms for the DNS
industry development in
developing countries (Africa)
ASWG
36. Strategic Projects - 2
Competition,
Healthy
DNS stability and consumer trust Core operations
governance
security and consumer including IANA
ecosystem
choice
Sub regional Africa ICANN
meetings to contribute to global
meetings.
An ICANN academy to help in
capacity building and HR
Promote African leadership in
development in Africa
best practices in DNS industry
An ICANN ambassador
Set up business development
program to promote global
incubators for the DNS
ICANN values
business in Africa
Deploy Anycast Instances of L-
Increase African representation
Research and development Root in cooperation with
in leadership positions at
programme for Africa for Regional Organizations.
ICANN management
promoting innovation
and increased participation in
Leadership development
IETF forums.
program in multi-stakeholder
Internet governance.
DNS resiliency workshops for
African ccTLDS.
Strengthen African participation
in ICANN AoC review teams
Identify policy gaps and
support policy advocacy
processes
ASWG
38. Key Measures - 1
Competition,
Healthy
DNS stability and consumer trust Core operations
governance
security and consumer including IANA
ecosystem
choice
Accurate and available WHOIS
Data
Term - Definition - Metric -
Target
Number of workshops
Number of African participants
in ICANN constituencies.
Domain Name Indicators
Number of workshops
conducted for potential registry
Regional Implementation of
Operations
ICANN participation in African
-Number of Domain Names
Registered
and registrars
meetings
-Penetration
Number of accredited
Number of Appropriate
Documents produced In An ICANN Academy and
Registers
-Complaints / UDRP
Appropriate African languages
targeted to various
number of Academic
participants
-DNS Availability / Failure
Number of Workshops for
stakeholders
-Incidents on DNS operations
ccTLD business models
Number of African participants
-Domain Name Pricing
Number of L-root instances and the quality of participation
Research report on DNS
business in Africa
Deployed
and contributions
Security Indicators
Number of other root-servers Number of ALS’s from the
An observatory
-DNSSEC Operations signed in
Africa.
instances Deployed African region and number of
workshops organized by
A foundation for DNS Industry
-CERT Operations in Africa
AFRALO
in Africa
-CERT Training Certified People
Revised delegation and re-
delegation procedures
ASWG
39. Key Measures - 2
Competition,
DNS stability and consumer trust Core operations Healthy governance
security and consumer including IANA ecosystem
choice
Number of government
participants contributing to GAC
and high level meetings
Number of participants
contributing to global ICANN
meetings
African experts on new gTLD
evaluation panel
Number of Africans trained by
the ICANN academy.
An African leaders award
Number of start up companies Increased number of African
being incubated
staff members
Innovative ideas and patents Number of Africans leading
and increased number of African IG processes
participants in IETF forums.
Increased number of
Number of ccTLDs benefiting Africans participating in AoC
from resiliency workshops
review teams
Increased copy of root severs
Number of policy documents/
strategies
ccTLD Whois performance
Registries & Registrars Af* growth, Support for Af*
New Internet communities
Adoption of multi-stakeholder
model
Visibility of ICANN at African fora
ASWG Communications in French
41. RESOURCES AND TIMELINE
Determination of resources needed for the
strategic plan will be done by ICANN
Timeline :
First year
Second year
Third year
ASWG
42. Year 1 - critical list
• A program for enhancing cooperation with I* organizations and IGFs (3 months)
• To promote regional events for multi-stakeholder engagement (3 months)
• An ICANN academy to help in capacity building and HR development in Africa
(6 months)
• Produce Targeted Documents in appropriate languages regarding ICANN
operations (6 months)
• Consumer/Community Capacity Building (6 months)
• Establish ICANN operations in Africa (6 months)
• An ICANN ambassador program to promote global ICANN values (9 months)
• Leadership development program in multi-stakeholder Internet governance. (9
months)
ASWG
45. Roles
• Jointly by Africans and ICANN throughout
implementation
• While ICANN is not a development agency it
is strategic to contribute to development of
ICANN's constituent industries
• While Africa can benefit from support it must
invest in its businesses and partner
ASWG
47. Principal Recommendation
The strategic working group recommends that this
draft outline of the strategic plan be further on
turned into a fully fledged strategy document, after
further consultations are conducted within the
African communities and ICANN constituencies.
ASWG
48. Other
Recommendations
• Integrate the ASWG activity into the ICANN
annual corporate planning process
• Reform the membership of the ASWG to be
better aligned with ICANN constituency and
SO/AC organizations
ASWG
50. Concluding Remarks
• Designing of the ICANN strategic plan for Africa is
timely
• Africa deserves special attention to be fully integrated
in Internet business/industry
• ICANN by this strategy is assisting to transform genuine
capacities into real development opportunities
• We learned how to better engage with the community
and believe the exercise should form part of ICANN's
regular delivery
ASWG
51. Acknowledgements
• ICANN
• AFRINIC
• AfrICANN
• African Internet community
• ICANN community
ASWG
52. Commendations
• Special thanks go to Adiel Akplogan, CEO of
AFRINIC and staff for the tremendous technical and
management contributions throughout the project
• We thank Ray Plzak for contributions and Tarek
Kamel of ICANN for coordinating discussions at the
retreat
• We thank Fadi Chehade, Akram Atallah and Steve
Crocker of ICANN for initiating and supporting the
effort
ASWG
53. ASWG Members
Core
Maimouna Diop Diagne
Palesa Legoze
Pierre Dandjinou
Nii Quaynor
Regional/Constituency
Alice Munyua
Barrack Ong'ondo Otieno
Mouhamet Diop
Tijani Ben Jemaa
Michel Tchnonang
Liaison
Rafik Dammak
Waudo Siganga
ASWG
56. Strengths - from the perspective of
Civil Society Business Government
Provision of Fellowship program
Multi-stakeholder decision making
to ensure african attendance
model for engaging with the
community
Regionalized Number Resources
Benefit by participatingo through
management policy -
Capacity Building and awareness ICANN Fellowship program
single Internet
feel
(Education & development)
experts Volunteer to use
Regionalized Number Resources Successful and Regionalized and
management policy - single Integrated Number Resources
Multi-stakeholder bottom up
Internet
management policy - single
mechanism for engaging with the
Internet
community in decision making
Current ecosystem made of
dedicated and Track record of strong support by
IGF at national and regional level
engaged volunteers.
dedicated and engaged volunteers
GAC high level meeting
ICANN's meetings in Africa every
two year
AUC participation in GAC
ASWG
57. Weaknesses - from the perspective of
Civil Society Business Government
Absence of clear regionalization Strategy
at ICANN
Absence of clear internationalization
Weak ICANN presence on the continent
Weak ICANN presence on the continent
Strategy at ICANN
Absence of domain name industry
Weak African domain name industry and
Lack of ICANN presence on the continent
Absence of content and application associated Business.
industry.
Domain name industry in it infancy
Poor participation of AFRICAN Businesses
Poor participation of AFRICA in ICANN
Poor participation of AFRICA to ICANN and ICANN domain name constituencies
process.
process.
and its related initiatives (New GTLD).
Poor/inefficient outreach to African Inefficient outreach to African
Ineffective outreach to African
governments
governments
governments in respect to their role in
developing domain name Industry.
Lack of transparency
Lack of transparency
Inefficient communication toward AFRICA.
Poor communication toward AFRICA
Poor communication toward AFRICA
Weak multi-stakeholder decision-making
Weak management and luck of support of
Weak ccTLD management in the region - model and regional balance.
absence of regional meetings
african ccTLD
Lack of Training capacity for skill required
Lack of outreach to African business
Weak participation of African private
sector
for domain name business and associated
program.
No impact on growth of the domain name
Representation of African interest on the
Board
industry
Weak ccTLD management
Poor relationships with African ccTLDs
lack of qualified african experts
ASWG No clear link with the AF*
58. Opportunities - from the perspective of
Civil Society Business Government
Emerging Internet continent, usage by
youth
Majority of next billion Internet users will
more likely come from Africa.
Africa region as an Emerging economy
Internet Innovation driven by Mobile
and Internet market
Technology: Current outstanding growth
Emerging Internet ecosystem with the
of the mobile telephony implies majority of Internet Innovation and growth driven by a
Majority of next billion Internet users will
next Internet users will be from Africa; boom in Mobile Technology
thus, a need for specific projects for Africa
come from Africa
Growing potential market in the domain
Internet Innovation driven by Mobile
Untapped emerging market
Name Industry.
Technology
Office in Africa
Growing interest of key actors in ICANN
processes.
Growing interest of key actors.
Growing interest of key actors.
Government and emerging Industry
Government and emerging Industry
Highly qualified experts.
ICT a cross cutting pillar of most african
countries development plans
Highly qualified experts
Potential growth of GDP and youth
employment
ICANN’s image and perception to be
Develop IDN to boost the internet economy
in Africa
increased through contribution to the Growth of ICAN legitimacy due to
growth of a continental Internet economy
internationalization through increased
African Participation
ICANN's legitimacy to grow with more
participation from African communities,
namely at GAC level
ASWG Develop IDN to boost content in Africa
59. Threats - from the perspective of
Civil Society Business Government
Involvement of governments
Limited Involvement of governments in the
multi-stakeholder decision making model.
Poor participation and contribution of
african governments in GAC
Weakness of ICT infrastructure
ICT infrastructure not adequately geared to Lack of ICT infrastructures and awareness
Unstable political economy
support domain name Industry.
and capacity
Resistance of governments to multi-
Heavy intend by government oversight and Lack of common understanding of multi-
stakeholder model
control of Internet.
stakeholder model
Heavy intend by government oversight and
Ongoing perception in Africa of ICANN as Lack of understanding of how government
control of Internet
non-International organization.
work and diplomacy
Participation to ICANN process
Lack of investments in domain name Lack of timely response and
(discussion forum, comments, meetings
industry and associated business.
implementation of GAC advices
etc …)
Inadequate response to the high Lack of implementation of AOC
Linguistic barrier
expectation from ICANN and its
stakeholders in Africa.
recommendations
Poor reach out to African communities
Linguistic barrier (1) Poor out reach to
Inability for African to conduct business African communities (2) Lack of financial
Lack or Poor financial commitment to an
with ICANN in a reasonable manner.
commitment to an Africa Internet Agenda
Africa Internet Agenda
(3) Poor or inadequate representation of
Lack of trust and consequence of ICANN in Africa (4) Poor perception of
Poor or inadequate representation of
inappropriate legal framework ICANN by african government
ICANN in Africa
ASWG
60. SWOT from Community Questionnaire
Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats
ICANN's meetings in Lack of Current outstanding Poor reach out to
Africa every two communications/
growth of the mobile African communities
years
telephony implies
Poor perception of majority of next Lack or Poor
The fellowship ICANN's activities
Internet users will be financial
program which
from Africa; thus, a commitment to an
ensure African Poor outreach to need for specific Africa Internet
participation to African governments
projects for Africa
Agenda
ICANN's meetings
Africa as one of
Lack of a physical
highest GDPs
Poor or inadequate
Bottom up approach presence in Africa
representation of
in policy
ICANN in Africa
Icann's image and
development
Partial linguistic perception to be
coverage of the increased through
Multistakeholders continent
contribution to the
mechanisms for
growth of a
engaging with the No impact on growth continental Internet
community of the domain name economy
industry
ICANN's legitimacy
Poor relashionships to grow with more
with African ccTLDs
participation from
African communities,
No clear link with the namely at GAC level
AF*
Develop IDN to boost
Poor representation content in Africa
of Africans on the
Board
61. Recommendations from SWOTS
Treat Africa as a specific Internet ecosystem
Build African Entrepreneurship in the domain names area
Increase current translation of ICANN's documents in different
languages
Set up an Internet foundation for developing countries (Africa)
Promote business development incubators
Ensure a physical presence in Africa to conduct outreach to policy
makers
Establish ICANN's Ambassador program in all regions of Africa to
ensure adequate representation
Commit a study on feasibility of a domain name industry in Africa
ASWG